Lam Rim – Lamrim080616wed 4 – KR

1 h 36 min · 4,758 words

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - Lamrim080616wed 4 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Continues the Lam Rim teaching, moving from the small-scope path to the middling and great-scope paths. It explains the four noble truths and definite emergence as the basis of the middling path, then bodhichitta grounded in great compassion. The talk presents self cherishing as the root of suffering, teaches the equalization and interchange of self and others, and closes with questions on giving up self cherishing.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 36m

UUID: 5c1b723f-ac15-4c3c-bfc4-14a1263a3522

Words: 4,754

Therefore, let’s do like this from today onwards. Proceed as what is of greatest benefit for yourselves. If it is of greatest benefit, as I suggested, to listen to the teachings and try to remember, then do in that way. And if on the other hand, you find greater benefit in taking notes, you can’t let loose of your notes, then proceed in that way. So we’ll explain a little bit of the path of being shared with the small and of the middling scope.

Then at times when one doesn’t have the possibility, the time to do so, one can proceed in this way. Otherwise, one can engage in a complete overview of the path. Then some of you are new here, so I think it will be beneficial for you. Then one wants to gain some type of certainty in this matter. So as I explained previously, there are seven cycles or topics of meditation within the path shared within the being of the small scope.

Now within these seven topics, which or which one is the essential one? Can you answer quickly? Please? Then that is not quite it. Obviously, I heard something you didn’t hear, when Khensur Rinpoche taught because Khensur Rinpoche always said that the core practice of the being of the small scope was practicing virtue and relinquishing non virtue.

Then, as far as death and impermanence is concerned, that is somewhat different. Death and impermanence, meditation on death and impermanence is what impels us to practice. As Je Tsongkhapa says in the three principles of the path, realizing that this rebirth of leisure and endowment is profoundly meaningful and that time is short. Turn the mind away from the vanities of this life. Now here, the statement that time is short refers to the practice of death and impermanence.

Turning away from the vanities of this life precisely is this training in virtue and relinquishment of non virtue. Then as Je Tsongkhapa says, definitely, as long as the thought of death has not arisen, there will be no practice. The thought of death is therefore what impels us to train in virtue. And clearly, this respect, thinking of death and impermanence is a preliminary to engaging in virtuous practice. Then as Jetsun Milarepa said, think first of death.

It is on this basis that practice arises. So clearly, the core practice of the being of the small scope within the varieties of practices is the practice of causality. And when we speak of causality, this actually abuts on training in virtue and abandoning non virtue. The practice of training in the 10 virtues might seem straightforward, but it is quite complicated when we reflect on it in detail. For instance, the three mental non virtues are actually very difficult to train incorrectly.

So this is how one should train, then you understand the seven topics. The precious human human rebirth, its rarity, its transitoriness, death and impermanence, the suffering of the lower realms, refuge and karma and causality. So we have now finished the very brief presentation of the path shared with the being of the small scope. It’s been covered over a long time here. Let’s pass to the path shared with the being of the middling scope.

Now here, a path includes abandonments and attainments. Practice is a practice of abandoning the abandonments. What are the abandonments of the path of the middling scope here? So you’ve only spoken of what’s to be abandoned. What is to be taken on board?

What’s to be practiced? Practice means that you give or you abandon something and you gain something in the process. We said practice is abandonment and acquisition. So what is acquired? So at the level of the path which is shared with the being of the middling scope, the object of abandonment is the first two truths, the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering.

What is acquired are the two last truths, the truth of cessation and of the path, and the means for this is the wisdom realizing emptiness. As is said in the scriptures of the conquerors, abandon and acquire the four noble truths. What is abandoned are the first two noble truths. What is acquired are the two last noble truths. So this is therefore what is abandoned, the two first truths.

Now what are the causes or the conditions for this? So at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope, the condition of engagement is meditation on death and impermanence. Now at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope, what is the condition of engagement in the path? It is the thought of definite emergence indeed. As Je Tsongkhapa says in his concise Lamrim, without striving at understanding the faults of the noble truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering, how can the mind wishing for liberation be generated?

So here, initially, one generates a realization of the thoughts of the first two truths, and independence on this, the mind striving for liberation, in other words, definite emergence, is generated. Then it is very good. You understand. You should practice a bit now. This is a very pleasant line of reasoning then.

This is how one proceeds to subdue one’s mind. Initially, one must understand how to subdue the mind, and then one must engage in subduing the mind. But to do this in one day, that is very difficult. It is something which one engages in over time, gradually, incrementally. Then the reason we say it is difficult is precisely because of our lack of courage.

This lack of courage, which gives rise to the laziness, which causes us to procrastinate to keep deferring to tomorrow the practices which should be done today, arises fundamentally from grasping at permanence. We think we will be around forever, and therefore, there is no particular reason to rush in practice. So this is what we want to cover on the path shared as the being of the middling scope. What is the practice of the being of the great scope? So as we said, practice is abandoning and appropriating or acquiring.

So you acquire bodhichitta, what exactly do you abandon? Yes, why not? Then if that’s how you’re going to put it, altruism has to be what is acquired and egoism must be what is abandoned. So therefore, both the method and the wisdom aspect of the path meet in bodhichitta and what is to be abandoned here. And the object of abandonment here is self grasping.

Grasping at true existence. Then if the practice is to abandon self cherishing and to acquire cherishing others, what is the condition for engaging in this practice? So great compassion is therefore the cause for engaging in practice at the level of the great vehicle just as definite emergence is the cause for engaging in practice at the level of the being of the middling scope. When, definite emergence is extended to others, it becomes great compassion. Now, the objects of, observation of meditation at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope are in an abbreviated form, the four noble truths, or when developed, the, 12 limbs of dependent origination, both in the forward and in the reverse sequence.

So this is how one should proceed enumerating the objects of meditation at the level of the path of the small, the middling scope. And then if time is present, if one has time, one reflects on them. And at in this way, one gains an experience. I’m not talking here of realizations. Who has realizations, but some sort of experience.

And this acts as a cause for engaging in practice. So these feelings, these sensations are very powerful. Then they are the result of practice, and this just calls for time. I do not accept that you do not have the time to practice. That is just not true.

Everyone has half an hour or one hour. If you say you don’t have time, it is because you haven’t given up this life. It is a great fault to waste time. Even one minute which is not used well is a minute which we will never gain again. Therefore, of wasting our time, we should use time well.

Therefore, at the level of the path of the being of the great scope, one must generate bodhichitta and the cause of bodhichitta is great compassion. The aspect of great compassion is seeing all sentient beings as suffering, whereas the aspect of love is seeing all sentient beings as lovable. So this training in love and compassion abuts directly on training in the practice of giving and taking or Tonglen. And this arises from the actual interchange of self and others, which in turn arises from understanding both the thoughts of self cherishing or egoism and the qualities of cherishing others or altruism. So when we speak of the thoughts of self cherishing, the outline refers to thinking through numerous lines of reasoning, of the thoughts of self cherishing.

And this actually leads one to understand the faults of not giving up one’s body, which leads one to understand the fault of not giving up one’s body meaningfully. And this, not giving up one’s body meaningfully arises because one does not want to give up one’s body, which is a source of pleasure. So reflecting on the thoughts of self cherishing or egoism is of a great benefit for us in this life. For instance, we can see the impact of insatiability which the experience of suffering and of happiness, in other words, ourselves which grasps at a self, has. For instance, when we eat food, we are insatiable.

Then we eat and eat and eat, and eventually, not only is our stomach full, but we get bile disease. Then, we blame the food, and we say the food is the food’s fault. It was too rich. But the food is not guilty. The food is matter.

The food has no intention. The fault lies in our own self cherishing within ourselves. Then it is clearly our fault. Instead of viewing food as medicine, we approach food in a lustful fashion. And, when we overeat out of self cherishing, out of egoism, then as usual, instead of blaming ourselves, we blame others.

But what is strange here is that we don’t blame a conscious entity, we blame food, which has no consciousness at all. So it’s a thought of craving, the craving for food. This is it is this craving for food which causes suffering. So I am not saying that it is always the case that, we alone are responsible for the suffering which arises, let’s say, from eating food. From time to time, the food itself may not be suitable.

But overwhelmingly, it is our own self cherishing which is responsible for this type of suffering. So in brief, all suffering, in other words, both physical and mental suffering can be traced back to self cherishing. Then this applies not only to the small forms of suffering we talked about, but to the great horrors where people, out of egoism, kill their own father, kill their own mother, kill their own child. All this can be traced back to egoism or self cherishing. Therefore, egoism or self cherishing must be seen as our greatest foe, our greatest enemy.

As is said in the scriptures, of the conquerors, self cherishing is the root of all degeneration. Therefore, take exclusively revenge on it. The following outline, reflecting through numerous lines of reasoning on the qualities of cherishing others or altruism, it becomes very clear when we reflect on ourselves that our happiness depends on others. I’m not saying it depends totally on others. It does depend in part on ourselves.

But our happiness depends on others. It is a dependent origination which arises from others. Therefore, all happiness mainly arises in dependence on others. It is something we can see clearly if we take the case of a meal. Let’s take a meal for which we need vegetables.

Then these vegetables have to be grown by someone in soil. Someone else has, therefore, provided us with the vegetables. And if you were to say, well, actually, I owe nothing to this person because I paid for these vegetables. I gave them money. Money alone will not provide you with vegetables.

So I think all of us understand clearly that all our happiness arises from others. It is not that difficult to understand. We refuse to do so, however. And what is it which refuses to do so? Self cherishing or egoism.

Then through reflecting through numerous lines of reasoning on the thoughts of egoism and on the qualities of altruism, eventually through study, one will reach a point where one wishes to engage in the interchange of self and others. So you have all received numerous teachings on the interchange of self and others. However, what is really important is to understand the core meaning, the central meaning. What is the core meaning of the interchange of self and others? Can you ask some?

Could you ask them? Are you talking of Tonglen here, of giving and taking? I’m asking you about the equalization and interchange of self and others. The equalization and the interchange of self and others is a means to give rise to generate or the practice of giving and taking. As it is a means to generate, it occurs before.

So within the path of the being of the great scope, the second subdivision of the second outline is devoted to mind training by means of the interchange of self and others. And this has five subdivisions. The first is equanimity. The second is the thoughts of self cherishing. The third, the qualities of cherishing others.

The fourth, the actual thought of the interchange of self and others. And the fifth, in dependence on this training in giving and taking or Tonglen. As these are in sequence, they follow each other. In other words, each one arises after the previous one is finished or culminated. This is the case for every single step of the Lam Rim.

They do not coexist. So it actually is quite difficult to understand what is meant by the equalization and the interchange of self and others. It is quite easy to use the words to speak of self cherishing, cherishing others, equalization and interchange of self and others, bodhichitta. These are all words. But the meaning is actually very difficult to understand and to generate.

So to start with, when we speak of the equalization and the interchange of others, that doesn’t mean that somehow I will swap places and bodies with your, and he sits here and I sit there. We are two different mental continuums. That is obviously not possible. Then in Lamrim Cemo, there are numerous refutations of the viewpoints of great scholars regarding the practice of equalization and the interchange of self and others. There are these refutations precisely because there are problems in the understanding of this practice.

If there were no difficulties, why would you bother with the refutations? It would be a waste of time. So what does the Lamrim say on the equalization and the interchange of self and others? Lamrim Chemo explains that the interchange of self and others means to interchange the position of self cherishing and relinquishing others. At present excuse me, the position of self cherishing and of cherishing others.

At present, the suffering of others is indifferent to us. And whether they experience happiness or suffering is nothing to us. We have no reaction. On the other hand, our own happiness and suffering is of very great importance to us. Now the interchange of self and others means to interchange these two outlooks.

It is possible to swap outlooks. So basically, what occurs here is after repeated habituation, so reflecting on the faults of self cherishing or egoism and on the qualities of cherishing others or altruism, eventually, the mental factor, the aspect of the mind, which is focused on oneself, eventually focuses on others. And the aspect of the mind which was disregarding others and focused in disrespect respecting others focuses on oneself. This is what is meant by the inter interchange of self and others. So please reflect carefully on this interchange of the positions of self cherishing or egoism and cherishing others or altruism.

It is important. It is covered in detail in. So the outlook of the interchange of self and others and of the practice of giving and taking, is at times quite similar. It is a characteristic of study that one tries to understand the differences. So as Śāntideva says in Bodhicharyavatara, engage in this practice of the interchange of self and others in great secret.

This was indeed a secret practice of the Kadampas. It was a practice for beings of extremely sharp acumen. Beings like ourselves are obviously beings of dull acumen. So for us, this practice is difficult. There are two types of beings of dull acumen for which this practice is difficult, and I’d like you to think about this.

The first is being like beings like ourselves, ordinary beings, but the second are beings who have generated uncontrived definite emergence. Now, why is this practice difficult for beings who have generated stable definite emergence or uncontrived definite emergence. The mode of difficulty is the following. It is not the case that beings who have generated uncontrived definite emergence do not value, the state of full enlightenment. Naturally, they value the body, speech, and mind of the Buddha since it is this body, speech, and mind of the Buddha which is a source of the teachings which they rely upon.

Actually, bodhisattvas are the cause of Buddhas. So, we ourselves, are in the same situation as these, practitioners of the middling scope. We value, we admire the, teachings of the Mahāyāna, the attainment of full enlightenment and so forth. So these beings of dull acumen value these teachings of the Mahāyāna. They value the interchange of self and others.

They value bodhichitta. They value the state of full enlightenment, But they think this is too difficult. I mean, who can practice the interchange of self and others? I certainly can’t. I must take care of number one.

I must attain my own liberation. Then even though such a being is actually a very advanced practitioner who has all the realizations of the being of the small scope, therefore has turned away from the vanity of this life, has given up this life completely, and has also the realizations of the being of the middling scope. In other words, has turned away from cyclic existence in general, from all rebirths. And therefore, even though such a being should find it very easy to engage in the practice of the interchange of self and others, this practice is very difficult for such a being. So such a being, in other words, a being who has generated mere uncontrived definite emergence finds it therefore very difficult for this reason to train in the interchange of self and others.

In our case, likewise, and when I say our case, it is ordinary beings like us in this room, we find it very difficult to train in the interchange of self and others for a different reason. Mainly because we have not given up on happiness. We have not given up on the happiness of this life. We have not turned away from the vanities of this life. And as a result, we find it almost impossible to train in the interchange of self and others.

Even though it is quite straightforward to explain the practice of the interchange of self and others, it is something which is very distant for us simply because we are completely unable to give up our obsession with the happiness of this life. Then I cannot help but feel that those who have given up the vanities of this life and who have given up the miseries of cyclic existence as well will find it a little bit easier to train in the interchange of self and others than us. So in the context of our reflection on the Mahāyāna, I would like us at present to think first on the thoughts of self cherishing or egoism, and then on the fact that all our happiness arises from others. And I would like us to examine this with an impartial, open mind to see whether this is the case or not. Mhmm.

Let us meditate during Over the playbook, Page one, we recite 1B, two, three, four and also Page five, number six, Mandalorian, verse one and three. Thank you. So what is difficult, therefore, is to understand the self cherishing or the egoism within our own mind stream. We should not focus on the egoism outside of us, within the minds of others. Now, as far as self cherishing or egoism is concerned, there are several modalities of self cherishing.

Broadly speaking, three. The self cherishing or the egoism within the minds of ordinary beings like ourselves. Then the self cherishing or the egoism within the minds of fully characterized practitioners of the small scope who have given up on the vanities of this life. And then the self cherishing or egoism within the mind stream of fully characterized practitioners of the middling scope who have given up on the vanities of all lives. Now whether there is self cherishing or egoism within the mind stream of Mahāyāna practitioners is a difficult question.

Since Mahāyāna practitioners have already generated bodhichitta, there should be no self cherishing. Then what is very helpful to us is to reflect on these three types of self cherishings and their differences. So, what are the differences between these three types of self cherishing? For us, ordinary beings, it is the incapacity to give up, our own interests and advantages in this life. In other words, our incapacity to, give up this body.

Then, for beings of the middling scope, what precisely is their self cherishing or egoism? It is much more subtle. It is actually the incapacity to, give up it is the incapacity to give up the bliss of liberation. So we’ll stop here for today. And if you have questions, we’ll take a couple of questions.

I don’t really understand what giving up one’s body actually means or the incapacity of giving up one’s body. So we call giving up one’s body in this context, giving up one’s benefits or happiness within this life. For instance, if you were to have a telephone or a watch and you were unable to give it away, then that would qualify as being unable to give one’s body. So we’re talking more instead of the physical body as opposed to the mental approach to how we see the body? My apologies.

It’s my it’s a mistake in translation. These are exactly homophonous interpretation. It’s mentally giving up, not giving up one’s body. It’s mentally giving up, not giving up one’s body. So it’s the incapacity to give things up mentally.

So here, this incapacity to give things up mentally is what one must counter by means of mind training. Just following on from those last two questions. In the case of being asked to give up one’s watch or one’s phone, if you could mentally do that but not physically like, could you mentally do that but not physically do it? The inexpensive way of doing it. Right?

So it’s a bit strange to give up mentally but not to follow-up physically. Right? There’s no relation, is there? So mental relinquishment or giving up mentally has numerous aspects. One can give up one’s wealth, one’s prosperity, one’s body.

There are numerous aspects. Another? Another questions. Just hold the microphone to chin. Keshe la, I recall many, teachings ago you gave an instruction for catching a bus and your instruction was the seat next to you or the seat you’re sitting in, the seat next to you is not for your own possessions, it’s it’s the its purpose is for another person to sit down on.

So beware of placing one’s own possessions next to one in the seat. Is this when you gave this teaching or is this a good way of thinking of giving up one’s you know, think having the mind that says, this is my seat, which is totally ludicrous. Is this an example of, countering self cherishing? This keeping the seat next to you free is quite similar to a practice of altruism because after all, that seat may be required by someone who does not have a seat and you are thinking of that person. Then, it’s obviously very difficult, when one travels by bus or by train, one becomes very narrow minded, very stingy, and one’s possessions come first.

This small. Another question? In regard to the whether there is self cherishing in the great scope, I thought that if the antidote to self cherishing is bodhichitta and that full enlightenment would indicate that the training in bodhichitta has been completed. So surely there would be still self cherishing within the great scope. So we will look into it, quietly.

Basically, altruism and egoism are mutually contradictory. In other words, when altruism is is present, egoism cannot be present in reciprocally. Now since, bodhisattvas have, given rise to bodhichitta and have generated altruism, how exactly could egoism be present? This is something we have to examine. If egoism is present, their bodhichitta would have degenerated.

Then, if you think of the following example, you will understand, when anger or wrath is present, within one’s mind, then love is not present. And when love is present within one’s mind, then anger or wrath is not present. They cannot be present at the same time within the mind. They are incompatible or contradictory. And, Yasmin?

About the self cherishing, if you want to eliminate, can we use the method of, like a mother cherish their children and extending the love and use that method to extend to all sentient beings? Most definitely, once one is able to extend the love a mother has for her child, the cherishing a mother has for her child to all beings whomsoever one meets, and this is spontaneous, one has abandoned self cherishing. Yeah. Geshela with people who I suppose I’m thinking of Hīnayāna who have achieved the bliss of personal liberation and I understand it’s very difficult to leave but some of them then go to the Mahāyāna. What impels them?

What makes them give up that self cherishing that you mentioned? So once an Ahat, let us say, an Arhat, a hearer Arhat has entered the bliss of liberation, then they are in a state of meditative equipoise, which is extremely blissful. And until they leave that state of meditative equipoise, it will not be possible for them to enter the Mahāyāna. It is very difficult for them to leave the state, and, they remain in the state for a large number of eons. But even after leaving it, it is difficult for them to enter the Mahāyāna.

They will not leave the meditative equipoise, of liberation rapidly. They must encounter a spiritual teacher of the Mahāyāna, and even so, it will not happen rapidly. Anshaya? My question is regarding the inability to give up this body, and sometimes we do things for people or give things for people physically, but we hold some mental tension, what I do, afterwards. So it’s not genuine altruism.

So is Geshela saying the best way to counter that mental tension and facilitate better altruism through Tonglen. First one, must understand clearly what this mental tension, this unhappiness comes from. Then whether or not giving and taking can eliminate it depends. Fully qualified Tonglen arises in dependence on the actual thought of the interchange of self and others, which arises in dependence and understanding the thoughts of egoism and the qualities of altruism. Mhmm.

What’s the source of the unhappiness? What’s the source of attention? Since the source is ultimately self cherishing, then one should start by analyzing through numerous doors the thoughts of self cherishing. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top