Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014-09-10 – KR.mp3
UUID: 7aec03c5-d58f-4bc0-835f-fface99de941
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2014-09-10
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 24m
Words: 3,075
It is extreme extremely important to generate a motivation before engaging in a deed in the same same way as when we prepare supper, for instance, we generate the motivation to prepare supper before doing this. And to generate such a motivation, we must recognize it. So when we speak of your motivation, we speak of the we the wish to engage or to start something. And for this, we must know the something we want to start and wish to engage in it. Otherwise, just to say blindly, generate the motivation without having a clear idea of what we want to do is really meaningless.
It’s like striking water with a sword. It’s a bit the same thing as if every day meals are served at twelve noon, and we show up at 01:00 hoping to eat something. Then obviously, we won’t have anything to eat because the time for meals is over. Right? And, therefore, it is important before generating the motivation to be very clear about what the object wished for by this motivation is.
It’s a bit the same thing as if one’s car has a problem. Then, when one’s car has a problem, one investigates the problem and, repairs it. Now imagine if instead of following the sequence of first finding the problem and then repairing it, one does things in the wrong order, upside down. Initially, one plans on repairing one’s car when there is one no problem, and one doesn’t really know what to do. And then after after that, a completely different problem arises.
This is plain silly. And therefore, initially, one must identify what it is one is planning to engage in and then generate the motivation to do this. One must, for instance, investigate how one plans on improving or healing one’s mind and then generate motivation to improve or to heal one’s mind. For instance, if powerful anger arises within our mind stream and we fall completely under the sway of anger, we have no control left, then obviously this is a very difficult situation. So one has to investigate the means to dissipate this anger.
Then when such great suffering arises within one’s mind stream, the elimination of this suffering is happiness, and this is something we should strive for. But before engaging in this, we must clearly differentiate between physical and mental happiness and suffering. Dharma practice is completely unrelated to generating physical happiness or eliminating physical suffering. There is no relationship whatsoever. It is on the other hand closely related to generating mental happiness and eliminating mental suffering.
This is something we must understand. It is also critical to differentiate between physical happiness and mental happiness. For instance, when we look at physical suffering or physical happiness, if for instance it is too hot in the room and we suffer physically from heat, we turn the air conditioner on. This provides a sensation of physical happiness which eventually, as we grow cold, turns into suffering. This is physical happiness and physical suffering.
The mind on the other hand, mental happiness and mental suffering involves, for instance, stating this is blue, this is a human being, this is an animal. These conceptions or these ideations are mental events. And therefore, before engaging in the study of the lamrim, the graduated stages of the path, we must clearly understand which suffering we plan on dispelling and which happiness we plan on actualizing or realizing. It is only once we have done this that we can meaningfully engage in the study of the Lamrim. Now, if for instance, our goal is to dispel anger and all of the afflictions associated with anger under the sway of which we fall, then initially we must understand what anger is and what the suffering caused by anger is.
And then once one has understood what one wishes to engage in, what one’s goal is in other words, then at that point and only at that point can one generate the motivation to engage in this. Yeah. Yeah. And, therefore, when we talk here of generating the motivation before attending teachings, it is critically important to understand what a motivation is and not to think it is something related with lunch. And therefore, let us reflect for a couple of minutes on generating this motivation.
So we have, broadly speaking, completed the topic of refuge, and, therefore, it is up to you at present to examine your mental continuums to see whether there is refuge or not within your mental continuum. And if there is, very good. And if there is not, how will you generate it? In the context of the Lamrim, it is important to distinguish between two refuges, ordinary or mere refuge and special refuge. In this context, we have to ask ourselves what basically is the happiness we are striving for.
Now there are persons for whom the main happiness driven for is material happiness. Material happiness, however, is happiness which is finite and which is not infinite or limitless. It is finite simply because it depends on exterior material objects. Then if we reflect on where true happiness comes from, true happiness is mental and it arises from the very depths of our own mind. Likewise, inner suffering is also mental and it arises from the very depths of our own mind.
What is therefore the root of this inner happiness and what is the root of inner suffering? The root of inner happiness is the elimination of self cherishing and the root of inner suffering is self cherishing. And this self cherishing or egoism is rooted itself in the apprehension of a self. Now through analyses, at this point we should investigate whether through eliminating the apprehension of a self, it is possible to eliminate the suffering which derives from it. And this elimination of the apprehension of a self can be done through applying the antidote to the apprehension of a self, which is the view of selflessness.
Then through repeated habituation with the antidote, it is possible to eliminate the ignorance which is an apprehension of the self. And at this point, one will have obtained the actual refuge, the actual Dharma refuge, which is none other than the wisdom realizing self selflessness. This is something which is possible, but it calls for refuge, for it calls for effort. Then we should investigate whether it is possible to obtain such a stable object of attainment on the present basis of leisure and endowment which we have. And indeed, with effort, it is possible.
It is certainly impossible once we are reborn in the lower realms and let alone mental suffering and the fact that we have no control left of over our own minds. In addition, we have no control whatsoever over our own bodies. When we reflect about this situation, great fear arises within our mind. And this fear acts as a motor which leads us to take pure refuge. It is on this basis then that one can practice.
This is, for instance, the motivation of the practitioners, whether they are Shavakas or Pratyeka Buddhas on the stage or the path of accumulation and of preparation, who reflect and think, while I am still on the path of accumulation, of preparation, what guarantee do I have that I shall not be reborn in the lower realms? It is very difficult to be certain that this will not happen, and on this basis, they strive for an arya path. In other words, the path of seeing. And therefore, when we reflect on the fact that on such a physical base, if we practice with energy and perseverance, life after life, we will either attain our goal of liberation or our goal of full enlightenment. Whereas, if we do not have such a physical base but are reborn in the lower realms, it would be impossible to attain our goal of liberation or full enlightenment.
At this point, one will have generated special refuge. And therefore, through reflecting in this way on the fact that we must attain our stable goals of liberation or happiness, we dedicate whatever roots of virtue we have to this goal and independence on this. Eventually, one day, we will attain it. Do you understand? Yes, sir.
Really? Food for thought in this topic because let us say you make offerings. If you have not studied and do not understand what precisely is happening happening, then to whom do you make offerings? What offerings do you make? Therefore, one must study and realize that oneself must generate the Buddha jewel, the Dharma jewel, and the Sangha jewel.
These are our own objects of attainment. And dedicate one’s roots of virtue to this goal. Therefore, one needs a good teacher. One needs to have a calm and untroubled mind and accumulate roots of virtue. And should one generate on this basis a refuge which is rooted in the profound study of scriptures and strive to generate within oneself the Buddha jewel, the Dharma jewel and the Sangha jewel, this will be the resulting refuge.
If on the other hand one is unable to do this, but from the depths of one mind, one cringes at the thought of the suffering one will experience in the lower realms and is convinced that such such suffering will be insupportable and unbearable, and is also convinced from the depths of the mind ideally through having generated a valid cognizer, but at the very least through having generated conviction in the capacity of the triple gem to protect one from these sufferings. And one goes for refuge to an exterior triple gem, a triple gem exterior from oneself, then this is causal refuge. Then you, yourselves, must examine your mental continuum to see what is present within it. Probably, type of refuge is present, perhaps fully characterized refuge, otherwise, refuge. And you should examine whether causal refuge is present within your mind stream or resulting refuge.
It is said in Buddhist scriptures that resulting refuge is a special refuge which is superior. This is therefore the distinction between causal and resulting refuge. If from the very depths of one’s own mind, one is one’s own teacher and one strives one oneself to become a fully enlightened being embodying the dharma, then one has resulting refuge, and this is what differentiates Buddhists from non Buddhists. Whether mere refuge or causal refuge is sufficient to differentiate Buddhists from non Buddhists is something I do not know. So I have I have three questions for you.
The first question is, what is the nature or the definition of refuge? The second question is, is refuge a main mind or a mental factor? The third question is, from when till when does refuge last or is refuge present? So what first is the nature or the definition of refuge? It’s something you should know.
I think having faith in the dharma and the teachings and then being able to apply it to oneself from one’s heart is the refuge that we seek to be able To seek protection and to be free from suffering. To have a conviction that cannot be overturned at the very least to hopefully the very best having a direct valid cognition that it is the triple gem only that can protect me from rebirth in the lower realms. Mhmm. The definition of refuge is that one accepts the refuge precepts and becomes a follower of the Buddha. Do you have Having conviction that the triple gem is able to protect one from the lower realms and the general sufferings of samsara.
And not taking refuge in any other than these. I questioned myself last week because I actually went to a Christian church last week for a service and I questioned refuge and for me I asked why Buddhism and why not this? For me the answer was there is no path. Refuge offers me a path and to be free from samsara. It offers me a way.
So it gives me protection and it shows me a way to be free from samsara. It’s not possible to have refuge without great fear. Without great fear there is no true refuge. Then one has great fear of the specific sufferings of the lower realms and the general sufferings of cyclic existence on the one hand. This is the first cause, and in addition, one is convinced that either one has a valid cognizer or one is convinced that the objects of refuge, the triple gem, have the qualities to protect us from these fear.
Then when single pointedly one turns one’s mind for them, and one places one’s hope in them, this is refuge. And then it is said in the text that this refuge is a wishing mind, in other words, within main minds of metal factors, a metal factor which places its hope or its wish in an object of refuge which can protect it from the specific sufferings of the lower grounds and the general sufferings of cyclic existence. Then check for yourselves in your book, liberation in the palm of your hand, and after reading the section on the nature of refuge, check your own mental continuums, your own mind, and ask yourself sincerely, is there refuge in my mind or not? And if there is not, you must engage in the cycles of meditation to generate refuge. So we will drop set questions two and three since I have answered my own questions in the explanation.
I told you that refuge is a hope, then obviously it is a mental factor. Whether it is a thought or not is open to investigation. And I ask you until when or what was the boundary of refuge? Then refuge is present until one has gained liberation from suffering, at which point it becomes empty. So until one becomes an Arhat or until one has gained liberation.
Then if one has special refuge and not just ordinary or mere refuge, then one experiences the eight advantages of refuge, which I shall not give a detailed commentary upon. You can read them in liberation of the palm of your in the palm of your hand. These eight advantages are, first, that one has become a Buddhist. Secondly, that one is the basis for all vows. Thirdly, that one has purified the obscurations of all previously accumulated karma.
Fourthly, that, one accumulates swiftly a vast collection of merit. Fifthly, that one will not be harassed or tormented by human beings and non human entities. Sixthly, that one will not fall in the lower realms. Seventhly, that one will accomplish whatever one wishes to accomplish, and, eighthly, that one will become enlightened swiftly. Then I will take your questions at present.
Just regarding Geshe’s question from when does refuge lost or is refuge present? When I was thinking about that, the question he put to us, I was thinking that refuge is present beyond full enlightenment because with special refuge one has actualised and embodied the triple gem so one actually becomes the triple gem so one’s mental continuum is the same as the triple gem and the refuge. So I’m a bit confused. Then Geshela is saying that the boundaries of refuge is present until you gain liberation, at which point becomes empty. But if you’re the embodiment of refuge, your mental continuum is the embodiment of refuge, how can it then have that boundary and to you be the refuge.
So generally speaking, when the object of observation of refuge or the purpose of refuge has been completed, there can be no refuge. Now in the context of these teachings, am talking specifically of the refuge of the being of the middling scope, and we are not talking of the refuge of the being of the great scope or other forms of refuge. Oh, another question? Do you have any question? Geshela, in the motivation Geshela talked about there being no relationship between physical happiness and mental happiness.
And yet Buddha Shakyamuni took some milk when he was just before his enlightenment, so to strengthen his body, wouldn’t that imply that there is a relationship between physical and mental happiness. It is not that there is no relationship whatsoever between physical and mental happiness. There is a small relationship. As Shantideva says in Bodhisattva Acharyavatara, pay this body your servant its salary. However, it is not possible to attain full mental happiness on the basis of just this body.
However, this body, this physical base is necessary for the accumulation of the collections of merit and wisdom. I was just wondering, how does taking refuge use up obscurations acquired from previously accumulated karma? This is the case probably because when one takes truly refuge, and this applies to pure refuge and not just to mere refuge, in the Buddha, one takes refuge in every single Buddha who has ever existed, and one then experiences the blessings of all these Buddhas. These blessings dispel the vast amount of non virtuous deeds which we have accumulated since previous lives. As you remember, when we go for refuge, we go to a field of refuge which is visualized, and actually we generate bodhicitta with respect to the field of refuge, but we generate compassion with respect to the lower field, the field of sentient beings.
Through the combination of bodhicitta and of compassion, all thoughts can be purified. Then if one has stable unwavering refuge in the triple gem, and this refers to a refuge which is continually present, not a refuge which is occasionally present, and if this refuge is present whenever difficulties arise within our life, then it eliminates all suffering. That is easy to answer. In short, very easy. Maybe.
That’s one way to think about it. This profound conviction, the triple gem has the power, the complete power to protect me from suffering. When it is present, indicates we have mere or ordinary refuge. Yeah. Why don’t we stop here for today?
Just before you race off to grab some chai and a biscuit, flyers for the two days in October in praise of dependent arising, teaching on emptiness, recommended by his holiness to recite for the rebirth of our teacher, Ken Soombershe. So that will be a great two days on the October. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- causal refuge
- The objects of refuge - the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha - existing in the mental continua of others, as opposed to resultant refuge. Only by relying upon these external refuge objects can we achieve our own internal resultant refuge. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.