47 min · 2,355 words · 30 March 1993
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk continues the Wheel of Sharp Weapons teaching from verse 39 of Atisha’s mind training text on how self-cherishing generates afflictive emotions. It explains that the root of negative states is grasping at self versus other, and that the mind is obstructed in meditation by dysfunctional views, such as doubts about whether emptiness exists or whether one can realize it. It also distinguishes afflicted views from mundane and transmundane correct views.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1993-03-30
Duration: 47 min
UUID: 1cf8f899-4cc7-45f7-866c-3c86b98db358
Words: 2,351
Just as we ourselves do not want suffering nor the causes of suffering, likewise all sentient beings are equal in not wanting suffering nor the causes of suffering. It would be wonderful if myself and all living beings were free of suffering and the causes of suffering. This is compassion. May myself and all living beings be free of suffering and the causes of suffering. This is aspiring compassion, or the prayer of compassion.
Then exceptional resolve expresses, I myself will free myself and all living beings from suffering and the causes of suffering. The exceptional resolve over compassion. Making request to the Buddhas that may I be empowered by your blessing to be able to free myself and all living beings from suffering and the causes of their suffering. In order to actualize this aspiration to free all sentient beings from the suffering and the causes of suffering. I am making this my motivation for this going to listen to the universal vehicle training in order to be a best benefit to all living beings.
So as I previously explained, the way we were going to conduct the teachings was that once a month we were going to have a session totally devoted to questions and answers, and being the last session of the month and this would have been that session. But since we’ve only had two teachings thus far this year, I thought we would divide it half and half, half teaching and then half to go to questions and answers. So beginning on verse 39, which reads as follows. When attachment and anger disturb and upset us, no matter how much we may try to suppress them, this is the Wheel of Sharp Weapons returning full circle upon us from wrongs we have done. Till now we have held onto improper outlook, stubbornly cherishing only ourselves.
Hereafter let us uproot self-interest completely. So you know if we consider this we can really understand what’s being talked about here. The fact that from time to time we generate anger, generate develop attachment, jealousy, miserliness, that these going through these cycles of the arising of these various afflictive emotions within our mind. We’re we’re continually generating a plethora of conceptions. Lots of thoughts continue in our mind which trouble our minds.
So all of these patterns of dysfunctional thought which are continually arising within our minds, these negative attitudes, from what are they arising? Under what influence? It is because we have been habituated to these negative ways of thinking, these dysfunctional thoughts, both in this life but also in previous lives, that they wash over us continually like waves on the ocean continually coming one after another, one after another, almost without end. So the continual arising of these troublesome thoughts, these negative patterns within our mind, simply arise out of the force of habituation to negative patterns, dysfunctional patterns of mind, both in this life but also over many previous lifetimes. And this is the Wheel of Sharp Weapons returning back to ourselves.
So these negative attitudes which are continually rising in our mind, they come about through the continual conception of I I, this powerful conception of self which arises out of the ignorance of self grasping. It depends upon this continuous emphasis upon this I and leading to a self importance of the I in terms of everything is thought, the I is central to all things. We cherish the I, we forget about others, that we only want to concern ourselves with the happiness of this I and to free it from suffering. So there arises a self centered attitude. A verse by Śāntideva, in which he traces the evolution of these various negative attitudes that we develop.
And they all arise out of the distinction between I and other. We develop, we have a very powerful sense of I, I itself. And we, it’s extremely forceful. Out of this sense of this discrimination of I, there arises concomitantly sense of other. So in dependence upon the arising of the conception of I arises the conception of other or you.
There is my side and the other side. So there is this powerful conceptions of both self and other, these attitudes. Out of these conceptions, these powerful attitudes or conceptions of self and other in terms of self, we develop attachment. We not only develop attachment to self, but also to mine, my loved ones, my friends, my children, my possessions. On the other hand and on the other associated with the conception of other, we develop senses of aversion, of not liking, of jealousy, of hatred, anger.
So all of these various negative attitudes of attachment and hatred arise out of discrimination of self and other. So it is out of this conception of I which arises in relationship with ignorance, misconceiving the nature of the I, that other comes about and in dependence upon these two conceptions that the associated emotions of attachment and aversion, and in dependence upon these a proliferation of other afflictive emotions which arise in dependent upon these two basic afflictive emotions of aversion and attachment. And in dependence upon the arising of these afflicted emotions, then we engage in various types of actions. We accumulate karma and all the various negative qualities in terms of attitude and action arise in this way. So how do we bring an end to all of these proliferations of afflictive emotions based upon the basic afflictive emotions of attachment and aversion?
These arise from making a distinguishment between oneself and others. That this constant clinging to the I, the importance of the I on the one hand, and discriminating against against other as if they are unimportant, simply leaving them on the side. So it is that these proliferations of afflictive emotions arise in making a distinction as to the importance of I and other, making one’s I self central and others unimportant. So if we begin to dissolve this discriminative quality in the sense that both myself and others are exactly the same. There’s no difference in that in our wanting our both wanting happiness and not wanting to suffer.
Completely equal in that regard equally. There’s no distinction made from the point of view of happiness and suffering. So continuing and discussing another aspect of the Wheel of Sharp Weapons returning to ourselves from the point of view of our meditation, our practice. That though we seek to meditate to cultivate various states, that when we try to meditate, the object of our observation does not appear to the mind or does not appear clearly. It does not arise.
We’re not able to ascertain it. We can’t understand what it is we’re meditating on. When we meditate on emptiness, there’s nothing clear appears to our mind. We don’t understand the object, there’s no realization. So that on one hand we’re not able to the object doesn’t appear to us clearly, we’re not able to understand it, we’re not able to ascertain it, to realize it.
On the other hand when meditate such a subject as compassion or love or the awakening heart, when we are trying to generate the attitude of mind of compassion which is embodied and expressed in the thought, it would be wonderful if all living beings were free of suffering and the causes of suffering. That when we try to meditate on that, we say something from our mouth and we may recite those words. And this is not actual meditation on compassion is that the entity of the mind is transformed into a compassionate mind. This is the cultivation of compassion. It’s not through the thought in the mind or words from the mouth, but the entity of mind itself is transformed into a state of compassion.
This is what meditation on compassion is. When we do it, we simply and only, we mouth the words or simply think thoughts in our mind, these thoughts. And we’re not able to actually generate our mind or transform our mind into the entity of compassion. So we have these obstacles. Why is that?
So we’re asking question, why do I have these obstacles? What’s the problem? It is because our minds are under the influence of various distorted views. That due to holding on to distorted views within our mind, negative views, then we aren’t able to gain realization. We aren’t able to generate these states of mind.
So what is the obstacle to our gaining realization to generating these various states of mind? As was mentioned, there are various distorted views or dysfunctional views. For example, when we meditate on emptiness, we say that phenomena do not exist inherently. We use the reason because they are dependent arising. But when we try to think this through, nothing appears to our mind.
There’s no ascertainment by our awareness of what we’re actually, the object that we’re trying to penetrate, that we’re actually trying to get to. This is due to these dysfunctional views that we have, that we now possess. What we’re really thinking and which acts as an obstacle to gaining these realizations and generating these states of mind in terms of this meditation on emptiness is are things really empty or not? I’m not really sure. Even if they were, could I even though I’m meditating, can I really do I really have the ability to gain a realization?
I’m not sure if I can really understand it or not. Out of this sense of is it really this way? Does emptiness really exist? Can I, even if it were to exist, can I understand it? I’m not sure if I have the ability to gain realization.
These various dysfunctional views that we harbor act as an obstacle to the actual gaining of realization, to the ascertainment of the object that we’re trying to penetrate. So we have to gain some conviction that emptiness in fact exists. I can realize emptiness overcoming these dysfunctional views that we harbor which act as an obstacle to gaining realization. And the same holds true for these other positive states of mind, generate them such as compassion, love, the awakening heart. These are really important states to generate within our mind.
But again, due to our dysfunctional views, we have have a sense that can these in fact be generated? Can I develop them? I really don’t think I can. Therefore, due to the force of these dysfunctional views, meditation has no power, has no force. The same holds that we were just mentioning with respect to emptiness.
That we wonder, well does it exist? Maybe it doesn’t exist, but I’ll never realize that, I can’t. And therefore we have no conviction either in the existence of the object or our ability to develop an understanding of it or to actually generate it within our mind. Not having that conviction, then we make no great effort. Meditation is not forceful and therefore it is these dysfunctional views which act as an obstacle to gaining these realizations.
We have to rid ourselves of these dysfunctional views to eliminate them. We have to see that others, that in fact emptiness exists, we have to see it in fact it is, and others have gained realization of it, why can’t I? Others have realization, have developed love and compassion, why can’t I? And gaining a real conviction that one too can gain these understandings and generate these states of mind. So an analogy would be in the case of one has a great goal in mind, some great work that one’s thinking of undertaking.
And one questions, well you know is this really worthwhile or not? Beginning to have doubts about whether it’s worth all the trouble. Whether the goal is worthy of all the effort that you’re going to make. And then not only, but over and above that, think well even if it is can I actually do it? I don’t think I can handle it.
I don’t think I can achieve the goal. And so in such a state when nothing is achieved and we’re prevented from even directing ourselves toward the goal and but additionally making great effort in trying to achieve it. So there are many types of dysfunctional views. With an expanded number we could list 36 or we could condense those down to 12 or we could even condense those down to five. So these views are listed.
These dysfunctional views are listed by Vasubandhu. Such views as the view of the transitory, the view of the permanent self, the view of extremes, the view of holding wrong ethics and conduct as correct means of liberation. That these are all afflictive views on the one hand, but then there is another category of views which are correct views, authentic views, and these are in two, mundane and transmundane views. So these correct views or authentic views are of two types, mundane and transmundane. So the transmundane view is the direct realization of emptiness.
And this is the most important because it’s able to, by means of this view, one can destroy all the afflicted emotions. But then there are the mundane views or the mundane correct views. By mundane it simply means ordinary, that is to say the views which are not direct realization of emptiness. Those correct views which are not within the direct realization of emptiness are termed mundane, authentic views. So for us ordinary individuals, mundane views are extremely important. Our practice depends upon them.
That is for example, views with respect to what is to be abandoned, what is to be cultivated, what is to be adopted or rejected. The mundane correct view is subsumed within the view that with dependence upon positive physical, verbal and mental acts, all wanted, all desirable results arise. Wholesome types of results, positive types of results. On the one hand and on the other, in dependence upon negative physical verbal mental acts or unwanted or undesirable results arise. This is the mundane correct view.
Key terms in this teaching
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.