Lam Rim – 2012-08-22 – KR

1 h 46 min · 4,553 words · 22 August 2012

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2012-08-22 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teacher stresses faith and conviction grounded in reasoning, especially belief in past and future lives and in karma and causality, as the foundation for Dharma practice. He distinguishes Hinayana from Mahayana by altruistic motivation rather than by the lamrim, and explains the eight benefits of relying correctly on a fully qualified spiritual teacher. He recommends reading and discussing books on rebirth and logic rather than idle talk.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 46m

UUID: de2ba4cf-8f21-4321-9de0-32dea5e04361

Date: 2012-08-22

Words: 4,549

Are you a bit cold? Yeah. No problem. Are you a bit cold? Yeah.

If we want to practice dharma in a careful, sustained way, it is critical for us to have not only conviction but actually faith in the teachings. Irrespective of whether one is a human being or an animal, probably our foremost goal is striving for happiness. Yet it is almost certain that we understand only physical or bodily happiness and that the thought of mental happiness doesn’t even enter our minds. All of us understand clearly that physical happiness is not lasting nor permanent. It is transient and easily transforms into suffering.

We can see this clearly at the time of our own demise. When we die, it is clear that there is a rupture, a disconnection between the physical happiness of this life and whatever physical sensation we have in future lives. For the durable, the unchanging happiness which we all need, it is indispensable to study a dharma and within dharmas to study Buddhist dharma and within Buddhist dharmas to study the most profound dharma of all, that of the great vehicle or the Mahāyāna. Regarding both Buddhist study and practice which are indispensable for the attainment of this durable happiness, it is indispensable as a foundation to have faith and conviction. What is the motor of faith and conviction and in what is faith and conviction indispensable?

We need faith and conviction in the existence of past and future lives. And this can only be generated through reading the numerous works which have been written on past and numerous and future lives and analyzing them carefully with reasoning over and again. How should we proceed in this analysis? We can see that we are composed of body and mind and while it is open to debate whether the mind is of a different nature than the body, which is matter or not, under analysis we can see clearly that the mind must be different from the body and from matter. Then the question which arises is where does this mind come from and where does it go?

It clearly comes from somewhere and that origin of the mind is past lives. Having established the existence of past lives, the existence of future lives is self evident. In our case, one can say that we have a fortunate rebirth. Then if we analyze what the cause of this fortunate rebirth is and we trace it back in time over the lives, Geshela believes it is possible to get a sense that this originates from virtuous deeds. If you were to take on the other hand the case of animals, let us say dogs or pigs, and we analyze the cause for their present animal rebirth over numerous past lives, one can get a sense that it would arise from a non virtuous deed.

As Je Tsongkhapa said numerous times in his prayer for happiness or felicity, generating the faith of conviction in the incontrovertibility of causality. This refers to generating a faith which is rooted in analysis and reasoning, an incontrovertible faith in karma and causality. Here, karma and causality is what is referred to in Sanskrit as karma and it is this to which we have to generate a profound faith based in reasoning. If we take the countries which are traditionally Buddhist, which experience what we could call sociological Buddhism, where the Buddhist teachings have been transmitted from father to son over the centuries, Countries such as Tibet, Thailand, Vietnam and so forth. It is clear that in these countries most people have a natural faith from early childhood in the existence of past and future lives.

What they have faced, very few if any have studied. However, they have a natural belief as well in virtuous and non virtuous karma. And if we try to understand where this natural belief in the efficacy of virtue and non virtue arises from, it probably arises from the fact that this was taught to them by their parents and that over the many lives in those cultures they heard this over and again from their teachers who said, practice virtue, the results will be beneficial for you in future lives and practice non virtue, avoid non virtue so as to avoid difficult results. However, if we examine the belief of these people and we ask them for instance precisely how do past and future lives exist, then they can’t provide an answer because there has been no study. It is extremely important to understand the existence of past and future lives and of karma and causality.

Your translator has given many conferences at TBI on the topic of past and future lives and it is critical to try to understand this topic. There are numerous books in English which are available and you should read them carefully, think carefully and analyze carefully. The reason for this is that the lamrim, the graduated stages of the path, was uttered for intended trainees who actually had a faith rooted in conviction in the existence of past and future lives. Therefore, it wasn’t really uttered for us and it is difficult for us to understand it. It is addressed to trainees of a higher level.

However, with repeated habituation within our minds, we can come to understand the existence of past and future lives And it is important for us not to do this alone in our study, but to talk to educated Buddhist practitioners in English and to actually discuss this. Geshela said that we have direct experience in the monasteries of the benefits of this. This is something the police might not enjoy, because police or the police exists basically because people are uncontrolled and have no ethics. For someone who actually believes in the existence of past and future lives and of karma and causality, there would be no need for a police force since that person would, as they say, become his own law and would set his own ethical standard. Such a person would not need to be subdued by others.

The police unfortunately is necessary because most people only act egotistically in their own interest. Do not believe however that in Tibet because everyone was a Mahāyāna practitioner, there was no need for security forces. One cannot generalize in this way, but it is true that the social situation was better. In the old days in Tibet, all the Tibetans had a fundamental and profound faith in karma and causality, the existence of past and future lives, in the triple gem and so forth. It was however a naive faith which was uncorroborated, unsubstantiated by reason.

There was no study. At present, studies have improved somewhat. Then there is a second point, which is that the dharma which is studied in the Tibetan tradition is the Mahāyāna dharma and quite naturally when we are asked which dharma we practice between the Hīnayāna and the Mahāyāna, between the lesser and the greater vehicle, we will answer we practice the Mahāyāna. Then if we are investigated a little bit further and someone asks us precisely what is the difference between the Hīnayāna and the Mahāyāna, then we are stuck. Now, this is a very unfortunate state of affairs.

Generally speaking, it is very good to ask questions from others and to be interrogated in this way because this gives rise to doubts and hesitations. The greater the doubts and the greater the hesitations, the greater in turn the study. The greater the study, the greater the understanding. There is no doubt that the supreme place for Buddhist studies are the three seats of Sera, Ganden and Drepung. His Holiness Dalai Lama has said this repeatedly because it is in the three seats that this analytical investigation of the Buddha Dharma occurs.

For instance, taking our topic, of the difference between the Hīnayāna and the Mahāyāna, one would debate to see what the difference is, what the point of juncture is, if there is such a point of juncture and so forth. For instance, if one speaks with a learned Theravadin and one tries to understand the difference between the Mahāyāna and the Theravada, it is not evident because the Theravada, just as the Mahāyāna, is rooted in the four noble truths. The foundation of the Mahāyāna is the four noble truths. Likewise, it is rooted in understanding of karma and causality. So what precisely is the difference?

For this study is necessary. If we take the case of Gesheera and Anila, Gesheera says, if we were to ask Anila, Anila, is the boundary between the Hīnayāna and the Mahāyāna? How do you define the actual difference? Very possibly, Anila would be at a loss for an answer. She wouldn’t know how to answer.

Now this is a very awkward state of affairs. If one was to answer and say yes, the Mahāyāna is a Lamrim, then that is not a correct answer. Or if one were to say, well the Mahāyāna is a practice of Yamāntaka, That also is not a correct answer. We should give Anil as an example, all of us must think about this for ourselves. That’s very important.

I thought, Then if you analyze carefully, for instance, in the Theravada, there is there are teachings about Jampa, about love, Maitri, and about compassion, Karunā. It would seem that there are no teachings about boundless, love and boundless compassion, And then if we take the Theravada countries, in other words Thailand, Burma, Cambodia, perhaps Laos, then the foundation of their practice is the Four Noble Truths. Therefore, some texts say that they do not focus on the practice of love and compassion. And if we analyze what the foundation of Theravada or Hīnayāna practices and the components which are shared with the Mahāyāna, it is the Four Noble Truths, the teaching on the 37 limbs of enlightenment, the teachings on the 12 links of dependent arising. There are clear teachings on, selflessness in the Theravada.

These are the teachings on the selflessness of persons. Then what is the difference between the Hīnayāna and the Mahāyāna? The difference is motivation. And when we say motivation, what are we talking about? We are talking about altruism, the motivation to benefit others.

Therefore, it is very dangerous and inappropriate to set the Lamrim as a criterion for being a Mahāyāna practitioner. Instead, it is the motivation which is the criterion. The motivation of a Theravada practitioner would be striving for liberation from cyclic existence for his or her own sake. Then whether we have even something close to that is for us to examine. It is already rare.

And therefore, what is critical is at the beginning to have 100% of an altruistic motivation. We can clearly see the dangers of the lack of altruism in the development of the situation in Burma and how it has spread through Assam to all of India. As you know, there is civil strife and unrest in Burma and it spread eventually to the Bodo communities in Assam, which are in a state of de facto civil war with their Muslim neighbors. This has spread throughout India and has impacted Bangalore. So the police actually warned all the monks of Sera Je monastery and the other seats not to leave the monasteries and told them that they could not take responsibility for what happened if they left the monasteries.

Even the neighboring village of Kushanmadaw, which is some forty minutes from Sera Je, is de facto sealed off. And this is a result of a purely verbal affirmation of one’s faith. The statement I am a Buddhist, I am a Christian, I am a Muslim without any inner understanding. If there were an inner understanding of the teachings, probably this would not happen. Cannot say with 100% certainty this didn’t happen in Tibet.

He thinks it’s highly improbable that among Tibetan Buddhists and the folk traditions, the Nyingma, Kagyu, Sakya and Geluk traditions, there was anything of this order. In Lhasa, there were some Muslims, only a few, and it is said they came from Nepal. Therefore, Geshela has explained two main topics in this introduction. The first is, a recognition of the existence of past and future lives as well as karma and causality. And the second is altruism.

It is on the basis of this recognition of past and future lives that over and again, one should generate an altruistic motivation. And if that altruistic motivation is generated 100%, then probably one can say one is a being of the great vehicle, a Mahāyāna being. Therefore, this is what we should do over and again when we generate the motivation. Therefore, we will now meditate for two minutes on generating this authentic motivation, which wishes to listen to teachings on the virtuous friend, the spiritual friend, with the pure motivation of exclusively wishing to benefit others. At that point, this teaching becomes graduated stages of the path.

And therefore, Geshela would like to strongly encourage you to read those books which demonstrate, which bring evidence for the existence of past and future lives, are available in English. And after reading them, you should not just investigate them by yourselves, you should actually discuss them with others. It is through this process of discussion that your understanding will become firm. Otherwise, it will not be firm. This firm understanding which arises through analysis is what is known as an inferential valid cognizer through its own force.

From within the division of inferential valid cognizers into inferential valid cognizers through their own force and their inferential valid cognizers out of repute. So it is this inferential valid cognizer out of its own force which one wants to generate. Then development in one’s own Buddhist practice does not come through accumulating the retreats. It does not come at all in this fashion, it comes through this process of thinking, debating and analysis. This is what leads to mental transformation.

For instance, Wednesday before the teachings, if you come at five or some at 06:30, instead of sitting in the foyer and gossiping, which is a complete waste of time, you should instead use that time to discuss the existence of past and future lives and of karma and causality. This is of true benefit. All of us like to gossip. All of us like idle talk. Geshela himself enjoys idle talk as well, but it is a very good way to waste a human life and to waste time.

Therefore, instead of engaging in idle talk, when you meet someone, chat for five minutes and then spend your time talking about something which for once is meaningful. And do this in a dialogue. Don’t just engage in a monologue because it’s in the dialogue that your understanding will deepen. And therefore this passage of Je Tsongkhapa in which Je Tsongkhapa says, since all of the mundane and super mundane qualities without exception arise through relying on a fully qualified virtuous friend, engage in the actual body of the practice. This is an extremely profound introduction to the practice of the graduated stages of the path.

One must rely on a spiritual friend, but not any spiritual friend, a fully qualified spiritual friend and he is the root of all qualities. And in the outline of the LAMRI, we have reached the fourth outline, which says the foundation of the path is relying on the virtuous friend or the spiritual teacher and having relied on him how to practice. Here, the path referred to in the foundation of the path is none other than the three principles of the path, which is definite emergence, bodhichitta and the correct view. And having engaged and reliance on the spiritual teacher, we in turn engage in the practice of that. And therefore it is through building on the foundation of conviction in the existence of past and future lives and karma and causality, that in turn, one’s practice of relying on one’s mentor, on one’s teacher will skyrocket.

This is quite extraordinary, isn’t it? Geshela cannot speak of other cultures, but certainly in the Tibetan tradition, one’s teacher, one’s tutor is considered as kind in imparting teachings to us as one’s mother. And this is foundational for the Lamrim. And therefore, starting by building on a profound conviction in the existence of past and future lives and on a conviction in the operativeness of karma and causality, in turn one will become much closer to the dharma. Becoming much closer to the dharma, one in turn becomes much closer to the teacher who imparts the dharma.

As one becomes closer to him in turn, his advice becomes much more pregnant with meaning for us. It is the same thing in worldly matters. If you have a lover or if you are with someone whom you really love, then whatever they tell you will be very powerful for your mind, much more powerful than what some unknown person says. All the more so, if this is a person of whom you can say this is someone of irreproachable ethics, honest and pure. And therefore, in worldly affairs, when we encounter someone who is forthright by nature, who is honest and irreproachable, this person’s advice has great weight for us.

Likewise, as far as dharma is concerned, we do not talk about this life. Dharma begins with the next life and the advice which is given in the context of dharma is for the betterment in future lives, to attain happier status in future lives. The spiritual teacher is one who gives such advice. Since Geshela’s motivation is not in the slightest, to encourage you to have faith of any type in him, he can speak about this bluntly and honestly. His goal is to encourage us to engage in dharma practice and dharma practice means initially to study and on that basis to practice, there is no practice without this.

And for this, one needs an authentic spiritual teacher of the like of His Holiness, the Dalai Lama or our teacher Khensur Rinpoche. On Thursday, And precisely because there are those who try to delude others even in the Tibetan tradition, it is critical that you examine very carefully before engaging in this relationship. Otherwise, there is a very big risk down the line of feeling quite silly. If one has well studied and one practices, there is no danger in having however many spiritual teachers one wishes for. Atisha, for instance, had 152 gurus.

That’s true. 152 teacher. This was the case formerly when one had spiritual teachers who were fully qualified, who had all the qualities of study and practice. And if one wishes to understand what the benefits of such an approach are, there are eight benefits to relying correctly on the spiritual teacher. And the first of these is listed on page six seventy six of your outline of Meaningful to Behold.

It is outline four eleven two eleven. You will come closer to Buddhahood. What is meant here is that if a spiritual teacher who is fully qualified in terms of studies and meditation gets a disciple who is himself fully qualified in terms of aspiration and effort, Then it is said, it is akin to holding Buddhahood in one’s hand. Now such a disciple would be the likes of Milarepa. And here, when one refers to a fully qualified spiritual teacher, it is a spiritual teacher who can teach the totality of the path.

Then Geshela fully understands that for us it is difficult to practice on this level. The teachings have been present in Australia for the last maybe fifty, sixty years, fifty years perhaps. Then, we ourselves are new to the teachings, we lack this energy. Therefore, what is necessary for us is to proceed slowly and to implant karmic imprints within our mind. So this is the first advantage, we will come closer to Buddhahood.

The second advantage, four eleven to 12, it pleases the victorious ones, in other words the Buddhas. We ourselves at present cannot see the Buddhas and the Bodhisattvas which surround us. Why, however, does it please us to please them that we rely on the spiritual teacher? Because in so doing, we are fulfilling their objectives. It is said in The Essence of Nectar Lamrim in the same way as a mother is delighted when another helps her child.

This refers, as an example, the situation where a mother sees someone else giving something to her child, helping her child and she herself is delighted. Likewise, the Buddhas are delighted by the help our Guru extends to us. The third advantage is that one will not be disturbed by demons or bad company, outlined four point one one two point three. And the meaning of this outline is that through constantly thinking of how to please one’s teacher, for instance our teacher, who is going on 88, then in turn the ability of evil spirits or demons to harm us dwindles. Now here when we speak of evil spirits or demons, Geshela sees this as referring to conceptions and harmful fantasies.

It is clear that in Tibet, people believed and knew of the existence of various classes of spirits such as the 10, the king spirits or the ghosts and so forth. However, when Geshela is all alone here in the evenings, to be frank with you that is not what he fears. Since this is a very big building, he is rather afraid of thieves and they are quite material. You’re very lucky in Australia that they are rare and that if you close the doors there is little risk. However, in Tibetto and India, it is an altogether different situation.

The fourth advantage for 11 to 14, you will automatically put a stop to all delusions and misdeeds in Tibetan. They will actually dwindle by their own force. This only occurs if one relies on a fully qualified spiritual teacher and it doesn’t occur automatically, it occurs through our own efforts. If we do not put the effort, it doesn’t happen. Likewise, the fifth advantage, one’s insight and realizations into the levels of the path will increase.

They will once again only increase through our own effort and not through the teachers imparting them somehow. Likewise, the sixth advantage on page six seventy seven, you will not be deprived of virtuous spiritual guides in all your future rebirth, virtuous friends in all your future rebirth. This is similar to the deed of engaging correctly with respect to the spiritual friend. Likewise, for the seventh advantage, you will not fall into the lower realms. It is certain with 100% certainty that if one relies correctly on a fully qualified spiritual friend, one will not experience lower rebirths.

The final eighth advantage, one will effortlessly realize both one’s contingent and ultimate goals. This means that through having met such a fully qualified spiritual friend and engaging from one’s own side in study and in practice, we will actualize all of our spiritual goals. Think Geshela would not explain all of this. He would encourage us to read the section from page two eighteen to page two twenty eight in which a very beautiful account of parts of the life of Dromtonpa, Atisha’s closest disciple, is given. Dromtonpa, as you know, relied very closely on Atisha and was never separated from Atisha.

Another disciple of Atisha, Mahayogi Ngok, constantly engaged in retreats and they compared their realizations. Then we will stop here for today. And if you have questions, Geshela is open to your questions. Then Geshe lah asked me to recommend one because I read in English. Geshe lah himself is putting effort at learning English.

I strongly and heartily recommend Stevenson’s, Ian Stevenson’s works. We have them in the library. You can start by reading 20 cases of the reincarnation type. And if you are a dedicated and hardworking student, reincarnation in biology in two volumes is a masterpiece. We have it in the library.

It is maybe one year of work, but you will gain a very sound understanding on that basis. In Dharmakīrti’s Pramāna Vartika, in the second chapter, there are numerous reasonings which demonstrate this. I have translated them to some of my seminars. I don’t think it’s translated in English. It’s very detailed presentation, the second chapter of the Pramāna Vartika.

And you have a magnificent work translated in English, Shāntarakshita’s Tattvasamgraha, translated by Ganganatha Jha and Kamalaśīla’s commentary. It’s published by Motilal. It’s a masterpiece. Generally speaking, in the Tibetan tradition, one relies on Dharma Kirti’s Pramāna Vartika and Gyaltsab Je’s commentary called Clarifying the Path to Liberation. Yes.

Yes. I’m happy to give the bibliography again to whoever wants it. To rely correctly on the spiritual teacher means not merely to rely verbally on the spiritual teacher, but to apply, to put in practice the teachings and the transmissions which are given to one by the spiritual teacher. Moreover, if one meets a fully characterized spiritual teacher, to rely correctly on him means to study whatever he says and to put whatever he says into practice. Yeah.

No, there’s no specific need. It is actually in the process of study that an understanding of the four bodies of the Buddha will arise. There is no immediate benefit for one’s practice of an understanding of the four bodies of the Buddha. Perhaps the greatest quality of the noble Milarepa, of Jetsün Milarepa, was what the Tibetans called his, the bone of the heart, the bony heart. It means his perseverance, his courage, his inner strength, his determination.

This is that aspect which we have to train him. Whatever Milarepa studied from his teacher, he put into practice. In our cases, all of us enjoy theoretically the prospect of becoming Arhats or Buddhas. The practice isn’t there. So what we have to do is put in practice what we study and this not over one or two days but over a lifetime.

Most definitely, this is 100% true. If you look at the features of someone’s life now, you can deduce from that what they must have done in the past to get there. For instance, if you take great wealth, we know that some people accumulate great wealth through tremendous hardship and effort. But for others, it simply lands in the palm of their hand without any particular effort. Where does this difference come from?

It comes from the practice of generosity in previous lives. If that comma is not present, even if you put great effort, you would not get the money. That’s not the case. Not everything is connected to comma. Otherwise, Geshela’s drinking or not drinking a glass of water would be a result of past comma.

So you have to analyze. You have to analyze. For instance, for some, a very ugly appearance in this life, a very dark expression might just be the result in this life of ruminating on their failures. That would not necessarily be a karmic result. Geshela will think about it quietly in this further next time.

Now I don’t know. But

Key terms in this teaching

four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Kagyü
The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Marpa, Milarepa, Gampopa, and their followers. One of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. Cf. Nyingma, Sakya and Gelug. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
Nyingma
The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top