Lam Rim – Lamrim (6)

1 h 34 min · 4,512 words

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - Lamrim (6)
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Continues the Lam Rim teaching on refuge and bodhicitta, covering the two aspirations and liberation, then impermanence and death as antidotes to complacency. The talk moves to the five paths of hearers, solitary realizers and bodhisattvas, including the arhat paths and how solitary realizers differ in motivation. A lengthy question and answer session follows.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 34m

UUID: 1f273424-6dbe-4605-8a1e-199a7bd6bc83

Words: 4,509

So Geshe la thought that he would explain today going for refuge and the generation of the mind. In other words, the generation of bodhicitta. And this largely in keeping with Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra, the ornament of manifest realization in which there are numerous explanations of these topics. As you remember, the definition of bodhicitta which Geshe-la gave was a special mind endowed with both aspirations. The first aspiration is the aspiration for the sake of others, and the second aspiration is the aspiration for full and utter enlightenment.

In the context of the first aspiration, the aspiration for the sake of all others, one seeks for its cause and its cause is refuge. And the nature of the second aspiration is enlightenment. So what is the nature of bodhicitta? Should I explain this already? The definition.

Definition. Is there a difference between nature and definition? So Geshe-la, what is the actual definition? Then it is really very helpful when one gets up in the morning to reflect on this definition and to reflect specifically on both aspirations. As a result, one’s mind will be happy and at ease and probably a virtuous mind as well.

Then Geshe la cannot say whether you have time or not. He certainly does have time in the morning. So when he wakes up, he thinks of being endowed with both aspirations. And on this basis, one can generate the motivation. So I don’t know.

I’m not sure your time, you know. But I have more time enough. I ended, you You are very, very more time. Sorry? We should have time for that.

Really, okay. So, obviously, if one has time, it is ideal to focus on this in the morning when one gets up. So when one explains the nature of bodhicitta, one therefore explains these two aspirations, and the aspiration for full enlightenment is an aspiration to attain full and utter enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings without exception. Then the other aspiration is the aspiration for the sake of others. This is great compassion, the wish to eliminate suffering from others.

Do you understand? This is very significant. Sometimes, Geshe-la feels that you confuse compassion and bodhicitta. Great compassion is the cause of bodhicitta. Bodhicitta is the result of great compassion.

Then this wish for the sake of others, which is none other than great compassion, is a wish to free others from suffering. But for this wish to arise, one must understand the mode of one’s own being beset by the afflictions. If one does not understand how oneself is beset by the afflictions, it is very strange to wish to liberate others from this. And the cause of great compassion itself is therefore uncontrived bodhicitta, uncontrived definite emergence. You understand?

Good. Then definite emergence in Tibetan is or definite refers to liberation. Or emergence refers to the mind in which that wish for liberation has arisen. So therefore, the two syllables of definite emergence in Tibetan, ne and jung, refer respectively to liberation and to jungwa, the mind which is striving for that state. And this is illustrated by the verse in Je Tsongkhapa’s three principal aspects of the path, in which he says, when day and night, the wish for liberation arises, fully characterized definite emergence has been generated.

Now here, you can see the equation between definite between definite and liberation, and emergence and the mind striving for liberation. So this is a very profound set of two verses. When day and night, the wish for liberation arises, then definite emergence has been well generated. So liberation here refers to a an unchanging state of happiness dependent on the mind. It does not refer to some sort of absence of exterior things or whatever.

It does refer to the noble truth of cessation. Well, liberation is therefore the attainment of a happiness independent on the mind. And irrespective of whether we attain this liberation in this life or in a future life, it is critical initially to understand that the attainment of such a liberation exists, that we ourselves can attain such a liberation. So when we think of liberation, we typically think of Buddha Śākyamūni. But Buddha Śākyamūni has departed, and Buddha Śākyamūni’s continuum and our continuum are different.

It is not terribly related to us. Instead, when we think of liberation, we should we should think of our own attainment of liberation. Then liberation is the extinction of the afflictions. This extinction of the afflictions give rise to gives rise to happiness. That is liberation.

So as Ārya Nāgārjuna says, through the extinction of karma and the afflictions, liberation. Then for ourselves, we can see that when we reduce the influence of anger, or let us say desire, affliction such as anger or desire in our mind stream, we are happier. Then, obviously, if we were able to eliminate them durably or permanently, then we would be durably or permanently happy. And this is done through applying the antidote. Then we must not think that it is impossible to separate our minds from the afflictions.

It is possible to do so. And there is a passage from Sūtra, which is very inspiring in this respect, and which says the nature of the mind is pure light. Then if we think of the example of a child at birth, and during the first couple months of its life, until the seventh, eighth months, and so forth, then it illustrates this very clearly. Because at that point, a child has no clear sense of self and others, and the afflictions are limited. As a child grows older, these afflictions become more powerful.

The same thing is true about the mind. So then how precisely do we separate the mind from the afflictions, once we have understood that this is possible? We separate the mind from the afflictions through applying the requisite antidote. As Ārya Nāgārjuna says in a stanza, which begins with, through the cessation of karma and afflictions, liberation, and ends with the famous line, it is by the means of emptiness that these are ceased. Now here, the antidote which is to be applied is the wisdom which realizes emptiness, which is directly opposite to the mode of apprehension of the I by ignorance.

So once one understands that through applying ever more powerful wisdoms, realizing emptiness as antidote to the afflictions, it is possible to eliminate them incrementally until one attains a state of liberation. A profound conviction in liberation will arise. This profound conviction in liberation is one of the most eloquent ways of presenting going for refuge. This is how Geshe la himself reflects on the relationship between going for refuge and bodhicitta, and one does this in terms of the Lam Rim and for a given person. And then obviously, it depends on whether one has the time to do this or not.

And therefore, reflecting over and again on liberation, and reflecting over and again on the faults of cyclic existence, reflecting over and again on the faults of the afflictions, then one can generate a mind striving for liberation. Without reflecting over and again on the thoughts of the afflictions, one cannot generate a mind striving for liberation, and such a mind is said to be virtuous and a cause for liberation in Then it is very helpful to reflect as follows. It is through the apprehension of one’s own permanence that one falls into the lower realms at the level of the path shared with the being of small scope. And it is through the ignorance grasping at one’s own self that one falls into cyclic existence at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope. And it is through self cherishing that one falls into the extreme of peace.

In other words, that instead of focusing on full and utter enlightenment, one one focuses on the attainment of the state of an arhat, at the level of the path shared with the being of the great scope. So at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope, it is through the apprehension of one’s own permanence. In other words, the belief that one will live for a very long time, even though it is clear that the time of death is completely uncertain. That in turn, one makes preparations for this very long life. And for instance, one will buy a house, and then in dependence on that house, one needs the food which goes with such a house, the drink or the beverages which go with a house, the lifestyle, in other words.

And obviously, to get all this, one must engage in various activities as a result of which one accumulates non virtuous karma. This non virtuous karma leads to a rebirth in the lower realms. This is very clear. It’s obvious. Then this apprehension of one’s own permanence is extraordinarily harmful.

It is the cause of procrastination, and it is a cause of all laziness. We think, well, I mean, I should go on a retreat, and during a retreat, one has special conditions to accumulate virtue, but right now, don’t have time. I’ll do it next year, or I’ll do it next month, or I’ll do it next week, and so forth. Now the antidote to the apprehension of one’s own permanence, the only antidote to it, is meditation on death and impermanence. One’s own death and one’s own impermanence, and specifically, the uncertainty of the time of death and impermanence.

Then, as a result of this meditation, one gives rise to contentment, and that is a source of happiness. Do you understand? So when one meditates on the uncertainty of the time of death, contentment arises. Then people often think that somehow one has to meditate and become habituated to contentment. That is not the case.

How could one do this? However, in our own case, we are beset by this apprehension of our own permanence, And this apprehension of our own permanence is a mistaken, a wrong mind. Is it mistaken in a wrong mind because its object is mistaken and wrong. Its object is the idea that somehow we will live, let us say, I will I am fifty at present, that I will live another fifty years. Then we have no control over the duration of our life.

As a result of this mistaken mind, a mistaken conviction arises. To its opposite, once one meditates on the uncertainty of the time of death, the uncertainty of the time of death is reality. This is the way things are. Then as a result, a valid mind arises and contentment arises. So contentment is a virtuous state of mind, and we must cultivate this contentment through meditation on death and impermanence.

And then, as a result, we will engage in an ethics, which is a protection against the ten non virtues, and we should target principally the non virtue with which we are the most familiar with. Then if we behave in this way, we will deposit karmic imprints. We refer frequently to karmic imprints, but basically, the term is a little bit obscure. What it means is just habits. And then at the time of one’s death, there should be no difficulties.

Obviously, we must take care of one’s health and one’s body, because if one has a hard death, then things are difficult. Do you understand? If you have understood, you will practice. And then it’s easier. Right?

It’s something we can do, in other words. So therefore, one must deposit virtuous karmic imprints of the mind stream. Then when one speaks of virtuous karmic imprints, we’re speaking of habits, of habituations. And if one does this regularly, then at the time of death, one will die in a virtuous frame of mind. Under the force of this virtuous frame of mind, if we like this human rebirth, we will be reborn as a human being the next time.

Because she was asking me, if you don’t like it, and I said after, then it’s easy. Right? This body of ours does not arise just at random. It arises from numerous causes and conditions, which are difficult to accumulate. It arises from past causes and conditions.

Now, this life is short compared to future lives. Future lives are much longer than this one. So future lives should be more important than this life, not the other way around. So therefore, we should meditate over and again on death and impermanence and on future lives. Meditating just on death is not terribly helpful, since it’s a given that we will die.

And meditating in this way on death and impermanence, and on future lives, we should then focus on that within the ten non virtues, which is closest to us, which we practice the most easily, and apply the antidotes to that. So at the time of the death of our death, we will powerlessly be reborn in the higher or the lower realms, independence on the virtuous or non virtuous karma, which is activated at that point. And an example will make this clear. Let us take a child in Australia. Children go to school here, let us say, at age five.

Then there is a lot of conditions which are necessary to have a good education. One needs a good school, good teachers. One needs to come from a good family to have a good birth. And if all these conditions are assembled, then the child powerlessly progresses. Let us say, the child has good parents, and the parents send it to a top notch private school.

Then all other things being equal, the child will do very well for himself or herself. Then if the parents send the child to a bad school, where he has bad teachers, the odds is that he will not do well for himself. It’s the same thing. Just as a child’s path in life is determined almost powerlessly by its good fortune in its parents, over which it has little or no control. Likewise for ourselves at the time of our death, our good or unfortunate rebirth are determined powerless powerlessly by the virtuous or non virtuous mind streams within our consciousness.

Do you understand? So let us at present generate the motivation to receive these teachings on Lam Rim thinking. I want in the future to obtain a good base like this one, and to obtain such a good base, I must accumulate the causes and conditions, the karmic causes and conditions for such a base, because it is on a base such as this one, a human base, that I will be able to think about liberation and full enlightenment. Please open the paper, page one. We recite page one b, two, three, four, and also page five, another six mandala offering, verse one and three.

So at present, let us turn to grounds and paths on the Lam Rim. Geshe la has completed the explanation of the five Mahāyāna paths. The Mahāyāna path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning. Now there are two other vehicles, the vehicle of hearers and the vehicle of solitary realizers. Both, just like the Mahāyāna vehicle, have five paths.

You have the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation, and normal learning of a hearer. And you have the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation, and normal learning of a solitary realizer. Mhmm. To understand So the presentation of the five paths of a hearer and the five paths of a solitary realizer are the same. Do you understand?

So please give the five paths of a hearer. Together, please. Or together, please. You you’ve got to say path of accumulation of a hearer. Path of preparation of a hearer.

It’s appropriate if you don’t add hearer. So please repeat again. Now the five paths of a solitary realizer. Long in English, isn’t it? Yes.

In Tibetan, you know That’s it in Tibetan, right? So what is the difference between the paths, the five paths of a hearer, of a solitary realizer, and of a bodhisattva? It is motivation. There are three different motivations. The motivation of uncontrived definite emergence is the foundation.

Do you understand? So this basically connects or encounters with the motivation. So if one generates for one’s own sake alone, a motivation of uncontrived definite emergence, one has entered the path of accumulation of a hearer. Alright. If you have questions right now about that motivation, ask them now.

Okay. Now, once again, on the foundation of a motivation of uncontrived definite emergence. If one generates the uncontrived wish to attain full enlightenment for one’s sake alone, one has entered the path of accumulation of a solitary realized Buddha, a Prateka Buddha. Do you understand? Now, the mode of progression on the five paths for hearers and solitary realizers, apart from the difference in motivation, is identical to that explained for the Bodhisattva Yana.

In other words, for a hearer on the path of accumulation, once that hearer gives rise to an insight focused on emptiness, he will he or she would have passed to a hearer path of preparation. And then he or she progresses up to a hearer path of seeing, path of meditation, and a hearer path of no more learning. The same is true for a solitary realizer. So Geshe la, I would like to ask you at present, how does a hearer on the path of accumulation progress to a hearer path of preparation? When he develops through single pointed meditation on emptiness, progressing, progresses then to the path of a conceptual realization of emptiness on the path of preparation.

Yes. So he has progressed to a path of preparation. So how does he progress from a hearer path of preparation to a hearer path of seeing? When for the first time he develops a single pointed direct focus on emptiness arising from meditation, he’s developed a hero path of seeing. How does he progress from the hearer path of seeing to a hearer path of meditation?

When having arisen from the hearer path of seeing, enters directly into a direct insight into emptiness arisen from meditation. He has entered into the hearer path of meditation. So how does he or she progress from a hearer path of meditation to a hearer path of normal learning? During the hero path of meditation, the obscurations to grasping at true existence are steadily abandoned and once the grasping at true existence is completely abandoned, the being enters the hearer path of no more learning. Yes.

Yes. That is how a hearer on the path of meditation proceeds. Okay. So let’s go. Yinda in Tibetan.

Right? Mhmm. So you’ve got fifteen paths. You’ve got five hero paths, five solitary realizer paths, five bodhisattva paths, which makes fifteen. So let’s now think in terms of the fifteen paths.

Within these fifteen paths, how many aria paths are there? That’s it. Do you understand? Which one? Which ones?

The Mahāyāna path of seeing, the Mahāyāna path of meditation, the Mahāyāna path of no more learning, the hearer path of seeing, the hearer path of meditation, the hearer path of no more learning, and the solitary realizer path of seeing, the solitary realizer path of meditation, and the solitary realizer You can summarize and say, a hearer a hearer path of seeing meditation and normal learning, a solitary realizer path of seeing meditation and normal learning, a mahayana path of seeing meditation and normal learning. So therefore, on these fifteen paths, how many aryas are there? Sumire. Nine, seven. Nine.

Nine. Yeah. Yeah. Sure. You have nine ārya paths, and you have nine types of ārya beings on these nine paths, one for each path.

Alright? So within these nine ārya beings, how many arhats are there? Six. Six. Okay.

Chik sugre. Chik druig. Okay. Yu says three and Jill says six. Okay.

And the other one. How many arhat beings on these fifteen paths? Nine six three. Two. Knee.

What do we mean by arhat? In Tibetan which means overcoming the enemy, the foe. What does that mean? There are only three. Right?

How could you have No nine. No nine. No So an arhat is a being who has abandoned the afflictions. Then the afflictions are abandoned on the path of no more learning. In that case, how could there be any else but three?

Okay. Nine. Good. That’s about good. About realized that was wrong too.

How many Buddhas? Yeah. Yeah. On the Mahāyāna path of no more learning. So a higher path of no more learning is Buddhahood.

Do you understand? He says, the question is, do pratyeka Buddhas exist or not? So in the case of solitary realizers or pratyeka buddhas, all their goal, full and utter enlightenment, is the same as in the Mahāyāna. The motivation is completely different. The motivation is to attain full enlightenment for their own sake alone.

Then they are set to attain a body with the thirty two major and the eighty minor no. They’re set to attain a body similar to that with the thirty two a major and the eighty minor marks, and it takes them much longer to attain this. It is said that they must practice for one hundred eons. Mhmm. You can question.

Yep. I would like to ask, I’m a bit confused about the motivation of the hearer and solitary Realizer. Realizers. Yes. Could Geshe la clarify what’s the difference?

What’s that motivation? The motivations are very similar. It is hearers and solitary realizers both are aiming for their own sake, but their goals are different. The hearer is aiming for liberation for his or her own sake. Mhmm.

The solitary realizer is aiming for Buddhahood, full enlightenment, but for his or her own sake. You understand? The objects, the goals are different. What does a solitary being do once they’ve attained full and utter enlightenment with their time if they’re not seeking to benefit? Solitary realizers Prateka Buddhas cannot attain a state like that of Buddha Śākyamūni.

It is not possible. Because one needs a huge amount of merit for this, even though that’s their goal. What what do they what do they do though? Are they then Can we deal with that later? They’re loving to If they can’t achieve their goal and that’s the motivation, what happens to them next?

Well, since it’s all for their own sake, it’s self evident. Right? So hearers and solitary realizers are motivated by self cherishing, but they have different goals. Their goal. The goal.

Different. But they can’t achieve it. They attain a goal. Okay. Just in the wake of that, could Geshe la please make the distinction between a hearer on the path of no more learning and a solitary realizer on the path of no more learning?

Have they attained the same enlightenment liberation. So it is better to talk, instead of talking of hearer paths of normal learning and solitary realizer paths of normal learning in this context, to talk of hearer arhats and solitary realizer arhats. Their attainments are different, because a solitary realizer arhat practices one hundred eons to gain this attainment of his, and therefore, attainment must be more important. And it is said that he attains or she attains a body with a simile of the thirty two major and the eighty minor marks. Solitary realizers are rare.

Maybe they exist only in tenets. The level the hearer no more learning path is lower than the solitary realizer no more learning path. Yes. Yes. Apart from motivation, what is the etymology or meaning of hearer and solitary realizer?

Is it the mode of listening and meditating? So Shavakas, hearers rely on hearing extensively the teachings of the Buddha from the the root shu in Sanskrit to listen. Right? Solitary realizers, on the other hand, once they have entered the solitary realizer path of accumulation, progress to the path of preparation and onwards all by themselves. There is a strong resolve to practice alone, and they live in solitude.

They do not live in society. If I may ask another question, the, a Buddha existing for its own sake seems like a oxymoron. I don’t know how you translate that but it seems a contradiction in terms and therefore have I confused the causes of Buddha from a Mahāyāna perspective is bodhicitta and emptiness. And in the absence of bodhichitta, there can be no Buddha. So are we redefining the word Buddha?

The difference is exclusively in the motivation. Then the solitary realizers never attain their goal by definition. They attain something, but it is not the state of full enlightenment. It’s impossible for them to attain that. So please be aware of the fact that we speak when we speak of in Tibetan.

Is an arhat is a being who has abandoned afflictions totally, including their seeds. An ārya being has abandoned afflictions, but not totally. So what Geshe la described just before that, is that a Mahāyāna perspective or Mahāyāna view from the Hīnayāna view, would they not say that it is possible to obtain, to be a, what do you call, a solitary realizer, a particular Buddha. Doesn’t matter. Just focus on bodhicitta.

It’s a lot of problems with Kritika. You have the rhinoceros like Pratyeka Buddha, etcetera. Geshe la’s explanation of Salam, the three vehicles with its five paths each, which make fifteen paths, is from the standpoint of Then the other systems of tenets, Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, Svatāntrika, Mādhyamika, Chitamatra, have their own presentation of the differences between these fifteen paths. For instance, Vaibhāṣikas and Sautrantikas assert that one progresses from the level of warmth, the first of the four levels of the path of preparation, to the path of no more learning in one meditative session. Chris, can you pass?

Mark away. Speaker. I’m just curious about the hero in solitaire realizer. They practice until they reach but could they change their path, you know, like in a next karmic life, could they change their path to the Mahāyāna path and then go from accumulation? Yes.

They definitely they definitely can enter the Mahāyāna. There are many complications. Geshe-la is happy to talk about it, it’ll take many months. The complications are as follows. On the one hand, it said it is said that all sentient beings are suitable to become enlightened.

Then obviously, this would apply to solitary realizer, hearers, and pratyeka Buddhas. On the other hand, the Chitamatra schools, which assert eight collections of consciousness, assert that when solitary realizer and hearer arhat reached the end of their life, their continuum is severed. There are three final vehicles. Therefore, they could not enter the Mahāyāna. Okay.

Stop here. I have a chance. Things went very well. recite the prayer. Pages eight, nine, ten, eleven, twelve.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
Sautrantika-Svatantrika-Madhyamika
The Sutra Middle Way Autonomy school, a division of the Svatantrika (Autonomy school) of Buddhist philosophy. The proponent asserts a presentation of conventionalities through mostly conforming with the Sautrantika (Sutra school). LYWA
yana
Literally, vehicle; a spiritual path that leads to an awakened state. The vehicle and spiritual journey depends on the attitude of the practitioner. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Can practitioners of the hearer or solitary realizer path change to the Mahāyāna path in a later life and begin again from the accumulation path?

Yes, they definitely can enter the Mahāyāna, but there are many complications, and explaining them fully would take many months. On the one hand, it is said that all sentient beings are suitable to become enlightened. That would apply to solitary realizers, hearers and pratyekabuddhas. On the other hand, the Chitamatra schools, which assert eight collections of consciousness, hold that when a hearer or solitary realizer arhat reaches the end of life, their continuum is severed. These schools assert three final vehicles, so by their view such practitioners could not enter the Mahāyāna.

Scroll to Top