Lam Rim – 2018-08-08 – Lamrim

1 h 29 min · 3,826 words · 8 August 2018

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2018-08-08 - Lamrim
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching argues that realizations such as definite emergence, bodhicitta and emptiness require fully characterized meditation, meaning calm abiding, supported by contentment, ethics and reflection on death and impermanence. It contrasts limited physical happiness with unlimited mental happiness and explains that a person is an imputation on the basis of the aggregates, which themselves change moment by moment.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 30m

UUID: 16c66844-7596-4db2-a513-3cac1e978940

Date: 2018-08-08

Words: 3,822

So it is good to think as follows. In our own cases, we can probably, understand and explain what bodhicitta is. We can understand and explain what great compassion is. We can understand and explain what impermanence is. Probably, we can also understand and explain what emptiness is.

Yet, our minds remain untransformed. This doesn’t affect our mind. Why? What is missing? What’s the problem?

Then if we take definite emergence, we can give examples, instances of definite emergence. We understand definite emergence very well, yet we do not have definite emergence. We have had no experience of definite emergence. We are unable to generate a realization of definite emergence. So how do we complete this?

What is missing? This is how we should think. Karma, why? Why? Sorry.

I would say laziness. Okay. Not too much. Just laziness. A lack of meditation, which is connected to laziness.

Nearly 99%. 99%. Exactly. Meditation. Because we don’t have a mind arisen from meditation on those.

Oh, that’s okay. Alright. That’s okay. That’s enough. Thank you.

That’s enough. So you hit the nail on the head. It’s meditation indeed. So without meditation, there is no experience. Therefore, we must meditate.

So, indeed, you have said meditation. This is what Geshe la himself says. This is what his Dalai Lama asserts. This is also what Kyabje Trijang Rinpoche has said. It is because we do not meditate that we do not gain realizations or experiences.

To gain realizations or experiences, we need to meditate and we need actually fully characterized meditation to gain a realization of the five paths and the ten grounds. Fully characterized meditation is calm abiding. So we have received many teachings on the five paths and the ten grounds, but sometimes it seems as if some of the students don’t believe that the five paths and the ten grounds exist simply because they themselves are never able to attain them. They are never able to attain them because they lack calm abiding. They lack lack.

Then, within the, five paths, within the five paths, the path of preparation from the path of preparation onwards, it is indispensable to have calm abiding since the path of preparation arises in dependence on a concentration which is an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight. Then why is it that seven or eight hundred years ago, there were in Tibet great siddhas such as Milarepa and so forth who gained all of the realizations which we are talking about. And now, we basically don’t see such great siddhas and yogis anymore. If they they exist, we don’t encounter them. Simply because back then, there was very little in terms of material development, very little focus on exterior objects.

And as a result, people were able to focus single pointedly on whatever practice they were engaged in and gain realizations. Since then, our society has experienced tremendous material development. And as a result, we are overly scattered, in material objects and unable to do this. At least this is what Geshe la thinks about it. Do you understand?

And the same is true for monks and nuns who are part of society, but nowadays are overly attached to material objects. This is unavoidable. Then to gain calm abiding, we must initially generate a renunciation or a definite emergence from cyclic existence. This means to turn away from the happiness of society at large, a happiness which the world proposes us. Very few, if any, people have this nowadays.

So to do this, we must see the faults of society, the problems of the values which are being proposed to us. You know? In Tibet, how do you say? Two words, you know. So the meaning of these two syllables, which is translated often in English as karma biting is as follows.

In Tibetan means peace. It is a pacification of the outwards movement of the mind, the outwards distraction of the mind. Then the second syllable means to dwell or to abide, to dwell single pointedly on the object of observation. Then ask yourselves whether we are able from the moment we wake up in the morning to pacify this outward distraction of the mind. Our mind follows our sensory consciousnesses or the mental consciousnesses which we experience are induced by sensory consciousnesses.

Can we pacify this or not? Then in the Lam Rim, it is taught that to give rise to calm abiding, we need the collection of causes or conditions for calm abiding. Generally speaking, there are numerous such causes and conditions. But if one summarizes them, one can summarize them into three. The first is contentment.

The second is ethics. The third is meditation on death and impermanence. If we have these three, we can give rise to calm abiding. So we need to complete the collections of causes for calm abiding, these three causes.

So some of you have a very strange understanding of contentment. You seem to believe that it is inappropriate to generate contentment because if one were to generate contentment, then one would not be able to fulfill the goals of one’s children. And for instance, if one’s children were experiencing hardship, it would be inappropriate to have contentment. Then this doesn’t begin to connect with the meaning of contentment. Then it is self evident that if you have children, you are the protectors of your children.

Who else but yourselves will protect them? And if your children need help, you must help them, but you must help them in a dispassionate way, in a contented way. And to think that when you have contentment, this is incompatible with fulfilling your family obligations, that is not correct. So discontentment refers to, for instance, the following situation. It is perfectly adequate to cover one’s needs in Australia to earn a $100 a day, But a $100 a day is not enough for us.

Then we think, I really would like to earn $500 a day. And when we earn $500 a day, we think, what about a thousand dollars a day? Then this is discontentment. This is insatisfaction. Then when this is for one’s own sake alone, discontentment, dissatisfaction have appeared.

It’s obviously different if you are doing this for the benefit of a community at large and so forth. Have you understood? If you can generate contentment, your problems, the hardship you experience will definitely dwindle. This is a certainty. But it’s clear.

So the reason for which discontentment is or lack of contentment is so widespread is because in society at large, we are taught to seek physical contentment through the satisfaction of our sensory consciousnesses, and our sensory consciousnesses are satisfied by exterior physical objects. The reason this can never satisfy us fully is because such exterior physical objects are finite. They are limited. There is a term. In the same way as, for instance, when you eat, you know very well that if you eat without any sense of measure, you will eventually feel ill.

You have eaten beyond the limit of what you should. Then it is self evident. For instance, if we take eyes, the visual consciousness, what satisfies our eyes are shapes and colors. Shapes and colors are finite. They are limited.

Then for the ear consciousness, the sense hearing, it’s the same thing. The sounds are finite. They are limited. The same is true for all our five consciousnesses. Then we have an inadequation between on the one hand what we want mentally, which is measureless infinite happiness, and what can be offered by the exterior world, which is finite limited happiness.

This inadequation is a source of our misery. So on the one hand, the physical happiness which we seek is finite and limited simply because exterior physical objects are finite and limited. Mental happiness, on the other hand, is measureless. It is potentially infinite and unlimited. If it were finite or limited, then there would be problems because there would be no such thing as the attainment of the state of an or full enlightenment.

But mental happiness is infinite or unlimited. We can get as much as we want. The more we practice, the more we meditate, the greater the happiness. Isn’t it true that the daily happiness which we strive after is the happiness due to exterior physical objects and that mental happiness has no place in our lives? If we want interior happiness, we need to meditate.

We need fully characterized meditation. In other words, we need calm abiding. Once we have attained calm abiding, there is no hardship, no problem of any type. And this is why in these three principles of the path, which so many of us recite, it is said in conclusion, therefore, oh, child, having understood the three principles of the past, retire and rely on solitude. The three principles of the path are definite emergence, bodhicitta, and the view of emptiness.

And once one has understood them, one should meditate. Then some of you may recite the three principles of the path. Others will understand the words. I will retranslate them again. Therefore, having understood the key points of the three principles of the path rely on solitude.

Do you understand? So so many of you complain that you understand definite emergence, you understand bodhicitta, you understand something of emptiness, and nonetheless, you have no experience and gain no realizations. And this is due to lack of meditation. And that is why Jetsongkapa says, therefore, having understood the key points of these three principles of the path, rely on solitude. Rely on solitude means to meditate.

So we must meditate. We must do retreats. And to be able to generate calm abiding, a fully characterized state of meditation, we must understand what the nine mental abidings are. What are the characteristics of the first mental abiding, the second, the third, the fourth, and so forth. And this is why Kensur Rinpoche over and again gave his advice to his students, meditate, meditate.

And His Holiness the Dalai Lama does the same thing. Mhmm. Limited limited limited limitless Then as was explained, physical happiness is limited, whereas mental happiness is limitless. Therefore, it makes sense for us to seek for mental happiness. Now if we observe our own minds, we find that it is the afflictions exemplified by anger, which are the source of our greatest mental suffering.

And therefore, we must find a way to these afflictions so that our mind is at peace. Our mind, if you wish, is like a sheaf of corn with numerous layers which surround the central cob. Then to reach the central cob, we must eliminate these exterior sheaths. We must, in other words, cleanse or purify the mind. How do we cleanse or purify the mind?

We do so by focusing on the main problem, which is the ignorance grasping at a self. To do this, we need a union of calm abiding and insight.

So it is taught that in Buddhism, there are three refuges. Buddha is the propounder or the teacher of refuge. Dharma is the actual refuge, and sangha are the helpers in one’s practice, those who accompany one. Now why exactly is it taught that dharma is the actual refuge? Simply because it is our own mental peace and happiness which we seek, and this can only be accomplished by interior means, by means of the practice of dharma.

Then since to be able to get rid of the afflictions exemplified by anger or by desire, we need a union of calm abiding and insight. We must understand what calm abiding is. To gain calm abiding, we cannot jump helter skelter the various nine levels. We must progress from level to level. Therefore, we must initially understand what the first mental abiding is, the first level of calm abiding.

And the first level of calm abiding occurs when one is able to put the mind for one second even continually on its object. So now when we say that the mind must be focused uninterruptedly on its object, on which object? One can choose a representation of the Buddha or a flower, but butter lamps are very practical in a sense because there’s not a lot of color or movement. So one just focuses on the mental image of a butter lamp. So here, the object of observation must be one which elicits neither desire nor anger within your mind.

Otherwise, if the object of observation elicits desire, then your mind is troubled at that point and there is no meditation. Then if you’re allowed to choose the object of meditation of your choice, they will be lustful lustful ones, and your mind will just go off. Careful. You know? Do you understand?

Then, therefore, please be careful. Do not choose as objects of observations, objects which generate either desire or anger. A butter lamp is perfect in that respect. For that matter, a statue of the Buddha too neither normally elicit desire nor anger. Then when we say to focus, for instance, on a butter lamp, this does not mean that one should stare at the butter lamp with one’s with one’s eyes.

Calm abiding is not generated with the visual consciousness. If it were, that would be very odd since we well know that we can focus on something visually while our mental consciousness travels all over the place. Instead, it is a mental consciousness which must be focused on its object. If it’s just a case of staring at the object of observation, Geshe could do that right now by staring at his clock. And you fall asleep.

Right? Therefore, one does not focus with the visual consciousness, but with the mind. So here, it is better not to close your eyes when you meditate since drowsiness appears instead. One should keep one’s eyes half open, and then one should mentally construct the object of visualization. For instance, a butter lamp, trying to see it as clearly as one can in front of oneself, first for one second, then for two seconds, then for three seconds.

Then if we can do this in the morning after waking up when the brain is fresh, that is ideal. It will not happen at once, but over time with practice, it will. So let us at present meditate during a couple seconds, and then do generate the motivation and do the recitations. Mhmm. Please open the prayer book, page one.

We recite one day, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, Mandal offering, verse one and three.

So when we have generated a sense of disinterest in the situation of cyclic existence, of disinterest in the values of our society, then at this point, this is mere definite emergence. Then this mere definite emergence, this ordinary definite emergence must be extended. At present, it lasts for only a brief instant of time. To extend it, we need fully characterized meditation. In other words, we need calm abiding.

So when we get some type of sense of the faults of cyclic existence, of the faults of the society we live in, we notice that immediately after that, our mind is distracted and loses this. Then at this point, we need calm abiding. When we have calm abiding, we are able to improve and increase these experiences. So the example Geshe la gave previously was that of felling a tree with an axe. We want to fell a tree with an axe.

If we hit always at the same point with the axe, we will fell the tree rapidly. If on the other hand, our aim is not true and sometimes we are hitting above and sometimes below, then it’ll take forever to fell the tree. So calm abiding is like an axe held by a strong and stable arm. The mind is very powerful, and whatever it focuses upon, it accomplishes. Well, it’s the same thing as trying to sweep a temple with a stalk of straw.

It’ll take forever to do that. But if you collect all the stalks of straw and turn them into a broom, you can sweep the temple rapidly. Likewise, if all of your mental capacities are focused on one object, then accomplishment occurs rapidly. So at present, our minds are scattered all over the place. At in the present, in the past, in the future.

In the present, they are focused on dozens of objects all over. Then if we can bring our mind down together and focus it on one object, we can accomplish our realization of that object rapidly. This is what his one is the Dalai Lama teaches regularly. Then this doesn’t only apply to dharma, but to studies. Many, perhaps most of you, have engaged in higher studies.

Then you will know that if you wish to study something, you must focus. And if your mind is scattered and distracted, it takes forever to accomplish or to finish your studies. Then imagine how much you can accomplish with a mind focused like calm abiding. Mhmm. The biggest obstacle at present to our mental peace and happiness is the ignorance grasping at a self.

And this is why Jetsongkopas says in his three principles of the path. In as much as through merely generating definite emergence in bodhicitta, it is not possible to sever the roots of psychic existence. Put effort at realizing interdependence. And Āryadeva adds in his 400 Stanzas, he who has realized interdependence has realized emptiness. So please listen carefully.

Geshe la will explain emptiness at present. Try not to be slack. So there are numerous gradations or levels of interdependence, coarser and more subtle. Geshe la would like to begin by pointing out that whatever is a composite phenomenon is necessarily a dependent origination or interdependent because it arises or exists in dependence on another. Does not believe believe he needs to point out to you that exterior physical objects exist independence on others.

So let us focus at presence on persons. Persons are dependent originations. They originate or they exist independence upon. In dependence upon what do persons exist or originate. When Geshe la was explaining this topic last time, you asked him, but how do we identify the person or the I?

Then that seems self evident. You do say I get up in the morning and I go about my life. Then if that is not an identification of the I, what exactly do you expect? Likewise, for the table. This is a table, but if Geshe la points on the top of the table or point to the top of the table, neither are the table.

So the top of the table is not the table. The color of the table is not the table. Neither are the feet of the table. Mhmm. Yet the table exists, is beneficial, and performs a function.

Then last time someone asked, well, where is the person? Well, obviously, indeed, where is the person? So this leads us to the view. Yet the person does exist. The question is, what is the mode of existence of the person?

So someone raised the doubt last time, and it’s a good doubt. Well, after all, we say that the I is not inherently established, not established from its own side, not established by its own characteristics. So where is this I? Then after all, we all get up in the morning. We go about our lives, about our business.

For whose sake do we do all this if not for the sake of the I? Are we doing this for someone else? Who exactly are we doing all this? And, obviously, our head is not our eye, our fist is not our eye, nor is our nose. But we have to investigate what the I is.

So now at present, the issue is a little bit delicate because we must distinguish between Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka on the one hand and the lower schools from Svatāntrika Madhyamaka downwards on the other hand. So for the lower schools from Svatantrika Madhyamaka downwards, the I or the person is the mental consciousness. For this is not the case. So let us examine ourselves. Will give this example examining himself.

He knows very well what he looked like six, seven, eight years ago. Then when people meet him nowadays, they say, my goodness. Geshe la has aged a lot. His hair is all white. He doesn’t look at all the way he looked before.

Now on what basis do they say Geshe la has aged a lot? Geshe la does not look as he looked before. So on what basis, therefore, can we say that Geshe la has grown grown old? Geshe la, after all, is a dependent origination which arises in dependence on others. Then Geshe la will take himself as an example here of being old since he has noticed you are deeply uncomfortable in being told that you are old.

So it’s okay. He is happy to be old. So Geshe la is old. His being old is something which arises independence on

Others on something else. So please explain why. Quick. Quick. Quick.

Quick. Quick. We say Geshe la is old in dependence on the aging of his form aggregates. Apart from explaining independence on the form aggregate, how do you do it? So that is self evident.

Geshe la is therefore imputed on a basis of imputation, which is his body and mind, his physical and mental aggregates. It is on that base that one says Geshe la is old when one imputes it on that base. Geshe la So when you say Geshe la is fat, Geshe la is skinny, Geshe la is handsome, you always say that on the basis of Geshe la’s form aggregate, his body. So let us now set Geshe la’s example aside and take Hiro as example. Hiro is impermanent.

Then Hiro’s being impermanent is a dependent arising occurring in dependence on others. In dependence on what? Please explain. Can you explain? Independence on euros aggregates being impermanent.

We impute Hiro’s being impermanent on that basis. Precisely. So Aggregates being impermanent is something we all understand. Geshe la suspects when Hiro was young, he looked very grand. I’m just joking.

Sorry. So when Geshe la asks why exactly do we say that hero is impermanent, you typically answer because Hiro disintegrates instant by instant. This is not wrong. It is correct, but it does not help us to understand interdependence at all. Instead, one should reflect that hero is an imputation on the basis of hero’s aggregates.

Hero’s aggregates themselves disintegrate instant by instant. Therefore, the imputation on that basis also disintegrates instant by instant. Please keep this in mind. Do you understand? Do you understand?

Yeah. Thank you. Oh, yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top