Ornament for Clear Realisations — 2004-09-23

Buddha House Adelaide

Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Ornament for Clear Realisations — 2004-09-23
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 55 2004 09 23 OCR.mp3

UUID: 828a1d3e-4e46-4c36-81df-2cff216e901e

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2004-09-23

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 46 min

Words: 2,850

I’ll I’ll get on to that. So in order for us to understand the study of characteristics, which is another way of saying in order for us to understand logic. Okay. So this word that they translated here as characteristics, yeah, is also the word that is used to describe dialectics, is also the word that’s used to describe logic, and is the word that’s used to describe a definition. In Tibetan, they all come in together as one.

Okay? So in order for us to understand this chapter on characteristics, there is one, two, three, four, five terms we need to understand. The first one, which is easy, it’s this idea of our own description according to our own school. So in this instance, it’s the description according to our own school, which is the shedra’s textbooks. Next thing is what’s called a basis for characteristics.

The thing after that is an instance of a definition, an instance of a definition or a definindum. Then we will have a definition, and then we have a the way that something exists in cohesion with that definition. Okay. Sorry. And I said, guess what?

Just have to, like, link that up to the Sorry. Okay. Sorry. Sorry. Because it goes, I I don’t understand how you can teach the characteristics of something or the definitions of something too if people don’t understand what definitions are.

The the the there’s a black definition, there’s logic that’s involved in definitions. So how can he said, so I I wanted to skip to something that they will actually get. Right? Which is the sixth topic in this but I don’t have six topic notes here and so Geshe-la said okay do they have notes on the characteristics of the applications and I said yes so he goes okay we’ll go through this but I’m not sure it’s going to make any sense alright so we finally found then the part in the text which refers to these four characteristics, which is knowledge characteristics, differentiating characteristics, functional characteristics and entity characteristics, the different types of characteristics that a thing can have. This.

Okay. So from within within these, the first thing is the knowledge characteristics. Within the knowledge characteristics, there is said to be the knowledge of bases, the knowledge of paths, and the knowledge of the exalted knower of aspects. These three different divisions. So I guess he said he just wanted to skip all over these things, and he had planned to skip all over these things and not do them.

But that means, like, missing out on two whole up two two whole topics. Yes. But now we can’t find anything because he was based he was studying was prepared to do a teaching on a different bit. You’re gonna do the. Come Right.

Okay. We finally got somewhere we’re up to and that we can’t stand. So we’re doing the knowledge characteristics of the knower of bases/knowers of bases. So there’s all these different types of characteristics that we can have. And we’re up to the first, i.e., the knowledge characteristics.

And we’re doing those with reference to the knower of bases. So it basically means trying to understand what the knowers of bases are. So and the description of a knower of bases according to this is this the and I have to translate very slowly. Okay? So we have an assortment we have an assortment of different minds in a being that is where the mind moves towards something that doesn’t accord with the true nature of reality or the way that things actually exist, which is also sometimes translated as the mode of abidance.

So we have ways of thinking that don’t accord with the nature of things, the way that things actually abide, and therefore what are called discordant classes of minds. Now these kinds of minds are the result of attachment based on incorrect signs that have been generated by karma based on the three doors. So by performing actions, create imprints for a negative states of mind, including desire and attachment and so forth, that then lead us to misperceive the nature of abidance, the way things actually are, and hold them as being inherently existent. Now the antidotes to these ways of thinking, anything that is said to be in a class with the antidotes to these ways of thinking, and is in the continuum of a bodhisattva, is said to be a knower of bases. In this instance, we would say that a knower of bases is anything that is a yoga in the mind, encountered within the practices of bodhisattvas that is is this they’re not gonna he’s determined you’re not gonna understand, but this has got to be making some sense.

There is a mind that is in the continuum of a bodhisattva that is in accordance with or takes as its object anything that is associated with the practices of the lower vehicle but acts as an antidote to any of the discordant ways of thinking that create these different types of suffering. So basically, this means that we’re talking about a mind that is focused on the lack of self or on selflessness. And this mind that is focused on the lack of self or selflessness is an antidote to any of the other desirous or non-desirous minds that create suffering in the minds of ordinary beings. But these knowers of bases are actually confined to the continuum of bodhisattvas. We’re not talking about the knowers of bases in any other beings’ mind streams.

We’re talking about the application of Hīnayāna type realizations in the continuum of bodhisattvas that are a use of the realization of selflessness in order to get rid of negative emotions and kleśas, the afflicted emotions, and they’re to disturb the mind and create suffering. Oh, Did the Yeah. Yeah. He goes, okay. All of it’s alright then.

Well, then we can keep going. Oh, yeah. Really? He’s really concerned that you don’t And this one. This one.

Yeah. Okay so knowers of bases, the applications which are knowers of bases in the continuum of bodhisattvas — or yeah. So it has sixteen objects. These Okay. Sorry.

So the first four of the sixteen aspects, those those are the sixteen aspects of the Four Noble Truths. So in accordance with those first four, there is said to be sixteen objects that are related to the knower of bases. So there is four different aspects to every one of those four aspects. There’s four different characteristics to every one of those four aspects, or I should say. Oh, okay.

Oh, lord. Oh, god. So it’s like I’m really stretching my mind to understand it. I’m damn. I have to say it again now.

Not trying to make sense of it enough to say it again. Okay. So you have these four moments from the sixteen aspects of the Four Noble Truths, right? And so you have the first four aspects. Now, from the moments of realizing impermanence up to the moment of realizing selflessness is said to be associated with the knower of bases/knowers.

But you have different ways of looking at these knower of bases/knowers because you have the first the the idea of those themselves, the knowledge of those themselves. And then there’s also the fact that these things are developed on the way to becoming a Buddha. And then you also have this idea that this knowledge is in the continuum of a Buddha. And then you have the idea of the selflessness of those objects. Alright.

So you have different you have different aspects to those objects that you’re taking as practices as when they’re the knower of bases. So No. So then hello, Okay. So this sorry. This is it’s very difficult to translate.

So you have this idea, right, of the Tathāgata, realizing the Tatho. Sorry. It’s it’s very difficult to do this. So I’m gonna try and do it in maybe Sanskrit would be easier. Yeah?

Okay. Have you heard there’s a difference between Tathāgata and Tathagat? Yeah? Tathāgata is like the state, The Tathāgata is the one or the thing that is the ness of it, right? So it’s saying that the Tathāgata realizes the Tathāgata.

Alright? Did you get that? So but in the fact that they are the same thing, then the realization is one of selflessness. Yeah? So there’s, like, this is a nondualistic element happening to it with through the play on words.

This is why I was assuming I’ll call god. I don’t know how to translate that. So you start off with this realization of impermanence, then you end up with the realization of selflessness. But this selflessness is said to be like the. And then the realization of that is.

Alright? So the the the these two things are and are linked in that way. And Gesh was going, you don’t understand? I’m going, yeah. I’m just, like, thinking how the hell do I translate?

And and he’s already convinced we’re not gonna understand anything. So yeah. Oh, man. I will. Yes.

Okay. I’m I’m sorry. This is just, like, it’s so difficult to translate. I’m assuming, oh god. Anyway, I will try, and we will try and hopefully get somewhere.

There is a quote from the root text, which is actually in a section in these notes that’s associated with knowledge characteristics of the application in the knower of basis. Alright. So how it ended up in this other section, I’m not I’m not sure. It says the knowers of bases and so forth, also that those that are other than them as the aspects of vastness. Alright.

So it’s in reference to that. And what we’re what it’s doing is when you are putting forward syllogisms in debate, you start with saying, this is what we’re taking as our example, and then you explain that that is something, and then you give a reason for it. Okay? So you say, take for example this. This is such and such because it is that.

Right? Okay. Now the thing that we’re taking for example in order to establish the definition of a knower of bases’ knowledge characteristics is the bodhisattva’s yoga that knows the selflessness of the person and comes about in dependence on a base which understands that an incorrect or mistaken aspect is an incorrect view. Do you want me to say that again? And and Geshe was like, mister sixty years debating.

Right? It is this because it’s necessarily that, it has to be that. What do mean there’s a problem with that? And I was like, right. I said, I’m just gonna say it to them again slowly.

Okay. Again, then he goes, yeah. This. Okay. You see, this is why he was, like, saying this.

A bit difficult to explain all this about definitions. If you haven’t studied definitions, then you can’t go, is this because it’s necessarily that, and that means that it’s this, right? Anyway, but doing it slowly. So what we’re taking as our example is so you say take for example such and such, right? So we say take for example the yoga of a bodhisattva.

So a bodhisattva’s mental training, yes, which knows the selflessness of the person and comes about in dependence on a base, which knows that wrong views are mistaken. Okay? So that’s what we’re taking for example, that yoga, that practice. And then it says this practice, right — this thing that we’ve just talked about here is put forward as being the definition of an application that is a knower of bases because it realizes the selflessness of the person in the continuum of a bodhisattva. And it is said to be this.

Because it is engaged in that process. That’s the reasoning for why it can be used. It can be defined as the definition It can be used as the definition for a knower of basis, which is a yoga practice that Bodhisattva is engaging. Okay? Because it engages in the practice of using selflessness in order to get rid of negative states of mind.

So does that make sense? I said if I say it slowly, they’ll get it. Okay. So in order to understand this syllogism, in order for us to understand this why this logic works, we need to take it apart and look at the different parts of it. The first thing that we need to look at is what’s called the general image, the generalized image that is being presented in this syllogism.

The second thing that we need to look at is the divisions of incorrect views, which is the thing that we’re negating. And then we look at this in a condensed way, so it’s a summary of why that is the case. And then we look at what is a person. If we’re looking at the selflessness of persons, we need to define that’s what a person is, and then we look at the etymology of this of the of the terms that we’re looking here looking at here. Okay.

So in order for us to understand the general ideas that we’re talking about here, then we look we can look at some of the views that were put forward at the time of the Buddha. Now in general, at the time the Buddha was in on earth and teaching, they were said to be a group of Okay. Six. Six, what are called tritikas. It literally means ford builders.

But it mean it’s another way of saying those who propounded views that weren’t Buddhism. Yeah. That that took you away from the path you’re supposed to be on. Right? So there were six that were called those that were called Tīrthikas.

I’m I’m not saying it right. Anyway, Ford Ford builders, bridge builders, bridge builders to the wrong side of of the creek or whatever it is. Right? And there were six of them, and then there were six different views that were propounded by their students that were slightly different than these original builders. And then there’s said to be six more views that were propounded by those who focused on equanimity in terms of meditation.

So we have eighteen views that were said to be incorrect. Now, Okay. So from and then from in these eighteen groups came sixty two different ideas that were were said to be included within this incorrect views that were using the knowledge of bases to refute. So eighteen of these views were propounded by these people focused incorrectly on what was the beginning of Samsāra or the beginning of existence. So they were with regards to creation stories and so on.

And the other the other forty four were with regards to how you ended suffering, what the end of what liberation was. Alright? So some of them regarded to where we came from, and others with regards to how we end suffering. So altogether, there was there were sixty and sixty two of these wrong views, some with regards to where we creation and some with some with regards to the end of suffering. Okay.

So with regards to the eighteen that talked about, where we came from where we come from, creation stories or the, the extreme of the beginning, that were, wrong views. And then there were four that related to things being permanent. There were four that re that spoke of Okay. Sorry. There were four that talked about there were four that talked about how things were permanent.

There were two that talked about how things, were not continuous. There were four that talked about, whether there was whether there was a beginning or not. And there were Sorry. Sorry. So I’ll start again because I just changed what we were saying.

Okay. The third there was four that propounded permanence. There was four that propounded that some things were permanent and other things weren’t permanent. There was two that said there was no such thing as a continuum. There was four that said there was some things had a a beginning and other things didn’t have a beginning.

And there was four that said that referred to the getting rid of self or the not getting rid of self. So then it goes through and goes goes away, which which how many is there? Sixty two? Okay. So from amongst those who said that things were permanent, there was said to be a few people who had developed the clairvoyance of remembering previous lives in dependence on their meditative stabilizations and having perfected form realm levels of mind.

And they were able to, using their clairvoyance, perceive that they had lived in different lifetimes had experienced different lifetimes for sometimes twenty eons sometimes fourteen eons and sometimes eighty eons alright so they could remember the fact this far. Now in dependence on this clairvoyance, they said that things were permanent.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
tathagata de zhin sheg pa (Tib)
Epithet for a buddha; literally, “one who has gone to suchness.” LYWA
three doors go sum (Tib)
Body, speech and mind. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top