Meditation

1 h 2 min · 8,579 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Meditation (Ilia Durovic)
Meditation (Ilia Durovic)
Meditation
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 62-minute seminar, Ilia Durovic presents the Three Principles of the Path, concluding a two-year teaching series rooted in both Je Tsongkhapa’s foundational text and His Holiness the Dalai Lama’s commentary. Rather than treating emptiness as a philosophical puzzle, Durovic grounds the teaching in the canonical struggles that gave rise to Buddhist tenet schools, then builds conviction about past and future lives as the essential base for practice. He argues that Westerners approach the view wrongly, and advocates studying Ian Stevenson’s reincarnation research before Lamrim. He addresses the divergent capacities in his audience directly, distinguishing between students studying Je Tsongkhapa’s Cittamātra commentary on Tuesdays and those new to Buddhist basics. He stresses that study and practice must be inseparable, criticizes faith-based Buddhism as misguided, and calls practitioners to personal conviction about cyclic existence and its suffering before attempting advanced philosophical views. The second half promises technical coverage of emptiness itself.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 02092017Ilia'sSeminarA 2 – IS.mp3

UUID: 9513e4d9-840f-4be9-9ae3-e03926c27ff0

Teacher: Ilia S. Durovic

Collection: Meditation

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~8,575

Well, it’s 2:00. So welcome everybody once again to another of Ilia’s seminars on the Three Principal Aspects of the Path which encapsulates the entire essence of the Buddhist path. And so we’re very fortunate to have Ilia to share his wisdom and vast experience with us. As per normal we will have a break, a short tea and loo break, ten minutes because I know Ilia has a lot to get through. So if you’re careful you can bring your beverage here afterwards so that we can keep the momentum going.

And thank you for your small donation for the facility fee, air conditioning and lighting etcetera. So without any further ado, I’ll hand over to you. Thank you very much. In the living illustration of interdependence, I would say no tea, no loo, no break. Right?

No tea, no loo, no break. So I am delighted to see quite a few of you here today. We are coming to the end of this two year presentation of these three principles of the path. We started in 2016. I wanted to cover the three principles of the path for several reasons.

First, because I think it was really perhaps the core teaching of Khensur Rinpoche, and he covered it at TBI magnificently in my opinion. And I was fortunate enough to receive it to be an adjunct translator for His Holiness the Dalai Lama in Lausanne when he gave it in 2009. And frankly because if there is one text which is I would say, the core of the oral tradition, of the Gelukpa tradition, it is the three principles of the path. Then I think for many of our students I have seen in the last two, three years, times have become very hard. We have lost a lot of students, students are not able to do what they would like to do, even our management is overstretched and overwhelmed.

Many old students who had moved on, have come back, faced with hardship. Then in difficult times, one needs a very very simple teaching. Something which can be put in practice easily. The time is no longer the times are no longer the times for elaboration, for sophistication, one needs the basics. And the three principles of the path are the basics.

Then as I had suggested two years ago, I don’t know if any of you have tried, one maybe, I had suggested that you memorize it. I don’t know if you did Andy, did you? Congratulations, congratulations. Those of you who can’t memorize anymore, I have done my best to translate it as carefully as I can. Here you have the root text of the three principles of the path in bold characters, and the outline given His Holiness the Dalai Lama’s commentary, to my knowledge it’s an unpublished commentary, or untranslated should I say in Tibetan.

So I’ve sourced the outlines and translated them. I really would encourage you to make it your habit to recite it in English once a day. It’s not long. And if you recite it thoughtfully, you think about the meaning, you will have covered the totality of the Sūtrayāna. And over the years, without making any particular effort, as you keep reciting it, you will have memorized it.

Then when difficulties arise in your lives, a passage will come up. This happens to me frequently now, it’s been many many years that I’ve been memorizing things in Tibetan and a stanza will come up. For instance, from generosity, prosperity and from ethics, happiness. I memorized this not quite forty years ago, thirty five years ago. And then it’s very very helpful, because in moments of difficulty in your life, you have this core advice which comes.

Then I’m working on the assumption that most of you do not meditate and probably will not meditate. Experience has told me that most students don’t meditate and when you ask them what they’re meditating upon, it turns out that what they’re doing is not even remotely connected to what we teach. So in that case, it is this simple advice which will be of benefit to your minds. Meditation is perhaps too advanced for most of our students, it just doesn’t happen.

I think many of our students are in the situation, Kamalaśīla describes beautifully in the Bhāvanākrama, where he says, to study one topic and to meditate on another is akin, and you who are Australian know everything about horse racing, I don’t, to taking a horse and walking it around one horse racetrack and then racing it on another. So I gather I don’t go to horse races, and I used to ride, but I’ve never raced horses. When you want to race a horse, you walk it around the track, I gather. In Tibet, that must have been the case. Here I gather too, that the horse knows the track, and then the horse is racing the track it knows.

Then if you study one thing, let’s say at TBI we study the path shared with the being of the small scope, and you meditate on something completely different, very advanced, perhaps rather pretentious, then what benefit there is is open to question, probably none. You’re wasting your time at TBI and you’re wasting your time meditating, because what you study you don’t meditate upon, and what you meditate upon you don’t understand. Now this is the root of Je Tsongkhapa’s critique of the situation in Tibet in his age, when Je Tsongkhapa says in the prologue to Lamrim Chenmo, nowadays, yogis do not know the fine points of scholarship and scholars do not practice. So Je Tsongkhapa’s entire life, if you wish, was dedicated to trying to bring study and practice together.

This is, if you wish, the very definition of the Geluk tradition, is the inseparable training in study and practice. As soon as you separate study from practice, you are out of the pool of Je Tsongkhapa’s thought, you are out of the pool of the Geluk tradition. If you start thinking that you don’t need to study because you have to practice or you need to practice because you have to study, you are already outside of the Geluk tradition. Well, this is very much the essence we have to focus upon. Then how one proceeds depends on the capacities of the person.

The Tibetans who have the capacities study twenty years and then practice. This is really how it is done in the monasteries. Then this is not possible for us. But the closest thing I would say, especially in 2017 is what we have at TBI. There’s only one or two centers in the world where we have a study program of this caliber, what’s going on on Tuesdays especially.

I don’t know of any center in history, in the history of the transmission of Buddhism to the West, in which the Cittamātra view has been presented in this way. And I have translated for you anew, the root text of Je Tsongkhapa, the commentary, and you have a new translation of Gyaltsab Rinpoche. To give you an idea, this would definitely be worth a PhD thesis in a leading US university, that’s the caliber of what we have been doing the last year. Then before that, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen covered sa lam, grounds and paths, for one year. Those of you who came regularly benefited tremendously.

We have one student here who has been steadfast over the years. I have known him ever since I came to Australia, and I would like to commend him today, that is Chris Ridley. Chris is a very humble person, he is not someone who is academically trained. I think you have studied with Lama Zopa Rinpoche for more than twenty years, haven’t you? How long has it been?

So it’s been since the nineteen eighties for sure. Right? So Chris has been here maybe thirty years, twenty five to thirty years. Then when I came the first time to Australia, Chris was there, I remember him in 2007. When I came to Australia in 2008 for the Yamāntaka teachings, Chris was there.

Then I was fortunate enough to translate these great teachings from Rinpoche, the great teachings Rinpoche gave, which is if you wish the pinnacle of the Geluk tradition, the very essence. I think you missed nothing. You got Vajrayoginī, you got Yamāntaka, you got Lama Chöpa, you got the six yogas of Naropa, Rinpoche’s teaching on calm abiding, you got what Rinpoche taught you was here. Then I’d like to shake your hand. Thank you.

So I think if you want to see an example of a good western student, it is Chris Ridley. Chris is not ordained, he’s a simple man, but Chris has lasted the course. And if you ask him, I think he would recognize there is benefit. So when I met Chris in 2008, I found it rather difficult to communicate with him. We would talk and I knew this was a very kind person, but what he was trying to say to me, by the time we got there, I was in a state of rather advanced exhaustion.

Now, Chris has one of the sharpest minds in this class. When Chris asks a question, it’s dead on. Then I don’t think that is a result of Chris’s work, it’s certainly not a result of age, that is a result of practice. Daily practice, attending teachings regularly. And Chris comes from a Christian background, very strong Christian background.

I think your father or your grandfather went to Tibet. Your grandfather’s cousin was a missionary in Tibet and met the thirteenth Dalai Lama. So you can see there’s a very strong karmic connection. Tried to convert him, which is very good. I’m sure the thirteenth Dalai Lama had a very soft spot for the Christians.

They all have had someone who bears my namesake, Ippolito Desideri. I always felt close to him, but our initials are the same, right? ID, right? So he was a Jesuit monk who went to study at Sera Je Monastery in the late seventeenth century. And believe it or not, he became a Geshe, so mister Geshe studies, was a direct support of the Dalai Lama’s.

He translated Lamrim Chenmo in Latin. And I’ve always I’ve never seen the copy. I know it’s extant at the Vatican Library. Can you imagine? Around fifteen nineteen sixteen ten, right, the time of the great fifth, a bit later, sixth of great fifth.

None except the name, but I always thought it was interesting, we had exactly the same initials. And I had a lot of admiration for him, a lot of admiration. So if you yourselves want to benefit from what is done here, the way forwards for yourselves is to settle down. At the beginning, it’s like when one’s a teenager, when one’s young one looks at a lot of things. Then the time comes to settle on a career, to settle on a partner, to settle maybe in a country, depending on what sort of family you come from.

You all know people who never settle down. Then you all know that it doesn’t end well, right? No real job, no real partner, no money later on in life, the end result is what? Nothing. So at the beginning, one has to be a teenager.

There’s a point where the time for being a teenager is over. You have to become adult. And that also means settling down with one teacher in one center. The fewer teachers you have, the fewer centers you go to, the better things will be for yourselves. Because if you have many teachers, you must rely on all your teachers in the same way, which is very difficult.

And if your teachers especially come from different traditions and you do not have a very powerful mind, you will suffer a lot because you will receive apparently contradictory teachings. As a result, Atisha who had himself 151 teachers, always recommended to have one. And I think for our Western students, if you are able, and I think very few of our students are able to do this, but if you are able to connect strongly with one teacher, the way Chris did for instance with Khensur Rinpoche, then there will be great benefit for yourselves. If you are not able to do so, then I’d say at the very least try to understand the teachings. You don’t have to become Buddhist.

His Holiness actually discourages the conversion of Westerners because broadly speaking, it doesn’t work. We have a rate of attrition of ninety percent among Western converts, right. Over ten years, the studies are from France, from Karma Ling, 90% of students who are coming in year one are no longer coming in year year 10. Then since you’re basically converting for this life with the hope of benefiting future lives, that means basically complete failure. Right?

There’s no other way to put it. So do not become Buddhist quickly. We have asked Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen to stop giving refuge casually. As you know, at TBI, we no longer give initiations, no Anutara Yoga tantra initiations, because experience shows that it is not possible for students to commit. The commitment is verbal, it’s not serious.

It’s a sad comment, but it’s the way it is, so one has to work with reality. And the metaphor I would give you is that of making a vase. So if you’re a vase maker, at the end of the day, the only question in your mind is given this material, can I make a vase or not? The type of vase differs. If you’re given gold, you can make a gold vase, which a hundred thousand years from now will still be inoxidizable and undamaged, gold does not oxidize as you know.

Then, if you don’t have gold and you have silver, you can still make a silver vase, it will oxidize but it’s precious. If you don’t have silver and you have iron, you can make an iron vase. It’s hard, it will oxidize fast, a thousand years from now there’s nothing left. And then, if you don’t have iron and all you have is clay, you can make a clay vase that lasts two, three years. It’s better than nothing.

It’s still a vase. But if you have sand, however hard you try, you cannot make a vase. And the gold vase is a being of the great scope, it is an eternal training. The silver vase is a being of the middling scope, aiming for his own liberation. It’s precious, but it oxidizes.

The iron vase is a being with a small scope. He’s aiming for a future life for himself, a good future life. It works. It’s still a vase. And the clay vase is, I think, the majority of our students who are here because of mental problems.

It also works, but it’s for two three years for this life. Many of our students don’t really believe in reincarnation, don’t believe in karma, then they just go through the motions, it’s something we see a lot. Then the sand vase is the person who is never a receptacle for the teachings. You pour water in sand, you all know, you go in the beach, what happens? It’s gone, right?

It’s as if you had never poured the water in the sand in the first place. So from your sides, at least be a vase, at least take the teachings on board. If you want it because you have mental difficulties, depression, whatever, I mean I’ve lost track of the new terminology for mental diseases, right? It keeps changing every two years. Okay, that’s not what it was taught for, it may not work that well but it still is of benefit.

But really it is the three metal vases, the iron, silver and gold vase, in other words, the path shared with the being of the small, middling and great scope, which the teachings are of benefit for. Like the teachings on karma and causality, frankly, if you don’t believe in past and future lives, you’re not gonna practice them, because there’s a cost for you in this life, right? And then if you don’t practice them, there’s no benefit, apart from wasting a Saturday afternoon, which I hope you’re not doing. So from your side, since what we have seen over the years, I’ve been almost ten years here, is that I actually I don’t know you. So when people come here, there’s a lot of spin control which goes on.

People present a certain aspect of themselves, their baggage is very well hidden, so we don’t know who we’re dealing with. But that makes no difference really because you’re here for your own sake. For your own sake, come if you’re gonna put some of this in practice. Don’t come because you have nothing else to do with your lives. And if that’s the case, I’m not very good at social aspect of things, but I can surely find people who can tell you nice places you can go to meet friends.

It’s not a social center here. If you want a social life, please, there are pubs, there are clubs, Greek clubs, French clubs, all the clubs you want. Right? Human life is short. At the end of the day, none of us in this room is terribly young anymore.

The time, as my late father used to say, is the most precious thing in the world because you cannot buy it. You cannot buy it. You can sell it. You can sell your time. You can sell your labor, but you cannot buy it.

So use your time wisely. And here now with the three principles of the path we have come to the core, if you wish, which is a presentation of the view. And I wasn’t quite sure whether we would be covering this together or not, because it is a difficult and advanced topic and the levels, let’s say, in a group like this are extremely divergent. We have students, I would say four students, well three students really, who are attending four actually with Mark, who are attending, Geshe-la’s Tuesday teachings regularly, so we can give a much more advanced presentation.

Five with Aniela, excuse me. Then we have some students who only come to the Wednesday teachings, and we have some students who come occasionally and some are new. So how do you present a topic such as emptiness to a group like this? Then there’s really only two approaches. The first approach is not to present it, which is probably the simplest approach.

It precludes a lot of misunderstandings. The second approach which I will use today is the scattergun approach. Hopefully, every one of you will get something. Then for the knowledgeable and experienced students like Chris or Mark, who has done very well this year, then the easy parts will be a bit boring. And then the advanced parts for the beginner students would be overwhelming.

But for the experienced students would be of interest. So hopefully at the end of the day each one of you will find some benefit. I’m really sorry we have problems with the usual problems with the screen. I’m just going to shut it down. It’s completely useless, basically, the system.

And we will work from the text since you all have the text in front of you, do you? So last time as you remember, we covered stanza six, the reason for which the view is necessary on page three. Since one who is not endowed with the wisdom realizing the mode of abiding, albeit having become accustomed to definite emergence and bodhicitta, will be unable to sever the root of existence, strive at means to realize interdependence. So here, this stanza explains the reason for which one has to generate the view. In other words, the reason for which selflessness or emptiness has to be studied.

However, I think we need a much vaster context as Westerners to make sense of this. Now, I have been personally in Buddhist studies for, I’m going on forty years now. I started at age 19, so thirty six years for sure. And I think one thing which has been clear over the years that most Westerners who are interested in emptiness approach the issue of the view as a philosophical challenge. Then, certainly when I was at university with Jeffrey Hopkins, this was the case.

My classmates, with one exception, were interested in emptiness purely from a philosophical standpoint. That is a fundamentally flawed perspective for a series of reasons, And we have to move back a little bit to understand why. Even in the Tibetan textbooks on tenets, and you have one listed in the bibliography which I translated of Jetsün Chögyi Gyaltsen, the way tenets are presented, the four systems of tenets Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, Cittamātra and Madhyamaka, is some sort of independent creation of scholars in India. So someone taught Vaibhāṣika, someone taught Sautrāntika, someone else let’s say Asaṇga taught Cittamātra and another group Nāgārjuna, Āryadeva, Buddhapālita and so forth taught Madhyamaka.

And each of these systems of thought and of the philosophy is presented. Now this is actually incorrect. This is not how things occurred. This presentation is largely due to the fact that Tibetans had pretty much lost contact with India by the time these treatises were composed. If we look at the genesis of the tenet systems in India, the genesis is canonical.

So apart from Chris, does anyone know what canonical means? It means canon or scriptural. In other words, the issue which arose was basically that the Buddhists in India were faced with a collection of sutras of the three turnings of the wheel of the law. The first turning of the wheel of the law, the second turning of the wheel of the law, and the third turning of the wheel of the law. And they had to make sense of apparently discordant statements in the various turnings of the wheel of the law, all uttered by Buddha.

So the first turning of the wheel of the law is broadly speaking what is now known as the Pāli Canon. It’s not a complete fit, but pretty much. Western scholars consider that the Pāli Canon and the Pāli Canon alone is historical, and therefore, if you study Western scholarship, you will find that the second and the third turnings of the wheel of the law are all considered to be later works, not in other words, not taught by Buddha, then the big open question is taught by whom, why, all that is left unanswered. But if you start delving by yourselves in Western scholarship, this is what you will encounter. Western scholars, in other words, adopt the viewpoint according to which what the Buddha historically taught is included in the first turning of the wheel of the law.

That doesn’t mean that everything included in the first turning of the wheel of the law is historical, but they would say that sutras like the Metta Sutta, the sūtra on love, or the Fire Sutta, or for that matter the Satipatthana sūtra, are historical and probably taught by Buddha. Now the way sutras were recorded is that initially they were memorized. The arhats memorized the sutras having developed the siddhi, if you wish, of photographic or absolute memory. And at a later council, it eventually became clear that this mode of transmission was becoming fragile, and the sutras were written down. And here we have in the Buddhist tradition a fundamental split between what we now know as Theravāda, in the old days they were known as propounder of Hīnayāna tenets, and the Mahāyāna.

Because Theravāda to this day considers the Mahāyāna Sutras as false. They do not consider that Sutras of the second turning of the wheel of the law, like the 8,000 verse perfection of wisdom sūtra, and Sutras of the third turning of the wheel of the law, like the Samdhinirmochana sūtra, were taught by Buddha Śākyamūni. Then, the proponents of the Mahāyāna consider all the Sutras of the Theravāda, the first turning of the wheel of the law, as true, as taught by Buddha, taught in Pāli what used to be known as Magadhi, the language of Magadha. So the question which arises is what is the status of these later sutras? These later sutras, according to all the Mahāyāna Buddhists, were hidden and rediscovered around the first century of our era by Nāgārjuna.

It is Nāgārjuna who rediscovered the perfection of wisdom sutras in what is known as land of the Nagas. Now the land of the Nagas, Tibetans believe, was actually a place ruled by Nagas, semi spiritual beings, the body of a serpent. I personally have long believed that it is in present day Assam, which to this day is called Nagaland. There are tribes called the Naga tribes, a very isolated part of India. It’s a part where these texts could have been hidden, when Mahāyāna progressively disappeared in India.

So this is referred to, for those of you who follow the Tuesday class, in Je Tsongkhapa’s commentary on mind only. When he says up to the time of Asaṇga, Madhyamaka only. And then if you read the great Korean commentary of Woncheok, you find that Woncheok has some very harsh words for the propounders of Hīnayāna tenets, harsher than I would use here. Basically, there was a doctrinal struggle. This doctrinal struggle is at the root of the appearance of the four schools of tenets.

Propounders of Hīnayāna tenets just had to make sense of the sutras of the first turning of the wheel of the law, in which Buddha basically taught, Buddha Śākyamūni taught that exterior phenomena are real, and that the person is an imputed existent. And this gave rise to two schools of tenets, the Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika school. The differences between these two schools of tenets are minor, and the core difference, and this again is not something you would understand if you study tenets, the core difference is hermeneutical, how the canon is interpreted. The Vaibhāṣikas, normally 17 schools of Vaibhāṣikas, depends how you count. The Vaibhāṣikas, you could say, are Buddhist fundamentalists.

Right? So they consider that everything the Buddha taught is literally true. And if the Buddha taught something in the first turning of the wheel of the law, as long as he actually taught it and it is not part of the development of the sūtra, this is literally true. Then on this base, they obviously exclude the Sutras of the second and the third turning of the wheel of the law saying, Buddha Śākyamūni never taught that the world was of nature of mind, as in the Lankavatara sūtra. He never taught that all phenomena lacked inherent existence as in the 8,000 verse perfection of wisdom sūtra.

Therefore, these works cannot be the work of the Buddha. This is Vaibhāṣika position. Sautrāntika develops Vaibhāṣika’s position a bit philosophically, and it was actually an influential school in Buddhist logic, but it is still the school for which the sutras of the first turning of the wheel of the law are canon, they are the word of Buddha, agama, we say in Sanskrit, and the latter sutras of the second and third turning of the wheel of the law are spurious. Now the two schools of the Mahāyāna, Cittamātra and Madhyamaka, arise as an attempt to make sense of what the Buddha teaches in the sutras of the second and the third turning of the wheel of the law. Nāgārjuna, who rediscovered the sutras of the second turning of the wheel of the law, the perfection of wisdom sutras, developed his entire philosophy, Madhyamaka, as an attempt to account for Buddha’s teachings in the 8,000 verse perfection of wisdom sūtra, as well as in all the other ones, the 100,000, 25,000, 20,000 verse perfection of wisdom sutras.

Asaṇga developed Cittamātra as an attempt to account for Buddha’s teachings in the third turning of the wheel of the law, specifically the so called Samdhinirmochana sūtra, as well as the sutras concerning Buddha nature, the Tathāgatagarbha Sutras. So you can see that the arrival of the tenet schools is rooted in canonical issues. Now this, generally speaking, does not go down very well with our Western students. Perhaps it’s one of the reasons it’s not presented by Tibetan masters, because faith is a very big problem for Westerners, and therefore it’s easier to broach Buddhism through philosophy and practice. But actually, if you look at the history of the arising of the tenet schools, the core issue for Nāgārjuna is how to make sense of what Buddha says in the Heart Sūtra, in the Vajracchedika sūtra, Vajra Cutter sūtra, the 8,000 verse sūtra and so forth.

Then you can see that underlying Nāgārjuna’s thought, underlying Madhyamaka is Nāgārjuna’s commitment as a Buddhist. This is completely absent in the understanding of Nāgārjuna among Western Buddhist scholars and philosophers, which is why I would discourage you from reading this material. Nāgārjuna is approached as a philosopher, his Buddhist commitment is secondary if not irrelevant. The fact that Nāgārjuna composed praises of the Buddha, like the Lokatitastava, is completely ignored, it’s an embarrassment. At best, at worst, those praises are somehow discounted and asserted to be spurious, the works of another Nāgārjuna, this is the specialty of Western Buddhist scholarship, which is to multiply the Nagarjunas and to multiply the Maitreyas, you have at least three Nagarjunas and four Chandrakirtis.

This is how it is handled. There’s no evidence there were three Nagarjunas and four Chandrakirtis. It’s a the French say, a bit of prestidigitation, right? So Nāgārjuna therefore is rooted in Buddhist practice in an attempt to account for the perfection of wisdom sutras and it is from this that Madhyamaka arises. And also, the goal of all of these practitioners in the schools of tenets was not to develop a philosophical system, but to gain liberation from cyclic existence.

And here it is very helpful, and for those of you who are not attending classes regularly, I apologize, we could enter into things in some depths, but it’s difficult to present emptiness otherwise. It’s very helpful to present the schools of tenets from the standpoint of basis path and result. And all the four schools of Buddhist tenets, the Hīnayāna schools of tenets and the Mahāyāna schools of tenets, assert the same basis, which is saṃsāra, cyclic existence. Then they assert the same paths even though the object of meditation emptiness is different. And they assert different results.

At the level of the basis, there is a fundamental problem for us, which is that the basis, which is cyclic existence of the nature of suffering, is not accepted by the majority of westerners. So I think in the case of our students in this center, but in all the other centers I have been at, the main cause of the suffering of people is an incredibly narrow mindset. So our students come with this astonishingly narrow mindset focused on this life, and within this life and a couple years within this life. And if everything goes wrong during those couple years, the student’s mind is deeply destabilized. If it stretches over time, the student’s mind is shattered.

Now how it is shattered depends on the actual nature of the person, but this is what has led to the explosion of Western psychiatry and all of the therapeutic techniques. But the core of the problem is not addressed. The core of the problem is that the moment you take distance, you have perspective, these problems dwindle. And there’s a lot of empirical evidence regarding this. For instance, there is a lot of evidence now that once one becomes aware of the suffering of others, in other words one trains in altruism, one’s own suffering decreases.

One’s own suffering as a mental experience decreases. The more one is self centered, the less one is aware of others, the greater the personal suffering. Now if this is the case when you spread your outlook among other beings, imagine what it would be like if you spread it through time, through the cycle of your lives. Imagine how you would contextualize, because that is what dharma provides. Imagine how you would contextualize your sufferings if instead of seeing them circumscribed in a period of two, three years, in a life lasting thirty five, forty, fifty years, you saw them as something which was a blip on the screen over thousands, 100 thousands, millions of lives.

Your outlook would change completely, right? This change in outlook is a transition from the path shared with a mundane being to the path shared with a being of the small scope. In other words, your focus spreads to future lives. This alone liberates you from suffering, from a great amount of suffering. Then an analysis of the nature of this cycle of lives is a difficult point.

A majority of Buddhists never are able to engage in this analysis. A majority of Buddhists, at least in non Western countries where life is harder than here, are quite able to see that this life is really not worth struggling for. This life is unsatisfactory. But their goal is a better future life. But when one understands that it is life after life after life that this pattern of suffering is going to be repeated, at that point the question arises whether this is unavoidable or not.

At that point, one is at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope. And the issue of how to avoid it arises. So at that point, one has a base, within the base path and result shared with all the four Buddhist schools of tenets, but shared also with all or almost all Indian schools of philosophy. That is saṃsāra. And the question which arises is what are the characteristics of saṃsāra?

Is saṃsāra something worth living in and working for or not? Then I will try to avoid the term saṃsāra because it is used in a very glib fashion in Western centers with very little understanding. One has to think very carefully, and I think for us, the most helpful works for this, and I have mentioned this many times at TBI, are the works of professor Ian Stevenson. It is when from your side you generate this real conviction that past and future lives actually do exist, this is reality, it is not what the Buddhists say, that you yourselves have had past and future lives, and I see from your body language that 30% of you are not convinced. It is when this happens that you start to ask yourself, is this worth it or not?

And that is the next step, that step Stevenson cannot help us with. Right? That step you have to analyze those lives in terms of the eight, the six and the three sufferings. Is it worth going through these sufferings again and again or not? Maybe, and this is perhaps true of the majority of the new age groups, maybe that overall reincarnation is a very pleasant state of affairs.

I have read to present my talks here many accounts of purported past life memories, and overall you get the sense that for the person recalling a past life, it’s very pleasant. They find it exciting and adventurous, and people tend to project a lot in the past. Everyone wants to have been the Lord of a Scottish castle, or I was always struck when I was young that everyone remembered a past life as Empress Nefertiti, then they can only have been one, right? So if that is the case and in your past life you were Nefertiti, in your future life you’ll be an imprint, then this is rather fun. There’s some bad moments but it’s rather fun.

If instead of that, what you’re dealing with in your human rebirth is endless drudgery as a peasant who is making at best enough to eat every day, and at worst a refugee somewhere in Africa, and in your non human rebirth, the suffering you experience is the appalling one of eating others alive and being eaten alive by others, which is what animal rebirths are about, then you might want to seek liberation from this. And here the question which arises is, is this possible or not? So all of these steps are steps we must cover personally. Each one of us in this room, if you choose to follow this path, has to cover this by yourselves. If you do, there will have been benefit to your coming here, if you don’t it would have been pointless.

How much conviction you generate depends on the material you draw upon. Westerners are not convinced by the lines of reasoning used by Tibetan scholars. It does not work. We can present the lines of reasoning of Dharmakīrti proving past lives. It is like throwing stones at a cloud.

Everyone stares at you blankly, it doesn’t register. But Stevenson’s research does, and you should study Stevenson’s research carefully. His books are still available. I would put it to you that your time spent studying Ian Stevenson’s research is much better spent than your time spent studying Lamrim, because most of us do not understand Lamrim. We are not at a level where Lamrim resonates.

It’s an intellectual construct. It does not hit you where it counts. Once you are convinced, and I think Stevenson’s research is a way to do it, and perhaps that of other scholars in the field, psychiatrists mainly who have regressed patients hypnotically, like Roger Woolger for instance. Once you are convinced that you truly have had past lives, and that there is no way to put a beginning to the number of past lives, the next question is, is this a good state of affairs or not? And then you have to really think carefully.

My telling you that it is not a good state of affairs is broadly speaking useless. It does not elicit conviction. And at this point, you are at the level of all of the great beings of ancient India, which asks the question, well, if we are aiming for moksha, in other words, liberation from cyclic existence, how? And it is this question that the Upanishads in Hinduism try to answer, that Jainism tries to answer, that Buddhism tries to answer. And you have to ask yourselves, which of these great spiritual traditions is the one which convinces you?

So you should not be here and we don’t want you to be here because Buddhism is a default option. We don’t want people like that. It’s become like that since the movies about Tibet and the Dalai Lama in the late nineteen eighties. His Holiness the Dalai Lama got the Nobel Peace Prize. We have this endless stream of people passing through Buddhist centers.

They never stay. It never seems to impact them. They leave after a year or two years, and we start all over again. So His Holiness has said the time has come to eliminate confusion. And it is precisely this type of confusion we’re talking about today.

So before I start talking about emptiness in the second hour, which will be much more technical, I feel it’s very important to set the foundation here. The base is cyclic existence and the cyclic existence which is of the nature of suffering. Then without that as a base, if you’re not convinced that that is your lot, there’s no reason to study emptiness and you shouldn’t be studying emptiness. And then the paths in the broadest sense of the term are not only Buddhist. As I mentioned, Hinduism says exactly the opposite of Buddhism.

Hinduism says that indeed, the Upanishads say indeed, saṃsāra is of the nature of suffering, we should strive to escape from saṃsāra, but escape from saṃsāra occurs through identifying your true self, your ātman, and understanding that your true self is one with God Brahman. And the Upanishads assert that the reason for which it is self evident that this is the path is because all of us are convinced that we have a self. I start talking and I start touching my chest here. The Upanishad says that the Ātman is actually within your heart, supposedly the size of a thumb, whatever that means. Then this is a strong argument.

The argument that we are naturally inclined to believe in a self, and this natural inclination is a sign that there is such a thing. But that the self we believe in, the Ātman we believe in, is too restricted a presentation of self. And because it is too restricted, when we understand it in its full sense, excuse me, as one with God, with the ultimate self, we gain liberation from suffering. So for yourselves, I would suggest that you read the Upanishads. They’re very well translated.

There are dozens of translations in English, latest by Patrick Olivelle. As Westerners, we have predispositions towards believing both in a god and in a soul. So this must be countered. And it cannot be countered by saying, this is not what the Geshe taught and I come to a Buddhist center and frankly it’s nice here, I don’t want to have to leave. I overheard conversations like this.

I overheard one lady saying to another, but after all I have nothing else, right. I’ve overheard this at TBI. So that’s not a very good reason to be here, right. A good reason to be here is that you are actually convinced of the basics of the Buddhist message. And this has to come from your side.

So read first Stevenson’s work, try to see whether you believe in reincarnation or not. You have to go far beyond belief, have to become a conviction for there to be any, certainly, practice in the Indian tradition of any type. Reflect carefully on the nature of cyclic existence, and then I would suggest that you read the works of the great Indian thinkers who are non-Buddhist. Not just the Upanishads, but for instance Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras, the Sutras on Yoga, Yoga Sutras of Patanjali. Look at the other explanations, you must be able to dismiss them.

If you find that actually you really are very attracted, like one of the students here recently to the idea of a God, this is not your place. You should not be here. And then once you have reached a point where you are unconvinced by the arguments, let’s say in the Upanishads and Patanjali’s yoga sutras about the existence of a self, and the fact that the path to liberation is a union of self, in other words Ātman with Brahman, then ask yourself is the Buddhist statement that the path to liberation is selflessness true or not? It is counterintuitive. Every living being is convinced that there is a self.

Insects are convinced of a self, dogs are convinced of a self. So the Buddhist statement is a very daring one. The standard of proof therefore must be very high. Now to the difference of the Upanishadic traditions, the Upanishadic traditions consider that the Vedas, the ancient scriptures of India, the four Vedas, are authoritative and derive much of their teachings on the Self, on Brahman from the Vedas. Buddha himself taught that in matters pertaining to liberation and enlightenment, it is only logic which is authoritative.

In a famous stanza, the Buddha says, bhikshus and scholars do not accept my words because I uttered them, test them as a goldsmith tests gold through rubbing, through cutting, and through burning. Now, this statement applies to three categories of phenomena. According to Buddhist philosophy, phenomena can be subdivided into manifest phenomena, hidden phenomena, and extremely hidden phenomena. Manifest phenomena are sense data, like for instance the color and the shape of this book. Hidden phenomena are what is accessible to logic, which means I would say, for instance, the pretty much totality of theoretical physics, let’s say, much of human relations.

Extremely hidden phenomena are the subtle details of karma and causality, which karmic deed will give rise to which result when. These are the three categories of phenomena. Now according to Buddhist logic, and this is implied in this stanza which I quoted, the first category of phenomena, manifest phenomena, must be ascertained by sense cognizers. So you ascertain sensory phenomena by the visual consciousness, the auditory consciousness, the olfactory consciousness, the gustatory and the tactile consciousness. They should not be ascertained, for instance, by logic.

The second category of phenomena, hidden phenomena, are called hidden because they cannot be accessed by the senses. They are ascertained by logic. In other words, by what we know as an inferential valid cognizer. The third category of phenomena, extremely hidden phenomena, can only be accessed by a particular form of logical inference which relies on the experience of a being, in this case the Buddha, who has omniscience and is able to see the causal relations between very subtle phenomena. Now what is important is that in Buddhist philosophy and in Buddhist practice, everything that is necessary to gain liberation and full enlightenment falls in the second category, is a hidden phenomenon accessible to logic.

In other words, to put it rather bluntly and excessively, for a Buddhist practitioner of sharp acumen, faith is unnecessary. Buddhism is not faith based. If your practice is faith based, it’s a reflection on your lack of abilities or your misunderstanding. Buddhism is based on study and on meditation on what one has studied. That does not mean that there is not throughout Asia, what Geshe-la very sarcastically called sociological Buddhism, which is in the Tibetan temples, people, very devotedly praying to the statue of the Buddha and in, I saw in Singapore in the Chinese temples, people clapping their hands together with sticks of incense.

And in my wife’s hometown, there was a temple to the Buddha dedicated to military promotion. So people go there to make offerings, to get promoted in the army. Then this is just ignorance. This has nothing to do with Dharma. This is sociological Buddhism.

Then if that’s what you’re interested in, I think you’re better off with Christianity. Right? Because that’s part of our tradition as Westerners. But if you are interested in pure Dharma, then pure Dharma hinges, and this is the crux of the Geluk tradition as I told you at the beginning on the combination of study and practice. That’s what there is.

Then I think we will take the tea break. Before the tea break, I’d like to ask you if you have any questions on what I’ve covered so far. Because we’ll be covering something very different in the second part. That’s an excellent question. Does anyone have an answer?

So my question was in the three principal aspects of the path, there’s a little outline given by His Holiness and there is no text that says this is the measure of having gained bodhicitta. There isn’t indeed, why would that be the case? Do you have an answer? I do have an answer but I just wanted to, thought it might not be right. The answer I thought was that he does give the measure of having generated definite emergence and perhaps that could be applied.

Yes. In other words, the measure for having generated uncontrived bodhicitta is implied in the previous verse which states on page two of your text. Section 4.3, if through such habituation longing for the marvels of cyclic existence does not arise for even an instant, and if the mind striving for complete liberation arises day and night, at that point definite emergence has been born. So here, what does this stanza say? Through habituation means through meditation.

So neither definite emergence nor bodhicitta arise spontaneously. It is through effort, through meditation. Once that happens, and here’s the criterion for definite emergence is the second verse. Longing for the marvels of cyclic existence does not arise for even an instant. That is what one is countering as opposed to longing for the marvels of this life, which would be countering the vanities of this life.

Right? For even one instant. And here in the third verse, if the mind striving for complete liberation arises day and night, this is a criterion for having generated uncontrived definite emergence. It indicates indirectly that this is a mind arisen from meditation. In other words, it indicates that this is a mind arisen from?

That’s what I wanted, I wouldn’t ask you, right? From what? If it’s a mind that isn’t from meditation, what type of meditation are we talking about? Yes. So this is the problem.

Do you see the problem? No, we need calm abiding to generate spontaneous renunciation. In other words, we need calm abiding to enter the path. So this means that calm abiding has to be generated before the smallest path of accumulation. Do you understand?

And if you’re going to say that’s not the case, then you have to define what a mind arisen from meditation, not which arises from calm abiding can be. Because what’s being said in the three principles of the path is that definite emergence is present in the dream state. Then uncontrived bodhicitta is present in the dream state. Now, there’s only certain types of mind which are powerful enough to inject motivations in the dream state. Ordinary meditation is not.

Especially not consistently. If you meditate on a topic, over time it may appear in your dreams from time to time. But what we’re talking about is a mind arisen from meditation which is powerful enough to inject these motivations continuously in the dream state. Has to be calm abiding. No doubt about it.

It means that in your dream you’re motivated by it. In your dream you have renunciation. In your dream you have bodhicitta. If you want a very, very basic criterion for having definite emergence or bodhicitta, that’s it. Right?

Because always I said, a good monk in his dreams is a monk. That means in your dreams you wear robes. It’s interiorized. Right? Then we will take a break at present, and then after the break, I’m afraid we have to get a bit technical.

Key terms in this teaching

atman dag (Tib)
Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
nagas lu (Tib)
A snake-like being of the animal realm that lives in or near bodies of water; commonly associated with fertility of the land, but can also function as a protector of religion. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top