Lam Rim – Lamrim180516 (1

1 h 28 min · 3,949 words

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - Lamrim180516 (1
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. This session continues an earlier Lam Rim teaching. It explains that the wisdom realizing emptiness counters grasping at a self because the two apprehend the self in directly opposite ways. The teacher sets emptiness aside for now and turns to bodhicitta, including equalizing and exchanging self and others. Self-cherishing is presented as the source of suffering and cherishing others as the source of happiness. The talk ends with questions and answers.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 29m

UUID: 20079662-e6e6-426f-a506-8648780bf5f2

Words: 3,945

So, the object of attainment of the path shared with the being of the middling scope is liberation, and the means to attain the object of attainment is the wisdom realizing emptiness. So the object of abandonment, in other words, is, the ignorance grasping at a self. And the means to abandon the object of abandonment, as was said, is the wisdom realizing emptiness or selflessness. Now, how precisely does this antidote, the wisdom realizing emptiness or selflessness, counteract the the ignorance grasping at a self? So I would therefore like to ask you, since the wisdom realizing emptiness on the one hand and the ignorance grasping at a self on the other hand in the relationship of an antidote to an object of abandonment, what is the mode of operation of the wisdom realizing emptiness?

You have an answer. When we say that the wisdom realizing emptiness or selflessness is the antidote of the ignorance grasping at a self, then we need a mode of operation, a reason for this. Why? We should start with that. Yeah.

So our object of attainment is liberation. This is what we are aiming for. That which prevents us from attaining it is ignorance grasping at itself. Now we all say that the wisdom realizing selflessness is the antidote of that ignorance. Why?

You’re saying that the wisdom realizing emptiness and the ignorance grasping at the self are incompatible or contradictory. Why are they incompatible or contradictory? So Molly said that the ignorance grasping at a self apprehends phenomena wrongly and that the wisdom realizing emptiness apprehended the mode of reality or the mode of existence of phenomena. That is appropriate. But what is this wrong mode of apprehension of the ignorance grasping at itself?

So your answer is that what is apprehended, what appears to the ignorance grasping at a self is a person which is inherently existent, established from its own side, or established by its own characteristics. This is appropriate. This is correct. So the ignorance grasping at a self, apprehends that self as being established from its own side, by its own characteristics, and inherently. On the other hand, the wisdom realizing emptiness, apprehends such a self as non inherently existent, non existent from its own side, and non existent by its own characteristics.

In other words, the mode of apprehension of the ignorance apprehending a self and the mode of apprehension of the wisdom realizing selflessness are directly contradictory. You have to reflect on this. So you have to check for yourselves how oneself appears to oneself, how your I appears to yourself, not so much what you think other people might be experiencing. And, if you check for yourself how your I appears for yourself, you will get the sense that the I exists within the aggregates from its own side. So you have to investigate for yourselves what this ignorance grasping at an I is grasping at.

So the topic of emptiness and the wisdom realizing emptiness is a difficult one. The wisdom of realizing emptiness is an analytical state of mind. What does it analyze? The fact that the self does not exist from its own side, by its own characteristics, and inherently. In other words, such a wisdom’s mode of apprehension is directly opposite or contradictory to the mode of apprehension of the ignorance grasping at a self.

Such an ignorance apprehends a self as existing inherently from its own side and by its own characteristics. This is something you have to think very carefully about. So generally speaking, studying emptiness within the great treatises, is not that difficult. However, even if you understand emptiness on the basis of the great treatises, and for that matter, if you generate not merely an understanding, but a realization and in dependence on that realization, even a valid cognizer realizing emptiness, a definite ascertainment of emptiness Without being able to understand how emptiness can target the ignorance grasping at a self, how the wisdom realizing emptiness can act as an antidote against this ignorance. Such a realization will probably not act as an antidote to the afflictions or to this ignorance.

This is not an easy topic. You must identify within yourselves the object of negation. So I will not explain emptiness in detail here. We have covered it over the last two years at TBI during the tenets class. So I hope some of you attended.

In brief, all of the schools of philosophy of ancient India, whether it is the non Buddhist Tīrthikas or the Buddhists, ask the question, what is the I? Now the Tīrthikas have one answer. The Buddhist schools of philosophy have another answer. There are four different modes of assertion of selflessness within the Buddhist schools of philosophy, each one more subtle than the previous one.

So here, what is important is for you to understand the nature of this I or the self. And this, we have to check within ourselves. We can see in little children from the age of one or so forth that there is a very strong sense of my and mine. The child would say this is mine. Now, this sense of my or mine arises in dependence on a sense of I.

What you have to do is examine for yourself, within yourself, how this I appears and how it exists. Then if you can link this to the teachings of the great treatises, this will be very powerful. So here, it is critical to understand the mode of existence of the I. When we reflect upon ourselves, we can ask ourselves, well, basically, how do I exist? And then once one understands this, one will understand the mistaken modes of existence of the I, which are the object of refutation.

Now emptiness here is that which refutes. There are numerous presentations of emptiness. Ideally, one would accept that of Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka, but it is not indispensable. The presentations of emptiness in the lower schools of tenets, Svatāntrika Madhyamaka downwards are also extremely beneficial. So, you asked me, a couple of weeks ago to explain emptiness in greater depth.

Then, I do not wish to enter directly in an explanation of emptiness, but we’ll start by an introduction in which we investigate what the nature of the I is. So the I exists. We have to start by laying that down. As something which exists as a phenomenon, it is either permanent or impermanent. There are some schools of tenets which assert that the I or the self is permanent.

It is not an arbitrary assertion. There’s an assertion they root in reason and logic. However, the Buddhist schools of tenets or philosophy assert that the I is impermanent. All of the schools of Buddhist philosophy from Vaibhāṣika are all the way up to Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka assert that the I is impermanent. They, however, assert different modes of existence of the I.

Now, it is very important for us to start by trying to understand what the I is and its mode of existence as a foundation for an understanding of emptiness. Otherwise, to enter immediately in emptiness is of little benefit. So if I enter into many details on, this topic of emptiness in the nature of the I, I’m afraid you will I’m afraid you will doze off and eventually fall asleep and sink to the floor, and there will be no benefit whatsoever in attending this teaching. So for this reason, I will pass directly to Bodhicitta. Now emptiness is a difficult topic.

If we study emptiness, even if we gain an understanding or realizations of emptiness, it often is of little direct benefit. It is much further down the line that direct realizations of emptiness become beneficial. This is not the case with bodhicitta. With bodhicitta, we can see from the very beginning that if we reflect on bodhicitta, it is of benefit. So don’t be depressed.

Even if you have no realization or understanding of emptiness, nonetheless, you can enter the path of the Mahāyāna. Since the realization of emptiness is only indispensable at the level of the middling path of accumulation. But at the level of the small path of accumulation, you do not have to have a realization of emptiness. Then obviously, it will be difficult to attain full enlightenment on the basis of bodhicitta alone. We should not be depressed and take the example of Acharya Vasubandhu, one of the greatest scholars of Buddhist history who lived more than a thousand, maybe fourteen hundred years ago.

This phenomenal scholar never realized the view of emptiness in accordance with the prasanika view. He was a Chitamatran, so he did not realize the prasanika view. I am not saying, however, that you should set aside the study of emptiness. Instead, you should put effort and study the topic, talk about it, and over time, over the years and the lives, an understanding will arise. It will not arise at once.

Otherwise, if we just set the topic aside, that is laziness. Now what precisely is a fully characterized mind of bodhicitta? As Maitreya says in Abhisamayālamkāra, I assert that bodhicitta is striving for full enlightenment for the sake of others. To understand fully what bodhicitta is, one must understand both its object of observation and its object of appearance. Now in the case of bodhicitta, probably both object of observation and object of appearance are utter and full enlightenment.

The aspiration of bodhicitta is both or twin. First, an aspiration for full enlightenment, and secondly, an aspiration for the sake of others. Now it would be appropriate to say that bodhicitta is a wish for one’s object of attainment, full and utter enlightenment for the sake of other sentient beings. And, therefore, for the sake of others, one strives for full enlightenment. Now the foundation of bodhicitta is for the sake of others.

And here, when we refer to, for the sake of others, we mean that whomsoever we meet, whichever human being or nonhuman being we meet, we should generate happiness upon meeting this person. This is the foundation, the very foundation of bodhicitta. Be careful. Listen to me, please. And therefore, let us focus on Bodhicitta, which is a more straightforward topic than emptiness.

Now the foundation here, and this is also the foundation of the equalization and interchange of self and others, is whomsoever, whatsoever sentient being one meets, one should generate happiness with regards to the meeting of that sentient being. Then let me give you an example. It should be similar to the happiness and the joy which a mother or father experiences when they hear or they see their only child, preferably quite young, ages one, two or three, since when they grow older, there are problems and you’re maybe not delighted to see them. But when they’re young, then this experience of happiness is there. Now, if we didn’t have this experience of happiness, then it would be difficult for us to generate.

And if we have no memories, we can ascertain this from serving others. Now, bodhicitta is a mind which has two aspirations or two wishes. The first is an aspiration or a wish for one’s object of attainment, full enlightenment. The second is an aspiration or a wish for the benefit or for the sake of others. Now, this aspiration for the benefit of the sake of others refers to each others, to all sentient beings without exception.

What is the foundation of this aspiration for the sake of others? Its foundation is a feeling of happiness with respect to others. And this feeling of happiness with respect to others arises from the equalization and the interchange of self and others.

How does one proceed in the equalization of an interchange of self and others? Initially, one must reflect on the qualities of altruism or cherishing others, which is said to be the foundation of all benefit and happiness. Then after this, one must reflect on the thoughts of self cherishing or egoism, which is said to be the source or the origin of all thoughts and degeneration. As you remember, there are two modes of generation of bodhicitta. The first is the instruction of the sevenfold causal generation of bodhicitta.

The second is the instruction of the equalization and interchange of self and others. We shall cover the second instruction. This second instruction is subdivided into five outlines. The first is equalization of self and others. The second is reflecting through numerous doors, in other words, numerous lines of reasonings regarding the faults of egoism or self cherishing.

The third is reflecting through numerous doors or lines of reasoning of on the qualities of cherishing others or altruism. The fourth is the actual thought of interchanging self and others. And the fifth or the final one is the way of meditating on or giving and taking in dependence on that. So one should definitely memorize these five outlines of equalization and interchange of self and others and try to understand them. Uh-huh.

Do you understand? So the first outline we covered last time, it is equalization of self and others or equanimity. Now what is this equanimity and equanimity of? It is not an equality of heights, we have different heights, nor of sizes, nor of intelligence, nor of wealth. It is an equalization or an equanimity in terms of the fact that we are equal in wishing for happiness and equal in fearing suffering.

Then I can guarantee 100 that we are equal in wishing for happiness and not wishing to experience suffering. We’re all equal in this respect, aren’t we? Now, this equanimity is therefore an equality in terms of wishing for happiness and not wishing for suffering. It is not a difficult topic to understand. The treatises just point out, it is easy to understand.

We all wish for happiness, but this happiness we wish for to be worth it should not be a transitory, ephemeral happiness. It should be a lasting, durable happiness. Then we have to ask ourselves, how do we obtain lasting or durable happiness? Likewise, we all fear suffering. But what is the source of unceasing suffering which we experience?

These are the two questions we have to ask ourselves, and we have to look deep within ourselves and ask these questions sincerely. So we have to check within ourselves. We could do it without referring to any text, but it is best if we check within ourselves, find an understanding of what the causes of suffering and the causes of happiness are, and then compare these with the analysis of the great scholars of ancient India. And then we will be spot on. So this is really important, isn’t it?

If we try to analyze when we study equanimity, what the source of happiness is, what the source of suffering is, it will draw it all together. So we should, therefore, reflect carefully on this and try to generate some type of experience of Bodhicitta. As is said in Lamrim Chenmo, it is not sufficient to reflect on bodhicitta at the beginning of one’s practice and then set it aside and function on the basis of a nebulous sense of altruism. This is worthless reasoning. Let us therefore now reflect during a couple of minutes on the source of happiness, not transitory or ephemeral happiness, but lasting, durable happiness, as well as on the source of suffering.

We recite one b, two, three, and four. Also page five, number six mandala offering, verse one and three.

So we have to reflect, therefore, on the origin or the source of perfect happiness as well as on the origin or the source of unremitting suffering. So you probably understand that the source or the origin of unremitting suffering is none other than grasping at a self as well as self cherishing. On the other hand, the source of perfect happiness, not transitory ephemeral happiness, is none other than cherishing others or altruism. So you can see that if we reflect on the sources of suffering and of happiness, The source of suffering deep within us is self cherishing or egoism. The source of happiness is others.

And it is at this point that we come to the second outline of the presentation of the interchange of self and others, reflecting through numerous lines of reasoning on the faults of egoism or self cherishing. Then, since I suspect we have direct experience of egoism as a source of great personal suffering, I don’t feel the need to give a commentary. I always say, it’s me. It’s me. Right?

So this is something we can observe on a daily basis, every single day of our life when we try to examine the sources of suffering and happiness within our life. The problem which arises is when we say that the source of suffering is self cherishing or egoism, this self cherishing is to a large degree blended or mixed with grasping at itself. So we have to differentiate them, don’t we? So if we take self cherishing, then self cherishing has both an, aspect and an object of observation, just as grasping at a self. But we have to be able to posit a different aspect and observation for self cherishing than for grasping at a self.

Otherwise, if they are one in the same, then once one attains the first ground, normally, one has eliminated grasping at itself. But since self cherishing is still there, then it would still be there as well. Now, if we reflect carefully on how self cherishing is a source of continuous unceasing suffering, then we can understand clearly how cherishing others or altruism, let alone bodhicitta, is the source of great happiness. So if one doesn’t have faults and only has qualities, then that’s perfect. But if one has faults, then what is important is to identify what these faults are and to identify these faults as faults and then to seek to generate the appropriate qualities.

So when we say self cherishing, in Tibetan, what does the self refer to here? If it refers to the eye within grasping at an eye, then probably self cherishing and grasping at an eye are one in the same. Now for us, ordinary beings, these two are pretty much confused. It is said in the Buddhist treatises on bodhicitta that reflecting on the thoughts of self cherishing or egoism is extraordinarily beneficial. It enables one to purify vast amounts of sin and to accumulate great amounts of virtuous karma.

So I suspect you find these topics of self cherishing and cherishing others somewhat more exciting than my presentations on emptiness where everyone seemed to doze quietly away. So if one can reflect on the faults of self cherishing and reflect on the qualities of cherishing others, then there is benefits for both oneself and for others. One’s mind will be at peace, one will be happy and one will experience less disease. Then at present, I will take your questions, a couple of questions. Please ask short, clear questions.

Don’t go on and on. In trying to differentiate between self cherishing and self grasping, was it said before that an arhat still has self cherishing but does not have self grasping? You also see very good answer, which arises from careful thinking. However, we have to think very carefully about the distinction between self cherishing and grasping at itself. Then I would say if you had attained the state of an arhat, I would accept that as an answer.

I’m joking. But basically, you have to analyze carefully, carefully this one. Another. Did you just say that when on the first ground of a Bodhisattva, a real Bodhisattva path, the Bodhisattva still has self cherishing but no self grasping. No.

For that matter, at the level of the first ground, one has not even abandoned self grasping. One has to distinguish between those who have entered within abiding in the type or not. However, one abandons self grasping at the level of the eighth ground. So when you refer to abandoning self grasping at the level of the first ground, you are probably thinking of abandoning imputed self grasping, not abandoning innate self grasping, which is only abandoned at the level of the eighth ground. Ananda was talking about.

Was talking about identifying our faults as thoughts. Could he speak more on that? So here, this refers specifically to understanding the, thoughts of self cherishing or egoism as thoughts. Then this is something we have to check for ourselves. For instance, do you yourself have desire?

Do you yourself have anger? Do you have competitiveness or jealousy within your mind stream? Then you should check or not. If they are present within your mind stream, you have to ask yourself, what is the cause? What is the source of this?

Then if we analyze, we find that the source is self cherishing. It is egoism. Then one understands clearly the thoughts of egoism or self cherishing. Usually, we may have covered this last week, but is there a subtle difference between the equalizing in the equalizing exchange of self and others and equalization in the sevenfold cause and effect as the preparation of equalizing? There are differences in the instances which are given of these equanimities, but I don’t believe there are big differences in the substance of these equanimities.

However, it is considered easier to generate equalizing self and others within the equalization interchange of self and others. Has it ever been speculated over how many lifetimes it would take to abandon grasping at the self, or can it be done within one lifetime? Of course.

That’s a very good question. If we identify self cherishing and grasping at a self, yes, it is possible to abandon self cherishing in one life. Since we would say that it is not present in the mind stream of an arhat. However, if we do not identify self cherishing and self grasping, then it is probably not possible to abandon them in one life in the Sūtrayāna. So we set the Mantrayāna apart here.

Yeah. If self cherishing and grasping at a self are identical, if they are identical, then upon attaining the state of an arhat there would be no self cherishing because there is no self grasping if they are identical. So if you want to understand correctly self cherishing, you really need to understand correctly grasping at a self. The two are very, very close. Then at present in our mind streams, it is all there.

Self cherishing, self grasping, all the afflictions. It’s a big soup, but we are unable to identify the individual components, and we are unable to identify them as faults. I’m trying to to define the two. Is it possible to define grasping at a self as wanting one’s own needs to be met as in an who wishes for liberation for their own sake, whereas self cherishing is ignoring the needs of others? So the definition you have given for self cherishing might do, abandoning the interests of others.

But the definition you have proposed for self grasping is probably inappropriate. Can Geshe la give an example of the self grasping and, you know, and also self cherishing with this you know, a different I’m gonna have to think about it, and I’ll give you the examples next time. I will give you next week, please. We should stop here for today. Open the page nine.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Sutrayana döi thegpa (Tib)
The Sutra Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Paramitayana; the non-tantric path that encompasses both Hinayana practices such as the thirty-seven wings of enlightenment and Mahayana practices such as the six perfections... LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Does a Bodhisattva on the first ground still have self-cherishing but no self-grasping?

No. Even at the level of the first ground, self-grasping has not been abandoned. Self-grasping is abandoned at the level of the eighth ground. The idea that it is abandoned on the first ground probably comes from thinking of imputed self-grasping, which is abandoned at that level. Innate self-grasping is only abandoned at the level of the eighth ground. A distinction is also made between those who have entered within abiding in the type and those who have not.

Is there a subtle difference between equalizing self and others in the exchange of self and others, and the equanimity that prepares the sevenfold cause and effect instruction?

There are differences in the instances given of these two equanimities, but there are not believed to be big differences in their substance. However, it is considered easier to generate the equalizing of self and others within the practice of equalizing and exchanging self and others.

Scroll to Top