Lam Rim – 2014-10-15 – KR

1 h 48 min · 4,625 words · 15 October 2014

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2014-10-15 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. This talk continues a Lam Rim teaching on the small-scope path, outlining the seven meditation topics and the two essential cycles of death and impermanence and karma and causality. The main focus is karma and causality: its definiteness and increasing nature, and how conviction in it can be checked through everyday conduct. A question and answer session follows on war, mental illness and responding to anger.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 49m

UUID: 35e030b6-4020-4304-8582-46bef95b658f

Date: 2014-10-15

Words: 4,621

So within the context of the practice of the being of the small scope, once the presentation of karma and causality is completed, the practice of the being of the small scope is completed as well. So topics of reflection and the cycles of meditation included within the practice of the being of the small scope are probably seven in number. Within these seven main cycles of meditation, there are numerous subtopics. So when one speaks of meditating, of reflecting, or of practicing the path of the being of the small scope, it means meditating, reflecting, or practicing those seven topics of meditation. Then if one can focus exclusively on one such topic that is excellent, otherwise, alternatively, if one can set aside each week one specific time for meditation and train in these seven topics, that is also excellent.

These topics are the precious human rebirth, its great meaningfulness, its rarity, and its transience, the suffering of the lower realms, comma and cause refuge, and karma and causality. So these are the seven topics of meditation. Within, is he passed as a being of the small scope. Do you understand? Oh, good.

So in whichever topics of these seven cycles of meditation one meditates upon, if one meditates on the preceding topics leading up to it, it will become particularly potent. For instance, if one meditates on karma and causality, after meditating on the six topics leading up to it, it will become particularly potent. Likewise, if one meditates on death and impermanence, after meditating on the topics leading up to it, it becomes particularly potent. So the first of these seven topics is a precious human rebirth of leisure and endowment. Endowed with the eight leasures and the 10 endowments, we have such a rebirth since we satisfy these 18 factors, and as a result, we have a profoundly significant physical base.

What is the meaning of this is that with such a form, we can accomplish whatever we set out to accomplish. The second topic is the profound significance of such a rebirth, and the third topic is its rarity. Such a rebirth is rare because it is not sufficient to be born a human being to have a human rebirth of leisure and endowment. One must also be endowed with all of the sense organs. We know, for instance, many cases of human beings who lack the sense organs or who are diminished in one respect or the other.

The fourth topic of meditation is that such a rebirth is easily destroyed. Indeed, it is not permanent and durable. And here, the term destroyed indicates that one is meditating on death and impermanence. You can see in this way that there is a very close relationship between the previous and the latter topics. And this fourth topic that such a rebirth is easily destroyed.

In other words, death and impermanence has numerous subtopics in which it is unnecessary to enter, such as meditation on death in terms of the three roots, nine reasons, and the three conclusions that death is certain, the time of death is uncertain, and at the time of death, nothing apart from the dharma will be of benefit. In a nutshell, what is taught here is that this body is not stable and not permanent, and that we have no control over the time of our own death. Nobody can say, tomorrow, I will not die. In a year, I will not die, and so forth. And a critical point in the context of meditation on death and impermanence is to understand that at the time of death, future lives are ushered.

For this, we need, if we cannot generate a valid cognizer, which realizes the existence of future lives at the very least, a profound stable conviction in the existence of future lives. After our death, there are only two possible orientations. One can either be reborn in the higher rebirth or reborn in the lower rebirth. The cause for being reborn in the higher rebirth is a vast amount of virtue. The cause for being reborn in the lower rebirth is non virtue.

When we examine our own minds, we can see that non virtue is exclusively present. Therefore, we have already decided to be reborn in the lower realms. It is at this point that one should give rise to the anxiety at this thought of being reborn in the lower realms. At this point, the following cycle or topic of meditation is a reflection on the suffering of the lower realms. And we should, in this matter, be akin to someone who has been sentenced to a horrifying punishment and who appeals to the government or to some overlord for a means to have that punishment remitted.

When we are told that if you do such and such, you will not face the full extent of the punishment, we engage in the deeds prescribed immediately. Likewise, we should search for something or someone who can protect us from the suffering of the low of the lower realms, and this can only be the triple gem. And just as someone sentenced to a terrifying punishment will appeal to an overlord and engage in whatever is recommended to avoid punishment to the full extent of the law. Likewise, reflecting on the suffering of the lower realms, we go for refuge to the triple gem and engage in the prescriptions imparted by the triple gem, specifically, in this case, those which are related to dharma. In the foremost prescription related to dharma is to behave in accordance with karma and causality.

If we do not engage in mistaken deeds from the standpoint of karma and causality, we will not have to experience the suffering of the lower realm. Then if at present for a couple of seconds, we meditate carefully on all of the cycles of meditation of the being of the small scope, which have been explained, leading up to our main topic, which is common and causality. Then the topic of karma and causality will acquire a particular significance. And therefore, we should generate the motivation to receive these teachings on karma and causality, and if we gain the gist literally of karma and causality, this will be excellent. Otherwise, whatever experience we can gain will be very helpful.

Let us meditate. So it is ideal if we are able to gain uncontrived experience of all the cycles of meditation of the being of the small scope, and then on that basis gain uncontrived experience of all the cycles of meditation of the being of the middle scope and eventually of the great scope. If this is not possible, at the very least, we should try to gain contrived experience of these cycles of meditation. Then if one practices in this way in the morning after waking, waking, then one will be very heedful regarding whatever deeds one engages in in the afternoon. One will be careful.

However, all of us are similar in this respect. While it is easy to meditate for one day, it is very difficult to do so for seven days. So what is important is to practice continually. Then if it is possible to meditate regularly in this way, that is ideal. However, that is not possible.

I doubt that there is anyone in this room who is unable to find some time once a week, let us say one hour, once a week to meditate. Then when one does this, one gains an uncommon sensation, an uncommon feeling during meditation. Then I’m not saying this to give you a hard time nor should you give yourselves a hard time. Instead, you should think that making this life meaningful amounts to nothing else than in this life preventing one’s rebirth in the future in lower realms, which do exist, and doing whatever is necessary to ensure one’s own rebirth in higher realms, which also do exist. This is what is meant by a good or worthy life.

A good or worthy life is not a life in which one stuffs one’s face. So a good life is a life in which one prepares for a good rebirth. It may not be possible for us to meditate on all seven cycles of meditation of the path of the being of the small scope. Then in this case, we should take the essence of the path of the being of the small scope, and this is two cycles of meditation. The first, on death and impermanence, and the second, on karma and causality.

Initially, if we meditate carefully on death and impermanence in accordance with the Lamrim, with the graduated stages of the path, then as a result of this meditation, we will become extremely careful in our behavior, and this ushers directly the meditations on karma and causality, which teach us what to practice and what to abandon. Then meditations on death and impermanence and karma and causality must be practiced inseparably from each other. Then the very essence of the meditations on death and impermanence is the third root, the realization that at the time of death nothing is of benefit apart from dharma. Once one has this realization, one will die without fear and at ease, because one will have dedicated one’s life to dharma practice, and one will die in full knowledge that one has done so. In this way, one should combine inseparably the practices of death and impermanence and meditation on karma and causality.

Refuge is first and foremost refuge in the dharma since the dharma is the actual object of refuge, and Buddha is the imparter of this dharma. And in the context of the path of the being of the small scope, dharma is none other than karma and causality. It is precisely this dharma which acts as a refuge and protects the practitioner of the path of the being of the small scope from rebirth in the lower realms. On the other hand, the dharma, which is the object of refuge of the practitioner of the being of the middle scope, is twin. It must be understood on the one hand in terms of the object of abandonment, which is cyclic existence, and on the other hand, in terms of what should be practiced, which are the four noble truths leading to liberation.

Then, if one meditates on karma and causality as the culmination or the conclusion of the preceding six cycles of meditation, the meditation of karma on karma and causality will become particularly potent and significant for oneself. On the other hand, if one immediately broaches the meditation on karma and causality with no preliminary, since we are ourselves beginners, this meditation will have no particular impact on our mind. Therefore, one should proceed incrementally from cycle of meditation to cycle of meditation. Then the actual title of the outline on karma and causality is particularly profound. Secondly, generating the faith of conviction in karma and causality, which is the root of all happiness and excellence.

Here, it is a conviction which must be generated. A conviction in what? A conviction in karma and causality. In other words, in the fact that virtuous deeds lead to happiness and non virtuous deeds lead to suffering. So to be able to generate conviction in a karma and causality, we must ascertain karma and causality and must we must be convinced in its existence.

Here, it is best to proceed through visible phenomena. And setting past and future lives aside, we can see in the world which surrounds us that many nations are beset by conflict and war. Now war is a visible phenomenon, and if we investigate the conditions or the causes of war, we will find that the foundation of war is anger and competitiveness. This anger and competitiveness are non virtues. So just in the here and now of this life, we can see that non virtue gives rise to suffering without appealing to past and future lives.

Then it should be easy to understand that nonvirtue gives rise to suffering if one thinks in this way. Then we can likewise see that virtue gives rise in this very life to peace and to happiness. To take an example, all of you have probably heard of the numerous occasions on which his holiness the Dalai Lama has imparted the Kālacakra initiation in Bodhgaya. There is, at the very least, two to 300,000 devotees who attend these initiations. It has never been heard that there have been any crimes, any difficulties, or any violence of any type during these huge gatherings.

Why is this the case? This is the case because all gathered motivated by a virtuous intention, aware of the fact that the initiation of Kālacakra is an extremely important and meaningful occasion, and as a result, peace and happiness prevail. Then in reality, we can see in such a context that from virtue, peace and happiness occur. Then this is how one should reflect on karma and causality. And, clearly, it is up to oneself to examine one’s innermost being to see whether one actually believes in karma and causality oneself in one’s private inner sphere or not.

This is something we and we alone know, and I would ask you to investigate for yourself. Now if we imagine a situation in a house, for instance, in which someone sets an incredibly expensive watch on a little table and just walks away. Clearly, the opportunity for theft is present, and most of us when we see such an extraordinarily valuable watch will naturally like it. But if within our minds belief in karma and causality is present, then even though the wish to see it arises, we will not do so. Then it is not the case that nonvirtue is something of which only dharma practitioners are aware.

Nonvirtue exists for both dharma practitioners and nonreligious practitioners. There is such a thing known as natural misdeeds or natural non virtues. Then in the example of the aforementioned watch example, if we see this extraordinarily expensive watch on the table, and even though we would like to have it, and we know that if we steal it, it would be ours for the having, if nonetheless we reflect and think, should I steal it, I will accrue a very heavy non deed, this is something I myself will experience in the future, and great fear should arise at the prospect of experiencing such a non virtuous deed, then we can be sure that we have conviction in karma and causality. If on the other hand, we grab the watch and walk away, at that point, it is obvious that we do not. Then we ourselves know whether conviction in karma and causality is present in our mind streams or not.

Then if one does not steal the watch, thinking, if I steal the watch, the odds are high that I will be found, and I will face major trouble from the police and the law, then this is not a sign of belief in karma and causality. This would more be a case of social ethics, and as such, from a karmic standpoint, would become a karmic neutral. So this is the topic of karma and causality. This is how one reflects and if one does so, there is great benefit for oneself both in this life and in future lives. There is nothing extra to add on karma and causality as Lama Tsongkhapa says in his foundation of good qualities.

Bless me to have the heedfulness which enables me to accumulate the collection of virtues and to abstain from all non virtuous deeds. Then when we speak of practice, practice does not have to start with the formal sitting. Karma and causality is actually practice. For that matter, it is the foundation of practice. There is no practice of the four Noble Truths without an understanding of karma and causality.

So the topic we have started to study, which is generating the firm conviction in karma and causality, the foundation of all happiness and excellence is subdivided into three subtopics or three outlines, reflecting in general on karma and causality, reflecting in particular on karma and causality, and having reflected thereupon the means of engaging and abstaining. The first topic is subdivided into two, reflecting the actual reflection in general and the specific reflection in general, and that first topic itself is subdivided into four. The increasing nature of karma, excuse me. The first topic is the definite nature of karma. The second is the increasing nature of karma.

The third is that one does not encounter a karma which one has not accumulated. And the fourth is the inexhaustibility of karma. So the first of these subtopics, the definiteness of karma refers to the fact that whatever karma one accumulates matures in accordance with the karma accumulated and not differently. It is incontrovertible in this respect or non-deceptive. There are numerous examples of this in Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand by Kyabje Pabongkha Rinpoche.

I won’t cover them all, but we’ll just give one example. In days of yore, around the time of Buddha Kāśyapa, there was a respected worker called Zodin who was contributing to the erection of a stupa. And filled with doubt at the size of the stupa projected, he said, when will such a stupa ever be finished? When the king had completed the stupa, Zodin experienced regret at the doubt he had expressed and offered a beautiful bell which was placed on top of the stupa. As a result of this offering, in a future life, he had a beautiful voice which was in keeping with the beauty of the sound of the bell.

So this is the first sub topic, the definiteness of karma, the second sub topic, the increasing nature of karma refers to the fact that even the smallest karmic deed, virtuous or non virtuous, over time becomes incredibly powerful. For instance, a small non virtuous deed can become very powerful after a long period of time. The there are numerous examples in Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand in the palm of your hand of the increasing nature of karma. I shall not list them all, but just one. It is recounted that a sea creature with 18 heads was cast on the shore, and Buddha Śākyamūni and all of the people of the area assembled around the sea monster.

Many non Buddhist practitioners, tirthikas, came as well wondering what the Buddha would say about such an event. And Buddha Śākyamūni, who could see the innermost roots of causality, of karma and causality, went up to the sea monster and addressing him said, you have 18 heads, and you have these 18 heads because in a previous life, obeying the injunction of your mother, when you debated with monks, to defeat them in debate, you said to one of them, your speech is that of a frog. To another, your speech is that of a sheep. To another, your speech is that of an ox, and so forth. Isn’t that so?

Then I have nothing left to add for today. We shall stop here. If you have questions, please feel free to ask them. I’ve got one would you believe? Small, long virtues.

How can how do they become bigger over a period of time? So to give you an example, even though a very small deed is performed, if it’s performed with respect to a powerful field, such as, for instance, a member of Sangha, that small deed can become very powerful. In the example which was given, even though this person had said nothing more than to one monk, your speech is akin to that of a frog, to another yours is akin to that of a sheep. Nonetheless, through the power of the field, in other words, the recipient was a monk, this deed became karmically very heavy. My question is, in situations like when somebody has a mental illness, how as a practitioner do you honour the circumstance of mental illness without the judgment, you know, like some people can say what Could you just be clearer because I’m hearing you Sorry.

Less and People with disabilities, for example, how is it how do you represent the complexity of karma and causality and compassion and non judgment when yeah. Just through, for instance, seeing the obvious sufferings of someone who has a physical ailment, might be blind, an invalid, who has lost an arm or lost an a leg, compassion will naturally arise for that person, and with that compassion respect. However, when you reflect on the fact that this is the maturation of a deed which was committed in a distant past in a previous life, even greater compassion should arise. Yeshua mentioned to reflect on the seven practices of the smaller scope but no mention was made of guru devotion. Does that fit more in with the practices, or is it also part of the seven small scope practices?

The practice of reliance on the spiritual teacher is not included within the path of the being of the small scope. It is instead the foundation of the path of the being of the small scope. Since it is said that the beginning of the path is the recognition of leisure and endowment, in other words, a precious human rebirth, the beginning of meditation is refuge, and the beginning of practice is karma and causality. Another. We were talking about war.

As dharma practitioners, is there anything that we can do to change the field that war exists in? The the field? Yes. You know, you’re talking about actions in the field like if you do something to a monk, it has greater consequences. I’m thinking about the field in a kind of quantum physics sense of the field of war and conflict.

As dharma practitioners, is there anything that we can do in our practice to interrupt what’s happening now? So I mentioned this in the context of the effect of maturation of non virtuous karma. However, it seems very difficult for us to be of any benefit to them whatsoever in our own practice. Another Without a realisation of emptiness it seems we’d have a mistaken view of ourselves or the self. Does this mean we would or we would have a mistaken view of rebirth and karma?

Therefore, how can we strengthen the conviction with that mistaken view of rebirth and karma based on a mistaken view of self? To the contrary, well, if one does not understand emptiness and one meditates on karma and causality, one’s sense of the inherent existence of karma and causality might increase. For someone who has a true understanding of emptiness, the deeper they meditate on karma and causality, which are the dependent arising, independence on causes and conditions, the deeper their understanding of emptiness and reciprocally. And If we were to take that war is brought about by anger and competitiveness and it is the ripening of their karma that’s bringing this to happen, does this mean that these perpetrators have not been exposed to the dharma in their past lives? And also without causing any offence to anybody that may have family involved does this also apply to our defence forces that are currently in the midst of it?

So regarding your first question, those who experience the hardship of war in this life experience it as a result of non virtuous karma which they have accumulated in previous lives. Whether they were religious practitioners or dharma practitioners in a previous life or not, is something I cannot answer. Regarding your second question, Australian soldiers who are fighting to defend their country, clearly, when one goes to war, one accumulates karma. No. In my opinion, since oneself has not chosen to support that or engage in that, then one would not accumulate non-virtuous karma.

Would like to ask a question about karma and causality. I have encountered many times about some conflict, you know, like I have the force to defend somebody. They talk about once one person talk about bad debt to another person and I force to defend that person because I don’t see the the other person in a bad way. Should I my question is should I just sit back and not not defend and just let it be or should I talk and there’s a number of choice because when you talk, you also your your anger also arise. So if someone uses harsh speak to a harsh speech towards one of your acquaintances, you should think that this person is controlled by anger, controlled by competitiveness, controlled by jealousy, and that they are basically almost insane, and treat them with that compassion.

And then when you think that he is behaving in this way under the power of anger, under the power of jealousy or competitiveness, and it’s almost as insane, then this is very helpful. So is that mean that I should keep quiet, then I don’t have to say In my opinion, everything depends on whether the person who is insulting your acquaintance will listen to the advice you give or not. If they will listen to the advice, you should give advice. If they will not listen to the advice, then you should not give advice. I’m following on that one.

What if the person that is doing the insulting has dementia? Well, there is a in worldly matters, there is a very big difference between true insanity and bad behavior. However, as as Milarepa said, the great Tibetan yogi, the world is insane for Milarepa, and Milarepa is insane for the world. So we should reflect in cases like these that it is not the person themselves who is responsible, they are totally controlled by anger. And we can contrast this with a situation with, for instance, a dog.

When you strike a dog with a switch, the dog often does not understand that you are striking him and will bite at the switch. This is a sign of the limited mental capacities of the dog. The dog does not understand that we are striking it. Likewise, in the case of an angry person, it is not the person, but the anger which has taken control of the person. I’m just here, stop.

We shall stop here for Yeah. With Ilya on the first of November, there are some flyers. Wisdom in Buddhism and the unique place of wisdom within Buddhism compared to the other traditions. So 02:00 on the November 1. And also just a heads up, there will be a letter being posted about Lama Dorje Chang puja on the November 13.

And it’ll be a very special puja because Ilya will be launching his compilation of Rinpoche’s teachings on a particular text. The I don’t think I can say it, Bodhicharyavatara on emptiness. And so there will be a very generous donor who will be distributing copies of that teaching. And so and it’s dedicated, Ilya’s text, his book is dedicated to the swift return of our teacher Khensur Rinpoche so it would be a quite auspicious time. So there will be a letter being sent out shortly and then followed up by an email.

But as I said, Ilya’s talk on the November 1 on wisdom and there’s Puja here with Geshe-la on Saturday at 05:00. Thank you. And Medicine Buddha at two. Never a dull moment. So stay for some chai.

Key terms in this teaching

cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
guru devotion
After finding a fully qualified spiritual teacher and establishing a connection, the disciple trains in devotion using logical reasoning. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top