1 h 34 min · 10,834 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a Lam Rim teaching on meditating on death and impermanence, covering the three roots: death is certain, its time is uncertain, and only Dharma helps at death. It then turns to the uncertainty of death, the futility of worldly preparations, and the lower realms as the next rebirth, describing the hot, surrounding and cold hells as a basis for developing renunciation.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 35m
UUID: 0f542a55-35e9-414e-9147-599f985bb045
Words: 10,830
So is the motivation of attaining the pureness in an equal enlightenment for the sake of all suffering mother sentient beings? With his vast motivation, the uncommon motivation, we endeavor to attain the vast state of Buddhahood, the vast grounds of Buddhahood. Thanks to the kind teachings of Gorge, Atisha, Je Tsongkhapa, and all their successors. A path which fuses non erroneously, sutra and tantra. Is going through the entire outline of the text.
Have studied until now. Certificate and tradition just to memorize the outline of the text, what is going to study. We’ll start reading the outline in English. The greatness of the given to show the teachings as an immaculate source. Atisha was born in one of the highest families, how he attained his good qualities in that very rebirth, the things he did to further the doctrine after teach teach gaining these qualities, how he did this in India, how he did this in Tibet, the greatness of the dharma given to increase one’s respect for the instructions, the greatness of allowing you to realize that all the teachings are are consistent, the greatness of allowing all the scriptures to present themselves to you as instructions, the greatness of allowing you to easily discover the true thinking of the victorious ones, the greatness of allowing you to save yourself from the worst misdeeds.
Now the numeral is complete, but it contains all the subject matter of sūtra and tantra. It is easy to put into practice because it emphasizes steps for the Now we have to skip directly to the meditation on death. This has three roots. The first root is that death is certain. The second is that the time of death is uncertain.
The third is that at the time of death, the only thing of benefit will be dharma. So these are called the three roots because they’re the three foundations of this meditation practice. So concern number two says, really, we have to recollect impermanence. And emphasized this. So if we do not recollect that all phenomena which are created are impermanent.
We’ve been in the danger of wasting our precious human rebirth and of apprehending composite phenomena as permanent. On this basis, we would accumulate many non virtuous deeds, and this problem then arises. So has a purpose of dharma. Relies on the realization that the affairs of this life are meaningless. On that basis, then we will not accumulate non virtuous deeds.
To meditate on impermanence and on the fact that this life is short, then we will practice the true dharma. We’ll practice dharma authentically. Whereas with the motivation which really thinks of this life, then nothing good can arise from that. So meditation on death and no permanence is therefore extraordinarily important. So we must meditate on death using the three roots and the nine subsidiary reasons for these three roots.
So the first reason is thinking about the inevitability of death. The first reason is that the Lord of death will inevitably come in no circumstance at all can prevent this. The second, thinking nothing is being added to our eyespan, and it’s always being subtracted from. The third reason, thinking about how we will definitely die before getting around to practicing dharma. So this is the root which ascertains the definiteness of dying.
The second root, thinking about the uncertainty of when we will die, this is where we stopped yesterday. So returning to the text, Geshe-la is giving the transmission of the second root. There are three reasons for the fact that the time of death is uncertain. The first reason, the lifespan of speaking for the Southern Continent is not fixed, and this is especially short lifespans during these degenerate times. And if you could be certain when you will die, you would first carry out your worldly works, subduing your enemies, protecting your dear ones, and so forth.
Then while living in happiness, you could practice dharma. But you cannot be so certain, so it is vital to think about the uncertainty of when you will die. The treasure of metaphysics says the inhabitants of Kur live a thousand years. On ‘2 of the other continents, their lives decreased by half and half again. In other words, on most of the other continents of life hence of the inhabitants are not are fixed.
Here, the lifespan is not fixed. At first, it’s immeasurable and ends up being ten years. It is said that in the beginning, the inhabitants of the Southern Continent had lifespans so long that they could not be measured in years if they live their lives to the last ten years. But in general, the lifespans of the inhabitants of the Southern Continent are not fixed, and this is especially true during degenerate times. Generally, we don’t think I will never die.
But until we are dying, we always have the thought I will die, but not this year. There may be reasons for feeling this way. Some of you may think, I will not die yet because I am young, but being young is of no help. The order in which death strikes is not according to age. Children frequently die young, and their parents have to bury them.
Also, many people younger than you have already died. Some even die as soon as they are born. Some think I will not die because I am not ill. Even this is not definite. Patients may be confined to their beds, and you can die for many healthy people die certain deaths.
Yeah. Some people die in the middle of a meal that ever in hand has started as premonition, that they would die before they had finished eating. Some people present at large ceremonies went to the temple on their own two feet only to be carried out as corpses on a stretcher. Many governments, officials, draw up grand political programs but never get round to carrying them out because they died before completing their work. In many holy beings collected works, the notation left unfinished appears.
They were able to compose only the title along with some fragments of verses and died before finishing. From among the relatives and friends who’s run us in our valley, we can say that so and so has died, but we do not think this has also happened to me. We treat it merely as an object of curiosity. We even hear people say, he has a nice saffron robe. I hope I get it next.
Death will definitely strike you down in the future, though when it is uncertain. As they say, there is no telling which will come first, tomorrow or your next rebirth. Do not put effort into tomorrow’s plans. It is right to work hard for your next life. From the collected sayings of the Buddha, some of the many people you see in the morning, you will not see in the evening.
Some of the many people you see in the evening, you will not see in the morning. How can you be sure that you will not die tomorrow? We make no preparations for death we are sure to experience, but whose time of coming is uncertain. It is not certain that we live to an old age. Remember that it is definitely a mistake to make a lot of preparations for an enjoyable old age.
Conservative Achieve says reaching this decision that we are certain to die and that its time is uncertain is very powerful for us. If you cannot return with a text, if you cannot better think about death coming today, tomorrow, the next day, at least you must think about how death can strike anyone between now and next year. You cannot be certain which of the people sitting here will die first. Someone sitting in the front row, in the middle, or at the back. You will not get a message warning you, not prepared to die.
Death will strike totally one day, and you will just have to leave whatever you were doing. Even simple monks have to stop drinking butter tea, eating body flour noodles, and go to their next life. This shows how uncertain the time of death is. Grasping at permanence makes you think you have many years left, but the day will come when you will die. People who die from ministers today are still thinking, I will not die today.
Someone they reach in this astrologically unfavorable year might remember death and wonder, will I die this year? But even if you have no such here, There is no year from your first few hundredth where you can say, I will not die this year. Suppose you were 28, you must think I may die this year. So when so and such died at this age, we might say, I swear that I will definitely not die this year, but we cannot make such a note. We are not only that, we might get led astray when we live in big towns and communities.
Death and impermanence are therefore practical subjects for meditation because they are not difficult to understand like selflessness. They are things we can see for ourselves. They are tangible. My own precious guru, my refuge and protector said, if you don’t die in a month or two, I pray that you may achieve some benefit for your next rebirth. If you don’t die in a year or two, may you achieve your eternal hope for your rebirth.
You must think this section over the way you have taught it quotations and all. The second reason when you will die is uncertain because there are many factors contribute to your death in the future of your life. So Gampopa says there is absolutely no certainty regarding the time of our death. Between the text, we are protected by our past prayers, merits, and the Buddha’s compassion. There are many contributory factors towards our deaths, like flies buzzing around rotten meat.
80,000 different types of hindering spirits surround us while we are alive, and they will be contributory factors towards our deaths. Wonder where can we eat you. When can we take your breath from you? The 404 types of disease swarm around us like a mist. The 360 types of evil spirits, the 15 great evil spirits who attack children, the 360 devouring spirits and so forth are greedy for our lives.
You do not have these external contributory factors. If you put four snakes into a container, the strongest snake will eat the rest. If the humours, which are wind, bile, and the four elements, a little out of balance, this can be a contributory factor towards losing your life. Many factors contribute to your death. Very few contribute to your life, and even these may contribute to your death.
Therefore, practice dharma. Not only are there many internal and external contributing factors to death, but many of the factors contributing to life may also contribute to death. Houses can collapse. Boats can break up or overturn. Houses can buck and trample you.
Your friends can trick you. Food can disagree with you, and so on. Many things can act as contributing factors towards death. Our like force is like the red hot gas in the flame of an oil lamp. As Nāgārjuna says, the lord of death resides within circumstances like the red hot gas in the flame of an oil lamp.
The third reason when you will die is uncertain because the body is quite insignificant. If our bodies were firm and hard wearing, they would not be damaged despite the many things contributing towards death. But our bodies, like bubbles and water, we do not measure contributing factors in order to die. We can die merely from being killed by a thorn. Anyway, even if our bodies were firm and hard wearing, it wouldn’t help.
Like, Nāgārjuna’s letter says, it is truly amazing that we wake up inhaling and exhaling after we have gone to sleep. In other words, when you go to sleep, your coarse breathing is suppressed, the subtle wind element can move freely in your nostrils. How amazing that you do not die when you resume your breathing of the coarse wind element. Think about this. When you will die is uncertain, then you should feel that you must practice Dharma now.
This is like being certain that an enemy is coming to tell you, but not knowing when. From that day on, you will try to stop him. If you want to practice a dharma, instead of someone that will last this year, the next, and you think, I will practice dharma after I finish the work, you are deceiving yourself. Said, it seems this work would only take a month or a year when it’s finished. I would practice pure dharma.
This sort of destructive evil spirit that tricks everybody. We feel I will practice dharma after I finish this or this or that project, but unfinished work is like the old man’s whiskers. The more it is cut, the more it grows. In other words, you never get around to your practice. When a project finishes, instead another project comes, and so you hold your practice over until that is finished.
Then there will be another, and you will think, I’ll delay my practice till this is done. Worldly work is like a river, it never stops. As Gungtangpa said, the great risk is before the tomorrow when you are going to practice dharma comes, the time for you to die will come today. So do not let your head be turned. If you would practice dharma, do it from today.
If you put things off and say, when this is finished, will practice dharma. I will practice dharma tomorrow. The work will never finish, but your time of death will surely come. Think of the three reasons why it is uncertain when you will die, and right away, you will abandon worldly work and decide to waste no time in practicing dharma. But there is no need for students in monasteries to interrupt their studies or group debating practice and go after some mountain cave.
Instead, you must convert what you are doing into dharma. Suppose you only recite the words of text, you may have recited the verse until enlightenment. I take refuge in Buddhadharma and the supreme assembly thousands of times, but check if you have properly thought over the verse even once. You will see that you have rarely done so. No matter what effort you put into business, farming, and so forth, they will never turn into dharma.
But those of us who are ordained must convert what we do into dharma. It’s a pity if we don’t normally practice dharma. It’s no pity if we merely do not know the facts. Returning to the text, think of how nothing can help you when you die except Dharma, the first reason wealth cannot help you. You may be like Brahma Indra, a universal emperor, but when you die, you will not take a single servant with you.
You will not be free to take even a single possession with you. These are of no help at such a time. You may be the most powerful king really every country, but when death comes, you will not be able to take even a grain of barley with you. You will be indistinguishable from a beggar. You will not be allowed even a walking stick.
The king will leave behind his trappings. The beggar will leave behind his stick. The living tree sūtra says, one may have enough food for a hundred years, but after death one goes hungry. One may have enough clothes for a hundred years, but after death one goes naked. From the bodies of Acharya Vattara, I must lose all my things, yet I do not understand this and commit various sins, for my dear ones and those not dear to me.
When born, you are born alone. When you die, you are just as alone. What can your meddlesome friends do if they won’t take on another share of suffering? A man once carved a great rock into a cube. Another person asked him what he was going to do with it.
Oh, nothing, he replied. I’m just going to leave it behind. So too will you leave behind all the wealth and all the positions you have acquired in this rebirth. The second reason, friends and relatives cannot help you. A dying man may be surrounded by servants, disciples, and his most intimate friends, some of them holding his arms and some holding his legs, but they cannot help him.
He cannot take a single one of them with him. He will travel the perilous road of the bardo alone. My dear Kye, great Anup said, your majesty, no matter how wealthy you may be, when you depart and go to another rebirth into the world, you will be like a man attacked by enemies in a desert, alone without your son or your concubines. From Engaging in the Deeds of Bodhisattvas, Bodhisattva. When you are caught by Yama’s messengers, what help are your dear ones? What help are your friends?
The Pänchen Lama, Lobsang Yeshe, said you will be forever separated from your loving, mourning dear ones. Some people are sure to die in the middle of the coming winter. Then how many of their plans for next year will they carry out? If we were now going to India, China or somewhere else, we are treated as something most important. We’ll prepare our luggage and travel with horses, mules, and servants.
But when we make the great move to our next rebirth, we’ll be without friends, alone, and unable to take even one of our possessions. The third reason, even your body cannot help you. When your diet will be of no help before the mountains turn to golden or become your dear ones. Quite apart from your wealth, possessions, and relatives, you will have to leave behind your body, the thing you call my body that was born from the womb with you that put you protected from hunger and cold, that you wouldn’t even prick with a thorn, that you guarded and cherished like a wish granting gem. As the Panchen Lama, Chekki Gelsen said, this body you so cherished and protected will prove deceptive when you most need it.
In other words, think about how you will be completely separated from this body that you have cherished and protected. Having thought over these three reasons does not have to stay afraid and depressed. As said, dharma is your guide to the undeceiving path. Dharma supplies you for the long trek. Dharma is your captain on the difficult journey.
From this moment, practice dharma with your three doors. Listen, lady of wealth. You have faith. Have you enough supplies for the long road to future lives after this one? If you don’t have enough, practice generosity.
That’ll be your supply. Have you enough companions to face the great terrorists and futurize after this one? If you don’t have enough practice divine dharma, that’ll be your companion. In other words, dharma is your guide, captain, and provisions for your journey when you die. If you have not practiced dharma, your death will be no different from that of an old stray dog in Somali.
This is a much better way to think. People going to visit their homeland do not make preparations for staying where they already are. They put all their energies into packages, baggage, and nothing else. You too must also decide to practice a dharma only, something untarnished by the obscurations of this life. Meditation on the aspect of death, which is the second way to meditate on death.
This is an instruction from my precious guru. Although it mainly centers on how to pursue meditation, a practical teaching, it is said to be as good to be good to contemplate in this way. You should recall the things said in either the text, compassionate refuge, the Pänchen Lama, of Losang Yeshe’s petitions made to be freed from the perilous road of the battle. Examine just what will happen when you die, then when you are approaching death, as it says in the Pänchen Lama’s petitions for the bardo. When the doctor gives me up, when ritual is no longer work, when friends have given up hope for my life, when anything I do is futile, may I be blessed to remember my guru’s instructions.
So considering that he’s giving the oral transmission of the passage we just read, and he says, the preparations we make for this life are fundamentally meaningless. So can see what she says. And so far as the time of death is completely uncertain, we must make the resolution to practice dharma now. It’s a concern that you’re still giving zero transmission. We’re at the third route.
And the first reason of the third route, that wealth is of no help at the time of death. So, Gampopa says, in this reason, we must reflect on the fact that our relatives cannot go down to the lower realms with us to accompany us, so we’ll be completely alone in that journey. Second thing, Geshe-la says, really, we should reflect on the fact that in the next life, we will go to the next life alone without, as a Tibetan text says, being able to take even one hair with us. Because which is now giving the trans oral transmission of the third reason of the third root, which is that at the time of death, even a preciously protected and cherished body will be of no benefit. Benefit.
So consider yourself. So let us think of the fact that we will be without a home, completely homeless, and we’ll have to abandon our bodies. The time of our death is normal practice, and this is what we have to be aware of. So, Geshe-la says we must therefore resolve to practice meditation and death as a motivation for our practice. We’ve now reached the second outline, which is meditation on the aspects of death, which we have already read.
The text, Examine just what will happen when you die, then when you are approaching death, as it says in the Pänchen Lama’s petition for the bardo, when the doctor gives me up, when rituals no longer work, when friends had given up hope for my life, when anything I do is futile, may I be blessed to remember my guru’s instructions? In other words, the illness gets worse despite proper medical treatment or rituals, the things the doctor tells you and other things he’s telling everyone else. Your relatives and friends tell you only nice things, but get together in secret behind your back and agree that you will die. You display very various nasty internal and external symptoms. Your body heat dissipates.
Your breathing is labored, your nose become constricted, your lips are contorted, your complexion is pallid, and so forth. You regret your past misdeeds, but you have not sufficiently purified them or refrained from repeating them or practiced in a virtue. Your fatal illness causes you suffering, and the signs of the progressive dissolution of the elements appear to you. You have various terrifying hallucinations that prevent the visual aspects of your present life from appearing to you. Your aggregates are rolled up in a blanket, put in a corner of your room and hidden behind a curtain.
People like to cheap butter lamp for you. If you’re a lama, they will dress you in your initiation costume to make you look presentable. Returning to the text, at present, you may work hard to have a good house of warm soft clothes and carpets. But when you die, your body will be folded up into three sections, trussed up with a leather leather slit strap, left under bare earth or rocks and so forth. At present, you may enjoy the most delicious food, but in the future, you will have to live on the smell of burnt offerings made for the dead.
At present, you may be called such things as geshe, sir, or venerable monk. In the future, a time will come when your body will be called corpse, and you will be called the late mister so and so. Whenever your lamas see your in whenever you lamas see your initiation costume, it should remind you that when you die, your remains will be decked out in it. When we see our blanket, it should remind us that our corpse would be wrapped in it. This is how much remembrance we need.
Jemila Repa said the teraphan name of corpse would be given to the yogi’s body. This also applies to your body. You’ll be unimaginably frightened. I would have hallucinations of dust storms and firestorms, of being buried under avalanches or mounds of earth, of being surrounded by whirling fire of being swept away by water or winds and so forth. Some lamas claim to give dead people’s consciousnesses a sound introduction to the bardo and perform the introduction ritual next to the corpse’s head.
Yet the time to give a true introduction to the bardo is now. It is more beneficial to do this before one dies. We can always be sure of enjoying food and drink, but this will not happen when we are dying and have to say, Help me sit up. How certain that we will not practice dharma at such a time. Geshe-la says these introductions to the bardo.
are really only of use to us now. Returning to the text, how certain that we will not practice dharma at such a time since we do not even practice now that we are alive and well. All the same, these rituals of introduce introducing the corpse consciousness to the Bardo may be slightly helpful because the blessings of the Buddha are inconceivable. Returning to the text, a source of the meditation on the aspects of death engaging in the deeds of the bodhisattva, the bodhisattva, bodhisattva. Go into the charnel grounds, it will prove that other people’s skeletons in your own body are perishable things.
In the future, you will keep a more level head. When someone dies and his bones are scattered in a charnel ground, consider that his bones are no different from your own. You’ll be more level headed in the future. The corpses in the charnel ground were originally like your body. Human beings used to cherish them.
The great adepts of India used to hold human thigh bones or skulls. They did not do this because they wanted to look terrifying or threatening. It was to increase their awareness of aspects of death. Even this skull cup was once a person’s head. He so cherishes here that even if his fingernails scratch it, he would say, ouch.
If you’re an ordinary monk, we’ll leave your monk’s cell empty when you die, and someone else will move in, saying, oh, he died a number of days ago, and I got the room. Someone else will wear your saffron robes and say, they used to be so and so’s. I bought them. Likewise, a time will definitely come when other people who at the moment cannot use your furniture, clothes, and so forth will buy them and use them. This is why the seventh Dalai Lama, Kelzang Gyatso, said, in time, I will lose even these possessions.
I’m glad to have borrowed such gems. In other words, they are things on loan to you for just a short time. If you cannot bring yourself to think about your own death, go and witness someone else dying. It is impossible that you would not recall this instruction at such a time. We do not think about this.
Yet why do we get frightened when we see a rope and mistake it for a snake? This is amount of fear we need to have. We may die before we wear out one saffron robe, for instance. Think about it. Our lives are extremely short.
These things are discussed in the instructions given to the King sūtra. The Great Lamrim discusses how meditation on impermanence can be an antidote to getting fat at a time when you have access to magnificent clothes, food, and so forth. Whenever you see your possessions, that is your clothes and so forth, always thinks, these are only masquerading as my things. There will come a time when other people will divide them up among themselves, and I don’t doubt they will say they belong to the dead person. I now cherish my body and look after it, but a time will come when it will turn into what is called a corpse.
If I were to see it then, I would be terrified. I would be nauseated if I touched it. It will be tied with a rope, they will do all manner of things to fit to it. Think how your leftover barley flour will be used in offerings, how the rituals of introduction to the bardo will be performed next to your head, and so forth. Some other person will handle your skull saying, this is his skull.
The quality is not too bad. Such a time is coming, and from now on, you ought to do things you will not regret regret. The criterion for having developed realization into death and impermanence in your mind stream is if you want to be like Geshe Khamlungpa. Then review this material in moderate detail. Second thing, there is no oral instruction apart from this direct meditation on the aspect of death.
If we don’t prepare for meditating on our death, As Amherjee says, the situation of having no youth, no old age, no happiness, and vast suffering. And then it’s over. So because it’s extremely important, let us meditate on this carefully. Returning to the text, we have reached the eleventh day. The Lolita Vistara Sutras is the three realms are as impermanent as autumn clouds.
Being die and are reborn. It is like watching a play. Being’s lives are as brief as a lightning flash in the sky or rush on like high mountain waterfalls. In other words, the three realms, the earth, Mount Meru, and all are like autumn clouds. Beings are born and die.
It is like watching a play for the characters can change from moment to moment. Our lives do not last long. They are mere flashes of lightning. They undergo cessation from instant to instant, are not stationary and rush by like high mountain waterfalls. You should therefore think I will practice Dharma immediately.
The Lamrim is the best gateway to the one path followed by all Buddhas of the three times. You should therefore attend this discourse on the Lamrim so as achieve Buddhahood for the sake of all sentient beings, then you must put it into practice. Related the restated the headings already covered and reviewed yesterday’s material. The section developing a yearning for a good rebirth has a second subdivision. Thinking about what sort of happiness or suffering you will have in your next rebirth and either of the two types of migration.
The contemplation on the suffering of the upper realms will come later in the medium scope. I would now discuss discuss the suffering of the lower realms. You will surely die, but it is not certain when. After you die, your consciousness does not end. It must definitely take rebirth.
There are only two places in which you can tend rebirth, the upper or the lower realms. You can assess inferentially to which of these two you will be going. As I have already said, we get divinations and horoscopes made to tell us where we will be reborn next, but these are unnecessary. Buddha has already predicted that we’ll go to the upper realms if we have been virtuous and to the lower realms if non virtuous. From the Jātaka tales, be quite certain your next rebirth into the world will be happy or unhappy.
We make many plans for this life, which we call thinking about the future. Says, look at it simply. We are composed of two parts, body and mind. Forget about the body. The body we will leave behind, but the mind will continue.
Where where the mind goes will depend exclusively on virtue and non virtue accumulated in our lives. So think carefully. Which of the two sides have you privileged? Have you accumulated more virtues, or have you accumulated more non virtue? And then it will be very clear whether we go to the higher realms or the lower realms.
So therefore, we should analyze this carefully. So the full maggot we leave behind, but the mind goes on. And the road the mind follows depends on the karmic imprints of virtue and non virtue. So when the coarse minds, which are minds which are contaminated by virtue, non virtue, travel on to the future lives. It is contingent on whether virtue has been mainly accumulated or non virtue has been mainly accumulated as to whether they go to the higher or the lower realms.
So there is really no practice apart from this practice of cause and effect. So there’s really nothing nothing else to practice apart from that, whether we are monks or lay benefactors. So understand clearly how karma functions. The non virtuous karma, the virtuous karma, neutral karma. This is what we practice.
Returning to the text, we make many plans for this life, which we call thinking about the future. It is nothing of the sort. Be even more farsighted. Investigate where you will be reborn next. If you do so, you will see that you cannot escape going to either the upper or the lower realms.
Because the number says there is no third alternative, and that you are not free to choose which of them to go to. If we had a choice, who would still be in the lower realms now? That’s where you are now reborn where you’re reborn next depends on Karma. If you have a mixture of karma, The concept of which is before there really only two paths. The path of virtue, which relies on virtuous karma, and the path of non virtue, which relies on virtuous karma.
Carefully, but keep in mind that the vast majority of sentient beings live in the lower realms. Do you really believe that if they had a choice, they would choose to stay in the lower realms and would not choose to come to the higher realms? They are through forces they do not control. Returning to the text, if you have a mixture of karma, some virtuous, some non virtuous, the stronger will ripen first. If both types are equally strong, the one you are most familiar with will ripen first.
If you are equally familiar with both types, the type produced earlier will ripen first. So Ken Sonobuchi says it is in that last case, the karma which is produced earliest, which ripens first. Vasubandhu’s own commentary, his auto-commentary to his Abhidharmakośa says, karma turns the period of life, the heaviest karma ripens first, then the nearest, then the most familiar, then the karmic actions done first. So if we analyze our thoughts conservatively, it says we will find that the vast majority of them are contaminated by the afflictions, by the delusions, such as anger, pride, ignorance, etcetera. Returning to the text.
For us, non virtuous karma is a strong of the two. Our thoughts are normally only of attachment and so forth. That being so, all common produced from these thoughts is non virtuous. Even our virtuous deeds inadvertently come under the power of non virtuous thoughts, and very few of these actions dedicated towards our future lives. Take the example of your scolding a disciple.
Your motive is extreme anger. So as the actual deed, you use words that will hurt the other’s person’s feelings As it depends, will hit the mark. As the final step, you rejoice over what you have done. Motive, the actual deed, and the final step are all very powerful. On the other hand, when it comes to virtuous states, if the motivation is there, the deed is not completed.
If the deed is completed, the motivation was not virtuous to start with. We never have a complete deed. Returning the text, the majority of our sinful actions are simply most powerful, but our virtuous actions are as follows. There was once a man who used to be distracted by other thoughts whenever he recited the hundreds of gods of Tuśita, the Gandhavyuha. He would hold conversations with other people while reciting the text many times from start to finish.
We also mouth the words of texts. But meanwhile, our minds are engrossed in worldly matters. But little virtue we have is destroyed by anger or wrong views. Even our smallest known virtues double in size every day. Further in past lives, when we’re born as insects, insects, creatures, sea monsters, beasts of prey, and so forth, we committed many enormous sins.
These, in addition to the above mentioned sins we have committed in this life, constitute a vast number of very powerful non-virtuous deeds we have accumulated. We are not capable of remedying all these before our deaths by purifying them and by refraining from repeating them. We know this is beyond our present capabilities. This proves by direct valid cognition that we are more familiar with non virtue than with virtue. The only possibility that we shall go to the lower realms in our next rebirth.
We cannot be confident of not going to the lower realms until we have achieved the forbearance level of the path of preparation. They say that even the Mahatma, Bodhisattvas have been reborn in the lower realms. Suppose you go to sleep tonight as a monk in your nice room on your soft bed. You then die because of some sudden unfortunate occurrence. By the time you would normally have awakened the next morning, you may already have arrived at a place where all the hills and valleys are filled with fire.
What would you do then? Returning to the text, you would not be sufficiently moved to develop renunciation if you now simply meditate on how you may be born in the lower realms in the same way that you would be watching a show. As Nagajuna said, we collect the great heat or cold of the hells as if you had spent a day there. That is, you should meditate to produce insight into being born in this or that lower realm. This is rather like the generation stage meditation on.
You must become afraid. We hold in high regard those meditations and having the divine body of a tutelary deity, but it will be much more beneficial in the beginning to meditate for a while on having a hell body. The suffering of the hot hells will facilitate our first mental transformation and will produce our first development of renunciation. This is a wholesome result. We will also become sad.
Sadness has great qualities. It gets rid of arrogant pride and so forth. So you can see what Geshe-la says. This is precisely what we don’t want to meditate upon, isn’t it? And yet there is nothing more beneficial than others.
Said, the good quality of suffering is that it removes arrogance through suffering. One develops compassion for the beings in saṃsāra, avoids sin, and rejoices in virtue. It is easier for us to develop renunciation with this option of rebirth as human being. For the screen, we will meditate on suffering. The meditation on the suffering of the lower realms has three sections.
Thinking about the sufferings of the hellers, the hungry ghosts, the animals. First, thinking about the suffering of the hellers. This has four subheadings. Thinking of the sufferings of the great or heart hellers. The heart hells are located as follows.
The hell of continual resurrection is 32,000 yojanas under Bodhgaya in India. The other hot hells are below this hell with 4,000 yojanas between them. All the ground and all the mountains in these hells are composed entirely of red hot iron. The ground, like that in the human realms, is not at all flat, not at all like the palm of your hand. When you’re about to be born into the hot hells, what can you do?
As Gungtangpa said, human life is impermanent. A short bark of sleep crowded with meaningless dreams, some happy, some sad. When you suddenly awake to life in the lower realms, what will you do? And so he says this life is really like a dream. And then suddenly, the dream of the Bardo has started.
Returning to the text that is at the point of death, you have hallucinations of being cold, so you develop a craving for heat, which activates karma leading to rebirth in the hot hells. You die. This is like falling asleep. You experience a as you would have dreamed. So Gampopa says, the moment within our minds, desire aversion arises with respect, for instance, to cold, then we activate karma leading to one of these specific hams.
But then if we have cold and we want to be warm, we desire heat, and this activates another type of karma. You die. This is like falling asleep. You experience the battle as you would have dreamed. Then you suddenly find yourself in the hot hell, so just like waking up.
Hellfire is seven times hotter than fire in the human realms. Let us compare these two types of fire. Human fire is so cold compared to hellfire, it is like water cooled by wood. Someone once carried a small ember from the hells to the human realms and placed it on the ocean shore. All human beings were driven mad by the heat, and they could not bear to have it where it was.
If you’re born in the midst of such fire, it would present no problem if your body was small and it will merely be consumed by the fire. But your body is huge, as large as the mountain range. Geshe-la says, what we call a fire is not hot at all compared to what beings experience down there. Returning to the text, This would still be no problem if the soles of your feet was calloused as the skin on the feet of some of us. Actually, it’s a bit of a misreading of the Tibetan.
The Tibetan says, it’d be no problem if your skin was as calloused as the skin on the feet of some of us. This doesn’t happen. Your body is like the body of a baby at its mother’s breast. So the sufferings of the hot hells in general are quite unbearable. The suffering of having a body, the thing being burned, that is enormous.
The suffering of having flesh with as little tolerance to pain as a newborn child’s. The suffering that the thing during the burning, the fire, it’s extremely hot and so on. There are eight such hot hells. First, the hell of continual resurrection. There are no hell gods here.
People born in this hell are sentient beings who have taken rebirth here under the power of evil karma. When these sentient beings see others, they immediately get angry. Anything they pick up turns into a weapon. They hack each other to pieces, all faint and collapse on the ground. Then a voice from the sky tells them, you will now be revived.
A cool wind strikes their bodies. This wind is a contributory factor for their scattered flesh and bones to come together. Their bodies heal and become as they were before. Then they do the same thing again. Every day, they fall into these death faints.
Every day, they have many hundreds of different deaths. They’re revived many hundreds of times. We must develop insight into what it would be like to be born there now, to be hacked by weapons, to faint, to be revived, and so forth. If in this life we are stabbed by even a small knife, it’ll only kill us once, and we will suffer inconceivable terror and pain. In this hell, we would die many times each day and would experience this terror and pain each time.
So Geshe-la says, let us meditate on our bodies having the aspect of that of beings in this hell of continued resurrection. Returning to the text, our lifespan there would also be very long. Our previous human lives would bear no comparison. Nāgārjuna says in his letter to a friend, The suffering of being impaled 300 times by a spear in body single day cannot compare to the least suffering in hell, cannot rival it, cannot come anywhere near it. Return to the text, the black line hell.
From this hell on downwards, there are hot held guards such as elephant headed arvas and pig headed yakshas. These hell guards and workers are huge as mountains, have bloodshot eyes, and are horrifying. They shout words like hit and kill. In your meditation, you should feel terrified, but they are going to destroy your body. The hell god sees you and lay you supine on the burning iron ground.
They make many wheels on your huge body with ropes of burning iron that leave black marks. Some of the guards saw along these as a carpenter would saw as a carpenter would saw a piece of wood. Other guards chop along the lines with axes. Others use hatchets. After you have been dismembered in these ways, the bits of flesh and drops of blood that fall on the burning iron ground surface are still connected to your consciousness, and they add to the suffering you experience.
The causes for being reborn in this hell are committing the 10 non virtues, equipping people, and so forth. Rebirth here is usually the karmic ripening of killing. Two mountains resembling, say, goats or ram’s heads race together, and you are crushed. The crushing hell. Rebirth here is usually the karmic ripening. Rebirth here is usually the karmic ripening of killing.
Two mountains resembling, say, goats or ram’s heads race together, and you are crushed between them. There is no avenue of escape. The two mountains separate, your body regenerates to its former state. The process is repeated again and again. Some beings are ground to powder between grindstones.
Some are pounded with pestles like sesame seeds. Some are squeezed in iron vices. You could be crushed or whatever between many different instruments. These take the form of any killing instrument you used in the past. Suppose you kill a mouse between your fingernails.
Later in hell, you will be killed by being crushed between two mountains that look like fingernails. The hell of lamentations, you are placed inside a house of burning iron. It has no doors, and it is all on fire inside and out. You suffer thinking, will not find any means of escape. Your great suffering makes you wail.
The hell of great lamentations, you are placed in an iron house which is contained within another each, similar to the one above. Your suffering is also twice as great. You think, I may escape from one of these iron houses, but not from the other, and so you suffer. Committing the 10 non-virtues of recklessly drinking alcohol or recklessly drinking alcohol can cause rebirth in these hells. A sugar tells us much the same thing.
Drink alcohol, and you’ll be born near a place of lamentation. People who serve drink will be born in its surrounding hell. The hot hell, you’re impaled in a flaming iron skewer that runs through your anus and emerges out of the top of your head. All your insides burn and roaring flames issue from your mouth, eyes, and so forth. You are cooked in a huge of boiling water, then your bones are reassembled, and your body is restored to its former condition, and you are cooked all over again.
The extremely hot hell, this is twice as hot as the previous hell. Your flesh muscles and insides all can come off the bone. When only your bones remain, you are reassembled and restored to your former state. Some beings are pressed between two iron plates and their bodies flattened. Burning iron wire is wrapped around the bodies of some beings.
Their flesh and bone oozes out like dough under pressure. Some are impaled on three pronged skewers of burning iron that run through their anuses and out of the top of their heads. Their tongues are stretched through their many yojanas, many leagues long. Then furrows are made in them by plows and so forth. Some beings are held between two pieces of iron resembling book covers, and their bodies are squashed like books.
There are thus very many ways to experience suffering. Kyabje Pabongka Rinpoche told the story of how Kokalika, one of Devadatta’s circle, was born in this hell. The Avichi Hell, the hell without respite. In this hell, there is no chance to rest, and so the suffering here is greater than in all the above hells. When we burn rocks or iron in a fire, they become indistinguishable from the fire.
The bodies of beings born in this hell are similarly indistinguishable from the fire. One can tell that there are sentient beings in this hell only by the pathetic sounds they make. They are burned by 11 fires. The fires at the four cardinal points of the compass, the four of the sub points, the fire at the zenith and nadir and the fire within their bodies. They are like charred wicks.
The Tibetan actually reads a charred small sticks which are inside the wick. Their suffering is limitless. From Nāgārjuna’s letter to a friend, among all causes of happiness, the elimination of craving is the lord of happinesses. Among all suffering, the suffering of the Avicii Hell is similarly the most intolerable. In other words, the Avicii Hell contains more suffering than the total suffering of the rest of the three realms, including the extremely hot hell.
So the hells contain these sufferings, we think I shall not be reborn there. But we can never be sure of not being reborn of these hells as soon as we leave this life. We cannot be confident of not going to the lower realms. We have accumulated many causes for definitely being born in hell. These causes are very powerful and have in no way degenerated.
The worst cause of our committing any of the 10 non-virtues will cause our rebirth in hell. Medium instances will cause our rebirth as hungry ghosts, the least rebirth as an animal. They say we will be reborn in the hell of continual resurrection because of committing misdeeds against the Pratyamoksha vows. The careless and not caring is a wrong translation. And in the hell without respite because of breaking major pratimoksha vows.
So we must beware. We have in our mind streams many extremely grave misdeeds, breaking minor vows and misdeeds against the pratimoksha and tantric vows, getting angry at bodhisattvas, being disrespectful to gurus, and so forth. If we have broken a major tantric vow, we will be reborn in the Avicii hell for a number of eons equal to the number of moments that elapsed before we restore the vow by retaking it and purifying the sin. We did not care in the past when we broke minor Pradimoksha vows. We have transgressed the rules and have already accumulated the karma for being reborn in each of the hothills in turn.
In these rebirths, we must experience suffering until the results of even their karma runs out, for we would not be able to detach our consciousnesses from our body. Nāgārjuna’s letter to a friend tells us, such sufferings are utterly intolerable. One will experience them billions of times so long as the non virtue has not run out. One will not stop living that life. The life in the eight hot hells are very long.
The shortest lifespans are those of beings in the hell of continual resurrection. Fifty of our human years constitute one day for the gods in the realm of the four kings. Thirty of these days are reckoned. It could be one of their months. Twelve of these months, one of their years.
Five hundred of these years make a life time for beings in the realm of the four kings. Yet this is only a day in the hell of continual resurrection. Thirty of these days are reckoned to be a month in this hell. Twelve such months make a year. A lifetime in the hell of continual resurrection is five hundred of these years.
One could say that this is 1.62 by 10 power twelve human years. Own words state that it’s 1.66 by 10 power twelve years, but this is a mistake. You should consult either the Mehrot monastery edition of this text or Lamrims of the southern lineage. It might seem strange to see that these hot hells are so many Yoganas away, but no great distance lies between you and the lower bones, only the fact that you still breathe. Think about it closely.
You can’t be sure you won’t have gone to these hells by next year or even by tomorrow. If you go to these hells, what will you do? Says these lower realms are really not far away at all. Returning to the text, as it is, we cannot bear having our bodies burnt by fire or pricked by a needle. How then could we bear being born in these hells as the Kadampas of the past have said?
It is as if only one of our feet stands in the human realm. We have already put the other one on the lip of a hell cauldron. We have already created the causes for being born in hell. Krishanavaji says, to create invest on virtues, we can definitely created these causes within our mind stream. Returning to the text having been born in the lower balance, it is impossible to get free of them or to find any refuge.
So then the Vajray says, let us try to envision the sort of suffering we would have to endure in these lower realms. Returning to the text, just before being reborn there, we must work hard while we still have a little of our lifespan left. If we do not gain the best thing, buddhahood, or the next best, becoming a siddha, we should at least work hard in some way to prevent ourselves from being reborn in the lower realms by purifying our sins and so forth. So, we have we have no guarantee we will gain a human rebirth. So let us practice what we can.
Returning to the text, the surrounding hells. Around the outside of the hot hells, like the iron fence that encircles this world system, there are four surrounding hells, the fiery trench, the putrid swamp, the plane of razors, and the uncrossable torrent. The time comes when the karma of the beings born in the hot hell weakens. These beings then escape the hot hells and go to the surrounding hells. There are also beings who are born straight into the surrounding hells.
When some of the beings are ready to escape from the hothills, they get the idea of running away. They leave by the gates of the hothills and arrive at the fiery trench. Their legs burn up to their knees, and as they pull their legs out of the trench, they heal. The legs get burned this way every time they take a step. They spend many hundreds of thousands of years crossing the fiery trench, being continually tormented by the suffering, hoping to escape from it.
Later, they escape the trench but come upon the putrid swamp. Literally in Tibetan, the swamp of decomposing corpses. They sink into it up to their necks and writhe about. Many worms with sharp iron beaks penetrate their bodies and eat them, leaving their bodies like sieves. The beings spend many hundreds of thousands of years crossing the swamp hoping they will escape from this too.
They reach the plane of razors. This plane is completely full of sharp razors whose tips point upwards. They experience the suffering of the razors penetrating and cutting up their legs. Eventually, they escape the plane and come to a forest where the trees have swords for leaves. Mistaking these for living trees, they walk under them.
The sword leaves cut into their bodies, which then heal and are cut again. Such are the sufferings they experience. When the beings emerge from the forest, they come up on the Shalmali tree trunk, which has many sharp iron blades. The beings hear the cries of relatives who are most dear to them coming from the top of the shalmali. But as they scale it, the tips of the iron blades point downwards penetrating their bodies.
Undergoing these sufferings, they make their way up. When they get to the top, terrifying birds pluck out and eat their eyes and brains. Then the cries come from below, and the beings climb down. The iron blades point upwards and penetrate their bodies. When they reach the bottom, dogs and wild beasts eat them from their feet up.
The beings experience a suffering of going up and down like this until their karma runs out. They say that these three different types of assaults from weapons should be counted as the one surrounding hell. When the beings get free of this, they arrive at the uncrossable torrent. The moving water is mixed with fire. It burns and cooks their bodies as boiling water cooks peas.
They experience this suffering for a long time. We are all set to be reborn in the hot hells. It is vital, therefore, to work hard as a means not to be born there by modifying our behavior. Thirdly, thinking about the sufferings of the cold hells. The cold hells on a level with the hot hells and lie to the north, which is why this land of ours is so very cold.
The cold hells are separated from each other vertically by 2,000 or leagues. You may be wondering in that case, cold hells could not be on a level with the hot hells because the hot hells are separated from each other vertically by 4,000 yojanas. There may be 4,000 yojanas between each ground surface of the hot hills, but each of the cold hills has snow covered peaks that are 2,000 yojanas high, so the cold hells are in fact level with the hot hills. If you desire cold bodily sensations at the point of death, this activates the karma to be reborn in the cold hells. You experience a bada as if it were a dream.
You are then reborn in the cold hells, which is like waking up. There are snow covered mountains in these places, each many high. There is no light from the sun, moon, fires, and so forth. It is so dark that you cannot see the movement of your own arms. The ground is a field of ice.
A blizzard rages on high. Between these two, a cold wind blows. There is no means of keeping warm. No fire, no sun, no clothes, nothing. There are eight such cold hells, each one progressively colder.
There is a hell of blisters where you develop blisters on the body. The hell of burst blisters is even colder. Here, the blisters burst dripping blood and lymph. The next hell is even colder. The body stiffens rock hard.
You can’t move, and all you can say is ba. In the next hell, which is even colder, you can’t even say this. You can only make the faint sound hoo from the back of your throat, your palate, actually, at the Tibetan. In the next hell, you can’t even make this sound. The mouth is tightly closed, the teeth clenched.
The next head is even colder. Your body is as stiff as a corpse. Turns blue in color and makes a cracking sound. It cracks like a lotus. In the next, your flesh develops a 100 or a thousand times more lotus like cracks.
In the and the hells below it, the bodies of the Hell beings dot the ice field of snow covered mountains like the jewel studs that decorate stupas. Their bodies are so frozen that they cannot move. Chandragomin’s letter to a disciple says, a wind that is no equal seeps into their very bones. There you may see it in body shiver and our bones they crouch. Insects, product of their feed in the hundreds of burst blisters.
Their fat lymph and marrow drip out. But as many flies with poisonous beaks gather around the lymph dripping from the cracks in the hell beings’ bodies as they attack them, even the drops of blood falling on the ground are still connected to the beings’ consciousnesses. They experience the suffering of the drops freezing and cracking. In addition, the beings experience such suffering as being tormented by various infectious diseases. The Jatakas mention the causes for being born in these cold hells.
Holders of views within all their future lives dwell in these places of darkness and cold winds. They will contract diseases that rot their very bones. What good then lies in dabbling in such views? In other words, the cause is such things as holding wrong nihilistic views, for instance, a view that the law of cause and effect does not exist. We have accumulated many causes for being born in these hells, and they have not degenerated since.
These causes are stealing other’s people’s clothes, removing covers from statues, or throwing sentient beings such as lice out in the freezing cold. The lifespan of beings in the cold hells are as follows. The Introduction to the Middle Way states that these sentient beings have lifespans half as long as those born in the great or hot hells. Says, emptying a bin of sesame seeds by taking out a seed once every hundred years gives the lifespan of beings in the hell of blisters. The other lifespans increase 20 fold each.
In other words, the lifespan is as long as it empty takes to empty a bin holding 80 Magadha standard bushels of sesame seeds by throwing out one sesame seed every hundred years. One eightieth of a bushel holds 15,000 sesame seeds, and so it would take 9.6 by 10 to the power of nine years to empty the bin. This is the lifespan of beings in the first of the cold hells, the hell of blisters. In the hells below, it increases 20 times for each hell. Fourth, thinking about the sufferings of the occasional hells.
These hells are in the human realm, on the ocean shore and so forth. At one time, some merchants invited Ārya Shankarakrita to accompany them to an island. He straggled behind the others and walked to the ocean shore where there was a beautiful temple. The 500 members of the Sangha there invited him inside. The monks fought at noon, but when noon passed, everything returned to normal.
He asked for the cause and was told it was a result of them not being friendly to each other and fighting in the past when the teachings of Buddha Kāśyapa was still in existence. The aya also saw hell beings in the form of walls, pillars, pestles, ropes, brooms, water pipes, and cooking pots. Later, when the aya returned from his journeys, he asked Buddha Śākyamūni about this. We have already dealt with Buddha’s replies concerning the pillar like beings in the section on preparatory rites. The pestle like creature, however, had been a monk in the time of Buddha Kāśyapa’s teachings and had lost his temper and said to a novice, you ought to be parted with a pestle.
The monk had become the pestle like creature as a result of these insulting words. Kyabje Pabongka Rinpoche told how these beings had been experiencing these things from the time of the teachings of Buddha Kāśyapa to the present.
Key terms in this teaching
- Avici narme (Tib)
- The lowest level of hell. LYWA
- eight hot hells
- The hell of being alive again and again, the black-line hell, the gathered and crushed hell, the hell of crying, the hell of great crying, the hot hell, the extremely hot hell and the inexhaustible hot hell. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- oral transmission lung (Tib, Wyl)
- The verbal transmission of a teaching, meditation practice or mantra from guru to disciple, the guru having received the transmission in an unbroken lineage from the original source. LYWA
- pratimoksha vows pratimokshasamvara (Skt); so thar gyi dompa (Tib)
- The various levels of individual liberation vows for lay and ordained, including the five lay vows, and the novice vows and full ordination that monks and nuns take. LYWA
- three realms traidhatu (Skt); kham sum (Tib)
- The desire, form and formless realms. LYWA
- upper realms
- The three higher realms in samsara of human, asura and sura. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.