2 h 10 min · 8,502 words · 20 June 2012
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Teaching introduces Śāntideva’s Way of the Bodhisattva, focusing on the sixth chapter on patience. It explains that bodhichitta grows from extending ordinary love and compassion to all beings, and that anger and self-cherishing are the main obstacles, with patience as their antidote. A closing question-and-answer exchange suggests observing anger in daily situations.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 2h 10m
UUID: 4fae8845-3e40-4f41-912e-4b69d8c17f68
Date: 2012-06-20
Words: 8,498
So tonight we begin the teachings on Śāntideva’s text, the way of the bodhisattva or as we often have known it in other translations you’ll see that as guide to the bodhisattva’s way of life or a guide to the practice of the Bodhisattva is probably a little bit closer to what the title actually implies. The chapter that we are concentrating on is the chapter on patience. Now as we sit here tonight, we understand that each one of us we have a wish as practicing Buddhists to attain the state of Buddhahood. And we understand that in terms of cultivating the qualities that enable us to progress in our development. We need to engage in study and practice and that we need to come to a broader and fuller understanding of what it really means to bring benefit to other living beings which is of course the driving motivation of striving for perfect enlightenment.
So when we talk about this desire to bring benefit to all sentient beings, every sentient being without exception. Of course we need to ask ourselves how exactly is it that we about achieving, understanding and then achieving such an aim. Of course, the best possible way to cultivate a mind that is capable of bringing perfect benefit to all living beings is to cultivate the mind of enlightenment of bodhichitta. And what we need to do is to study its nature and the way in which we are able to cultivate it within ourselves. And this is what brings us here tonight.
And so in order for us to be able to cultivate an understanding of bodhichitta and to understand the nature of the benefit that we are able to bring to other beings, text such that this has been composed. And it’s on the basis of the understanding that we derive from this study that enables us to not only understand, the nature of bodhichitta but also the nature of the benefit that we’re able to bring to all other sentient beings. All sentient beings who wish to be conjoined, who wish to enjoy without interruption happiness. So when we understand what bodhichitta is, we understand that it comes about on the basis of a cause. As all things come about in the nature of cause and effect, bodhichitta itself also comes about in dependence upon a cause, a specific cause.
And the cause that we identify is love and compassion. This loving kindness and compassion is the root cause of what results ultimately in bodhichitta. So when we talk about the loving kindness and compassion that is the cause of bodhichitta, we can see within ourselves and the people that we know and say in general that all people are able to express loving kindness and compassion. In some form or another, most people at some stages within their life will express loving kindness and compassion. But this common, if we call it the common loving kindness and compassion does not act as the basis, does not act as the cause for generating and attaining bodhichitta.
So even though we are able to experience loving kindness and compassion and extend that towards other living beings, the nature of the way that we do it in general in our normal lives is not suitable to be the basis for creating bodhichitta. And the reason for that is that the loving kindness and the compassion that we are able to generate within our day to day lives is usually directed to specific targets or specific objects. And they are into objects that fulfil certain criteria for us. We are able to cultivate loving kindness and compassion towards them. So the difference between the common loving kindness and compassion and the loving kindness and compassion that acts as the cause to attain bodhichitta is that it is a loving kindness and compassion that is directed to all sentient beings.
Every single sentient being without exception. And it is not conditioned upon a certain kind of relationship between us and the object of our loving kindness and compassion. We therefore we have the seed, the potential. We have a knowledge of an experiential knowledge of some kind of loving kindness and compassion. And now our task is to be able to elevate that, is to be able to expand and make more extensive the scope of our loving kindness.
Make it less dependent on specific causes within our close connections. To make it that that loving kindness is able to be extended without moderation and without exception to every sentient living being. At that point then the loving kindness and compassion that we are generating becomes the cause for bodhichitta. So we must understand that our focus is on a skill that we already possess in some form And it is a process whereby we are extending, we are expanding, we are super sizing that loving kindness and compassion that we all know and have experienced. So we understand that loving kindness and compassion go together and they have contained within this expression of comparatively simple expression of words a vast and important meaning that is associated with what it is to express loving kindness and what it is to express compassion.
And in general we say that love is wishing for happiness and compassion is wishing for one to be completely separated from the causes of suffering. So when we look around living beings that surround us and the sentient beings of sentient beings that exist in the world. We understand that each one of these sentient beings has their own unique preferences and tastes and dispositions. And some people might find certain kinds of happiness or comfort from certain kinds of foods, certain kinds of styles. There are many we can see superficially the kinds of things that bring happiness to people and that how and that the way that their individual disposition directs them towards different kinds of things to satisfy that desire to be happy.
But if we look deeper into it and look beyond and look beyond the the simple objects at which they seek to be, close to in order to be happy, we can see that what is actually driving them is this desire to be happy and this desire to be separated from the things that cause them to suffer. And so even though the dispositions of people are very different, their tastes are very different. If we pair this back we can see that what is in common to all sentient beings, all sentient beings deep down we can see that it boils down to them wanting to be happy and not wanting to suffer. And this is why when we come to understand what is loving kindness and what is compassion, we understand that there’s a lot to think about and there’s a lot to understand when it comes to their real meaning. So when we talk about the kind of love and when we talk about loving kindness and compassion especially love and compassion that we direct towards people in the world.
It’s quite easy for us to look at people who we can see are quite clearly suffering. People who are hungry, people who are destitute, people who are extremely ill, people who have few or if any resources. And it’s not all that hard for us to cultivate a feeling of loving kindness and compassion towards these people. It’s obvious that we will generate those feelings towards such people who are suffering. But it’s not quite so obvious to us that we should be generating loving kindness and compassion to people who live with abundance of wealth and who have every comfort and who enjoy let’s say good health, easy life and have few or if any material concerns or cares.
But in the process of us trying to understand how it is that we can expand and make our ability to express loving kindness and compassion on a much more expansive way. It comes we’re able to look at these people who are not immediately deserving of compassion. Understand that if we are to analyse more deeply than superficial appearances, there is more likely than not suffering that exists within their lives no different to anyone else. And suffering can be very relative between different groups of people depending on what they’ve become habituated to. What we’re trying to do is generate loving kindness and compassion to every sentient beings.
We’re trying to engage in a process that enables us to build up from being very limited in the number of people we will direct love and compassion or people or living beings that we direct love and compassion to. And we’re trying to expand that to every sentient beings. And one process in which we can engage to work towards this goal is that we can be mindful not to limit our loving and compassion, loving kindness and compassion merely to the people who have obvious sufferings. But understand that even people who have no obvious sufferings at all still possess deep down within them a desire to be happy, a dislike of suffering and are therefore warranted, are worthy of having our loving kindness and compassion directed towards them. So when we talk about loving kindness and compassion, it’s important to remember that this isn’t a creation or an invention of religion or a purely religious phenomena and specifically Buddhist phenomena.
That as long as living beings have existed there’s been people feeling loving kindness and feeling compassion towards certain people or certain beings within their lives. Even before the time of the Buddha two two and a half thousand years before there were still people who were experiencing loving kindness who were expressing loving kindness. There are people who were expressing compassion. So the fact that this exists as a trait that is common to all of us that has been going on has been enduring throughout all time. It’s not something that is merely being created by a religious tradition.
And so if we think about the nature of loving kindness and compassion and the way that it’s existed in the world, it is something that we could analyse and think about quite deeply with our own thinking and investigation. So the distinction we draw though is that when it comes to the practice of Buddhism, the loving kindness we’ve already established is something that everyone throughout all time have been able to experience and generate towards others. And that is not something that is specific to Buddhism or any other religion. However when we come to Buddhist practice there is a difference between the way we go about understanding, investigating and cultivating loving kindness and compassion. And the main difference is that within the Buddhist tradition you find that this idea of attaining happiness is combined with a belief system with a structure that is that combines to create an elevated or a more refined and sophisticated state of mind or ability for awareness.
So within Buddhism we see that we have this desire for happiness conjoined with a belief system with a structure that enables us to engage in the practices that make our happiness develop and become stronger and more enduring. So within the Buddhist system it’s conjoined with elements that we learn about the nature of past and future lives of cause and effect, the four noble truths and the state of Buddhahood and the ability to attain the state of Buddhahood. So we are using loving kindness and compassion not just not in their more primal way that they are experienced or expressed by people. But in a very sophisticated way whereby this desire for happiness is conjoined with the belief system and techniques and structures and means by which to accomplish other things. And the things that we’re able to accomplish are the realizations that lead all the way to the attainment of Buddhahood.
And so if we trace back in a historical sense that though there would have been loving kindness and compassion expressed before the time of Buddha, was on the basis of the Buddha’s teachings that we’ve been able to see the expression of loving kindness and compassion incorporated into a belief system that has as its principal goal an enduring happiness. And that it has a structure that is attached to it that enables us to pass through various techniques, stages of development all the way up to attaining Buddhahood. So this is the distinction that we can see between the loving kindness that is expressed has always been expressed through all time and the loving kindness that we are now referring to within the context of a Buddhist teaching. So when it comes to, within specifically Buddhist training, our understanding of loving kindness and compassion is something that involves not relying on a simple instinctive feeling or response. It’s something that necessitates a great deal of investigation, of exploration, of study, of practice, which involves of course listening to teachings and thinking carefully and clearly over the things that are heard and investigating further within one’s own practice.
So this is the reason that we tonight in this time that is Geshela prepares us to do our to set our motivation before the teachings that we have spent more time than usual almost half an hour has been spent tonight trying to establish the theme that we are focusing on for these teachings. So that the motivation that you set will be much stronger and more sincere. The reason for this is that loving kindness and compassion are vitally important for us to be able to make any progress within the Buddhist path and to attain any of our hopes and aspirations to bring benefit to other living beings. And that our understanding of what is meant by loving kindness and compassion within the context of generating bodhichitta and bringing benefit to other living beings is what we are trying to is what we’re compelling ourselves to seek an understanding of. And when we set it as we set our motivation now for the next couple of minutes we can sit in meditation and set our motivation.
It’s Geshela’s hope that this longer than usual introduction to the topic gives you a sense of the importance of loving kindness and compassion to practice and the need you must have to set a very strong and determined motivation to explore its meaning to its best possible outcome. So we can do two minutes now, a couple of minutes now of meditating, cultivating this motivation within our mind. So we begin now we turn our directions towards the text, the practices of the bodhisattva and we know that it is composed by Śāntideva And there are 10 chapters that make up the body of the text. And of these 10 chapters, the chapter that we will be focusing on is the sixth chapter, which is the chapter on patience. We should keep in our mind that this text, the text The Way of the Bodhisattva’s Practice is a text that is of one of the greatest texts ever composed on this topic of bodhichittah.
It is a text that is famous not only for the content of the text itself but because of also of the qualities of the person who composed the texts. So in terms of our understanding of bodhichitta, it is hard to imagine that we would find a more superior text to this one that gives a better exposition, an experiential exposition on the nature of the practises of a bodhisattva and the cultivation of bodhichitta. So for these two reasons it is a profoundly important text. And it is also important that we understand the qualities of the author of the text and have an appropriate reverence for Śāntideva himself and his ability to compose such a text. And just as a footnote to that, the text itself within Tibetan is of course considered to be, in the manner of its writing and its poetic qualities, to far exceed anything that we see translated into the English.
So the qualities that Sanskrit readers and Tibetan readers derive from the text of hearing such complex and profound instructions put into such concise language is not something that we derive from the various English translations that we’re able to read. So Shandideva himself was an Indian Buddhist monk. He was born according to this text, he was born and lived for about seventy years. So he had a relatively short life by our expectations. He lived for fifty years and he lived what we can count back to being about thirteen hundred years ago.
And he lived in Northern India. And as a young man, he was someone who was greatly influenced by, was as a young man, he showed great potential and was greatly influenced by the appearance of a Mañjuśrī in his meditations. So those of us who have some understanding of the history of Buddhism in India will know of Nālānda Monastery and of the great Buddhist practitioners and scholars who built up Nālānda Monastery in Northern India. Nālānda Monastery was one of the most famous places in India at the time, remembering that India around this period, it was a golden age of intellectual exploration into Buddhism. And the greatest minds of the time directed their energies towards this exploration of Buddhism.
And Nālānda Monastery was where some of the greatest scholars of the time lived. And it was to Nālānda that Śāntideva went to live after he There’s a long and complex history that we could, that we can read about Ashantideva. But to say in brief, we can say that he was the son of a King. He was intended to take over as a young prince to take over the duties of his father within the kingdom. He had a vision of Mañjuśrī just before he was to take the throne.
And an awareness arose within him that he should devote himself to Buddhism rather than to worldly affairs. And he went about stages of his life in training and practice before he arrived at Nālānda. Now when he arrived at Nālānda then he was in the company of a very large number of monks and also scholars and lay people, but great scholars, great practitioners and people who were very driven to excel in a highly competitive environment. But when Shandideva first took residence at Nālānda, he gave very little sign that he was in any way had any talent or disposition towards understanding let alone practising anything of Buddhism. And the people around him grew tired of the fact that all he ever seemed to do was eat, go to the toilet, sleep.
And that was about all that Śāntideva was known for. That he would just eat, sleep, and the greatest effort he would put into anything would be to the bathroom. That would be it. And otherwise, he just devoted himself to what they believed was doing nothing at all. And as it was a very competitive and a very intense learning environment, It began to rub a lot of people up the wrong way that this person should be seemingly be so disrespectful to the price position he had to be a student at Nālānda.
And people began to plot ways that they could actually try and expel him from Nālānda. Unfortunately for them there wasn’t anything that Shandideva was doing that was in any way illegal or broke any laws of Nālānda community. So he wasn’t able to be expelled for any reason. They therefore had to contrive a reason and they tried to look for ways that they could discredit Śāntideva and have him expelled from Nālānda. So the people who were keen on seeing the end of Shandideva decided that they should, given that he wasn’t actually breaking any rules and there was no legitimate reason to expel him.
They contrived a, new practice which was that people should be able to compose a sūtra and be able to recite that to the other students. And, if you read historical accounts of Nālānda or see archaeological sites, you can see that there was a courtyard. They had a courtyard there, a large area where people would sit outside and there was the opportunity for someone to take a seat and present something to the rest of the community who could debate or argue or listen whatever the program was. So these people decided well given that all that he does is eat and sleep. What we’ll do, we’ll get into, we’ll start this tradition where you have to compose a sūtra and then we’ll all be able to do it because we all study so hard and we’re all very diligent.
But he just sits and sleeps. He’s going to get when it’s his turn to do it. He’s going to get shown up and he will be humiliated and fought before us to leave Nālānda. So that was their plan. So when it was time for Nālānda, for Shandideva to come and give his presentation, of course they set up a throne for him to have to sit on as someone had to sit up when they were the person to be delivering their oritation.
And so if Geshela is saying there is probably people among us who have been to India and have been to Nālānda. And otherwise there may be people who are planning to go to India or have a mind to go to India. And Nālānda is a place that is near Bodh Gaya. It’s a place that is extremely important to visit if you’re able to. And if you do go there, you’re able to see the remnants, the archaeological remnants of the courtyard and the throne where these events took place.
And the throne that they built for, Śāntideva to give his oration was actually, very, very high, almost ridiculously high, because of their own, motivation was of course to humiliate him. So first of all, they constructed for him a ridiculously high throne to sit on. Now their cunning plan, of course, was that they built this very high throne that would have no means of getting up to the seat which would be the first way that they would sort to humiliate Śāntideva. But of course Śāntideva went to the back of the throne and was able to ascend almost instantaneously to the top. And the people who had been the main ringleaders of who had been contriving this scenario to humiliate Śāntideva began to be somewhat doubtful of what was coming and what was about to happen because of Śāntideva’s ability to ascend to the top of this throne so quickly and so easily.
They couldn’t understand how someone so slothful as Śāntideva could suddenly all of a sudden spring to the top of this very, very high throne. So when they constructed this throne for Śāntideva to ascend, he was at first the intention was that he would be ridiculed by not being able to get to the top of the throne. Of course he was able to. And then once he got to the top of the throne then he was the request was made. He stated what kind of thing should I say to you?
I’ve no experience in doing this before. Should I say something long or should I say something short? What is it that I should present to you today? Should I do something short or long or something in the middle? And this is the bit people responded to Shanti Davis.
This was the first thing Śāntideva said and this is what people responded to. And so he urged them to listen carefully to what it was that he was about to elaborate upon. And so when Ben Shandideva sat sitting on the throne was able to without referring to anything in front of him was able to recite from memory what we know as The Way of the Bodhisattva’s Practice. And it was expressed with such incredible poetic and lyric force combined with such obviously intense and profound understanding of them every aspect of the path, the Buddhist teachings. That of course people were incredibly awestruck by what Śāntideva was at, what was coming out of Śāntideva’s mouth.
Of course they had no expectation whatsoever that he would be able to say anything of value whatsoever. We remember in fact he was being set up for a fall. The whole reason that this scenario was constructed was to see him be humiliated. And yet when he took his seat, this practitioner who everyone believed was the lowest of the low and the laziest of the lazy was able to recite from heart this extremely profound and in-depth text on the nature of bodhichitta and in fact the entire path of Buddhism. Now at that time there were people within the audience who had the ability to reme had amazing powers of memorisation.
So you remember at this time a lot of texts were memorised and when someone gave a teaching like that, the way that that teaching was passed on was by people, certain people who had the unique skill to have what a memory as such a perfect memory that they were able to hear a text and then recite it later on. And that’s how texts have been come into have later been transcribed and into the Canon of Buddhist writings. While there were people listening to Śāntideva amazed by what he was saying and trying to commit everything they heard to memory. Now there became some, later there became some disquiet amongst the people who had memorised these what Śāntideva had said. That they weren’t certain just exactly how much, how long the text had gone for.
Because as some stories relate that Śāntideva ascended into the sky as he was reciting towards the end of the text. So amongst the people whose job it was to memorise what was being said weren’t able to agree on how many chapters there were in the text. At the time most people thought that there were only nine chapters in the text. And others had a suspicion that there was a tenth chapter. And so after Śāntideva had left Nālānda and returned to life as wandering as a, he gave up the appearance of a monk and he just wandered around India like he was a destitute person.
He wandered around doing good deeds for people going into meditation retreats and went down to the South Of India. And it became known that he was in the South Of India and people went to find him to try and get him to elaborate for them just exactly how long the text was. And he referred to certain points within text of where the text was going to start and finish. And it was by these people seeking out Shandideva that they were able to finally come to an agreement on what actually constituted the entire text. So there were two monks who went in search of Śāntideva to be able to finally get from him an authority on just how long the text went for and how many chapters were in it.
And it was these two monks who were able to track him down after many travels to be able to track him down say to him that they had attempted to record the text as best as possible. But there had been disagreement between how many chapters there were and if Śāntideva could give them an explanation as of the ending of the text. Okay. So it was because of the work of the combination of the efforts of three monks who were able to put into, we suspect that the time it would have been into Sanskrit who are able to put a definitive recording of the text into writing. And it is of course to them that we must be most indebted that they were able to not only make this trip to transcribe the talk, but also be able to track down Śāntideva to beget told precisely the number of chapters and where it ended and how it ended.
It was because of these efforts of these three that we’re able to enjoy coming down to us first into Sanskrit, then into Tibetan and then coming into English that we were able to have the privilege of being able to read this very famous. And when say famous, it is hard to, I mean, lots of texts are called famous texts, But of the famous texts, this is one of the most famous texts because not only as we’ve described the way it was composed, the way it was presented and the kind of person who was able to do it. And again remembering as a translator’s footnote that it was its qualities within this original Sanskrit that set it above and beyond anything else that had been written on Buddhism up until the time. So did Śāntideva have the right idea? The story goes on that afterwards, after he had left Nālānda and returned to living in various parts of India.
Mostly he resided in the South Of India. So the story of a kingdom within this is at the time when there are many kingdoms all around India was divided up into various kingdoms. And there was a kingdom in which there was to be a debate between different sects to decide what belief system would dominate within this kingdom. And on one side there was a non Buddhist school and the other side there was a Buddhist school. And this was constructed by a king within his kingdom to see how a debate would play out in order for him to decide what should prevail within kingdom.
So the monks preparing for this, preparing for this debate, they tried to seek out Shandideva in order to have his assistance in preparing and executing the debate so that they would be successful. And eventually they tracked him down and they asked him to come and give assistance to them so that Buddhism would prevail within this kingdom so that they would be successful in the debate. And Śāntideva agreed that he would come and participate in the debate. But first he made some conditions that first they should organise, make special preparations for him related to preparing certain cloths and vase and fire in terms of, in a way that Śāntideva required for him to be able to come and give his assistance to the debate. So in the night they made preparations in an area for this to take place and everything was a place was cleared and things were spread out.
And people, of course, wondered what was going to take place and things were going to unfold. And preparations were made for them to begin the debate and to see what influence Śāntideva was going to be to the Buddhists who were trying so desperately to prepare and succeed in this debate. So when they, all the preparations were made and there were all the kinds of ritual implements that related to the way in which this debate was to be conducted were laid out. There were certain things put in each of the directions in which these are the things that Śāntideva specified that had to be in place. And of course the people from non-Buddhist side of course had their reasons for their that supported their arguments and they were able to present them in a way that they thought was the most powerful and strongest and convincing.
And of course then Śāntideva came and Śāntideva was able to simply by his manifestation was able to have this most amazing influence on the people involved in the debate and of course the king and the kingdom. And so because of what unfolded in front, because of this unfolding in front of the King and his court and seeing the way that Shandideva was able to manifest in front of this audience and have such a convincing victory over the non Buddhist. It was eventually it came about that all the non Buddhist came over to the side of Buddhism and all their structures and belongings and monasteries that were set up all came over to the side of Buddhism. And so there it is significant that this entire kingdom then was able to be turned towards Buddhism because of the nature of Śāntideva and his ability to affect people through his presence and his teaching. So this is a very brief explanation of some of the key features of Śāntideva’s biography of course, but biography of teachers is something that’s very important within the Tibetan tradition.
So that you will be able to find things that cover about the life and times of Śāntideva and Geshela encourages you to find them and to read them because it’s quite beneficial to read these things because Śāntideva was such an exalted being. It’s very important that you can get whatever understanding you can of his life works. So now if we come to talk about trying to become a good person and be a person who is able to use their mind well, to be kind hearted and to have a good and stable mind. What is it that interferes with us being able to continually maintain such a steady and virtuous state of mind? Well the things that undermine our ability to be able to maintain a mind, a kind hearted, a mind motivated by kind hearted intentions.
The thing that sabotages us is the mental, other mental afflictions. And of course, when we come to understand the mental afflictions, we see that anger and desirous attachment are some of the fiercest mental afflictions that can undermine our ability to continually maintain this kind hearted state of mind. So even though there are times when we’re able to manifest this good hearted, kind hearted state of mind that beneficial for oneself and others. Even though we’re able to do it periodically, we’re not able to sustain it. And we’re not able to sustain it because it is being undermined by certain afflictions.
And we need to find an antidote for those afflictions to in order for us to be able to better maintain our better state, our good states of mind. So we are looking for antidotes to the mental afflictions. And here we come to the practice of patience and the power that patience has to act as a extremely powerful antidote to the things that sabotage our mind. So we understand that like all living beings we have a mind and that when it comes to our mind being if we try to investigate whether our mind is a good mind or a mind that is other than a good mind, it is the mental afflictions which determine or corrupt a good mind. So it is important for us to find out the nature of this corruption.
What is it that is causing this corruption? How is it unfolding? What are the parts that come together in this process of corruption that weakens our ability to sustain a good mind? Of course with amongst the mental afflictions, anger and desirous attachment and we see stem from have as their root self cherishing. And that self cherishing is the most damaging aspect because it lays at the root of these other mental afflictions.
And Śāntideva through his teachings in the practises of the Bodhisattva is able to explain to us and offer training in the manner in which that we are able to cultivate the antidotes to self cherishing. And antidotes to self cherishing will of course have this effect. This effect whereby one’s self cherishing is overcome, the mental afflictions are weakened. So this is the great power of Śāntideva’s text is that at its core it enables us to eliminate self cherishing. So Geshela it urges us to listen very carefully to everything that is contained within Śāntideva teachings and the explanations that we receive on it because of the power of the text.
We’ve already understood by listening to the history of the text how profound it is and how in such high esteem this text is held. That is very important that we listen to it very carefully and understand all the points that Śāntideva is making because of the benefit it will have to our minds. And Geshela quotes from a verse that is in chapter four There’s a verse in chapter four that the English says enemies such as craving and hatred are without arms, legs and so on. They are neither courageous nor wise. How is it that they have enslaved me?
So normally when we identify a threat to a near and immediate threat to ourselves, we might imagine that we see an enemy or a dangerous person that coming at us brandishing sword, brandishing a knife, brandishing a weapon or being very frightening us with their appearance and threatening behaviour. And it is quite clear and evident to us that they’re a danger to us. We can see very clearly visually when someone comes at us with a knife that they are dangerous to us and they represent a clear and dangerous threat to our well-being. And when we were in such a situation, we would act immediately to defend ourselves and protect ourselves. And unfortunately, the enemies as referred to in this verse that Geshela recited before.
The greatest enemy that we have an enemy more powerful, more dangerous than someone brandishing a knife and attacking us. An enemy more dangerous than this is the enemies of desirous attachment, anger and self cherishing. And the quote from Śāntideva says, what a pity it is when anger, desirous attachment and self cherishing arise in our mind. We don’t have the same instinctive response to defend and protect ourselves the way that we do when we see someone about to attack us with a knife. What a pity it is because it is far more damaging to us than any damage that someone with a physical form could do to us.
And yet instinctively we respond to the one with great fear and would try to protect ourselves immediately. But we just lack that ability to instinctively alert ourselves to the need to protect our minds from the effects of desirous attachment, anger and self cherishing. And this is the point of this quote that we should begin to identify that which enemy, is that which is the greatest danger to our mind. So it’s very important, it’s extremely important that we should investigate very carefully the nature of anger. Think very deeply and think wildly within your experience and what you see in the world around you of the effects of anger.
And understand just how potent a danger it is in terms of destabilising our mind and creating unhappiness and suffering. Now if we very carefully and with a great effort investigate into the nature of anger, We can begin to see the kinds of behaviour anger compels us to engage in. It’s impossible to imagine that we could pick up a gun and fire it at someone while we were sitting in a very relaxed state of mind in comfort and in peace. A gun could be put in front of us and it would be absolutely impossible for us to imagine that we could ever use it against anyone And yet once anger is let loose in our minds, then of course it’s nothing at all for someone to pick up a gun and fire it at someone. And so what is the cause there?
Cause is anger because in each situation the gun was there and in a clear contented state of mind that idea of using it is abhorrent. And yet once anger has completely destabilized our mind. Our ability to make decisions are so corrupted that we engage in all manner of unwholesome unhelpful and destructive behaviours. So it’s at this level that we must understand the effect that anger is having on us. Investigate what anger does to our mind once we allow anger to arise and to abide in our mind.
Investigate what kind of behaviours follow after we’ve let anger loose within our minds. This is very important for us to investigate. So again, is again Geshela stresses that if from reading Śāntideva’s texts, we are encouraged to make this investigation of anger. That anger can be so powerful, so insidious that it can transform a person that they would go from being within a person who believes themselves incapable of causing harm to others being capable of committing murder. It’s not the gun that causes it.
It’s not, it is but anger that transforms mind. Destabilises the mind, corrupts the mind, and compels us into all manner of behaviours that in a normal calm, relaxed, clear mind we would never imagine ourselves capable of performing. But that is the power of anger that it is able to completely transform the way we think and the way we behave. And again, this stresses again, Śāntideva compels us to make this investigation of the power of anger. So if we are able to understand the dramatic effect that anger has over our mind, it’s important that we are able to make an investigation that will produce that from which an investigation from which we are able to derive an antidote for anger.
We’re able to find something that will be as potent in diminishing anger as anger is itself in causing us for our mind to become corrupted. And through the text we’re able to see that Śāntideva posits that it is patience. It is patience that is the cure, the cure all, the perfect antidote for anger. So first within these two things we understand that the problem is anger and the antidote is patience. And this is what we can explore through this section of his text.
So now we’re delving into chapter six, the perfection of patience. And Śāntideva brings up the topic of anger and explains to us that anger, there are two kinds of anger in terms of its power of destruction. There is the anger that destroys all good conduct. So whatever kind of good deeds that we’ve been able to cultivate within our mind and whatever propensities for acting, thinking and behaving habituating ourselves to thinking and behaving well. Even single moments of anger are able to corrupt this propensity that we have built up to continually behave in a virtuous way.
So even though we might spend a great deal of time performing virtuous deeds such as giving and the other making offerings and doing other activities as we learn within dharma practice. Even if we feel that we’re able to cultivate a consistent practice that is benefiting our mind habituating ourselves to behaving virtuously. Even a single moment of that is able to destroy all of that effort that’s been put into creating a new because what we’re trying to do is create an instinctive response to the world whereby we are virtuous. While we do virtuous things instinctively. And yet anger, if we allow anger to explode within our minds, what we’re doing is we’re destroying our capability to maintain this constant focus, this direction towards continually performing virtuous deeds.
And the other anger that is talked about here is that anger that is if it is directed towards an anger directed towards a bodhisattva. Well, is the damaging effect of that anger is that it would destroy eons of virtuous merit that has been accumulated throughout eons and eons and countless lifetimes would all be destroyed if we would have just a moment of anger towards bodhisattva. So there we can see the two kinds of anger. The anger that is towards a bodhisattva which is the most worst possible kind of anger imaginable and has the worst possible effect in terms of erasing any virtuous store of merit we have. And then there is just the normal anger that arrives in the course of our days and how that anger there has the power to destroy whatever pattern or habituated behaviour we have been able to establish that is directed towards behaving, thinking and behaving virtuously.
And when we understand the way in which anger is a from on the basis of anger, the hatred and jealousy arise. And that therefore when we seek to find an antidote to these things, We’re able to identify the specific antidote to anger that because by diminishing anger, by diminishing anger we’re able therefore by consequence to diminish hatred and jealousy. States of minds that are very hard that won’t arise if we’re able to eliminate all propensity for anger from our minds. So anger is the most profound way to damage our virtue and the anger directed towards just normal people in our lives has the power to destroy one kind of virtue that exists for us. But anger that’s directed towards a bodhisattva or exalted highly realized beings.
Well, causes infinitely more destruction to the virtuous merit we may have accumulated in the past. So by this we should understand now that there is no misdeed worse than anger because of the power that it has to diminish all virtuous activities that we’ve engaged in in the past. And also the fact that anger will give rise to other mental afflictions such as hatred and jealousy. So understanding this, understanding the power that hatred has to do such destruction to our immediate well-being and our long-term well-being and our progress on the path. And we very carefully have to identify the most powerful possible antidote we can to make sure that anger in no way disrupts anger in no way disrupts our practice and diminishes our practice.
And Śāntideva makes clear that the most powerful antidote to anger and therefore by consequence to all the effects of anger that unfold through the mental afflictions within our mind, the most powerful antidote is patience. And understanding the special qualities of what’s being talked about when the word patience is used is very important. That we know the word but we must understand quite carefully what is being expressed through the word patience in the context of this text and what patience really means. So tonight we have introduced the text that we’re studying as something of the history of Śāntideva and an introduction to the beginning of this chapter six text. And Geshela would like to know is it clear?
Have you understood with some clarity what we’re trying to express tonight? Yes, yes, yes. Good. Good, good. Thank you.
Thank you. Thank you. You’re so really important. Maybe. And then one question, just one question.
In short. It belongs to the vast. Generally speaking, it belongs to the vast. But because specific chapters within the text deal with because certain chapters deal with specific things such as on wisdom and calm abiding. These chapters relate to the profound.
Geshela said it was it’s a good question because a text such as this can see that component parts belong to each. Some sections you can say belong to the vast and other belong to the profound. Now probably four minutes free. So just one question. Very, very easy because So I really guess I was suggesting that a good way to investigate anger in our daily lives is to think very clearly about and possibly put ourselves in the presence of our worst enemy.
And watch your mind at the time of how when you, as you move away from being in a situation where you’re not surrounded by an enemy to being close and impacted upon by an enemy. And that’s the time when you can most see how your thinking slightly changes. How your perspective on things will change when your enemy is very powerfully in your mind. And then analyse yourself, your feelings, the thoughts, the subsequent thoughts that arise in your mind after you hold the image and the threat of your enemy very clearly in your own mind. And that’s a way you can investigate the changes that come about within your psychological state on dependence of anger that you would have towards an enemy.
So there are two ways that you can do that in the sense of observing the way that you react when it’s a person who is in your face and making you feel very unhappy. And so when such a when you’re in a moment of conflict with a person to investigate them how you feel and what arises in your mind. And then the other way of the investigation is then to hold in your mind imagining the enemy. So there’s two ways that you can do it. One is to put yourself in a situation where someone is confronting you, where they themselves are causing distress towards you.
That’s a situation of conflict and you can investigate how your mind is working when you’re in that moment of conflict. And the other way you can do it is by reflecting upon within your mind generating image of an enemy and seeing how your mind changes its equilibrium and what thoughts and behaviours occur to your mind from doing it that way. So they’re the two ways that you could investigate the effect anger can have upon you just in the course of our normal day, normal work. I think Geshela is saying at first you experience it to just observe and investigate what changes and what effect it is having. And then that’s part of an investigation.
So Geshela wasn’t referring to implying antidotes or anything like that. He was just referring to making an observation of the effect it has on you. And that’s the first step to investigate the simple effect it has. And then from that point on, then you can continue to make exploration into the nature of the effects of anger. Geshela suggests that in the moment that you’re able to observe anger having arisen in your mind, it’s likely that you will be able to trace it back to a preceding sense of desirous attachment and some kind of confounding influence to your desires within this drive of desirous attachment.
So this is one of the first things you probably will be able to see in investigating anger in a situation that preceding it there has been some confounding towards your desires.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.