Lam Rim – 2012-09-19 – KR

1 h 31 min · 3,804 words · 19 September 2012

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2012-09-19 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk covers generating a motivation to benefit others on waking and reviewing the day in the evening, with joy or repentance depending on how it went. It explains two kinds of renunciation, one arising from bodily suffering and one from mental suffering, and why the spiritual teacher is seen as the channel for the Buddha’s deeds and blessings. Questions near the end touch on faith and patience.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 31m

UUID: 2b8a467c-12d3-410b-a496-3ab0e91ddb4a

Date: 2012-09-19

Words: 3,800

Garden. Garden Park. Park. What? Park.

Linga. Linga. It is important for us to practice uninterruptedly and continuously without any disruption. And this is specifically an issue regarding the generation of the motivation. Irrespective of whether we generate our motivation upon rising for one minute, two minutes, five or six minutes, depending on whether we are in a hurry to go to work or not.

What is important is that we practice this generation of this motivation of the motivation which is an impelling of the mind every single day. If we defer it and think I will do it tomorrow or in the future, there is a very high risk we will forget to do so. And it is therefore important every day irrespective of the number of hours during which we have to work to fulfill our duties carefully so that at the end of the day we can look back at the day with happiness. Specifically, we should generate at the beginning of the day a strong motivation, an impelling of the mind and this motivation should be a motivation to benefit others, not merely to benefit others in theory, but we should really try to benefit others in actuality. Then at the end of the day, we should recapitulate what we have done during the day looking back.

And if we see that we have behaved in keeping with some motivation, then we should rejoice and generate joy. On the other hand, if we see that we have disregarded or broken with our goals, then we should generate guilt and repentance. In this context, guilt is a very beneficial state of mind. Most of you probably must recite on a daily basis highest yoga tantra commitments, rituals of highest yoga tantra. For this to be meaningful, it is important to generate before reciting the ritual the requisite motivation.

It is very difficult to do so during the recitation. It is therefore before reciting these commitments that one should meditate on love, on compassion, on bodhichitta within the limits of one’s capacities. And then having done so, one recites the commitments. Then they become profoundly meaningful. Likewise, for those who are ordained, it is extraordinary to be able to dedicate one’s life to trying to generate love, compassion and bodhichitta.

In so doing, a human life becomes profoundly meaningful. Then you may have some major doubts regarding the benefits of all of this. And it is clear that if one stays all alone in one’s dwelling and never meets anybody, it is very difficult to see whether there are benefits or not. So for this, it is helpful to go out in society and to meet people. Then when one meets people and one interacts with them and one observes the changes in one’s mental states and one’s behavior, one will become convinced of the benefits.

And when we go in society, we will be relaxed and at ease. Whatever difficulties happens, our minds will be at at peace. Then we will be lucky indeed. Precisely because love, compassion and bodhichitta are rooted in a deep affection for others. This gives rise to a closeness with others and independence on this closeness.

We are at ease with others and narrow mindedness will cease to arise. Narrow mindedness will be dismissed from our minds. It is obvious that if we are obsessed with ourselves and we do not generate these states of mind, then we will suffer greatly from high expectations and disappointed fancies. And this in turn leads us to an obsession with the behavior of others. What are others up to?

Does he have this? Does she have that? What are they up to? This in turn leads to great inner suffering. If we take for instance, this dharma center or this temple, irrespective of how many of us may be present at the teachings, if we generate an affectionate and kindly mind towards each other, envy and competitiveness cannot arise.

In the self same way as in a family, we see that envy and competitiveness do not arise in a loving relationship between parents and children. Instead, both parties try to help each other. We see with his holiness the Dalai Lama whose only thought is for the benefits of beings in this world, human and non human. There can be no place in such a being for envy or competitiveness because his sole preoccupation is the welfare of others. Likewise, if we ourselves are solely preoccupied with the welfare of others, there will be no mental suffering within our mind streams.

Don’t think His Holiness the Dalai Lama is probably a Buddha. We do have to give an example of a Buddha after all. And certainly, there is 100% certainty that he is a Bodhisattva. And how could we ever hope to reach such a level? This is a wrong way to look at it.

Our minds through habituation can eventually become like the minds of his holiness. To be able to generate these three states of mind which are love, compassion and bodhichitta, a vast amount of merit, waves of merit are necessary. Now it is important to understand here how such waves of merit can be generated. Clearly, when we engage as preliminaries in the ethics of abstaining from the 10 non virtues, our main focus is on future lives. The amount of merit which is accrued is important but limited.

However, if we consider the total number of human beings on this planet, which range in, the 7,000,000,000 category and we reflect, on the amount of merit generated by loving thoughts, thoughts of compassion towards these beings, we can see that it will be huge. Generally speaking, we must accumulate simultaneously both collections of merit. The collection of merit and the collection of wisdom. And while the collection of wisdom is accumulated through study, the collection of merit is accumulated through these practices. It is indispensable to generate a fully qualified bodhichitta to generate as a preliminary a fully qualified state of renunciation.

And in this context, you may have the doubt whether having generated renunciation, one is automatically on the path to liberation or not. This is not an illegitimate doubt to have, nor is it a wrong view precisely because one’s motivation is good. In as much as one’s motivation is good in engaging in such analysis, there is nothing wrong and it’s actually beneficial. So you should check for yourselves. Because So you see if we analyze the process of generation of the two renunciations, Initially, we reflect on past and future lives, then on karma and causality and the suffering of the lower realms reflecting after this on death and impermanence.

Then as a result of this, we generate the wish to be reborn in a higher realm. This is what we could call ordinary renunciation, ordinary definite emergence. Then reflecting on higher realms in general and on the general and the specific sufferings of cyclic existence, eventually specific or fully characterized definite emergence arises. The problem, Geshe-la says, is from his standpoint, if he thinks that we reflect, we can see this too, one might think, well after all, once I’m reborn in the higher realms and there is no core suffering, why shouldn’t that be enough? What’s wrong with that?

So the first point therefore is that there is no automaticity in the generation or the transition from ordinary renunciation to fully characterized renunciation. Since one might very well be satisfied with the idea that there is no major suffering in future lives and one’s future lives will be happy. And this probably arises because this is a renunciation rooted in the abandonment of physical or bodily suffering. And therefore this first renunciation is a renunciation which arises from an abandonment of physical or bodily suffering. However, it is only one of two types of renunciation.

The second form of renunciation is a renunciation which arises from an abandonment of mental suffering. Now it is difficult to see how a renunciation which arises from an abandonment of mental suffering could not connect with dharma practice. And this clearly is rooted in an understanding of the suffering nature of all of cyclic existence, both the lower and the higher realms. Now there are multiple presentations of this. Buddha Śākyamūni, for instance, initially presented the Four Noble Truths and then in dependence on the Four Noble Truths presented emptiness.

There are multiple ways to present this. And therefore, one should think about things in this way and think there are really two broad paths involved in the generation of renunciation . And therefore, we shall reflect or meditate for some two minutes. First, on such a renunciation, and secondly on the generation of the motivations of love, of compassion and of bodhichitta to listen to these teachings on Lamrim. So regarding the topic of the dharma which we are considering at present, we have covered both the reason for which it is necessary to see one spiritual teacher as a Buddha and the reason for which it is possible to see him as a Buddha.

And both reasonings and quotes were given. We will now focus on the reasonings. And the first of these reasons is the uncertainty of appearances. We can see based on quotes from Lama Chöpa that this is the case. And in addition, if we take the example of the moon, we can see that wall there is only one moon in the sky of our world.

Nonetheless, multiple moons of various appearances appear in as reflections in pools of water. Likewise, it is said that even though there is in actuality only the Buddha and his mental continuum, nonetheless, for the sake of taming trainees of different constitution and dispositions, the Buddha appears at times as hearers or Shravakas, at times as solitary realizers or Pratyekabuddhas and at times as bodhisattvas. It is said in turn from our own standpoint as ordinary beings that we are unable to perceive the enjoyment bodies of the Buddhas, the Sambhogakayas. We have not had the opportunity to encounter the supreme Nirmānakāya, Buddha Śākyamūni. Then, should the Buddha on the other hand for our benefit appear as an antelope or a stone, we would lack faith in him.

Therefore, for our benefit, he appears in a manner which is commensurate with our perceptions to help us. What is this manner of appearance which is commensurate with our perceptions? It is none other than that of our spiritual teacher. The example which is given in the Lamrim is a bit difficult for you to understand. It’s the example of a traditional Tibetan dance, Cham.

So Geshela will propose an alternative example. Let us imagine a soldier standing in the center of a mirrored hall with four doors and mirrors which reflect him all over the hall. There is, in actuality, only one soldier, but to observers on the outside, there seems to be a multitude of soldiers. Likewise, even though there is only one Buddha, for the sake of beings, he manifests in a multiplicity of forms. This is something Geshe-la fully appreciates.

It’s difficult for a Western audience to accept. It is clear that when Westerners read these passages in the Lamrim, it doesn’t fully connect with their own understanding. One does need faith here and it is something which can only arise through repeated habituation. Therefore, we should read these passages again and again. Geshela will be very blunt and honest with you.

The intended trainees, the intended audience for which the Lamrim, the graduated stages of the path was composed was a Tibetan audience. Tibetans had tremendous faith, extraordinary faith, and it sufficed to rely on that faith to teach them the Lamrim. So this is probably not the case for a Western audience. Therefore, one should proceed very slowly in these matters. And in the case of our spiritual teacher, irrespective of whether he is a Buddha or not, this is something which we have no way of determining.

If we reflect on our reaction, should we encounter Buddha Śākyamūni in actuality, we will see the problem. Let us imagine we encountered Buddha Śākyamūni in actuality. Do we really believe that because of this meeting instantaneously renunciation, bodhichitta and the correct view would arise and increase exponentially within our mind stream? Obviously not. Then as the Buddha said himself, I came to teach you the path to liberation, The path to liberation you must tread yourselves.

Treading the path to liberation refers to practice and that is in our hands. Reflect carefully on this powerful statement of Buddha Śākyamūni, I am my own Lord and protector. Who else could be my Lord and protector? Who else indeed can protect us but ourselves? And it is therefore through our own practice that we eventually protect ourselves.

This is why he is known as the Dalai Lama, in very acute advice, said one must carefully distinguish between the interpretative and the definitive spiritual teacher. The interpretative spiritual teacher is our spiritual teacher as he appears to us, for instance, our Lamrim teacher to give an example. But the definitive spiritual teacher is actually our own mind. Mind is your own guru. You are your own gurus and then through studying carefully, you eventually will be able to stand on your own feet.

This is profoundly rooted in tantra, this presentation of His Holiness of the interpretative and the definitive spiritual teacher. And therefore it is critical for us to understand our spiritual teacher as the performer of the deeds of the Buddha. There is in this respect, a very potent, powerful quotation, which says, the spiritual teacher is akin to a crystal which magnifies the light of the sun. With it, it is possible to burn fabric, to burn cloth. The meaning of this quote is that through the mediation of the spiritual teacher, in the same way as through the mediation of a translator, the deeds of a Buddha can be enacted and can, for instance, just as the rays of the sun, lead to a burn in the surface of a fabric.

However, if we put the fabric in the sun without a magnifying glass, literally in Tibetan they say, a fire crystal, without a crystal to, ignite the fire, then the fabric will never take fire. In the self same way that should Geshela teach in this temple in Tibetan without a translator for two or three hours, there would be no benefit whatsoever to you. Geshela’s teachings are mediated by a Lotzawa, a translator, and it is what the Lotzawa translates which is actually of benefit to you. Likewise, the Buddha’s deeds and blessings, and here Geshe-la feels one can consider them to be broadly speaking synonymous, are mediated by our spiritual teacher. It is actually through our spiritual teacher that we gain access to both these deeds and blessings.

Now regarding the term blessings in Tibetan chinlab, we have two different etymologies. His Holiness the Dalai Lama has said that Chinlab which is composed of two syllables in Tibetan can be understood as follows. The second syllable lap actually refers to the root meaning. And this refers to the enhancement of one’s mental capacity through study. Our teacher, Kensur Rinpoche has given a different but quite similar etymology of the term chinlab blessing, saying that the second syllable lap derives from the Tibetan term labpa, which means large waves.

And in the same way as waves can expand and cover a huge expanse, likewise do blessings. And therefore, Geshela feels that when the spiritual teacher gives an introduction to Lamrim, to the graduated stages of the path, and from one’s own side, one reflects over and again on these teachings and eventually the dawning of an or the glimmer of an understanding arises suddenly within one’s mind. That dawn of an understanding is what is referred to by the term the blessings of the spiritual teacher. Then the term blessing in Tibetan, especially the second syllable is often used to refer to sudden outbursts. Means huge in Tibetan, an eruption of something.

So this eruption of understanding occurs in dependence on the blessings of the spiritual teacher. As Śākyapandita said, it is through the intermediary of the spiritual teacher that the blessings of the Buddha reach us. Here, blessings and deeds can be seen as synonymous. Therefore, faith and conviction in the spiritual teacher are needed. More generally speaking, faith and conviction are slightly different in terms of their meaning in this context.

Faith in the spiritual teacher and conviction in the spiritual teacher are broadly synonymous. For progressing on the spiritual path, both study and faith are necessary. It is difficult to progress on the spiritual path through study alone. Faith also is required. Probably, it is not possible to speak of faith, in this context, for those who do not accept the Buddhist teachings.

One must accept the Buddhist teachings to be considered as someone who has a possibility of faith. Geshele has nothing more to add on this topic today. Then he will take your questions at present if you have any since your questions will provide further for further reflection. There is a finite amount. It is completed actually upon the attainment of full enlightenment.

It is Tibetan term is to go to the to the end or means beyond, to go beyond, which is a term used for perfection. Perfections are to go beyond. From the standpoint of visualization, it is very beneficial for oneself to see and actually it’s necessary for practice to see the mind of one’s spiritual teacher or the mental continuum of one’s spiritual teacher as one with that of Buddha Śākyamūni. However, to say that in actuality, the mental continuum of Buddha Śākyamūni and that of one’s spiritual teacher are identical is difficult. They are two different beings.

And this is why it is taught in Mahāyāna sūtra Lamrim that the spiritual teacher should have 10 qualities. If these 10 qualities cannot be fulfilled, he should have five. If the five cannot be fulfilled, three. If the three cannot be fulfilled in this age of degeneration, then at least his qualities must be superior to his faults. He must be more preoccupied with others than with himself and he must focus more on the future than on the present.

That is a very, very good point. And in this day and age, who could hope to get a spiritual teacher who does not appear to have any thought? As I said in the Lamrim, one should reflect only on the qualities of the spiritual teacher and not on his faults. As a result, the qualities will increase. We know this for ourselves.

We only reflect on our qualities and we see ourselves as totally faultless. It’s great advice because instead of examining others behavior all the time, we should examine our own and then one’s understanding would increase. Another question? The best is every single day when one wakes up to generate this motivation and then to recite whatever rituals or commitments one has to recite or practice. And then live through one’s day and at the end of the day, assess how the day has gone.

And if one has acted in accordance with one’s motivation, then one can rejoice and generate joy. And if one has not acted in accordance with one’s motivation, if one has broken one’s commitments, then one should generate repentance and start the next day all over again. So these are two separate divisions of renunciation. One is a division of renunciation into ordinary and fully characterized renunciation. The other is a division of renunciation, The renunciation which abandons bodily and the renunciation which abandons mental suffering.

They are very different. Because the renunciation which abandons mental suffering, which is perhaps the most important for our society, since we are societies in which mental suffering is very high, is one which can be focused on this life. Whereas ordinary renunciation from within the twofold division of ordinary and special renunciation already thinks of future lives. So these are two different subdivisions of renunciation. Yes, is a very acceptable way to proceed.

So what you say has a strong connection to something, Geshe-la would like to point out, which is that when we talk of faith, we talk of something which actually is not seen, is not heard, is not smelled, is not tasted, is not therefore experienced through the senses nor is it something ascertained by reason. Otherwise, it would not be faith. There’s much to be thought about on faith. So here there is a lot to be said about faith and Geshe-la. Would encourage you to think about it.

Clearly, faith is something which does not arise independence on the five senses, sight, hearing, smell, taste or bodily tactile sensations, nor does it arise independently of reasoning. Then what precisely does faith arise in dependence upon? It arises in dependence clearly on a mental state. And what is the function of faith in addition? Now His Holiness the Dalai Lama explained a threefold subdivision, but Geshe does not remember it right now.

Reflect for instance on the fact that if you take one of your teachers or instructors in matters of this life, in worldly matters, you do not speak of faith in the context of that relationship. Wonderful. Isn’t that exactly? This is not what Geshela is saying at all. He’s not saying you should study less or work less, but instead, when you happen to go to work and you meet people, then you should compare your way of thinking and their way of thinking and your reaction to them and in that context see whether there’s improvement or not.

Therefore, if we never have any contact with others, In Tibetan, we say go out in society, but I think Australians view society in different terms than Tibetans. If we never go out in society, then it is very difficult to know whether we have renunciation or not. So definitely patience is something which can only be practiced when there are at least two. It cannot be practiced in solitude. It can only be practiced when there is someone who disagrees with oneself, who is at odds with oneself.

His Holiness the Dalai Lama has made an extremely interesting point in this matter. He has said patience does not refer to being submissive when you are powerless and don’t have the capacity to do anything. Patience refers to not reacting when you are powerful and fully able to do so but choose not to do so. That is true patience.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
Highest Yoga Tantra Anuttara Yoga Tantra (Skt); la na mä pä gyü (Tib)
The fourth and supreme division of tantric practice, sometimes called Maha-anuttara Yoga Tantra. It consists of the generation and completion stages. Through this practice, one can attain full enlightenment within one lifetime. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
nirmanakaya emanation body; tul ku (Tib)
The emanation body of a buddha that manifests in a variety of forms for sentient beings. LYWA
tantra gyü (Tib)
Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
Yoga Tantra näljor gyi gyü (Tib)
The third of four classes of Buddhist tantra, literally meaning "union" due to the increased emphasis on internal activities compared with the previous two tantras. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top