44 min · 3,910 words · 1 April 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk opens with the seven points of mind training and the need for a dharmic motivation (Bodhicitta, renunciation or avoiding lower rebirths) before any action, then turns to the Ornament for Clear Realisations. It explains the path of preparation for realisation, the five powers of faith, joy, mindfulness, concentration and wisdom, and how they focus on the emptiness of the Four Noble Truths. It ends partway through the sixteen aspects and the power of mindfulness.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-04-01
Duration: 45 min
UUID: 39415ba1-8540-4cf7-894b-61a8d712bd79
Words: 3,906
From the Buddha, the Dharma, and Sangha. So it’s not just considering the Buddha Okay. So in the seven points of mind training, which was collected by Geshe Chekawa he said that at the beginning there should be two at the end there is two things sorry at the beginning and at the end Now what this is referring to is before we perform any action we need to cultivate the right motivation for whatever it is that we are going to do. And because we are cultivating the right motivation, that also means that we need to do something with the right motivation. If we don’t do anything, then we have nothing to dedicate.
Even though he says too, there are three things that we need to concentrate on: we need to concentrate on the preliminary, which is the motivation we need to concentrate on the actual action, which is the performing of a virtuous action and we need to concentrate on the last which is the dedication or what he said as at the end. So there’s these three things that we need to concentrate on even though in his quote it says there is two. At the beginning, we need to develop the right motivation. What this refers to is the way we think about something before we act on that thought. If we want to practice Mahāyāna Dharma or we want to be part of the altruistic vehicle, we need to develop the motivation of Bodhicitta.
If we develop the motivation of Bodhicitta loving kindness thinking of others then our actions become those of the Mahāyāna vehicle. If we don’t develop these actions and we do something with the motivation that what we are doing is in order to achieve liberation from saṃsāra then our actions accord with the actions of the middle scope or the middle type of being. If we do something with the idea that we are doing it in order to create the cause or to create the positive action to be reborn in the higher realms or to be free from negative karma then we do something that accords with the lower scope if we don’t think of any of these things then what we are actually doing doesn’t become Dharma, doesn’t become Buddhist Dharma it may be positive by its nature but it doesn’t become a dharmic action if we don’t have one of those three motivations so we need to think about either developing the mind of Bodhicitta before perform an action or the mind of renunciation before we perform an action or the mind that’s turned away from the lower realms and the performing of negative actions. So through through either of these through any of these three motivations, then we have turned whatever it is we’re doing into Dharma.
So what it is that we’re studying this evening is what’s called the ornament of clear realizations or the ornament to clear realizations. Now, an ornament of clear realization or a clear realization is a Mahāyāna mind. So this means that this text is a Mahāyāna text or a greater vehicle text. And so because it is a greater vehicle text then we should try and attune our minds to the essence of this text and develop a Mahāyāna motivation or a greater vehicle motivation for studying this text so what we need to develop in order to study in order to develop a Mahāyāna motivation is our Bodhicitta if we have uncontrived Bodhicitta then every action that we perform becomes a mahayana or a greater vehicle action If we don’t have Bodhicitta, if we don’t have uncontrived Bodhicitta then we need to develop the mind or the thought that we need to focus on achieving enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings So we do this in a contrived way but by doing something this in a contrived way that plants the seeds for developing Bodhicitta later. I guess he wants to know if we have to meditate.
So he said, Okay, if you want to meditate, then you should think in this way. You should think that all sentient beings are the same as we are and that they all want to be happy and they don’t want to experience suffering. Unfortunately, they do not know the causes for experiencing true happiness and through their effort to achieve happiness continually create the causes for experiencing suffering. In this way, they are exactly the same as us. In order for them to understand what it is they need to do to achieve happiness, they need to be able to be shown dharma.
So, and not only do we think of this but also that all of these sentient beings at some stage or another have been our parents. They have shown us great kindness. We have had countless rebirths which means that we have had we have countless mothers and through being our mother they have shown us great kindness. So given all this then the only thing that is reasonable for us to do is to continually strive towards Buddhahood in order that we can show these beings how not to suffer. So when you have that idea in your head, when you have thought of that idea, then you can meditate or familiarize yourself with that idea for a few minutes.
And also, if you remember that the virtue you are about to create by looking through or studying the clear ornament of realization if you were to mix that virtuous action with the virtuous actions of all of the five different types of beings then that becomes a very powerful force and by rejoicing or feeling very happy about the virtuous actions of all of the five types of beings then the action we’re about to perform becomes very powerful so if you concentrate on how immense the virtuous actions are and rejoice in that or have a happy mind about that then your meditation will become all the more powerful so now you’re supposed to meditate for a couple So we’ve arrived we’re going through the text and we’ve arrived at the discussion of the five powers, which comes under the heading in the English translation, the fourth division, the path preparing for realization. And he said he wants to know if you’ve all got it. This one. Yeah. So in the text it states, after the path thoroughly training concentration and what that is referring to is the four legs of magical emanation which we went through last time we were here and that was referring to the different powers of concentration that people develop especially on the path of accumulation.
So after they’ve developed these four legs of concentration they can then move on to what’s called the development of the five powers. So the reason that these come after those four legs of magical emanation is that they use the four legs of magical emanation which are these different types of concentration or these different concentrations as a basis for developing the five powers. So this is talked about after the concentrated states because it uses the concentrated states as their basis for development. Okay, so where it says after the path thoroughly training and concentration there is reason for explaining the path preparing for realization, because they come about and so what this means is that when you’ve trained your mind thoroughly through concentration you then move on to the path of preparing for realization so where it says here explaining the path preparing for realization realization that is referring to is realization of emptiness and so if you thoroughly train your mind in these four different types of concentration you develop the five powers based on those things and they act as a cause for you to develop further levels of understanding and then you go on to achieve the realization of emptiness.
Where it says it is stated or what that is referring to is the original commentary what it says in the original commentary by Haribhādra and he was one of the first people to write a commentary on the Abhisamayālamkāra or the ornament of clear realization and then in explanation it says that having thoroughly trained the mind, heat and peak arise. Heat and peak are referring to the first two levels of the path of preparation. So, then when it says a textual meaning, what this is referring to is take the path preparing for realization so this is the path that gives rise to the realization of emptiness and is why the path of preparation is called the path of preparation. It says there are many because the main focus is on the development of the five powers of faith, joy, mindfulness, concentration and wisdom and these are components of course of this thirty seven dhammas compatible with enlightenment so what we have happening here is a process which brings about the realization of emptiness and it’s called path of preparing for the realization of emptiness. So in this we have four different sections.
The first two are called heat and peak. Now in the heat and peak stages you do the training in these five powers. The five powers are actually a training process in joy, mindfulness, concentration, wisdom and faith. These five powers. So in that process it said to be there’s a preparation and a training process happening then when you get on to the next two levels of path preparation that is the path of patience and the path of a supreme Dharma which are the last two sections path preparation.
They’re actually said to be the cause for the realization of emptiness. The first two are the preparation. The latter two are the cause for the realization of emptiness. So in the first two you are practicing what are called the five powers that is using antidotes to get rid of the thoughts that need antidotes the things to be abandoned through these practices of faith, joy, mindfulness, concentration, and wisdom. Okay.
Right. So when it says the next the the next thing that we need to go through is the focal object and it says the focal objects exist because the four truths are that so what that means is what beings are focusing on when they have the five powers or what the object of focus for the five powers is the emptiness of the four truths. The lack of inherent existence of the four truths. Now the reason that one of these is for example faith is that if you are able to perceive the truth of the four truths and the truth of the emptiness of the four truths then the three different types of faith will naturally arise. You will have clear faith because you’ll be able to see it clearly.
You will have believing faith because you will be able to understand what the results will be. You will understand, you will believe that the results will come about and you will have aspirational faith. And then you will also have aspirational faith because you will have desire to make these results come about. And so in this way then the mind focusing on the emptiness of the Four Noble Truths is a main mind, right? So it’s the main objective of concentration and the first of these, for example, faith is a mental factor that comes along with this main mind focusing on the emptiness of the four noble truths.
Okay, so the Ārya paths it says here that is because by preparing for the aria paths right now this Ārya paths we’re talking about is everything from the path of seeing and up with the paths. On the path of preparation what you’re doing is preparing for these Ārya paths, preparing for the path of seeing, the path of meditation and the path of no more learning. The way that you bring about the path of seeing is by perceiving directly the nature of reality through meditation on the four noble truths. In order to train for this to come about then you practice by focusing on the emptiness of the Four Noble Truths and this practice is focusing on the combined aspect or the aspects that are the combination of the four noble truths. Okay, so the four truths are focused on in combination or in or lumped together for one of a better way of putting it.
And through focusing on this, that acts as a cause for the path of seeing to come about. And so it says here that this is the cause for the path of seeing. So in the Samgraha Nāgārjuna said, what is the focus of the powers and then says the four Ārya truths. So the focus of the powers of powers here is obviously referring to the five powers of faith, joy, mindfulness, concentration, and wisdom. And what they are focusing on or what their objective meditation is is the noble truth.
So the method of meditation it says the method of meditation exists because by the convictional faith in the practice and rejection of the four truths relying on the yoga derived from meditation one meditates with continuous mindfulness holding without forgetting the focus and aspect Now what this means is the method of meditation exists so that is the way that it comes about because if you have the yoga derived from meditation. Now yoga derived from meditation is another way of saying calm abiding. Okay so if you have calm abiding then you have a steady basis from which to on which to sorry a steady base on which to rest your meditations and with these meditations you can then focus on the four noble truths. So focusing on the four noble truths and seeing the four noble truths correctly means that you will be able to see what is to be abandoned and what is to be practiced. Through focusing on what is to seeing clearly what is to be abandoned and what is to be practiced you will develop a convictional faith.
This convictional faith will then inspire you or keep you focused on continuing on mindfully without forgetting the focus and the aspect. So this means that we have some of the five powers included within that process. No. It doesn’t matter. I’ve got a strange feeling I’m pronouncing this Sanskrit wrong, but you guys don’t care.
So it’s a collection. It means a collection. The collection of all is the name of the text in English anyway which was by Nāgārjuna. In this again he says: what is the method of meditation? The power of faith meditates by means of higher convictional faith on the four truths.
So this is just backing up what was just explained previously that the way that this meditation comes about is if you have this if you can see what’s going on because you’re focusing on the four noble truths then you’re going to have a very clear convicted faith in what’s happening and what it is you need to get rid of and what it is you need to develop. Okay. So the process that’s going on here is that by being able to focus single pointedly on the objects of the four noble truths faith obviously comes about alright and through faith coming about especially this convictional faith that if you do what is you’re supposed to do then the results will be certain then the next thing that comes out is this thing that’s called joyous effort or a joy in the process that’s happening. Process that’s happening through this joy in taking joy in the process that’s happening then there is no difficulty in staying focused on the object and not forgetting the object along with this comes this idea of concentration where if you are focused on an object and you don’t forget it which is the practice of mindfulness and then this brings about concentration Okay.
So then this process of concentration means that you’re able to single pointedly focus on any object you wish to concentrate on without being distracted, without having other thoughts come up. You’re able to concentrate on something and understand it properly by not being distracted by anything else. So what happens with this process is that you are concentrating on the object of the Four Noble Truths and you can understand what it is that needs to be abandoned and what it is that needs to be practiced. And while this process is happening, then the fifth power which is the power of wisdom is able to analyze that situation to investigate the nature of that situation and focus on the emptiness of that situation or whatever it is that we are focusing on. So these five aspects that we have here faith, joy, mindfulness, concentration and wisdom are actually all mental factors that accompany a main mind that is focused single pointedly in a meditative concentration on Four Noble Truths.
This one. Is that okay? It’s focusing on what’s called the sixteen aspects of the four noble truths. And within those sixteen aspects, is emptiness. There is selflessness.
All of these things are in that. So it’s focusing on the compendium or the collection of those sixteen aspects. So in this way, it is focusing on their emptiness as its meditative focus. So the reason that this needs to be done is that when these five powers are being cultivated or when they are present, the being is on the path of preparation in the preliminary two sections of that. That is the heat and peak section.
At this stage, using the five powers to develop their capabilities. After that they quickly need to establish or develop what are called the stages of the path of preparation of patience and supreme Dharma. So to quickly bring that about and practice the part of the path they’re on, then these five powers need to be cultivated or need to be they need to be possessed. Okay. So as Nāgārjuna said in his collection of all then what is the result of this meditation it says it’s to quickly comprehend the four truths now this is another way of saying to realize emptiness, the sixteen aspects of the Four Noble Truths and develop heat and peak.
So these have already arisen and they need to be completely developed. Okay. So that’s the first two stages of path preparation which have arisen but need to be completed after this the next two stages of the path preparation patience and supreme Dharma need to be brought about quickly so this is the reason that they being on the the being who has developed the first part of the path preparation and needs to focus on the five powers. And then indeed, Okay.
So then the next thing we have where it says the nature, and when we’re going through these things, when it comes up to the nature of the thing we’re talking about, this is another way of saying the definition of the thing we’re talking about. So it’s pin pointing its nature so what it is that we need to pinpoint the nature of first is these five powers now it says that the definition of a power from among the thirty-seven dharmas compatible with enlightenment. The reason that it is specified here is because there are many different types of powers and when we talk about different beings’ powers it could be referring to any number of things, but specifically when we’re talking about the thirty-seven dharmas compatible with enlightenment the definition of a power is a pristine awareness or an exalted knower in the other translation which produces through its own power the Ārya path which is its result. Now what it means when it says through its own power is that it’s the cause for that to come about. It’s the reason that the Ārya path comes about as its result.
And this means that it’s directly related to the result. There isn’t many other things in between that happen before the Ārya path comes about. Okay, so classifications or the divisions of this section is the five powers: the power of faith, the power of effort, mindfulness, concentration, and wisdom. And they are divided in this way because it says in the collective work of Nāgārjuna, faith, effort, mindfulness, concentration, wisdom. Okay, sorry.
Okay, sorry because again I was saying that this is like the reason they’re saying is like wait a minute, the power of faith, effort, mindfulness, concentration and wisdom as defined here is by Asaṇga and so why are they using Nāgārjuna as a root text? He goes, he said that this Grantha or these collected topics was actually Nāgārjuna’s commentary on Prajñāpāramitā Sutras that the Buddha spoke, right? And so from the one perspective, you have Maitreya the clear ornament of realization and they’re not using the quotes from Nāgārjuna as like a root text for this commentary, right? They’re using them to show that Nāgārjuna said exactly the same thing. So even though Nāgārjuna and Asaṇga came from these different lineages is to show that there’s correlation between the two.
Okay. So it wasn’t so it’s a root text. And the other thing is that the actual Ornament of Clear Realization is a very, very short text. It doesn’t go for many pages and it’s done fairly cryptically. And this collection of topics by Nāgārjuna is a very extensive commentary that is actually quite easy to read.
So they’re using it as a reference to kind of decipher the clear ornament of realization and also to give a backup for these two different reasons. Okay, so to be more specific what these five powers actually are. The first one where it says the first is convictional faith in that to be practiced and rejected of the four truths. Now the reason that it says convictional faith in that to be practiced and rejected of the four truths is because two of the four noble truths need to be abandoned and two of the four noble truths need to be practiced. The truth of suffering and the truth of the origin of suffering need to be abandoned.
The truth the path and sorry the truth of cessation and the truth of the path need to be practiced. If you are focusing on the four noble truths and you are able focus on them single pointedly and clearly then you will understand perfectly or completely what it is that you need to abandon and what it is that you need to practice through these Four Noble Truths through that, you will develop what’s called this convictional faith. You will be absolutely convinced about what will happen if you abandon things and what will happen if you cultivate positive things. So that’s the first one. The second one is taking delight in comprehending the four truths, which is another reason why it shouldn’t be effort, but anyway.
Third is holding without forgetting the focus and aspect with respect to those. Okay, so this means that mindfulness is that you’re able to continually focus on the sixteen aspects of the Four Noble Truths without your mind wandering
Key terms in this teaching
- Collected Topics dura (Tib)
- A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
- five powers
- The five practices to be applied in this life and near the time of death. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
- The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
- path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
- The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.