1 h 30 min · 3,331 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains great compassion as an uncontrived wish for all sentient beings to be free from suffering, covering physical and mental suffering and whether arhats possess it. It distinguishes great compassion from conventional bodhichitta, whose object is full enlightenment for the sake of all beings, and from love, which differs in aspect. Audience questions follow on these distinctions.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 31m
UUID: 9871ace9-5a25-4165-b584-f8166060bcec
Words: 3,327
So there is an uncommon phrase at the beginning of Candrakīrti’s Madhyamakāvatāra of great compassion. Unlike other treatises of ancient India in which qualities of hearers or pratyaka buddhas are praised in Madhyamakāvatāra, it is great compassion. And the verse means, therefore, initially I shall face great compassion. Why does Chandakirti say therefore here? Therefore is uttered because it is independence on great compassion that bodhichitta is generated and independence on bodhichitta that one attains full enlightenment.
It is independence on the full enlightenment of great beings that Pratyekabuddhas and hearers exist. And therefore instead of beginning with a praise or a presentation of the four noble truths of emptiness, it is particularly beneficial to begin with a praise of great compassion. So to practice and to train great compassion, we must initially understand the nature of great compassion. In other words, its characteristics. What exactly is great compassion?
And therefore based on the great treatises, if we were to say that great compassion is an empathy which finds the suffering besetting sentient beings insupportable. Then such presentation seems quite elegant and easy to understand. Here, however, one must distinguish first between the object, all sentient beings, what precisely are all sentient beings, what is a sentient being, what are the sufferings afflicting sentient beings, specifically the three sufferings and so forth. So, in the case of great compassion, therefore, its object of observation is all sentient beings. In other words, every sentient being without exception.
As to its aspect, it is not necessarily the case that every mind has both an object of observation and an aspect. There is a huge number of main minds and mental factors far beyond our capacity to enumerate them, and it’s far from clear that all mental factors have both. But in this case, the aspect of great compassion is the thought, why should they not be freed from suffering? Then it can be a bit awkward to present it like this. Then, this unmistaken wish to free all sentient beings without exception from suffering is great compassion.
How do you identify sentient beings? What is a sentient being? Do you believe that there are no sentient beings apart from human beings or not? I wasn’t terribly sure whether you will consider them all sentient beings or not. It’s a matter matter of your culture.
In Buddhist texts, these are all sentient beings. What about fish? Such as beings are subdivided into beings of the higher and of the lower realms. We ourselves are obviously beings of the higher realms. And when one refers to great compassion, it is an empathy which is uncontrived and whose object of observation is all sentient beings without exception.
So suffering is broadly speaking subdivided into two, physical and mental suffering. Now regarding physical suffering, it’s open to question whether all pervasive suffering has a physical manifestation or not. But definitely the suffering of suffering and the suffering of change manifest as physical suffering. The suffering of suffering is for instance, the suffering of a stomachache, of a headache, and so forth. The suffering of change, for instance, would be the suffering we experience after eating a delicious meal and feeling bloated.
Then that feeling of bloatedness is the suffering of suffering. My apologies. It’s the suffering of change for bloatedness. Then let us turn to mental suffering. As far as mental suffering is concerned, the suffering of suffering, of change, and all pervasive suffering are all present.
What can you give as examples of the two first? Can you? The suffering of suffering at the mental level and the suffering of change at the mental level. So precisely, the, suffering of suffering at the mental level is first a mental suffering and then an experience of suffering, for instance a suffering which arises from jealousy, from competitiveness or from anger. Now, what example would you give of the suffering of change at the mental set level?
In other words, on a mental experience which at present is not suffering but will become suffering later. Suffering of change. Natalie? Suffering happiness within self existence? Okay, another.
Yummy, yummy. That’s very good. So all your examples are pretty similar, but to try to give a very clear example of the suffering of change at the mental level, this must be first a mental experience and in addition of the nature of the suffering of change. A very good example would be the affection one has for one’s boyfriend, one’s girlfriend, all that stuff. Basically, initially, it is a very pleasant experience, but it is a given that the experience is not stable.
It is given once one enters in any type of relationship of that nature that there will be difficulty. So we have large variety of instances of suffering of change within our mind stream. A very good example is the grass is greener elsewhere syndrome, where we travel to a distant land which strikes us as beautiful and clean and everything our homeland is not. And initially, that’s a very pleasant experience, but over time, dissatisfaction and suffering arise. So that initial experience is not an experience of suffering, it’s experience of happiness, but it will become suffering.
As far as the third subdivision of suffering or pervasive suffering is concerned, it is neither specifically physical nor mental. What is referred to by all pervasive suffering is the suffering of endless cycles of the 12 links beginning with ignorance, and in dependence on ignorance, primarily first desire and then anger arises and this occurs over and over and over again unceasingly. So as far as great compassion is concerned, great compassion is the wish for all sentient beings with exception to be freed from suffering. Here, the object of observation is all sentient beings and the aspect is let them be free of suffering. However, the suffering cannot be restricted to physical suffering.
It would be very strange this this be the case. It is both physical and mental suffering. Now here a doubt arises regarding hearer and solitary realizer, arhats. Is great compassion present within their mind stream or not? So let’s go.
Let’s go. The hearer and Prateka Buddha, in other words, those who have abandoned the afflictions, is great compassion present or not within their mind stream? Treatises have been written on this. So some of you say that great compassion is present in the mind, but some say it isn’t. So what’s your answer?
It’s not difficult. I’ll say no. Not many. Okay. Okay.
That’s okay. And if I said they didn’t have self charity, and they do. And then another? Do they have great compassion with respect to their Yes. Yes?
So do arhats have great compassion for their object of observation or not? So if, arhats have compassion for the object of observation of great compassion, all sentient beings, they must understand that all sentient beings suffer and they must understand the mode of suffering. Now, arhats have no mental suffering. It would be very strange to have to say they have mental suffering. They have abandoned mental suffering.
But they have physical suffering. They have not abandoned physical suffering. How concerned? Do you understand? They have physical suffering.
Then all of us have the object of observation of great compassion. So clearly, they have the object of observation of great compassion, which is all sentient beings. Now the aspect of great compassion is the wish for all sentient beings to be free from suffering. Suffering here is a threefold suffering which was explained previously, but it can also be subdivided into physical and mental suffering. Whether mental suffering is present or not, we must analyze, but physical suffering as well.
Then in the higher rebirth, the experiences of physical suffering are present. The suffering of heat, of cold, of being hunger, of being thirsty are all present. So as far as physical suffering, therefore physical suffering is present within the higher realms. Mental suffering is evidently present. Physical suffering can be eliminated by physical means, overwhelmingly by beings of the higher realms.
And mental suffering can be eliminated through training in empathy and compassion or reflecting on the 16 subdivisions of the four noble truths. Then when one studies Mahāyāna Dharma, one studies it so that eventually one is able to explain it to others. But in the process, one also finds means to counter one’s own mental suffering. So understanding how this mental suffering arises, how to target the afflictions and so forth. So the nature of great compassion is therefore an uncontrived empathy which wishes to free all sentient beings from the sufferings which beset them.
And here the term uncontrived empathy is specifically designed to counter the existence of great compassion within the mind stream of arhats. Since the term uncontrived great compassion indicates that this great compassion eliminates the cause, which is self cherishing and also gives rise to gives rise to superior resolve. Then based on such a definition, it is possible to assert that great compassion is not present within the mind stream of arhats. Now regarding the substantial cause of great compassion causes, as you know, are subdivided between substantial causes and cooperative conditions. The substantial cause of great compassion is definite emergence.
Since when definite emergence is extended from oneself to others, it becomes great compassion, and therefore, great compassion is its substantial result. So therefore, uncontrived definite emergence is the substantial cause of great compassion. Now does uncontrived definite emergence induce a great compassion? How would this happen? Since one has to posit a mode of transition from the path of the being of the middling to the path of the being of the great scope.
What is your opinion on this? So how does one pass from the path of the being of the middling to that of the being of the great scope? What is the mode of transition? No. I mean, it is self evident that based on what we said that, uncontrived definite emergence is a substantial cause of great compassion.
But if we take our own case, let us imagine we had generated uncontrived definite emergence within our mind stream. What is gonna lead that to turn into great compassion? Why would this happen? Please. So in it is said that this is a very difficult point.
This mode of transition from the path of the being of the middling to that of the being of the great scope, and it is affected through studying carefully in treatises the qualities of cherishing others and the thoughts of self cherishing, the qualities of great compassion, bodhichitta and so forth. However, it is added that if one has actually entered the path of a Śrāvaka or a Pratyekabuddha, it is extremely difficult to exit it. So when we engage in the practice of the Mahāyāna, the first step is to define our goal, is full and utter enlightenment. And then to see what connection of causes are necessary for this goal, and how we proceed incrementally until eventually we reach this goal. In the self same way that if the pilot of an airplane wants to take the airplane to India, not the passenger’s plane, then, he must have a clear sense of where he is going and what the intermediate stages are, otherwise the plane will never get to India.
What is therefore the meaning of the path shared with the being of the small scope and the path shared with the being of the middling scope. These paths are not paths of the small scope or paths of the middling scope because they are not engaged in with a motivation of the small or the middling scope. They are engaged in after generating a motivation of the great scope. Even if we are unable to generate a fully characterized motivation of the great scope, nonetheless, we try to generate one and then we engage in practices shared or common with the path of the being of the small and the middling scope. So this is what there is to say on great compassion.
Now great compassion gives rise to the superior resolve, which is that state of mind, which says to itself, I will accomplish the welfare of sentient beings. And that superior resolve induces great induces bodhichitta. And therefore, the superior resolve, induces, conventional bodhichitta. Once the superior resolve is generated, one has resolved to help all sentient beings. But then sentient beings have innumerable dispositions and afflictions, and one needs to know their dispositions and afflictions to help them.
At what level does one fully know this at the level of full enlightenment. And therefore, with this as a motivation, one strives for full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. This is conventional bodhichitta. Now, irrespective of how one chooses to generate it, in this presentation, we are focusing on generating bodhichitta by means of the equalization and interchange of self and others. These four steps are present.
And once, one has been able to generate a bodhichitta, then one is in a very different situation altogether. So, this is what conventional bodhichitta is. Now, what is the object of observation of conventional bodhichitta? It is full and utter enlightenment. For the sake of who?
For the sake of all sentient beings, and this is how the aspect appears. So, now I have explained this already, but I’d like to ask you what is the difference between conventional bodhichitta and great compassion? Let’s go. Let’s go. If you want, please.
Yes, I am. Great Oh. Compassion is the heartfelt wish that all beings be free from suffering and that induces the wish that if I don’t do it who will? And then the last part of the question was what is yes. So so therefore, I must, attain enlightenment myself to bring this about.
So you’re not being asked to sequence of generation. What’s the difference? I asked you what is the difference? So, I’m not asking you the detailed explanation in the Buddhist text, but just the meaning. I explained it already.
So it is rather uncomplicated. The object of observation of great compassion is all sentient beings. The object of observation of bodhichitta is full and utter enlightenment. So, they have completely different objects of observation. If you posit the objects of observation of these two minds, it becomes very clear.
So otherwise, if you try to pause it in terms of the aspect of great compassion, it’s very awkward. Then there is food for thought when one compares empathy and love. What precisely is the difference? So we use the terms love, empathy, and great compassion quite casually, but it is important for us to understand clearly the distinctions. For instance, there has to be a distinction between love and empathy.
What is it? So why are you saying that love is partially mistaken? Says who? In our culture. No problem.
What are the other answers? However you want to play it. Alright, Chris? I agree with Chompa Chopio. Love is the wish that others be free of have happiness in the course of happiness.
Empathy that they be free of suffering in the course of suffering. So, in the case of love and compassion, the object is exactly the object of observation is exactly identical. It is all sentient beings. Then the only way you can posit a difference in terms of the aspect. One has a pleasing aspect.
One has a pleasing aspect, the other has an unpleasing or displeasing aspect. Love has a pleasing, pleasurable aspect, and compassion has a displeasing, unpleasurable aspect. So probably once self cherishing has been countered and cherishing others or altruism has arisen, love arises as well. A great compassion would be generated at a level of Tonglen, of giving and taking. Then basically, there, seems to be no distinction in the object of observation of love and of, great compassion.
There is a distinction in terms of the aspect. Then let us reflect on this, in meditation during a couple minutes and generate the motivation. K. Please open the page one. We recite one b two three four and also page five, number six, mandala offering, Thank you.
Then, please I will take your questions. I would like on topic questions and short questions, so we understand what you’re asking. Then questions on love, on great compassion, on a conventional bodhichitta which we cover. If I understood correctly, you said great compassion and bodhichitta was a mind. Is also love and compassion minds?
All are the consciousnesses. All are conceptions. All are conceptions. And also date part of the difference between the aspect of love and empathy, the one being displeasurable and the other pleasurable. Other one is not.
So love has a pleasant aspect and compassion has an unpleasant aspect, since love is focused on the happiness bestowed on others, and compassion is focused on the suffering of others. Then within the two, I believe that love has to be generated first. Since once one has countered self cherishing or egoism, cherishing others or altruism arises, and this is very similar to love, and it is only independence on cherishing others that the wish to free others from suffering, which is compassion can arise. I guess following on from that, in the sevenfold cause and effect method, love precedes compassion. Is that a causative relationship and cause for compassion?
Michel has said that definite emergence extended to others is a cause for great compassion. Are they similar? When we say that when a definite emergence is extended to others, it becomes great compassion, This is a succinct statement, but love is generated in between. Mhmm. There you go.
And other? Is the freedom that comes from cherishing others similar to the freedom of uncontrived definite emergence? What do you mean by freedom? Well, just in reflecting on the qualities of cherishing others, one of the thoughts that keeps coming up to me is a sense of freedom. A sense of a freedom that is different to self cherishing.
It’s not really a question, is it? The question was, is that sense of freedom of cherishing others similar to the the sense of freedom of liberation? If I were to replace freedom by experience, would that be okay? Let me just think. Yes.
Thank you. No. The experiences of definite emergence and the experience of self cherishing are very different. The experience of definite emergence on the one hand is a focus on liberation, whereas the experience of cherishing others is a focus on others which gives rise to love. And?
Because we have ignorance, when is it possible to know that one’s encompassing all sentient beings in one’s meditation. Yes, study because when uncontrived great compassion is generated, it counters self cherishing and it arises from fully characterized definite emergence. So study is critical. Study of great compassion, study of love, study of bodhichitta, study as a prelude to practice and then independence on study, we can train in love, great compassion and bodhichitta, and eventually realize fully characterized love, great compassion and bodhichitta. Okay.
Just one question, please. I can’t really see the difference between empathy and love. Freedom from suffering is happiness. So the empathy which wishes sentient beings to be free from suffering is also wishing them to have happiness. There are differences in terms of the order of generation since in the seven fold sequence, love, affectionate love is generated first and compassion after, there is also an important difference in terms of the aspect of these two minds.
One has a pleasing aspect that is love and the other has a displeasing that is compassion. Okay. On this Saturday, day to day Dharma practice starts at 10AM to twelve and discussion and meditation on the four aspects of the
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
- Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.