1 h 39 min · 4,119 words · 18 April 2014
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching introduces the Seven Stanzas of Mind Training and its lineage, then covers the first stanza on training in the preliminaries. It explains meditation on death and impermanence as the core practice of the small-scope path, countering clinging to permanence and turning the mind toward future lives and virtue.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 40m
UUID: eecfc228-e74b-4815-bc85-ccb0d2548fce
Date: 2014-04-18
Words: 4,115
All of you have assembled this morning around 08:00 here at the center and have generated the requisite motivation for these teachings. Generally speaking, whatever deed one engages in, one needs a motivation to do so. Generally speaking, to generate the motivation, one should withdraw one’s mind inwards. If one one’s mind, however, is distracted or scattered outwards, then it is of benefit to engage in the nine cycles of breathing. However, if the mind is not scattered outwards, this is unnecessary.
Then without allowing one’s mind to fall under the sway of anger, of desire, or of envy, one should let it be just so, then there is great benefit in putting such a mind to work. Then the topic we shall be studying is bodhichitta, therefore, we should try to reflect on bodhichitta as much as we can. To generate a fully qualified motivation of the being of the great scope, it is indispensable to initially have generated a fully qualified motivation of the being of the small scope. Therefore, one should start by taking the resolve that one will turn one’s mind away completely from all the affairs of this life and focus exclusively on future lives, and then on this basis generate the motivation of the being of middling scope and so forth. Then for a couple of minutes, let us, generate quietly the motivation to attend these teachings.
Call card somebody. Deborah, you’re behind Who is the new gentleman behind you? Where are you from? Where are you from? In Adelaide.
I’m gonna take it easy since it’s Easter. I’m gonna have my cup of tea. The topic for the long Easter weekend teaching are the seven stanzas of mind training. Their author is the famous Seven training. 7.9 training.
I’m engaging Chekawa. If we trace the origin of the seven stanzas of mind training in Geshe Chekawa’s teaching, Geshe Chekhawa received them from Geshe Sharawa. Geshe Sharawa received them from Geshe Potawa. Geshe Potawa received them from Atisha’s foremost disciple, Geshe Dromtönpa. Dromtönpa himself received them from Atisha, and Atisha received them from his own teacher, Serlingpa, Sumatajvi.
The origin of this work lies in a passage by Geshe Langritampa, which Geshe Chekhawa read, which begins with the lines when envied by others. This verse had a huge impact on Geshe Chekhawa, and he tried to encounter its author. Unfortunately, Geshe Langritampa had passed on, but his disciple Geshe Sharawa was still living and Geshe Chekhawa met Geshe Sharawa. There is a relationship between the eight verses of mind training on the one hand, and the text we shall be studying, the seven stanzas on mind training on the other. The topic of the eight verses of mind training is the interchange of self and others.
Whereas, the topic of the seven stanzas of mind training includes this as well as the graduated stages of the path. The eight verses of my training. There are extraordinary accounts about these old Kadampa and Nyingma masters of yore who engage in this practice that they would live at peace with animals while engaging in their practice and so forth. The actual text of the seven stanzas of mind training begins with the verse, I pay homage to great benevolence. Here, great benevolence can be understood in terms of its implicit and explicit meanings.
The implicit meaning of, or the interpretable meaning of great benevolence is the deity which encapsulates great benevolence, which is Avalokiteśvara. Whereas the definitive meaning of great benevolence is great benevolence itself. Then you have the text in this book, Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun. It’s a very different edition from the one I shall be using, so I will translate directly from the Tibetan text. So the root text continues, for the sake of teaching the greatness or the nobility of the source of this dharma, the lineage arises from Serlingpa, who imparted the teachings on the essence of nectar of this instruction.
So here, the term essence of nectar of this instruction refers to the state which one is striving to attain, which is the state of full enlightenment. The foremost means to attain the state were taught by guru Suvarnadvipi as the equalization and the interchange of self and others. And therefore, the raison d’etre of the homage at the beginning of the treatise, I pay homage to a great benevolence, must be clearly understood in terms of the second line teaching the nobility of the source of this teaching. Great benevolence here refers to great compassion. Why is homage paid to great compassion?
Because great compassion is the cause of bodhichitta and bodhichitta as is explained in the second verse is the essence of the instruction imparted by guru Suvanna Deepi. It is attained through the foremost practice. He taught the interchange of self and others. It is said in Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun, Namkha Pel’s commentary, that, there actually were three different lineages of equalization and interchange of self and others. And these three different lineages were fused in the teachings of guru Suvarnadvipi, which are mentioned in the stanza.
It is from Suvanna Dhvipi that the lineage of the essence of the instructions proceeds. Then what were these three instructions which were fused in one, under the aegis of guru Suvarnadvipi? The first instruction of the equalization and interchange of self and others is to be found in Ārya Nāgārjuna’s Ratnāvali, the rosary garland. The second lineage of interchange and equalization of self and others is to be found in Asaṇga’s and Maitreya’s, Śrāvakabhūmi and Bodhisattva Bhumi. The third is to be found in Śāntideva’s works.
Then when three lineages are fused in one in this way, under the aegis of Guru Suvarnadvipi, they become uncommonly powerful. Following line, teaching the greatness of this dharma for the sake of generating veneration for the instruction begins with the verse akin to a diamond, a Vajra in Sanskrit, the sun or a grove of trees. Just as even a sliver of diamond remains because of its substance worth more than other precious stones, likewise this instruction is worth more than other instructions by its very nature. It enables one to attain the state of full enlightenment on the basis of the practice of the equalization and the interchange of self and others. This instruction is also similar to the sun, just as the sun eliminates darkness wherever it shines.
Likewise, this instruction for generating bodhichitta and specifically ultimate bodhichitta, the wisdom which realizes emptiness, eliminates the darkness of the grasping at a self wherever it shines. Finally, it is compared to a grove, a grove of medicinal plants. Just as a grove of medicinal plants heals all diseases, likewise, the ultimate bodhichitta can eliminate self grasping, whereas conventional bodhichitta counters self cherishing and extirpates it from the root. The root text continues. I will explain the meaning in this work, and the main topic of this treatise is presented in the two following verses.
When the five degenerations are widespread, they must be transformed into the path to enlightenment. The first verse, when the five degenerations are widespread, refers to the age we live in at present, the age during which Buddha Śākyamūni taught. Buddha Śākyamūni taught when the five degenerations were widespread. The topic of this treatise is a means to turn the five degenerations into the path to full enlightenment. It is open to debate whether it is possible to do so through the practices of the being of the small or the middling scope.
For instance, the five degenerations are probably an obstacle to the practice of the being of the middling scope. However, the being of the great scope transforms these five degenerations into the path to full enlightenment. How would it be possible to transform these five degenerations which are widespread into the path to full enlightenment? Let us take the example of a practitioner who has generated bodhichitta. In the age of the five degenerations, when others are beset by envy, by jealousy, by anger, and by desire, such a practitioner when confronted with them would think, why are they beset by this?
And influenced by bodhichitta, in other words, nothing else than altruism, the mind wishing to help others, would understand that these arise from his own karmic imprints which have arisen from ignorance. Then, it is quite straightforward to transform this into practice. Then moving onwards with our root text regarding the stages of the practice of the disciple of such an instruction, they are sevenfold. These are said to be sevenfold because in keeping with the name of this treatise, these seven stanzas or the sevenfold mind training, it has seven subdivisions. And the first such division is given in the following verse.
First, practice the preliminaries. Here, since the topic of this treatise is a generation of bodhichitta, the preliminaries are the stages of the path preceding this. In other words, the practice of the being of the small and of the middling scope. And the specific topic of the first subdivision is teaching the dharma on which one is to rely as a preliminary. Then what are these preliminaries?
First, it is the practice of the being of the small scope, which includes meditation on death and impermanence and karma and causality. Therefore, should meditate on death and impermanence initially as much as one can. And therefore meditating on the path of the being of the small scope as much as one can, one should meditate on death and impermanence. Then within the outline of the LAMREM, as you remember, we have two preliminary outlines, identifying the precious human rebirth and taking the essence of such a precious human rebirth. Identifying a precious human rebirth hinges on the features of this precious human rebirth, its rarity and its great meaningfulness, which are explained in terms of its nature, of causes and of examples.
These are all topics you should now be familiar with. I am firmly convinced that all of you are people who take only the essence of a precious human rebirth. Then we can put this topic aside, can’t we? In this context, the stanza of Śāntideva’s bodhisattvacharyavatara, if having at present obtained such a precious base, I do not extract its essence. What will there be more foolish and more idiotic than this is particularly powerful.
What indeed will be more foolish and what indeed will be more idiotic than this? I suspect that when we are delicately drinking a cup of tea, these stanzas will have little impact on our mind. However, when we listen to teachings like this, they should. And from within the twin outlines at the beginning of the Lamrim, inciting one to take the essence of a precious human rebirth, and how to take the essence of a precious human rebirth once thus identified. I shall not dwell on the first outline inciting one to take the essence of the human rebirth since all of you have forsaken your well earned repose during Easter, have forsaken your families and long walks in the wild, and instead have come here to attend three teachings for three long days.
And then, as a preliminary, if you can, it would be very beneficial to engage in the practice of the six preliminaries as I explained in mind training like the rays of the sun or liberation in the palm of your hand. These are means of acquiring physical and verbal verbal merit. And therefore, one should practice as follows, first reflect on the rarity of a human rebirth, a human base of leisure and endowment, and then reflect over and again on death and impermanence. And when one’s analytical meditation becomes unclear, visualize clearly in the space in front of oneself, the field of accumulation of merit with one’s most kind root teacher, and visualize nectar coming from one’s teacher and dissolving within one’s heart. And once again, one’s meditation will become clear.
Then the first verse of the sevenfold mind training is, as you remember initially, train in the preliminaries. The foremost preliminaries here are the practice of the being of the small scope, and foremost within these is meditation on death and impermanence. Then really there’s not a lot to say about this, since after all death is something we are all going towards. It’s him, isn’t it? Then independence on him we practice.
On the one hand it is true death and impermanence is our foremost enemy. On the other hand it is also true that without him there is no practice. And therefore, the very essence of practice hinges on remembering death and remembering impermanence. When one refers to the fear of death and impermanence, Togme Zangpo, as mentioned in the 37 practices of a bodhisattva quoted in mind trainings like the Ray of the Sun says that there are two main reasons for which most people fear death. The first is that one will be parted from all one’s kin and friends whom one cherishes so much and whom one will never ever see again.
The second is that one will be separated from all one’s possessions, the wealth, the houses, the money and so forth, which we have worked so hard to get and which we shall never see again. These however are not the true reasons for which one should fear death. Then such an anguish faced with death is not what is referred to here, it is unnecessary to have studied to have such fear. Such fear is a fear every single one of us has without exception. What is the manner in the rationale for fearing death?
It is the following, at the time of death, whether we are reborn in a higher or in a lower realm will already have been decided by our lives. At that point, the decision will have been taken. As Khensur Kangurwa Rinpoche said, quoting a stanza of Nāgārjuna’s Ratnāvali, which is particularly powerful in this context, from non virtue all suffering in the lower rebirths, from virtue the higher rebirths. At the time of death, we know very well what deeds we have engaged in and what we have abstained on. We know that to be reborn in the higher realms, we need huge waves of merit, and we know very well that none of us has accumulated this.
We know that to be reborn in the lower realms, non virtue is the condition, and we know through experience that our mind is filled with this. Therefore, it has been decided. Then, when during our last breath, during our agony, we look back on our our life and we realize we have accumulated no virtue worth talking about, and we say in Tibetan, aka, holy Moses. You really shouldn’t be laughing, know. When we say this, that fear is the fear we are talking about.
And as Je Tsongkhapa says, when thinking about death, we start preparing. Indeed, when thinking about death, we start preparing for the future. Then when one thinks in this way about death, a very powerful mind which strives for future lives will arise. This is the mind striving for future lives of the being of the small scope in my opinion.
Then what is this mind striving for future lives? What is it striving for? It is striving for happy rebirths. Then what are the causes of these happy rebirths? These happy rebirths are results.
Therefore, their causes are the corresponding causes, virtue. When such a mind arises, then we strive to engage in the practice of virtue. Then, at present, this is my own private view on the matter regarding motivation and how to train in this way. Virtue is subdivided into three, physical, verbal and mental virtue. Then in my opinion, from within the three types of virtue, physical, verbal, and mental virtue, It is the virtue, which is mentally arisen through meditation on impermanence and death, which acts as a main cause for higher rebirth.
Then I don’t know about you, but I have often wondered, it seems that there is so little practice of the being of this small scope. But when we understand that the very essence of this practice is meditation on death and impermanence, it may be a lot more than we think. How is it? Really? Good.
All of us have studied so many texts on the practice of the being of the small scope that we have a headache from it, but the key here is to get the essence, as Khensur Kangurwa Rinpoche said, get the essence of the essence. Therefore, what is the core practice of the being of the small scope? It is meditation on death and impermanence, and meditation on death and impermanence is the foremost antidote to the apprehension of one’s own permanence. Here, when one speaks of one’s own permanence, one does not refer to the permanence of one’s five aggregates, form, sensation, discrimination, composition of factors, and consciousness. One refers to the delusion of permanence of one’s own body, the idea that I’m going to be around for a long time, and independent from this, one needs to have all the conditions for a comfortable life, wealth, relatives, friends, and one engages in numerous activities for this.
Meditating on death and impermanence counters this, and as Khensur Kangurwa Rinpoche, the holy teacher said, this is the essence of the practice of the being of the small scope, it counters the apprehension of our permanence. It’s a very profound oral instruction. The key antidote of the being of the small scope counters the apprehension of our own permanence. The key antidote of the being of the middling scope counter self grasping. The key antidote of the being of the great scope, counter self cherishing.
As his holiness the Dalai Lama said during last year’s teachings in brief, we need to give rise to the antidotes against self grasping and self cherishing. The antidote to self grasping is the wisdom, understanding selflessness. The antidote to self cherishing is bodhichitta. In other words, we need to give rise to wisdom and method. Then considering the emphasis placed upon meditation on death and impermanence, you might wonder how precisely does one meditate on death and impermanence.
One starts by taking oneself as an example, and one reflects on the fact that ever since we were born out of our mother’s womb, we have been progressing inexorably towards our own death, just as a stone which is dropped. If you drop a stone, it never rises back towards you. It progresses or it drops all the way down to the floor. Then in the case of our own death, when the time comes doctors will be of no help, we cannot fight it, medicine will be of no use, there will be nothing which can avert it, it is actually the way things are, it is the nature of things. It is extremely beneficial for all of us in this room to think that sixty or seventy years from our from now not a single person present in this room will still be alive, nobody will even remember who you were.
Now if you reflect on this, this is very powerful for your minds. At that time only dharma can protect our minds, then if you think in this way, a couple days from now when you hear of the difficulties people are facing, let’s say planes disappearing, wars breaking out, you will think just how comfortable our present situation is. There are great waves of benefit therefore in meditating oneself in this way on death and impermanence. Sleep. Then, if we meditate in this way on death and impermanence, as the realizations of death and impermanence become more powerful within our mind stream, we realize that this life is extremely short indeed, and the importance we attach to this life dwindles, whereas the importance we attach to future lives increases.
In the same same way as for instance, someone who is facing imminent death in a couple days is going to make no particular preparations for the following two or three days, likewise we will make no particular preparations for this life but will focus instead on future lives. This is how meditation on death and impermanence leads one to focus on future lives. Khensur Rinpoche said it is a matter of countering the predilection for this life. It is not a matter of countering the figments, nangshi in Tibetan of this life. In other words, it is not the case that meditating this way, we’re gonna throw our house away, our clothes away and so forth.
And therefore, it is the predilection for this life, this clinging to this life, which will be weakened by these meditations. Then the appearances of this life, the figments of this life, we actually need. We need clothing to wear, we need food to eat and so forth. Then during the meditation session, we train our minds in this fashion, focusing them upon death and impermanence, and during the periods between the meditative sessions, when we go around with our daily affairs, we engage mainly in physical and verbal activities. Then, through the power of meditation on death and impermanence, it is definite that the non virtues, the unsuitable deeds of body and speech engaged in between meditative sessions will greatly decrease.
Then in dependence on such meditation on death and impermanence during the meditative session, during the breaks, between the meditative sessions, we will be careful about our behavior. Otherwise, there would be no point, would there? Then I believe that through meditating during the meditative session with one’s mind on death and impermanence, between the meditative sessions, this this meditation on death and impermanence will carry through and influence our deeds of body and mind, will both increase the virtuous deeds leading to higher rebirth in future lives, and will decrease the non virtuous deeds which might lead to lower rebirth. Then there’s not a lot more left to say about the practice of the being of the small scope, in dependence on engaging in activities such as generosity, ethics, forbearance, enthusiasm, concentration and wisdom for future lives, we will accrue good results in future lives. Specifically, the deeds of generosity and ethics, the ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues engaged in during the meditative session and in between will lead to such results.
Then foremost among the practices of the being of the small scope are meditation on death and impermanence and on karma and causality And through correctly meditating on death and impermanence, one ushers the meditations on karma and causality. And therefore as I said in mind training like the rays of the Sun, through meditating on death and impermanence, one will be wary regarding activities of this lives and those concerning future lives, and one will relinquish engaging in non virtuous deeds. And we will maybe leave questions and answers for this afternoon and stop at present on the practice of the being of the small scope, addressing the practice of the being of the middling and the greater scope later on in the teachings. Then in our case, the focus of our practice is the practice of the being of the great scope. We study the Mahāyāna Dharma and we say we practice the Mahāyāna Dharma.
It is taught that one should initially practice the practice of the being of the small scope to be able to pass up to the practice of the being of the middling scope, and then practice the practices of the being of the middling scope to pass up to those of the great scope. This is a difficult point which we should reflect upon. Why is it indispensable? What is the uncommon connection between the practices of the being of the small scope, which leads up to the practices of the being of the being of the middling scope? And what is the uncommon connection which makes the practices of the being of the middling scope indispensable as a prelude to those of the great scope?
And we will stop here for this morning. Then there is no need to make any prayers or recitations. Left. If we could if we could excuse me. If we could just not have talking in the Gompa excuse me.
If if we could not have talking in the Gompa because people might wanna just do some meditation and reflect. Thank you. And lunch will be soon. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- bhumi sa (Tib, Wyl)
- Ground, or level, as in the ten bodhisattva levels. LYWA
- chulen
- Literally, “taking the essence.” Chulen pills are made of essential ingredients; taking but a few each day, accomplished meditators can remain secluded in retreat for months or years without having to depend upon normal food. LYWA
- definitive meaning nitartha (Skt); ngedön (Tib)
- One of two main ways of understanding a Dharma teaching, this one is where the content is be taken literally and not open for interpretation, as opposed to the interpretive meaning. LYWA
- five degenerations
- The degenerations that occur as human beings evolve over the eon of existence; they are: the degeneration of disturbing thoughts, of lifespan, of time, of view and of sentient beings. LYWA
- Nyingma
- The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.