45 min · 2,575 words · 4 March 2004
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the four close placements of mindfulness (body, feelings, mind and phenomena) using a commentary on the Abhidharma by Vasubandhu. It shows how to meditate on impermanence, suffering, emptiness and selflessness through the definitions of each base, and how this common method differs for hearers, solitary realizers and bodhisattvas.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2004-03-04
Duration: 45 min
UUID: 931ec93b-9f22-4f9c-bac0-176658f13df4
Words: 2,571
So the general characteristics that we meditate on for all three for body, for feelings and for mind are impermanence, suffering, emptiness and selflessness. So this is to say that we focus on the fact that all compounded phenomena is impermanent, that all afflicted or contaminated entities are suffering and all dharmas are empty and selfless. This means that for each of these things, we focus on the fact that, say for example, the body. The body is impermanent. The body, because it’s compounded phenomena, is impermanent.
The body, because it’s a contaminated phenomena, is by its nature suffering. And the body, because it is a phenomena, is empty and selfless. And we do the same for the other three close placements. Alright. So then in the the commentary to the Abhidharma by again, by Vasubandhu.
He says then that not only do we focus on these specific characteristics of the four objects, that is the impermanence, suffering, emptiness and selflessness of these, We also focus on the definitions or the characteristics of the things themselves or the way that they’re explained. So it says the thing itself definition is its nature. So therefore, we have focus on two different things. So the definition of phenomena is that it is its own entity. Then the definition of compounds is that they dissolve or they cease to exist.
The definition of contaminated suffering is that it is the truth of suffering. And the definition of dharma’s being empty or phenomena being empty is that the definition of dharma’s is that which is empty or it is there’s two there’s that which is empty or that which is established by its own entity. So, no that which is its own entity, sorry. So it means that, for example, when we are focusing on the body, we focus on how the body is impermanent because it is a compounded phenomenon and how compounded phenomena disintegrate because that’s their definition, right? And then when we focus on the suffering nature, the truth of suffering nature of the body, we focus on the fact that because it’s the truth of suffering nature No, sorry.
Because it’s a contaminated phenomena therefore its nature is the truth of suffering. And when we focus on emptiness of phenomena, we focus on the fact that because phenomena are their own entity, that entity is emptiness so therefore they are empty. And we go through and focus on both aspects of all of these general characteristics of the four close placements in mindfulness. So this means that for every base, every one of these, every close placement body, feelings, mind or dharmas, then there is like a specific type or a specific focus that we can put onto that base. So it’s said to be the characters that it has and the things that have that character.
So, for example, if we’re focusing on the body, and we have this close placement of mindfulness on the body, then first of all, we think that the body’s definition or we develop the understanding that the body’s definition is a collection of phenomena or a collection of things. So this is the definition of the body. And then because this body then, which is a collection of things, we focus on the first of its characteristics, which is that it’s impermanent. Then we focus on the fact that it’s suffering. Then we focus on the fact that it’s empty.
Then we focus on the fact that it is selfless. After we focus on these, then we focus on the fact that it is impermanent because it is a compounded phenomena. And because it’s a compounded phenomena, that means that its definition that it ceases to be, that it disintegrates. Then we focus on the fact that it is suffering, instance of the truth of suffering and once we realize that we think that is because it is contaminated phenomena. Then why is it contaminated phenomena?
Because it’s something that’s generated and ceases to be. Then when we’re focusing on the emptiness of it we realize that this emptiness is the definition of phenomena itself. Because this is a collection of phenomena therefore empty as well. So we go through this process of focusing or developing understanding or having close mindfulness about these different characteristics of the body. So because of this then we say that there is characteristics and a thing which has these characters.
So we put one on top of each other. We think, okay, there’s a thing that has these characters and it’s these are the characters and we go through the characters one by one. Okay. So then we’re now onto the specific characteristics of these four close placements. Now, the first one we deal with is body.
The specific characteristics of body is said to be that it is made from the elements, the four elements which is fire, water, earth and what have I missed? Yeah, right. Got it. And air. I knew that was And then what’s called the things that are derived from the elements.
Now there’s two different ways of looking at this. Things that are derived from the elements are said to be the seven things or the seven characteristics or the seven different types of experience of touch. Okay as from collected topics. So you have the seven different experiences of touch are heavy and light and rough and smooth. So they’re the main four that are associated with body that are derived from the elements.
Characteristics. But then you could also include the other three things that are said to be experiences of touch, which are heat and cold and dryness. This one? This one. Oh.
Oh, okay. Yeah. I was like, so why not wetness? And he said that’s in the four the four elements. It’s water.
So then the next one, the specific characteristics of feelings are said to be that the feelings are by their nature experience. That means feelings are the experience of suffering, experience of happiness and the experience of equanimity. Now these experiences then if we are focused on meditations on those are done through the general characteristics So you focus on the impermanence of, say, suffering, the suffering of suffering, the emptiness of suffering, the selflessness of this feeling of suffering, and through the same with happiness and so forth. The next one then, the mind is by the mind by nature activates focus. So what this means is that our mind is something that has a focus.
So this is the characteristic of mind. So then for every focus, every mind and its focus then you meditate on the impermanent suffering, emptiness, selflessness, disintegration, generation, uncompoundedness and so forth of that mind and its object. Okay. So Dharma is the individual nature of the mental factors, etc. This means the mental factors are apart from feelings and instances of mental factors that aren’t feelings are for example discrimination or discriminatory minds or discriminatory thoughts.
Discriminatory thoughts are things like that’s red, that’s yellow, that’s pink, that’s green, that’s a man, that’s a table and so forth. Therefore those mental factors that perceive things or differentiate between things. We then take them as an objective meditation focus on those and focus on the impermanence, the suffering, the emptiness of these objects, the compounded nature, the contaminated nature, the the selflessness and so forth. The disintegration and so and so forth. Okay.
So this way that we’ve just been explaining the way the Geshe has been explaining the method of meditation is what’s called the common method of meditation. And what that means is that it’s a method of meditation that’s common to both Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna paths. So this means that hearers and solitary realizers as well as bodhisattvas all focus on these objects of meditation. Right now, from amongst these, first of all talk about the focus for meditations, and the way that this is differentiated from the common focus for meditation is that hearers and solitary realizers focus on their own bodies, and bodhisattvas focus on the bodies of themselves and others. Yeah.
Oh, yeah. Hug this one. This one? This one. Oh, yeah.
Okay. So the next thing, the attention. What do they pay attention to? Well, here is in solitary realizers meditate. What are we up to?
Attention. hearers and solitary realizers pay attention to impermanence etc. Bodhisattvas meditate on non observation regarding the characteristics of dharmas. Now what this means is that they focus on the emptiness of these characteristics. So they don’t meditate on the characteristics themselves they meditate on the emptiness of those characteristics.
So therefore we have they meditate on the emptiness of the impermanence of the body or they meditate on the emptiness of the suffering of the feelings or they meditate on the emptiness of the emptiness and the emptiness of the selflessness of the mind and so forth? Well, non observation is not focusing on objects, focusing on So they’re saying that the reason it says that’s not going to help you. The reason that it says non observation is because they recognize the lack of inherent existence of things. So the things that they’re object they’re focusing on are not observed as being inherently existent. Okay.
So then also the obtain obtainment, what they obtain is said to be different also. Hearers in solitary realise meditate for the purpose of freedom from the contaminated body etc. But bodhisattvas meditate to establish a parinirvana which is Buddhahood. And they don’t have this idea of getting free from something and not being free from something else. They develop the focus of attaining Buddhahood instead of trying to get free from something.
Good. So, yeah, we finished. Suffering. So doesn’t know. Not happiness.
The experience Okay. The the experience of not of something no. The experience of something considered not good. Or the yeah. Or it could be the lack of experiencing good.
The body. So, where it says contaminated entities are associated with suffering or they are suffering, they are by their nature suffering, yeah? So the reason that what it means by contaminated entities is anything that comes into being on the basis of karma and delusion. So as the body comes into being on the basis of karma and delusion, that means that the body is pervaded by suffering. No.
It’s Okay. So the way that it should be read then is dharmas, right? What dharma refers to is all dhammas, yeah? And these are, like with a colon, right? Mental factors other than feeling comma, non concordant composites and non compounds.
Okay. So the the first one, the one you’ve got non-concordant composites that’s usually translated non associated composite phenomena, compositional factors or compound yeah. And non associated compositional factors. And this includes things like humans, beings, and time. I was about to say, beings and time.
And the other one that says non compounds is a a synonym of permanence. So okay. So the the non associated composite non associated compounded phenomena or I don’t know what the other one you got, the other translation was. Non associated compounded. Yeah.
So this means things like there’s two different types of those. There’s those which have life and those which don’t have life that are within that group. So things that do have life are for example humans and other beings and sentient beings and Buddhas. The things that don’t have life are for example tables and any other compounded things that have characteristics and so forth. So I reckon if you said Dharma is all dharmas and then put a semicolon and crossed out the which.
Which are, sorry. And you just had mental factors other than feeling, comma, non-concordant composites and non compounds. Yes. So it means not only just the concept of time, but also today, yesterday, tomorrow, a month, a year, a week, these things. So if you focus on the emptiness of those things, then that is a Mahāyāna perspective on this meditation.
If you focus on their impermanence and their being in the nature of suffering and their selflessness, then it’s a common perspective to focus on it with. Yes, sir? Okay. Okay. So when we’re focusing on these things in succession, then you focus on the fact that, okay, the body.
What is the body? The body is the collection of phenomena that are labeled body. Yeah? And that collection of phenomena, this labeled body, comes about because of suffering and sorry, comes about because of karma and delusions. Anything that comes about because of karma and delusions has these specific characteristics.
It is impermanent. It is by nature suffering. It is selfless. It is empty. These characteristics come with it.
So it’s an instance of the truth of suffering in the body because it comes about by karma and delusion. So Geshe-la held up that little jar there and he said, This is the truth of suffering. This is by nature’s suffering. It has no life there. There’s no feeling there, but it’s by nature’s suffering.
The little jar. Okay. So this little jar, I’m not even sure what it is, right? This little jar is there because of the collection of karma, the collection of impure karma, the collection of karma that is a cause for rebirth in saṃsāra. And any cause for rebirth in saṃsāra is contaminated.
So therefore, because it’s contaminated in its essence, it means that it is the truth of suffering. So by the base of that object, Geshe-la can then experience either happiness or sorrow. He said, especially if I drink tea, for example, the tea is in the nature. So the tea then is the same thing. He has the tea because the tea has come about by contaminated karma, right, and contaminated emotions or neurotic emotions and so therefore on the basis of that happiness which he said he did when he drank it or he can experience suffering when it runs out.
Therefore a, it in itself is an instance of the truth of suffering. Contaminated phenomena. It’s not the feeling of suffering, it’s the truth of suffering. It’s not the it’s like the definition of feeling was experienced. It’s not.
So so for example, this little jar or the tea isn’t the experience of suffering, isn’t the feeling of suffering, but it’s an instance of the truth of suffering. So, because it doesn’t have consciousness, it can’t be experience of suffering. So the reason that it’s said to be an instance of the truth of suffering is that it doesn’t no, the fact that it’s said to be an instance of the truth of suffering doesn’t mean that it has the three types of suffering. It doesn’t mean that it is the suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and all pervasive suffering. Because in order to experience the suffering of suffering and the suffering of change and also pervasive suffering then you need to have consciousness.
Then you need to have had that experience of saṃsāra since beginningless time. Objects without consciousness don’t have those. But on the basis of this object, these three different types of suffering can come about. Therefore it’s said to be by its nature suffering and it’s said to be an instance of the truth of suffering.
Key terms in this teaching
- Collected Topics dura (Tib)
- A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
- compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
- Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- parinirvana
- The final nirvana the Buddha attained when he passed away in Kushinagar, India. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- three types of suffering dug ngäl sum (Tib)
- The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and pervasive compounding suffering. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.