1 h 7 min · 3,400 words · 12 April 2016
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a Lam Rim session explaining the definition of a path as a sapience upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. The talk distinguishes definite emergence (liberation or the truth of cessation) from the thought of renunciation, and explains uncontrived (spontaneous, unfabricated) renunciation and how the path begins with wisdom of the Four Noble Truths. A question and answer session follows.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 8m
UUID: 4e472ec4-9384-4382-8f4f-d030460dca0c
Date: 2016-04-12
Words: 3,396
So last time we gave a commentary of the definition of a path. As you remember, a path is a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. Now this definition can be subdivided into three parts. An uncontrived definite emergence, upheld by uncontrived definite emergence, and a sapience which is upheld by uncontrived definite emergence. Now if you understand these three components, then we are on solid grounds.
So at present we must endeavor to understand the meaning of this definition which with its three components, renunciation, a sort of uncontrived renunciation and a sapience which is upheld by a sort of uncontrived renunciation. Then I shall not enter into a lot of details on this. There’ll be some basic explanations followed by question and answers followed by discussion by pairs of two. So the first component of the definition is definite emergence. Now definite emergence is a concept we are familiar with from the three principles of the path.
Definite emergence, the mind of enlightenment or bodhichitta and the correct view. However here, there is food for thought because it is not merely definite emergence which is mentioned but an uncontrived sort of definite emergence. Now in the context of these three principles of the path, when reference is made to renunciation, what is actually to be understood is the thought of renunciation. Renunciation itself refers to liberation or the noble truth of cessation. The thought of renunciation refers to striving for liberation and it is clear in the three principles of the past that this is the meaning of renunciation in the light of the stanza which reads, when striving day and night for liberation without for one instant yearning for the marvels of psychic existence, one will be said to have attained uncontrived renunciation.
Then the reason I give this commentary is because if you reflect carefully by yourselves, you might wonder why references made to renunciation since renunciation definitely emergence refers to the noble truth of cessation or to liberation and what the distinction is with the thought of definite emergence. And if we think of the three principles of the past, sometimes one feels a bit odd. Many people who don’t think at all never find anything strange. I I think Tenzin is a bit odd. And no problem.
And you can ask questions from Tenzin. Wisdom of the path in these three principles of the path. And in the two verses, upon generating day and night, the mind striving for liberation, definite emergence will have been well generated. Definite emergence will have been well generated refers to the generation of uncontrived definite emergence. Do you understand?
Now there is no need to enter into great detail regarding the reasons for which definitive emergence refers to liberation or to the noble truth of cessation. You will note that in the 16 characteristics of the four noble truths, each of the four noble truths has four characteristics as you know. If you take the third noble truth, the noble truth of cessation, the four characteristics of this fourth, this third noble truth are cessation, peace, sublimeness and definite emergence. So it is clear that definite emergence refers to the third noble truth of cessation. Then when you leave this class to return home, I would suggest that you look up the 16 characteristics of the four noble truths and specifically the fourth characteristic, the last characteristic of the third noble truth, noble truth association and you will find that this fourth characteristic is definite Now, these four characteristics of the noble truth of cessation all are the truth of cessation.
Now there is some debate about this. We will not enter into the debates here. They are too advanced but one debates along the lines. It follows that the characteristic of the noble truth of suffering, suffering is necessarily the noble truth of suffering because the characteristics of the truth of cessation aren’t necessarily the truth of cessation. These are complicated debates, but what matters is that the fourth characteristic of the noble truth of cessation, which is definite emergence, is the truth of cessation and here definite emergence refers to the state one attains, in other words, liberation.
So within the three divisions of the definition, definite emergence, a sort of uncontrived definite emergence and a sapience upheld by a sort of uncontrived definite emergence, we have covered definite emergence. So this is for renunciation which as was explained is none other than liberation or the noble truth of cessation. Now the second component of the definition, an uncontrived thought of renunciation. Here a thought of renunciation refers precisely to that mind which is striving for liberation. And when we say uncontrived, we mean that this mind is unfabricated.
It does not call for any effort to generate it. It is spontaneous. And here the two verses from the three principles of the path are most explicit. When yearning for the marvels of psychic existence does not arise, And day and night, the mind striving for liberation occurs at that point, un contrived, at that point excuse me, renunciation will have been wholly developed. Wholly developed here means uncontrived renunciation has arisen.
Then please read the translation of the three principles of the path in English. We have numerous translations. The words are very sharp. Now what precisely do we mean by uncontrived renunciation? Let us take an example.
Probably there is not a single person among us who when he or she wakes up in the morning does not automatically go to the kitchen and start thinking about preparing breakfast. This is not something which calls for any effort or any particular thought. It is an automatism. Now it may or may not be different for supper depending on whether you’re accustomed to heavy suppers, but I think everyone automatically takes breakfast. We have therefore an uncontrived aspiration to take breakfast.
When definite emergence arises in the same way spontaneously, we have generated uncontrived definite emergence. Then this is what is meant by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. Now in our case, occasionally definite emergence arises within our mind stream. Occasionally renunciation arises within our mind stream. This is not the definite emergence or the renunciation referred to in the three principles of the past because it is sporadic, it is occasional.
Now regarding the methods for explaining the striving for liberation, I would say there are probably two. The first relies on scripture and relies on an explanation of the qualities, the potency and the characteristics of the mind striving for liberation. Then there is another way to proceed which is taught in Jetsungpa’s Concise Realization, the concise lamrim in the verses which read without striving at understanding the faults of the truth of suffering, how is it possible to generate the mind striving for liberation? And here through understanding the faults of the noble truth of suffering and specifically of our contaminated aggregates, the wish to be freed from it is generated. So one proceeds in this context to initially reflecting on the thoughts of psychic existence and generating a profound sadness at the thought of being in psychic existence And then in turn this gives rise to the wish to be freed from psychic existence.
This is the mind striving for liberation. As Maitreya says in Uttaratantra, the disease is to be known. Here, the disease refers to the noble truth of suffering and in this context we are in the situation of someone who wakes up one morning with an extremely acute stomachache and goes to the doctor, feeling all along as if a wound, an ulcer had opened in his stomach. And the doctor after examination says, you will have to take medicine regularly for one month and if you do so, you will be healed. If you don’t, risk to die.
At this point clearly we will do precisely what the doctor recommends us to do, won’t we? And finally, the third topic of the definition of a path, a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived sort of definite emergence. This when it is generated, intimates that we have entered the path. Now, as you remember the definition of a path is the sapience which is upheld by a sort of uncontrived renunciation. The sort of uncontrived renunciation has been explained.
What remains to be explained is a sapience which is upheld by this. Why is the term sapience which is upheld by this and specifically what is the meaning here of sapience or Kempa in Tibetan. This is best understood through seeing that after generating a thought of definite emergence, which is uncontrived, We then reflect on the two first noble truths. Noble truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering, which in summarized form of the two truths and in developed forms are the 12 limbs of dependent origination in the forward sequence. And reflecting on this, we then generate a very strong wish to attain the object of attainment which enables us to be free from this which is none other than liberation.
When this is generated, we have entered the path. So having generated definite emergence, we then wish to understand the means to attain liberation. And these means are none other than the Four Noble Truths. Reflecting on the Four Noble Truths, we understand that the root of cyclic existence is none other than ignorance. And having understood this, we try to find the means to put an end to ignorance.
The valid cognizer which ascertains this, which ascertains the object of attainment and the means to put an end to it, this is called a sapience in the honorific. Do you understand? So therefore please reflect on the three subdivisions of the definition of a path. The first is definite emergence. The second is a sort of uncontrived definite emergence.
And the third is a sapience which is upheld by a sort of uncontrived definite emergence. Now you might wonder in this definition, what is the meaning of upheld? When we say a sapience which is upheld by a sort of uncontrived definite emergence. Upheld here refers to the motivation which underlies the sapience. This motivation is a motivation of renunciation or definite emergence.
As a result of this motivation, all the roots of virtue which are accumulated become causes for the attainment of liberation. It’s not the case in general that all roots of virtue are the causes for the attainment of liberation. Only those which are upheld by a motivation of definite emergence. And at this point, the motivation of definite emergence fortifies the power of the roots and the power of the roots of virtue in turn eventually fortifies the motivation and they move upwards in parallel. Then now during the meditation period, I would like us to meditate on the definition of a path, a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence.
I have explained all of the elements of this definition to you. Now, I would like to ask you to reflect on the three components of the definition before meditating on the meaning of the definition and if you do this your understanding will be sound. And after this, we will meditate for a couple of minutes and a bit after we will have questions and answers. Three four. And page five, number six month of offering, verse one and three.
So once a path has been generated within one’s mind stream, in other words, a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. At that point, one will have entered the path and within the paths, one will have entered the first of the five paths, which is known as the path of accumulation. Then we should not enter into the distinction between the paths of hearers, solitary realizers or bodhisattvas at this point. We will explain the path of accumulation next week. So, now please answer.
What is the meaning of a path? Quick, quick, quickly. Okay. Can you answer? You answer?
The meaning of path. Then others had recited it so it’s not difficult for you. So I’ll take your questions at present, then please make your questions short and one question per person so everyone has a possibility to express themselves. Actually. I’m just finding it a bit difficult to understand that the thought talking about the thought that this the path is a sapience upheld by a thought of uncontrived definite emergence?
Because it seems to me that if you’re once you’ve entered the path, it’s a series of thoughts that continues on. So it’s like or a series of minds rather than just a mind because Geshela mentioned before that sometimes we can have an uncontrived thought of definite emergence or renunciation, but it’s not an uncontrived one, a contrived thought of definite emergence. So that can be a thought, but that seems to be a single thought compared to the mind that is on the path. There are numerous thoughts, numerous substances within the mind of a being who has entered the path. Every single one of them is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence.
So, it is of particular importance to realize that sapience in this definition refers specifically to an understanding of the Noble Truths, the aspect of the Four Noble Truths which is to be appropriated and the aspect which is to be rejected. That is not to say that all paths refer to the Four Noble Truths, there are numerous other aspects such as generosity, the practice of giving and whatnot. Although there was no necessary entailment that the practice of giving should necessarily be a practice on the path. But the key here is that paths are intimately linked to the Four Noble Truths. Yeah.
Nele. After having entered the path but prior to liberation, it follows that there would be afflictions because the afflictions have not been abandoned. And it seems possible to me that some afflictions would be incompatible with a sapience which is upheld by uncontrived definite emergence and also that some sensations such as extreme pain could also be incompatible. And so therefore one could fall off the path or exit path. Indeed, there are afflictions and suffering within the minds of being who have entered the path.
Obstructions and difficulties do arise. This however is or can in no way turn them away from the path since a being who has entered the path by definition has generated an uncontrived mind of definite emergence. Therefore, when suffering arises, this suffering is turned into virtue by one being taken on the path. I’m just seeking clarity of what Geshela said this evening in terms of the reference to uncontrived definite emergence that constitutes a short form of uncontrived thought of definitive emergence. The it is not a short form for thought of uncontrived definite emergence.
But in the context of an uncontrived thought of definite emergence, it represents a spontaneous thought, not a continuous necessarily, a continuous thought, but a regular spontaneous thought. It is not a it does not amount to the cessation that comprises one of the four characteristics of cessation. Can you summarize your question, Richard? Yes, it is not, what I’m saying is that in referring to uncontrived definite emergence, it is not short form for a thought of uncontrived definite emergence. It is a short form for uncontrived thought of definite emergence, which is not the same thing.
That’s my understanding. There’s no difference between uncontrived renunciation and an uncontrived thought of renunciation. Exactly, but there is a difference between that and thought of uncontrived renunciation or thought of uncontrived definite emergence. There is a difference. Excuse me.
Is a In English there is a difference. There’s already clear difference between an uncontrived thought of definite emergence and a thought of uncontrived definite emergence. What’s the difference? Can you tell me? Yes.
The uncontrived thought is not the final result that is being striven for, which is a cessation of the afflictions, liberation. So it is a it is on the way towards the attainment of that. So an uncontrived thought is this spontaneous thought which is leading towards, striving towards the that attainment. It is not an occasional thought. It is a spontaneous thought.
It’s one which will arise, but it is not the total cessation that arises from deaf which is the same as definite emergence. Can I make myself your advocate, please? Richard, can I make myself your advocate? I think I understand what you’re saying. Confusion seems to arise from the fact that we distinguish between definite emergence and the sort of definite emergence, but as a shortcut when speaking in the context of the three principles of the path, when we speak of definite emergence, we mean the sort of definite emergence.
In reality, to be technical and precise, definite emergence is liberation or the truth of cessation and the sort of definite emergence is the motivation striving for liberation. There can be an uncontrived sort of definite emergence. It does not make sense to speak of an uncontrived definite emergence if is precise and technical. So you should imitate Richard and ask questions on definite emergence, uncontrived definite emergence and the thought of definite emergence. These are the sharp questions.
Your questions are floating all over the place. Sorry. Those questions are really helpful. They’re helpful for me as well. The other questions, they do not address the crux of the problem.
Then? Yeah and then another question. Then there is a lot of food for thought in upheld by uncontrived renunciation. Yeah. Wallace.
When we speak of that definite emergence is the prerequisite of bodhichitta in which level of, in which level of wisdom it is. The level of wisdom that is generated by thinking, by reflection, or by meditation. I think it’s by the it’s at a level of meditation. Yes, in my opinion it is at the level of wisdom arisen from meditation. Because obviously when we refer to wisdom arisen from meditation, this relies on wisdom arisen from thinking and from hearing as prerequisites.
Then here, uncontrived renunciation means renunciation which is unfabricated, is spontaneous. And Nada? Could I do a follow-up? Sorry, could I do a follow-up question? Okay.
Then in my own study and practice, could I could I do the in a in following sequence such as following the long range from guru devotions, small scope, medium scope, large scope. I do it in one sequence and then repeat it over and over again. This is the kind of study habit I have in my science and engineering study. I like to do an overview first and then go into topics deeper and deeper. If you have time, it is best not to do an overview meditation but to meditate on one given topic of Lamrim until you gain an experience and then move to the next topic.
Overview meditations are only when we don’t have time. For the transcribers. It’s a floaty question. Can Geshe-la give us an example of a situation where one would have uncontrived renunciation? Where one would have?
So uncontrived definite emergence refers to an uncontrived wish for liberation. These two are one and the same. And when we say uncontrived, we mean that it is totally unfabricated, spontaneous. It It calls for no effort whatsoever from our side. This is something we do not have at present.
At present, we do experience instance of renunciation or definite emergence, but these are contrived. They are fabricated through meditation. Now the best example would be for uncontrived definite emergence when we rise in the morning. We have a natural wish to have breakfast without any particular reflection on the topic. It is spontaneous.
Okay. Then at present, we have the discussion session by pairs if possible. If the two involved don’t understand enough, then bring a third party who understands something. And the topic of discussion is the three subdivisions of the definition of a path. A sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived sort of definite emergence.
One, definite emergence. Two uncontrived definite emergence, and three, a sapience upheld by a sort of uncontrived definite emergence. Okay.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Can you give an example of a situation where one would have uncontrived renunciation?
Uncontrived definite emergence (renunciation) is an uncontrived wish for liberation; the two terms mean the same thing. "Uncontrived" means totally unfabricated and spontaneous, calling for no effort at all. We do not have this at present. The renunciation we do experience now is contrived, fabricated through meditation. The best example of the uncontrived kind is rising in the morning and naturally wanting breakfast, without any particular reflection on the matter. That wish is spontaneous, and uncontrived renunciation is meant to be just as spontaneous.