1 h 26 min · 3,308 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching covers meditation posture and focusing the mind, with mindfulness of the breath as a remedy for distraction. It then explains subtle impermanence as momentariness, contrasts it with coarse impermanence, and links it to understanding emptiness. A question and answer session on time, imputation and conceptual minds follows.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 27m
UUID: 2b4b5b27-2696-4353-b98c-eeeb76ed512a
Words: 3,304
So as Śāntideva says in a quote in the Bodhicharyavatara, whatever mental activities are, we must forsake distraction. And clearly, whatever studies we engage in, whether these are the studies of the Lamrim or for that matter studying cooking, we must make sure that our mind is not distracted. And therefore, irrespective of what we studied, it is important to have a stable mind, a mind which is not distracted. In the selfsame way, as for instance, when we are in this temple at present, our bodies physically are stably, if you wish, in this temple. Likewise, our minds should be stable as well, and this stable mind is what we call meditation.
In the same same way as when we are engaged in a job or doing some work, if our mind is stable and focused on the job, we finish a job quickly. Likewise, when we meditate, it is the same thing. Then it’s fairly self evident, it’s easy to understand, but both in mundane matters and in dharma, the more distracted our mind is, the more scattered we are, the longer it will take to accomplish anything and to realize our goals. When the mind is not distracted to the outside and focused on an object, this is known as gom in Tibetan meditation. Then as I mentioned last time, when one meditates, posture is very important.
One should endeavor to adopt the seven point posture of Vairochana, and if one can, one should sit in Vajrasanā. In other words, one basically sits with one’s legs crossed, one’s palms, right palm resting in the left palm at the level of the navel navel. The back and the neck should be straight. The head should be slightly inclined. Teeth and lips should be loose with the tip of the tongue touching the palate since when one meditates, this gives one control over the flow of saliva.
Then in addition, one’s head should be slightly inclined downwards, and one’s eyes partly open. If as beginners, we close our eyes, then our minds will sink. Our shoulders also must be level. Then if one’s mind is distracted, scattered to the outside and not focused on a virtuous object, to bring it in focus, one should initially practice mindfulness of the breath. Here, one counts entire cycles of breathing involving inhalation and exhalation as one cycle, and one counts them in groups of seven.
Either seven, fourteen, or 21 until the mind is focused. So adopt the posture, please. Otherwise, it’s inappropriate. Can you? Can you make this one?
Can you adopt this posture? If you can sit cross legged, it’s okay. Then at present, let us meditate during nine or ten minutes on whichever virtuous topic you choose to focus on upon. It can be impermanence, renunciation, or bodhichitta. Mhmm.
Okay. So meditation means that the mind is focused on an object to the exclusion of any anything else, and here obviously the sensory consciousnesses follow the mental consciousness. So the risk is when the mental consciousness is focused in this way and the sensory consciousnesses dwindle that we fall asleep. Then one good way to proceed is to take the resolve at the beginning of the day. Today, I shall help.
I shall be of benefit to others. Then if one is unable to do this, at the very least, one should take the resolve not to harm others by means of one’s body, speech, or mind to practice non violence. Otherwise, if one harms others by means of one’s body, speech, mind, then because of dependent origination, that harm will return to us. This is something those who go outside to work are probably aware of the impact of physical, verbal, and even mental attitudes and behavior. But for that matter, even those who stay at home and don’t go to work at all also are mindful of this.
And for myself, it’s a very pleasant state of affairs. And for myself, it’s a very pleasant state of affairs. Obviously, from time to time, there are difficulties, but the key then is to practice forbearance. Forbearance must be trained in before to apply or to reflect on the qualities of forbearance when difficulties arise that is very difficult to do. Then obviously, since our body follows after our mind, and actually our body and our mind are mutually related.
When the mind is at peace, then there are no physical or health problems. When the mind is at ease and relaxed, this manifest in terms of one’s physical and verbal behavior and attitude. And you can see that on the street. You have some people who are easygoing and when they see you, they wave and they say hi, you know, and it is because their minds are at peace. And you have others who are uptight and who are like that focused on one point, then their minds are not at peace.
Right? Most of the young ones seem to be like that these days. The old ones on the other hand, they don’t seem to have a lot of conceptions like that, they just wave at you and say hi. It depends on one’s conceptions and one’s fancies, right? Then to lead therefore a meaningful human life, the most important is to avoid violence, specifically physical and verbal violence towards others.
Then if we avoid violence, our own minds will be happy and at peace. Now within Lamrim, the core is obviously the four noble truths, and the 16 aspects of the four noble truths, and as you remember, the four aspects of the first noble truth are the aspects of impermanence, suffering, selflessness, and emptiness. Within these impermanence, which is listed first, probably in my opinion refers to coarse impermanence. It’s just my own opinion. And the reason for this is that within these four characteristics, have as was said in permanent suffering and emptiness, and the emptiness here is the coarse emptiness of persons, persons being empty of being permanent one and and independent.
And it will be difficult to posit coarse impermanence at that point, so it has to be posited at the beginning. So here what is important is for us to understand subtle impermanence, and I referred to the course surface of persons, persons being empty of being permanent one and independent in contrast with the subtle empty emptiness of persons, persons being empty of being substantially existent autonomous entities. It is actually very difficult to clearly differentiate these two. They are closely related. Actually, does not differentiate them, but what matters for us is to understand subtle impermanence, because through subtle impermanence we can gain an understanding of the coarse surface of persons.
Through reflecting on the meaning of subtle impermanence, I believe we are able to eventually differentiate the coarse and the subtle surfaces of persons, simply because when we reflect on subtle impermanence, we automatically reflect on the dependency of phenomena with respect to each other, their mutual dependency, and this ushers an understanding of the difference between the coarse and the subtle selflessness of persons. So now when we wish to reflect on impermanence, we quite naturally reflect on the impermanence of the exterior world within the two, the exterior world out there and ourselves in here, simply because it is fairly evident to us. However, we seem to resist reflecting upon our own impermanence, even though we ourselves become old, and it should be evident to us. And this resistance arises from grasping at permanence. Have all of us have a great grasping at permanence.
When I ask someone here, how old are you? Eventually, you know, they don’t answer right. They sort of back off. That is grasping at permanence. Then we have numerous minds which are simultaneously present within ourselves.
We have minds which are minds of grasping at permanence, which coexist with an awareness of our course in permanence. We should see which matches reality. Then a very helpful way to look at it is to reflect on our own impermanence, and in as much as we are not autonomous, we are predicated on the five aggregates and the form aggregate, and the form aggregate changes, we change. Then when we endeavor to reflect on subtle becoming, subtle impermanence, subtle becoming depends on coarse impermanence or coarse becoming. Without coarse impermanence excuse me.
Coarse impermanence depends on subtle impermanence. Without subtle impermanence, there can be no coarse impermanence. Now as was said, the definition of subtle impermanence is momentariness, or if you prefer, momentary disintegration. What exactly is the meaning of momentary disintegration? Its meaning is that the instant of generation is also an instant of destruction.
So here, when we say that an instant of generation is in the nature of a destruction, what we mean is that no effort is required for disintegration to occur. It is a spontaneous, a natural process in opposition, for instance, to let us say, impermanence where a human being transforms his state through effort. Do you understand? Do you know? Okay.
So listen carefully. This example should make it clear. Food is important. Then imagine that you have a meal in front of yourself and you have to eat it, but someone tells you, you have to finish the meal in three minutes. Then, obviously, you will say it is not possible who can eat a full meal in three minutes.
It takes five or ten minutes or however, simply because the meal is composed of many parts. It takes time in other words. Likewise, for a meal, which depends on numerous parts, time is required as you understand. It is necessary to have time. So for a meal, therefore, is required.
It depends on time. Time is necessary. So therefore, as was mentioned, the definition of impermanence, subtle impermanence is momentariness or momentary disintegration. Now here regarding the mode of disintegration, there are two modes of disintegration. The first is a spontaneous or a natural mode of disintegration without any effort.
This is the mode of disintegration of subtle impermanence. The second is a mode of disintegration which calls for effort. This is the mode of disintegration involved in coarse impermanence. So therefore, we have, for instance, the becoming or the transformation of exterior phenomena due to effort, due to the effort of a human being, for instance. This is coarse impermanence.
Likewise, we also have the becoming or the transformation of one’s mind due to effort. This is also course impermanence. So regarding interior course becoming or interior course transformation, there were two types of interior course becoming, virtuous and non virtuous interior course becoming. If, for instance, our mind under the influence of anger or jealousy transforms for the worst becomes worse, then this is a non virtuous course becoming. If on the other hand, through effort, our mind becomes better, it orients in the itself in the direction of virtue, and this is virtuous course becoming.
Then, therefore, when we refer to impermanence as momentariness, we are referring to the becoming of composite phenomena. And there are numerous modes of disintegration of composite phenomena, but this becoming, this impermanence is important. Now under the influence of grasping at our own permanence, which is a mind which thinks that we are going to be here for a very very long time, then we behave in an extremely inappropriate way, do not practice and the way to counter this is through meditation on impermanence. Let us therefore at present meditate on our own impermanence. Page five.
Mandalofring. Plus one, that is three. You know, is Tibetan image in so so. Okay. So, the definition of subtle impermanence is momentariness.
In other words, momentary disintegration. And here, if you want to explain the mode of disintegration which is being referred to, it is impossible to do this without grounding this in time. You must explain time. So examine for yourselves whether it is true that it is impossible to explain or to ground subtle impermanence without relying on time and by time he refer the time, time of the watch, time of hours, minutes and so forth. Is that correct?
Okay. So I’d like to ask you how do you formulate or explain subtle impermanence dependence on time? And generally speaking, the measures of time, years, months, days, hours are human creations, but the momentariness which characterizes subtle impermanence, this is not. It depends on time, doesn’t it? So please think carefully about this, because once you have been able to understand momentary disintegration, then you are very close to an understanding of emptiness.
And by emptiness, mean here, obviously, the cause emptiness of persons, persons being empty, of being permanent one and independent. How do you explain subtle impermanence independence or in relation with time? Is is the One example that comes to moment of parting from somebody. One moment they’re there, and then the next minute you’ve said goodbye. We can measure the time independent on notion of time.
From the time that you say something to the time that I hear it, your words are not there but the change is so subtle that it’s not noticeable. About a sneeze. Yes. I ask Krishna if he’s missed. Okay.
I said yes. You say, okay. I explained last time that years of positive independence in months, months on weeks, weeks on days, these on hours, these on minutes, and these on seconds, but no one seems to bring that up. You just wander off in your own thing, don’t you? The pillar of very easy.
Easy way to do it. Right? Maybe we didn’t mention that because we were waiting we thought that I thought that Geshela wanted some original ideas not to just say what he had told us last week. You see, if you had answered my question, I would have been at ease. But you didn’t answer my question and I’m wondering why?
So think about this. It is through thinking about this that one will understand. You take dharma practice for instance, we can speak of dharma practice in the context of time. Without time it is impossible to speak of dharma practice. For instance Buddha Śākyamūni required three kalpas to attain full enlightenment.
That is time, period of time. If you think about this, it will become easier. One has to rely on time. Yeah, honey, have your questions? Why rely on time?
So when I say rely on time, I mean in relation with time. It is in relation with time that I can give explanations to you. For instance, if we meditate, you know, We say I meditate then. I meditate let’s say for two, three, five, ten minutes, my mind focused on an object, but if I don’t give a time, what do we mean by meditate? It is independence on time that our explanations become straightforward.
Okay. Next questions. Would you say then that you say then that time never stops? So to be able to explain anything regardless of what regardless of what it is, means time. Yes.
Therefore, one shouldn’t waste time. Nothing is more important in this world than time, you can’t get it back. Very important time in the world. You know? Okay, thank you.
Okay. Geshela, are destruction and generation linked and manifest in coarse impermanence in the way that they are in subtle impermanence? I heard tonight about coarse impermanence being the becoming of phenomena, I’m just wondering about the destruction aspect as well as the generation. Yes. Naturally, there is generation and disintegration in the context of cause impermanence because cause impermanence depends on subtle impermanence.
Geshela taught about the two different modes of disintegration. One being spontaneous or natural without effort being subtle impermanence and the second one cause for effort being coarse impermanent impermanence. I don’t really understand the effort component of coarse impermanent. If we take the example say of some of a death, of our own death, then where is that effort component in that example of course impermanence? It the I gave as an example of course impermanence, a mode of disintegration which occurs with effort.
It is not the case that every instance of course impermanence is accompanied by effort. It’s not a definition in other words. It covers only part of the topic, not the totality. Geshela your comment about not getting time back. So for us to be permanent time would have to stop.
It would be great if you could find the means but there isn’t, right? If you could get back time which was wasted, things would really be strange. Impossible, you know. Geshela, I’m trying to get a sense or understanding of what time actually is. Is a Buddha beyond time?
What do you mean by beyond time? Not subject to time as we understand. Buddha is impermanent. He changes naturally instant by instant. We talk about past, present and future as labels not existing like Geshe de mentioned years, months, weeks as human construction.
So what is time? Well, time is the same thing, Time is a conceptual imputation, isn’t it? Mhmm. Can a non conceptual mind impute? Yes.
Yes. Yes. But what would you give us an example? Well, the five sense organs, the five sense consciousnesses. Washing.
Well, my understanding is that they are direct valid cognizers. In which school? We’ll go straight to the top, Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika! What is your question? What is my question?
I guess I can’t understand the possibility that a non conceptual mind can actually impute because and I posit the five sense organs as examples of non conceptual minds. I can’t understand how they compute because impute because imputation requires concept conception or conceptual mind. What do you mean by impute here? They don’t have an object or what? Yeah.
They do have an object. So Okay, that they can’t alright, maybe I’m just thinking I’m confusing imputation with mental imputation. I’m assuming that they can’t mentally impute, but I’m assuming that impute requires some mental cognition. Probably, imputation is an activity of the mental consciousness. It’s difficult to see sensory consciousness is doing it.
What is the mode of imputation for a yogic direct perceiver? It is similar to the mode of imputation by a visual consciousness. Yeah, exactly. A 100%, you know. What is the mode of imputation by visual consciousness?
In view directly. No, there is no imputation by the visual consciousness. It is an imputation by the mind. I’m a little confused now then. So we have mental direct perception, yogic direct perception, sense direct perception, and self knowers are the four subtypes of direct valid cognizers, if I remember correctly.
So all of those are non conceptual yet as an understanding, yogic direct perceivers have the capacity to impute without conceptuality. If that is correct, how does that imputation take place without conceptuality? No. These four direct perceivers cannot impute. To impute, you would need to have a meaning generality.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Okay. Just getting back to the discussion around time, it would seem that human beings are extremely adept at wasting time and I would assume that Buddhas or being in enlightened state, no time is wasted. So that would assume that time wasting is in itself an affliction. Would that be right? When under the power of grasping at permanence, one thinks that one’s own end is far away, then one behaves in a blameworthy way.
So in the context of the explanation of impermanence, it’s very interesting to study the view of the Vaibhāṣikas and their understanding of impermanence and to ask whether some of those schools are Buddhist or not, but we haven’t had time for that.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.