Lam Rim – 2012-04-11

1 h 48 min · 4,310 words · 11 April 2012

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2012-04-11
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching begins with motivation and then explains suffering in two kinds, physical and mental, and how karma gives rise to physical suffering. It moves to the origin of suffering in the afflictions and the subtle self-grasping ignorance, which is opposed by the realization of selflessness, requiring a stable mind built on ethics and concentration. It then introduces the seven-limb prayer within Guru Yoga, covering prostration and offering, followed by questions and answers.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 49m

UUID: b282296d-564c-43e6-aeba-91acf5ed8ce7

Date: 2012-04-11

Words: 4,306

Regarding the generation of the motivation, in general, a motivation is necessary and this motivation should be at the very least the motivation of gaining a higher rebirth. Then such a motivation should be set on both the side of he who explains the teachings and the person who listens the teachings. And even though everything which is explained may not be of benefit to a given student, nonetheless the student should reflect that something at least will be of benefit and he or she will listen to it with that motivation. We should generate the motivation in keeping with our usage. As Āryadeva says, the wealthy suffer in their minds and the poor suffer in their flesh.

The meaning of this verse which was rooted in Āryadeva’s analysis of the predicament of all beings is that those who are well off suffer less bodily and more mentally while it is the opposite for the poor. And this can be seen firsthand in Geshe la’s homeland where people have great faith in the Buddhist teachings, but there is no clear analysis of the teachings in terms of reasoning and scriptural quotation. And based exclusively on this faith in the teachings, many people choose to become ordained thinking that being ordained is after all a very pleasant state of affairs. Thinking exclusively of this life and not thinking of future lives and relying on the advice of their parents who say to them, if you are a monk, if you are ordained, you will eat well, you will have a good situation, life will be easy for you. What is the motivation of these people?

Their main motivation is to eliminate bodily suffering. They can have no understanding of suffering from the standpoint of the mind since such an understanding is contingent on study and they have not studied.

Unfortunately, there are more and more people who become ordained for this reason based on these grounds and the root of this problem is the lack of study which as a result means that they do not look at the long term. These sufferings which are related to physical sufferings are for instance the sufferings of hunger, of thirst or of lacking adequate clothing of whom we all have direct or indirect experience. Now generally speaking, physical sufferings can be subdivided as was explained into two. Physical sufferings which are related to distant karma and physical sufferings which arise from a disturbance of the bodily elements in this life. Regarding physical suffering, we can see that physical suffering which arises on the foundation of the elements can either be eliminated through addressing the disturbance of the elements or through taking medicine from a well trained doctor.

However, if we examine the ultimate cause of this physical suffering, we can trace it back to karma which has been accrued in past lives. And for instance, if one is speaking of physical suffering within the context of a happy rebirth, for instance, physical suffering of a human being, then this physical suffering is the result of negative completing karma. Generally speaking, positive impelling karma which has caused rebirth as a human being was created in a past life. But negative completing karma through for instance, killing an animal such as a sheep, a cow or whatever has matured and this has caused suffering within this life as was clearly explained in the teachings on the 12 links Geshe la gave this weekend. When, however, one has committed an extremely heavy non virtuous deed such as killing forcefully a cow, a dog, a cat, then the only possible result is a result of maturation, which is a result or a rebirth in the lower realms.

This is experienced once and not over and again. And therefore, these results of maturation which are suffering on a physical level are results of powerful non virtuous karma accumulated in previous lives. Therefore, when suffering on a physical level is experienced, it generally can be seen as being as Geshe la explained of two possible sources rooted in that foundation of the elements in which case it can be healed through medicine or provoked mainly by karmic imprints from the past in which case irrespective of the medical treatment which is engaged in over and again the disease or the infirmity remains incurable. When such a disease, such an infirmity is incurable one has to then start thinking carefully about karma and causality. At this point, if one is a Buddhist, one has to think this is my karma.

This is something which I myself accumulated in previous lives in which only I can experience. If on the other hand, one believes in God, then one has to think this is God’s will. As for the other groups, Geshe la is not terribly sure what their viewpoint is. And regarding at present mental suffering, there are two categories of mental sufferings we have to consider. The first are the mental sufferings of expectations, which are under the sway of powerful afflictions such as desire and anger.

And the second are mental sufferings connected with intense virtue. And the second category of suffering, suffering which arises through the intense practice of virtue is for instance the suffering which arises when we study intensely difficult topics such as the Four Noble Truths or the generation of bodhicitta on the basis of great compassion. And however much we study, we still do not understand the topic. Suffering arises as a dependence of this. This suffering is virtue.

And we must distinguish very carefully between these otherwise we might think that all suffering is to be rejected. Now if we take the example for instance of a hearer, a Śrāvaka, who is practicing on the path of meditation and who is driven to attain the path of no more learning. In other words, the liberation of a Śrāvaka, meditating single pointedly on selflessness. When meditating in this way and the result does not arise, such a śrāvaka experiences a suffering which is part of the path of meditation. Another example would be the tears which flow spontaneously and the bodily hair which stands spontaneously on end in the mind of one who is meditating powerfully on great compassion and who thinks how is it that sentient beings cannot be free of suffering and of the causes of suffering.

Such a mind is a profoundly virtuous mind, yet there is a form of suffering which is associated with it. We cannot fully say that it is the sensation of some suffering which would be a little bit odd but there is definitely a suffering associated with it and this suffering is an extremely virtuous and powerful state of mind. And therefore, distinguishing in this way between the two subdivisions of mental suffering between that mental suffering, which is a suffering impelled by the delusions and that mental suffering which arises from great virtue is extremely benefic. Fundamentally, the mental suffering which arises from the delusions, which is under the sway of the delusions, if it continues, will abase us ever more and lead to a weakening of the resolve of the person and of their will. On the other hand, the mental suffering which arises from extreme virtue, the greater it is leads to an ever greater force and energy as well as courage in the person.

When we see the poor and the weak who are brutalized, are denied their rights and a mind arises within us thinking full of compassion for this poor person, overwhelmed with compassion, such a mind is a mind of virtue. So this topic of suffering with its two subdivisions into physical and mental sufferings in turn leads us to the issue of the origin of suffering. In other words, the second noble truth, the noble truth of the origin of suffering. And regarding the origin of these mental sufferings, for all of us do understand that they are rooted in the afflictions such as desire, competitiveness, jealousy, envy, pride. Nonetheless, it is one matter to understand this.

It is a very different matter to be able to eliminate them. If they could be eliminated in the same same way as Geshe la lifting the top of his cup from the table, then all of us would have no suffering in the slightest. This is not the case. Therefore, one must study over and again the great texts to understand how to eliminate them. And irrespective of what one is practicing, let us say Guru Yoga, if before a session we meditate carefully for five minutes, ten minutes, half an hour, if we have time even one hour or longer and after meditating take a text on the topic which we were meditating upon and look at it.

Then we will understand how various key points in this text are related to our practice. In this way study and practice help each other. And we can see that whatever difficult experiences we have are clearly rooted in non virtuous karma from the past. For instance, any suffering of our aggregates is directly rooted in non virtuous karma accumulated in the past. Now, what is undeniable that there is some physical suffering, some physical happiness, excuse me, or happiness within our remaining aggregates.

Nonetheless, the core of our experience is suffering. And all of these afflictions, desire, envy, jealousy, and so forth are rooted in none other than this mistaken mind which thinks I or mine. This mind is mistaken because its actual object is nonexistent. And therefore, the fact that these afflictions are rooted in ignorance and that ignorance is a mistaken mind which apprehends an object which in actuality is a non existent phenomenon must be made clear to us. This ignorance is none other than the mind which apprehends an autonomous person, which is an experiencer and enjoyer of the aggregates on the basis of the aggregates which are experienced and enjoyed by it as an autonomous entity.

This is none other than the subtle self of persons. The mind which refutes this is the mind which meditates or reflects on the subtle selflessness of persons. As sentient beings, in other words as migrators within cyclic existence, we are controlled by the delusions and the delusions themselves in turn are under the sway of the apprehension of a self. This apprehension of a self is the fundamental ignorance, this mistaken mind which has been controlling us since beginningless time. There is probably nothing else behind this beginningless mind.

As Dharmakīrti says in his Pramāna Vartika, it is from ignorance that the afflictions arise and from the afflictions all wrong behavior which gives rise to suffering. This ignorance is none other than the innate ignorance present since beginningless time. And likewise, Candrakīrti in his Madhyamakāvatāra says basically the same thing as Dharmakīrti in Pramāna So as Candrakīrti says in the Madhyamakāvatāra, the yogi tries to put an end to the apprehension of the self. In this context, this apprehension of the self which is an apprehension of a mistaken object is none other than the apprehension of a person which is not a mere nominal imputation on the basis of the aggregates from one’s own side but which actually has an autonomous existence independent of this mere nominal imputation on the basis of the aggregates. The non establishment of this autonomous existence apart from the mere nominal imputation on the basis of the aggregates is none other than emptiness.

The object of refutation, the object of negation of emptiness is this autonomous existence apart from a mere nominal imputation on the basis of the aggregates. And this refutation is none other than the affirmation of the subtle selflessness of persons. Any doubt regarding the existence of a certain autonomous self which exists independently of the aggregates on which it is imputed is as Āryadeva says sufficient to tear saṃsāra to shreds. In our case, this is what we should be putting effort in. We should be putting effort in understanding what the antidote to this mistaken mind, apprehending the existence of an autonomous self which exists apart from the mere self nominally imputed on the basis of the aggregates which are its basis of imputation is.

And in our case, the fact that this is difficult is due to the fact that we have no previous karmic imprints for this. On the other hand, we have an infinite number of previous karmic imprints strengthening anger, jealousy, competitiveness and spite. Therefore these arise with great ease within our minds whereas meditation on emptiness or on great compassion and bodhicitta do not.

If you take for instance this temple, there is no elephant in this temple at present. The nonexistence of the elephant or elephants in this temple at present is therefore an existent phenomenon because precisely there are no elephants in this temple. On the other hand, the existence of elephants in this temple is a non existent phenomenon precisely because there are no elephants in this temple. Through reasoning in this way, we can understand that the existence of a self which is autonomous and independent of the aggregates which are its basis of imputation is a non existent phenomenon and that non existence which is emptiness is an existent phenomenon. And we can see therefore that to be able to focus our minds single pointedly on such a subtle selflessness of persons, we need a stable mind.

Such a stable mind can only arise when fantasies and fancies are reduced. The reduction of fantasies and fancies can only occur with the reduction of desire and anger. This in turn is only possible when the mind’s outward slant is reduced and when the mind’s inward slant is increased. This in turn is only possible through the training in ethics which is the foundation for the training in concentration. Therefore, it is important to be able to bring our mind within and to analyze carefully by what means it is possible to bring our mind back within ourselves.

This is the foundation of training in concentration and on the basis of such training in Samādhi then one can meditate on the selflessness of persons. So if we study and meditate in this way, although it will be impossible for us to abandon the subtle apprehension of a self in this life, we nonetheless will be able to reduce it. Through reducing it, we will reduce afflictions such as desire, anger, envy, spite, hatred, jealousy, and in future lives will move upwards on the path. How are you? Geshe la thinks we are probably practitioners.

Then if we are practitioners, we should check how our anger, desire, envy, and spite have been behaving since we started practicing and whether they have reduced or not. If they have reduced over the years, then our practice is in the right direction. Otherwise, it is not. And if we are in the situation of those who memorize but are unable to retain, who reflect but are unable to understand the meaning, who meditate but gain no realizations. The time has come to put in practice the oral instruction which Mañjuśrī gave to Je Tsongkhapa which is to rely on the field of merit to accumulate merit.

This is not something which we can see, hear, smell or touch but it’s something we have to practice. So this is based on faith. Generally speaking in the Buddhist tradition we rely heavily on reasoning but this is based on faith. And within the preparatory rites, we have at present reached the fifth of the preparatory right on pages six seventy five of your English translation, the outline. In the text, it is page one seventy onwards, the offering of the seven limb prayer.

And as Dulpopa, Geshe-la thinks it is probably Geshe Dulpopa imparted as an oral instruction, if one does not endeavor to see the guru as inseparable from the tutelary deity even though one were to study for one century, one would gain no realizations. And these seven limbs are listed on page six seventy five. They are prostration or homage, offering, confession of sins, rejoicing and then moving to page six seventy six, requesting the wheel of dharma to be turned, petitioning the merit field not to enter nirvana and dedication. Now even though the Guru Yoga of Jetsongkapa, the 100 deities of Tuśita Ganden Lhagyama is very short. Nonetheless, all seven limbs are present within it.

Regarding the first limb of prostration or homage, there are three types of prostration or homage, physical, verbal and mental homage. Physical homage or physical prostration is of two different types. The prostration with five points of contact which is the one which Geshe la does where the two knees, the two hands and the head touch the ground and the long prostration. It is explained in Sūtra and it is said that the merit which is accumulated is contingent on the amount of ground which is covered. And when one offers prostrations, one’s hands must be folded with both thumbs folded within the palm.

This is the Buddhist method of offering prostration. Non Buddhist, Hindu traditions put both the thumbs outside. Then therefore, four points of contact of the folded hands, the top of the head, which creates a karma for obtaining the Buddha’s uṣṇīṣa or the crown protrusion the throat, which creates excuse me, the point between the eyes, which creates a karma for obtaining the Buddha’s beautiful hair the point at the throat which creates a karma for obtaining the Buddha’s speech which has 60 qualities and the point at the heart. Then when we offer the long prostration, we should stretch our whole body on the ground touching our body, touching the floor, the totality of our body. However, we should not stay stretched out.

Instead, we should rise as quickly as we can. This creates the karma for being liberated rapidly from cyclic existence. Moreover, when we stretch out, we should not close our hands in fist like this instead they should be open. Now there is a tradition of offering 100,000 prostrations and whole generally speaking, this is a very good thing to do. It may at times sound a bit grand and one must be very careful that one does not end up offering prostrations thinking exclusively of the number of prostrations one is offering.

Instead, one should offer correct prostrations with a correct motivation. What is the correct motivation for offering prostrations? It is to offer these prostrations motivated by the practice of the four forces. In other words, the force of the base, the force of repentance, the force of the antidote and so forth. The force of the antidote is that prostrations be an antidote to the faults and the afflictions.

Generally speaking, they are an antidote to the faults which are accumulated with respect to the three categories of vows. The Prātimokṣa vows, the Bodhisattva vows and the Tantric vows. The specific antidotes to each of these breaches should be applied. So in the case of Tantric vows, the specific antidote to breaches of the Tantric vows are the recitation of the Vajrasattva mantra, one rosary or more. It is said that if one offers 100,000 recitations of the Vajrasattva mantra, one can purify all breaches of the tantric vows.

Recitation of the Vajrasattva mantra in conjunction with prostrations is particularly powerful. There are numerous forms of prostrate of prostration. It is said for instance that when we see a representation of the body, the speech, or the mind of the Buddha, if we join our hands in reverence, we will accumulate

Great Roots of Virtue. Now in our case, it is quite surprising to see the reverence we show physical supports of the Buddha such as the statues which we have behind us. We always fold our hands when we see them. Yet we show no respect whatsoever to the Tripitaka or to Buddhist books. However, the true object of refuge are the books or the texts, not the statues.

The second of the seven limbs is the limb of offering. Here there are numerous different offerings such as the offering of water, of flowers, of incense and so forth. However, if we lack all of these, we can simply offer the roots of virtue which we have accumulated through study and meditation. And even if one does not study and therefore is unable to offer the roots of virtue of study and meditation, one can nonetheless mentally visualize flowers, visualize incense and offer these mentally offering great accumulating great virtue in the process. And the third limb will be the limb of confession.

We won’t enter into it during this teaching. Therefore, you have questions, Krishna will take one question now. We have to think about the questions perhaps. Yes, Jade. So just killing a sheep probably will not lead to a rebirth in the lower realms because of the weakness of the base.

The sheep is not a sufficient base for this in and of itself. Killing a human being would lead to such a rebirth as long as the action is accompanied by the four features which make the action complete. However, if we kill a sheep, then this can act as a completing karma which is going to cause suffering throughout a human life which is taken. Does that answer your question? Are there other questions?

Yes, Pamela. So if we take the suffering which arises within the context of the practice of great compassion through empathy, That suffering at the present moment is indeed suffering but it is virtue because the result the result of maturation of that suffering is happiness in future lives. For the present, it is not happiness. In the future, it will be happiness. Are there other questions?

Another questions. Yeah. You lost the debate. I I can’t hear you. My apologies.

It is the innate apprehension of a is beginningless. There is no beginning. In Geshe la’s case as an ordinary being, he can posit his own innate apprehension of the self as beginningless ignorance. Are there other questions? No.

No. Never. No. Geshe la does not think that suffering which arises from disturbance of the elements such as, let’s say, the flu, for instance, would be karma. Otherwise, karma would become very strange, he says.

Yes it is very difficult to posit clearly a difference between outer and inner interdependence. Outer interdependence is loosely, very loosely connected to karma and causality in terms of the cooperative conditions affecting beings. Inner interdependence on the other hand is exclusively connected to the substantial causes and cooperative conditions of karma and causality. His Holiness was probably thinking of the passage in Abhidharma which says the worlds arise from karma. Now generally speaking, this passage is to be interpreted since one distinguishes between the worlds which are the recipients for beings and the beings which are contained within the world.

While the beings which are contained within the world are definitely the product of karma, it seems difficult to say that the totality of physical events, cosmic events within the containing worlds are the product of karma and causality even though they do arise from empty eons and so forth. So the so called controlling cause, a third of the common causes is loosely connected to the individual karma of beings. To say that the totality of the environment in which a being is born is a result of the karma of that being seems a very difficult position. And do you have other questions? Yes, please.

Yes. Yes. Yes. My apologies. So the question basically is if karma is in us every rebirth, where does it reside?

Geshe la says, Karma resides in the substantial continuum of the mind. And if you ask what the substantial continuum of the mind is, it is simply the mind. So here when one speaks of karmic imprints perhaps it’s better to speak of karmic potencies because you might wonder what is imprinted in what. So these karmic potencies, according to the lower schools of tenets through the Chitamatra school, dwell within the mental consciousness. Now according to the Prāsaṇgika school, as Geshe la explained, conventionally, they dwell indeed in the mental consciousness, but ultimately, they dwell within the mere I.

All right. Yeah. Yeah.

Geshe la is not quite sure what this talk about inseparable nature might be. You can’t see text as inseparable from the Buddha. However, when we prostrate, we have to prostrate to the Buddha’s body, speech, and mind simultaneously. This is correct prostration. But why do we prostrate to the Buddha?

The Buddha himself cannot eliminate our suffering. He cannot bless us in any way. It is his teachings which eliminate our suffering. Therefore, we prostrate to him recognizing the qualities of his speech. As I said in Dharmakīrti’s Pramāna Vartika in the second chapter, it is through understanding that the Buddha’s speech is Pramāna Vaccha, speech which is a valid cognizer that in turn our faith in the four noble truths increases ever more.

And this in turn leads to an increase in our faith in the Buddha. Our teacher, Khensur Rinpoche, taught many times on the relation between the two truths, the conventional ultimate truths, the four truths, the four noble truths, as well as the meaning of innate ignorance, for instance, in his commentary on Bodhicittavivarāna. And Geshe la would like to encourage all of us to read or reread this carefully. His Holiness Dalai Lama has given numerous small teachings on these topics which are translated in English. Geshe-la would like to encourage us to complement his teachings by those.

Do you understand? Probably. Yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
guru yoga lama nel jor (Tib)
A practice in which one views the guru as inseparable from a deity or the Buddha, in order to amass the two collections of merit and wisdom and to purify negativities and obscurations. LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top