45 min · 3,043 words · 10 June 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A commentary on Haribhadra’s Clarifying the Meaning explains the three doors of complete liberation: liberation of embodied looking at form, formless looking at form, and liberation of the attractive. These are practised by Mahayana accumulation-path beings, Hinayana never-returners, and foe destroyers free from obscurations to absorption, to remove obstacles to absorption and attraction or aversion. The mental basis is the final concentration of the form and formless realms.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-06-10
Duration: 45 min
UUID: 2d433da9-0ec3-44f9-8b2e-0b8b39e2bb45
Words: 3,039
Yeah. Chocolate Right. I was I’m just managed to convince him we don’t have to wait for Joe because now he can actually listen to the tape. Sorry. I’m losing all my papers.
Okay. So this evening, we’re gonna go through No. Because we’ve stolen from remote control. Uh-uh. Of course.
Okay. So in Haribhādra’s commentary, which is called clarifying the meaning, then he says about these three parts of emanation that they are The first one is being not thoroughly free and the second one is thoroughly free from discrimination of form and internal and external forms respectively that’s like views and external forms and they are said to be with form and without form. These two complete liberations are antidotes to the obstructions of emanation and one abides with the body after manifesting and fulfilling the attractive door of complete liberation and emanating attractive and unattractive bodies are antidotes to the afflictions of pleasure and displeasure respectively. Thus these three are the aspects of the doors of complete liberation which means that we’re dealing with three different types of manifestations and that’s basically what it’s saying there. The first of these three manifestations is a liberation of the embodied looking at form.
So this is not the not thoroughly free one, and it has form. It’s one way of having a liberation to the obstruction of emanation and the next one is liberation of a formless looking at form that is looking at form from the point of view of form a formless concentrated state. And then there’s also the liberation of the attractive or the that of seeing that which is the liberation of seeing something to be attractive and something else not to be attractive. So in order to understand these three parts of manifestation, we need to look at, first of all, what the three are. And they yeah.
They’re they’re just what we said. The liberation of embodied looking at form, formless looking at form and the liberation of the attractive. So we need to look at what they are and then I need to look at the explanation of those which includes the description of the base for liberation in terms of mind and body, the way to meditate on this, the definition of the what it means, the words mean and the reason for doing it. So then we look start with the looking at the first of these, which is the base for these meditations and teachings and teachings and teachings and teachings. Okay.
So then when we’re talking about these three paths of manifestation, there we have the liberation that’s looking at embodied form and the liberation that’s form less and then this liberation of the attractive right. So the first two eliminate the obstructions to absorption the obstacles that would impede yogi to manifest as he wishes and then also we have this one they’re getting rid of the idea of liking attractive forms and not liking unattractive forms. So with all these developments in their mind stream it means that if we’re trying to define the base for which from which a being is able to do these meditations and teachings and teachings and teachings and teachings that is the embodiment that they have then they can be a bodhisattva who is on the mahayana path of accumulation or they can be a Hīnayāna never returner so that means that that a never returner is someone who doesn’t need to come back into embodied form apart from the embodiment they’re in, they’re going to achieve arahatship in that lifetime. Gema oh hang on sorry, there’s just I noticed that there’s a difference between this notes and what it in here, I think. Course.
Okay. Sorry. This is getting a bit confusing because it says in here, he was either a never returner who manifests the body of a foe destroyer who is free from the two obscurations, the afflicted obscurations, the obscurations to absorption. So we’re on page fifty two. But I was just trying to figure out how someone who wasn’t a foe destroyer could manifest the body of a foe destroyer when they weren’t a foe destroyer yet they’re only a never returner.
And Geshe-la said that that’s not what the text says. So in this one, we can say or a Hīnayāna yogi who is either a never returner or I said my sorry. I just stuffed up. Who manifests a body or a photo so I thought I said of a foe destroyer. Sorry about that.
One of them is a never returner so that’s someone who’s in their final lifetime and they’re about to achieve arahatship. That’s the one type of person. Then the other person that could have these realizations, is a foe destroyer who is free from two obscurations, afflictive obstructions and obstructions to absorption. Now you can be a foe destroyer, you can be someone who has achieved nirvana but not have and gotten rid of the obstructions to absorption. So you can only develop your realizations in dependence on the lower formless sorry the lower form realm meditative states.
But if you are one of these type of foe destroyers that is one who is free of the two obscurations afflictive obscurations and obstructions to absorption it means that you can get into the more subtle types of meditative absorption that are linked to the formless realm. Okay so that means that you’re able to do to make have much more subtle meditative techniques than you would if you were someone who was an arhat who had merely gotten rid of the causes for suffering as opposed to that which would stop them from having these very subtle absorptions. Right? I was just checking because there’s something that’s not in here. Okay.
I don’t think it’s in here. If it is, someone please tell me. So the reason that these three different types of being would be meditating on would be meditating on these things trying to develop the three parts of manifestation is because they haven’t developed what are called the eight form concentrations Okay there’s eight form concentrations so is the four concentrations that are associated with the form realm They haven’t developed those and so therefore they’re using these three parts of manifestations. If they develop those, they wouldn’t be necessarily needing to use the three types of forms of manifestation in the these three types of liberation because they would have already developed the results of that. Naughty.
Oh, yeah. Okay. So then if from the Abhidharma, the Abhidharma says that the main people who use have this meditation are beings who are born as a human are born as humans that is humans with these subtle meditative concentration states that accord with the form and formless realms but that doesn’t pervade there is also beings who are reborn into the form and formless realms because they die with these levels of meditative concentration when they’re human and they can also be using these three parts of manifestations in order to be able to develop the eight different concentrations from the Formless Realm that they need to develop So this means that in order for them to develop what’s called the liberation that is cessation then they can come from any of the three beings in any of the three different realms that is the desire realm, the form realm and the formless realm can actually be meditating on these three parts of manifestation that is if they have the ability to and they haven’t produced its results. Okay. So if you guys have got there’s a kind of a map or a chart on page sixty six, which may be helpful at this stage.
We’ve got a chart, and I’m thinking, cool. A chart will help, but now I’m not so sure. Okay. So so the the the definition of this the definition of these three parts of manifestation is freedom from certain types of obstructions to absorption and dependence on the final concentration that is its empowering condition and has the ability to display various transformed manifestations. So freedom from certain types of obscuration that is what we’re talking about when we said that there was one type of foe destroyer that was free from two different obscurations.
It was free from the obscurations of negative emotions and obscurations to absorption. So this is a person who is able to develop these different levels of absorption. Now when it says final concentration what it’s talking about with final concentration and what we need to define what we also need to define the mental base for these realizations right so we had like a physical base which was a being who was a foe destroyer or would never return or someone on the path of preparation accumulation. The mental base for this, the concentration that’s the base for this is what’s called the final concentration of any of the different levels of the Form and Formless Realm. So when you’re moving through the Form and Formless Realms after developing calm abiding and you when you develop calm abiding you enter the first concentration and when you’re on the first concentration your perception and the subtlety of your meditation becomes more subtle and more subtle and more subtle and so you develop the first concentration and then while you’re developing this first concentration you get rid of things that may be obscuring the subtlety of your meditation so that’s what’s called a liberation that is cessation.
So with every liberation and cessation that comes along you also develop what’s called a final concentration. Okay so every time you’re moving through these different levels right and you come to say the first concentration that has an introductory phase and then it has a concentration where you’re putting a lot of work to develop the subtlety of that concentration and finally two things come about and that is a liberation which is cessation that is the cessation of the obscurations to the subtle subtlety of the meditation and also you have what’s called concentration. That makes sense? So there’s a final concentration for every level of these where you’re working through the form and formless realms. So those final concentrations are what’s the mental basis for these, three powers of manifestation.
They’re the empowering condition for these manifestations for this ability to manifest. Okay. So the definition there then we move on to the definition to focus on that completely. Now the first part of this definition of the path of manifestation indicated in this case is an exalted knower which is just another lesser saying path which is freedom from certain types of obscurations to absorption in dependence on a final concentration that is its empowering condition. So this is what we were just talking about with the final concentration being the mind that comes along with the cessation to obscurations to mental concentration right?
So you’re concentrating you’re developing your concentrative abilities in the form realm and so if you are able to get rid of something that may be obscuring the subtlety of that meditation yeah then that’s said to be a liberation of cessation because so you’re liberated from because you have the cessation of that obscuration yeah and so when you have you were liberated and you have this because of the cessation of that obscuration along with that liberation comes this final concentration so the final concentration comes about because of this liberation which is cessation and so that is what you use as a basis or a mental basis or an empowering condition for the ability to display these various manifestations. So the then because of this final concentration, then you have the ability to get rid of obscurations to absorption, right? And then you also have this freedom you also develop this freedom which is like the liberation of cessation so then because of that this being then has the ability because they have these very subtle levels of mind to be able to manifest in all these different ways right they’re able to show different manifestations of whatever they want to manifest as all sorts of different things.
What we’re dealing with here is the mind that has this ability through abandoning these different obscurations to mental absorption. Or yes, yes, by abandoning obscurations to absorption, the mind becomes more subtle and therefore has the ability to manifest in all these different ways. So the definition we’re dealing with here is not the manifestations themselves, but the mind that has the ability to manifest in this way. Okay. So the borders for this or the boundaries for this type of realization are that it exists from the Mahāyāna path, it exists from the path of accumulation because that s when people start doing these types of meditations and teachings and teachings and teachings and teachings.
On the Hīnayāna path, it exists from the path of seeing. So someone who is a never returner has perceived selflessness and is therefore on the path of seeing of the Hīnayāna. Okay, so the way that this is meditated upon, first of all we have the liberation of the embodied looking at form. Now this is basically if the meditator focuses on the idea, has the conception that they an embodied being that they have a physical body while they are focusing on an object and looking at their lack of inherent existence of that object or the lack of inherent existence of their body, yeah, that is the liberation of the embodied looking at form. Now the next one, the liberation of the formless looking at form, they perceive that they don’t have a body they perceive their existence is formless, and through this conception So, yeah, it’s not conception, but they think in this way through this what would you call it?
Well, let’s just say thinking in that way. Right? So first of all, it’s it’s not Okay. Alright. So Okay.
So this is a conception. I was just I’m allowed to say it. Alright? I was just making sure. So they have the conception that they are not an embodied being, and then they are focusing on other forms.
So in this way they’re not focusing on their own existence, they’re focusing on the forms around them and then non inherent existence of theirs. So they’re doing it from two meditative positions. The first one being the conception that they have a physical form and the second one being the fact that they don’t have a physical form and then on top of that so when they’re able to look at the see through their physical form to see that it’s not inherently existent and therefore it’s not there alright then they’re able to look at all the other objects they’re focusing on get through perceiving the non inherent existence of the objects they’re focusing on get rid of attraction to some and dis-attraction or repulsion from others. First of all they are dealing with themselves being formed being looking at form and then they think of themselves as being a non form being because they see the lack of inherent existence of self and then they’re focusing on form still and looking at the non inherent existence of forms and then based on that non inherent existence of forms they’re able to get rid of the being attracted the idea of being attracted to some and being attracted to others Now the reason that you say that this is a conception that they have is because this particular meditative practice is confined to those beings who are either on the path of accumulation or once returners on the Hīnayāna path or arhats who have gotten rid of obscurations to meditative absorption are those three types of beings.
Buddhas don’t have this meditation but they have an understanding of this meditation which is why it says to be something that is in accordance with the development of a bodhisattva and not a mind that is unique to Buddha. Buddhas don’t actually have this conception they have the realization of that conception. So the reason that they are this is called three paths of manifestation is because it uses the focus on manifestations on being a manifest being or not being a manifest being or seeing how things are not inherently existent and therefore can be different types of manifestation. It be are actually different manifestations. It uses those meditations and teachings and teachings and teachings and teachings to get rid of obscurations to meditative concentration.
This one? Sorry. So then the idea and I forgot something from before when the meditator is focusing on being an embodied being, they don’t just view themselves as being a one embodied being. Like this is me and I’m an embodied being. They have this idea that they are big sometimes and that they are small sometimes, that they are rotten sometimes, that they are clean sometimes.
So there’s all of these different visualizations they’re doing with their being. It’s not just like one embodied being focusing on self, it’s different manifestations that they’re able to produce based on their understanding of emptiness. So the reason for doing these meditations and teachings and teachings and teachings and teachings isn’t just so that they can turn themselves into all sorts of good stuff, good things, good emanations or bad emanations. The reason that they are doing these meditations and teachings and teachings and teachings and teachings is because by seeing through the falsity of form, by being able to perceive themselves as all of these different emanations or to even perceive themselves as being a non emanated being then they are able to get rid of obscurations to meditative concentration and knowledge of obscuration and therefore progress along the path towards becoming a Buddha, so it s for the benefit of self and others that they doing it. So that s the end of the three paths of manifestation.
Okay. So the the part from the commentary clarifying the meaning that we
Key terms in this teaching
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- two obscurations dvi-avarana (Skt); drib pa nyi (Tib)
- Deluded mental states that block the attainment of liberation and enlightenment. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.