Mind Training — 2012-02-25

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Mind Training (Ilia Durovic)
Mind Training (Ilia Durovic)
Mind Training — 2012-02-25
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2012-02-25 – KR.mp3

UUID: 64b8f788-f706-4f97-870f-d69368e0d9f1

Teacher: Ilia Durovic

Collection: Mind Training

Date: 2012-02-25

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 29m

Words: 11,177

I should mention you all have a bibliography which gives some of the references of today’s talk. It’s a mixture of the easy to read and the scholarly. So I hope everyone will find something here which is of interest. So our presentation of materialism in its stark forms leads us to a situation where we can actually diagnose our present predicament, which is soft materialism. In other words, a consumer society.

And you can see, I mean, if we try to assess stark materialism, we have basically the shopping mall, the toys, the parties for the young, the ideal Australian family with three children, all of which emanate from money. So from the materialist standpoint, the goods of life, the sum total of everything which is a source of happiness is rooted in money and therefore money is the ultimate goal. Now if based upon our previous analysis of the developments of Calvinist doctrine which led to modernity, we try to identify what modernity is the nexus of. I think this is a fairly good representation of modernity. Modernity arises at the intersection of individualism, egalitarianism, relativism, privatization, and the technological consciousness.

These five factors probably define modernity to a greater or lesser degree in every single western society which calls itself modern. And it is this modern nexus within which the transmission of, in our case, the Buddhist tradition is occurring with all of the problems it implies. This is what we will talk about at the end of this hour. So if we look at world civilizations, we have a recent world value survey which plots on the one hand on the abscissa survival values versus self expression. In survival values when it’s just struggling to make ends meet.

In self expression values everything related to survival has been taken care of, one can try to express one’s individuality. And in the ordinate plots traditional values at the bottom versus secular rational values. We can see at the very bottom of the chart the Islamic and African world, traditional focused on survival. And what is very striking is that modernity as we understand it arises, the arrow is my own addition, arises within Protestant Europe. It is the conjunction of a maximum of self expression with a maximum of secular rationality.

The Asian world, which still is considered modern, focuses largely on secular rational values, but is in many cases less wealthy than Europe. And the English speaking world, as is well known, tends to be much more religious than much of Western Europe. And the question we have to ask having defined the materialist nexus, as we said, as the intersection of individualism, egalitarianism, relativism, privatization, and technological consciousness is very simple. Does materialism work? Because if it works, then we will have this one conference and then I will go on a vacation and you too.

But if it doesn’t work, then we have to understand why it doesn’t work. And when I was on vacation over Christmas in Chiang Mai, generally speaking as you know, graffiti is one of the lower forms of urban art. But I saw an instance of graffiti which I think is one of the most exceptional instances of urban art I ever saw. It’s an anonymous philosopher who painted this on a wall in Chiang Mai. It is a definition of materialism.

A child called wisdom shouting money. If we were to ask what the values of much of modernity are, I think they are summarized in this graffiti. And then if it is the case that money or as we like to put things more euphemistically, the human development index, prosperity, the living standard are the cause for happiness. And this is something which we should be quite, we should find quite easy to establish. It is however surprisingly not always the case.

If we look at charts which show the correlation between happiness on the one side and material welfare, with happiness measured by polls and the welfare measured by the Human Development Index which measures the totality of the level of development in a society, not just one’s own income but for instance as in Australia benefits, healthcare, security and what not. What we would expect is maximum happiness for those countries which have maximum human development index. We’d expect a cluster up here and we would expect nothing down here. We would expect to have no societies with a low human development index and high happiness. Surprisingly, two African countries, Tanzania and Nigeria, actually top the chart in terms of the happiness index and are at the very bottom of the chart in terms of prosperity and wealth.

On the other hand, we have an amazing number of countries which are actually very high up on the human development index and in which people are absolutely miserable. This is a recent survey which was done between ’95 and 2000. I don’t have more recent data. But what this data shows, and this is worldwide data, each of these dots is one country. What this data shows is that there is not a correlation, an automatic correlation between prosperity and happiness, even in the broadest sense of prosperity as all of the aspects of human development including education, health, security, and whatnot.

We have extremely poor countries in which people feel they are extremely happy and extremely wealthy countries in which people are absolutely miserable. Now if we take the case of Australia which concerns us, I have plotted on this chart data from two different sources. One is study on social change by Inglehart and the other data on Australia’s GDP per capita from 1945. So you can see that the GDP per capita, in other words, what the ordinary man gets, Fluctuates quite widely. It rises sharply from 1955 up into 1970, plummets and has been rising steadily ever since.

However, if you look at mean happiness, mean happiness has been steadily moving downwards from 1945. So certainly for Australia it is very clear that GDP per capita, in other words, one’s individual wealth has an inverse correlation to happiness. Then if we continue with our investigation of whether materialism works or not, And look at world suicide rates, where suicide is seen as the ultimate act of despair. What is quite striking is to find that suicide is, with the exception of India, a disease of the developed world. It is extremely high in the former Eastern Europe, which also rank very low in terms of happiness on the world happiness index, largely because of disappointed expectations.

It is extremely high in North America, in the developed countries of South America, Argentina and Chile, and in Australia and New Zealand. And in the case of Australia specifically, the situation is even more interesting. If we plot male suicide rates in Australia in the twentieth century by age group, we find that those in their upper 80s see basically a constant rate suicide. You look at the dark red line here. Ages 65 to 84, the suicide rate is basically declining in keeping with improved healthcare.

But what is astonishing is that the suicide rate in the fifteen to twenty four age group, which is nominal in the early nineteen hundreds, skyrockets by two thousand. It actually passes from six deaths per 100,000 in 1907 to twenty seven deaths per 100,000 in the nineteen ninety’s and twenty deaths per 100,000 in the 2000, decade. And this is extremely puzzling. The living standard has been increasing steadily. Australia is safer than it ever was before.

Never have the young had as much freedom, certainly in terms of their personal development. And the suicide rate has increased by a factor here of almost five. Yet the topic to the best of my knowledge is almost taboo in Australian society. Australia has to be the happy country and these figures, are simply not addressed. Grant told me actually privately interviewing a statistician that the figures are misleading because this statistician told him that many accidental deaths among the many suicides among the young are called accidental deaths so as not to distress the family.

So this chart raises fundamental questions for the society we live in. If material progress is the guarantor of happiness, why is it that young Australians are so unhappy that the rate of suicide increases by five hundred percent in one century? And we see the response to this situation from The United States, which is a psychiatrist of unhappiness. This is data which has just been published in 02/11 comparing total inpatient days, in other words basically rates of internment, by age group in The US between 96 and two zero seven. If we take children aged five to 13, total inpatient days is multiplied by more than two in ten years.

Adolescents 14 to 19, psychiatrist explores it increases here by what 40%. It is only in the elderly that internment decreases. Now this data was collected before the global financial crisis of two zero eight. It would be extremely interesting to have recent data which would show what the rate of internment of children and adolescents is in reaction to the financial crisis. This is the data of a prosperous country with some of the highest growth rates in history fueled by debt.

It clearly demonstrates as far as children and teenagers are concerned that prosperity does not lead to happiness. However, even though these charts show that materialism in general does not work, my contention is that in addition to the deficiency of the system as such, we have entered in the final crisis of materialism, which started in 1989 with the collapse of the iron wall and which the global financial crisis of two zero eight is now ushering with the progressive demise of much of our consumer societies. I was raised in Switzerland, which as you know is one of the wealthiest countries in the West and returned with my wife over Christmas to Switzerland, for our Christmas vacation. This is what I saw on the high end streets of my hometown in Switzerland. Every 20 to 25 meters, there were beggars.

This is a picture which I actually took. I didn’t take the pictures in the snow but they were begging in the snow. This has happened in the last three years. We were planning on going to Paris with my wife. I said to her, if it’s this bad in Switzerland, we’re going to skip France.

Now, what is happening? If we look at the Lojong threats to materialist societies and our consumer societies, I think we can summarize them as follows. On a scale ranging from two zero eight to 2,100, the immediate threat is a global financial crisis which started three years ago. Then we are facing what is known as peak oil. The progressive exhaustion of our carbon fossil resources or to be more precise, the steady increase in extraction costs, which means the end of an easy cheap energy society.

We are in an obvious cycle of nuclear proliferation worldwide and the threat of pandemics is considered extremely high by organizations like the CDC in Atlanta, which specialize in the prevention of pandemics. Natural disasters, I will show the charts have increased steadily in the last century. And the Lojong threat of global warming is a threat not just to human civilization, but it may be a threat to all species on earth. These five threats are putting the model of a civilization rooted in matter and sense happiness under tremendous pressure. And if we investigate them further, the first of these, the global financial crisis of two zero eight, is rather well epitomized by this picture from The US of this homeless man who took a low interest adjustable rate mortgage loan.

In other words, a subprime loan. There are at present as you know hundreds of thousands of Americans who in the last three years have lost not only their houses, but their jobs, their cars, and generally whatever relationship they were in and are homeless. And have no clear hope of ever reentering the job market. This crisis is a direct product of the constant accumulation of material goods to a degree which is incompatible with one’s means to accumulate. In other words, through debt.

And if we look at government debt as a percentage of GDP, we can see, for instance, for The United States debt levels of 80 to 100% of GDP. For Europe, high debt levels. For both Brazil and India, high debt levels. This is government debt. In other words, these are infrastructure costs, welfare costs, which are incurred by societies or in the case of The US military costs, incurred by societies which can no longer afford them.

Some countries are in what is known technically as the ring of fire where the debt to deficit ratio is so high that they are facing sovereign risk, a risk of collapse of government debt. In other words, of collapse of their economy. This includes countries like Greece, but also countries such as Japan, most of Europe, United States, Italy. And you can see even on the edge, countries which are supposedly well behaved financially such as Netherlands, The Netherlands and Germany. You might be reassured of the thought that Australia has a very low rate of deficit to debt.

And the news looks good indeed until one enters into greater detail in private debt in Australia. If we start addressing the issue of household debt, in other words, we’re no longer focusing on government debt, which is government’s desires which they cannot satisfy with the means at their disposal, which leads to mortgaging the future for the present, but individual debt. In other words, the individual citizen of a materialist society aspiring to a status he cannot afford. This is the evolution of household debt between 1982 and 02/2009. As you can see in Australia it passed from 50% to above 150% of annual income in keeping with all of the Anglo Saxon countries.

In the case of some European countries such as Holland, we are at approximately 250% of annual disposable income. This debt is overwhelmingly incurred to purchase real estate on the misguided premise that real estate can only rise. This has led to the bankruptcy of an entire generation in The United States. This is leading to the bankruptcy of an entire generation in Europe. This will probably lead to the bankruptcy of an entire generation in Australia.

If we look at the charts for Australia, this is data from the Reserve Bank of Australia as of 2010. This is household debt to income in Australia in 1977, 38%. By 1996 it’s around 60%. In the Howard Costello in other words, in ten years, it skyrockets to 160% of disposable income and it seems to keep on rising. I don’t have the figures for the last two years.

This means that every Australian household is bust, owes two years income. In other words, every Australian household has had dreams which it could not afford. Now this is a direct product of a system which fosters consumption. In other words, in Buddhist terms which fosters greed, which sees itself as surviving only through the uncontrolled development both of state greed and individual greed. The result of this situation can clearly be understood if you look at the statistics for the ratio between suicide and unemployment in the EU.

These two charts are for the new EU countries, in other words countries from Eastern Europe like Estonia and the old EU countries. You can see between 2000 and the beginning of the financial crisis two thousand seven, suicide and unemployment fall in conjunction with each other. And in 2008, they skyrocket. The reaction to the collapse of one’s material situation to unemployment in a situation where one owes between one and one and a half years of income is self destruction. So the global financial crisis is the first crisis we are going through which will probably lead to the demise of materialism as we know it.

Another much more ominous one, is what is known as peak oil. You may not believe this but this is actually a picture of a street in Camden, New Jersey in The States. You might think you were perhaps in a slum in South America. Peak oil refers to the increasing cost of the extraction of carbon fuels, not just oil but gas and so forth, as they become rarer and rarer. This is the official version.

The official version is that crude oil has peaked between 02/2005 and 02/10 and that the availability of crude oil from present fields is going to collapse and actually is collapsing at present. However, the IEA chart includes in green and in blue crude oil from fields yet to be developed and crude oil is from fields yet to be found. In other words, stuff nobody knows anything about. And it’s quite extraordinary that having included these you find oil production, surprise surprise, remains constant for the next decades. So this chart has been savaged by Finnish researchers at the University of Helsinki who have said that it is nothing else but propaganda.

The clear data certainly from Saudi Arabia is that Saudi Arabia has already reached peak oil. It is becoming more and more expensive to extract oil. Those of you who follow the news and saw the explosion of the Bravo platform in the Gulf Of Mexico last year see the costs involved, not just financial but also ecological in extraction of oil from very difficult to reach situations. What this means in a nutshell is the end of the age of cheap energy. Therefore, the end of a certain lifestyle for much of the Western world, particularly United States and Australia, which is very much hooked on cheap energy.

And we can see this very clearly if we look at the price of oil from $18.51 to $2.00 6. At the beginning oil was extraordinarily expensive. It was very hard to find and very quickly by the eighteen eighties, the price of oil apart from some blips remained constant up to the first oil crisis which I remember as a child in 1973. The first oil crisis is the beginning of the large scale indebtedness of western societies. Growth rates of 7%, five to 7% per annum which was the standard from 1945 up to 1973 plummet.

But the demand for welfare, for social assistance, for a medical system and for infrastructure remain. Hence, debt is incurred systematically by all western nations. As a result, the paltry situation of most of the public finances. You can see the price of oil skyrocketing, dropping in the 1990s and then rising steadily ever since. It is well above $100 a barrel at present.

Estimates are that if the crisis in The Gulf becomes a full blown crisis, we are looking at prices of oil per barrel of hundreds of dollars a barrel. It is in other words the end of a certain lifestyle. And we can see here in the inflation adjusted US oil price, the steady increase in the price of oil since the end of the second world war. The direct result of this in America for instance, has been that the lifestyle which was taken for granted between 1945 and 1970, which was that on one salary, one could make a family of four live and sent two children to school and eventually to college, that lifestyle has collapsed. By the nineteen eighties to afford the same lifestyle, both parents had to work at full time jobs.

Now to afford this lifestyle in 2012, both parents together work at three jobs. It is a full time job for each parent plus a part time job for each parent. This shows a clear collapse in the living standard with the community at large growing ever faster just to stay where they are. This is a second source of pressure on the materialist economy. The third is nuclear proliferation and war.

There is little to say about this. You follow the news. We have had an explosion in the number of nuclear capable states in the last ten years. And especially now we are in a situation of de facto nuclear proliferation in one of the most critical areas in the world, The Middle East, critical for the world economy. As some of you may know, Henry Kissinger, our late secretary of state said there are two grounds for which United States will use a nuclear option.

The first is to defend the Pacific trade lines. The second is to defend the Middle East. In other words, these two areas are considered vital for America’s strategic future. Hence, obviously for the strategic future of the developed world. The third risk which all societies face, which is little talked about at present is pandemic risk.

Pandemics are a fact of human history. They have occurred repeatedly. We are the inheritors in many respects of Fleming, the discoverer of penicillin and of an age in which disease is broadly seen as irrelevant apart from chronic and wasting diseases. That age in many respects may be coming to an end. And if we look at a list of major pandemics in history, we can get a sense of the scale of the threat down the line.

Smallpox in the antiquity, the so called Antonine Plague, killed five million. The two plagues, the plagues of Justinian in the sixth century and the Black Death between 1348 and 1352, killed respectively twenty five and one hundred million. Keep in mind that at the time when the black death struck Asia and Europe, world population was 400,000,000. In other words, one person out of four globally died during this period. The Spanish flu, which is still within human memory, killed some seventy five million persons worldwide.

Thirty percent of the world population was infected according to the studies I read and the mortality rate was a poor three ten to twenty percent. If we jump to HIV AIDS, which broke within my memory when I was a teenager, twenty five million have so far died of AIDS. And the next threat on the horizon, which we hope will not materialize, is H5N1, avian flu. So far it has resisted jumping the species barrier. The threat is taken seriously enough that all of the major world economies have been stocking antivirals.

If we extrapolate from the figures of the Spanish flu to Asian flu, what we get is the following data. If we assume that thirty percent of the world population is infected by Asian flu when it breaks. The world has a population of some seven billion. This means two point one billion persons infected. The mortality rate of avian flu is known.

At present it is sixty percent. Sixty percent of two billion is one point two billion dead. These are figures which in many respect might put an end to development as we know it. Now they are hypothetical figures, but they are definitely lurking on our horizon. Those of you who follow these things may know that it seems there are cases in which avian flu has been transmitted from human to human in Bali and in China.

Further down the line natural disasters seem to be increasing for reasons we do not fully understand. However the insurance statistics are very clear. This is US government data regarding the insurance cost of natural disasters in The US. I don’t have the data globally. But you can see an explosion in insurance costs between 1950 and 02/2008.

The official explanation is that more and more people build in risk areas. I would put it to you that that is only part of the problem. Finally, Lojong, undoubtedly the greatest threat to our species and no longer just to an economic model is global warming. This is the data regarding global fossil carbon emissions since 1800. Then there is very little to say.

We can see basically that once the industrial revolution takes hold, we pass from the factor zero to 8,000, in other words 8,000,000,000 metric tons of carbon put in the atmosphere each year. Now whether or not one subscribes to the theory of global warming, it is very difficult to imagine putting 8,000,000,000 tons of carbon in the atmosphere without this having some sort of impact. And if we look at the three models of global warming which are proposed, the optimistic model which is sustainable development which seems far removed from us, successful development, which we are all striving for, and what we seem to begin, which is every nation for itself. We are looking by 2018, in other words, by the time of the children of many of us in this room at situations where at the poles for instance, the temperature would have increased by six and a half to seven, maybe seven and a half degrees. And where at the Equator in the most pessimistic pessimistic model, we have temperature increases of four to four and a half degrees on average.

It is very difficult to see some of these regions remaining livable. We can envision mass shifts of population and huge transformation in agricultural patterns. It is very hard to imagine something like this occurring without tremendous international disruption. Then on top of these rather pessimistic scenarios, we have two scenarios which are discussed, have been discussed in the last two, three years, which are runaway global warming. These are scenarios in which either the permafrost in which carbon is trapped or the methane deposits of the both bottom of the ocean are actually released through global warming.

This leads to an uncontrollable and non linear increase in temperatures. In the case of carbon dioxide, carbon dioxide over 20 has a global warming potential of one. Should the methane which is trapped at the bottom of the oceans or in the permafrost be released, we’re looking at global warming factors of 20. In other words, we’re looking at uncontrollable global warming. Should this happen within our lifetimes?

This is sufficiently critical that both NASA and the European Union have commissioned task forces to specifically address the issue of the melting of permafrost, which seems to be occurring in Alaska and Canada. So these are the sources of pressure on the model of society we have created which is a materialist model of society rooted in the acquisition of material goods with little or no limitation. It is quite clear based on the data I have tried to show you that we seem to be running smack into a wall. The question we have to ask ourselves now is faced with the failure of the materialist model, failure in general, and failure based on the critical factors which we addressed, do religions have anything to offer and if so what? And I will address in this course only the sociological in the immediate benefits of religion.

This by the way is a picture from one of the beautiful temples in Chiang Mai in Thailand. Look at the relevance of religions, this a chart from 02/2009, you can see in green most of the countries in which religion is relevant. Among developed nations it’s mainly The United States And a couple Mediterranean countries. Religion is totally irrelevant in Australia, in China, in Mongolia, in much of the former communist countries. If we now look at some of the sociological data from countries in which religion is relevant, what we find is that those countries for instance which are Muslim, in other words in which religion, the Islamic religion is relevant, have an extraordinarily low level of alcohol consumption.

Christian countries in which alcohol consumption is allowed have higher rates of alcohol consumption. But what interests us is the fact that a religion such as Islam and in India, Hinduism can limit or almost eliminate the impact of alcohol consumption on society. So there is a very clear positive benefit in that respect. And it is even clearer if we look at alcohol abstention. I used to be very struck when I was in India at just how few Indians drank and how wholesome the lifestyle of the ordinary Indian was.

Now if we pass to another category of intoxicants, cannabis, You can see it is a vice of the developed world. United States, Canada, Europe, Australia, the developed countries of South America, it is absent in the third world. There is an inverse correlation certainly with religion in most countries apart from The US. In the case of cocaine consumption it’s even more striking. It is as you can see a vice of developed nations.

In our societies, however, religion mainly survives as a means of consecrating rites of passage. In other words, as a means of reaffirming sociological identity. This is not religion in the sense we will be talking about it this year. This has a lot to do with one’s social identity. And we are in a particular situation which I think is rather unique in history.

We are in the situation in which we actually can choose to be religious or not and we can choose the religion we practice. This basically is a modern development. Until certainly the nineteen fifties in most countries in the world, one was born into one’s religion. One never chose one’s religion. In other words, one never had to deal with the issue of conversion.

Overwhelmingly modern religiosity is rooted in conversion as opposed to birth. Conversion is well known as factor of instability, psychological and cultural instability. In the case of our communities in the West, in this room, I think perhaps apart from two persons, every single Buddhist is a new convert. Then the issue of conversion concerns us directly. We are very sensitive to it when it arises in third world countries and tend to see it as an evil.

Yet we do not show the same we do not have the same view on conversion in our own countries and under our own latitudes. And the fundamental question behind conversion is one which is very aptly posed by a Christian thinker, JK Chesterton. Does one ever really convert? JK Chesterton has commented somewhere that usually when a westerner converts to a non Christian religion, they never really convert to that religion at all. All they really convert to is Christianity minus the parts of Christianity they find unpalatable.

In other words, they never cease to be Christian. Now this was certainly the case when Chesterton wrote in the nineteen thirties. Nowadays, the materialist paradigm has become so dominant. My personal impression is that most westerners who convert to Buddhism never ceased to be materialist. They are just materialists without the aspects of materialism which are bothersome.

This prevents any authentic appropriation of Buddhism. And we have two very high profile examples I’d like to cover with you And then I would like to show you some statistics from France on, the conversion of Frenchman to Buddhism, which I think apply quite well to Australia. The first case I would like to talk about is a Buddhist scholar known as Paul Williams, who converted to Buddhism in his teens after being very close to the Anglican church. And Paul Williams recounts this anecdote. He was attending a Buddhist retreat and a very great Tibetan lama came to him.

Paul Williams was admiring the English countryside. And this lama said to Paul Williams, ah yes, beauty. I used to know what it meant. Now I only see suffering. This profoundly Buddhist comment disturbed Paul Williams greatly.

So much so that he eventually came to the feeling that Buddhism was hopeless and struggled to return to the Christianity he had initially abandoned. Reconverting back from Buddhism to not just Christianity, but Roman Catholicism and becoming a lay Dominican preacher. The case caused quite a scandal. Williams actually published a book, the unexpected way to try to explain how after thirty years of being a Buddhist, he converted back to the religion of his childhood. What is striking here is that it is the religion of his childhood which actually carried the day when he was searching for spiritual solace.

It was these deep roots in his early childhood which were more powerful than anything intellectually appropriated later on. In the case of Paul Williams, we must give credit to mister Williams for sincerity and clarity in his religious positions. This is not the case for the following figure who actually was trained by the same teacher I was in Switzerland, Stephen Batchelor, a best selling so called Buddhist author who actually, has repeatedly expressed skepticism regarding one of the fundamental teachings of Buddhism, the existence of reincarnation. To put it blunt bluntly, if you don’t believe in reincarnation, you cannot be a Buddhist. There’s no debate about this.

It is non negotiable. But Batchelor has tried over the years, and it occurred when I knew him at Tapacharling, to have it both ways. He trained with the greatest Buddhist teachers of his age, my teacher, Geshe Rabten, and a very great Korean Zen master Kusang Sunim. And it is quite striking when you read in Confessions of a Buddhist Atheist to see his attitude. I maintained an ironic but respectful distance from Korean Zen orthodoxy.

I put Kusan Sunim’s instructions into practice, but in a way that corresponded to my own interests and needs. And then Batchelor adds, as I had discovered with my Tibetan and Zen teachers, the body of opinion that constitutes their respective orthodoxies is neither flexible nor negotiable. We can see here a particularly problematic relation to the religion one has freely chosen to convert to, which is dwelling in a state of non commitment in case for over 30 and erecting this non commitment as a doctrine. A bachelor actually claims to be an agnostic Buddhist and a contradistinction to all of the Buddhist historical texts goes so far as to wonder whether the Buddha himself subscribed to the doctrine of transmigration or reincarnation. Then obviously in this matter, there is really no debate.

Buddhologists unanimously affirm that whatever Buddhist texts want to assert as core texts, the Buddha taught and believed in reincarnation and was foundational for his practice. This has led His Holiness to Dalai Lama and it is a recent development in the last ten years to discourage the conversion of Westerners to Buddhism. This was not the case when I started. I translated for His Holiness in Geneva in 1986 in French. And we were only 150.

There were only 150 in the room. And, his holiness was quite open to the conversion of Westerners to Buddhism. In terms of stability of conversion, broadly speaking, it has been a failure. We have a constant stream of new Buddhists coming to centers, but very few committed Buddhists. And Westerners who convert to Buddhism often convert in a superficial way, which prevents the teachings from being of real benefit to them.

This has led his holiness to ask directly whether they would not be better served by another religious tradition. And therefore I could have chosen from any of a dozen teachings I attended by his holiness in the last ten years in the West where he has said this. I chose from his latest book. It is not by and large a good idea for people to adopt religious practices which are not well grounded in their own culture and educational background. To do so can be difficult and lead to unnecessary confusion.

And this is unfortunately the situation which we deal with in the transmission of Buddhism to the West. Many westerners who are caught in the modern nexus we talked about of individualism, egalitarianism, relativism, privatization, and technological consciousness, try nonetheless to fit Buddhism within that nexus without understanding that in some respects at least there is incompatibility. And to confirm his holiness’s rather clear advice on this topic, I would like to show you some of the only sociological statistics we have on attendance at Buddhist centers. They have unfortunately not been collected for The only in a paltry fashion for The US and not at all for Australia. But we have a remarkable set of data for France, which were collected over a decade and which study Buddhism as a new religion in France.

I should point out immediately that the problems you will see which are associated with the conversion of Westerners to Buddhism are not unique to the conversion of Buddhism. They are problems associated with conversion to any religion. I have longtime friends in Switzerland, in the Orthodox Church, who are dealing now with a large flux of new converts. They describe to me the same problems we have in Buddhist centers. The data collected here was collected from a Kagyu Center in France, over ten years and with some 10,000 participants.

You can see attendance turnover statistics. Year zero you have 100% of the students by definition. After five years, 10% of the students who were coming in the first year are still coming. After ten years, it is 3% of the students who are still coming. So of 100 students who attended Carmeling, let us say in 1976, the date of its foundation, in 1986, only three were coming.

Those of you who know Kensouk Rinpoche’s ministry in Adelaide probably can see that the same figures apply here. When Rinpoche started teaching in Adelaide twenty years ago, think back at who was attending the teachings and then think back at who was attending the last teachings Rinpoche gave at TBI last year. I myself was quite floored since I came to Australia. I started translating for Rinpoche in 2007 in Australia, the Vajrayogini seminar in Sterling. We are in 2012.

Students who were attending in 2007, I no longer saw by 2009. Students who attended Rinpoche’s Lama Chöpa commentary in 2009, I don’t see nowadays. We see students one year, we don’t see the next year. Then we do not have the statistical data of Karmalink, but we do have a very strong sense that there is extreme instability in the conversion to Buddhism. This is not good for the student and this is not good for the center.

A French sociologist, Lenoir, studied conversion to Buddhism in France, focusing on two traditions, the Zen and Tibetan tradition with some nine forty eight questionnaires sent out. What he found was that the vast majority of Buddhists have been Buddhist for between one and fifteen fifteen years. We’re looking at approximately 80% of all Buddhists in centers. There are a very, very small number of Lojong Buddhists, a mere 18%. Buddhism is a new tradition, but did these studies at the beginning of the twenty first century, late 1990s, early twenty first century.

Buddhism had been present in France at that point for forty years. Then what we find is that overwhelmingly those who are attending these centers consider themselves Buddhist. And as we would expect, 66% who consider themselves Buddhist, We find some 73% of those of the students who have taken refuge. This is basically what we would expect. We also find in France, this is not the case in Anglo Saxon countries, that the majority of the French Buddhists believe in reincarnation.

Disbelief in reincarnation is a very specific issue of The United States and the Anglo Saxon countries. However, when the students are asked what the goal of their practice as Buddhists is, one is quite amazed to find that a solid 43% want improvement in this very life. And therefore would not qualify as Buddhists according to the traditional Tibetan criteria. Then 13% want a good rebirth, so would qualify as practitioners of the small scope. And some 30% would like liberation, so they would qualify as practitioners of the middling scope.

Nobody seems to aim for full enlightenment. So perhaps the nine forty eight persons who answered the questionnaire, nobody was a Mahayana practitioner. Which is very awkward in a tradition such as the Tibetan tradition. And where the statistics become problematical is when the participants were polled and asked whether they thought one could be a Buddhist and a member of another religion at the same time. 51% said yes.

Then another 15% said yes but. Then those who don’t know, we have another 15% which makes 81%. So if we use the standards of Kensurinpoche for pure dharma practitioners, we have 18% of the nine forty eight students polled who would qualify on that basis as Pure Dharma practitioners. And 80% would qualify as non Pure Dharma practitioners. Then if we look at the age groups, we find a situation similar to that we have in Australia.

In Australia it is even more extreme. We have very few young people. The less than 35 a paltry 20% and an overwhelming 80%, 79 above 35. In Australia, I think the above 50 are dominant in the center. Sometimes it’s the above 60.

So these teachings, religious teachings in general, do not appeal to the young who are caught in the world of the senses. Buddhist teachings in particular, because they are stark and difficult, have strong negative appeal for the young when they are seen as authentic as opposed to fuzzy dharma. And they only appeal to those who have faced the difficulties of life which tend to come with age. And one finds that the young who come often have had uncommon or difficult experiences. They have been in accidents, they have been hospitalized, they have had difficult family backgrounds, they have in other words been face to face with inordinate levels of suffering early on.

So this leads us to what we’ll be addressing in the next couple conferences, possible foundations for ethics, which is the foundation for a good life. Ethics does not have to be religious. They’re both religious and non religious ethics. Within religious ethics, one can practice the ethics of theistic religions, which are our ancient Western religions, Christianity, Judaism, and in some parts of the West Islam. It’s an ethics rooted in fear of divine judgment.

The ethics of non theistic religions, mainly the Indian religions, Hinduism, and Buddhism is rooted in a belief in karma and causality. Without a fear of divine judgment or a belief in karma causality, there is no religious ethics. Then we have the alternative secular ethics, which His Holiness has started to propound actively especially with his book which was published I think in 2002, 2003, ethics for a new millennium. Because I think his holiness feels there is little chance of the religious flame reviving in the West and westerners are so heavily secularized and materialistic that one has to focus on what might work for them, which is a secular ethics. And according to his holiness, this has to be rooted in a sense of shared humanity and interdependence.

Then what are the benefits of the great religions for those of us who choose to travel this path? I think there’s no figure more emblematic of the benefits of the great religion than the meeting of Pope John Paul II and his holiness Dalai Lama. There are some qualities the great world religions teach which are of benefit in the here and now in this life for us and for society. And those are the ones we will address today. They are simplicity, which is at odds with much of materialism, and contentment, both of which cut the roots of the savage materialism we have been experiencing.

The awareness of transience of impermanence is present in all the world great religions and is a source of great happiness and peace. Ethics and kindness, what his holiness calls the good heart, are all qualities which are taught by all the great world religions in one form or the other. And I have given you some examples with which we will progressively close the conference. These are some quotes regarding simplicity from the gospels, from the dharmapada, and from Lao Tzu’s Tao Te Ching. You will see that as far as simplicity is concerned, the teachings are quite similar.

And the next great value which is taught is contentment. Perhaps the most alien value to most westerners. Again, we have two quotes, one from the Dharmapada, one of the oldest texts attributed to the Buddha and one from the epistle of the Philippians attributed to Saint Paul in the Christian gospels, the Christian New Testament. And we can see here once again that the crux in terms of how one lives is remarkably similar. Regarding the awareness of transience, I could not resist quoting from Ecclesiastes from the Old Testament.

All is meaningless says the teacher, meaningless, meaningless. What profit is therefore man and all his work for which he toils under the sun. A generation goes, a generation comes and the earth remains forever. There is no difference in the outlook of the Ecclesiastes and that of Shantideva. But all my foes will cease to be and all my friends will cease to be and I also will cease to be and likewise everything will cease to be.

Then regarding ethics, the great religious traditions, broadly speaking, teach nearly identical teachings. The magnificent teaching in the Psalms. Blessed is the man who does not walk on the path of the wicked. In the Dharmapada, by oneself evil is done, it is oneself who suffers. By oneself, the evil is not done and by oneself, one becomes pure.

No man can purify another. And a quote from the Upanishads, the great texts of the Hindu tradition. Finally, regarding kindness, I think there is no fundamental difference between the teachings in the gospels and in the dharmapada as far as practice in this life is concerned. So we can see that all the world’s great religions have a corpus of shared values which we covered here. Simplicity, contentment, awareness of impermanence, ethics, and kindness which enable us to function better together in this very life.

And this is the answer to the title of this conference, why be religious? Because in my personal opinion, the great religions provide the best means for developing these qualities. I am not saying it is not possible to develop them in a secular context. I think it is possible. I do feel it is less stable.

The question, however, has to be whether or not Westerners are still able to be religious. And if they are, whether they should try to return to their own religious tradition as his holiness recommends, or convert to another religious tradition with all the instability we saw. The problem is compounded by the fact that now in the West in many respects, Christianity is moribund. Scandal after scandal, a decredibilization of the institutions, disbelief in the Christian message means that Christianity has little influence over most westerners. And if the choice is between materialism on the one hand and a religious teaching on the other hand, religious teachings have intrinsic superiority over materialism.

If we look at a chart of the world population, we can clearly see that we have gone from a situation up to 1640 where we were maybe 400,000,000 and could afford to behave in pretty much any which way. There was if you’ll forgive me for the term breathing space to a situation where we are at present 7,000,000,000 and will be more than 10,000,000,000 in this century. We are condemned, we are sentenced if you want to get along with each other. And we have no choice but to develop these religious qualities. Whether we develop them through religion or in a secular fashion is up to us.

But we must find a path which enables us to develop these qualities because otherwise, as I hope to have shown, we as a society, perhaps as a civilization, are doomed to collapse. When one is at the nexus of a series of destructive forces all acting together, it is almost impossible to escape. The only hope for us is global cooperation and that is rooted in these values. Therefore, I would like to conclude with the advice His Holiness has given. One must distinguish between belief and respect.

Belief refers to total faith, which you must have in your own religion. At the same time, you must have respect for all other religions. The question for us as Westerners is, can we have total faith in Buddhism? Or are we going to be indefinitely in a state of suspension of disbelief? If we are going to be indefinitely in a state of suspension of disbelief and of skepticism, then the Buddhist teachings will have limited benefit for us.

And we should see whether there are other religious traditions or even secular traditions which are of greater benefit. What definitely the Buddhist teachings do not need are secular agnostics such as Stefan Bachelor in their midst, claiming to be Buddhist and yet espousing what amount to non Buddhist theories. Thank you very much. I have completed my talk for today. I hope it wasn’t too long, too difficult, or too blunt.

And if you have time, I am more than open for your questions. That isn’t going to make things more difficult for those who follow us because the path for those who go outside of the road most traveled is going to become more and more difficult. Because at the moment, everybody in this room who’s actually gone and looking for alternatives knows that there has been one one of the problems and the confusion is there’s a distinct lack of support. And as the Buddhist message becomes more homogenized in the West, whether that will completely disseminate and almost destroy the value of even contemplating becoming a Buddhist. Yes.

I mean, I have talked a lot about sociology in this conference. Personally, I’m not interested at all in sociology. I think the Buddhist message is an individual message of private conversion and through the change in one’s private attitude and one’s own mind over time what has influence over others. Should they choose to benefit from this? Then Buddhism as a political force in America I know nothing about.

I think it would be quite sad if Buddhism went through the road of evangelical Christianity. I don’t think this is the teachings of the Buddha. But I think for us, the goal of this conference was to ask a very simple question. Are we ready to convert fully to the Buddhist teachings or are there reservations? If there are reservations, are there reservations about unimportant things such as Mount Meru, let’s say?

Or are they reservations about the fundamentals such as a noble truth of suffering or reincarnation? If there are reservations about unimportant things, then that is unimportant. If there are reservations about fundamentals, then we should not become a Buddhist because we will not be able to take refuge sincerely. And if we are not able to become a Buddhist sincerely, Buddhism will be of no help to us. So we are harming the Buddhist community, and we are harming ourselves.

So I think the one sign that all is not good in the process of transmission of Buddhism to the West in the Tibetan tradition, which I know, is the extreme instability of attendance at teachings Lojong. That is a very clear sign that refuge in the dharma, which are the teachings, is absent. Then it becomes very worrisome when the person has taken many initiations, many great transmissions, has many vows and disappears after a couple of years. In that case, I think we as a center, and I know the great teachers are doing this, have to reassess what teachings are given in the West. I know his holiness no longer gives major tantric transmissions in the West.

I know of at least two great Tibetan geishes who have banned the ordination of Westerners and his Geshe Zopan, Geshe Raptan, my teacher. And, I know that his holiness and it is recent in the last ten years discourages the conversion of Westerners. He does not forbid it, but he encourages Westerners to look very carefully at their own tradition before closing the door. The door has to be closed. It is not possible to be half Buddhist and half Christian.

It is not possible to be half Buddhist and half materialist. These do not coexist. Then the person is really harming themselves. So since his holiness has been extraordinarily direct in his presentation, I thought that as his disciple, I too should be clear. And that’s what we will be talking about in the next four to five months.

After this talk, we will talk next time of what the scientific data regarding the death process is, the questions it leaves open, and then we will make a very clear presentation of the great religions and their differences. One cannot be an authentic Buddhist if one does not know clearly what the alternatives are and if one cannot say, I do not believe in them. I’m sorry. It’s a very long answer to your question. A very long answer to your question.

My apologies. Are there other questions? And I’ll try to answer much in a much shorter fashion. Yes. Ethics as model but it doesn’t offer that spiritual side, that internal development.

So it’s a blueprint on how to be ethical, but it doesn’t offer tools in a similar way that Buddhism does to become ethical. So to me that explains in some way why you have the conversion happening because as a buyer of religion in a religious market, so to speak, Buddhism does give you the things that you need to become ethical and move towards it. Whether it be the Lamrim, Luo Jong, whatever, there are those tools there. Whereas in Christianity, those tools are hidden. They’re mystical tools and they’re not accessible or readily accessible.

What you say is true. I think the greatest strength of Buddhism as a religious tradition is that it teaches the antidotes to the delusions, which are not taught in Christianity. So these antidotes enable one to take control of one’s mind through mind training. The great difficulty Buddhism faces is that it is a demanding tradition. It demands study and effort and this is the great strength of Christianity.

Christianity is extremely simple. It is a very simple religious tradition which helps simple people who need some sort of guideline to develop ethics and a kind heart. Then I wish that the conversion in the West to Buddhism was motivated by this understanding you talk about. I don’t think so. I think it’s motivated by the grass is greener elsewhere syndrome.

Because the most popular religions in Asia right now are Christianity. The religion to which has the highest rate of conversion in Korea is Christianity. Christianity is taking off in Thailand. There are even Tibetans who convert to Christianity. If it was a case that they understand that their own tradition has antidotes to the delusions and Christianity doesn’t, this wouldn’t happen.

It’s more a case of aspiring to a fantasized identity. Westerners aspire to the fantasized piece of the Buddhist traditions. Buddhists aspire to the fantasized wealth and success of Western societies. I can, for instance, say for a fact, having having translated and taught in Singapore, that the majority of Singaporean Buddhists are Chinese Christian converts who have reconverted back to Buddhism. And they converted or their families converted to Christianity initially, probably for sociological reasons.

Then what you say is true. Dharma, if well understood, offers a palette of tools which is unequaled in any religious tradition. The problem is one must study and meditate to use this palette of tools. This calls for a lot of time and effort. This is what Khensur Rinpoche has emphasized in every single teaching he has given at TBI.

If one is not ready to put that time and effort, then I think there is a problem. I think there is a problem. So I hope that answers your question. Unfortunately, it does. Yeah.

Are there other questions? Yes? I think much depends on the lifestyle of the person. If one is a monk involved in the study programs of the great monasteries or someone who is studying full time, from a Buddhist standpoint, the greater the doubt, the better because one is in the process of eliminating it. Then these doubts which are eliminated through reasoning become an extraordinarily powerful foundation.

In that context, doubt has to be encouraged. On the other hand, if one is not involved in a process of study and one has tremendous doubts and reservations, this is extremely problematical because one is not involved in a process of clearing these and it will prevent the tradition one is practicing from being powerful for oneself. So it depends on one’s lifestyle. In the monasteries, one is encouraged to doubt everything because one studies in tremendous depth and intensity. Then here, has always emphasized the importance of faith simply because nobody studies.

There’s no time. And if people are not going to study, one does not want to raise doubts because they will not be able to clear them. So I hope that answers your question. I’m interested in your opinion on this. But being a dharma practitioner in the West, what would your model of an ideal Western dharma practitioner look like considering the karmas of having a family needing to be somewhat normal in a Western society?

It’s a very difficult question. From a traditional Buddhist standpoint, the ideal dharma practitioner is the monk precisely because the monk frees himself completely for dharma practice. It is clear nowadays that to be ordained you have to live in a monastery. Otherwise it’s not possible to keep ordination certainly in the West. Then if one is a lay person practicing, one is in the situation of practicing with very little time.

I think for a lay person especially, for all practitioners, but for a lay person especially, The most important thing is to listen very carefully to the advice of teachers such as Rinpoche, who have a very profound understanding of the western mind. And if we listen to what Rinpoche says based on twenty years experience teaching in the West, it’s rather pessimistic. I mean, I was here when Rinpoche departed. He asked the Australian students to develop two qualities, faith and courage. Now Rinpoche does not teach about faith and courage in Singapore.

I translated it for him in Singapore. In Singapore Rinpoche teaches about renunciation. Faith is there. In India, Rinpoche never talks of faith and courage. He talks of meditation and ethics.

This means that in Australia, Rinpoche has identified lack of faith and lack of courage as the two weaknesses of his students. What has Rinpoche proposed as a daily plan for us? It’s basically the generation of motivation. This is something all of us can do. From a Buddhist standpoint, the deed depends on the motivation.

If our days are filled from 07:00 in the morning until six in the evening with work, then family responsibilities, then fun. It is a generation of motivation in the morning which transforms this in something greater than just this life. Then all of us obviously would like to engage in the advanced practices, but there is no time. So I think it is very uninspiring. I agree with you.

But it is those simple practices of the daily generation of a motivation to help others every single day of our life, which is of benefit and on top of this basic ethics. Basic ethics is the abandonment of the 10 non virtues. That means that even in this life we will not face difficulty and definitely in future lives we will not face inordinate suffering. And then on top of this I think anyone who considers himself a Buddhist must attend one teaching a week. We take refuge in dharma.

The true refuge is dharma. We take refuge in the teacher because of he teaches dharma, and the sangha because he practice dharma. If we do not try to know dharma, we have no refuge. So those three things I think are possible. It is possible to generate the motivation every day.

Ten, fifteen minutes. It is possible to try to live ethically. It’s possible. Ideally, to take lay vows, but that is difficult for Westerners, but at least not to turn on virtues. And it is possible once a week to come to the teachings.

And then if one has time for a westerner as opposed to a Tibetan, it is extremely important to try to do a retreat. It is in a retreat, even a one or two retreat, that a couple experiences will come. These experiences will change the way we look at the world. Then it’s no longer up here, it’s here. Westerners believe what they see.

Therefore, if one does a short retreat, suddenly something will happen. I want to have a very powerful meditative experience. Who knows? Most of my friends who did retreat had these experiences. Then they came out of retreat different.

And then they will try to keep on doing retreats as much as they can. Normally, in every sincere retreat, you gain one or two experiences. Then it is easy to get free from the shackles of materialism because you know. One can’t explain to others, but one knows. So I think that’s more or less how one should try to do things, in my private opinion.

But remember she spoke of courage and faith. Courage and faith. And what’s the courage do you think? Commitment. To have the courage of one’s beliefs.

It is to stop, to stop hesitating. We would say in English bluntly, it’s American, I’m sorry, it’s one of states, to put one’s money where one’s mouth is, To start delivering. Tibetans do. Some westerners do. And the reason this is important is because with courage and faith, whatever tradition we practice starts benefiting us.

Our lives change. We commit. Then we need courage because there’s a price. When we start practicing a religious tradition, there’s a price to pay. For instance, let’s say we decide to stop drinking, which is emphasized in the Buddhist tradition because ours is a tradition of mental control.

Drugs, alcohol are anathema to Buddhists. If we stop drinking, there’s a price to pay in terms of our social lives. It calls for courage and faith. Then to stop killing. It sounds easy until you realize that it might mean stop using insecticides in your house.

Then you have to put up with the little creatures. So those are the two values. And then I think for Westerners, it is extremely important to attend teachings and to document oneself, Not to commit prematurely, not to rush, to wait until there is some type of certainty. Because premature commitment and then departure is very destructive for the person. It sows the seeds in future lives for never being able to commit to a religious tradition.

And then premature commitment to a teacher out of emotional reasons and then abandonment of that teacher is extraordinarily destructive. I mean, was very surprised when I came to Australia just how many students had come to Rinpoche’s teachings, taken initiations, and then we would say the Tibetan tradition abandoned Khensur Rinpoche. They walked away and they never came back. And I met them by accident and they would say this terrible Australian way of putting things, we moved on. You hear people say that.

And that is a clear sign that they weren’t careful in the beginning and then they had reservations, and then they abandoned everything. And then they were worse off than when they started. For that reason, the most important thing in dharma centers is to slow people down. Slow people down. They come to the teachings.

They attend. They listen. They study. They think. And then quietly, quietly, they start taking only the commitments they can keep.

If they cannot, teachings are they are welcome to attend teachings as non Buddhists as long as they want. Indefinitely. But they have to be clear in their minds. I am not a Buddhist, and we have to be clear in our minds they are not Buddhists. But that is a relation of honesty.

Where it is very problematical is where the person goes through the motions. From their own side without being really convinced, from the standpoint of the teacher in the center, they are thought to be Buddhists, and then eventually they walk away. Then this is very problematic. Are there any more questions? Then I’m sorry I took a long time today but I think the foundations were important.

I think it may be yours. I’ll give you mine. We are extraordinarily fortunate, Ilya, to have you being the loudspeaker, as you once described yourself, for Khensur Rinpoche, having translated for him over many years and Geshe Rabton and many other great teachers, You have the bifocal perspective which we are so much grateful for being able to benefit from in echoing the views of our teachers in a way that we can readily understand. And so I thank you so much for being a bridge for us and to help us to understand how we can relate to the teachers and to the teachings. And I am sure that we will all take your words to heart and examine ourselves and see how we can apply them to our own lives.

The next seminar, as Ilya alluded to, is on the March 24, death in its aftermath at 02:00. And just to also put in a plug for Geshela’s teaching on the 12 links of dependent origination, which is a further teaching really about the four noble truths. Those of you who attended Geshela’s teachings on the four noble truths, he gave a personal invitation for us to attend. That is on the April on Easter. And there are lots of other activities throughout the week here at TBI, so please have a look at the website, the newsletter.

So I would just like to ask you to join with me in thanking Ilya very much for a stimulating presentation. Thank you. See documentary on near death experiences which provides a lot of strong data regarding the survival of the mind after death. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
Kagyü
The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Marpa, Milarepa, Gampopa, and their followers. One of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. Cf. Nyingma, Sakya and Gelug. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
Mount Meru
The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top