Mind Training

1 h 57 min · 8,146 words · 15 October 2009 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Mind Training (Khensur Rinpoche)
Mind Training (Khensur Rinpoche)
Mind Training
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Ilia S. Durovic delivers a 117-minute teaching on three interconnected Buddhist texts: the Diamond Sūtra, the Seven Point Mind Training attributed to Chekawa Yeshe Dorje, and the Three Principal Paths. Speaking primarily to a Taiwanese and mainland Chinese audience, he opens by establishing the comparative philosophical landscape, explaining how different world religions answer three fundamental questions about the self—its nature, its beginning, and its end. Durovic clarifies Buddhism’s distinctive position: that a permanent, unitary, independent self does not exist, yet the mind has no beginning and no end. He then traces the function of emptiness wisdom (Prajñāpāramitā) through the three progressive stages of learning, reflection, and meditation, showing how direct insight into ultimate reality arises only when combined with bodhicitta, the altruistic wish for enlightenment. Throughout, he emphasizes the gradual cultivation of wisdom as the path, encouraging practitioners to traverse the five Buddhist paths—accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation, and no more learning—without discouragement or arrogance. The talk is pitched at practitioners with both cultural familiarity and serious philosophical interest in emptiness doctrine.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Diamond Sūtra, Seven Point , and the Three Principal Paths; 15 October 2009 (… (2).mp3

UUID: ea5a4449-ef00-439b-bbdf-e33b7fd4d299

Teacher: Ilia S. Durovic

Collection: Mind Training

Date: 2009 (exact day not recorded)

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~8,149

So here, it is the the main audience is the Taiwanese from Taiwan. And, also, there are many others, coming here to receive the teaching, including those from Mainland China. First of all, may I express my wishes and greetings to all of you attending this teaching. And the Chinese friends, we have we met for the last few years for this for such kind of gathering for teachings. And you are coming here again with enormous effort.

And despite all the difficulties, I’d like to express my thanks to you as well. The discourses that we’re going to do today consists of the first Vajracchedika Sūtra or Diamond Cutter Sūtra. And the second one is Seven Point mind training, which is composed by Chekawa Yeshe Dorje and who is the lineage holder of Kadampa of the Kadampa master, Atisha. In Tibet, the the two systems, the new and the old, the transmission or the system of Kadampa flourished, and this belongs to the old version. And, the new Kadampa system, according to that, we have the teaching of the three principal paths.

So these are the three texts that I’m going to, teach this time. And, the the Seven Point mind training and the three principal paths, so these two, not only the auto transmission, I also have the explain the explanation the transmission of the explanation of the text is also with me. And the Seven Point mind training, I received the oral transmission plus the explanation transmission from also from And then with regard to the three principal paths, I received the teaching from Tagdrag Rinpoche plus Ngawang Losang and Trijang Rinpoche. And then as for the Vajrachchhedika Sūtra, which is the essence of the of the all Prajñāpāramitā sutras, There is no the transmission the teaching transmission of this text on the explanation level. So I it it just has the oral transmission oral transmission of the teaching, which I received from.

Okay. As preliminary part of the teaching, first, we’re going to recite Heart Sūtra in Chinese followed by the four stanzas. English. I prostrate to the glorious triple gem. Thus, did I hear at one time that Bhagavan was dwelling on Vultures Mountain in Rajagriha, together with a great community of monks and a great community of Bodhisattvas.

At that time, the Bhagavan was absorbed in the concentration of other categories of phenomena called profound perception. Also at that time, the Buddha, Buddha, the the Venerable Śāriputra said this to the Buddha, how should any child of the lineage train who wishes to practice the activity of the profound Prajñāpāramitā wisdom? He said that Any son of the lineage or any daughter of the lineage who wishes to practice the activity of the profound Prajñāpāramitā wisdom should look upon it like this correctly and repeatedly beholding those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Form is emptiness emptiness is formed. Emptiness not other than formed.

Form is not other than emptiness. In the same way, feeling discrimination, compositional factors, and consciousness are empty. Śāriputra, likewise all phenomena are empty without characteristic, unproduced, unceased, stainless, not without stain, no deficient, not fulfilled. Śāriputra, therefore in emptiness, there is no form, no feeling, no discrimination, no compositional factors, There is no eye element and so on up to and including no mind element and no mental consciousness element. There is no ignorance, no extinction of ignorance and so on up to and including no aging and death and no extinction of aging and death.

Similarly, there is no suffering. origination, cessation, path, there is, there is no exalted wisdom, no attainment, and also no non-attainment. Śāriputra, therefore, because there is no attainment, Bodhisattvas rely on and dwell on the Prajñāpāramitā wisdom. The mind without obscuration and without fear have completely passed beyond sorrow. There is the endpoint of Nirvāṇa.

All the Buddhas who dwell in the three times also manifestly can be awakened to unsurpassable, perfect, complete enlightenment in reliance on the Prajñāpāramitā wisdom. Therefore, the mantra of the Prajñāpāramitā wisdom, the mantra of great knowledge, the unsurpassed mantra, a mantra equal to the unequalled, the mantra that thoroughly pacifies all suffering should be known as truth since it is not false. The mantra of the Prajñāpāramitā wisdom is declared thus. One should train in the profound Prajñāpāramitā wisdom like that. Then the arose from this concentration and confirmed the saying, said, well said, son of the lineage, it is like that.

It is like that. Once you practice the profound Prajñāpāramitā wisdom, just as you have indicated, even the the tathagatas rejoice. The Bhagavan having said this, the the Buddha, surrounding in their entirety, All over the world of gods, humans, asuras and Gandharvas were all delighted by what was spoken by the Bhagavan. May the three poisonous afflictions be eliminated and may be able to engage in the bodhisattva’s deeds through the blazing of the wisdom that is the ultimate reality. And may all aspirations which come in the way to achieving enlightenment be eliminated.

On this, there are 6,000,000,000 human beings, and we can broadly divide or group this 6,000,000,000 human beings into three groups. One, those having beliefs or believers, and the second second, who is totally against or anti anti religion. And third, those who are neutral, not strongly anti nor believing in any religion as such. So there are three groups. And, however, all these three share one thing in common.

That is they all wish for happiness and not wanting suffering. And now and they also share one thing in common. That is they all seek they all resort to some means to achieve happiness, and to eliminate suffering. So now what is the difference among these three? So primarily, with the believers, they seek to achieve this happiness and avoid suffering on the basis of mental thinking.

They try to pacify one’s mind, calm the calm one’s mind in order to seek happiness and eliminate suffering. And whereas the other two, they are primarily the materialist. They’re materialistic or they seek to achieve happiness, which is on the physical level or sensorial happiness, like trying to avoid, physical pains or illnesses, hunger, thirst, and so forth. And they think that

They simply seek to achieve happiness on the level of the food, on the level of clothing and the fame and which they they think can be achieved through money, and this is the the result. This is the way they resort to to achieve happiness, to eliminate suffering. So this is the difference between these two, the one c one believers and other the nonbelievers, out of which there are further two groups. So this world, the contemporary world, has, marks, incredible material development, but still it is not it is not sufficient to to bring about a genuine happiness in humanity. So still we see obvious mental, suffering and mental suffering and pain.

So now there is a new development happening. Whether or not one believes in a religion or not, still, that new development is to seek a genuine mental happiness and mental peace. The meaning of the tea offering, the the the verse that the Chinese used is the one make offering to his son is the the Dalai Lama. He’s only saying make sure that you also take your bread with the tea. So, among these three groups, when we try to compare those believers with those who are anti religion or anti religion anti anti religion, we see that in terms of their mental happiness, we see that those people who are truly against religion, they tend to have less respect toward the values such as truth, honesty, and so forth.

And then whether or not the those believers, whether they truly put into practice these values such as truth and honest and so forth, but still, they mentally, they have greater respect towards these values. So overall speaking, we see that those people who are nonbelievers, they tend to have a greater sense of the negative emotions like attachment, aversion, and so forth because of the less amount of respect towards honesty and so forth. And whereas those who are the believers, they are in a better position to maintain equilibrium state of the mind. However, while being a believer, it is not as it is not a good thing to believe in religion simply on a basis of, basis of, the religion being once, the kind of, tradition on the basis of being, the tradition kind of pattern. Instead, it must be accepted or be more serious about it by by reflecting on the merits of accepting, the religious faiths and the demerits of demerits of not accepting their religious beliefs.

So on the basis of that, you must be you must have a more serious amount of faith and regard to the religious traditions that you feel attached you feel connected to. And among the different religious groups, we see that there are some without any, any philosophy as such, like simply propitiating, some spirits or low local spirits and so forth. And whereas in India, about since about three thousand years ago, the religions evolved with philosophy. The earliest ones, according to the text that we study, the earliest ones consist of the Samkhyas who happen to be, who happen to be about 3,000. And then in two thousand six hundred years ago, Buddhism came into being, and contemporary contemporary to Buddhism is Jainism.

And then the earliest would be like Judaism. Judaism is also quite early, then followed by Christianity and Islam. And the Parsi, the religion which they follow. So Zoroastrianism, which first evolved in Iran and later on has some root in Bombay. So this is quite an early, religious group.

And then later in in India, there is Sikhism. So all these religious beliefs, which I cited now, they are with philosophy. Now to sum up as to how to group these different religious faiths, we can speak that in terms of, two groups, theistic religions and nontheistic religions. And under nontheistic religions, we have Buddhism, Jainism, and a part of some some Sankhya. And then from among the nontheistic, we see that one who believes in a concept of soul, concept of ātman, which where a self is posited to be separate from the body and the mind or the aggregates.

And, one who doesn’t believe in such concept of self and atma. So this is one way of classifying all religious faiths. And another way of doing it is by classifying the entire or different religious systems of the world into two. One who believes in this concept of soul or atma characterized as self, characterized as distinct, as separate from the body and the mind versus, religion, which does not accept in the concept of atma and soul, which is Buddhism. Those of you here, as of of to many of you, it may be this what I’m gonna say may be a little bit a repetition.

But since that there are many newcomers, it’ll be alright. It’ll be fine to mention the same thing. So, basically, there are three questions coming up. The first one, what is self, or what is the nature of self? And the second one is, is there beginning to the self?

And third one, is there an end to the self? All different religious beliefs, they try to answer try to give answers to these three questions. And Buddhism, when it comes to the first question, which says, what is the self? Then it is only Buddhism who says that there is no such a self. And all other religious beliefs say yes to this question.

Such self, the such a self exist. Another question is, what does it mean by the self, the base of the discussion, the self, which Buddhism says it does not exist and others are proposing it existent. But but what does it really mean by that self? So it doesn’t mean, the self in, in terms of conventionality. It is not in terms of the conventional self.

No one there’s no one there’s no religious belief who deny the existence the self. But they this self, which the Buddhism, denies and others accept is something characterized by three characteristics. A self, which is, permanent, unitary, and independent, and, those who believe in existence of such a self, self characterized by these three characteristics

Yes. They think that, the reason why they are led to accept such a self with three characteristics is that they see the body and the mind as the object of, the objects of possession, objects of objects of utility, and it was the self as the appropriator or the the one who utilizes the body and the mind at the op as the objects. And then these the the the second group, they find it difficult to posit a self, which is That’s honestly what you mean. On the basis of the body and mind. So therefore, they come to believe in a self which is distant from the body and the mind.

So it is only Buddhism who says that there’s no such self which is which is characterized by the three characteristics. Although the self does have a control over the mind. So now to the second question, whether or not the self has a beginning. All the theistic religions, they believe that the self has a beginning, and the time of the beginning of the self is the the time when the creator god first created the self or the person. For example, according to Christianity, even this very life that we have is also created by god, and perhaps it is created at the time of first conception in the mother’s womb.

And this is the beginning to the self according to Christianity. So, likewise, there are other Hindu traditions like those believing in Brahma saying that the Brahma, the great Brahma or the Maha Brahma, Brahma is the one who created the cells, who created the who created other cells. And they accept the creation, the creator, the Brahma is the creator, and also they accept the functionality, the karma operating and also accepting, the reincarnation from the later lives. So according to this system, it is the time when the great Brahma, first created the the persons or the beings that the self first started to exist. And then according to Sankhya tradition, there is what is known as the 25 objects of knowledge, and of which the one is the primal substance, the creator, which is believed to be permanent, and the second one is the self.

And these two are taken as the ultimate reality. So from the point of view of all these different religious systems who belong to the theistic theistic group, they believe in the begin the existence of a beginning to the self. And whereas when this question is asked to Buddhism, since they are the self, there’s no distinct self as such. A self is different from the body and the mind. Self is simply taken as a construct, mental construct on the basis of the body and the mind.

So to deal with this question whether or not this this self, which is designated on the basis of the body and mind, has a beginning, we have to solve the problem whether the body and the mind which form the constituents of the self has big have begin in mind. And then as as for the first, we explore into the body, whether it is the beginning in the mind. Since that the self is designated on the base of the body and the mind, we need to explore whether the body has a beginning or not and the mind has a beginning or not. And as for the body, we can think of that in turn on two levels. One, in terms of, say, oh, the human body.

Of course, the human body, we obviously see that it is the beginning. However, when we try to explore its, the the subtle constituents such as the particles, minute particles like, atoms and so forth, on that level, we it is difficult to posit a beginning because the particles which constitute our body, the atoms and so forth, they existed since the the conception, since the and the evolving of the universe. And the universe, it is believed to be evolving, abiding, and then degenerating, and then the the state of vacuity. In fact, in Kālacakra system, there is what is known as the space particle. So those particles which constitute our body, they’re originally originally, they come from the the particles that existed at at the time of the world the world system evolving.

And then that particle that existed at the time of the evolving of the the world system, that also came from the the space particle, what is known as the space particle, which existed at the time of the of the of the universe. So we see that. And then from this evacuated state, because due to cause and conditions, then the the world system, the various world systems, they they come into being. They come into being, they abide, and they, again, they decay. So in all sorts of sutras and tantras, there’s mention as to how the whole system is they first assume the state of vacuity and then forming or coming to or coming together of these particles to form the different world systems, then abiding of world systems, and then again, destroying or getting getting having the worlds destroyed or degenerated.

So on the on the level of the subtle particles, we see that there’s no beginning to the body of of of ours. And now exploring into the mind whether it has a beginning or not, since that of the body in the mind, the mind is the primary factor on which the self is designated. So we need to say that whether the self is beginning or not. We need to explore primarily whether the mind has a beginning or not. And then just as the physical body on the subtle particle, on the level of subtle particle, it is not beginning, the mind as well, has no beginning and, has no beginning because all functional things, they should necessarily come into being by dependence on their causes, which in turn is of two kinds, substantial cause and the cooperative cause.

Substantial cause referring to the cause which which is responsible for giving rise to the the main substance, the material, the the matter part or the material aspect of the object, and the cooperative cause is referring to those which aid to the transformation of that very substance into a new result result. So in terms of our mind, the the substance of the mind is the clear and the knowing aspect of the mind. So if you believe in the beginning of this mind or the beginning to this the clear and knowing aspect of the mind, then we should either accept that this clear and knowing aspect of the mind coming to being randomly without dependence on any particular cause, or you have accept that it exists, eternally or permanently. So then if the the mind were to clear the knowing aspect of the mind, if it does come into being randomly without any dependence on causes, then if that once happened at the time of the beginning, why should it not happening now? So we see that it is not happening now and which entails that any functioning thing, including the mind, which is clear knowing aspect, it also should have a substantial cause, which can be traced to beginninglessly.

And again, as mentioned earlier, the mind for it to come into being, it should have two causes, substantial and the cooperative cause. In terms of the substantial cause, there is no beginning to it. Since that the mind, which is the primary the prime basis of designation primary basis of designation has no beginning, the self, which is designated on the basis of this mind as well should as well should have no beginning. So as a response to this question, whether the self has the beginning from Buddhist from the point of view of Buddhism, there’s no beginning to the self since the mind, which is a primary basis of designation for the self, has no beginning. Hi.

In Buddhism, there is explanation of the external world, which is inanimate in nature. In Tantra, there’s the mention of how the world the world system how the world systems are formed and how they, come into destruction. And in terms of evolution of the world system, the five elements are mentioned, to take part in it. The, space element of space, air, air or wind, fire, water, and earth. And the space here may not necessarily be referring to the just a mere empty space.

It could be referring to the space particles space particles. So then we need to think of when the world is evolved, it evolves from these subtle elements and then becoming successively becoming grosser starting from the element of space, which constitutes the space particles, then becoming the element of air, element of fire, element of water, and element of earth. And then when in, when the the at the stage of degeneration or when the world gets destroyed, so that it then the elements, they turn to, destroy in the reverse order, from the grossest, the earth, the element of the earth getting destroyed into the element of the water, then to the element of the fire, element of air, element of the space. And here, we are not a thing of the space in terms of just the empty part of the space. It is the space particles.

Otherwise, how can we conceive of the idea the particle of the, particle of, the air are coming coming about or arising from this mere empty space. So it must be thought of in terms of the space particles space particles existing. And then because of the very forceful, interactions of these space particles, the particle the the element of the air comes into being. And then, again, because of the, because of the interaction of these air elements, then the the grosser one, which is the heat, is formed, and then the water element, the earth element. Water water element having the ability to to adhere to another object and the earth element.

And because of, again, the interaction among these water element, it comes a more solid version of it, which later becomes the earth element. So in terms of the so we can we need to think of this evolution in the the proper way of evolution and the reverse way of evolution. Proper way of evolution when the world systems are formed and the reverse way of evolution when the worlds come to an end. So now we move on to think about how the solid objects or the body associated with the mind, which is sentient, comes into being. So so there, when it comes to a sentient object associated with the, with the mind, another additional element is there, the element of the consciousness.

So in Highest Yoga Tantra, there’s the mention of the very subtle state of the consciousness. In terms of the evolution and in terms of the, coming to an end, the dissolution of the elements and the coming to being of the the elements, it is much more the same except that there is the additional element of consciousness taking part in it. And, the the subtleness of the consciousness or the mind, it is also referred to as the internal space, not externally, referred to as the internal space. So this experience of the subtlest consciousness there, you don’t have the you don’t have the experience of that consciousness, subtle consciousness with the with something as an object and you as the the the subject. So this concept of the subject and object totally dissolves there.

You have the experience as though, like, it is just total vacuity or emptiness. It is not the real emptiness, but the sense of vacuity, sense of, space like. So therefore, it is referred to as the internal space. And then within that, again, we see the first level of the empty, third empty, and fourth empty and so forth. And then, again, with the the beings, what happens is that in terms of the being coming to the it’s a person coming to being evolving.

First, there’s the experience of the subtlest experience of this mind referred to as the fourth empty state and then becoming grosser to the third, to the second, to the first. And then from this first empty experience of the mind, then the grosser levels of the mind come into being, which are known as the eighty indicative thoughts, eighty indicative minds. And then from there, the the karmic force karmic force come into play. And then the four elements come into being, the element of the air, fire, water, and earth. And then dissolution, the order will be reversed form.

And then what is set by contemporary modern cosmologists, it very much accords with what is explained earlier. Now as for the third question, whether or not the self has an end, according to theistic religions like Christianity, there’s a mention of the final judgment after the death. And then during the final judgment, it is decided whether you are going to go to heaven, have communion with god, and then live happily there, or you go to hell. So if you if you belong to second category, gonna go to hell, better it is that you annihilate rather than they’re going there and to be there in hell all the way all the way through. So whereas from, from Buddhist point of view, as a response to this question, third question, whether or not the self has an end, there’s quite a, extensive discussion.

According to the of the four different schools of Buddhism, the first one, which is, Vaibhāṣika, so there’s a part of Vaibhāṣika school who believe in the annihilation of a mind happening, annihilation of the continuation of the mind happening at the time of one achieving what is known as the parinirvāṇa. Whereas all other Buddhist systems all other Buddhist systems, they believe that this mind has no end. So, actually, the translator, the Chinese translator, is trying to translate a very small bit, which is, some internal matter, and he’s one of us to ask him to stop, and no need to mention, translate that. Okay. Then, from the point of view of the other schools other than that small section of the Vaibhāṣika, all Buddhist systems believe in the continuation of mind going all the way down without any end because the mind is characterized as a mere luminosity or clarity and knowing.

And for the discontinuation of this mind, there’s no forceful no forceful power to stop the continuation of the clarity and the knowingness of of the mind. If when there’s a continuation happening and if there is no powerful powerful force to discontinue, to stop the flow of the continuation of that mind. Why why should that mind come to an end? Why should the continuum of the mind come to an end? So, of course, there are specific, kinds of mind like the ignorance and distorted, distorted levels of mind.

So which have very powerful remedy and because of which we can bring an end give an end to this, specific mind such as ignorance, distorted, mental system, so forth. So here, we need to make distinction between the mind, the basic mind, and the mental stains, such as ignorance and so forth. As for the mental stains, since they have various powerful remedies, they can be brought to an end. Whereas in terms of the mind is the base of these stains, so since the mind is of the nature of the clarity and knowing, it has no force for or powerful powerful counter force because of which there is no reason as to why the mind should have the continuation of mind should have an end should have an end. And there’s one system of non-Buddhist tradition by the name or, you know, which believes that the mind and the the stains of the mind are the intrinsic nature of the mind.

When the when the stains are destroyed, the mind also destroys get gets destroyed. So saying that the continuation of mind has an end, whereas Buddhism, it follows a different approach or explanation saying that while the mind while these the mental stains are the characteristics of the mind, but they are not the intrinsic nature of the mind. As such, while the afflictions, while the ignorance and so forth, which are the mental stains, they have remedies, powerful remedies, and they are brought to an end. The mind as mind in itself has no powerful remedy. As such, the continuation of mind will continue endlessly.

So since the mind has no end, the person or the self designated on the basis of this mind as well should have no end. This is the Buddhist explanation of the response to the third question whether or not the self has has an end. And then, on top of that, in Buddhism, there is what is known as the Tathāgatagarbha or the Buddha nature, which is believed to be existent in all sentient beings. And then because of this potential known as Buddha nature, all sentient beings will, at one point, achieve enlightenment. So once you become enlightened or once you become buddha, then you’ll remain eternally as buddha.

So therefore, there is no end to the self because each of the sentient beings are bound to become, buddha at one point and then we’ll continue in that state eternally without end. Now put on the We know that there are all there are many different religious beliefs on this earth. And and among the humanity, we see

They’re all diverse mental temperaments, mental interests, and so forth. So these different religious beliefs, they truly benefit these, the humanity on this earth, which have diverse interests and temperaments and so forth. So even speaking from Buddhist point of view, the Buddha Śākyamūni, the same teacher, he taught all different kinds of views, diverse views in order to suit the mentality of the people with different dispositions, temperaments, and so forth. So if this is a case happening with this with the single same teacher given all different diverse teachings, then why not the different teachers giving teachings on in different ways to suit the mentalities of so many people or human beings on this earth? So from this this respect, we see that all the different, other traditions, they also have they also are of great benefits to the the so many, human beings.

So therefore, we need to, have respect to all the different religious beliefs, which is really very important. But in terms of faith, it is good to, have faith in one’s own personal, religion. So when it comes to, the different religions, it is best to maintain one’s own traditional religion. If you are Christians or Muslims, it is better to stick to one’s own, traditional religions such as Christianity or Islam. Likewise, those who are Buddhist, you stick, better to stick to one’s traditional religion.

And so the teaching that we’re gonna give here is on Buddhism, and Buddhism is basically of two kinds, the one that flourished in Pāli language and the other in Sanskrit language. And the one in Sanskrit language first flourished in China abroad, India. So and then later, it flourished in Tibet. So from that point of view, you are the Chinese audience. You are the Chinese Buddhist.

You are a senior as compared to the Tibetan Buddhist. So we are the junior. And from the point of view of being you as the senior, I always, during my giving discourses to the Chinese audience, I, first of all, make it a point to, bow down or show respect to the Chinese Buddhists for they being the senior students of the Buddha Śākyamūni. So today also, I’m I’m showing my respect and bowing to you for being the senior Buddhist or the students of Buddha Śākyamūni as compared to the Tibetan Buddhists. But at the same time, I say that, in terms of the knowledge in Buddhist philosophy, the junior students are not too bad.

The reason why I say this is that in Tibet, the sole figure who proliferated, who flourished Buddhism in Tibet is the great Shāntarakshita and who happened to be a a great scholar, senior scholar in Nālānda University. And his his specialty is in the Madhyamaka view, the philosophy philosopher middle way and Buddhist logic. So he is referred to as the one who stands so elegantly without elegantly, fearlessly with equipped with these two knowledges, the knowledge in the Buddhist philosophy philosophy of middle way view and the Buddhist logic. So he has a tremendous confidence in this. So it is very important to study the Buddhist philosophy of emptiness or the middle way view complemented or combined with the study of Buddhist logic.

And Shāntarakshita, along with his student Kamalaśīla, both are so well known in the study of the middle way view and the the Buddhist logic. So the kind of Buddhism that’s in Tibet by these two masters are on the basis or grounded on the Buddhist philosophy of, middle way view and the Buddhist logic. So they this has brought a tremendous benefit in the upholding of Buddhism in Tibet. Korean number, Japanese number, Vietnamese number, Oh, the Chinese, Buddhist, Koreans, the Korean Buddhist, Japanese Buddhists, Laotians, Tibetans, Mongolians, and the the this the Russian Mongolians, they are all they all belong to the upholders of Buddhism that flourish in Sanskrit and to base who consider the Prajñāpāramitā sūtra as the theme, as the essence of Buddhism. So here in the Heart Sūtra, when it says that all Buddhas, the Buddhas of three times, only through dependence on the Prajñāpāramitā wisdom teachings, it is through that that they achieved enlightenment.

And so here, when you speak about the Prajñāpāramitā or the perfection of wisdom, so what is this wisdom aspect? The wisdom connotes a mental state which discerns the the reality, which dis which understands the reality. So to understand this, we need to know what the reality is. And the reality consists of two parts, one which is just on the the appearance level and the other, the reality on the on the the on the subtler on the subtler sense of the reality. And although although the beings that they they wish to have happiness and they don’t suffering, but it is because of it is because of the inability to to see what causes suffering and what causes happiness.

And so from there, we see that there’s the the inability inability to understand the reality. There’s the ignorance which drives the beings to accumulate karmas or the accumulate actions to give rise to suffering. So there’s the ignorance and giving rise to that. So this ignorance which misconceives the reality, again, it it it is of two kinds. One, which misconceives the reality on the appearance level, and the other which misconceives the reality on the subtler sense.

So therefore, the Buddha taught ignorance, which is of two kinds, the ignorance which misconceives the ultimate reality and the ignorance which misconceives the law the law of causality, the karmic law of causality. So this subtle level of the ignorance, which misconceives the ultimate reality, so this ignorance gives rise to the gross ignorance, which misconceives the the law of causative relationship. So from this, we see that, there are two levels of reality, one which is on the surface and one on the surface or the appearance level, other on the subtler level. So it is here it is here through this misconception or the ignorance which gives rise to suffering. So if you don’t want suffering, we need to eliminate the ignorance.

And how do we go about doing this? How do we go about eliminating the ignorance? It is through resorting to some means to introduce a wisdom, introduce the intelligence which which can override the ignorance, which can overcome the overshadow the ignorance. So it is only through introducing this wisdom or the intelligence which understands the reality through which we eliminate the ignorance that we can eliminate suffering. So and this wisdom, which is to which needs to be introduced, is not something a mere understanding.

Rather, it must be a very active state of intelligence which analyzes the reality. And, again, when we speak about back to the Heart Sūtra when it says that all the the Buddhas, they resort to the perfection of wisdom. So when you speak about the perfection, so this perfection can be thought of, again, on two levels. One in relation to to the result, which is the enlightened Buddhahood, state of the Buddhahood. The other in relation to the in relation to the agent giving rise to this full enlightenment.

So when we speak of this perfection of wisdom or the perfection of Paramita in relation to the resultant state, so it can be related only to Buddhahood. Whereas in terms of the the agent begin giving rise to this enlightenment, we can thought of that even in terms of the, the, the learning stages of the path. So, the kind of the wisdom which is required here, in order to have the perfection wisdom, it is not sufficient to have the understanding or the wisdom which realizes the the surface reality or the appearance reality. Rather, it must understand the ultimate reality, the subtlest on the level of the ultimate reality. And that understanding of the wisdom, that wisdom that you generate as well should not be on the conceptual level.

It must be direct and nonconceptual experience, non dualistic experience. And that and this wisdom, which understands the ultimate reality non dualistically, so this is nothing something special of the bodhisattvas or the Mahāyāna practitioners. It is common to common to Shravakas and Pratyekabuddhas. So now what is what how would you characterize this wisdom as so distinctive in relation to the Mahāyāna path and make it the Prajñāpāramitā wisdom, not just the wisdom, but the Prajñāpāramitā wisdom is only when that is complemented by bodhicitta, the altruistic wish to become enlightened or buddhahood for this achieve buddhahood for the sake of all sentient beings. So only when this wisdom, direct realization of emptiness, ultimate reality complimented complimented by this bodhicitta, then it becomes the ultimate Prajñāpāramitā.

No. No. They should’ve reliance on sensations of the wisdom of wisdom, professional wisdom that

So now this perfection of wisdom, in order to have this, we need to we need to achieve that perfection of wisdom in a gradual stepwise way. So they for that, there’s mention of three kinds of wisdoms. The the wisdom of learning, the wisdom of reflection, and the wisdom of meditation. Say the the first wisdom, the wisdom of learning. So here, the the the disciple or you as the practitioner, you start receiving teachings on this ultimate reality, emptiness, which is discerned by the professional wisdom.

So this emptiness, you start receiving teachings from a teacher, then you read more of, do extensive reading of the materials on this topic, and then you gain some kind of understanding, about emptiness or ultimate reality. So this is what is known as the wisdom derived through learning. And then whatever you have learned, you try to reflect on it. You try to understand as to what truly it means, what truly the emptiness means. And then at one point, you gain a deep sense of discernment.

I see. This is it. This is what is known as emptiness. There’s a true understanding dawning in you. So at that point, it is the second wisdom, the wisdom derived through reflection.

So this is, also known as the, the, cognition or the inferential cognition. When it first dawns in you, this is wisdom of reflection. And at that point, you are able to discern what the ultimate reality is so well by oneself. And then, however, the one demerit or one drop here is that this understanding comes to you only through effort. And without effort, if you don’t put effort, then you will think about it.

It doesn’t come to you. So it it needs to be spontaneous. To upgrade to this level of the spontaneity, it you must upgrade to the level of the third wisdom, the wisdom drawn through meditation. So here, whatever kind of understanding or discernment that you have of the emptiness, ultimate reality, you try to do it over and over again, familiarize with this understanding, meditate on this topic as much as possible. And then at one point, it becomes so spontaneous in you.

The moment you think about the ultimate reality, it simply clicks. It simply comes to mind so spontaneously. Of course, such understanding is complemented or helped through the power of meditative concentration. So this is how we cultivate the three levels of the wisdom in order to achieve the Prajñāpāramitā wisdom, you know, to get to enlightenment. So say, in our case here, you are studying this teaching, the Vajrachchhedika Sūtra on emptiness, ultimate reality.

So what you understand is that you gain from listening to my teaching, so this wisdom of wisdom of learning. And then and then you reflect, then you meditate. So this is sequence. So therefore, in, there’s a mention in the mantra at the end, which means gate gate paragate parasamgate bodhi svaha, go, go, go beyond, go still beyond and establish into enlightenment. So this is what it is trying to imply is the need for us to traverse along the path in a very sequential and a graded graded way or graded state.

So it is only through gradual upgrading of one’s mind, that one’s mind becomes more and more noble, but that one’s mind becomes more and more realized in along the path. So this is indication. So it has a deeper implication when it says, pointing to the the five gradual paths to achieve full enlightenment. So when you feel when you feel despondent, there is when despondency creeps in your mind, you think about this, go go go beyond, go still beyond, and establishing enlightenment. So this is how all the Buddhas, they travel along the path in a very gradual state, gradual way.

So why should I feel despondent? So this being the the fact, this being the path that the Buddhas followed, I too can follow it. So this can eliminate your sense of despondency. And then at times, you might feel a little bit, arrogant having an empty pride. So, again, we if you think about these gradual steps to get to enlightenment, it can again help us eliminate the empty pride as well.

So it can help us eliminate the two extremes. And then this is how one gets to the Prajñāpāramitā in the form of the five the paths, the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation, and no more learning. And then of the first the path of seeing is the first Bodhisattva ground. And then you progress along the ten Bodhisattva grounds and Once I met a person who who narrated his who shared his dream with me and told me that, oh, I dreamt of such and such things. So maybe I have reached the first Bodhisattva ground, which is within the third Bodhisattva path, within which there are 10 Bodhisattva grounds.

And he’s and he said, oh, it seems like I achieved that level. And His Holiness could not really deny what he what he was trying to say. And then he’s said that, oh, in the supplement to the middle way by Acharya Candrakīrti, there’s a mention of all different all different qualities as, qualities associated with someone achieving the first Bodhisattva ground. It’s not just mere dreams. There are many other qualities such as the gaining the ability to shake the eight eight different sorry, 100 different worlds and so forth.

So so this is what I shared with I I told him, it is not just dreams that discern whether you have achieved the first bodies of the ground. There are many other indications which which need to be accompanying these signs to discern whether you have achieved first bodhisattva ground. And then so when you feel a sense of arrogance by having some good dreams, then it’ll be too good to reflect on this mantra. So which tells you that, oh, it is not something abruptly coming anew, randomly coming anew, these highly spiritual realizations. Rather, they should they should necessarily achieve these high spiritual realizations in a gradual gradual steps like the path of accumulation, path of preparation, path of seeing, path of meditation, path of no more learning and so forth.

So this is how we again, when you reflect on how one needs to be proceeding through the different paths in the form of what is said in this mantra, it will help us remove our empty pride or arrogance. And then on the other hand, you might think about the the Buddha, the qualities of the Buddha as something so distant. Yeah. Which is beyond our ability. But then again, we think about So much more is something which we can achieve.

So much effort purifying the negativities. So this is very good. Thinking about this Right. Part which needs proper sequence. When I speak about the the meaning of this mantra, I explain it on two in two ways.

One, which requires effort to pass through these different five stages, and the other, without effort. So the one without effort, I explained it as what occurs to us so naturally as a part of our life. Say say you are born on this earth and then you are a child or a teenage, and then you move to the adolescent state, then you move to the youth state, then you move to the oldest stage, and finally, the death. So the Buddhist. So our first one is the first one is teenage.

Next is youth. Sorry. Adolescence. And next, paragate is youth. And parasamgate is old age.

And finally, bodhi svaha is the death. So this is what happens to us. So we are falling through these five stages in a very natural part as a natural part of our life, which doesn’t require any effort. So this is what I explained, the mantra in the form of a joke. But the the one which needs to which needs which needs effort in order to go through these five stages is is in terms of one’s own mental qualities.

In terms of the mental qualities, as I mentioned earlier, we need to proceed through, cultivating the more and more powerful wisdom first through the wisdom derived through learning, the wisdom derived through reflection, and the wisdom derived through meditation. And then in terms of the experience, first, you try to gain some kind of vague idea of the concept of the ultimate reality or bodhicitta, whatever. And then you try to gain gain a confidence in this understanding. And then next comes the, the the confidence on the level of effort. And finally, through further familiarization, it becomes effortless or spontaneous confidence or understanding of the reality.

So this sound with only with effort, you can go along the five paths, with with effort and, through learning. The morning session, we we stop the morning session here and then afternoon session from one to three. And then after that, we do review if you’re interested. For the Chinese, you just arrange somehow to, do the review. And for the English, again, you can carry, carry the review the way you want, so that it will be helpful to you that you don’t forget what you have learned.

So for the English, maybe it is a good idea to do the review in the College Hall at 4:00 in the College Hall for the English for the English listeners for the review.

Key terms in this teaching

atman dag (Tib)
Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
oral transmission lung (Tib, Wyl)
The verbal transmission of a teaching, meditation practice or mantra from guru to disciple, the guru having received the transmission in an unbroken lineage from the original source. LYWA
parinirvana
The final nirvana the Buddha attained when he passed away in Kushinagar, India. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top