Lam Rim – 2016-04-20 – KR

1 h 30 min · 3,920 words · 20 April 2016

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2016-04-20 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching says that happiness and suffering come from within the mind, so one should rely on oneself rather than external things, and that friends and enemies are shaped by our own afflictions. It argues that liberation exists because afflictions are adventitious and the mind’s nature is clear light. It then explains great compassion as the root of bodhichitta, followed by student questions on the scopes of the path, coarse and subtle afflictions, and the four immeasurables.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 31m

UUID: 2e864bcc-aa82-443e-bc4e-4a564b629740

Date: 2016-04-20

Words: 3,916

Śāntideva indicates in his Bodhisattva Charyavatara, all living beings without exception, whatever they engage in are trying to attain happiness and trying to eliminate suffering. So therefore, all persons endowed with the mind, in other words all living beings are absolutely identical in wishing for happiness and not wishing for suffering. There is no debate, there is no controversy regarding the fact that all sentient beings wish for happiness, harmonious with themselves and wish to be protected from suffering, disharmonious returns with themselves. Now why is there no debate regarding the fact that all sentient beings, all living beings wish for happiness and do not wish for suffering simply because it is self evident, it is visible. That is the reason for which there is no debate about this.

Then what precisely do we see as the source of happiness none other than exterior physical objects and what do we see as a source of our suffering once again none other than exterior objects. This is not a theoretical position. This is something we can see if we examine within ourselves. This is very easy. We are convinced that, totally convinced that all our happiness comes from the exterior and we are also probably completely convinced that all our suffering comes from the exterior as well.

Now it would be quite remarkable, excellent actually, if you yourselves came to understand that the source of true happiness, of stable happiness is deep within the mind and the elimination of suffering is the elimination of mental suffering. So this is easy to understand, easy to think about and it is something we should reflect upon each day. So we are all identical in wishing for happiness and we are all identical in wishing to avoid suffering. Then where analysis is called for is how precisely we achieve happiness and how precisely we eliminate suffering. You may remember Khensur Rinpoche said many times, establish your own happiness, dispel your own suffering.

So why is this the case? This is not an outlook which arises out of study or reflection. It arises from our condition in this world after birth from the womb of our mother. All physical happiness at that point depends on exterior physical entity. Then all our hopes, all our wishes, all our happiness are invested in the exterior world.

And when exterior events, exterior phenomena do not cooperate, then our minds become deeply saddened, depressed and if we are not careful, we end up facing a profoundly troubled mind, mental problems. Now when this happens, nothing can be done, it’s too late. So it is very difficult for the exterior world to give us 100% of what we want. That’s really it, isn’t it? And therefore, it is important for us not to place all our hopes, all our convictions, all our expectations of happiness on the outside.

For that matter, when we say that the virtuous friend, the spiritual teacher is the foundation of the path, this does not mean that the spiritual teacher can give us realizations. It depends on us. Actually Buddha Śākyamūni said, I teach the path to liberation. I am my own master. I have none other.

Then this is how we should practice. It’s a very profound verse in which Buddha says, I am my own teacher. And it really extends to understanding that others cannot be our enemies. This is very easy, this is very straightforward. It is not something which is difficult to understand.

There are topics in Buddhadharma which do give one a headache, are difficult to understand. Then if you want deep topics, I will explain deep topics. Then what we need is something which is easy to understand, is straightforward, which is understandable. That is the Buddhadharma we need. And therefore when we place all of our wishes, our hopes and our expectations on the outside world, these are the difficulties we face.

So we should not place our expectations, wishes and hopes on the exterior world. Instead we should become the masters of our own minds. Then we can see this happening in the surrounding world all the time. We see those people who have invested 100% of their hopes, wishes and expectations in the outside world and who are bitterly disappointed because the outside world does not satisfy them, trying to commit suicide by cutting their own throats, by ingesting poison and so forth. This is a result of placing all one’s hopes in the outside world.

So it is not the case that one should not rely at all on the physical, the material world. One must rely on the physical and material world but not 100%. Instead, how should one proceed? One should learn to rely upon oneself. Have, place hope in oneself.

So when we say have placed hope in yourself, be convinced in yourselves, why do we say this? We say this because it is a means to generate the self confidence to actualize our own happiness and to eliminate our own suffering. We alone can do this. It is very easy. So therefore, we must be convinced of ourselves.

We must have faith within ourselves or faith of ourselves. And if we do not do this, then who can do it for us? And as a result, our minds will become troubled and disturbed. And the second topic is that of friends and enemies. Everybody without exception is convinced that friends and enemies come from the outside.

Enemies come from the outside and friends as well come from the outside. It is only those of sharp acumen who understand that friends and enemies come from within us. Those who do not have a sharp acumen laugh at this idea that friends and enemies come from within us. It’s something we have to understand, it is really helpful to us. Now if we take the case of enemies whom we see as out there opposing us and we analyze carefully, we can see that this enemy we see out there who is our foe, if we were to talk kindly to him or her, be gentle towards them, over time, this person would change.

In other words, there is no permanent enemy out there against us. In this world, I mean we do have the people who are on our side and we do have the people who aren’t on our side, don’t we? We have the people who contribute to our happiness and the people who contribute to our unhappiness and those who contribute to our unhappiness, we call them enemies, don’t we? But because they are human beings, if we are kind to them, if we are gentle to them, they will become close to us, won’t they? Then the same thing is true for friends.

This is something we all have direct experience of. Both enemies and friends are transitory and impermanent. You may be very close friends with someone but then over time they become great enemies. So if we analyze who is the true enemy, the enemy on the exterior is someone who we can get close to if we are kind with them. They can become friends.

The true enemy are the afflictions within us because the kinder we are with the afflictions, the more powerful they become. And the more powerful they become, the greater their destructive power. And therefore, if we take anger for instance which is one of the afflictions, then anger is a true enemy because the friendlier we become with anger, the harder and more powerful, the more destructive anger becomes. And this is true for all afflictions. On the other hand, an exterior enemy, the closer we become to, the closer he becomes to us and eventually he or she turns into a friend.

Then what we really need is a permanent state of happiness. A state of happiness which will satisfy us durably, not the transitory unsatisfactory state of happiness we experience at present. Now this is something we all say but it is something we actually have to live. So, such a happiness exists and therefore what we need at present is after generating conviction and hope within ourselves to strive for this happiness and not any happiness but a permanent durable happiness. This is called liberation.

Liberation is none other than a liberation which is an extinction of karma and afflictions. Now in Buddhist scriptures, it is taught that there is a durable permanent abandonment of anger and what I would like to ask you is whether from your side you truly believe that such a state exists or not. Now I’ve explained a fair bit here, but the first step is to make one’s mind relaxed and at ease. Then these states will come, not to be narrow minded. Then obviously some will laugh at such an approach.

It does happen but it is important for us to reflect quietly about these topics and it is very important to understand faults as faults, to identify faults as faulty. So does such a stable, durable happiness exist? This happiness is taught to be the extinction of the afflictions. Now the doubt which may arise is if we eliminate all afflictions including anger, do we actually eliminate the mind? Is anything left?

And if we eliminate the mind, we have basically eliminated the person. Well this is a very solid doubt. So it is important for you to give rise to doubts. The more doubts you can generate, the more profound your study and the greater your certitudes. So the doubt therefore is after all liberation is an elimination of the afflictions, an abandonment of the afflictions.

And let us say, if we abandon desire, then there is no longer any desire in the mind. Is the mind left or not? Now this doubt is invalid because there is what is known as the mental consciousness and this is separate from the afflictions. So there is a passage in sūtra which says, the obstructions are adventitious, the nature of the mind is clear light. In other words, the nature of the mind is not to be afflicted.

So let me give you an example to enable you to understand this. Imagine a mountain creek. So at its very inception, the water of the mountain creek is extraordinarily pure. As the creek flows down the sides of the mountains and into the valley, it becomes saturated with sediments and garbage and becomes filthy. But even though it is filthy, there are means to bring it back to its state of pristine purity.

The same thing is true for the mind. It is possible to eliminate the afflictions from the mind. And therefore the afflictions are not mixed with the nature of the mind. They do not enter in the nature of the mind. This is akin to the example.

This is easy to understand, isn’t it? If an affliction, let us say anger was part of the nature of the mind, penetrated the nature of the mind, then we would constantly be angry, wouldn’t it? Then in this room you are probably not angry right now, are you? It is pretty obvious. Then the same thing is true for jealousy and envy.

Jealousy and envy do not enter within the nature of the mind. They are not part of the nature of the mind. At present, when you are listening to these teachings, your mind is relaxed and focused. You are not beset with jealousy or envy. And this is true for all the afflictions.

So on this basis, we can say that probably liberation exists because we need a rationale for studying the Lam Rim. Otherwise, if we’re studying the Lam Rim without believing that liberation exists, then that is stupid. It is irrational behavior. So the topic, the goal of the lamrim is liberation. We must be convinced that liberation exists.

Then clearly, liberation must exist to justify our studies. In the same way that when you see Momo’s on the outside, then there’s a desire to eat those Momo’s arise. If there were no Momo’s out there, the whole process would be silly. So liberation must exist and our efforts are driven towards that. Otherwise, one would enter in an endless cycle of writing texts and reading texts.

Then these teachings are given and you scribble away desperately and then you put your notes down at least I would hope you read them but I’m not quite sure. But I mean that is not how to proceed, you must listen carefully. Then we can see for instance with the definite emergence of the being of the small scope which is a striving for a higher rebirth in future lives. That if we were to ask ourselves, am I sure of attaining this state? Am I sure of attaining a higher rebirth in a future life?

It’s actually quite difficult to answer this with certainty, very difficult. On the other hand, if we take the definite emergence and the liberation of a being of the middling scope, the liberation of a being of the middling scope is a cessation of all afflictions. When we analyze in this way the nature of the mind, if we ask ourselves, can I attain such a state? It seems easier to answer yes, doesn’t it? So we have to ask ourselves, does liberation exist or not?

If it exists, we have to strive for it. Then if one puts sufficient effort, one becomes an Arhat or a foe destroyer, one who has destroyed the afflictions and one attains a state in one life. If one does not attain it in one life, one attains it in several lives, a multiplicity of others. There are numerous types of foe destroyers. But attainment or not attainment depends exclusively on effort and on targeting the afflictions and nothing else.

So Ārya Nāgārjuna in his root verses on Mādhyamika says, the liberation from karma and affliction that is attained through eliminating the causes thereof, which is ignorance and this is attained through meditating on emptiness. And therefore, let us reflect as follows. Let us endeavor to establish to our satisfaction the existence of liberation by means of a valid cognizer and if this is not possible, at the very least, through reasons establish the existence of liberation. For indeed, if liberation did not exist and if the afflictions infused the nature of the mind, then the situation would be very different. However, the afflictions are adventitious, they are occasional, which means they do not infuse the nature of the mind.

Let us therefore meditate for a couple of minutes as I explained on liberation and the rationale for its existence. This is extremely important for us. Thank you, Didi. Please open the prayer book, page one. We recite one b two three four and also page five, number six, Mandal offering, verse one and three.

And therefore, once one has generated an uncontrived mind which wishes for the state of liberation which was described, in other words, an uncontrived renunciation at this point, one will have entered the path of the being of the middling scope and one will gain the realizations of the path of the middling scope. However, at this point, reflecting on the qualities of bodhichitta of great compassion and so forth, one will generate a wish to proceed forwards to the Mahāyāna. Otherwise, one would stay at the level of the Hīnayāna and this is not the goal of the Lamrim. Now, how does one generate bodhichitta? It is taught that the root of bodhichitta is great compassion.

Compassion exists already within our mind stream, but now it must be extended to all sentient beings. When it is extended to all sentient beings, it becomes great compassion and then we feel close to all sentient beings. Now how does one generate great compassion? There are two means to generate it. The first is the mind training involving the interchange of self and others.

And the second are the causal instructions in the sevenfold causal instructions. And we shall stop here today and at present I will take your questions. Have you got few questions? If you want, here. Last week, Geshela, if I understood correctly, you were talking about people doing retreats on emptiness and other topics, but you said that you didn’t know of anyone doing a retreat on bodhichitta.

And that led me to thinking that with the reiteration often through the text of you saying that, you know, reading text is not enough and you need to put it into practise, then how would you put into practice while doing a retreat on bodhichitta if you can’t practice generosity in the other perfections? Nobody attains bodhichitta directly during a retreat. Initially, one must meditate on great compassion. One must meditate on the qualities and the potency of great compassion. And then over time, over a long period of time, eventually this leads to bodhichitta.

Yeah. I would like to ask about, you know, the small scope. We practice on 10 virtuous deed. And I’m thinking if we have a sort of in a small scope teaching on controlling the affliction, you know, anger, desire, and what other thing? Attachment on that, then we will eliminate the 10 non virtues.

You know, like the medium scope a bit of a quick, you know, eliminate the affliction to in the small scope that will eliminate the 10 non virtuous? Can you can I what is your question? I mean, because we we have the small scope, we we say that we have to practice on the eliminating the 10 non virtues. But what I’m talking about is if we know about median scope to eliminate the affliction, that means anger, attachment, and desire, that three component if we can incorporate in a small scope, then we eliminate the 10 non virtues. There is no means to abandon the afflictions at the level of the path of the being of the small scope.

That means is not taught. The means to abandon the afflictions is only taught at the level of the path of the being of the middling scope. That is why the object of abandonment of the path of the being of the small scope is much more circumscribed. It is merely the 10 non-virtuous deeds. Because the means which is taught at the level of the path of the being of middling scope to abandon the afflictions is the wisdom which realizes emptiness.

Now, one should examine for oneself whether this wisdom which realizes emptiness is taught at the level of the path of the being of the small scope or not. Geshela posed a question for us a couple of weeks ago. He said we posit bodhichitta as the criterion for being a Mahāyāna being, but why wouldn’t great compassion be the criterion for being a Mahāyāna practitioner? What difference is there and why? And I wanted to I was thinking is the difference that great compassion is a wish to free all sentient beings from suffering, and bodhichitta is actively engaging in achieving that goal?

So in the context of the Mahāyāna, the generation of the mind of bodhichitta is an aspiration which is aiming for the attainment of full enlightenment. Another? Could Geshela give a precise definition on what is coarse affliction and what is subtle affliction? So the difference is as follows, the coarse afflictions are afflictions whose objects are the five sensory objects, the five exterior physical objects. Whereas the subtle afflictions are afflictions which are focused on form and formless entities.

There is also a difference between coarse and subtle afflictions in terms of their relation to ignorance. So at present we are dwelling in the realm of desire but in Buddhist teachings it is taught that there are two other realms above the realm of desire, the realm of form and the formless realms. Amanda. You were speaking tonight, Geshela, about holding people close and seeing people with equanimity. I was just wondering, I’ve been wondering for a while, in the four immeasurables, what does it mean by you talked tonight about holding people close and about transforming how friends can be transformed to enemies and enemies can be transformed to friends.

And what what does it mean by holding others distant? What’s the meaning of that? That part of the verse? Could you show me the could you show me the Tibetan, please? Thank you.

Holding some close. Thank you. So when we ask to be free from the desire and the hatred which hold some close and others far, what is meant by this is that when we have friends, we view them as close to us. We hold them close to us and as a result of this desire arises towards them. Whereas when we have enemies, we view them or we hold them as distant from us and as a result of this, the anger arises.

Then in the four immeasurables, the immeasurable equanimity, we pray to be freed of this. What would be the motivation of an Arhat to develop bodhichitta? For someone who has attained the state of an Arhat, the attainment of full enlightenment becomes very distant indeed. And therefore it is before one attains that state that one must become repeatedly familiar with the qualities and the advantages of great compassion and of bodhichitta. And then this will act as a seed for that.

And it is said that once one generates great compassion, one severs the vehicle of the Arhat, the chariot of the Arhat and therefore it is extremely important for us to be aware at present of the qualities of great compassion and try to generate it. Another, two, double, Maggie and second, Monica. Geshela, tonight you said we should be questioning does such a state of durable happiness exist if we eliminate all afflictions such as anger? We were asking all these questions whether liberation exists. Mhmm.

And then you said it is important to generate doubt. The more doubt you generate, the more profound the realization is. Can you explain this relationship between the solid doubt and the profoundness? So when one reflects on the existence or non existence of liberation and strong doubts arise, at this point, the only way to clear these doubts is intense study. And this intense study is of tremendous benefit to us on the path.

Monica? Just in relation to the previous question, I just wanted to ask then if, when you develop great compassion at the level or is it at when you’re developing you develop great compassion at the level of a definite emergent, uncontrived definite emergent, is that combination then where one becomes a bodhisattva That’s a good question. At that point one will not have become a bodhisattva but one is very close to becoming one. So regarding Valonso’s question on the distinction between coarse and subtle afflictions, it is said that all the afflictions taught by the schools of tenants from Svatantika Mādhyamika downwards are coarse afflictions and that subtle afflictions are only taught by the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika School. They are the result of the subtle ignorance which is propounded in the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika School.

This is a difficult topic. And just one question, have you got? Why don’t we stop here for tonight?

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
four immeasurables caturapramana (Skt); tsä mä zhi (Tib)
Also known as the four immeasurable thoughts or the four sublime attitudes, these are four states of mind or aspirations: loving kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy and equanimity. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top