1 h 30 min · 4,215 words · 29 July 2015
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a Lam Rim teaching on the three scopes of the path, with the four noble truths as the main topic of the middling scope and the afflictions and karma as the key focus. It explains karma as intention and intended karma, and discusses the order in which emptiness is realized. The talk closes with a question and answer session on karma and afflictions.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 31m
UUID: 5c6efd75-101b-4c0d-be88-85dd00a8326a
Date: 2015-07-29
Words: 4,211
It’s. So the topic of the Lamrim is the Mahāyāna or the great vehicle. Therefore, when one studies the Lamrim, these studies must be upheld by bodhichitta. However, when one studies the path of the being of the small scope, one’s motivation is to attain a higher rebirth. When one studies the path of the being of the middling scope, one’s motivation is to attain liberation.
This is not contradictory with the Lamrim being upheld by a motivation of bodhichitta since we do not want to mix the motivations with the paths. Otherwise, it creates confusion. So in the same way, the generation of bodhichitta is specific to the path of the being of the great scope, whether one generates it through the sevenfold cause and effect procedure or through the interchange of self and others. Whereas an introduction to the view of emptiness occurs within the context of the path of the being of the middling scope and the being of the small scope has its own specific topics. I brought this up because there have been questions during the teachings on whether a motivation of compassion was not required in the context of the study of Lamrim.
Obviously, this is the case. But the reason for which this is not brought up is because when we study the path of the being of the small scope, we should study only the path of the being of the small scope. And when we study the path of the being of the middling scope, we should study only the path of the being of the middling scope. Otherwise considerable confusion will arise. So the main topic of the path of the middling scope is saṃsāra and nirvana.
saṃsāra is the object of nirvana, of abandonment, excuse me, and nirvana is the object of attainment for which the mind of liberation strives. And as is well known, the four noble truths are the main topic of the path of the middling scope. Psychic existence itself can be understood in terms of the first two noble truths. The second noble truth, the noble truth of origin is the cause of psychic existence. And the first noble truth, the noble truth of suffering is its result.
The converse or the obverse of this is the attainment of the goal, which is liberation on nirvana. This is the Noble Truth of cessation. The third Noble Truth and the means to attain it is the fourth Noble Truth, the Noble Truth of the Path. Now listen carefully. The, main topic of observation for the being of the middling scope is none other than the four noble truths.
Then, as you remember, the, uncommon objects of observation of the path of the being of the small scope, are fourfold. These are death and impermanence, the suffering of the lower realms, refuge, and causality. And the first three preliminaries identifying a rebirth of leisure and endowment reflecting on the great meaningfulness of such a rebirth and reflecting on its rarity are probably common preliminaries to all three paths. So you do understand, don’t you? The uncommon object of observation of the path of the middling scope is the Four Noble Truths.
The uncommon object of observation of the path of the being of the small scope is as I explained, meditation on death and impermanence, on the suffering of the lower realms, on refuge and on causality to which we add these three common preliminaries which are identifying a rebirth of leisure and endowment, reflecting on its profound meaningfulness and reflecting on its rarity. So the uncommon object of observation, the path of the being of the middling scope is therefore the four noble truths. The first of which, the noble truth of suffering has been explained. This refers to the five contaminated aggregates. The second noble truth, the noble truth of the origin of suffering refers principally to the afflictions.
So as was said, the main topic of the path of the being of the middling scope is psychic existence and, the liberation thereof, nirvana. Psychic existence can be understood in terms of the two first truths. The Noble Truth of suffering and the Noble Truth of the origin of suffering. The Noble Truth of the origin of suffering is subdivided into two. Origins of suffering which are karma and origins of suffering which are afflictions.
So you do understand what the afflictions or the kleshas are. These are states of mind such as anger, desire, pride, competitiveness and envy which are present within our mind streams. And as was said, within the twin subdivision of the noble truth of the origin of suffering into karma and into klesha afflictions. Afflictions are our foremost enemy because if we do not abandon the afflictions, it will be impossible for us to put an end to psychic existence. So if we are one who has been able to abandon the afflictions, then even though we have accumulated a vast amount of non virtuous karma since beginningless time, since the cooperative condition, the afflictions has been eliminated, this karma can no longer mature.
So as Ārya Asaṇga and many other great beings have explained, once we have abandoned the cooperative condition which is the cause of psychic existence, in other words, afflictions, karma can no longer mature and we will have put an end to psychic existence. The example thereof would would be the Arhat. So the first thing to point out is that war, once one has abandoned the afflictions, one indeed has become an Arhat and is no longer subject to psychic existence. This refers to what happens within one’s mind. It does not refer to some type of physical change.
Our hair will still become gray. We will still develop a large and flappy belly. We will eventually get cancer. The transformation is internal. All of these problems are physical problems.
In other words, they are related to exterior material objects. This is not a part of the goal of dharma. I do not believe that meditation on emptiness or compassion or meditation in general will be of any particular benefit for these material problems. Then this is my own private opinion. You are welcome to your own.
When I studied at the monastery, I had to study quite intensively. And, at times, disease came. Whether the rituals performed were of benefit or not is an open question. These external physical, problems are best addressed by increasing one’s wealth or by other, physical methods. They are not part of the sphere of dharma.
Dharma focuses on internal mental problems and enables one to eliminate afflictions from one’s mind stream. I suspect this has little or no effect on the physical world. So regarding the motivation, if we listen to these teachings on the Lamrim on the graduated stages of the path with the wish to attain liberation from psychic existence, all of the roots of virtue accrued through listening to these teachings will become causes for liberation. How this occurs is something I would like us to reflect about. So if I just tell you, you have to generate a motivation striving for liberation and as a result thereof, your roots of virtue are going to become causes for liberation Without any further reflection from your side, this is quite odd.
So liberation is none other but that abandonment which is an abandonment of the afflictions. You understand what the afflictions are in keeping with Asaṇga’s definition. These are mental factors whose function is to trouble the mind. They are present within our mind stream and they include anger, envy, jealousy, resentment and so forth. Abandoning, these is what is meant by abandoning the afflictions.
But to abandon the afflictions, first and foremost, we must understand what the thoughts or the defects of the afflictions are. Do you actually see the defects of the afflictions? So once we understand the faults of afflictions which are led by anger and which are present within our mind stream, and I would suspect that certainly as far as anger is concerned, most of you understand the faults of anger both for yourself and for others. Then independence on this, one understands the faults of the defects of afflictions in general. At this point, one wonders how precisely can I rid myself of these afflictions?
And when one thinks of ridding oneself of these afflictions, probably the mind striving for liberation has been generated. Then if we can reflect in this way on the faults of the afflictions for one day, for one week, for one month, or for one year, this will be profoundly beneficial. Then if this should be unmanageable for us, if during this mere hour and a half or so during which we attend Lamrim teachings, we are able to reflect on the faults of anger and of the afflictions and generate the profound wish to be freed from them. Attending these Lamrim teachings will become a cause for our liberation. This is explicitly said by Je Tsongkhapa in his Lamrim Chenmo.
Then what could be more meaningful than this? If from within the depths of our mind, we understand the faults of anger, we understand the faults of jealousy, of envy, then we will search for a means to eliminate them before they arise. Once they have arisen, it is very difficult to control. So it is before they have arisen that we should strive strive to eliminate them. This is very meaningful.
It is therefore extremely important having understood from within the innermost depths of one mind one’s mind the faults of the afflictions to generate the resolve to eliminate them and having generated this resolve to eliminate them, to strive for liberation, to listen with this in mind to the teachings of the Lamrim, which is peerless as a means to eliminate the afflictions. And after listening to these teachings, to reflect on them and to meditate on them. So this is important. This motivation to dedicate or to focus the roots of virtue accrued from listening to the Lamrim teachings through having generated a mind striving for liberation, towards liberation is not too difficult. Secondly, the cause for attaining liberation is repeated investigation, analytical investigation of emptiness, which is a wisdom which leads to liberation.
There is none other than this. So what, is the criteria for having developed capacity as far as emptiness is concerned? There are numerous forms of capacity or potency regarding emptiness. There is specifically a capacity regarding emptiness of a being who has entered the path, and a capacity regarding emptiness of a being who has not entered the path. Here, entering the path refers to having generated uncontrived renunciation.
In other words, to have generated the path of the being of the small scope. There is a potency regarding emptiness in beings who have not entered, the path of the being of the small scope, and there is a potency regarding emptiness in beings who have. His Holiness the Dalai Lama has pointed out that within the sequence of establishment of the realizations of Lamrim. As emptiness is explained in the context of the path of the being of the great scope after the presentation of bodhichitta, we might be under the impression that an understanding of emptiness is specific to the great vehicle which is not at all the case. So we must analyze from our own side to see whether a realization of emptiness is possible only within beings who have entered the path or whether it is possible both within beings who have entered the path and beings who have not entered the path.
And if it is possible within beings who have not entered the path, is it possible, also for beings of the small scope or for that matter for beings who are not even beings of the small scope. The reason, this investigation must be engaged in is because emptiness is linked foundationally to interdependence. Then, the study of emptiness hinges on an understanding of coarse and of subtle impermanence. And it is not necessary for such an understanding for you to have relinquished, all future lives or for that matter for you to have relinquished the vanities of this life. In that matter, emptiness is an interesting topic.
Then, the reason I bring this up is because there are different presentations in these three principal aspects of the path and another treaties of Je Tsongkhapa regarding the sequence in which realization of emptiness must occur. The conclusion of the three principles of the past reads, after having realized these three aspects, oh son, retire in solitude. This implies that one realizes the three principles of the past in sequence and then retires in solitude. On the other hand, another treatise of Je Tsongkhapa, a verse treatise, Tödunma, states that after having generated definite ascertainment with this mind, banish all elaborations. Banish all elaborations in this context refers to the vanities of this life and therefore, this second verse seems to imply that first one gains direct realization of emptiness and then one retires in solitude and banishes all the vanities of this life.
When our teacher, Khensur Rinpoche heard this verse, he said this is very odd. Would you please repeat it? And, mentioned it after this regularly. And Khensur Rinpoche’s immediate reaction upon hearing with this verse was to ask whether it was apocryphal or spurious. Because if this verse is indeed by the hand of Je Tsongkhapa, then obviously once one has realized emptiness, one progresses very rapidly on the grounds and paths.
And one would do this without having relinquished the vanities of this life, which is problematical. Realize the foundation and then move onwards to the truth. In this context, the foundation refers to the two truths. In other words, the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering. And this is seen as a foundation of, one’s training in Abhisamayālamkāra.
Then, clearly, the realization of emptiness hinges on an understanding of both subtle and of coarse interdependence. Then clearly, for those trainees of SHARP faculties, it is possible before having realized the four noble truths to realize the two truths and on that basis to gain an understanding of the four noble truths. Then obviously there are two categories of trainees, those of subtle and of sharp Those Those, of course and those of sharp acumen. Those of coarse acumen or those who have little time would simply train their minds in sequence with the Lamrim. Now in the context of emptiness, when we speak of emptiness, we are referring to the refutation of its object of refutation, which is none other than the way things ordinarily appear to our sense consciousnesses.
In other words, phenomena appearing as existing out there of their own side. This is the object of refutation. I shall not talk a lot about this so as not to foster confusion. For a couple of you, I believe there is some benefit in these explanations. For the majority, it seems difficult for there to be benefit since the immediate reaction will be how is it possible that the way things appear to our sense consciousnesses should be the actual object of refutation.
Such an understanding does not dawn easily. One must study carefully, reflect, study again, reflect some more and proceed in this fashion. Now regarding the generation of the motivation, as I explained previously, our wish is to eliminate all of the afflictions symbolized or of which anger is symptomatic. And to do this, we must identify the antidote of these afflictions. Since these afflictions arise in dependence on causes and conditions and can be eliminated through eradicating their causes and conditions.
They cannot just be eliminated by wishing for them to disappear. Therefore, generating this mind which wishes to be freed from the afflictions in turn, we decide to engage in the three activities of hearing, thinking and meditating on the Lamrim. So, my apologies. I have spent a lot of time explaining the motivation, but let us meditate on it. Yeah.
Yeah. Stanza, the verse I quoted from Tödunma which states after generating the ascertainment arisen through thinking of emptiness forsake the troubles or the elaborations of this life clearly intimates that first one gains some type of realization of emptiness before engaging in retreat. And this is exactly in keeping with the verse in Abhisamayālamkāra which says, first, the foundation, which he refers to the two truths, and then the four noble truths. So reflect from your own side on the meaning of emptiness in the light of these two passages. So as you remember, there are four uncommon topics of observation within the path of the being of the small scope.
And within the path of the being of the middling scope, the main topic of observation is the four noble truths. Within the Four Noble Truths, the first Noble Truth, Noble Truth of Suffering has been presented. And as to the second Noble Truth, Noble Truth of the Origin of Suffering. The first outline presenting the origin of suffering has been covered, identifying the origin of suffering. The second outline will be covered at present how karma is accumulated.
Then the main topic within the path of the being of the middling scope is precisely how one transmigrates within psychic existence. So if you want to know how you transmigrate in psychic existence, you have to follow the sequence of the outlines. So regarding the identification and the accumulation of karma, karma can be subdivided into two subdivisions. Karma which is intention and karma which is intended. Karma which is intention refers for instance to those states of mind which precede the generation of an affliction such as for instance anger, envy and so forth and which give rise to unsuitable bodily and verbal behavior.
Whereas a comma which is intended or intended karma refers to those, deeds of body or of mind which are performed under the influence of afflictions such as anger and so forth. In general, all karma is intention. Then there are numerous other subdivisions of karma such as the subdivision of karma into virtuous and non virtuous karma and so forth. But one point I would like to underline is that in the case of an Ārya being, Ārya beings can accumulate both virtuous and non virtuous karma. However, should they accumulate non virtuous karma, this non virtuous karma cannot be impelling non virtuous karma which causes an unfortunate or even rebirth in psychic existence.
So I shall not enter into greater details in this. We will all fall asleep. But we shall stop here for today. And I will take your questions at present. Please, one question per person.
Make them short and clear. And after everyone has asked their question, if there is time, you can ask a second question. Please hold the microphone to you, Chin. Geshe, in the case of karma which is intention, what is the state of mind which precedes an affliction? So karma, which is intention, refers to that karma which is manifest before one engages in non virtuous deeds of body and mind.
And it therefore refers to intentions such as anger, envy, jealousy, and so forth. Could Geshe-la please tell us again what intended karma is? Not intention, but intended karma. So intended karma or karma which is intended refers to that which occurs after the afflictions have arisen within the mind at the point when one decides to engage, for instance, in dependence on anger on a harmful action such as killing and so forth with respect to another being. Now according to the Vaibhāṣikas, such intended karma is actually a form.
It is material. This viewpoint is not accepted by any of the other schools and is countered by, Vasubandhu. Generally speaking, to realize emptiness, you need calm abiding. Calm abiding. To attain calm abiding or actually calm abiding counters afflictions of the desire realm, if you have not turned away from the vanities of this life, it is impossible to realize calm abiding.
That doesn’t matter. Do you have other questions? How do ārya beings accumulate nonvirtuous karma? So the way in which an Ārya being could accumulate non virtuous karma is as follows. Generally speaking, Ārya beings cannot accumulate impelling non virtuous karma.
In other words, karma which leads to a rebirth within one of the lower realms of psychic existence, which is non virtuous here. But they can accumulate non virtuous karma and the example given is that of, king Ajatashatru, who actually projected to kill his own father. He was an Ārya being. He projected to kill his own father, but he actually did not perform the deed. So, this was a nonvirtuous, karma, which was accumulated but not impelling.
And Nada? Mhmm. I just didn’t understand something that Geshela said at all. When he said, what is the criteria for having developed capacity as far as emptiness are concerned? And he said there are numerous capacities regarding emptiness.
I don’t really does capacity does that mean the ability to do it? The the capability of the different beings have different capabilities? I don’t really understand capacity in that context. My apologies. It’s a translation mistake.
It’s and not In other words, it is certitude regarding emptiness by valid cognition. And it’s not which means potency. My ears are failing with age. Is intending karma volition? If so, do we thus create our own afflictions through our own volition?
By volition, you mean what? The aggregate of volition or will? Volition. Intended. Intended.
Karma which is intended. Karma which is intention. I should firstly, there’s no word for will in Tibetan. So I’ve translated as close as I can by Dunpa. Then which is to aspire to to wish for.
The word for will does not exist. Then it is quite close, but it is not the same thing. What’s what I indicate that will. Then karma which is intention is intention. Aspiration on the other hand is wishing for the attainment of something or willing for the attainment of something, such as liberation or for enlightenment.
Is the Tibetan word for volition? There isn’t one. It’s an English mistranslation. I mean, it’s often that you get The aggregate of volition is a mistranslation for the aggregate of compositional factors. Volition and willed terms really don’t exist.
We have aspiration. We have wish. We have belief, but we don’t have will as it is understood in English. So Geshe-la was asking if it’s the future of the verb. It is, but it’s not the noun here.
Another another question. Geshela, when we were talking about, like, turning away from I haven’t really thought this question out. This is just something that I thought of. When we were talking about turning away from the vanities of this life, we talked about that there was a level of need that we still need to have some material possessions and things to survive. When it comes to afflictions, is there is there a need?
Definitely, from time to time, afflictions are beneficial. This is specifically stated in Buddhist texts. The example given for instance is, when you are studying and you say, I really must study. It is inappropriate for me not to study. Then at that point, both a certain pride and a certain self cherishing arise.
These are beneficial. And this is probably it. Chris, have you got a question? Just following on from that question, would they therefore be called afflictions? They are still afflictions.
They are afflictions. But if the if if the affliction is, by definition, something that is troubling the mind, then a sense of wanting to accomplish a goal could be quite a virtuous you know, like a I can’t think of what a word would be for a positive aspect of pride, but I can’t see how that would be. Self confidence. Yes. Yes.
So how is self confidence an affliction unless one has realized selflessness, I suppose. So where you do have to make a distinction is that in cases like these, these afflictions are said to be of benefit but they benefit this life, right? This life. Right? They still are afflictions.
You can, still have them operate as the cause for obtaining a higher rebirth in future lives. Right? There’s a lot of thought about afflictions. We shall stop you. I know someone who do set out have a good motivation raising money for charity and set out to be virtuous deeds.
But then in the process, when they see somebody doing something that they don’t like, they have a mental affliction, and this is nonvirtuous, Is that cancel out their original, you know, what they set out to be? Now this happens. It happens that when you have a good foundation of motivation and the rest in the process of performing virtuous deeds, anger can arise. This occurs for Bodhisattvas all the way up to the level of warmth of the path of preparation. But this does not affect the fundamental motivation.
Gonna come
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What is intended karma, as distinct from intention, and how do the Vaibhāṣikas view it?
Intended karma, or karma which is intended, refers to what occurs after afflictions have arisen in the mind, at the point when one decides to engage in a harmful action. An example is deciding, in dependence on anger, to kill another being. According to the Vaibhāṣikas, such intended karma is actually a form, meaning it is material. None of the other schools accept this viewpoint, and it is countered by Vasubandhu.