Lam Rim – Lamrim (7)

1 h 44 min · 4,867 words

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - Lamrim (7)
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. This final session of the year urges retreat and practice, described as abandoning defects once they are recognised as defects. It explains cultivating contentment by linking reflection on precious human rebirth with meditation on death and impermanence, including the three roots of death meditation, and previews emptiness for next year. The talk closes with a question session on the distinctions between arya, arhat and Buddha.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 44m

UUID: 8fda98d3-e159-4432-8505-a581f576582a

Words: 4,864

So this is the last class, the last class of this year of Pecha, in other words, guidance in the texts of Lamrim. And we have a period of vacations which would extend for more than a month, and if it is possible during this period, if one is able to stay in a retreat either for ten days or one week, and to engage continually, uninterruptedly in virtuous activities, this would be very good. And while Kensur Kangur Rinpoche was still with us at the monastery, he would sometimes instruct disciples to stay in a retreat on renunciation, and they would cover the paths shared with the being of the small, of the middling, and of the great scope. This is very beneficial. Then when one engages in retreats on a tutelary deity, an a Yidam, there are retreat manuals which give instructions on what what what one can engage in and what one should not engage in during the retreat.

And actually, in spirit, this is similar to the Lamrim even though the Lamrim does not develop these points. And there are only during such periods good dreams. There probably will be no nightmares at all, simply because one engages continually and uninterruptedly from dawn till dusk into virtuous, in virtuous activities and does not engage at all in non virtuous activities. During retreat, some of you may have experience of this as one puts such effort in engaging in virtuous deeds of speech and of body, there are no basically non virtuous deeds of speech and body during a retreat. As a result, one gets only good virtuous dreams.

And in our own case, this might be difficult to engage in, but fundamentally, what matters is to generate a good motivation for entering and retreat. This is something which we can do. So all of this has been explained many times, and what really matters as Kensur Rinpoche said very many times is to counsel one’s own mind in what it should engage in, and what it should abstain from. One has to link one’s own mind with the teachings. This is what practice is.

Then in your cases, you have certainly begun to do this, you have begun to think maybe the Lamrim explains the way things are, and you have begun to try to practice, but what exactly do we mean by practice? Do we mean by practice that one opens a book and peeks inside, or do we just hold the book? What exactly do we mean when we say we should practice? So Geshe-la, I would like to ask you, what do you understand by practice? So certainly, at the level of the path of the being of shared with the being of the small scope, we have listened to many teachings.

Then what exactly is to be understood by practice in this context? To take an example, which is perhaps a bit odd, let us take the example of going to war. Before one goes to war, one must train, one must practice fighting going to war. For instance, before one rides off on a horse, one must practice riding and know how to ride a horse. So before practicing, we must study what we intend to practice.

Now that has been done. Then at that point, what exactly do we mean by engaging in practice? In a nutshell, practice means to abandon or relinquish defects. So initially, it is not sufficient to say that something is a defect. We we must identify a defect as a defect, and then we must abandon the defects which are related with the path of the being of the small scope, those which are related with the path of the being of the great middling scope, and those which are related with the path of the being of the great scope.

As Āryadeva, Nāgārjuna’s disciple, said, what practice is there if one does not see the faults? And as Jetsongkhapa adds in his concise Lamrim, without putting effort at thinking about the defects of the truth of suffering, how can the mind striving for liberation be generated? Moreover, Kensur Kangur Rinpoche himself said, without seeing faults as faults, what practice is there? Do you understand? So in brief, as Kensur Rinpoche himself said, one must see the defects as defects and in the backdrop of this statement lies the stanzas from Āryadeva’s Chatuhshataka, the four hundred and from Jetsongkhapa’s concise Lamrim, the canticle of realizations.

So without identifying the faults as faults, identifying the defects as defects, nobody engages in anything. To give the example, if we see a meal which is rotten, who is actually going to eat that? Obviously, it is not beneficial to oneself. For that matter, it’s harmful. So therefore, what do we mean at this point by practicing Lamrim?

If we take the case of the path shared with the being of the small scope, it means identifying the defects which are focused upon at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope. These defects are known as objects of abandonment, and one must identify these defects or faults as defects or faults. Then if Geshe la were to ask what are the objects of abandonment or the thoughts to be relinquished on the path of the being of the smaller scope? So what is your answer? You can say all ten non virtues.

It’s okay. Fundamentally, it is the concerns of this life. So our goal is to train with contentment. So therefore, at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope, our goal is to train in contentment, and to do this, we turn away from the concerns of this life. As we do this, our mind becomes more and more virtuous.

This does not mean that occasionally non virtue does not arise, but overwhelmingly the mind becomes more and more virtuous, and as a result of this, at the time of our death, we can hope that our mind will be virtuous as a result of which we will be reborn in a higher realm. Then a very elegant way of presenting this is to view it as follows. The higher realms, liberation, and full enlightenment are not somehow out there in space. What attains the state of the higher realm, the state of liberation, and the state of full enlightenment is on mental continuum. This is something we have to understand.

When one attains liberation, one is not reborn in some palace of liberation in space. Instead, it is one’s mind which becomes liberated or one’s mind which attains full So therefore, our goal has to be to increase the power of virtuous minds within our mind stream to sixty, maybe even seventy percent of all minds. And then if we can do this as a result, we will continue proceeding in this way until the time we die, and these virtuous minds will impel a rebirth in a higher realm. Do you understand? Yes?

Yes, yes, okay. So the most fundamental topic to be trained in on the path shared as a being of the small scope is contentment in keeping with the verses of Jetsongkhapa’s three principles of the path. Through reflecting on the rarity of a rebirth of leisure and endowment, and the fleeting nature of this life, turn away from the concerns of this life. So as Geshe la has explained many times, it is through linking inseparably the reflections on a rebirth of leisure and endowment on the one hand, and meditation on death and impermanence on the other hand, that one can turn away from the vanities of this life and generate contentment. Once one has generated contentment, there will be less desire.

As a result, in turn, there will be less anger since anger arises from desire. So anger, but also jealousy, all arise from desire. Then if we can generate contentment and counter coarse desire as a result, we will also counter the arrival of anger, jealousy, and so forth. And it is self evident in turn that desire arises from self cherishing and from the apprehension of a self. As Candrakīrti says in the Madhyamakāvatāra.

The root of desire is the view of the transitory composite, and therefore the focus at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope must be the generation of contentment. As to the suffering which is caused by the lack of contentment, you all know exactly what it is. It is not being satisfied with one house, but having two or three houses, and then wanting the type of furniture appropriate for two or three houses, even though one cannot live in two or three houses, and then needing money one does not have for two or three houses, having to borrow for this and so forth. And this is lack of contentment. So there is no way to manage without contentment.

And to generate contentment, it is critical to meditate on death and impermanence as Je Tsongkhapa says, it is not possible to give rise to virtue without reflecting on the certainty of death. Then if you could stay in retreat, that would be very good. For instance, a retreat on the path shared with the being of the small scope. And here, when one is in retreat, one must link the topics of the Lamrim. For instance, the topics of the path shared with the being of the small scope.

One must link the former to the latter topics, and the latter to the former topics. As His Holiness the Dalai Lama has said, one must understand the relationship between these topics. Then to do this, one must be relaxed, one must have time. So one therefore knows whether one has time or not. It is something which we alone know.

And if we have time, in addition, we must take care of our body without which it is impossible to engage in these practices. And then one must investigate carefully. And for instance, at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope, one’s goal is after thinking about things carefully to give rise to a feeling. Well, yes, higher rebirth really do exist, and this is how one gets there. Or at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope after reflecting on the four noble truths, yes, liberation really does exist and this is how one obtains liberation.

This is the foundation. So this year, Geshe la covered two major topics. The first is past and future lives, in other words, one’s own past and future lives, and one must generate a conviction in their existence, and your translator went through a lot of trouble to try to convey this to you. And the second topic Geshe la covered was the smaller Salam, the smaller grounds and paths, the distinction between ārya and akhats. And as most of you know, next year, in keeping with the verses of Jetsongkhapa in the three principles of the path, without the wisdom which realizes the mode of abiding albeit endowed with definite emergence and bodhicitta, Geshe la will start to explain carefully emptiness.

Then Geshe la suspects that when you think of emptiness, have rather strange ideas. You think that it is somehow nothing existing at all. That is not the case, but it has to be explained in terms of coarse, the penetrating, and so forth. Geshe la himself makes no claim to have any experience of emptiness, but he has studied the topic. So Geshe la would like to say that he is delighted by your attendance this year.

You have come very regularly to the teachings. He knows you are very busy, but despite your busy schedules You are very busy. I know. You have no time. I know.

You have put some time aside for the teachings. Is a difficult topic. It’s not a topic where you just present like that. It is a matter of transforming the mind from within, and this takes time. And Geshe la really thinks it is extraordinary that you have been coming so regularly to the teachings.

Thank you. So thank you. So when we meditate on death and impermanence, we should meditate on our own death and impermanence. This is what is of benefit. And when we meditate on our own death and impermanence, we counter the apprehension of our own permanence.

Now you know what permanence means. It is this idea that we’re going to be around forever, for a very long time, and as a result, we need the lifestyle in keeping with a very long life. We need a lot of money, and we accumulate non virtue. As a result of this non virtue, we are reborn in the lower realms in the next life. Then, this is the main focus of the past shared with the being of the small scope.

The level of past shared with the being of the middling scope, one focuses on the selflessness of persons, and at the level of the past shared with the being of the great scope, one focuses on eliminating self cherishing. Therefore, the main topic of meditation for the path shared with being of the small scope is death and impermanence, and its main object of abandonment is the vanities of this life. Our goal is to generate contentment. And within meditation on death and impermanence, you have the three roots. The first is that death is certain, the second that the time of death is uncertain, and the third that at the time of death, dharma alone is of benefit and nothing else.

Now within these three roots, the most important is the second one. The first root is already decided or spoken for. We all know we will die, but it is the uncertainty of the time of death which we have not realized. As Mahatma Gandhi said, as if we were to die tomorrow, let us be dead to sensation today, for happiness let us study now. It is a very profound statement.

So Gandhi is saying that one must generate contentment. Now we are speaking of contentment for oneself. Obviously, when it comes to benefiting others, there is no contentment. This is how one should understand contentment. Past and future lives are extremely important for all of us.

So emptiness is very important at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope. And when Jetsongkapa in the three principles of the path says, without being endowed with the wisdom which realizes the mode of abiding, albeit having definite emergence and bodhicitta, Jetsongkhapa is implying that one can have generated fully characterized definite emergence without having the realization of emptiness. Likewise, as you know from studying Salam, one can have generated uncontrived bodhicitta without having the realization of emptiness. However, one necessarily must have the realization of emptiness from the middling level of the path of accumulation upwards. Otherwise, as Geshe-la says, they send you back down.

They make you do the year again. They don’t shoot you. So therefore, hearer, solitary, realizer, and bodhisattvas can all attain their respective smaller path of accumulation without the realization of emptiness, but from the middling path of accumulation, they must have the realization of emptiness. Therefore, we must gain an understanding of emptiness, ideally a determination by a valid cognizer, otherwise at least an understanding. When some of you practice deity yoga, what exactly is generated as the deity?

It’s not the coarse aggregates, the body. So this is something one must understand. The common path, the shared path is the foundation or that which leads into a secret mantra. Otherwise, there’s no secret mantra. That is therefore generated present a good motivation motivated either by definite emergence or by bodhicitta for a couple of minutes.

Verse one A, two, three, four. And then the Mandal offering on page five, verse six, the first and last verse. Page five. So then if you can, independence on the path shared with the being of the small scope, practice the path shared with the being of the middling and the great scope that is ideal, and the focus of the path shared with the being of the middling scope is emptiness. As Ārya Nāgārjuna says in his Precious Garland, to put to lead the afflictions and karma to extinction, one must train in emptiness.

Then the path shared with the being of the small scope has no particular relation with the topic of emptiness. The topic of emptiness is related with path beginning with the path shared as a being of the middling scope. During the vacations, try not to waste your time, but try to study the view and specifically the teachings His Holiness has given on these topics so that when we meet after the vacations, the explanations will be more accessible. Then try to take a good care of your health so that you can die with a minimum of physical hardship. And then, as a result, you will be able to focus your mind in the direction of virtue at the time of the death of your death, with not just a conviction in the existence of past and future lives, but a certainty based on reasoning on analysis.

And then as a result, you will die and be reborn as someone falls asleep and wakes up in the morning. It’s a bit like falling asleep, Sometimes when you fall asleep, there’s trouble, right? Especially when you’re little, then it’s a bit the scary. So people when they fall asleep, fall asleep in the certainty that they will wake up the next morning. Then it is precisely these lines of reasoning which must be applied to past and future lives.

Conviction is not enough in this matter. Conviction is weak and changing. We need a certainty based on reasoning. And try to take care of your health and focus your mind in the direction of virtue. As a result, you will experience peace.

Who does not enjoy peace and happiness? And therefore, try to avoid wasting your time by engaging in meaningless activities. As Śāntideva says in Bodhisattvacharyavatara, those recitations and, ascetic practices engaged in with a distracted mind are of no benefit whatsoever, and he adds, subdue the wild elephant of the mind. As a result, you will not experience fear. It is true, isn’t it?

It’s true, isn’t it? If one subdues the wild elephant of the mind, then not only is there no fear, but one can focus the mind in a virtuous direction. Then when we fall asleep, if we are too agitated and think too much, it’s impossible to sleep. We need a peaceful mind, don’t we? So Geshe-la explained Salam in detail.

Do you have questions on Salam? You had the discussion groups before the Salam class, right? So do you have questions from that group? Yes or no? Okay.

So listen in, what are the differences between an ārya and a buddha? An akhat and a buddha. What’s the difference between akhat and a buddha? Okay. How many mus?

Ahat and Buddha, how many mus? Moose, logical possibilities. How many moves? Speak. I said three.

Three. Okay. And other? Sorry. Just one.

Okay. And. Yeah, three. Sumire, you say three. Okay.

Good relax you know. Sorry, three, You’ve got to decide, right? Things are not great. Doka says just one. Can you show me please?

It’s only a Mahāyāna Bodhisattva who obtains Buddhahood. Doctor Chris, You said three. Which one? So an ahart and not a Buddha. A Buddha not an ahart.

Neither a Buddha and neither an ahart. And? Neither. No, no, sorry. Sorry.

Four. Okay. Just a minute. So what do you give as an instance of someone who is a Buddha but not an Akhat? Well, one has attained full enlightenment the path of no more learning.

On the path of no more learning. Give an instance of someone who is a Buddha, but not an akhat. Okay. So those who give four mus, give the mus. All of them.

It is clean. Pure. Pure mus, okay. You can be they can be a Buddha and an Ahat. Neither a Buddha nor an Ahat?

You can be an Ahat but not a Buddha. But it is not possible to be a Buddha without being an Ahat. Okay. And you? That’s it?

Yeah, yeah. A hundred percent. Four models, not just three. There are only three mus, three logical possibilities, There are not four logical possibilities here. As Andy said, someone who is the mu, the possibility of someone being a Buddha and not being an arhat does not exist.

Do you understand? Because an arhat is a person who has abandoned the afflictions. A person who has abandoned all the afflictions is an arhat. The seeds of afflictions? Yes.

It’s a good question. He has abandoned the seeds of the afflictions. Because if he had not abandoned the seeds of the afflictions, then because of those seeds, the afflictions could arise again. So your comment is a very good comment. One should say, a person who has abandoned afflictions and their seeds is an arhat.

Can I ask one more question? So does that mean an ārya being, I’m not really clear what an ārya being is, but is an ārya being who’s left behind abandoned afflictions but still has the seeds of affliction? Yes. It’s a difficult topic, Geshe. I think she went there for all of Salem.

But basically, in brief, it is not the case that an ārya has abandoned necessarily the afflictions and their seeds. There are aryas on the path of seeing and aryas on the path of meditation who have not abandoned the afflictions in their seeds. So those of you who gave three mus for the relationship between an akhat and a Buddha, please give the moo of a being who is an akhat but not a Buddha. Mhmm. What do you give?

Being on the a Hīnayāna being on the path of no more learning. Why is it not a Buddha? Have not generated uncontrived bodhicitta. Such a being has not generated uncontrived bodhicitta. Has not abandoned the obscurations to omniscience.

That’s better. Why is it? Because both the seeds and the afflictions have been completely abandoned. Because it is a person who has abandoned the afflictions and its seeds. Give an example of what is a Mu, which is both a Buddha and an Akhat.

A Mahāyāna being on the path of no more learning. Why is it Because it is a person who has abandoned the afflictions and their seeds. An instance of someone who is neither. Me. Really?

How many moves between a sentient being and an arhat? Semchen being and then an arhat, how many moves? Two. Okay you two. Okay okay okay just a minute.

And other? Okay, relax me you know. I’m very happy. Two. Okay.

Two. Two. And you? Three. Three.

Okay. And other? Two, two, three. Yield two and Andrew two, mark three. Okay and other.

Okay. So I’ll give you two mus, Jill. You can be a sentient being but not an Ahat. You can be both a sentient being and an Ahat. But it’s not possible to be an ahat not a sentient being.

And it’s not possible to be neither. Okay. And Mark? You said three. You said three, is it?

Okay. To the difference of dual, exist phenomena that sentient beings nor arahats. There exists phenomena which are neither sentient beings nor arahats. What are your three moves? You said three moves.

You said three. Three are that you can be a sentient being and an arahat. You can be something which is neither. You can be a sentient being without being an arahat. So what is the mood which is missing for you?

You cannot be in our heart without being a sentient being. Andrew? Gentlemen, you said just two. I agree with Jill, yeah. Okay.

The same? Same as Jill. Okay. Could you repeat yours, Jill, please? You can be a sentient being but not an arhat.

So what example do you give? Being on the Mahāyāna path of accumulation. Because you would have to you need a mind to be able to generate definite emergence. And what is your second move? You can be both a sentient being and an arhat.

So what do you give as example? A hero on the path of no more learning. Okay. Said whoever is in our heart is necessary as a human being, right? So what about Arya Buddhas?

Arhat is right? Are they sentient beings? Buddha is same Jain. We don’t say Buddha as sentient beings. We say that beings whose base are the afflictions and so forth are sentient beings.

Do you understand? There are three moves. Right? And something someone who is an but not a sentient being. Something which is or someone who is a sentient being but not in our heart and someone who is both.

Are there four mus? Because you also have something which is neither an arhat nor a sentient being. I’m gonna ask you the question now about what would be an example of something that’s or someone that’s neither an arhat nor a sentient being. The table. It exists, right?

It’s not an Ahat, it’s not a sentient being. So if you give the four mus, the mu which is a sentient being but not an would be a hearer on the path of no more learning. Then the mu of an arhat who is not a sentient being would be an Ārya Buddha. Both is easy. What do you give?

Both an arhat and a sentient being? No. It’s better to say a hearer on the path of no more learning. I don’t get this at all actually. How can you be an arahat but not a sentient being?

I think I don’t understand what the definition of a sentient being is. So we say that a sentient being is a being whose basis of establishment is the afflictions. Well given that definition that sentient beings have a base of the afflictions, even the neither category, couldn’t that be a Buddha? Even a what? In the neither?

In the neither category. He neither be a Buddha? Nor a sentient being. If the base of the sentient being is the afflictions, couldn’t instead as well as a table, couldn’t the other neither be a Buddha? A naga.

Okay. Another example apart from table in the neither section Yes. Of the moose, couldn’t that be a Buddha because they don’t have a base of afflictions? No. Because the moo, which is neither a sentient being nor an akhat, cannot be an akhat, and a Buddha is an akhat.

Gisela, it seems that the move of both is not possible because all akhats have abandoned the afflictions, therefore they are no longer sentient beings. You’re speaking of of both. Right? Mhmm. So we speak of when you speak of neither, it means neither one.

Right? There is a mu, which is both a sentient being and an arhat. That would be a hearer or a solitary realizer on the path of normal learning. But the question is, if the definition of a sentient being is a being whose basis of establishment is the afflictions, if that’s the definition of a sentient being, then theoretically, by the time they’re a Narhat, they’re no longer a sentient being, because the basis of their establishment is not the afflictions. I think that’s the point he’s trying to make, isn’t So obviously, there are arhats who are not sentient beings.

This would be for instance the Aryabuddhas, that everyone agrees. Okay. In your opinion, are Ahats reborn in cyclic existence? No. Because they have abandoned the afflictions their seeds.

Are beings on the path of seeing reborn in cyclic existence or not? Yes. Because they haven’t abandoned the seeds, and they may not have abandoned the afflictions as well. Because they have abandoned the seeds. Because they have not Have not abandoned the seeds.

The seeds, and they may not have abandoned the afflictions as So they didn’t abandon the afflictions, period. Right? That’s good. What about the path beings of the path of meditation? Are they reborn in cyclic existence?

Yes. Same thing. Right? Yes. All of them.

That’s enough. Good. Thank you. Went very well. They they may choose to be reborn in cyclic existence because of bodhichitta.

So obviously, bodhisattvas on the three pure grounds can choose to be reborn in cyclic existence for the sake of others, but are no longer reborn in psychic existence under the power of the afflictions. Right? Oh, things went very well. Thank you. Prayers page nine.

Mandala offering and we can if people would like to make offerings to Geshe-la with khatas.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
buddha, a sang gye (Tib)
A fully awakened being, who has totally eliminated all obscurations veiling the mind and has fully developed all good qualities to perfection. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top