Lam Rim – LAMRIM 2 – KR

1 h 37 min · 3,831 words

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - LAMRIM 2 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Explains the Lam Rim as the graduated path to full enlightenment for the sake of others, stressing that the mind must be transformed through study and training rather than prayer. It then reviews the six perfections, covering generosity and ethics briefly before turning to forbearance: its object, what opposes it (anger and jealousy), its benefits, and its three kinds. A question and answer session on these points follows.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 37m

UUID: f3dd2fcb-f557-4f0f-8e69-15809ffc9d48

Words: 3,827

So, the term Jangchup, Lamrim in Tibetan, the graduated stages to enlightenment is very profound. The term Jangchup or enlightenment refers to the object of attainment and or the stages of the path refer to the means to attain this object of attainment. So, the name therefore of the text, the book, or the scripture we are studying is the graduated stages to enlightenment, and the name is quite meaningful. The object of attainment, the result we are aiming for is enlightenment. And the stages of the path are the means to attain this.

And these means are unmistaken, complete, and in a correct sequence, sequential. The term enlightenment in Tibetan, Jangchup two syllables. Means to purify, and here it is the purification of the mental continuum of the two obstructions which are the object of abandonment. And Chup is synonymous with the syllable Gyepa in Sangye and it means to enhance, it is the result of this purification. So in the syllables, as was said, Jan refers to a purification of the two obstructions, but it’s a purification of the two obstructions not for one’s own sake, but for the sake of others.

And as a result of this, one gives rise to the meaning of the second syllable or in the context of which means to enhance, to increase, to increase what? One’s knowledge of all objects of knowledge. Now here it is precisely because this is for the sake of others that one is able to attain this state. For instance, hearers and solitary realizers are not able to attain such a state of full and utter enlightenment because they are aiming for liberation for their own sake. And therefore, since the object of observation, full and utter enlightenment, is far away, one must train continually and for a long time.

So one must therefore begin to train in this attainment of full and utter enlightenment for the sake of others. Therefore, we must train our continuum which is the foundation, so that it is progressively developed enhanced and enhanced and reaches this state. Now this is a very worthwhile pursuit. It is very worthwhile for one person to aim to be of benefit to all. So this is not something which we should pray for or which we should beseech.

It is instead something which we should study for and which we should train our minds in. So all of us have different mental continuums and therefore the state of enlightenment which is our object of observation, which is our object of attainment will be different for each one of us. It is an individual object of attainment. We will attain it or not independence of the effort we furnish. So there is not only one Buddha, instead every single one of us will attain eventually if we furnish the effort our own state of enlightenment and we will be different Buddhas.

It would be inappropriate to say that there is only one Buddha. So, therefore to attain full and utter enlightenment, we need a special mind which is striving for this and this special mind is bodhichitta itself is caused by a great compassion and therefore we should train in these three minds love, great compassion and bodhichitta. Now, it is not the case that with bodhichitta alone, one attains full and utter enlightenment. One does also need the wisdom which realizes emptiness. But whereas bodhichitta, great compassion, love are quite straightforward to understand.

This is not the case with emptiness. So therefore, returning to the topic of Jangchup Lamrim, the graduated stages of the path to full enlightenment. The object of attainment is full enlightenment, and the means to attain this objective enlightenment are the stages of the path. In other words, the path shared with the being of the small, of the middling, and the path of the being of the great scope. Now, these paths are not something which are outside some place on the ground or on a piece of stone.

They are actually within our mental continuum, and even though the goal is far away, if we train regularly and consistently, we will reach it. So it is very beneficial to reflect on the sequence of the Lamrim. Then one could start with great compassion and seek for the cause of great compassion and move backwards to the path of the being of the small scope. Or for that matter, one could start with a bodhichitta and move backwards to the cause of bodhichitta, keeping in mind the definition of bodhichitta, which was explained yesterday and in previous weeks. A special mind endowed with both aspirations and keeping in mind the meaning of both aspirations.

So in the case of great compassion and bodhichitta, it is our mind which has to be turned into great compassion or bodhichitta. It is a way of thinking. Whereas in the case of the wisdom meditating on emptiness, this wisdom is focused on an object which must be identified and understood, emptiness. So now as far as great compassion and love is concerned as well as bodhichitta, these are marvelous states of mind since they are focused on enacting the welfare of another. Either one or two people in this temple, or more and more people on the outside.

And this is a remarkable state of affairs. In our own case, we tend to be very narrow minded and focused on our own happiness, and this happiness actually turned systematically into suffering. So, would suggest that if this was the case for you this year, since next year is on the horizon, we say this year is over and next year I shall do things differently. So here therefore, we must habituate the mind and enhance it. The Lamrim says that one must habituate the mind and this does not occur through a process of prayer or solicitation.

Instead, we must study and meditate on these topics and we must turn the old mind into a new mind. So our mind is not a thing and therefore because it is not a thing, it is not an object, we can transform it. We can transform an old mind into a new mind through implanting karmic imprints. Numerous karmic imprints, which if the mind were a form, it would be impossible to put in one room. Now, at present, our minds are overwhelmingly minds induced by these sensory consciousnesses.

So, at present, most of our minds are therefore sensory consciousnesses or minds which are induced by sensory consciousnesses. And this becomes evident when we reflect on the state of deep sleep. In deep sleep, we become bereft of awareness, simply because sensory consciousnesses are inactive. Now our goal should be instead of having minds which rely exclusively on sensory consciousnesses, to generate minds which are independent of sensory consciousnesses, which do not rely on sensory consciousnesses. So for instance in the dream state, So, these minds of the dream state are very interesting.

I suspect that minds arisen from meditation would manifest during the dream state. So as is said in Brahma of Āryadeva, the nature of the mind is to be uncontaminated and pure light. And there is also a quote from the to this same effect. Then what we should do is we should polish our mind. We should eliminate the stains on our mind systematically until it is clear.

So, there are numerous passages in the Tathāgatagarbha Sutras referring to the purification of the mind by eliminating the stains and the obscurations on the mind. So the brain and the nervous system are intimately connected to sensory consciousnesses. When we start speaking of subtle consciousnesses, these are not linked to the brain or the nervous system. So, we can see for instance, before falling in a state of deep sleep, which as you know is bereft of consciousness, that if we engage in some activities and after we wake up from the state of deep sleep, we remember what we engaged in. This means that there is a transmission from before the state of deep sleep to after.

How this occurs is to be investigated. Is it a consciousness or a potency? It is a potency which is transmitted and this potency rests in the mental continuum. Now, concerning the means to attain the object of attainment of conventional bodhichitta, which is full and utter enlightenment, as was explained. They are subdivided into the six perfections and the four means of gathering disciples.

The six perfections have started to be explained. Geshela explained the perfection of generosity and ethics, and at present, we have reached the perfection of forbearance which is subdivided into three. Now, if you inquire whether generosity is permanent or impermanent, it is impermanent. It is therefore an entity and it is subdivided into matter, consciousness and non associated compositional phenomena. In your opinion, which of the three is generosity?

Generosity. Generosity. Another. Come on. So what, why?

Alright. Okay, so you say that generosity is a non associative compositional phenomena. What’s the object of generosity? The object of generosity. What’s the definition of generosity?

We finished the presentation of the perfection of generosity then. So exactly how is an intention to give a non associated composition phenomenon? So an intention is a mental factor, it’s a mind, right? It can’t be a non associated compositional phenomenon. So it’s consciousness.

Then between main minds and mental factors, it’s a mental factor. So what is discordant with generosity? Thank you. So that’s that for generosity. We won’t enter into three fold subdivision.

Now moving onwards to ethics. What’s the definition of ethics? So yes, ethics is a consciousness. Within main minds and mental factors, it is a mental factor which is defined as the intention to protect. So, then we want to enter into three fold subdivision of ethics, but regarding the ethics of restraining from non virtuous or wrong behavior, what is discordant with that?

Yes. In other words, it’s clearer if you say the seven non virtues of body and speech. So then, is the practice of generosity and ethics present within our mental continuum or not? We are not talking of the perfection of generosity and ethics for which bodhichitta in the background is indispensable, just to practice. Now moving on to the third perfection, the perfection of forbearance or patience.

Then within the threefold division of impermanent phenomenon, it’s an impermanent phenomenon, consciousness, matter, and non associated compositional phenomena. It is a consciousness. And within the division of consciousnesses into sensory and mental consciousnesses, it’s a mental consciousness. Forbearance has little or no relation to sensory consciousnesses. Then what precisely is the definition or the meaning of forbearance?

It is to have an untroubled mind in the face of suffering or harm. So forbearance is extremely important since in dependence on forbearance, we both will experience less mental disturbance and greater happiness. So, I have another question for you, and I won’t ask you the details of the definition and the object observation and so forth, but I would like to ask you based on your own understanding and experience. What is the object of observation of forbearance? Maybe forbearance.

Forbearance. Forbearance. So the object of observation? What is the object of observation of forbearance? Patience if you prefer, forbearance.

Object of observation of forbearance. Think of it. Another person? Who’s angry? Just one person, know, no second.

So if I was examining you, suck! That’s it. The objects of observation of forbearance. Are there other answers? What is discordant with forbearance?

So you’re basically saying that other people are the object of observations and in addition they’re discordant. It’s not good for me always to explain things because you just drift off. I noticed when I start asking questions everyone’s standing straight with eyes wide open. Some of you said that the object of observation of forbearance was other persons and then when I ask what was discordant with forbearance, some said anger, but others said other persons as well. The object of observation.

So therefore forbearance is a result, an effect. It therefore arises independence on causes and conditions. What are the conditions for forbearance? What are the conditions for forbearance? It arises therefore independence on a discordant condition.

So that is our target. Then I don’t believe I said that patience arises in dependence on discordant conditions. I think you said it. Courageous. So to generate forbearance, we therefore need an enemy.

We therefore need what you call a discordant condition. As it isn’t present now, does that mean no one has the practice of patience in their mind stream? So in that case you have numerous opportunities to practice forbearance. So therefore to summarize, forbearance arises on the foundation of our mental continuum. Its object of Its object of observation is someone with whom we are at odds.

It’s And the condition is someone with whom we are at odds or an enemy. And that which is discordant with forbearance is anger. Now, that which is discordant with forbearance, anger, exists at present within our mental continuum. And how do we generate forbearance? We generate forbearance through reflecting on the faults of anger.

Now, once anger has arisen, then there is very little practice of forbearance. So, as Śāntideva says in Bodhisattvacharyavatara, once anger has arisen, the best of meals has no taste. It is impossible to sleep. And indeed, once anger has arisen, we cannot enjoy our food. We find it impossible to sleep and for that manner matter, our facial expression completely changes.

We become bright red. Our eyes are bulging and red and we start talking as Geshela said, you know. And then once anger has arisen, our talk becomes meaningless and inarticulate because as the mind within is troubled, then the exterior expression collapses. Then, we must therefore reflect on the faults of anger and what gives rise to anger. For instance, insults, injuries, harsh words.

Then one must reflect on the faults therefore of what is at odds, is discordant with forbearance, and this would probably include jealousy or envy, since jealousy or envy cause the mind to be troubled just like anger. Jealousy and envy like anger arise in dependence on someone or something which is discordant with us and they trouble the mind. Therefore, they are antithetical to the practice of forbearance. Now when we train in forbearance, we will not immediately eliminate anger but over time, our mind will become more peaceful and more happy. Moreover, if we reflect on great compassion, fully characterized great compassion, then all of this will be included within it.

Moreover, from the standpoint of dharma, if powerful anger arises within our mind stream, it destroys, it annihilates the roots of virtue. So this is evident for us because, for instance, what is the expression on our face, on the face of someone when they train in virtue? It is a beautiful, peaceful expression. Now, this is exactly the opposite of the expression on the face of the same person when they are angry, where the face is angry and hard. And therefore, the practice of virtue and of anger are opposite.

You you like pretty faces, don’t you? Then, through the practice of forbearance, not only in future lives will we get a higher rebirth, but through the practice of forbearance, one will get a beautiful face and a handsome body. It is called a complexion endowed with the radiance of forbearance. So basically once one trains in forbearance in this life, then in the next life not only does one get a higher rebirth, but as a result of forbearance because the effect is similar to the cause, one gains a very beautiful peaceful calm expression which is called having the radiance of forbearance. So, this is for the nature of forbearance that which is incompatible with forbearance, anger, and the benefits of forbearance.

Now forbearance is subdivided into three, the forbearance of accepting harm inflicted from others, the forbearance of accepting suffering and the forbearance of accepting hardship for dharma. The first forbearance is the one we just explained. Then obviously forbearance arises in dependence on someone who is discordant with us, an enemy. Forbearance cannot arise or arises with great difficulty independence on close relatives, parents, those who are close to us. They’re not a ground for generating forbearance.

Yet, the enemy does not intend in any way to help us. This is strange, isn’t it? Then if you don’t have someone who is at odds with you, you cannot generate forbearance. So here, when we refer to the necessity of relying on someone who is at odds with us or an enemy, we’re referring to the first category of forbearance, the forbearance which accepts the harm inflicted from another and for this we need an enemy. Let us therefore meditate during a couple of minutes on the nature of forbearance, the object of observation of forbearance, that which is discordant with forbearance and the benefits of forbearance.

Please open the prayer book, page one. We shall recite one b, two, three, four, page five, number six, Mandala, verse one and three. Page nine. At page five. The study of forbearance is extremely important for society in general and for this one must understand clearly what is discordant with forbearance which is anger and jealousy or envy.

Then the results of anger or jealousy are nothing good. They were something good, it would be different. Then if you have questions, please one question per person. What was the object of observation of forbearance? No.

The object of observation of forbearance would be the person who is at odds with us. Thank you, Geshela. I’m thinking of the people in New Delhi. I’m thinking of the people in New Delhi that are basically being smothered and suffocated by a world changing kind of pollution. They’re really frightened.

They are not angry at anyone necessarily, But surely, they have troubled minds. And forbearance would be the ability to take those conditions without disturbing one’s mind. And that does not involve another person. So what how do we classify that? So forbearance has three subdivisions.

Then the practice, the inhabitants of New Delhi are forced to engage in, is a practice of supporting harsh exterior conditions. That has nothing to do with the presence of a foe of an enemy. They have actually no choice in the matter. For the third type, the objective of observation when keeping concentration or things to do with the dharma. So the third type of of forbearance is the objects of observation distraction in that case or when you try and so the three of the three types of third one.

No. Distraction is what is discordant with the practice of enthusiasm or perseverance. It’s a form of laziness. So it’s included within the, that which is discordant with perseverance. So what’s the object of observation?

Which object of observation? Of what? Not be not the one where you’re harmed by others or not the one when you’re just suffering but the one where you’re either losing concentration or you’re trying to deal with dharma. The target there would be what is discordant within the practitioner to practice. Then the commentaries do not indicate what the object of observation and what is discordant with each form of perfection is.

How would you think or how would you put yourself being your own enemy? How would you think about that? Just off the top of my head wanting to excel and do really well at either being a parent or if you’re studying academically that you put a lot of pressure on yourself which causes a lot of despair in yourself and unhappiness. So you’re saying anger would arise with respect to yourself as well obviously. You know there’s an expression of self talk sometimes can be very negative.

And some unhappiness and anger in yourself. So nothing coming in, it’s all in here. So, in your own case, is before the anger arises that it is extremely important to reflect on the thoughts and the dangers of anger. So as not to allow it to arise because once it has arisen, it is extremely difficult to counter. One of the faults of anger is the destruction of roots of virtue.

What is which aspect of dedication protects virtue from being destroyed by anger? Dedication is akin dedicating the roots of virtue is akin to shooting an arrow at a target. Once you have launched the arrow, even if a thief wishes to steal the arrow, he cannot steal it. Likewise, once virtues have been dedicated, anger cannot destroy them. Geshela mentioned tonight that the seven non virtues of bodies and speech are discordant with the practice of ethics.

Why are the three non virtues of mind not included? The reason is because these seven non virtues of body and speech are discordant not with the practice of ethics in general, but with the specific practice of the ethics of restraint from non virtuous action. Then the three mental virtue and non virtues are actually part of the sphere of intention. There are numerous other forms of ethics such as for instance, the ethics of abstaining from breaches from the Bodhisattva vows and so forth. Geshela spoke about when we wake up from sleep and we remember what we did the day before, that this is not a consciousness, it is a potency.

I’m not quite sure what is meant by the term potency. Could Geshe elaborate please? So, potencies are non-associated compositional phenomena. They are neither matter nor consciousness. They are required to maintain a continuum of memory before between what happened before a state of deep sleep and what happens after a deep state of deep sleep.

They cannot be consciousness because consciousness is not present during deep sleep. Is it a practice of forbearance to put physical distance between yourself and an object of forbearance? Physical distance? Yes. An object to a personal object.

All I can say is that the best is that if your life is at stake or you risk to be beaten, you should take a safe distance from whatever is discordant. Stop here. We shall stop here for tonight. Just a couple of announcements. The seminar with Ilya, Three Principal Aspects of the Path is not this coming weekend, but the following weekend, the nineteenth at 02:00 and then on the nineteenth and then on the Sunday the twentieth, 06:00, Lhabab Düchen Puja.

So one of the big four Pujas within the year of the Tibetan calendar. And then the following week is the AGM which on the twenty sixth the twenty sixth is the AGM, Saturday at 10:30 and we’ll bring something to have a shared lunch with Geshela afterwards.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
mandala khyil khor (Tib)
A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

How does dedicating the roots of virtue protect them from being destroyed by anger?

Dedicating the roots of virtue is like shooting an arrow at a target. Once the arrow has been launched, even a thief who wishes to steal it cannot take it. In the same way, once virtues have been dedicated, anger cannot destroy them. The act of dedication puts the virtue beyond the reach of anger, just as a launched arrow is beyond the reach of a thief.

What is meant by the term 'potency' in Buddhist teachings, and how can it be explained?

Potencies are non-associated compositional phenomena, which means they are neither matter nor consciousness. They are needed to maintain a continuum of memory between what happened before a state of deep sleep and what happens after it. They cannot be consciousness, because consciousness is not present during deep sleep. So something that is neither form nor mind must carry the continuity of memory across that gap.

Scroll to Top