1 h 25 min · 3,532 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains what dharma is: a transformation of the mind through study and reflection, linked to motivation, with Hinayana and Mahayana distinguished by motivation. It argues that lasting happiness comes from within and that the afflictions, rooted in ignorance grasping at a self, are the true enemies to abandon. A student’s question on the middle turning of the wheel and the link between the self and the afflictions is answered.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 25m
UUID: 89319e88-1274-4924-a2a2-8f1805e1133d
Words: 3,528
So at present, as you know, we are studying Mahāyāna Dharma and practicing Mahāyāna Dharma and we say this is what we study. But I would like to ask you a very simple question. When we say dharma, what do we mean by dharma? So then obviously you know dharma is subdivided within Mahāyāna dharma and dharma, but the actual foundation of both Mahāyāna and Hīnayāna is dharma and when we investigate, dharma connects with the motivation. Dharma is for instance not this text in front of Geshela.
If that were dharma, things would get very awkward very quickly. No, exactly. Dharma is not this book. What is the, you know, What is dharma? What is dharma?
Do you understand? So we study the Lamrim at inconsiderable depth but it is quite strange to talk about the Lamrim but actually to be unable to identify what dharma is. So what is dharma? No hurry, you know. You can think, you know.
Whatever counters the afflictions and it’s not focused on this life? Just for example, not sure still. It’s an example but there’s no necessary entailment. Modifying one’s behavior according to the law of cause and effect. Good.
The development of Very good. Thank you. Annette? The development of wisdom and compassion within one’s mind stream. We subdue our minds in order to cherish others rather than ourselves developing bodhichitta.
So all your answers are very good. You did not give the one answer I feared, which is that dharma is this book, then obviously dharma is not this book. This book, liberating the palm of your hand, it’s just a transcription in writing of one’s understanding of dharma. It is not dharma. Now, dharma is not offering prostrations, it is not offering mandalas, it is not reciting manis, nor is it for that matter doing one’s commitments.
Because all of these things are things we can see. Dharma is not something we can see. Exactly, you know. Wakening. Ah.
Sangha. Yes. Yes. Definitely. That is dharma.
So in your cases, because you have studied the Lamrim, you do not make these basic mistakes. Now for those who have not studied the Lamrim, there is a confusion between the means such as, for instance, offering prostrations, circumambulating stupas, and so forth, and the goal. Then our teacher Buddha Śākyamūni took into account the elements and the focus. In other words, the way of thinking of the trainees to teach dharma. He did not impart dharma without paying any account to the recipient.
Then as far as the systems of tenets are concerned, as you know there are four systems of tenets or four views in Buddhism. The Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, Chitamatra and Mādhyamika views. Now it is not the case that the Vaibhāṣika was taught for no reason. It is a view which is of benefit to beings and each being benefits from a requisite view even though Prasanika Mādhyamika is the ultimate view. Then as far as Buddha’s teachings himself as you know, Buddha turned the wheel of the law three times.
We have the first, the middling, and the third turning of the wheel of the law and these three turnings of the wheel of the law were in function of the different mental acumen of the disciples. Those of sharper and those of duller acumen. Now Buddha Śākyamūni from his own standpoint taught the middling wheel of the law as ultimate. Do you understand? Then if you take the term in Tibetan, it is probably in the future tense and it refers both to dharma and to phenomena.
In Sanskrit, the term is dharma, which derives from the Sanskrit root which means to grasp. There are numerous different levels of depths within the presentation of dharma and in the backdrop of dharma you have obviously the different system of tenets also with different levels of depth But in every case, dharma is of benefit to the mind. So when in dependence on study and reflection on the dharma, a sensation, a particular sensation arises in one’s mind. This can be said to be dharma. There has been mental transformation.
Now when independence on studying of the dharma, through studying and thinking about the dharma, there is a transformation, then that is dharma and ideally it would be a permanent uncontrived transformation, but that is difficult. So when we contrast dharma with the mundane or the worldly viewpoint, in a mundane perspective, it is widely accepted that the source, the root of one’s happiness is outside of oneself. One’s happiness comes from the outside. Likewise, one’s enemies come from the outside as well. This is something we all understand in this world.
We all have direct experience of this. Then obviously you see if our happiness came from the outside, then ultimate happiness would come from the outside as well. And if it did, then when we seek for it, we would find it. But the more we seek for this ultimate happiness, the harder it is to get it. Because obviously we are never satisfied, so it gets harder and harder and harder.
And then clearly when we look at it in this way, how could exterior physical objects provide us with lasting happiness? Whatever qualities they have, we infuse in them. They do not give anything back. You see with the reverse cycle AC for instance, that when you put it on hot initially, it provides temporary happiness. Then as you keep it on hot, you become too hot and uncomfortable.
Then you have to switch it on cool, at which point it provides once again temporary relief until you become too cold. So exterior phenomena cannot provide lasting happiness. Then it is clear that exterior physical entities are necessary, but we cannot obtain lasting happiness from them. They do not provide the totality, a 100% of our happiness. Then what does the balance of our happiness comes from?
It comes from within, from the mind. What precisely troubles, blocks, or prevents this lasting inner happiness from occurring? It is what we know as the afflictions. Exactly, you know. To understand, So basically the enemies of our inner happiness are therefore afflictions such as desire, envy, pride, and so forth.
Then the doubt which might arise is that if we are completely bereft of the say of desire or of pride, we may not be able to succeed in this world to gather what we need. Then that is a valid doubt, perhaps a little bit of desire is necessary. So, it is not that desire does not give happiness, it does, but it gives it does not give lasting happiness, it gives temporary happiness. And then it cannot give the totality 100% of our happiness and precisely because it can’t, it troubles us. And therefore our enemies and our friends are internal within our mind and the happiness we need is internal happiness.
This is a happiness of liberation. It is precisely because people over invest in exterior physical entities and they cannot get what they want, that their minds become troubled and they turn to alcohol, they turn to drugs, they turn to antidepressants, and these can definitely calm the mind. But in reality, it is much more helpful to focus the mind inside. This is dharma. Then it would be very good if it is possible for you to talk about this a little bit on the outside to people you know who are facing major difficulties.
There’s however many people there are in this room. If each one of you knows, let’s say, 20 people, you could see how beneficial it could be. Then at the level of the being of the middling scope, we understand the thoughts of the afflictions and this is something we are all aware of. We have studied and at this point, one understands that true happiness lies deep within the mind. And one turns the mind away from exterior physical entities.
Now this is not to say that one doesn’t need a little bit of affliction such as desire to progress in this world, but one reduces it dramatically. And then in dependence on such powerful virtuous minds, we collect large collections of imprints, potencies and so forth, and we need these. Then in this world of ours, we are accustomed to consider that our enemies, foes are on the outside and they are the ones we target. It is a profound transformation which is the one in which we view our enemies as within ourselves, as part of our mental continuum, as anger, jealousy, desire and so forth. And then at this point, our true enemies are inside ourselves and the exterior enemies are subsidiary.
So the fully characterized enemies, they exist within our minds. Then in Buddhist texts one refers to the abandonment of the afflictions and to one who has abandoned the afflictions as an Arhat, or in Tibetan has two syllables, means enemy and means to destroy. He is one who has abandoned the enemy of the afflictions. Okay. Then dharma in other words is that which transforms the mind and this links directly with motivation.
Now, Buddha dharma, the dharma of the Buddha is subdivided into two. The Hīnayāna or lower vehicle Dharma and the Mahāyāna or greater vehicle Dharma. Good. Thank you. Then the dharma, in other words transformation of the mind is directly linked to generating the motivation.
And here, one says repeated repeatedly generate the motivation in Tibetan. But what exactly is meant by generating here? These are basically states of mind such as definite emergence, bodhichitta or great compassion with which we have no experience. So we must generate them incrementally first. Then in our own cases, since after waking up in the morning, typically our minds are focused either on our jobs or taking care of relatives and so forth.
It is very difficult to turn our minds in the direction of dharma. And therefore, when one speaks of generating the motivation, this is not something which will happen in five minutes or so. We take the case of bodhichitta, we must reflect carefully on the advantages of generating bodhichitta and the disadvantages of not generating it and this will take at least ten minutes. So therefore, when the Lamrim says to generate the motivation, this is said for the sake of those who are unaccustomed, who don’t have the habit. And ideally, one should meditate on all the points of the Lamrim from the beginning, identifying a rebirth of leisure and endowment all the way until the attainment of full enlightenment.
Then in Tibet people did have the time and would engage in this overview of the totality of That the time, that time, long time ago, long time ago in Tibet, different now. Nowadays no one has time so we have to focus on bodhichitta itself for five, six or seven minutes. A long time ago, a bit less than a hundred years ago before the situation changed dramatically in Tibet, Tibet was a land of peace, happiness and dharma and people may not necessarily have studied but everyone had faith and they had time to practice. Now obviously, we generate the motivation when we are unaccustomed or unhabituated. Once we have some type of experience, either of impermanence or definite emergence or bodhichitta, there is no need to generate the motivation, it is already there.
Now, here when one speaks of, becoming accustomed to habituation to bodhichitta, this does not refer to an uncontrived experience of bodhichitta. In other words, an uninterrupted experience of bodhichitta. Generating something like this would be very difficult. However, it is possible with time and effort. So here when one is speaking of an uncontrived experience, this is an experience arisen from meditation, which is continuous.
Now what exactly do we mean by habituation? A good example would be for instance, typing away at one’s computer. At the beginning when one starts, one is obliged to look at the letters and then look at the text and then look back. Otherwise, one makes a mistake. But with habit, as one becomes accustomed or habituated, eventually one just looks at one text and types without checking.
So it is the same thing when one gains experience, let us say, an uncontrived experience of impermanence and so forth. Now in our own cases, when we reflect on bodhichitta or on definite emergence, then an experience arises, when we don’t it doesn’t. This is a sign that it is contrived. In other words, that we are not accustomed. An uncontrived experience is continuous.
So, therefore, if one can, one should endeavor at present to do an overview meditation on the totality of the Lamrim from identifying a rebirth of leisure and endowment until full and utter enlightenment. But if this is too difficult, one should endeavor to meditate on bodhichitta and on impermanence. And we shall now meditate during a couple of minutes. So you generated the motivation, didn’t you? So here, what is it therefore precisely which prevents us from this inner mental happiness?
It is none other but the afflictions and here we must find a way to abandon, to eliminate the afflictions. It is not appropriate or possible to do so through prayer. So we must investigate the source of the afflictions and trace back the afflictions all the way back to their source and we have already established that the source is ignorance grasping at a self. Now once we understand this in the light of the four noble truths, this probably qualifies as dharma. So what I wanted to cover with you today and explain is that the study of the functioning of one’s own mind and the identification of its mode of operation is dharma and this probably qualifies as Buddha And in the backdrop of dharma lies the motivation which differentiates dharma between Hīnayāna or lower vehicle dharma and Mahāyāna or greater vehicle dharma.
And the Hīnayāna dharma in turn can be presented in term of the four noble truths. Differentiation between Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna hinges on the motivation and not on the topics presented. For instance, we find both in Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna a presentation of the four noble truths. We find in both a presentation of the 12 limbs of dependent origination of the 37 factors of enlightenment. These are also present in the trainings of the Hearers and the Pratyekabuddhas.
And this as was explained hinges on the motivation, therefore we must generate the motivation for as long as an uncontrived motivation is not present. Once it is present, that is no longer necessary. This is what I wanted to explain today. And as for the Mahāyāna, when upon the foundation which I explained as dharma, in other words, mental transformation. In addition to that, one wishes to practice and gain realization for the sake of others, then this is Mahāyāna dharma.
So once one has identified the afflictions within one’s mental continuum as one’s true enemy, then it’s very straightforward because the afflictions are all the same. Whereas if one views people on the outside as one end one’s enemy, life is very complicated. Some are blonde, some have black hair, some have red hair, some have round eyes, some squint. And the affliction, they are all one, they are not different. And it’s really marvelous because the only difference is really verbal.
And people obviously have different diets as well. And then obviously once one understands that one’s true enemies are the afflictions within one’s mind stream then really that has become dharma practice. Then this is nature. This is actually the way things are. No one ever no one made this.
Then obviously apart from Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika one refers to primordial establishment of phenomena. So to make things very clear, allow me to repeat, persons are not created by anybody. Persons arise in dependence on causes and conditions. They are not created by God’s humans or whatever. So once we understand that our true enemy is the afflictions within our mental continuum and we see its faults, and then we extend this understanding to all human beings in this world, let us leave animals aside for the time being, then it is probably unnecessary to have any police.
We can relax and be at ease with each other. Then no one will hurl insults at each other, there will be no bombs, no terrorist attacks and this is probably something which is specifically human for animals it will be complicated. Then if we think what can I do to better all human beings in this world? What can I do to help all human beings in this world? And take the resolve, I shall do this, then this is probably adequate as an example of bodhichitta.
And then Buddhist texts say that at this point, one will be focusing on attaining the potency, the capacity of an enlightened being. Now, this is not something which will happen in a couple of days or a couple of weeks. It will take a very long period of time, but we then have the determination to do so. And let us therefore generate this motivation as best we can and after this, we will have the recitation of the prayers. Please open the prayer book, page one.
We recite one b, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, mandala offering, verse one and three. So it is therefore extremely important to understand the faults of the afflictions and to prepare oneself for when the afflictions arise. As is said, one should counter the afflictions with forceful means. And therefore, before anger arises, one must prepare oneself so that when it starts to approach, one is able to counter it forcefully. Then obviously this is present within all our mental continuum.
So it is best in the morning when we awaken to resolve to benefit others today and if we are unable to benefit them at the very least, we definitely will not harm them. How stupid it is to harm others. Then everyone in this room understands the force of the afflictions and if when you leave this temple, you talk about this to two people, then that will be 80 people who will know the faults of the afflictions. And if those 80 people talk to two people, that will be a 160 people. And then over time, all of Adelaide will have been affected by this and eventually all of Australia.
Yeah, one one day, know, one day, but a time, a long time. Yeah, yeah. And it’ll take time, but it is possible and I think there’s something you don’t really understand, which is that the mind and the afflictions are two different things. They can be separated. If you eliminate the afflictions, you still have the mind left.
Have you question? Okay. Please. Geshela taught that of the three turnings of the wheel, the middle turning, was supreme. Mhmm.
And I would like to ask why that is so. So it is because the emptiness which Buddha taught in the middle turning of the wheel of the law is the final emptiness that this turning of the wheel of the law is said to be supreme and of definitive meaning. These are said to be sutras of definitive meaning. Geshe-la, I can without any trouble see the faults of the afflictions, but the step to see that the cause of the afflictions is the self I struggle with, what is the link between the afflictions and that the self is the cause? So Geshe-la suspects that many of our students are confusing.
Mhmm. The I on the one hand which exists and is a person and the ignorance grasping at the self which is an affliction. Now it is when the ignorance grasps at the I that there is a superimposition which occurs, an imputation, and that has to be explained. So this is a difficult topic, which will be covered later. And Geshe-la notices that when you express yourselves you often seem to fall naturally in a Chitamatra perspective which is very good.
So while it is easy to explain these topics based on text, it is much more difficult to explain them based on one’s own experience. All the more so because the I and the ignorance grasping at a self are in a relation of subject and object and are blended. So I will explain this quietly over time. Yeah. So for instance, if we take the distinction between sensory and mental consciousnesses which was covered last night, it’s very easy to explain it based on the Buddhist text.
Essentially consciousness is a consciousness which arises in dependence on its uncommon controlling condition, is an exterior organ, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera. But when you try to actually explain this distinction in terms of your own experience, This is very difficult. Okay, stop here, thank you. I guess everybody got the email. But, anyways, we now start the opening ceremony for Medicine Buddha.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- definitive meaning nitartha (Skt); ngedön (Tib)
- One of two main ways of understanding a Dharma teaching, this one is where the content is be taken literally and not open for interpretation, as opposed to the interpretive meaning. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
- The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.