29 min · 2,141 words · 5 February 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains that emptiness is realised first through analysis and then directly, once dependent origination is perceived non-conceptually, which stops the grasping at inherent existence. It describes afflictive and knowledge obscurations and how practitioners on different vehicles and paths remove them. It also covers how an inferential cognition of emptiness arises shortly after understanding dependent origination, using the smoke-and-fire analogy.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-02-05
Duration: 30 min
UUID: 3418c626-e570-4e52-84c8-4de607f16156
Words: 2,137
What we need to do in order to use it as a sign to recognize emptiness. So there’s a difference between us being able to analytically arrive at the end of that process, and there is for us to see us to see that directly in every object. And once we’ve perceived it directly in every object, then it’s easy for us based on that sign, then we can Okay. So for example, at the moment, we don’t recognize all objects as being inherently existent to start off with. For example, with a table, if you’re talking about that as a phenomenal object, we don’t look at the table and instantly have the direct perception that there is a dependent origination.
Need to process it a lot before we come to that conclusion. So if we see the table, we don’t, as a direct perception, say there’s a dependent origination. We say that’s a table. Yeah? And if we start processing and going, do we really is it really inherently existing as a table?
If I just established it as something that stops the cup hitting the floor, would that be okay? You know? So we have to go through this process before we can see that the table isn’t inherently existent, that it’s a dependent origination. And it’s something that we could have doubts about at any time because we could lose our concentration on what we were contemplating or our analytical processes could go awry. So once we’ve done that a lot a lot a lot a lot and become incredibly habituated with the process, we would perceive things directly the way that we perceive them after a lot of analysis now.
Right? And so it means directly perceiving all things without that analysis. Because we’re talking about a non conceptual perception of dependent origination. All of our conceptions of dependent origination at the moment are conceptual. So if we’re able to perceive things non conceptually without thinking about it, without a moment’s thought that it’s a dependent origination, it’s not truly existent, that’s when we perceive the dependent origination and that stops us from perceiving it as being inherently existent.
Yeah? Blissful. Peaceful. Okay. So, yeah, it would make our mind a lot calmer because a lot more peaceful because what we have a lot of conceptuality going on in our head.
We can’t keep coming up with ideas about this and this and this and this and this. And if we perceived emptiness directly, then we wouldn’t have to do any conceptualizing. And we would be incredibly happy because we could see that we’re about to become free of suffering because it’s a realizing emptiness directly means that we’re definitely going to become liberated because we just have to get rid of the imprints of grasping inherent existence. So that would make us happy and calm, and we wouldn’t spend a lot of time thinking about things we don’t need to. And guess I said we’d be a lot happier than we are now.
So he said that if we put in the work and if we worked really hard, then we could be really happy, like truly happy. But we think, oh, it’s so much hard work and it’s so much like pain to get to being happy that we just don’t put in the hard work to get happy. Two sets of of obscurations. Uh-huh. Obscuration, omniscience, the knowledge obscuration.
Knowledge obscurations are obscuration, omniscience. They’re both the same? There’s two sets of what? Two different ways of saying both of them. Two different ways of saying the both.
There’s two. Two? And there’s two different ways of saying both. Yes. So you have obscurations, afflictive obscurations or obscurations to liberation.
And you have knowledge obscurations or obscurations to omniscience. Whichever way you wish to name them. Do you remove them as separate sets? Right? You remove that set first and then the second one.
Or is it intertwined like other parts of things? Sure. Sure. Okay. It depends.
Okay. If you’re a Bodhisattva, then you abandon Okay. Okay. So when you’re on the path if you’re a Bodhisattva, right? When you’re on the path of accumulation and the path of preparation, you’re able to harm the obstructions, but you’re not really able to get rid of them completely.
Because in order to start getting rid of them completely, have to have entered the unobstructed path on the path of seeing. Yeah. Okay, so from there you start abandoning obstructions from omniscience and obstructions to liberation, right? And you keep doing those sequentially, not sequentially a few of those, a few of that, a few of that and you’re getting rid of a whole bunch of stuff all the time. But up until you reach the seventh ground of the path of meditation, the seventh of the Bodhisattva grounds, you focus mainly on getting rid of obscurations to liberation.
Yeah, or afflictive of emotion obscurations. Once you get past that, only have obscurations to omniscience because you achieve liberation at the end of the seventh ground on the Mahāyāna path, right? So that means that at that stage, then you start working through the obscurations to omniscience. Now, if you are a hearer on the hearer path, on the hearer vehicle, you only get rid of all the way up the path to the end where you achieve arhatship. You’re only getting rid of the obstructions to liberation.
Yeah. If you’re a solitary realizer on your part, you’re getting rid of the obscurations to liberation and the gross obscurations to knowledge. Yeah? Or the obscuration to omniscience. Yeah?
Knowledge obscurations. Yeah? So therefore it depends on which path you’re on and which stage of the path you’re on. So Bodhisattvas are always getting rid of obscurations to omniscience and obscurations to afflictive emotion obscurations. But they actually focus mainly on one until they achieve liberation and then they do.
I don’t know how good I’m gonna be able to translate this, but go. Yeah. So it’s like white wall should be black like that, is that what you’re talking about? Okay. Mhmm.
Mhmm. Okay. So if if you’re doing something that’s called discriminating, that’s one of, the five aggregates, that is to say, there’s a wall, it’s a white wall, it’s a very white wall, or that’s a clean wall or something like that. There’s no problem with that. You don’t have to worry about that.
Right? When it’s a problem is when you say that’s a clean white wall, I want one. Yeah? Or there’s something there’s some inherent desire or attachment in the discrimination. Yeah?
It says that if there is desire in the discrimination, then you should be focusing on impermanence. Yeah. But discrimination is different to judging and you need to be so discrimination is fine. Don’t worry about it. Is if there’s attachment involved, then you start need to start thinking about impermanence.
Okay. So a white if you think, okay, there’s a white wall. Alright? Thinking there’s a white wall, there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s a this is normal that’s a good thought.
If you’re if then you have to kind of think though, if you wanted to train your mind in developing an understanding of emptiness, that wall is appearing to me as being inherently existent and it’s not truly existent. So that’s one way of looking at the wall that would help. But if you go, that’s a nice wall, I want one, then you need to start thinking impermanence. You can either train in looking at the emptiness of the wall or look to see if there’s any attachment there. But if it’s just a thought of the wall and being discriminatory about the wall, there’s no problem.
You’re not gonna give up till you you know you’ve realized Oh, okay. Sure. Sure. Sure. An inferential cognition of emptiness.
Yeah. Okay. Between having direct Yeah. Realization of the empty origination. Yeah.
Yeah. Much separate. Okay. I said, so do you realize Okay. Do you realize dependent origination at the same time as you realize an inferential cognizer of emptiness?
And Geshe was like, no, absolutely not. And I was like, why? And then we went backwards and forwards and then I realized I’m talking to a Geshe. And if you say the same time, it means exactly the same time, like the same instant. And then he’s like, very soon afterwards.
No, no, was just like, how long does it take or does it happen quickly? Yeah, know, but I was just saying, it happen at around the same time? And it was like, yeah, it’s almost the same, but he was like, no, can’t happen at the same time, they’re different minds. Anyway, so he said that it happens quite quickly afterwards, right? In a similar way that if you looked at the smoke on the hillside, you would recognise that there’s fire, but you actually have to think about it, yeah?
You can’t just be an instant thing, yeah. Because if we see smoke on the hillside then we know it’s fire, but if we don’t know about smoke, we’re not gonna know about fire, right. So you have to understand smoke in order to understand fire, yeah. And so once you understand that smoke means fire, then you can establish it; so once you understand that dependent origination means emptiness then you can establish an inferential cognizer of emptiness, right, and then once you’ve established an inferential cognizer you have to meditate for a fair while to develop that into a direct perception of emptiness. But it happens very quickly after — the inferential cognizer happens very quickly after the perception of dependent origination.
Minute. And then he said, well, you can have a generic understanding of the dependent origination and it could take you a lifetime to figure out emptiness. And he said that that could happen with people as well, that there’s understandings of dependent origination and to say how long it takes couldn’t be phrased because they actually have to think that that means emptiness at some stage. Yeah? So it could take a minute.
It could take a lifetime. So he said that it all depends on what the imprints are from previous experiences, whether people have developed that understanding that there’s connection or what their obscurations are, their afflictive obscurations and their knowledge obscurations are. So it depends on all sorts of things like that. He said, who can say which way people are gonna develop? If someone develops this understanding, it doesn’t mean then the next understanding follows.
That depends on their situation apart from Buddhas, and they can look and tell. But maybe Okay. So he said, but Joe should be able to figure it out because he has a big tummy. Right? And I said, Joe’s tummy is getting smaller and smaller about it, and he goes, yeah, but then he’ll understand impermanence because his tummy is getting smaller.
Yeah. Yeah. It’s just yeah. And he said you’re also really lucky because by having your stomach getting smaller and smaller, it means you’ll be more comfortable. Geshe-la says he has a big stomach, and it’s uncomfortable.
So that’s right. Okay. Now I was like, okay. Now we can finish because we’re talking about people’s stomachs. Stomach’s gotten really big and it wasn’t as big when he first came to Adelaide.
He said it’s not water. It’s fat on my stomach. It’s the fat as well. Yeah. Idea.
He thought he thought it meant on his stomach. He’s like, there’s not water on my stomach. It’s fat. He said it’s fat. It’s fat.
He’s very confused about this because he said when he lived in in He thinks it isn’t water, right? This is his theory. No, there’s logic in it. Because when he was in India, yeah, then he ate a lot of meat, ate a lot of fat, ate a lot of butter, and had a lot of greasy foods and things like that. And then he said, but he also drank Indian water, which meant that you pooed a lot.
And then you had a lot of stuff coming out of you. So that meant that he thinks it probably is the water because there’s nothing wrong with the water. That means that you don’t have any problems. So he thinks it is the water. Yeah.
Yeah. He said, okay. He drinks good water. That means that his stomach’s gotten a lot healthier. And because his stomach’s gotten a lot healthier, he’s not getting rid excess food.
And because he’s not getting rid of excess food, then he’s getting a fatter stomach. So therefore, it is dependent origination.
Key terms in this teaching
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- obscurations to knowledge jneyavarana (Skt); she drib (Tib)
- One of the two obscurations, the more subtle ones that block enlightenment; also known as subtle obscurations, obscurations to enlightenment and cognitive obscurations (Berzin’s translation). LYWA
- path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
- The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
- The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- Shravakayana nyen thö kyi thegpa (Tib)
- The Hearer Vehicle. One of the branches of the Hinayana. The path of hearers (shravakas), practitioners who strive for liberation from cyclic existence on the basis of listening to teachings from a spiritual guide or teacher. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Are the two obscurations removed one set after the other, or are they abandoned together in an intertwined way?
It depends on the path and the stage. On the paths of accumulation and preparation, a Bodhisattva can harm the obstructions but cannot remove them completely. Complete abandoning starts once the path of seeing is entered, and from there both obscurations are abandoned, a bit of each all the time. Until the seventh ground, a Bodhisattva focuses mainly on the obscurations to liberation (the afflictive emotion obscurations). Liberation is achieved at the end of the seventh ground, after which the focus is on the obscurations to omniscience. A hearer removes only the obscurations to liberation. A solitary realizer removes those and also the gross obscurations to knowledge.