Lam Rim — 2014-07-02

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim — 2014-07-02
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014-07-02 – KR.mp3

UUID: b962ee6c-c632-4a81-bf71-fa605546f38c

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2014-07-02

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 31m

Words: 3,443

As Buddha Shakyamuni said in the Mahaparinirvana Sutra, just as of all footprints, the footprint of the elephant is the largest. Likewise, of all discriminations, discrimination of death is supreme. The term discrimination in this quote refers actually to the recollection of death and of impermanence And this recollection is supreme because it acts as the foundation for the practices of ethics and generosity within this life, which in turn open the gateway toward other practices of virtue. This is why it is said that the recollection of death and impermanence is most important since it since it is the foundation for all attainments on the grounds and paths all the way up to full enlightenment. In other words, the recollection of death and impermanence is the foundation for all virtuous practice.

As Je Tsongkhapa says, without recollecting death and impermanence, you will not engage in any virtuous practice. For that matter, it should be recollected over and again. All of us are aware of this and probably all of us are aware deep down that we will die someday under the power of the grasping at our own permanence, we are convinced that we will live for a very long time. Therefore, when we awaken in the morning, our first thought should be of death and impermanence. And then after on this basis, we should take the resolve to engage in virtuous practice throughout the day.

Now generally speaking, there are numerous levels of virtuous mind, both coarse and subtle virtuous minds. Perhaps we should set aside the subtle virtuous minds such as the mind which meditates on emptiness, bodhicitta or great compassion, are difficult for us to generate, and focus on the coarser virtuous minds, the more basic virtuous minds. Since we have no way of knowing when we will die, and for instance, it could easily happen during a car accident tonight on the way back home, then at the time of death, we will have no recollection whatsoever. And therefore, when we awaken in the morning, upon awakening we should think back and say, I have awakened this morning, I have not died, this is good, and then at the end of the morning, when the time comes for lunch, we should look back on the morning and think, this morning I did not die, I could have died, it is now time for lunch, this is good, And then, as the day comes to an end in the evening, we should look back on our whole day, and if we have engaged non virtue, we should confess and generate the wish to restrain from this non virtue with strong remorse, if on the other hand we have engaged in virtue, we should rejoice and dedicate it, and then think today I have not died, this has been a good day, it has been a meaningful day, And if we practice in this day, every day of our life will be meaningful.

The recollection of death is therefore extremely powerful to counter the arising of the afflictions. And if there is therefore one experience in this world of ours, which we cannot relinquish, it is the experience of death. Then, we have to try to find a means to overcome the fear of death, and there is no means probably which is superior for overcoming the fear of death than actual recollection of death. If we recollect death during this life at the time of our own death, our fear will be lessened. Therefore, we have to search for means to bring this recollection to our mind.

One of the means is taught in the Lamrim, it is to think that when the time approaches the doctors will be of no help. The doctors will tell us if you behave well, if you take the medicine I will prescribe you, you might have a couple more years in front of you, you might very well not. Likewise, your own relatives will start speaking very kindly and very softly to you, which is always a sign. Then you will know. Then there are some innocent souls who will believe what the doctor says, and when he tells them you will heal quickly, they sincerely believe this, and think that they will soon be having mice millions once again, and going for walks.

Many are like that. And those are often the ones who have chronic diseases, not the ones who die like a butternut at once. And therefore, whenever opportunities arise in this life such as disease to recollect death and impermanence, we should seize these opportunities. And this is why it is said in the Lamrim that ideally, at the time of death, we will delight and rejoice. If that is not possible, then we will experience no harm, which means we will not experience fear, and if that is not possible, at the very least, there will be no remorse.

And we will think, this life, I have engaged in all the virtue I could and I have not committed heavy non virtuous deeds. Therefore, the very least, one should have no remorse at the time of death. Then ideally one would have no fear whatsoever. It may be difficult for us to be able to generate the joy and delight at the time of death, but fear at the time of death arises from the incapacity to relinquish the vanities of this life, and if one has been a sincere practitioner of the path of the being of the small scope, then one would have relinquished the vanities of this life, and such fear should not arise. This is why the Kadampa Geshe of yore said, I do not fear death, I fear the place of the next rebirth.

Now, this profound statement should not be repeated casually. It can only be understood in terms of a study of the Lamrim. The Kadampa Geshe’s of yore did not fear death because they had turned their back on this life. They had relinquished the vanities of this life. There was nothing left to be attached to.

They did, however, fear the next rebirth because in that respect they lacked control. Indeed, until one has attained the level of forbearance of the path of preparation, so the path of preparation has four levels, the first level is warmth, peak and forbearance is the third level, until one has attained the level of forbearance, one cannot be sure one will not be reborn in a lower realm, one lacks control in that matter. And in our cases, obviously, we do study the LAMREM. Whether independence on this, we are Mahayana beings or not, is a very different issue which I cannot decide for you. It is hard to say.

So what matters for us therefore is over and again at present to recollect death, to familiarize ourselves with death, and on this basis, to generate the motivation to listen to these teachings. Mhmm. And therefore, it is independence on the fear of death that one engages in dharma practice. It is definitely the case that many of the students who attend teachings attend teachings out of the fear of their own death. There is another group of students who attends teachings preoccupied with the general suffering of the world we live in, wishing to alleviate the suffering of beings in this world through helping them by giving them the requisite forms, sounds, smells, tastes, or tactile objects which they need.

However, it is impossible through such deeds to lead to an enduring, lasting, permanent state of happiness. This can only lead to a transient form of happiness. And therefore, we should reflect carefully on precisely the sort of happiness we need. Clearly, a physical happiness which is predicated on external material conditions can never be a firm, stable and enduring happiness. It is always affected by the fear of death, and the fear of the loss of the vanities of this life.

On the other hand, a mental happiness, an inner happiness, which arises from deep within the person will not be affected by the fear of death and will be permanent and enduring. It is this happiness we should strive for. There is however definitely a category of being who understands that physical happiness cannot be enduring and seeks for an inner mental happiness which will be permanent and enduring. If one seeks for such an inner mental happiness, one has to find the causes, the conditions for this happiness which counter the discordant factors. It is up to oneself to analyze carefully, but one can see that these discordant factors are actually the afflictions, such as anger and so forth, which are eventually rooted if one traces them far back enough into self cherishing and into the ignorance which apprehends the true existence of phenomena.

Do you understand? Really? I 100%. Pardon? Not to not to say.

Many not present. Really? Definitely, such a person exists, and such a person will not practice only motivated by the fear of death. And such a person will study the great scriptures, Buddhist or non Buddhist and many other traditions. And after studying these great scriptures, certainly in the Buddhist tradition, there is an extremely elaborate presentation of mental trainings.

For such a person, relinquishing the vanities of this life will not be difficult. Then you may wonder whether such a being would have entered the path of the being of the small scope. Most definitely, he will have and he will easily pass to that of the middling end of the great scope. Then, if we say he has entered the path of the being of the small scope, his foremost practice is the recollection of death and impermanence, and he will train in recollecting them inseparably. But the fear of death which he experiences will not be the fear of death of an ordinary person.

It will be a fear of death rooted in the understanding that at the time of his or her own death, like us, he will lose all control, and therefore he will wish to put into or to good usage this human rebirth or this basis of leisure and endowment. Viewing things in this way, such a being will practice like Milarepa, one does encounters people one does encounter people of that caliber. Then this is my own view on things. Such a person, although nominally a practitioner of the path of the being of the small scope, would have very strong affinities with the path of the being of the middling scope, would enter it easily, and would very easily pass from that path to that of the being of the great scope. Then such a person, such a being would have realized the meaning of the two verses in Je Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path through becoming habituated to the notion that this life is fleeting and does not last, turn away from the vanities of this life.

And such a being would develop those two verses and meditate on the fact that it is through becoming accustomed to the fact that this life is fleeting and transient, as well as future lives, that one should turn away from future lives. Therefore, within the outline, as you remember, the main outline is the means of training the mind in the stages of the path shared with the being of the small scope, which is subdivided into two, generating the mind which strives for future worlds, in other words, future lives, and teaching the means for happiness in future worlds, in other words, future lives. The first outline has been completed. Now this first outline is subdivided into two, recollecting death through understanding that this present world we live in does not abide for long, and thinking on the happiness and suffering of the two categories of beings in future worlds. The first outline has also been completed.

So I will now present the second outline. Regarding the second outline, reflecting on the happiness and suffering of the two categories of beings in future worlds, it is clear that at the time of our death, we will either be reborn in higher or in lower bounds. And many, if not most of us, will perform divinations or use astrology to try to understand which of the two rebirths we will be reborn in. This is completely unnecessary since, as Arya Nagarjuna says, from non virtue arises all suffering in this life and even rebirths in future lives. Through merely examining our own mental continuum, we will know.

And it is the most powerful karma present within our mind at the time of our death, which will determine which category of realms we are reborn in. If virtuous karma is the most powerful comma comma predominant, we will be reborn in the higher realms, otherwise in the lower realms. If virtuous and non virtuous karma of equal force are present within the mind, it is that with which we are the most accustomed to which we have the greatest habit, which will predominate. If, they are both of equal habituation, it will be that which has been accumulated the most recently. Then there’s reflect on our own situation.

If we commit a non virtuous deed, is complete with motivation, the actual deed and the completion of the deed, then it seems very difficult to prevent such a deed from maturing, irrespective of the virtuous deeds we engage in. Now let us reflect on our own situation. Then I don’t know whether you actually do recite the six session Guru Yoga in the morning or not, but let us assume you do. It is difficult to imagine reciting the six session Guru Yoga as a complete virtuous deed, because one needs a complete application, in other words motivation, the actual recitation must be complete, and the roots of virtue must have been dedicated. Otherwise it is not a complete virtuous deed.

Then if we take a non virtuous deed, the situation is completely different. All of the factors are complete. For instance, let us say take someone who has annoyed us, anger arises within our mind, the motivation is clearly complete. Then we utter hurtful and harmful words, the deed is there, and we check to see whether the hurtful and harmful words have hit their target or not. If they have, we delight and we rejoice in the deed.

The conclusion is there too. The deed is itself complete and powerful. Then the great teachers point out that while indeed it is highly beneficial to recite one’s tantric commitments, the meaning of these tantric commitments is very difficult to understand. On the other hand, there is tremendous benefit for us in recollecting death and impermanence even for one minute after rising in the morning. Then I have nothing left to add.

If you have questions, I’ll take your questions at present. Why? This is one question. So, I have to summarize your question. In a nutshell, your question is, have the Tibetan has Geshela heard of Tibetans having near death experiences which are distressing?

Okay. Do you see things can be summarized, can’t they? I have actually never had direct experience of what the Tibetans called the returners, these are people who die and then return to this life and remember their experiences. Does renunciation include giving up the notion that we can alleviate the suffering of other people in this life by giving them what they need for physical happiness? How could you abandon helping others after generating renunciation?

It would be exactly the opposite. The help you gave others would increase, even on the material level. And another another question. Kishanay is saying that the returners in Tibet are a completely different category from near death experiences, these are people who die for or who have been dead for days or weeks on end with no sign of physical death and no sign of any decay. There’s no breath, there’s no heartbeat, there’s nothing, and then they return and they are exactly like before with memories of what happened.

I was just wondering why does the realisation of death come before the realisation of bodhichitta and compassion? Why is that part of the larger scope and the realisation of death is the small scope? If you want to generate fully characterized, in other words authentic bodhicitta, it is indispensable to have meditated on death and impermanence first, because to generate fully characterized bodhicitta, one must first have meditated on the path of the being of the middling scope, and that leads one to a disgust with psychic existence, and to generate that disgust with psychic existence, one must have meditated first on the path of the being of the small scope whose main practice is death and impermanence. This is a case because if one wants to generate empathy, in other words compassion, which is a wish to free others from suffering, one wishes to free them from the sufferings of psychic existence, and here the sufferings of cyclic existence refer mainly to all pervasive suffering. To wish to free them from all pervasive suffering, one must first have generated the wish oneself to be freed from all pervasive suffering.

To generate that wish, one must first have been able to meditate on death and impermanence. Then definitely such cases do exist, Gesheera knows of one at Serraje. There’s a monk, Zurchen Gatso, in Gesheera’s compound, who was able to help at a distance over the telephone someone who suffered from a mental disorder and who lived in Tibet. Such things do happen. Not all monks have those capacities, and there are lay people who have those capacities too.

These are the ordinary siddhis, right? These are the ordinary siddhis, right? The ordinary paranormal powers. People who do the retreats gain these ordinary powers, these ordinary siddhis, right? When I’m accused of something I didn’t do the object of negation becomes very apparent and manifests the inherent self and often I’ve noticed that arises when I meditate on death as well.

A strong sense of the inherent self arises and then on that basis I feel some fear. Should I be keeping one eye or one part of my awareness on that inherent self and noticing that or should I be focused on focusing on cultivating the fear? If you are able to identify the object of negation in accordance with scriptures, then most definitely you should counter it at this point. Regarding the question of Amanda, on the importance of meditating on death and impermanence as a preliminary to training in bodhicitta. Actually, the importance of meditating on death and impermanence is extreme in all of the stages up to the stage of forbearance of the path of preparation.

So during the stage of warmth, peak, and peak of the stage of forbearance, warmth and peak of the path of preparation, we still have no guarantee that at the time of death we will not be reborn in a lower realm. As a result, during those stages, fear of death is rooted in fear of a possible lower rebirth. In this life as well, if you have a time limit for your studies and you are under pressure to finish them before that time and time limit elapses, you will put great effort. People who have no particular time limit tend to be slack. The same thing is true with death and impermanence, realizing that we must complete parts of the path before death, we put effort.

Yeah. Yeah. Another question? Mhmm. Nice.

I just wanted to know why is it that recollecting death and impermanence is specifically or closely related as a foundation for practicing ethics and generosity? I understand it’s the basis for all virtuous acts all progress on the path, but why is ethics and generosity specifically mentioned and seemingly closely related? So the reason is as follows. Through meditating on death and impermanence, we become aware of the forthcoming lives. However, we wish not to be reborn in a state of poverty or affliction.

And to avoid being reborn in a state of poverty in future lives, we engage in the practice of generosity. We shall stop here for today. Yeah. Yeah. Everybody.

Thank you. If you would like to register for lunch on Sunday being provided by Tibetan Buddhist Institute, we have a you can write your name here and just to help us with catering and or send us an email tomorrow. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
guru yoga lama nel jor (Tib)
A practice in which one views the guru as inseparable from a deity or the Buddha, in order to amass the two collections of merit and wisdom and to purify negativities and obscurations. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top