Lam Rim – 2012-09-22 – KR

1 h 9 min · 8,765 words · 22 September 2012

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2012-09-22 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. This talk on the precious human rebirth of leisure and endowment places the Lamrim within its lineages and explains its four greatnesses and how the three scopes of practitioners build on it. It covers the eight leisures and ten endowments, and the wrong views that obstruct practice. It ends by noting that practical identification of such a rebirth will follow after tea.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 9m

UUID: 9e992f0d-61ee-432e-90fd-36d84a352fa4

Date: 2012-09-22

Words: 8,761

The hand begins. So this conference itself is the second of the fully Buddhist conferences. The first was a conference on relying on the spiritual teacher last week. The second would be this conference on a human rebirth of leisure and endowment. As this is at present a fully Buddhist topic, for those of, us who are Buddhist, it is appropriate at present to take refuge.

Those of you who are not Buddhist, who just remain seated quietly in your chairs, but those of you who are sincerely Buddhist, just nominally or nebulously Buddhist, then we shall take refuge using the Sanskrit verses to our teacher Buddha Śākyamūni from all whom from whom all teachings proceed. So I’ve just discovered there are three types of prostrations. Long prostrations, short prostrations and prostrations with a hanging hearing aid. You have two handouts for this presentation. The first is the bibliography and the second is a reprint of a series of slides from the PowerPoint presentation to simplify following the material.

And I would strongly encourage all of you to take notes. This is fairly demanding material and it will be difficult for you to retain it all by memory. In the topic of a human rebirth of leisure and endowment or precious human rebirth as it’s sometimes called is one of the foundational topics. It’s generally considered to be a very easy topic, which I think is a fundamental misunderstanding of the topic itself. And I have for many years had the impression that one of the reasons for which the concept of a human rebirth of leisure and endowment resonates so much with the Western audience and it’s called over and again by Western Buddhists, a precious human rebirth, is because Westerners as a whole are overwhelmingly attached to this life.

And anything which goes in that direction, comforts the idea that this life is something highly valuable and precious, is something which will be taken on board. The question is, is that what is meant in the Buddhist context? And that is something which we will be addressing in this presentation. But first I would like to give some background on the Lamrim, its genesis and its uncommon features. The Lamrim as we know it arises historically at the intersection of two broad lineages, which both are traced back to Buddha Śākyamūni, the fourth supreme emanation body, the founder of the Buddhist tradition in this age.

These are the vast lineage and the profound lineage. The vast lineage whose emphasis is on the method aspect of the path, therefore on the generation of both renunciation and bodhichitta, principally bodhichitta. And which is traced down from Maitreya who gave these teachings in Tuśita to Asaṇga, the historical figure who transcribed them. His half brother Vasubandhu both lived sometime between the second and the third century of our era and then skipping a series of masters all the way down to Haribhādra who lived around the eighth century and who was extremely important for the transmission of the vast lineage to Tibet. The second lineage is a profound lineage which is perhaps better known.

It was retrieved by Nāgārjuna who it is said recovered the perfection of wisdom sutras which had disappeared between the time of the Parinirvana of Buddha Śākyamūni in the first century AD. History says that Nāgārjuna retrieved these perhaps within a community called the Naga community in, the East Of India. Then these transmissions were passed onwards to Āryadeva, Nagajuna’s foremost disciple and then jumping several masters to Buddhapālita, the founder of the so called Prāsaṇgika School of Mādhyamika to Bhavavivika, the founder of the Svatāntrika, Mādhyamika School and to Śāntideva whom most of you know. These two lineages were transmitted independently in India and this continued until the time of the great Indian master Atisha who transmitted them both to Tibet. The transmission of these two lineages by Atisha to Tibet occurred within the context of what we now know as the mind training teachings which Geshela expounds superbly every Sunday.

Then these mind training or lojong teachings were transmitted downwards from Atisha all the way to Je Tsongkhapa, mainly through the so called Kadampa Geshe of whom the foremost was Dromtonpa, Atisha’s heart son, his closest disciple and the founders of the three Kadampa lineages, Geshe Potowa, Geshe Puchungwa and Geshe Chengawa who founded the Kadampa’s following scripture, lamrim and oral instruction. You will notice that these mind training traditions were non sectarian. In other words, they were transmitted within the Kadampa tradition eventually to the great Kagyu master Gampopa and to the first Karmapa, Dusum Khyenpa. Je Tsongkhapa received the totality of these transmissions and Je Tsongkhapa can be seen in Tibetan history as a pivotal figure who tries to synthesize the totality of the Indian transmission. We could say perhaps that the two main roles of Je Tsongkhapa historically were one, a reformation of the Tibetan Buddhist tradition with emphasis given to the purity of monastic ethics.

And secondly, the presentation of a synthesis which enabled one to structure this gigantic amount of Buddhist material in what came to be known as the Lamrim, the graduated stages of the path. Now if we look no longer at a lineage of masters but a lineage of texts to see where the Lamrim comes from historically, The genesis of the Lamrim has been asserted by all of its great expounders to be Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra. So if we look back to our genealogy, we can see that the genesis of the Lamrim is traced back to the Bodhisattva Maitreya which is said to have taught the five texts including the Lamrim, including, excuse me, Abhisamayālamkāra to Asaṇga and Tuśita. So it is traced back at least to the second century AD. And then obviously its roots are to be found in the teachings of Buddha Śākyamūni.

But the first work which actually explicates the Lamrim is Atisha’s lamp for the path. And what is uncommon in Atisha’s lamp for the path is I think the Tibetan situation Atisha was dealing with. When Atisha came to Tibet, sūtra was opposed to tantra and tantra was opposed to sūtra. Those the Tibetans were unable to understand how to practice together sūtra and tantra, and specifically how someone who was fully ordained could engage in Tantric practice. The two were therefore seen as the sun and the moon and opposed.

This harmed both parties and this amounts to an abandonment of dharma. So what Atisha did was to provide a scheme which enabled one to understand the totality of the Buddhist teachings as instructions for one practitioner to attain full enlightenment. And this scheme is the idea of a graduated sequence of teachings adapted to practitioners of different levels. It is a revolutionary concept because within this framework, is possible to integrate the totality of Sutric and Tantric teachings. This chart you have in your handouts.

This was therefore, I would say, the vital contribution of the Bodhipathapradīpa, which is a very short work in verse of a couple pages with Atisha’s auto commentary. Some four centuries later, this seminal work gave rise to the Lamrim Cemo, the great stages of the path which Je Tsongkhapa composed around fourteen o two and which he then presented in an abbreviated form in 1415 in the middling and shorter Lamrims. All Je Tsongkhapa did was to take Atisha’s template and actually flesh it out. And this is why says famously in the Lamrim Cemo, the author of this is the author of that. Meaning, the author of Lamrim Cemo is none other than the author of Atisha’s Bodhipathapradīpa.

Je Tsongkhapa therefore views himself merely as expounding or developing on Atisha’s work. This has become the central template on which every Geluk practitioner finds his practice and from the Geluk tradition, it has spread to all of the other three traditions, the Sakya, Kagyu and Nyingma traditions. So each of those traditions has at present its own. It enables a practitioner first to identify himself on the scale of practitioners from the level of a being of small, middling or great scope. And then once he has located himself to see what practices are necessary for him at that point.

Therefore, I think the Lamrim is the innermost treasure of the Tibetan tradition. It is far more important in many respects than any so called advanced practices such as tantric practices which we neither understand nor are able to practice correctly. It is the Lamrim which is the beginning, the middle and frankly the end of practice. Since the lamrim includes detailed instructions on how to generate both bodhichitta and the correct view of emptiness. In other words, on how to enter the Mahāyāna and how to attain all the paths and grounds all the way up to the tenth ground.

It is indispensable to attain full enlightenment, to attain the so called path of normal learning for that transition from the tenth ground to the path of no more learning to engage in tantric practice. In turn, there were numerous commentaries on these three great Lamrims of Je Tsongkhapa. The three Lamrims are the Lamrim Chemo, the Lamrim Trungpa, the middling stages of the path and the lesser Lamrim. And these commentaries flesh out different aspects of the Lamrim. The first is the essence of refined gold by the third Dalai Lama.

It’s a beautiful small text. The second which I had the honor of translating for Khensur Rinpoche at Sera Je is the easy path by the first pension lama which is not translated in English but is available in French. The essence of refined gold is available in English. The we will see the particularities of these different lamrims in a couple of minutes. The third great commentaries From the Mouth of Mañjuśrī by the great fifth Dalai Lama who created Tibet as a modern state.

And the fourth is the swift path by the third Pänchen Lama, the second Pänchen Lama or the fifth and the sixth are the essence of nectar and liberation in the palm of your hand which I also have the honor of translating for Khensur Rinpoche at Serhagi. Each of these lamrims has its own uncommon specificity. The essence of refined gold is first and foremost a commentary on Je Tsongkhapa’s Foundation of Good Qualities. The easy path is the first attempt integrate lamrim with tantric visualization. From the mouth of Mañjuśrī is an attempt by the fifth Dalai Lama to flesh out the lamrim with quotes mainly from tantric texts.

While the swift path by the second Pänchen Lama, the reincarnation of the first Pänchen Lama is a further integration of lamrim and tantra. Finally, the essence of nectar by Yeshe Tsondru is a poem of realization by a very great practitioner from. It is really rooted in his own experience of meditating on the Lamrim. And perhaps the most important text for practice is the last one, Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand. Sera Je considers that the author of Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand is Kyabje Trijang Rinpoche, who took the notes when he was receiving teachings from Pabonga Rinpoche.

Sera may consider the author as Kyabje Pabongka Rinpoche and Trijang Rinpoche’s notes were a mere transcription. Whatever the case, liberation in the palm of the hand in addition to the other lamrims contains a totality of the oral tradition on the practice of Lamrim. The foundation for good Buddhist practice in the Tibetan tradition is rooted in this practice of Lamrim. And there are two approaches. If one is of limited capacity, one has a limited amount of time, one chooses one text in a function of one’s inclination.

If for instance one has very little time and I hope it will be translated in English, one could work with the easy path or the essence of refined gold. If one still wants to rely on one text and one has time, one would choose liberation in the palm of your hand or perhaps Lamrim Cemo. I rely on Lamrim Cemo myself. Then if one wants to enter in-depth in Lamrim, one relies on the totality of the texts. One takes a given topic, let’s say the precious human rebirth and one draws on all the texts with a different presentation to flesh this out.

This is what I will do today with this topic. Then for those of you who are interested, it is unique. It’s the first time it has happened since the end of World War two. His Holiness the Dalai Lama is giving the total transcript transmission of 18 different Lamrim text in India over the next two years. At Ganden in Drepung this year and at Sera Je next year.

These 18 texts include these six texts plus the three foundational ones which make nine, but include a series of other texts as well. This is something which is unique to a minority that has not been done of human memory. So what is the greatness of the Lamrim? And in a sense, why should we rediscover the Lamrim? Because one of the very big problems I think in Western Buddhist centers is that the Lamrim is taught perhaps prematurely.

Lamrim in Tibet was typically taught to geshes. In western centers it’s taught to rank beginners who therefore view this over time with at best a certain fatigue and at worst a certain contempt. Now this is extremely unfortunate because these are foundational aspects of the practice which are much more important than any so called initiations or transmissions one might receive whose vows one will not keep, whose visualizations one cannot do, whose meaning one does not understand and who eventually lead one perhaps to lower rebirths. The lamrim can only lead to one’s betterment. So the greatnesses of the Lamrim and I’d like to talk about this because it has not been talked about a lot at TBI are fourfold.

The first is knowing that all the teachings are free from contradiction. The second is enabling one to understand all of the Buddhist scriptures as instructions for practice. The third is finding easily the conquerors, in other words Buddha’s intention. And the fourth is refraining automatically from wrongdoing and you should have these in your handout. These four greatnesses are unique to the Lamrim.

There is no other corpus of teachings in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition which has these four greatnesses. And it is these four greatnesses which guarantee that if one practices the Lamrim regularly, one will progress on the spiritual path. But she often said despite oneself. It just will happen. So what are these four greatnesses and what are they rooted in?

The first presentation I know is in Je Tsongkhapa’s song of realization. In other words, his shortest lamrim. The realization that all teachings are non contradictory. The dawn of all scripture as instructions, finding easily the intent of the conqueror and protecting also against the abyss of wrongdoing. If we analyze them carefully, what does it mean to know that all the teachings are free from contradiction and that they are not, therefore, not like two bull yaks opposing each other.

Buddha Śākyamūni is teaching for instance in one sūtra that exterior phenomena truly exist and his teaching in another sūtra that exterior phenomena are purely mental and do not exist. If one sees this literally these teachings are contradictory and this undermines the foundations of one’s practice. Once one understands that these teachings were addressed to different trainees, different students and therefore that to one Buddha Śākyamūni taught one thing, to another he taught something else, to a third he taught something else because they were at different levels of the path. These teachings are seen as non contradictory. They are seen as means to lead one person over time to full enlightenment.

And therefore, this is if you want the graphic representation of the Lamrim. For worldly beings like ourselves who are trying to reach the goal of full enlightenment, it is necessary to progress through all of the levels of the path. And we do this because we ourselves as beings, as persons are changed in the process. From worldly beings who have in other words no focus apart from this life which I think is a case of most of us in this room. We eventually become beings of the small scope whose principal focus is on future lives.

For such beings, the practice to be engaged in is practice involving meditation on impermanence and meditation on the lower realms. Such beings do not engage in these higher practices which are of no benefit to them because having identified oneself as a being of the small scope, one engages in the practices which are appropriate and beneficial for oneself. As one’s mind expands and one no longer merely focuses on future lives but eventually realizes the vanity of all future lives, the fact that they are all identical in terms of suffering, At this point one becomes a being of the middling scope and at this point the practices one engages in change. One is different. The other practices are three trainings, ethics, concentration and wisdom of the 12 links which Geshela taught here a couple of months ago and so forth.

This is the main focus of practice in the Theravada countries. The countries which follow the path of the elders such as Burma, Thailand, Sri Lanka and so forth. Now as oneself evolves and eventually reaches a scope where one realizes that it is not sufficient to actually practice for oneself, but all living beings are interconnected and we have infinite responsibility towards all, at this point one will have become a being of the great scope, of the Mahāyāna. And here one’s practice shifts once again and becomes that of the six perfections. The perfection of generosity, of ethics, of forbearance, of enthusiasm, of concentration and of wisdom.

These are the practices of bodhisattvas. These practices must be engaged in for a well nigh infinite amount of time, three countless eons to yield their fruits since the goal is no longer just escaping oneself from the wheel of rebirth, the goal is the attainment of the state of full enlightenment. At the point where the Bodhisattva practitioner enhances his bodhichitta and reaches a level where the idea of practicing over three countless eons is in supportable when he or she thinks of the suffering of beings, not when he or she thinks of the hardship involved. At that point and at that point alone, it is appropriate to engage in tantric practice. And then the tantric vehicle is the fast vehicle towards full enlightenment as is taught by all the great masters, it is both the fastest and the most dangerous vehicle.

It is perhaps extremely regrettable that much of the transmission of Tibetan Buddhism to the West has occurred in the context of tantric transmissions for which westerners in their large majority are not ready. Therefore says since Bodhisattvas must take care of students who are followers of all three lineages, they must train in the paths of those three lineages. So the uncommon feature of the Bodhisattva practitioner is that precisely since the Bodhisattva is practicing no longer for his own sake as the beings of this small in the middling scope but is practicing to lead all living beings to the state of full enlightenment, he must train in the means to help these beings in function of their level. Some beings may be worthy beings to those he gives worthy advice. Some beings may be beings of the small scope to those he teaches impermanence.

Some beings may be beings of the middling scope to those he teaches renunciation, the 12 links, the three trainings. Some finally may be beings who have the potential to generate bodhichitta. To them he teaches the six perfections. The second greatness of Lamrim is to enable one to understand that all the scriptures are instructions for practice. This is perhaps the biggest difficulty I think Western students encounter.

One does see with most students who attend Buddhist centers and I think all Western countries, I’ve seen this in The US, in Europe, it’s evident in Australia. An extremely intellectual relation to the teachings. The teachings are seen as objects of intellectual stimulation. The teachings are not lived. The goal of the teachings is for them to be lived, in other words to be practiced.

The goal of the teachings is for every one of us to take them within our minds and transform our minds. And therefore one of the greatnesses of the Lamrim is to show us that there is not one single aspect of the teachings we receive which is not helpful for our own mind or if not for our own mind for the mind of another person. And this is why says in the in general, only the scriptures of the conqueror provide the means to achieve all temporary and ultimate benefit and happiness for those who desire liberation. Now to a western audience, this sounds like a very dogmatic statement. It is dogmatic for so long as you have not analyzed.

For so long as you are standing on the outside and have neither studied nor practiced, this is indeed a dogmatic statement. Once you analyze and you realize that we are caught in the cycle of lives and you try to find the actual means out of the cycle of life, it’s no longer a theoretical venture for weekends or vacations, it is something which takes over your life. Then you will need to find something which actually works and what actually works are the teachings on selflessness. These teachings are unique to the Buddhist tradition. It is if you want the Buddhist specificity.

Therefore, when we speak of liberation from cyclic existence, let alone full enlightenment, there is no gateway to liberation or full enlightenment apart from the Buddhist teachings. There are numerous religious traditions which provide highly beneficial teachings for other beings, which for instance teach development of ethics, the teach development of love and compassion, and enable these beings to attain higher rebirths. But if the goal ceases to be the attainment of a higher rebirth and becomes the attainment of liberation or the attainment of full enlightenment, then there is no other pathway. This is something which has to be determined through reason and analysis should you be interested to do so. One of the main reasons of Je Tsongkhapa’s coming to Tibet in the fourteenth century was to cause a return or to encourage the Tibetans to return to the foundational texts of ancient India.

The Tibetans like, unfortunately, I think most of the Asian cultures which adopted Buddhism eventually integrated Buddhism so much within their culture that they got trapped in a model where the teachings were presented as oral instructions. And these oral instructions were separated from the core texts, first of the Buddha himself, the scripture collection, and then the great commentaries of Indian pundits. And there was a very major risk and it has happened in some Chinese schools of Buddhism, certainly in some of the forms of Chan of the school itself basically drifting away from the central Buddhist core to such a degree that it is open to question whether it would be recognized as Buddhist by the great ancient Indian teachers or not. So for this reason, Je Tsongkhapa says, there are those who hold that there are separate personal instructions that teach the core meaning and are the heart of practice. And this is something we encounter even nowadays in the Tibetan traditions.

They then imagine that there are two separate forms of the teaching. A teaching that is explained to you, in other words, what is taught, the great shastras, the great sutras, any teaching that you practice. A private oral instruction separate from these given to one in retreat, which is perhaps not rooted in the sastras, the sutras, and the tantras. And Je Tsongkhapa here makes a very powerful statement. Know that you accumulate the karmic obstruction of abandoning the teachings when you see those classic texts as objects of contempt.

This is something which I have seen frequently among western students. There is a dismissal of the great Indian tradition of works such as Asaṇga’s Bodhisattvabhūmi, of works such as Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra, of the Madhyamakāvatāra, and an emphasis on some recent cryptic statement by some quasi unknown master who puts things in a very fancy way. This is a very dangerous trend. It is not a new trend. It is a trend which is extent at Je Tsongkhapa’s time.

So for the purity of the Buddhist tradition, we must over and again root ourselves in the great ancient Indian texts and their authoritative Tibetan commentaries and this rooting must occur within the context of reason and analysis. Now this was a problem even before Je Tsongkhapa’s time is shown by this quote of Kamalaśīla. Further what you meditate on is just that which you study. If there is one thing which Khensur Rinpoche has emphasized powerfully at TBI, it is precisely that. It is what is taught at the center which is one’s topic of meditation.

One does not come, study one thing at the center then read something privately at home and meditate on that. This is wrong practice. One comes and what one studies and tries to understand is what one practices. And then the three activities of hearing, of thinking and of meditating are fused as one. The third greatness of the Lamrim is easily finding the conqueror’s intent.

What was the intention of Buddha Śākyamūni when he taught these great sutras? Who was he thinking about? Why did he teach for instance that all phenomena of the nature of mind in the Samdhinirmochana sūtra? And did he teach, let’s say, in the Eight Thousand Verse Perfection of Wisdom sūtra that all phenomena are empty of inherent existence? What was his intent?

This can be easily understood to the Lam Rim. His intent was to teach in a function of the capacities of the various trainees. And the last greatness is refraining automatically from great wrongdoing. Great wrongdoing here refers to the greatest wrongdoing, which is the abandonment of the dharma. It means after having started to study the Buddhist teachings, after having engaged in that path, either to abandon the totality of the teachings or to erect one aspect of the teachings against the other.

To say, in the Theravada tradition, the Vinaya is pure. But because of the practice of tantra, there are problems with Vinaya in the Tibetan tradition. This is abandonment of dharma. Or to say the Theravada tradition lacks the essence of the great vehicle and to criticize it on that basis. This is abandonment of the dharma.

In every single case, as is said in the King of Concentration Sutras, the wrongdoing of one who abandons the collection of sutras is far greater than that of one who kills ahats equal in number to the sand of the Ganges. Why is this the case? Simply because once one has deprecated one form of the teachings, one has closed the door for oneself to ever connect in future lives with that form of the teachings. If one is a Bodhisattva practitioner, if one practices the Mahāyāna and one criticizes the Theravada, One creates a karma for not understanding the Theravada tradition. Therefore, in the future, as a practitioner of the Mahāyāna for being unable to help Theravada practitioners.

Therefore, one creates a karma for a downfall of one’s practice as a bodhisattva. So the lamrim protects against these four forts and has these four greatnesses. And this is, I would say, the inner essence of the Lamrim. Now how is the Lamrim studied in the great monasteries? In the great monasteries, the Lamrim is seen as the palm of one’s hand.

It connects the five fingers. For twenty years, the students in the Geshe program study the Prajñāpāramitā, the perfection of wisdom for seven years, the Mādhyamika for four years, Abhidharma typically for four years, Vinaya monastic discipline for four years and Pramāna throughout the course of their studies. However, these five topics are all connected inside the Lamrim and when a Geshe, a true Geshe, a Larampa Geshe who has studied well practices he practices the drawing on all five topics of study. And I would suspect there is no more powerful means of practice than this. He uses Pramāna, Buddhist logic to analyze Mādhyamika within the context of lamrim.

His understanding of Vinaya is rooted in the presentations of karma in the Prajñāpāramitā. When he offers mandala, he offers mandala in the light of Abhidharma. This is how in the Gelug tradition one is taught how to practice. The is not subsidiary. It is not a preliminary to be discarded as one moves upward in one’s practice.

It is the palm of the hand without which the five fingers cannot function. And this leads us to today’s topic which is meditation on a rebirth of leisure and opportunity. This is the second topic presented in the Lamrim after reliance on the spiritual teacher. And it is a topic which once it has been fully understood, leads one to choose to engage in one of three paths. The path of the being of small scope, of middling, or of great scope.

Therefore, it is a preliminary to the totality of the normal. Meditation on a human rebirth of leisure and opportunity is not as some say part of the practice of the being of small scope. That is an incorrect presentation. It is actually the foundation from which the practices for the beings of all three scopes takes birth. And this is why Nāgārjuna says, in who first practices high status, definite goodness arises later.

For having attained high status, one comes gradually to definite goodness. High status here refers to higher rebirth. Definite goodness refers to liberation or full enlightenment. Nāgārjuna is saying that first one tries to attain a higher rebirth and then over the lives, over the tens, sometimes a hundreds, sometimes a thousands of lives, one moves up to liberation and eventually to full enlightenment. This one stanza of the precious garland contains the essence of the Lamrim.

When I gave the chronology, if you wish, of the generation of the Lamrim passing from Maitreya’s Abhishamaya Lamkara to Atisha’s lamp for the path. I did not mention Nāgārjuna’s Ratnāvali because it is actually never mentioned in the Tibetan texts. It is studied, constantly studied, but is not mentioned in this lineage. However, it is a critical link. Now to understand correctly the lamrim and to understand correctly the concept of a human rebirth of leisure and endowment one has to introduce a concept which is presented a bit later in one’s studies which is the concept of the base The base is a foundation on which one is either able to accomplish a certain goal or the foundation on whose basis one can definitely accomplish a certain goal.

It’s the preliminaries if you want. If you’re an Australian, you have the right to, for instance, get benefits. If you’re not an Australian, you don’t have the right to get benefits. People fight to know who has the right to be an Australian and who has the right not to be an Australian. Why?

Not because of the flag, but because of the benefits down the line in the broadest sense of the term. Now those are mundane topics, but when one understands fully the base, one understands that the base, in this case Australian citizenship or residency, gives you certain rights you may use or not. You may choose to receive benefits or not. You may choose to go to university at reduced rates or not. But having this base, you have the right to do so.

You have the possibility. Without that base, you do not have that possibility. So understanding clearly what is the base for certain privileges, certain possibilities is critical in worldly affairs and is also important in one’s dharma practice. The great Kagyu master, Gampopa, whose presentation of Lamrim is magnificent because he starts out with a presentation of Buddha nature. Says, all sentient beings have Buddha nature.

Only a precious human life, in other words, human rebirth of leisure and endowment, which has two qualities of leisure and endowment, and a mind which holds the three faiths, of which the foremost is a faith of conviction, has a good basis to work towards enlightenment. So what Gampopa is saying here is that even though technically all sentient beings have good nature, all sentient beings have the possibility to become enlightened, Only a precious human rebirth is an actual base for full enlightenment because even though for instance, my wife’s two dogs have Buddha nature and I struggle to see it on a daily basis and frequently fail, nonetheless, even should they wish to attain full enlightenment, it will be impossible for them. They lacked mental capacity. However, should they obtain at some future date a human rebirth of leisure and endowment and wish to attain full enlightenment that is possible on that basis. And Je Tsongkhapa alludes to this as well in his song of realization when referring to the human rebirth of leisure and he mentions it as a base.

This base of leisure is superior to a wish fulfilling jewel. So if we try to represent this graphically to get a better sense of what is happening, We can see in terms of rebirth, the totality of sentient beings down here and they all share Buddha nature. They all have a mind which has the potential for attaining full enlightenment. Now within sentient beings, the question which arises and it is addressed within the monastic studies for instance at Sera Je is, what is a base for generating bodhichitta? Actually, not only human beings but some animals, specifically nagas are able to generate bodhichitta and even some hell beings.

Instead of Buddha Śākyamūni generated bodhichitta for the first time as a hell being. When filled with compassion at the sight of a fellow hell being who was dragging a cart and being tortured, he stepped in to help him. And the fruit of that compassion was that he was instantaneously killed in the hell realm, his hell rebirth took an end and he was reborn as a human being. So Buddha Śākyamūni according to a sūtra generated bodhichitta for the first time as a hell being. How therefore being a hell being can act as a base for generating bodhichitta But for attaining full enlightenment and specifically for receiving monastic vows, vows as a or a genog, one must be a human being.

A human rebirth of leisure and endowment is actually indispensable. And even within human rebirth of leisure and endowment, there is a further subdivision, a human rebirth of leisure and endowment with the so called eight ripened qualities which give particular power to one’s capacity to act as a human being. We’ll talk about that later on today. So what are the features of a correct meditation on a human rebirth of leisure and endowment? They are threefold.

The first is identifying such a rebirth, then contemplating its importance, and contemplating its rarity. And they must occur in the sequence for one’s mind to be transformed. So identifying such a rebirth, such a rebirth is said to be a rebirth with eight leisures, about which we shall talk, and 10 opportunities, five pertaining to oneself and five to others. Contemplating the rarity of this rebirth is to be done first by contemplating its rarity from the standpoint of causes, then the standpoint of effects and finally through examples. This is a complete program of mental transformation.

If it is followed correctly in sequence and not in a haphazard fashion, one’s mind will naturally be transformed. Then the question which arises is how to identify such a rebirth. And this is done through examination in the same way as here you can see metallurgists in the middle age examining and smelting gold. A human rebirth of leisure and endowment has eight leasures which is a rebirth which is free from four human absences of leisure and a rebirth which is free from four non human absences of leisure. And as we mentioned 10 endowments which include five endowments from one’s own side and five from the side of others.

Now this two fold presentation of leisures and endowment is rooted in the two passages in Shastra, in the great Buddhist commentaries which refer to a rebirth of leisure and endowment. The first is a passage in Nāgārjuna’s letter to a king in which he speaks of the eight leisures. The second is a passage in Asaṇga’s the stages of in which he speaks of the 10 endowments. These two, one from the standpoint of wisdom and one from the standpoint of method, were conflated to give a human rebirth with 18 features. So the quote from Nāgārjuna’s letter to king Gautamiputra is as follows.

Being reborn either as upholding wrong views or as an animal, as a preta or as a hell being, without the speech of conquerors or in a borderland as a barbarian, retarded and mute or as a long lived god are the eight absences of leisure. After finding the leisure bereft of that strive at countering rebirth. Countering rebirth here means attaining liberation. The eight absences of leisure are upholding wrong views, being an animal, being a hungry ghost, being a hell being, lacking a conqueror’s teachings, being an ignorant person in a border area, mentally retarded or mute, and a long lived deity. Every single one of these states actually prevents one in one manner or another from attaining liberation or full enlightenment.

And we will analyze them carefully. There is much more here than one would think at first view. If instead of following the traditional presentation, one breaks the eight absences of leisure up into four human absences of leisure and four non human absences of leisure, we can see that for a human being absence of leisure includes upholding wrong views, lacking a Buddhist teaching, being an ignorant being in a border area, and being mentally retarded or mute. Before non human absences of leisure being a hell being, being a hungry ghost, being an animal, or being a long lived god. Now what is meant here precisely by upholding wrong views, which is presented first, which is the biggest impediment to any type of Buddhist practice.

Because if one sincerely holds wrong views, one would even get started on the Buddhist path. So irrespective of the other qualities of one’s Buddhist, of one’s human rebirth, one cannot be said to have a human rebirth of leisure and endowment. According to Je Tsongkhapa, there are three wrong views which are referred to in this context. The first is disbelief in refuge in the Triple Gem. The second is disbelief in past and future lives.

And the third is disbelief in karma and causality. Now I think that easily 80% of Australians disbelieve past and future lives in common and causality. So already here you can say just in terms of wrong views, 80% of the population easily, and I will give you the figures later on, does not have a precious human rebirth. And even among those who attend centers, there was a very disturbing statistic which came from The United States. I don’t have the figures for Australia.

70% of American Buddhists don’t believe in past and future lives. Then if you don’t believe in the past and future life, let alone not being a Buddhist, you certainly don’t have a human rebirth of leisure and endowment. There’s no foundation for the practice of ethics of any type. This is why at TBI we have emphasized very strongly presentations of past and future lives and I will be doing this in the second part of this conference. The second absence of leisure which has to be analyzed is the eighth absence of leisure, being a long lived deity.

Generally speaking, there are three categories of gods. Gods of the desire realm, of the form and of the formless realms. Gods of the desire realm without exception lack leisure. They are obsessed with sense pleasures, very high order of sense pleasures, but sense pleasures and this prevents any type of practice. Practice.

However, in the case of beings of the form and the formless realms, one is reborn as a god of the form and the formless realm only through karma generated through concentration. Then lack leisure only the gods of the form of the formless realms who are not arias. There are indeed ariya beings. In other words, beings who have attained the path of seeing who choose to be reborn in the form and the formless realms. Then you cannot say that they lack leisure.

They are reborn in the state for reasons of their own. The second presentation of a human rebirth of leisure and endowment is a presentation of the 10 endowments which is rooted as we said in Asaṇga’s Śrāvakabhūmi, the Śrāvakabhūmi. The passage reads, being human, being born in a central region, having complete sensory faculties, having reversible karma, and having faith in the source. Buddha has visited, the sublime teaching is being taught, other teachings remain, there are those who follow it, there is caring for others. And this gives rise to the traditional presentation of the 10 endowments.

Five for oneself, being human, born in a central land with complete sense faculties, having reversible karma and faith in the source, and five depending on the environment that a Buddha has visited, taught, that the teachings still remain, that they are followed and that they are benefactors. Now if we analyze these 10 endowments and we study for instance a list of the countries, with the highest proportion of Buddhists. We can see that in Thailand for instance where there are some 95% of, Buddhists, 95% of the population is Buddhist. Certainly, 95% of the population fulfills the first requirement of being a human being and the second requirement of being reborn in the central land. And by the time one goes down to Tibet where the situation is quite dire nowadays because of the Chinese occupation, only 65% of the Tibetans now are Buddhist.

This includes the Chinese forces in the country. Then it is open to question whether being born in Tibet automatically qualifies one for having some of the features of every birth of leisure and endowment. By the time one moves down to Western countries, these countries probably do not qualify as central lands. Technically, a central land is a country in which there are sufficient members of the Buddhist Sangha to perform ordination. Then the number of Sangha members depends of the traditions.

It is between four and ten fully ordained members of Sangha. However, if we have a broader understanding of a central land as a land where the Buddhist teachings are widespread enough that we will be influenced by them in our daily lives, then there are very few countries, certainly very few western countries which qualify. The next topic which has to be covered is the issue of reversible karma. One of the five endowments from one’s own side is not having committed the five heinous actions. This is called having reversible karma because it’s karma which can basically be purified.

If one has killed one’s father, killed one’s mother, killed an arhat, shed the blood of a Buddha, or caused a schism, a break in the Sangha, this karma is almost impossible to purify in this life. Almost impossible. Of these five, by far the most dangerous is the last. It is extremely easy to cause a schism in the Sangha. A schism in the Sangha means a situation in which in the monastery, there is a split.

And a certain number of monks hold one position and another number of monks hold another position. Now strictly speaking, a full schism in the Sangha could only occur during Buddha Śākyamūni’s life. But it still is possible to consider splits in monasteries nowadays as schisms in the Sangha. And in the broader sense of the term when this happens in the dharma centers, the karma which is accumulated is broadly speaking almost as heavy. Dharma centers are very heavy objects karmically.

As Garchen and Batchelor said to me once in Estonia, dharma centers are the monasteries of the twenty first century. Nowadays monasteries will disappear. Nobody wants to become ordained. Nobody wants to study in the monasteries. Then what appeals to modern man is the dharma center.

The dharma center fulfills a function of a monastery. A schism in a dharma center, where two sides are erected against each other, is akin to a schism in the Sangha. And therefore, if one attains a dharma center from one’s own side, one has to be very careful not to give rise to this. I have seen many times in my own life, people who caused major disruptions in dharma centers, turned very badly very quickly after that. It was quite astonishing that the speed with which that specific karma matured.

Quite astonishing. Then another important personal endowment is having faith in the source. Faith in the source here generally means faith in the Vinaya, in monastic discipline which is the foundation of Buddhist practice. But it can be read more broadly as having faith in the totality of the Buddhist teachings. Clearly, if one doesn’t have faith in the Buddha’s teachings, then one is not going to practice them, one is not going to attend teachings, one will not make any effort.

These are the five endowments from one’s own side. Now regarding the five endowments from the side of the environment, the situation is actually when analyzed much more bleak. Strictly speaking, the four first endowments from the standpoint of others, number six that the Buddha has visited, that he has taught the teachings remain and that they are followed, can only be fulfilled when a Buddha is still present. In other words, the period when a Buddha reaches full enlightenment and when he enters Pariniarva. So this means that fully qualified human rebirth of leisure and endowment existed during the lifetime of the Buddha.

Not a single one of us in this room has such a rebirth because we are, and this is why the Pänchen Lama mentions it, in the Lama Chöpa. We are the garbage. We are the dregs. Those who did not meet the Buddha. Those who when the Buddha came and taught were doing something else, which is why the spiritual teachers come to teach us.

Then our human rebirth is not a fully qualified human rebirth because we did not meet Buddha Śākyamūni who was the fourth supreme emanation body, the universal teacher, when he came to teach. That comma, we did not have. So if we now try to understand precisely what types of human rebirths there are, Make a typology of human rebirths of leisure and endowment. We have fully characterized human rebirths of leisure and endowment which nobody has nowadays. They were only possible during the life of Buddha Śākyamūni.

Then we have what some of us have which is proximate rebirth of rebirth of leisure and endowment. With the eight leisures complete, the five endowments from one’s own side complete and from within the remaining five endowments from the side of another, only one would have to be complete, the presence of benefactors. So of the 18 factors, we would end up with 14. Then clearly from one’s own side, if in this room some of you, for instance, are not Buddhist, do not believe in karma and causality or do not believe in past and future lives, then we do not have a proximate human rebirth of leisure and endowment. Finally, there are similes of a human rebirth of leisure and endowment and I feel personally these are the human rebirths of all of the sincere practitioners of other religions.

Simply because the sincere practitioner of another religion which teaches ethics, at least teaches ethics, has enough to attain a higher rebirth in the next life. Irrespective of whether he or she believes in numerous past and future lives or karma and causality or not. Someone who, for instance, abstains from killing, abstains from theft because of the fear of the last judgment is actually engaging in virtue. And the fear of the last judgment for a devout Christian is very powerful, but this may lead to a very intense practice of virtue. Such a person will definitely get a higher rebirth.

There is no doubt about it. Then obviously such a belief is incompatible with obtaining liberation. It is not possible for such a person to obtain liberation. But a higher rebirth definitely. This is why his Holiness and Dalai Lama strongly encourages all westerners to first assess carefully their own religious traditions.

It is very difficult to convert to another religion sincerely. Generally speaking, it doesn’t happen well. Then if one’s own religious tradition teaches the basics which are ethics, practicing that religious tradition is enough to guarantee a higher rebirth for oneself. In other words, in terms of the result, one is on par with the being of the small scope. That is much safer as a bet then to abandon the religion of one’s fathers, to convert to another religion one doesn’t fully endorse, and to be unable to lay down the foundation for ethics.

It is much better to be a pious and dedicated Christian, Jew, Muslim, Hindu, then to be, let us say, excuse me, to be direct, a Western Buddhist, and I know many who smokes pot, who drinks, who runs around, and who says he’s a high tantric practitioner. I know people like that who teach. Such people are going down. There’s no question about it. Such people would have been far better off remaining Christians or becoming evangelicals than becoming Buddhist.

Not only do they harm themselves, they harm the teachings because people look at their behavior and they think this is how Buddhist’s behavior. This has led to a situation where many great teachers such as Geshe Lama Zopa, for instance, refused to ordain Western. Geshe Lama Zopa has put a ban on the ordination of westerners. He does not consider westerners able to protect the monastic vows. So this is why Nāgārjuna said, in brief, the view of nihilism is that effects of actions do not exist.

The view of existence is that effect of actions exist. Nihilism is regarded as a wrong view. The view of existence is regarded as a right view. This is a passage which grounds his holiness’s position regarding religious conversion. What Nāgārjuna is saying is that between the extreme of eternalism and the extreme of nihilism, there is not symmetry, there is asymmetry.

The extreme of eternalism is far preferable to the extreme of nihilism because on the basis of the extreme of eternalism, it is possible to construct ethics. On the basis of the extreme of nihilism, it is impossible to construct ethics. And therefore Nāgārjuna goes so far as to call the extreme of eternalism a right view. Therefore, it is extremely important for those of us who have recently become Buddhist not to present it and not to try to convert others to our belief. Because precisely it is very difficult for conversion to a religious tradition which is not part of one’s culture to be stable.

And if the person has some type of religious grounding in their own culture, as long as it is one of the great religions which teaches ethics, that tradition is of benefit. Then I think we will stop here for tea And then, after tea, we will address, practical aspects how to, identify precious human rebirth based on Stevenson’s research. Thank you very much. It’s in my computer bag in here.

Key terms in this teaching

buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Kagyü
The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Marpa, Milarepa, Gampopa, and their followers. One of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. Cf. Nyingma, Sakya and Gelug. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
nirmanakaya emanation body; tul ku (Tib)
The emanation body of a buddha that manifests in a variety of forms for sentient beings. LYWA
prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top