Lam Rim – LAMRIM (Salam 4

1 h 30 min · 4,134 words

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - LAMRIM (Salam 4
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains the Lam Rim outline, beginning with the exhortation to take the essence of a precious human rebirth by using the human mind’s capacity for self-reflection. It holds that lasting happiness depends on mental transformation and self-sufficient contentment rather than external possessions. It then covers renunciation and focus on future lives in the path of the small scope, and briefly touches on bodhicitta and emptiness in the greater scopes.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 31m

UUID: 0e9639d0-c46d-4fa3-b181-1cfed68b830e

Words: 4,130

Sometimes it’s very helpful to reflect on the outline of, Lam Rim, specifically Lam Rim Chemo, because it is a very succinct formulation of practice. And the outline of the Lam Rim includes these two sections. First, inciting one to take the essence of a life of leisure and endowment, and secondly, how to do so. And, in these two outlines, inciting one to take the essence of a human rebirth of leisure endowment and how to take such an essence. The term essence refers to practice.

So this is quite profound. So Khensur Rinpoche said, often, you have, listened to a lot of teachings. Now the time has come to change your minds. And here when we speak of depositing these teachings in the mind, it is not that we somehow generate a new mind, set the old mind aside and generate a new mind. Instead, we must take our present mind and transform it.

It must become something new. This advice which gave in Australia, frequently said, deposit this in your mind, change your mind, turn your mind into something different from the way they used to be. So this is our reward. Our reward is mental happiness, and this mental happiness is to be found in the Lam Rim through transforming our minds. Probably, for the majority of us, there is no physical suffering worth talking about.

The main suffering we have is mental. And therefore, the first outline for the sake of taking the essence of this base of leisure and endowment refers as far as the base is concerned to this existence. And leisure is just a summarized form for the eight leasures and the 10 endowments and numerous characteristics of this base. And the key here is to understand just how important, how critical this base is. So here, this human base is this existence of ours, and the issue is what are its characteristics which makes it fundamental.

As Śāntideva says, after feeding this body its salary, put it to good use. Then what is fundamental in a human existence? The human brain. Then, is there a difference between the human brain and the brain of a dog? Both have brains.

But are they similar or different? And if they’re the same, then we can just think and behave like dogs. Right? Then if a dog’s brain and our brain were identical in terms of potency, in terms of capacity, in terms of strength, then the only thing we could hope for would be to adopt canine behavior. Then, obviously, our brains are far superior to those of dogs.

So in which respect are they superior? So in your opinion, what is the difference between, the brain of a human being and the brain of a dog? Because after all, a dog does a lot of the things we do. A dog eats when he’s hungry. He drinks when he’s thirsty.

He protects his offspring or relatives. So what’s the difference between a dog and a human being? Dog loves his master. Right? So he loves his master, then he protects property against the enemies of his master.

So he’s the same thing. Right? So what’s the difference? He doesn’t think about future lives. Dogs think about the future, don’t they?

Not about the future. As far as I know. A lot a lot of people don’t think about future lives. Right? Most.

So what’s the difference? Humans are able to analyze and animals It’s a good way of looking at it. So what’s the difference? Following on from Jill, I would say, self reflection. Humans are able to self reflect on their behaviors, their mind, and, dogs are not able.

So there is a tremendous difference between the brain of a dog and the brain of a human being in terms of potency, in terms of power, in terms of capacity. Then this is when one reflects about things. When one doesn’t reflect about things, then these two brains are basically the same. And therefore, in this first outline of the Lam Rim, an exhortation for the sake of taking the essence of this base of leisure. This base of leisure is a human rebirth and specifically a human brain’s capacities.

And here, it is when one takes the capacities of the human mind into account that this rebirth becomes meaningful. Now Now human beings and dogs are identical in trying to avoid physical suffering. Dogs are very skillful at avoiding physical suffering. But it is a unique human prerogative to, understand what mental suffering is and try to avoid it. This is something dogs are unable to do, and this is something his holiness has pointed out.

Then all the marvels in this model world, they are the works of human beings. They are not the works of animals. How could animals do this? What exists has been created for the sake of human happiness and to eliminate human suffering. Then, however much we try, this approach doesn’t work.

We can keep at it day after day. And this is why Śāntideva’s advice is so powerful after paying it its salary,, put it to work.

And therefore, the most important is to eliminate mental suffering. The greatest suffering we experience is mental suffering. But this is not something which can be eliminated at once. It must be eliminated gradually over time using numerous reasons and rationales. In the world we live in, the society we live in, the greatest suffering people face is mental.

And therefore, after the first outline and exhortation for the sake of taking the essence of this base of leisure, which we all understand, we have received numerous teachings on this. The second outline, how to take the essence of this base that focuses on practice. Then because you have received numerous teachings of Lam Rim, Gesheka, I would like to ask you to keep only these two outlines in mind. The first, an exhortation for the sake of taking the essence of this base of leisure. And the second, the how to take the essence of this base.

Then this is all we have to think about. First, why we should do so? And second, how? And how includes the path shared with the being of the small scope, of the middling scope, and of the great scope. Have you understood?

Have you listened to these two outlines? Exhorting us to take the essence of this human base of leisure and endowment, and the second outline is how to do that. It is ideal to memorize the outline of the Lam Rim. It’s extraordinarily beneficial for the mind, but it is not possible unless one has received Lam Rim teachings before. Then the totality of the Lam Rim is included in these two outlines.

Then the second outline, how to take the essence of this base is subdivided into three, as was explained. The path shared with the being of the small, the middling and the great scope. And the first, the path shared with the being of the small scope is subdivided into three. The first is training one’s thought in actuality. The second is the measure of having done so.

And the third is countering wrong views. Then we will set the third, outline aside. So the first of these outlines, actually training the mind refers to the topics of meditation of the past shared with the being of the small scope. The second, the measure or the criterion, refers to an explanation of the mode of giving rise to these experiences, the criterion for their arrival. Otherwise, we would not know whether we had them or not.

Then the first outline actually training the thought is itself subdivided into five topics of observation or topics of meditation, you all know already. Do you understand? Of course. Means for sure. Yes.

Definitely. In Tibetan, say, of course. You are elders in the Lam Rim. Maybe apart from Amanda, most of you are elders in the Lam Rim. So in our own cases, we entrust ourselves completely 100% into exterior houses, exterior things, exterior objects in general.

Now it is not the case that these are unrelated to our happiness, but it is certainly the case that they cannot provide the totality or 100% of our happiness. Geshe la would like to challenge you to give him one single person who attained final happiness independence on material objects. There is not a single one you can give him. Not one of you knows anybody. On the other hand, if you ask whether there are people who have attained final ultimate happiness independence on mental training, then there are many, the and so forth, and ourselves to practice we can reach that point.

It is impossible independence on exterior objects to give rise to final mental happiness. Then it is not to say that mental happiness is completely independent of physical happiness. We need the modicum of physical happiness. But to think that if we had a gigantic house with a magnificent garden, a palace, let’s say, and beautiful creatures in the garden and so forth, this would lead to definite mental happiness. It is not true.

It leads only to trouble and trouble after trouble. Some of us have direct experience of this. And therefore, here, physical happiness alone is insufficient to make us durably happy because there is also mental happiness. And to be able to give rise to mental happiness, we need contentment, not contentment from others, contentment for us ourselves, the capacity to be self sufficient. So this is contentment which relies on oneself, not contentment which relies on others because contentment cannot arise from others, however many helpers we have.

And therefore, it is precisely because we lack this contentment which arises from self sufficiency that we are unhappy, and this is the core advice of the for the past shared with the being of the small scope, generate contentment. So Geshe-la is not saying that we do not need exterior physical happiness. We do. We are in physical bodies. We need flesh and so forth.

But what Geshe-la is saying is that we cannot rely on this totally or 100. So the second outline of, this threefold subdivision in Lam Rim Chenmo is the criterion of having generated the realizations of the path shared with the being of the small scope. And the text reads, after having turned away or dispelled the exclusive focus on this life, focus on future lives. Do you have this realization? Really?

Oh, that took a long time. And this is why Jetsunkhapa says in, is through realizing this in solitude that one puts effort, and this effort leads one to the path shared with the being of the meeting scope. So often we say that the definite emergence of the path, shared as being of the small scope is subsidiary. And we have the sense that sometimes it is only present from time to time. That is not the case at all.

It is something we must train in at present. So here, therefore, the criterion of having realized the path shared with the being of the small scope is when one focuses mainly, let’s say, 80% on future lives and in a subsidiary or an ancillary fashion on this life. Do you understand? Geshe-la is not asking you whether you have realized this, but do you understand? And you should look into it instead of sleeping.

Right? So here, therefore, one this realization is one where one focuses mainly on the next life onwards. Now that doesn’t mean especially at the beginning that somehow one throws this life away. We’re not able to do that. Then later on with practice, it’s another story.

Literally giving up this body. Renunciation. So this is the meaning of renunciation. It literally means in Tibetan, to give up this body, but to give up this body based on the study. Then the English translation definite emergence translates word by word the Tibetan word is definite emergence.

Then renunciation trans translates better the Tibetan term to relinquish or give up this body, which is difficult. Then to generate this striving for the next life onwards, we need to generate a profound conviction in the existence of past and future lives and specifically of that which transmigrates from past to future lives, which is the subtle mind and not any of the minds linked to the coarse brain. Then, this topic of the subtle mind is covered in the classes on Tuesdays from the standpoint of the Chitamatra School of Tenets. Chitamatrans call it the ālāyavijñāna or the mind basis of all. So if from the moment we wake up in the morning, we think of future lives, then we are suffused with a virtuous mind.

And this should foster happiness since virtuous minds are the foundation, the root of happiness. And if we can maintain this and eventually die with this state of mind, just one in the Dalai Lama has said, it is a given we will be reborn in the higher realms. Otherwise, it is difficult. And probably in our case, when we get up in the morning, it’s all about breakfast. And having stuffed our faces before going to bed, in the morning, we want to eat again more.

So virtuous minds are the essence of dharma. And if we can generate virtuous minds continually accompanied by their motivation, this is what we should do. Then I explained virtuous minds are dharma. So peace and happiness of virtuous minds, apart from virtuous minds, how would peace and happiness arise? Then even though we don’t use the terms, the meaning of virtuous minds is just that, peace and happiness.

These are the realizations of the path of the being of the small scope. So let us at present meditate as much as we can on the realizations of the path shared with the being of the small scope. There is a strong connection between the realizations shared with the being of the small scope and entry into the path shared with the being of the middling scope and generation of definite emergence. Definite emergence itself is the cause of a great compassion, which is the criterion of having entered the path of the being of the great scope. There is no doubt that entering the path of the being of the great scope is accompanied by bodhicitta.

So as was explained, last week, once one has generated spontaneous, uncontrived bodhicitta at that point, one has entered the path of accumulation of the Mahāyāna. This is followed by the path of of preparation of the Mahāyāna. One is at this point a Mahāyānist on the path of accumulation and then on the path of preparation. So at the point where a bodhisattva on the path of accumulation generates a mind arisen from meditation, which has the abandonments and requisite realizations and is focused on emptiness at that point, such a being has entered the Mahāyāna path of preparation. Then great compassion, bodhicitta, and so forth within the mind of that being are paths of preparation.

That being is a Bodhisattva on the path of preparation. So as Geshe la explained last week, the minds arisen from meditation or if you prefer the insights focused on emptiness are twofold. We have conceptual minds arisen from meditation focused on emptiness and non conceptual minds arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. To enter the path of preparation, one needs a conceptual mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. Then through habituation on the path of preparation, eventually, for the first time, a non conceptual mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness arises.

At this point, the bodhisattva is on a mahayana path of seeing. Then what is known as Mahāyāna Paths are subdivided into two, Mahāyāna ārya paths of seeing and Mahāyāna ārya paths of meditation. When one enters for a first time a Mahāyāna ārya path, one necessarily enters a Mahāyāna path of seeing. Then such a Mahāyāna bodhisattva on the path of seeing is on the path of seeing, and minds minds such as great compassion, bodhicitta, or the realization of emptiness in his mind stream are all Mahāyāna paths of seeing. So you asked a good question last time, which was when should either uncontrived definite emergence or uncontrived bodhicitta and great compassion be present within the mind stream of such a being.

And, actually, during meditative equipoise on emptiness, they are said to be in the background or in the backdrop. Then in practical terms, we can say that they are nonexistent at this point even though Buddhist texts, certainly the Serraje Monastery texts say that they do exist. And scholars have different assertions on this particular topic, and this is something which is resolved to gaining experience. Experience, in this case, refers to studying carefully. It is not possible for an understanding of this sort of topic to just rely on others.

So then you had another doubt, which is also a very good one. As was pointed out, calm abiding exists in the mind stream of those who have not entered the path, so does the realization of emptiness exist in the mind stream of those who have not entered the path. Then the doubt was, does an insight focused on emptiness exist within the mind stream of beings who have not entered the path? And this is very difficult because if such an insight existed, then there would also exist or have to exist a direct realization of emptiness within the mind stream of beings who have not entered the path. And then why wouldn’t there exist full enlightenment within the minds of beings who have not entered the path at all either?

So it is a good doubt. However, in brief, there cannot exist an insight focused on emptiness in the mind stream of a being who has not entered the path because the generation of uncontrived definite definite emergence is indispensable to give rise to an insight focused on emptiness.

Why is this the case? Because the emptiness which is meditated upon is not the emptiness of a building or a table or something like that. It is the emptiness of the I of the person, and this is immediately linked very closely with striving for liberation. So here, emptiness is posited on the base of the I or the mind. These are in brief of one nature, but different isolates.

Now why exactly would you want to posit emptiness on the basis of the I of the mind? Simply to counter or to become the opposite of the ignorance which is grasping at a self. Now why would you want to do this unless you were striving for liberation? So here, when we’re speaking of emptiness, one is not speaking of the emptiness of the clock or the table, but of the emptiness of the person. And, this is why Jetsunkhapa, in the final verses of the three principles of the path, says, after having gained realization of these, retire in solitude at the hermit and put effort.

In in other words, it is after having gained realization of the three principles of the path that one has to try to generate a mind arisen from meditation, and this is not easy. Then Geshe-la would like to apologize for explaining emptiness a little bit. It is confusing. He knows. Then there is an important purpose in explaining emptiness on the basis of the I or the mind.

This is meaningful, whereas explaining it independence on exterior object is not. And this is also closely connected to the topic of Buddha lineage. So let us now do the recitations and briefly generate the motivation before that. Page one. Page five.

So what I would like us to understand is why in dependence on an ārya base, it is not possible to accumulate karma impelling rebirth and psychic existence. So it is through thinking on these topics that you will get a sense of why it is said that in dependence on the base of an ārya, one cannot accumulate impelling karma causing rebirth in cyclic existence. Then if you have questions, please ask them at present. Just going back to, like, the Tibetan translucent renunciation in Tibetan to give up the body. Does that refer to just the form aggregate or does it include all the associative objects that support the body such as, you know, clothing and family and houses?

Or does it just mean not relying on those things for happiness? So giving up the body refers to having no lust, no desire. Then, it does not refer to giving up one’s physical body just to generating mere definite emergence. We would not be able to do so. What is the aspect of self cherishing?

The aspect of self cherishing. Aspects. Aspect. Number one. One.

You can share with think about it. This is just a terminological question, really. With the path of accumulation, Mahāyāna path of accumulation, what is the accumulate what’s an accumulation of? It refers to the accumulation of the collections of So the term accumulation and path of accumulation Mhmm. Refers to the accumulation of the collections.

For a normal being, we have afflicted mind. What is the what we call the terminology for the ārya being that they don’t have the afflicted mind? What do we call it? So it’s a bit delicate to speak of the afflicted mind of an Ārya being simply because an Ārya being, whether it is a an Ārya being on the the vehicle of hearers, solitary realizers or bodhisattvas, has seen emptiness as it is nakedly, if you wish. And therefore, the ignorance grasping at a self is no longer going to be manifest, then what afflictions could arise in that situation is open to question.

The reason for this is that if we take the case of bodhisattvas, for example, then a bodhisattva is a being who has generated uncontrived bodhicitta. At that point, self cherishing no longer arises in the mind of the bodhisattva because uncontrived bodhicitta is the opposite of self cherishing. Now if we rely on this example, it’s the same thing with ārya beings. How exactly would afflictions arise within the mind of an ārya being? Now generally speaking, there’s no anger within the mind of an, but they say desire exists.

But the problem is what is the mode of existence of this desire? And this has profound meaning in the light of the verse from Abhidharma, which says,

There is no impelling karma in the mind of an Ārya being. Why is this the case? Because the root cause which leads impelling karma to cause rebirth in cyclic existence is the ignorance grasping at the self. As Vasubandhu says in Abhidharma Kosha, upon seeing truth, there is no impelling. Now seeing here refers to the direct perception of what is truth, in other words, emptiness.

There is no longer impelling karma at this point. Can you please? The The reason I asked this, we I just refer yesterday, we have the six collections plus the two — the afflicted mind and the mind basis of all — is eight together. Right? Mhmm.

And that’s for the normal being. But if we get rid of the afflicted mind, that means the ārya being get only seven, is it? So that’s a very good question. It’s something we have to enter in in detail. But in a nutshell, in the mind of an ārya being, there still is the afflicted mind.

It is only absent when the ārya being is in meditative equipoise on emptiness. Hello. I can’t. I haven’t been to teachings for a long time, so I apologize to Geshe la for that. But I guess I had a doubt about future lives to do with karma.

I just look at all the suffering in the world and and look at the babies, the refugee babies that are washing up on shores, drowning, people having their legs blown off in Myanmar and associated things, and I can’t see how anyone has transgressed that far to deserve that kind of suffering. And to me, that makes me doubt the presence of future lives entirely because I can’t see how those small children could possibly deserve that fate. Then as far as the karma which leads to this tremendous suffering is concerned, the details of that karma are known as extremely hidden phenomena. We don’t have access to them. Then that the karma was accumulated, yes, it was accumulated.

Yeah. Yeah. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

chulen
Literally, “taking the essence.” Chulen pills are made of essential ingredients; taking but a few each day, accomplished meditators can remain secluded in retreat for months or years without having to depend upon normal food. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top