1 h 24 min · 3,423 words · 19 March 2014
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching begins by stressing a powerful, meaningful motivation for studying the Lamrim, aimed at future lives as well as this one. It then covers the precious human rebirth of leisure and endowment, the need to accept karma and causality, and how to use this rebirth through ethics, generosity and dharma-focused living. A question and answer session follows.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 24m
UUID: 4a7682d4-a59e-4ca9-a923-2f98bcedc6ac
Date: 2014-03-19
Words: 3,419
I’m a And initially, one should generate the motivation, not in a casual way, but carefully since a specific motivation is so important. Whether something becomes or not the Mahāyāna, whether it becomes or not a cause for liberation, whether it becomes or not the cause for the attainment of higher status in a future life depends on a weighty and powerful motivation. And therefore, for this short period of time tonight, which we dedicated to the Lamrim, we should resolve that this will become a meaningful pursuit. And what is meant by meaningful here? What is meant is that we shall not study the Lamrim, the graduated stages of the path exclusively for this life, but we shall study it for future lives and beyond, and we should generate a powerful and stable motivation for this.
And therefore, the presence of the app or the absence of a powerful and clear motivation is something we can ascertain through examining that motivation. If the motivation is single pointedly focused on the Lamrim and it is not distracted to anything else, then indeed this is a powerful motivation which will bring forth good results. If on the other hand, we just stay in the temple, but our mind is a thousand miles away, then we would have truly wasted our time. What would you like? Lame kale.
Oh, come on. Give us. Pardon? Really? We spoke last time of the issue of the existence or nonexistence of a self which was permanent, one and independent.
Now, while these are elegant and seemingly profound words, in and of themselves, they have little meaning. It is really for ourselves from our own side to investigate whether or not such an entity exists within ourselves. Then the self which is permanent, one and independent is an object of negation. This may sound somewhat dizzying to you, but you should basically proceed slowly and study the various books which are available in English on the topic. They’re also called Buddhists, which accept the existence of a self which is permanent, one and independent.
They are for that matter practitioners who in fact accept the existence of such a self. To this day, there are great Indian scholars who accept the existence of such a self. Then the topic of the object of refutation, the self which is permanent, one and unitary, permanent, unitary and independent occurs later on in the Lamrim. I just wanted to allude to it a little bit. From the standpoint of Buddhist scriptures, there is no such as a self or an Ātman, which is permanent, unitary and independent.
If we were to take the case of Lotsawa, your translator, then for him to be a self which is permanent one and unitary, He would have to be Lotsawa and to be permanent as well. If Ilya is indeed a person who is or a self who is permanent one and independent, then since the name Ilya is imputed on Ilya’s aggregates, this would have the unfortunate consequence that those aggregates on which the name Ilya is imputed would become permanent as well, which they are not. Should this be the case, we would see the problems which would arise since for instance, we say that independence on part of the physical aggregates of Ilya eating, Ilya eats, independence on part of the physical aggregates of Ilya walking, Ilya walks, and independence on part of the physical aggregates of Ilya sleeping, Ilya sleeps. Now this ilea which is permanent, one and independent does not exist. What does exist, however, is a mere imputation on the basis of the aggregates.
We can therefore see the inner contradiction in the tenets of those who assert that Ilya is a permanent entity while acknowledging that his aggregates are impermanent. Since they are asserting that a permanent entity can be imputed on the basis of an impermanent basis of imputation. This is the reason for which the Buddhist schools of tenets refute the existence of a self which is permanent, unitary, and independent? Do I understand? Little bit?
Or all understand? This is quite difficult, but it’s not something one can understand at once. Quietly, quietly, over and again. Let me set this topic aside. Now regarding the issue of wrong views within the eight freedoms of the eight leisures and the 10 endowments.
It is a critically important topic as it is said in many works that wrong views are the foremost obstacle to practice. It is critically important for a being who wants to practice dharma to accept or endorse 100% the existence of past and future lives in karma and causality. However, here we are not speaking of mere verbal assessment to these concepts. There is a great difference between verbal assessment and what is felt deep down within the person. It is what is felt deep down which counts.
Now it is not the case that someone who has wrong views cannot study Buddhist topics and cannot benefit from them. Such a person can both study and benefit from them. Such a person can definitely study the generation of bodhichitta, the four immeasurables, immeasurable love, immeasurable compassion, immeasurable joy and immeasurable equanimity and benefit greatly from them. For instance, the practice of the interchange of self and others, the four immeasurables, immeasurable joy immeasurable love, excuse me, compassion, joy and equanimity actually reflect the actual state of affairs of beings and phenomena. Such studies are greatly beneficial.
Where do wrong views involving the non acceptance of past and future lives and the non acceptance of karma and causality place an obstacle to practice. They place a tremendous obstacle to the practice of abstaining from non virtuous deeds, from sinful deeds. Since someone who deep down does not believe in past and future lives and does not believe in karma and causality, will be unable to abstain from non virtuous deeds and engage in virtuous deeds, in other words, will be unable to engage in a pure practice because he or she does not believe at all in the consequences of this for future lives. To engage in such practice, one must accept that through engaging in virtuous deeds, one will experience happiness and through engaging in non virtuous deeds, one will experience suffering. A person, however, who subscribes to the aforementioned wrong views is somebody who will only accept what he or she can see, hear, smell, taste and touch, and nothing else, and therefore is unable to engage in such practice.
Then within the two fold subdivision of valid cognizers in Buddhist treatises into direct valid cognizers and inferential valid cognizers, such a person accepts direct valid cognizers, pratyakṣa pramāna, but does not accept inferential valid cognizers. This is why it is said in the Bodhisattva Charyavatara by Śāntideva, put this servant your body to work and pay him merely his salary. Just as when one puts a servant to work and has to pay him a salary, one should put one’s own body to work. And the following verses refer to the fact that one should not entrust oneself or have complete faith in one’s aggregates or one’s body. So, this refers to the basis of leisure and endowment.
Yesterday, we talked in the context of this physical base of leisure and endowment of the difference between an animal and a human rebirth. And I pointed out that both human beings and animals strive for physical happiness and ask what is the difference, the human difference, which enables us to say that the human rebirth is exceptionally superior. Now clearly from the standpoint of dharma, such a physical base in its supreme usage enables us to attain full enlightenment, in a middling usage enables us to attain liberation, and in the minimal meaningful usage enables us to attain a higher status in future lives. What do we mean by dharma practice here? Recitations alone are not dharma practice.
Study alone is not dharma practice. What would the dharma practice of Lamrim be? There is dharma practice of lamrim when it impacts our mind. If you think really carefully and honestly about this, it is quite strange. Let us take a week which starts on Monday.
Then, we get up Monday morning, we have breakfast. Then after breakfast we go to work. Then we have lunch, then after lunch we work in the afternoon, then we have supper, then we watch television, then we’re tired and we go to sleep. Tuesday starts, we do exactly the same thing. So we work from Monday to Tuesday every day of the week in this circle, leaving this circle, and there is really no improvement whatsoever.
Isn’t that so? Then the months are the same as the days, the years are the same as the months. This is what is called Samsāra, isn’t it? Then let me give you an example. Imagine someone who is placed in a box, and he walks from one end of the box to the other end and back.
Back and forth, all day, hour after hour. If we were observing him, we would think this is very strange behavior. How precisely is our behavior different from that? Think for yourselves. Then Geshe was asking me if you’d understand the example.
In Tibet, they used to use animals of labor to plow fields, and they would be yoked in a pair. Then once one is yoked and starts walking, the Tibetan say, it’s walking as if it’s going straight to the mountains, because it never stops. It just keeps walking in a straight line. Then this will impact you if you think about it and then you will think how poor our situation is, how strange it is. Then it is very good to think in these terms and one will then wonder, how can I make this human life meaningful?
How can I give it some meaning? Then if one engages in a dharma practice of this nature, one will start by making sure one does no harm in this life and will live in respect and harmony with one’s family members. Then, by extension, one will live in harmony with the state and the rules of the land, and there is a good chance that at the time of one’s death, one’s death will be peaceful without fear. Actual dharma practice occurs with renunciation. Then we shall be talking of renunciation in a couple of courses.
And this topic of the human rebirth of leisure and endowment, which we shall cover for two teachings, is not a particularly difficult topic. We have already covered the identification of a precious human rebirth and the meaningfulness of this rebirth both contingent and ultimate. At present, I would like to cover the presentation of the meaningfulness of this rebirth through examples, and this is subdivided in three. Such a rebirth is meaningful in terms of its causes, meaningful from the standpoint of the examples given, and meaningful from the standpoint of its nature. When we speak of the three means of understanding the rarity of such a precious human rebirth, it is to impel us to take its essence in this life and not merely to try to obtain such a rebirth yet again in one’s future lives.
So don’t think like the Chinaman who was attending a teaching by a Mongolian teacher and who said to the teacher at the end of the teaching, you really have no life experience whatsoever. There are millions of people in China. To which the Mongolian lama answered, this is not the case at all. I was not referring to human rebirth, but to human rebirth of leisure and endowment. So once one excludes those who are mentally impaired, physically impaired or who lack any one of the leasures and the endowments, few indeed people with precious human rebirths are left.
The foremost causes for the attainment of a human rebirth of leisure and endowment in future lives are the combination of pure ethics and stainless prayers. Stainless prayers refer to prayers which are not contaminated with the mundanities of this life, but focus on welfare and future lives. Then in addition to protecting an ethics, which is an abandonment of the 10 non-virtues, one must engage in the practices of generosity and forbearance. If one does not practice generosity, one risks to be reborn as a pauper, whereas if one does not practice forbearance, one’s body will be afflicted. Someone who were to take a vase made of gold, fill it with filth and cast it away on the assumption that he would get another one when he needed it would be called an imbecile in our societies.
This is a situation of those who have a precious human rebirth, do not use it and expect to get another one. Then there is a lovely example regarding this. There was once upon a time a man from Tang, which is a very arid area of Tibet, who had come to Lhasa, through which there’s a large river, the the Kyi Chu. And for the first time in his life, he ate fish. He had never probably experienced this.
And, he stuffed himself to the gills, and then felt ready to vomit. But, he thought, it would be such a tragedy if after eating this delicious fish, I vomited and caught diarrhea. So this is the attitude we should have. A very good metaphor for our situation is that of somebody who is progressively pushing a huge boulder up a cliff. His goal is to push the boulder all the way up to the top of the cliff, and that must be the goal he keeps in mind.
But it may not be possible for the time being. Then at the very least, he must prevent the boulder from falling back down the side of the mountain, because then he will have to start all over again. And therefore, this must be our goal. At the very least, we must obtain another rebirth like this one in the next life and continue incrementally our progress upwards. Because for ourselves, frequently, when we are taught about full enlightenment or liberation, these are quite intimidating prospects.
One must practice for three countless eons to attain full enlightenment. Liberation is difficult, but at the very least, we must obtain a precious human rebirth, a physical basis of leisure and endowment in the next life, and continue step by step incrementally to progress upwards. Then if we strive to obtain such a physical base of leisure and endowment on our next lives, in this life we will be at ease and at death, our death will be easy. Tonight? We shall stop here for tonight.
Any question? What a painter. Last week Geshela instructed to study the foundation of all good qualities and in the second verse of that it says to extract the essence and Geshela spoke of that again during tonight to extract the essence from this life. What does that mean to extract the essence? The meaning of extracting the essence of a human rebirth of leisure and endowment is never to allow one’s mind to be distracted to the affairs of this life and continually to focus it on dharma.
Then one will have extracted the essence of this human rebirth. Good, thank you. That’s a good way of thinking, thank you. Today I attended a funeral of a 41 year old man and I don’t believe that he had any thoughts towards the dharma? I know we dedicate any merit that we obtain to all sentient beings so when a person hasn’t had an interest or been led to the dharma what can we do?
It’s not I haven’t really put that very well earlier. Sorry. I catch the drift, yes. Thank you. Ordinary beings such as us, irrespective of whether they are religious or not, will spend up to seven days in the intermediate state in the Bardo.
Then it is said that the prayers which are uttered for them during this period are help. Just going back to the section where Geshela was talking about abstaining from non virtuous deeds and developing virtuous deeds is not possible if one does not believe in past and future lives and karma and causality, talked about the fact that people who don’t have that belief can only believe in things that they can see and touch and hear and that are in front of them. I just wanted to check earlier because I wrote down those people could be valid cognisers only with direct and valid cognition. They only accept what? They only accept direct valid cognition.
Oh, only accept it, right, okay. In, we don’t see, taste, hear, or feel. We trust authorities to do that for us, like scientists. So we’re believing Most too. Very difficult to see how just having faith in science would qualify as an inferential valid cognizer.
Oh no, it’s not a valid inferential cognizer. What, that was stated in the context of Geshe-la saying that people only trusting what they can, you know, they’re not trusting the past people, their lives, which you have to investigate, and you’re just going on well, I’ve heard that there aren’t or there doesn’t, you know, nobody’s talking about it, so there must not be. They’re not believing in based on what they see, what they hear, what they can feel. They’re not relying on their own senses. We rely on authority all the time.
And another question. Geshela said that with some practices it isn’t necessary to sorry I’ll start that again. Geshe said that with wrong views some practices can still be beneficial giving the example of the exchange of self and others but surely with the or I would have thought with the exchange of self and others its function is rooted in cause and effect, the cause of the practice leading to the effect of the attainment of bodhichitta. So how if you have wrong views you possibly wouldn’t even believe in that that practice would have any benefit. In my opinion, it is not necessary to subscribe to karma and causality to believe in the benefits of the interchange of self and others, since this is something we can see and experience directly.
To take a precise example, attending the teachings in this temple. How do we know if our motivation is sufficient or not? If our motivation is 100% a wish to attain a better rebirth in future lives, we are 100% convinced of this, then this is a sufficient motivation. There are the three headings of the importance of a precious human rebirth and the third one being how even every moment of it can be most beneficial. Is that what is referred to when Geshela was saying to take the essence of this life that we don’t let a moment go past without creating causes for liberation?
This is not directly related to taking the essence of the Eight Freedoms and the 10 Endowments. The Eight Freedoms and the 10 Endowments are said to be critically important, profoundly meaningful, because it is thanks to them that it is for instance possible to gain a higher rebirth. And a dance, yeah, yeah. Geshe-la said, to make this life meaningful, one must live in harmony with oneself and family and state. I find this easier said than done as when I arrived home from work tonight I saw my two boys four and six briefly said hello to me and within minutes were fighting over a computer or a toy and were tearing each other apart and I had to physically tear them apart and speak harshly to them.
This didn’t make me feel good as trying to be a practicing Buddhist but is sometimes a necessity of life. Any advice? Yeah. Children. Yeah.
Yeah. Two boys. Two boys? And I had to raise my voice. You have an understanding of what it means to lead a meaningful human life since you experienced remorse after addressing harsh words to your children who had been calling.
This is a good sign. This Saturday with Geshela, 02:00, a public talk for an hour, mental peace in a time of crisis and uncertainty. Good opportunity to invite family and friends who might wonder what goes on here. And then you’ll be notified shortly about the
Key terms in this teaching
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- chulen
- Literally, “taking the essence.” Chulen pills are made of essential ingredients; taking but a few each day, accomplished meditators can remain secluded in retreat for months or years without having to depend upon normal food. LYWA
- eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
- The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
- four immeasurables caturapramana (Skt); tsä mä zhi (Tib)
- Also known as the four immeasurable thoughts or the four sublime attitudes, these are four states of mind or aspirations: loving kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy and equanimity. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What does it mean to extract the essence of a human rebirth of leisure and endowment?
Extracting the essence of a human rebirth of leisure and endowment means never allowing one's mind to be distracted by the affairs of this life, and instead continually focusing it on dharma. When one does this, one has extracted the essence of this human rebirth.