1 h 41 min · 4,630 words · 26 August 2015
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teacher explains how to meditate on the Lam Rim, using death and impermanence as an example, and insists on studying one topic deeply rather than scattering study. He describes the transition from the path of the small being to the middling being through uncontrived renunciation and the four noble truths, and explains meditation as withdrawing the mind from sensory objects toward calm abiding. A short question session and a farewell for a departing monk close the recording.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 41m
UUID: 188cdbeb-691f-45f8-a842-dff0e8d5f14c
Date: 2015-08-26
Words: 4,626
So we have finished the presentation of the path of the being of the small scope and its multiple objects or cycles of meditation. Now when one studies the Lamrim, one should study the Lamrim with the graduated stages of the path over and again. One should not view the Lamrim as one would view a secular object of study which one studies, one sits the required exams and then one sets the material aside. This would lead to very strange results if one were to study the path of the being of a small scope then set it all aside and pass to the path of the being of the middling scope. Now the path of the being of the small scope has seven topics or cycles of meditation.
Three are shared or common and four are uncommon. Before uncommon ones are death and impermanence, the suffering of the lower realms, refuge and causality. So when we speak of meditation or habituation, what is to be understood thereby? If we take for instance meditation on the body of death and impermanence, the actual topic of death and impermanence, how would one proceed? During one hour or so, one would set the mind on death and impermanence and reflect on it.
If instead, we just try to reflect on the topic for a couple of minutes, it is difficult for us to gain any type of experience on the spaces. So when we meditate on a topic such as death and impermanence, for us at presence, this present, this entails being forceful using forceful means to focus the mind on the topic. The mind will not naturally or spontaneously focus on it at our present state. I don’t believe there is one single person in this room who does not have at least one hour free every day. Who doesn’t?
Then in a twenty four hour period, obviously we have to sleep. This is empty time which could be used. So we should try to meditate one hour each day. If we take for instance topic of death and impermanence, how should we proceed? Death and impermanence is analyzed or meditated upon in terms of the three roots.
Death is certain, the time of death is uncertain and at the time of death, the only thing which is of benefit is dharma. Each of these three roots is subdivided into three reasons which is the reason for which the practice is called that of the three roots and the nine reasons. So one of the biggest faults in meditation on the Lamrim as explained in the Lambrim is a casual and superficial meditation on the Lamrim where one quickly says well, this topic has four outlines and death and impermanence has three outlines and then one passes on to the suffering of the lower realms, refuge, causality and so forth. As a result of such casual superficial practice, one never gets an experience, an actual taste of the topic. Then the way to counter this is to focus on one topic, for instance death and impermanence for as long as it’s necessary to gain an experience and then engage in an overview, a chagrön meditation on the remainder.
What do we mean by meditation? At present, we are controlled by our mind and our mind is controlled by the afflictions. Instead of this, we should withdraw our mind inwards and become the masters of our mind focusing it on a virtuous object. This is meditation. So you have asked frequently for an introduction to meditation.
This is what meditation is. Meditation involves setting one’s mind in a relaxed fashion on a virtuous object of observation such as the four noble truths, emptiness and so forth and leaving it there. So this is how one should proceed. One should first focus on one topic of meditation such as death and impermanence and after getting a feeling or a sensation of this topic, in other words an experience, one should move to the next topic upwards and upwards. Now at present, I have a question for you.
How does one pass from the path of the being of the small scope, the path shared with the being of the small scope to the path shared with the being of the middling scope. Please don’t answer elaborately, just a very short answer otherwise we will waste our time. So I’ve answered the question, please I’ve asked the question, please answer. Yes, the question is how do you pass from the path shared with the being of the small scope to the path shared with the being of the middling scope? So we are present covering the path of the middle, being of the middling scope in other words the four noble truths.
Then what is the mode of transition from the path of the being of the small scope to the path of the being of the middling scope? Another. And Nana? Yeah. And another answer.
Chris? So many of you answered turning away from the vanities of this life. Turning away from the vanities of this life is actually the realization of the path of the being of the small scope. If that is your answer, you have not explained how one passes from the path of the being of the small to the being of the middling scope. You’ve not explained the transition.
Some have said renunciation. Yes, there is an element of it present. So what I would definitely like to say to you today is that there is no benefit in this scattered approach which you have adopted to study which entails studying a little bit of the path of the being of the small scope, then a little bit of the path of the beak and the milling scope, then passing the view to the view, then doing a bit of tantra, then going back and at the end of the day, nothing is integrated or assimilated. Instead, since our present topic is the path of the being of the small scope, in other words the four truths, you should focus on the four truths and then try to gain an understanding of this. This is something I say based on an assessment of what I can see as your approach to study.
I am not saying that I have any realization of this but I have an experience I can see of how you study. And therefore when you study a topic like the Four Noble Truths, you should study this topic and then drawing on reasons incrementally build upon this build upwards and avoid this scattered haphazard approach to study which I see so much here. This is how you should study. When we say in Tibetan, is a path, is a stages. So there is an incremental progression in the stages and indeed one must first listen then reflect and eventually meditate on the topic.
Do you understand? As Je Tsongkhapa says in his Three Principles of the Path, when contemplating the marvels of cyclic existence, day and night renunciation arises at that point uncontrived renunciation will have been generated. Without elaborating this topic, living in Australia, if we reflect clearly in accordance with the teachings with the dharma, we will eventually understand that true happiness comes from deep within the mind and not from the outside. And at this point, we will not be like some who are fascinated by other countries and who keep thinking that all it would take is to travel to New Zealand or to Switzerland to be happy. Thinking that these are beautiful countries.
Beautiful they are indeed but these are countries which are of the nature of suffering just as here. Once one has understood that, definitely one has turned away from the vanities of this life. So once one realizes that whenever one travels to another country, one indeed the first couple days may be extraordinarily pleasant. After one year, it is exactly as in the country one has left. At this point, one will have a sense of the faults of cyclic existence and one will understand the passage in Jetsongapas text in which he says cyclic existence does not have even one quality.
So once one understands that whatever country one is in and these countries are pleasant countries. Nonetheless, one has to relate one’s experience to dharma, one can proceed. Then when one has understood that in the search for happiness, happiness is not to be found in exterior physical entities but deep within the mind. At this point, one will turn one’s mind towards an attainment of liberation and it is when this becomes completely spontaneous and for instance, when one rises in the morning instead of having breakfast or drinking tea, one discards this and focuses immediately on practice that one will be able to say that one has generated an uncontrived striving for liberation and has passed to the path of the being shared with the middling scope. Then among you who has this, I don’t know.
So as Je Tsongkhapa says in the Three Principles of the Path, once it arises spontaneously day and night at that point, one will have fully generated definite emergence. And the meaning here is that once as was said, renunciation arises spontaneously even when one rises then one will have generated the mind striving for liberation. One will have generated renunciation, one would have entered the path of the being of the middling scope and one would have entered the path. In other words, one would have passed from the path shared as a being of the small scope to that of shared as a being of the middling scope. At present, focusing on the path of the being of the middling scope, as you remember its main topic is the four noble truths.
The first of which is the noble truth of suffering. Once one has generated a realization of the faults, the defects of the noble truth of suffering, independence on this a mind which wishes to be liberated, to be freed from the noble truth of suffering spontaneously arises. Now this liberation from the noble truth of suffering is a noble truth of cessation, which in the sequence of the four noble truths is not presented in the second place after the noble truth of suffering but in the third place. But the question which arises, the doubt which arises is why is it presented in the third place and not in the second place? This is that which will naturally arise when one focuses on the thoughts of the noble truth of suffering.
So if one focuses at present on the four noble truths which are the main topic as I explained last time of the path shared with the being of the middling scope, then initially one should know what the four noble truths are. I should not enter into this. I assume it is known otherwise we will waste time in brief. The noble truth of suffering, of the origin of suffering, of cessation and of the path. And therefore, if we analyze the sequence of presentation of teaching of the four noble truths.
The first noble truth, the noble truth of suffering was taught in the first place. And then as was explained, spontaneously a desire to be freed from suffering which strives for liberation from the noble truth of suffering arises. This liberation is none other than the noble truth of cessation. But the noble truth of cessation, instead of being taught in the second place after the noble truth of suffering, is taught in the third place. So one might address the following syllogism.
It follows that the subject, the noble truth of cessation should not be taught in the third place but should be taught in the second place after the noble truth of suffering. Now what is your answer to this doubt? So if you have an answer, please give a concise answer explaining why the truth of cessation should be in the third position. Yeah. Another?
Chris? Yeah. Could you sub could you summarize, please? So that liberation which is attained in dependence on uncontrived renunciation which sees the faults of cyclic existence is indeed the noble truth of cessation. Now all as a result of a contemplation of the faults of the first noble truth, a noble truth of suffering, a mind striving for liberation does indeed arise.
This mind striving for liberation does not lead to a liberation which is the third noble truth, noble truth of cessation because it is not rooted in authentic reasons in my opinion. Now, after the noble truth of the origin of suffering, the noble truth of cessation is taught. The reason for this is best understood in the light of the 12 links and you probably know the 12 links. In their forward presentation, the 12 links in other words, in a summarized form, the noble truth of suffering and the origin of suffering represent the entry into psychic existence and in their reverse sequence, they represent the exit from psychic existence and they are or they teach the noble truth of cessation explicitly. Excuse me, they teach the noble truth of the path explicitly and the noble truth of cessation.
And in the reverse order, they teach the noble truth of cessation explicitly and the noble truth of the path implicitly. This is a bit difficult for us at present but slowly we will understand better the topic of the 12 links is presented within the Lamrim. So as I said, the noble truth of suffering must be known and the noble truth of the origin of suffering must be abandoned. A being who proceeds in this fashion almost certainly will be a being who will gain realization of emptiness by means of a valid cognizer. So such a being will seek for a means to eliminate the noble truth of the origin of suffering.
And the source of the noble truth of the origin of suffering is none other than self grasping or beginningless ignorance. Through training in the wisdom which realizes emptiness which or whose mode of apprehension is directly contradictory with that of the beginningless ignorance progressively through repeated habituation with the wisdom realizing emptiness, the force of beginningless ignorance will dwindle and eventually disappear. This is a noble truth of cessation. So once one has engaged in this process of increasing the wisdom which realizes emptiness to lead to a decrease in the ignorance which grasps at a self. The ignorance dwindles and when one sees this happening, great enthusiasm arises within one’s mind and one pledges oneself to eliminate completely this ignorance.
Once one has taken this pledge, one will actualize cessation. How was that? Don’t worry about it. These are not easy topics. Emptiness in the four noble truths are not straightforward to understand.
At the monasteries, we study all of the Paramita and Mādhyamika to gain an understanding of this. Just proceed slowly. So once through repeated familiarity with the wisdom realizing emptiness, the ignorance which grasps at a self dwindles eventually one will eliminate beginningless ignorance. At this point, if we look at the 12 links in the reverse order having eliminated ignorance, we will have eliminated the link of karma and having eliminated the link of karma, we will eliminate the third link, the link of consciousness. So this is a fair bit of material for today at present regarding the generation of the motivation.
There is nothing superior than first covering the path of the being of the small scope and then reflecting on the process of transition from the path of the being of the small scope to the path of the being of the middling scope to meditate. After this, we will have the recitations as usual. So we’ll meditate for a couple of minutes. So when we speak of meditation, meditation is that pacification which prevents the mind from being distracted towards exterior objects and which focuses it on an object of observation. The main obstacle to this is precisely the five sensory consciousnesses to which we are completely enslaved.
In addition, we can see that most of our conceptual activity arises in dependence on the five sensory consciousnesses. So this is something one can understand through direct experience. Meditation is very famous but if we try to focus our mind on an object of observation, it will not stay focused on that mind without distraction for even twenty seconds. So this dependence on the exterior sensory consciousness is something we are all well aware of through experience. Now precisely because within the twin subdivision of sensations into mental and physical sensations, we are overwhelmed by physical sensations which arise independence on the five sensory consciousnesses.
We see exterior physical objects as a source of happiness. Meditation involves turning the mind away from exterior physical objects and turning it inwards. When we have turned the mind inwards, we have begin to meditate. We have begun to meditate. Then when we try to meditate on difficult topics like the four noble truths or emptiness, there is a reason for which we tend to fall asleep.
Which is simply that when the mind is turned inwards from the sensory consciousnesses, it becomes dull. It loses its potency. Then we easily fall asleep. In brief, what we must do is after ceasing the sensory consciousnesses to nonetheless focus on the object of observation with a subtle mind. When we reach the point where such a subtle consciousness can be placed on its object indefinitely for weeks, months, even years without wavering from its object, we are on the path to calm abiding.
At this point, such a subtle consciousness does not depend on the body. Then such a subtle consciousness does rely on a wind or an energy. And it is clear that when a mind interacts with an exterior object, there is a movement of this wind or this energy which or on which that mind rides. Little is said about this in the Paramithyanas since such winds or energies are not used in that context. Through relying on coarse sensory consciousnesses which focus on exterior physical objects, it would not be possible to gain this type of understanding.
We need to rely on a subtle consciousness. It is this subtle consciousness which transmigrates. It is also through relying on such a subtle consciousness that we can know the minds of others. Once we have gained experience of such a subtle consciousness, since it does not rely on the coarse body, the contaminated aggregates, then it can remain focused on its object for hundreds or thousands of years. Stop here tonight.
So we shall stop here tonight. If you have questions, please ask few short questions. So of course, consciousnesses are the sensory, the five sense consciousnesses and obviously conceptuality which arises independence on these. They are called coarse simply because they cease when we sleep. They stop when we sleep.
Subtle consciousness is that consciousness which is present when we withdraw our mind within and the best example of subtle consciousness would be calm abiding. And We use consciousness to an extraordinary degree, however, much much we meditate, especially when we meditate on emptiness. Thank you, Geshela, for your instructions today on practice and and study. One question that I have: how much time should one spend on the preliminary practices? They can be very in-depth, detailed or can be very brief.
What is the best solution for those that are trying to practice the path? So if you are speaking of the preliminary practices before going into a long retreat, then you should spend as much time as is necessary to finish them. But I’m joking. However, what one should do is one should check one’s body, one’s health and then perform them as much as is possible for one’s physical condition and then this takes the time it takes. And then, yeah.
Thanks. I would like to ask if this is a practice of emptiness. Like, if I feel I like something and I dislike something, dislike and dislike are just afflictions. And if I apply antidotes to it, I will feel that the the definition of self doesn’t actually exist. Is this a practice of emptiness?
No, not really. What is critical for an understanding of emptiness is to identify the object of negation as is clearly explained in Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara. And once one has searched for this object of negation within its basis of imputation, the aggregates and has not found it after having gained familiarity with the I, then one is on a good path to understand emptiness. Otherwise, it is very strange to say that there is such a thing as selflessness since after all the I is an experience we all share. So it is once, when after under analytical investigation, the I turns out to be impossible to ascertain by a valid cognizer that when we dwell upon this absence, we gain a particular feeling, a particular sensation.
And mother? Yeah, go on. Such a sensation would be a sensation of joy. Could Geshela say a little bit more about the subtle consciousness that can know the minds of others? Would the consciousness be aware of that?
So when the five sensory consciousnesses are occluded or withdrawn inwards, since we are overwhelmed with their experience, it is a little bit as if no consciousness was present. And at this point, we can start to speak of a subtle consciousness which can be focused on an object of observation. Now, such a subtle consciousness is associated with a wind or an energy. Very little is said about this in the Pāramitāyāna, the Perfection Vehicle. This is developed in tantra and this wind or this energy accompanies the consciousness.
It seems to move when the consciousness is for instance impelled by a motivation. Then it is as a result of this that we can gain some sort of a sense of the way of thinking of others. Then our present consciousnesses with which we would like for instance to see what is far away, what is in future lives, what is in past lives, what occurs within the minds of others are coarse sense consciousnesses. These are things which enabled us to touch stuff like the table. So how could we accomplish such great goals with these coarse consciousnesses?
So we shall stop here. It’s a very special night tonight. We have a big party here. It’s a farewell for Venerable Lobsang Nyima. And Lobsang Nyima has been here at TBI since, when was it?
The 2009. ‘9, I think around that time. And I remember when he first came here, we’re doing making the throne for the statues, you know, that the statues of Je Tsongkhapa, Śākyamūni Buddha and Chenrezig with Marvin. You probably know one of the regret student who helped in many ways at the center. You know, he’s the one who done the all the electrician and there’s numerous Lobsang Nyima put effort and work for and management during His Holiness’s 2013 visit at TBI and, yeah, lots of effort and work for the center he’s done.
And, of course, the sponsorship as well, you know, that’s included. The many, many hours, you know, put in a sponsorship scheme. And last year, he choose that his path to ordain, you know, is very wonderful. Anyway, what I would like to say, you know, congratulations. You are part of what you’ve chosen and and thank you so much in your contribution to center and all those what you have done never lost and this is your great investment in terms.
So, and that’s it. I bought this special cake for you and a cake that is a mug cake and it’s got one path. I think it’s only the enlightenment path. So that’s the path. So anyway, I thought that might be So anyway, join, you know, the party, you know, to and I would like to ask, you know, Lobsang Nyima a few words, you know.
Rang him, you know, before. Could you say a few words? Is it possible? And we’d like to know the members and the students here at TBI. Thank you very much.
I haven’t got a lot to say as Tenzin said he just called me just before the teaching to say that he wanted me to speak. I don’t have anything, prepared at all. But, I guess, first of all, you know, I was just thinking about what great benefit we have all, had in being able to, have contact, with such a great being as Rinpoche and And for those I guess newer students that are here that maybe didn’t have direct contact with Rinpoche, what an incredible gift we have in a centre such as this one. Little old Adelaide with a relatively small community of, Buddhists and to have a centre like this is really amazing and we are extremely fortunate. And I guess going along with the centre, we have Geshela who is an amazing teacher and shows great patience in us and particularly myself who, you know, is sometimes slow to pick things up and, shows great patience and perseverance in continuing to teach us.
And Tenzin obviously, Tenzin’s been an incredible support, to myself and, you know, to all of us here as well, in keeping this center, you know, and you know, he really brings the life into TBI and I’m sure we’ll continue to do so. And for myself, an incredible thanks to, Ilya Juravic, where I’ve spent countless hours, learning the Dharma with Ilya and, you know, I can’t think to how to ever repay, the generosity that, Ilya has shown, not just myself, but all of us in being here, and translating and all those who have gained benefit through his seminars and so on. I probably haven’t got a great more deal to say other than, you know, I’ll miss everyone here. I’ll miss the centre. You know, I guess I’ve spent a lot of time at the centre over the last few years and you know, it’s definitely something I’m going to miss and, all those people, here I’ll miss.
And thanks to, you know, all those, people that support me. I guess I want to avoid naming particular people, but you know who you are and those individuals that have supported me in many, many ways. Thank you so much. It’s really heartwarming that you know, that people will kindly and freely offer, support. So, thank you.
Okay. Sunday, we have a Guru Puja. So Tārā Puja is especially dedicated for Rinpoche’s swift return and also the members and the benefactors and, you know, to well-being and, of course, remove obstacles, etcetera, if you have written an email and it’s pretty clear there. And if you’re coming along to share lunch with our Sangha and Puja starts 10:30 and finishes around twelve or just after twelve and then after that we share lunch. And of course, one of the monk, you know, Rabje, Venerable Rabje, he’s leaving on Monday, so we can farewell for that as well.
Just to let everybody know if you there’s been an email out today to say that there’ll be no teaching next Tuesday or Wednesday. Ilya has to go interstate, so there won’t be a teaching next Wednesday or Tuesday. Now put me just bring the tea. Okay. Thank you.
Did you want one? Alright. Page nine. And we offer okay.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
- The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
- puja chö pa (Tib)
- Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What is the subtle consciousness that can know the minds of others, and how does it relate to our ordinary consciousness?
When the five sensory consciousnesses are occluded or withdrawn inwards, we are overwhelmed by their experience, so it is a little as if no consciousness were present. At this point one can speak of a subtle consciousness that can focus on an object of observation. This subtle consciousness is associated with a wind or energy. Very little is said about this in the Perfection Vehicle; it is developed in tantra. The wind accompanies the consciousness and seems to move when the consciousness is impelled by a motivation. As a result, we can gain some sense of how others think. By contrast, our present consciousnesses are coarse sense consciousnesses, which touch things like a table.