36 min · 1,789 words · 23 March 1993
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains that trust in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha is essential for practice and brings happiness, and that trust can rest on reasoning or on faith in words. It describes how intelligent practitioners gain trust through reasoning, while simple-minded ones trust a fully realised Buddha who has no reason to lie. It links hardships such as unstable dwelling, crop failure and poverty to past actions, and a question and answer session follows.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1993-03-23
Duration: 36 min
UUID: 3eddd88e-aea7-4471-a859-50afc08914c2
Words: 1,785
So this, but this applies also to our secular activities. If one doesn’t have any conviction in what one is doing, doesn’t trust in the activity and engaging in it, then it’s difficult for that action to bear fruit. It’s difficult to that the action will bring any sort of fulfillment. And this holds even more so in terms of spiritual practice. Rinpoche is quoting a Buddhist and it’s talking about the yogis who attained the powerful attainments, who actually get realization.
They are of two varieties. Those who are extremely intelligent, they have great wisdom. Out of this wisdom they’re able to understand the nature of things and they develop a great trust in the method. They have great conviction in what they’re going about and the method of doing it. And they will be out of their great wisdom, will or their intelligence, they will quickly gain powerful attainment and the blessings of the practice.
On the one hand, and the other type of individual who quickly gains powerful attainment is the simple minded person has faith and trust. Out of this simple minded faith and trust, though they might not understand, they still give themselves over completely in a trusting manner to the practice. And they too are able to quickly gain powerful attainment. On the other hand, between these two extremes, there’s those in the middle. Those who say, well, I’m not quite sure what it, they don’t quite understand the nature of the situation nor do they have faith and trust.
So they are left in the middle somewhere considering the situation, and for them there’s no attainment of powerful attainment. So trust is extremely important. Without trust we are susceptible to many preconceptions, or another way to translate the term is superstition. We are liable to think all kinds of strange thoughts, have our own ideas, and we never actually are able to practice well. In dependence upon all of these various preconceptions that we have, these superstitions, right?
We develop, let us say, not having any trust, all this proliferation of preconceptions, which bring about fears, which bring about anxieties, all the various types of suffering that we experience. So trust is extremely important. If we have a trusting mind, we will have a happy mind. We won’t have a great many of these preconceptions roaming around our mind. So out of the sense of trust in the Buddha Dharma Sangha, then we will be able to maintain a happy state of mind.
But moreover, having been relying upon the combination of these three, we will then engage in the means of achieving further happiness and we will bring about both temporal and ultimate happiness. So there is a situation which we might experience whereby we’re continually having to move on from one place to another. We’re not able to abide in any one place for a long period. We don’t have any stable dwelling. Why does that come about?
The cause of this, oneself not having stability in one’s place to live, is because we ourselves previously have, what’s the word, when you kick somebody out, evicted our lamas and our parents from where they were dwelling, father and mother, from their dwelling. And as a result, we we experience an inability to be able to stay in one place. And then another situation, that of where we grow good crops. But as the crops grow, they’re afflicted by various diseases or hail falls down upon them. So this what is the what is the cause of such a situation where our crops are continually being destroyed?
This is because we have not observed our words of honor. That through non observing words of honor we create internal conflict with inside ourselves. And this is expressed as a result outwardly in terms of outer conflict, that there is a disharmony within our environment, within the nature and also in the social context that people are always in conflicts with one another, that they harm one another, that they don’t seek to benefit one another. And this all arises in dependence upon not observing our words of honor. As an antidote to this, then we should make, we should try to benefit others as we should develop a love and not harm others.
So there are some who, though poor, have tremendous desire for money and things, and the desire is ever increasing. If they have $100 they want $1,000 they have $1,000 they want $10,000 they have $10,000 they want $100,000 on and on. What is the cause of such a state? So this is due to miserliness in our previous lives, that one had not practiced generosity nor made offerings to the Three Jewels, the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. And as a result, one is poor in this life and has great desires.
So if we desire to have wealth in the future, to be rich, then it’s necessary that we accumulate the necessary karma, those actions, which act as the cause to bring about those ends. So it’s necessary for us to practice generosity, to make offerings, to make prayers to this end. So in engaging in the middle way, the Buddha is quoted as saying, through the practice of generosity one will in the future gain resources. Through the practice of ethics one will gain a wonderful human embodiment. So I’m going to stop there, so if you have some questions, you can ask them.
Yes. K. There doesn’t seem to be that much connection. So those who are extremely intelligent are able to understand the actual nature of the situation. They’re able to know how it is exactly, what is and what is not.
That is to say, have an understanding of what it is all about. So it is necessary in the process of coming to trust to pass beyond a state of doubt or qualm. In a state where we have qualms, there is not understanding. We still aren’t sure. Is it this way or is it not that way?
There’s doubt or the mind is split between is it this or is it not that. Once we come to understand, then we’ve eliminated the doubt, the qualms. We no longer are in a divided position. We come to definite ascertainment. We know whether it is or whether it isn’t.
So having eliminated qualms or doubt, we come to trust. So the process of eliminating our doubt is the means by which we come to trust, and this requires understanding. Analogy would be that if one person were accused of being a thief, and the person was accused of being a thief, but the thief denied being a thief. So it’s not clear. And so it goes to a third person, who is the judge.
And the judge initially has some qualms. He or she doesn’t know, and so it’s necessary to carry out an examination, trying to ascertain which one is telling the truth or not. So through a process of questioning, one comes to be able to ascertain the actual truth of the situation, eliminating the doubt, and one comes to trust that this person is the thief. So for for those of sharp intelligence, the means of coming to trust is through a questioning which eliminates doubt. So we can say that intelligence is the cause and the condition is the doubt bringing about that result, etcetera.
Yes. So there’s a difference between their trust. One is a trust based upon reason, and the other is an unreasoned trust, which is based upon words. Literally. One is an unreasoned trust, trust which is not based upon reason but which is based upon words.
And the first type of one, trust which is based upon reason. So the trust based upon reason is more powerful and more stable. So each of the various spiritual traditions has their own various doctrines, their own various views, and it would be extremely difficult to understand through reasoning all of the doctrines of all the various spiritual traditions. So we to limit ourselves to investigating a particular tradition. But within that tradition, for example, the Buddhist tradition, the various views and doctrines set forth can all be established through reasoning.
For example, one reason that we’ve talked about, we’ve emphasized, is the reasoning of dependent arising. For example, we say that the path is empty of true existence because it’s a dependent arising or because it has parts or because it is dependent upon terms and concepts. Emptiness is the reason by which we establish the view. Dependent arising is the reason by means which we establish the view of emptiness. And likewise, all the various views and doctrines can be established in the same manner.
So all the various doctrines, all the various set forth can be established through reasoning. For example, by way of example, the doctrine of the existence of past and future lives is established through reasoning, especially clearly set forth in a text called Pramānavārttika, or Compendium of Valid Cognition. And having once understood that, then we can go on to establish the law of cause and effect because there’s an interrelationship between them. So all of these various doctrines can be established through reason. So if we have time, I’d like to teach Pramānavārttika.
So I ask, well how does the simple minded individual develop their trust? Thought it might be useful. That the simple minded individual has trust with respect to the Buddha, that seeing that the Buddha has completed the path for themselves, that they have eliminated all their various faults and that they have a direct realization of what they’re talking about, the actual experience of it. And therefore what they say comes out of their own experience and it’s unerring. And they have no reason to lie.
There are only two reasons to lie. That is to bring about to bring about either one’s own welfare or to trick others. So there are two reasons why a person may lie. That is, one is to trick others, and the other is to bring about one’s own happiness. Mainly it’s to bring about our own happiness.
Or if a Buddha has already found complete happiness, then there’s no reason for him to lie. And over and above that, the Buddha has compassion for others. So out of this combination, I’ve seen that the Buddha has experienced the path, has direct realization, and can unerringly present the teachings, and there’s no reason for him to lie and he has great compassion, then whatever the Buddha says, the simple minded individual has great trust in him.
Key terms in this teaching
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
- Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.