Lam Rim – 2018-07-25 – Lamrim

1 h 39 min · 4,719 words · 25 July 2018

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2018-07-25 - Lamrim
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk teaches calm abiding as the basis of meditation, explaining the meaning of the Tibetan term and how to train the mind single-pointedly on a visualized object such as a Buddha image or flame. It then explains the lower schools’ teaching of coarse and subtle selflessness of persons, and the apprehended autonomous self as the root of mental suffering. It encourages practice during an upcoming Lam Rim retreat, followed by a short question and answer session.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 40m

UUID: e7c2a1d6-74da-4ad6-802a-628eff5be74c

Date: 2018-07-25

Words: 4,715

Mhmm. So, we all, like to meditate, but one must understand what is truly meant by meditation. To truly meditate, one must have attained calm abiding, Samatha. And, to do this, one must progress through the nine mental abidings explained in Maitreya’s Mahāyāna Sūtra Alamkara, starting with the first mental abiding. One should know what the first mental abiding is, then the second mental abiding, and so forth.

So fully characterized meditation is therefore calm abiding. Calm abiding in Tibetan is. It’s constituted of two syllables. Means pacification. Means abiding.

The, pacification refers to a pacification of the outwards distraction of our mind. Our mind is constantly distracted outwards by sensory objects. This must be pacified. Nepa or abiding refers to the mind abiding uninterruptedly and single pointedly on its object of observation. When the mind is no longer distracted outwards to objects of distraction, dwell single pointedly and uninterruptedly on its object of observation, and there is no physical or mental hardship, one has probably attained calm abiding.

So, calm abiding, therefore, refers as far as the né particle. Abiding is concerned to the mind’s being able to dwell or to abide for however long it wishes to dwell on its object of observation for hours, for days, for months, uninterruptedly. That’s it. You know? Just two words.

Calm abiding, therefore, has two syllables. Pacification. A And in Tibetan, it’s called when one interprets the terms, there’s a lot of meaning. So meditation, therefore, does not refer to adopting a strange posture and staying in that posture. It instead refers to practices such as calm abiding.

And to attain calm abiding, one must initially focus the mind on an object. It can be a statue, a representation of Buddha Śākyamūni or of Avalokiteśvara or of Tārā or of Mañjuśrī, and one must initially train in the first level of mental abiding. So this first level of mental abiding is called single pointedness. And when one trains in this first level of mental abiding, taking for instance as object of observation, a statue of the Buddha, this does not mean that one stares pointedly at the statue of the Buddha. So calm abiding is not generated in dependence on the visual consciousness.

Why is this the case? So this is inappropriate. What is the reason for it being inappropriate? If we take as object of observation, a statue of the Buddha, and we adopt the posture of meditation and stare at this statue, while our mind wanders all over the place, then our mind is not concentrated on the object of observation. So it’s self evident that we both have sensory and mental consciousnesses.

Then to use a sensory consciousnesses to stare at an object of observation like the statue of the Buddha, all one’s mind wanders all over the place is useless. So, therefore, meditation does not involve focusing the visual consciousness on an object such as the statue of Buddha Śākyamūni. The visual consciousness does not perform this work. Instead, it is the mental consciousness, which should be focused on its object. Geshe la suspects that this is a misunderstanding you might have.

Then it is perfectly appropriate to meditate without a statue of the Buddha in front of oneself just visualizing it. And at the beginning, this is not easy. Geshe la himself engages in these practices. One adopts a posture of meditation, and then one visualizes the image of the Buddha with one’s eyes partially closed but not completely closed. Then one focuses using the mental consciousness on the object of observation, and one can use objects such as a visualized flame and so forth, which are advantageous because there is not a lot of reflection involved in such a visualization.

We should avoid visualizing things like meals and so forth towards which there is attachment. Then initially, when one trains in calm abiding, one visualizes, for instance, a statue of the Buddha, at first for ten seconds, if one can do so. And then one extends this to twenty seconds, thirty seconds, forty seconds, fifty seconds. If one reaches one minute of uninterrupted sixty seconds, one minute of uninterrupted visualization, that is quite a feat. And at this point, one will realize just how much one’s mind is scattered and wanders.

Do you understand? Yes. Is it busy? Is it busy? Hello?

So when we rise in the morning, it would be very good to engage in a bit of meditation. Even a little bit is very helpful. As Śāntideva says, nothing cannot be generated through habituation. Therefore, at the beginning, we should just train in this way in calm abiding. Then it is difficult for us at the beginning to visualize uninterruptedly, an object of meditation.

So we should train in this. And, as, we will know from experience, the biggest interferences to concentration arise from the visual consciousness and the auditory consciousness. The olfactory, in other words, smell, gustatory and tactile consciousnesses not interfere that that much. Now this is something we should check for ourselves. Mhmm.

For beginners. Once, we are able to focus our mind for one minute or longer on an object of observation, whatever it may may be, our mental activity becomes our mental operativeness becomes far more rapid because our mind is able to focus on whatever activity it engages in without being scattered or distracted. So for instance

When we meditate, on impermanence, initially, we try to wrap our mind around the difficult concept of impermanence. And then we take an example, let us say, to stand in front of Geshe la. And then the moment we take an example, our mind is scattered by that example. It’s distracted into another line of thought. Now this is something perhaps you have experienced.

As Śāntideva says in his Bodhicharyavatara, all virtuous activities such as reciting the mantra, meditating, and so forth go to waste when the mind is scattered elsewhere. And indeed, if for instance, we were to recite mantras while thinking of something else, there is no benefit. So once, we are trained in meditation, we can accomplish whatever mental activities we choose to accomplish very rapidly. It’s one of the attainments. Just as for instance, if we have to fell a tree with an axe and our hand is steady and we experience, then we will hit with the axe always at the same spot and cut the tree rapidly.

On the other hand, if we chop poorly, then it’s sometimes above, sometimes below, and the tree never falls. Now when we speak of meditation, it does not necessarily refer to dharma. For instance, someone with powerful powers of concentration will do very well in all mundane studies as well as in dharma. So having engaged in the activities of hearing and thinking of the for instance, we must gain realizations or experience. And the realizations of the past shared with the being of the small scope are something which we can attain in this life.

It’s precisely because they can be attained in this life that we should put effort in them. So, these topics have been covered, here at TBI. And at present, Geshe la is teaching the, greater insight, the presentation of emptiness. Then, during the long October retreat, a ten day retreat, which is being held in September, at the end of, in September. Then, Geshe la will cover all these topics, and ideally, we will try to gain realization of Lam Rim topics.

And if we are unable to do so, we’ll try to engage in an overview meditation, a skorgom of the topics of Lam Rim. You know? Honestly? Okay. First, I have to translate.

So we have studied the totality of the Lam Rim ranging from the beginning, which is reliance on the spiritual teacher, to the end of the Lam Rim, which is the section on special insight or if you prefer, the generation of the wisdom focused on selflessness. But it is not sufficient to just have heard these teachings and for them to reside in one’s book so that when one is not quite sure what one has heard, one needs to check-in one’s book. Instead, one should also endeavor to generate some realization, some experience of this as much as possible. Good god. This is what is needed for So, therefore, during this, ten day retreat, we will have the opportunity to try to generate some realizations of the various topics which have been covered from the beginning, which is reliance on the spiritual teacher all the way up to the end of the Lam Rim, which is special insight.

And then after this next year, Geshe la intends to teach, taking the three kayas on the path as well as tantric grounds and paths as a prelude to understanding how to engage in deity yoga. Then we can engage correctly in deity yoga. Then as for realizations, it is up to us to generate them. It is inappropriate to say to someone you should generate realizations. And as far as the studies are concerned, they will have been completed both sūtra and tantra.

And, therefore, during this Lam Rim retreat in September, we should endeavor not only to be physically in retreat, but also verbally and mentally in retreat. Then it is up to us to engage in this retreat and put effort. If we do not do it, no one will do it for us. Yes. Is it busy?

No. Is it busy? Why? And therefore, we must aim to accumulate experience of the Lam Rim up to and even in the dream state during those ten days. Then for us, it is a sign of laziness that we view this as difficult because we are very fortunate to have the opportunity to engage in, such a retreat for ten days, with near perfect conditions up in the Adelaide Hills, with no noise of any type, perfect conditions for the yogi and the practitioner.

Then instead of ten days, there are real practitioners who engage in retreats for months on end. So, therefore, the experiences arisen from hearing of the and from thinking will have been generated now. The goal is to generate the experiences arisen from meditation. And for this, we must engage in meditation. It is not enough to babble about it.

You understand? Sure. Is he busy? So everything from the reliance on the spiritual teacher all the way to the end of the, which is a special insight, achievable, can be generated. It is just a matter of putting in the work and the effort.

And since you have already received teachings on these topics and have thought about them, then during this ten day retreat, we will endeavor to generate some experiences. And, therefore, one should, with a good motivation of compassion, and bodhicitta, at present, focus on a visualized object to try to generate concentration. This can be a statue of the Buddha or a butter lamp, a lamp for offerings. I think butter lamp is easy, is it? Which one?

What is easier for you? A light. Sorry? Light light for a candle. Light.

Light. Candle. Candle. Candle. Why?

Don’t know my mind. Right. Must have a reason. Because there’s not a lot of thinking involved in focusing on a light. Its shape is stable.

It doesn’t change too much, and it is clear. I’m sorry. Okay. Please. So let us endeavor to meditate a minute.

Please open the prayer book, page one. We recite one b, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, Mandal offering, verse one and three. Page five. Number six. As is said through misunderstanding emptiness, migrators wander in cyclic existence.

Then cyclic existence is difficult to understand. In brief, migrators experience hardship. In other words, it is to misunderstanding the self, which is selfless, that sentient beings experience hardship. This is not physical hardship. The view does not benefit in eliminating physical hardship.

It is mental hardship. So the view of emptiness, the view of selflessness, just as the generation of bodhicitta, compassion, and love are of benefit in dispelling mental suffering. Then if you experience physical suffering, this is of no help. You should go to hospital. They’ll give you a shot or they’ll operate.

Then if we reflect on, the source of the hardship we experience from the moment we rise in the morning until the moment we go to sleep at night, it is actually not lack of food or the basic material necessities which induces mental hardship. Instead, what induces mental hardship, mental suffering is discontentment with the happiness we have. It is this discontentment, this lack of contentment with the happiness we have, which is the source of mental suffering, and this gives rise in turn to powerful self cherishing, powerful egoism. So here’s the issue of self cherishing and self grasping arise. And once one has progressed on the grounds and paths and gained some attainments, then one is able to sense the difference between self cherishing and self grasping experientially.

At present, for us, this is not possible. So this difference has to be understood intellectually. So since we have studied salam, grounds, and paths, you are will be familiar with these concepts. As you remember, self grasping or the apprehension of a self is present both at the levels of the path of accumulation and the path of preparation. It is manifest at those two paths.

It is this ignorance grasping at a self of persons which is the root of all the afflictions which beset us such as desire, anger, jealousy, and so forth. They find their their root in the ignorance grasping at an I. As Chandragomin says in his praise of dependent origination, whatever baseness there is in the world, finds its root in the in ignorance. Now baseness here simply refers to hardship or difficulty. This is a very clear verse.

So when we say that all of the defects within our mind stream arise from the ignorance grasping at itself, and all qualities arise from the wisdom grasping at, selflessness, why precisely is the case? We must investigate what there is about this ignorance which causes us to be. So when we say that all evil, all nastiness arises, from this ignorance grasping at a self, just why precisely is is this the case? Why is this mind not a stable mind? And here, we must investigate how this mind apprehends its object.

Then we don’t need to adhere to distinctions of object, subject, mode of apprehension, and so forth. I, eyes. This ignorance which grasps at a sense at a self, this sense of I, I, exists in a very stable fashion within our mind stream. Is this ignorance grasping at a self, a correct or an incorrect mind? It is an incorrect mistaken mind.

Now how precisely it is incorrect and mistaken will be explained. That

So setting Prasangika Madhyamaka aside, all of these schools of tenets beneath it from Svatāntrika Madhyamaka downwards to Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika teach the existence of two selflessnesses of persons, a coarse selflessness of persons, the person being empty of being permanent one and independent, and a subtle selflessness of persons, the person being empty of being a substantially existent autonomous entity. Are you finding this presentation of coarse and subtle services persons difficult? Is he busy? Yes. Okay.

Really? You’re making Geshe look cough a lot. Yeah. Yeah. Oh, alright.

So the way we shall proceed is that initially, Geshe la will explain clearly the distinction between the coarse and the subtle selflessness of persons in the lowest schools of tenets from Svatāntrika Madhyamaka downwards. And then on this basis, he will explain the selflessness of persons in Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka. Then we will be able to encompass the totality of the from special insight downwards. Just as the lowest schools of tenets present two selflessnesses of persons, the coarse selflessness of persons, the person being empty of being permanent, one and independent, and the subtle surfaces of persons, the person being empty of being a substantially existent autonomous entity, they also present two mistaken apprehensions of person, the person being apprehended as permanent one and independent, and the person being apprehended as a substantially existent autonomous entity. So, Geshe la has been explaining these, two selflessnesses of persons, the coarse and the subtle, on Wednesdays.

And he would encourage you to take careful notes, study your notes, and consult your translator if you have any questions. It will be difficult in the future to get a translator of this caliber. So at present, while he is still here, please consult him. The difficulty in the future. Just be careful.

Listen carefully. Then, if you had learned Tibetan in the future, when the translator is no longer there, you would be able to study it by yourself. But since you haven’t, you would have to rely on English translations, which are mediocre. Since Geshe la feels very strongly from his side that we have excellent translators here. We have excellent conditions to study this.

He brings this up. And therefore, please listen carefully. Take careful notes. Consult your notes. Read.

Think about it. Don’t waste your time, in other words, while we have the opportunity to do so. Don’t be like upside down vases. Be like vases which are upright. You understand the metaphors of the upside down vase, the pierced vase, and the filthy vase.

So this apprehension of the person as a substantially existent autonomous entity, is present within our mind stream and taught by the lower schools of tenets, just how precisely does it apprehend its object. So not now, but when the sense of an I appears powerfully to ourselves, we should examine just how it seems to appear. And it appears from deep within ourselves as the owner, as the possessor of its base of imputation, which are body and mind. And this is what is meant by the term autonomously existent. So this innate apprehension of a self taught by the lower schools of tenets exists within our mental continuum.

When this powerful sense of an I appears within our mind stream, we should investigate its manner of appearance. And we can see that it appears as the owner or the possessor of body and mind without being included within either of them. So this person which appears as the possessor of body and mind without being subsumed with them, within them, is what the lower schools of tenets teach as the autonomous person. That apprehension of the person as such is the apprehension of the person as being autonomous. So how precisely does this eye appear?

This eye appears as if it didn’t depend on anything apart from itself, as if it did not depend on causes, on conditions, on parts, and so forth. And this is the source of all our problems. Just for example. So there are a couple examples for the relationship between this autonomous self, this fantasized autonomous self, and the aggregates. One is that their relation is akin to that of a general in the army.

The army depends on the general, but the general does not depend on the army. The second is that they are akin to the relationship between the master of the merchants and the merchants of which he is the master. Then which of these examples resonates for you? The general has power over the army and the soldiers without the soldiers or the army having any say in the matter. Likewise, this autonomous I is or appears as being the controller or the owner of the aggregates without depending on them in any fashion even though in reality, it does.

Then the Tibetan example which works really well for the Tibetan is the head of the merchant caravan and the merchants. There are no merchant caravans in Australia. So it’s not gonna work for you. So in Tibet, for instance, the head of a merchant’s caravan or the head of the merchants merchants had control of the merchants, but the merchants had no control over him. Then I suggested to Geshe la for Westerners the example of the owner of a company or a factory and the employees.

The owner has control of the employees. He hires or fires whom he wants. The employees have no control over the owner. They must just obey. What other examples could you find?

I guess Geshe la was asking me, what about the prime minister and the Australians? I said it doesn’t work. They can kick him out. They vote. Right?

Dictate issue. Dictate issue? That’s not in Australia. Right? So the example is a general and the army would work in Australia.

So in the example of the general and the army, the general has power, control over the army without himself being one of the foot soldiers. The foot soldiers have no control or power over the general. Now it is exactly in this way that the autonomous I appears in its relationship to its base of imputation, body and mind. It appears as having power or control over the body and mind without being a part of either body and mind. Whereas in reality, this is false.

It exists independence on body and mind. Are you starting to understand this? So if you don’t understand, now’s the time to ask short questions on this. No. Not long enough.

Not too long. Just run that part of Just on this. Okay. That’s okay. You have to sit, please.

So the object of refutation, therefore, in the lower schools of person of tenants is this autonomous person, which is a person which exists without depending in any way on the, body and mind or on the aggregates and has power over them. It is called autonomous because it exists from its own side independently. So here, when we speak of independence or autonomy, the meaning is very similar. Independence or autonomy means that we exist from our own side without depending on anything or anybody else. Then in reality, this is utter and absolute nonsense.

Nothing exists without depending on others or on other entities. And

Hence, this ushers the concept of interdependence. So therefore, Geshe la would like to ask you to investigate within your own minds whether the appearance of such an autonomous self exists or not. And when you realize that this autonomous self is at the root of all of the mental hardship and suffering which we experience, to ask yourselves, is this a correct authentic mind or not? And if it is not a correct mind, if it’s a mistaken inauthentic mind, why is this the case? What is the reason for it?

And therefore, next week, Geshe la will broach the topic of the antidote of this apprehension of the person as substantially existent autonomous entity. And this is precisely the person’s being empty of being a substantially existent autonomous entity. So, Gesheera, I would like to think that today you have understood what the apprehension of the person as autonomous is. And then we would investigate later what the antidote, which is that mind which is directly contradictory to this is. If you have questions, we’ll take two questions.

A few weeks ago, when Geshe was asking us questions about sorry. A few weeks ago when Geshe was asking us questions about plants, he asked for the reference from my assertion that the Buddha taught that, in some searches, that plants are one facultied beings. So I looked it up, and I’ll give it to you in a sec. Then one of them is from the numerical discourses of the Buddha, the Anguttara Nikaya. Can’t hear you very well.

Sorry. I’ll speak louder. One is the numerical discourses of the Buddha, the Anguttara Nikaya, the book of the sixes. It’s part three number three seventy two, and it’s the English translation is page 929. And Buddha relates the ruler, instructed the deity of the royal banyan tree as to the duties of a tree to show that a Brahmin to show a Brahmin that the Brahmin has duties he must do as an ascetic.

And so the deity of the tree asks the ruler Sakya, but how, sir, does a tree follow the duty of a tree? And Sakya, the ruler, replies, here, deity, those who need roots, take roots. Those who need bark, take bark. Those who need flowers, take flowers. And those who need fruit, take fruit.

And then the other reference is from the the Vinayapitaka, and it’s part seven. It’s offense number 267. And the Buddha said, how can you foolish man have a tree cut down that was used as a shrine revered by villages, revered by the kingdom. For foolish man in a tree are people having consciousness. Oh, your cost is very long.

Four minutes. I don’t need. Thank you. So both the examples you give are true and substantiated, neither proves what you say. The first example is drawn from a Sūtra teaching the impermanence of composite phenomena in which Buddha addresses a deity which inhabits a tree and uses a tree as an example.

The second example from the Vinaya Sūtra teaches that monks should not cut trees because these trees are the dwelling of numerous sentient beings. In neither case is the tree or plants being a sentient being taught. Okay. Okay. Second question.

Geshe la, is this the case that when you when when our mind are calm, then we don’t have the sense of I arising. But when you emotionally really strong emotion, then the eye the autonomous eye is there. The way to think about this one is that whether one’s mind is at peace or not isn’t the apprehension of the eye present? If the apprehension of the I is present, then it is blended with this mistaken apprehension. So let’s take the example of when you engage in studies.

Then that motivation which pushes you to study involves the apprehension of an I. Or for instance, when you have been struggling with a difficult concept in the Lam Rim and suddenly you understand it, you feel a feeling of great happiness. Then at that point, isn’t there a feeling of the I involved? In every single case, this feeling of the I is mixed with the feeling of an autonomous I. When you go to sleep Oh, yeah.

When you when you’re asleep and you dream, don’t you have a sense of I? Yeah. Oh, yes. It’s when the sense of the I is eliminated that indeed there is food for thought, but this only begins to happen on the path of preparation. Okay.

Just you. Thank you. I certainly have the feeling in the sense of an I. We’re we’re born with a name, a tax file number. There are things that are mine and then there are things that are yours.

I was listening to great psychiatrist called Nozick on YouTube. He’s a very intelligent man. He was talking about the self or the ego or the psyche, whatever you wanna call it, the soul. And after his life of work, he was commenting on death and saying that he believed that there was an I, a psyche, an ego that that continued on independent of the mind and body and possibly even out of space and time, but that there was a there was a self. You’re saying there is no self.

Is that correct? Yes. Yes. Does not accept the existence of such a such a self. So this self which you are referring to is probably what is meant by the self which is permanent, one, and independent.

This is not accepted in Buddhism. Then when we speak of the body, it is not just the coarse aggregate. There are numerous levels of coarseness and subtleness of the body. Then Andrew seems to believe that persons are permanent and permanent one independent. Then it’s something which is gonna be addressed.

Okay. Yes, Tom. Thank you. Page nine. Eight petal mandala offering.

Key terms in this teaching

grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top