1 h 33 min · 3,948 words · 19 February 2012
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching presents dharma as inner transformation of the mind rather than external rituals, and explains the three trainings in ethics, concentration and wisdom as antidotes to desire, hatred and ignorance. It stresses using the limited daily practice time well, reflecting on death and impermanence, and the importance of calm abiding. A short question and answer section follows.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 34m
UUID: 8a5caccb-87b6-42d4-9054-554d04621c95
Date: 2012-02-19
Words: 3,944
Regarding the generation of the motivation both for teaching and for listening to the teachings, the greater the motivation, the greater the import or the impact of the deed one engages in. Therefore, here, one should try to generate a motivation rooted in these three principles of the past path as best one can. In other words, rooted in an understanding of renunciation of bodhicitta and of the view which realizes emptiness. And this motivation should be generated interactively with an interactive process of study and meditation, not by study alone, not by meditation alone, but by the two together. And then however much one chooses to study or meditate, it be one hour or less, nonetheless, one should always train in the practice of the beings of the three scopes with such a motivation.
We speak of dharma. The question is what precisely is this dharma we talk about? We say we practice, we engage in dharma. What are we doing? This is a difficult point.
If we analyze carefully, we can see that dharma is the generation principally of that mind which focuses mainly on future lives and strives to establish one’s welfare in future lives. And then if we look at the so called practice of Buddhism, of dharma around us, what we will see is that it means generally to, do one’s commitments from time to time and to celebrate the Buddhist festivities. Vesak, the day of miracles, to come to the temple on those days, to do some circumambulations, to do some prostrations and to pray for long. If we examine the nature of the prayers which are uttered, we would find that these inner prayers are probably exclusively dedicated to the vanities of this life. All of this has nothing whatsoever to do with Buddhism.
It is not dharma. Those who are ordained, monks and nuns, normally have a little bit more time for practice. Those who are not ordained, lay people with responsibilities, have very little time. Therefore, what time they have, they should dedicate to trying to study a little bit and to practice what they study. The reason for becoming ordained is exclusively to practice.
There is no other reason. We have more time to do this. Then in our own homes, we have the possibility to practice a bit.
To give an example, in Tibet, in the fifties and sixties, the Chinese occupiers put tremendous pressure on the Tibetans. And the Tibetans were very dedicated and devoted especially to going on pilgrimage. There were many holy sites. Some of it very difficult of access. Some you could only have access to in the summer when the snow had melted.
Others you could only access to at other times of the year. And in those pilgrimage sites, there were often many strange manifestations such as self emanated statues and so forth. The Tibetans would go and do as many circumambulations as they could of these. And the Chinese authorities, accused all Tibetans in general of being, bad people, but especially the dharma practitioners and within within these, the monks and nuns most specifically, they prevented these pilgrimages and beat those who tried to do them. And then despite the brutality of the Chinese forces, crowds, throngs of Tibetans would go to these pilgrimage sites to prostrate, to circumambulate them, facing beatings and punishment.
Then in the early nineteen eighties, 1981, ’82, ’83, ’84, the regime, the Chinese regime relaxed its hold on Tibet. It was possible to go for circumambulations. It was possible to study. If you wanted to become ordained, you could. And astonishingly, people stopped going on pilgrimage.
Where there had been big crowds before, there were now only one or two elderly. This is a clear sign that even though the dharma itself was profound, the people who were engaging in these practices because they had not studied did not understand the meaning of this dharma. The dharma had not entered into their mind and it was all externals. Therefore here you have the possibility to study and should avail yourself of that opportunity. Now the situation has once again become more difficult in Tibet when his holiness imparted the Kālacakra initiation this year in Bodhgaya, fewer Tibetans in Lhasa were able to come, and they faced difficulties both coming and returning.
And while the telephone lines were up and running before, and during the initiation, at present for the last month, it is impossible to telephone to Tibet, and it is also impossible to telephone inside Tibet from Lhasa to any of the other cities. Geshe la has no contact with his relatives anymore. Therefore, this so called dharma we engage in, which is making prayers, making prostrations, ritual practices, is fundamentally externals. Dharma involves the inner transformation of the mind in its very depths. If that is associated with these external practices, then they have meaning.
Otherwise, they can only lead to some temporary happiness. If we examine the state of the mind, our mind at present is beset by the afflictions. There are numerous presentations of the afflictions that in Asaṇga’s Abhidhamma Samuchaya, that in Vasubandhu’s Abhidhamma Kosha. But if we were to summarize, these three root afflictions are desire, hatred, and ignorance. And therefore, what is dharma?
Dharma is simply taking these three afflictions, which which are desire, hatred and ignorance as our target and applying three antidotes to these three afflictions. The three antidotes to these three afflictions of desire, hatred and ignorance are the three trainings of ethics, of concentration, and of wisdom. These three trainings, in Tibetan, are called the three trainings because they are that in which we train. We might wonder at this point in the great monasteries, the great seats, the monks study for a very long period of time, for numerous years in great depth. What hope have we who cannot engage in these studies?
We should not think in this way. We should think that we all are beset by these three poisons, desire, hatred and ignorance. And all we have to do is within our own minds apply the three antidotes to these three poisons, which are the three trainings of ethics, concentration, and wisdom. Then in the great monasteries, the study program is designed for a large number of monks who put great effort in their studies. And therefore dharma practice is simply applying against the three objects of abandonment which are the three poisons, the three antidotes which are the three trainings.
There is no dharma practice apart from this. If we can resume our dharma practice in this, this would be of tremendous benefit for us. Now, which of the three trainings acts as antidote to which of the afflictions? Ethics, the training in ethics acts as antidote to desire mainly. And when we speak of the training in ethics, there are three different ways of training in ethics.
The one which concerns us since it is something which all of us commit to do is that ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 known virtues. So if we train in this, desire will decline in our mind stream and happiness will increase. And therefore, how does this proceed? When we apply the antidote of ethics, of the training in ethics to desire, this progressively reduces the mental wandering which is induced by desire. As this mental wandering is reduced, our minds progressively become happier.
Mhmm. This is the main way to establish our own happiness. It is different from helping others in hospitals and so forth when they’re in a state of need. This is focused on our own happiness. For instance, to take the case of Adrian, Gesheila believes Adrian has a very large house.
Then if one has a very large house, there are very large problems. The very large problems of maintenance and cleaning and worries and whatnot. Mhmm. Right? Isn’t that?
Yeah. Good. I’m I’m just joking. No problem. Must be a very comfy house.
If you had many children, you could put them to work, but living alone I guess I was just joking about your house. And this is the main focus of the Vaibhāṣika School. The Vaibhāṣika focuses on the reduction of desire through teachings on how to control one’s intake of food, how to live in a very modest setting and so forth. This is explained in detail in the treatises on Vinaya. And therefore, through reducing the stronghold of desire within our minds through the antidote of the training and ethics, our minds
More pacified. And as a result, we can then engage in the training of concentration. Then the second training, the training in concentration probably acts mainly as an antidote to hatred and to anger. This is the case because hatred and anger are strongly connected with the plane we live in, the desire realm. And they are broadly speaking absent in the higher realms.
Once one, trains in the training of concentration, training for instance in Samatha and Vipassana, one accumulates the specific causes for being reborn in the higher realms in which anger is absent. Independence then on a sound training in concentration, one can engage in the training in wisdom, specifically in a Vipassana, which focuses on eliminating the ignorance, which is an apprehension of the true self existence of the I. On the one side, the uncommon lineage of and his root guru is that the specific antidotes for the three poisons of desire, hatred, and anger desire, hatred, and ignorance are these three principles of the path. Renunciation acting as an antidote to desire, bodhicitta an antidote to anger, and the correct view of emptiness, an antidote to ignorance. Alternatively, as is explained in liberation in the palm of your hand by Pabongka Rinpoche, The totality of a day is subdivided into periods in which one is in session and periods between the sessions.
This day of twenty four hours is therefore subdivided to the sessions and period between the sessions in turn weeks, months, years, and eventually a whole human life can be understood in terms of these two subdivisions. And in turn, the session is subdivided into three parts, the preliminaries, the actual body of the session, and the conclusion of the session. Now regarding a human life, if we take an ordinary day of twenty four hours, we can see that within that day there is a time which we need for sleeping that is to be discarded. Then the time we spend working that also we discard. Then the time spent eating and in conversation that as well we discard and then in a day of twenty four hours at the most two to three hours are left for practice.
These two to three hours have to be spent well. How can we spend them well? Through reflecting on the fact that the being, the person that we are at present, acts under the impulse of his or her mind. And this mind in turn if we examine acts under the impulse of the afflictions. Therefore, it has no independence.
It is enslaved. We want freedom. Therefore, we must find a way to take control of our mind and turn our mind towards virtue in a stable fashion for two to three hours. That our mind is under the control of the afflictions. Every one of us in this room, when we check our mind, know for a fact.
Now in our case, whatever practices and commitments we might have, whether it is Yamāntaka or Vajrayoginī, if we are honest with ourselves and we examine our minds when we engage in the Sadhana, we will see Geshe la can certainly speak for himself. He cannot speak for us that our minds are scattered. It is very difficult for the mind to be concentrated on anything. And as his holiness, the Dalai Lama has said during the Kālacakra initiation, If we are honest with ourselves, we can see that what we really need is śamatha. Once we have śamatha, our minds will focus on what we set them upon.
I myself put effort at that. I have, as someone has said, some experience of bodhicitta. I have tried to gain some experience of emptiness, and you yourself should do the same. So Geshe la says, without this training in concentration, it is very difficult for us to achieve anything. So we can see that for ourselves a stable concentration, in other words, a state of shamata is important.
In the past, in Dharamsala, there were retreatants who, it is said, attained śamatha, then a couple, three or four at present. Probably, are some as well. And in the context of training in Samatha, within the nine, mental abidings which lead to Samatha, the eighth mental abiding is one in which the mind remains single pointedly and with perfect clarity on whatever object of observation one chooses. However, it is necessary initially to put some effort to place the mind on the object for months or years. However, as soon as one has attained the ninth level of mental abiding, the mind focuses on the object indefinitely as long as one chooses without striving, without effort.
And then in turn, moving onwards to the training in wisdom. Once we have achieved the training and concentration, if we place our mind single pointedly, for instance, on the impermanence of the, aggregates, the five aggregates, then our mind remains focused on the impermanence of the aggregates for as long as we wish, weeks, months, or even years. For ordinary beings such as ourselves and Geshe la, we are, without any doubt, 100% under the control of the afflictions, and we have no self control of any type. Then as one progresses upwards on the paths, the path of accumulation, of preparation, of seeing, then eventually the path of meditation and of no more learning, one becomes more and more free. At the level of the path of accumulation at which the wisdom arisen from meditation, which is a conceptual realization of emptiness arises.
While there may be some influence of the afflictions, it is very limited and they are very subtle. It is said that at the level of the path of seeing at which one has direct realization of emptiness, then at that level one is no longer impelled. Having seen the truth, one is no longer impelled. In other words, one has freedom in this respect. For us, this is the road to follow.
What time do you go to sleep? What time do you go to sleep and how many hours do you sleep? Two past two, two past twelve. Yeah. Ten hours.
You work eight hours a day more or less. Right? Yes. Breakfast, hour, and lunch, hour, and dinner, one hour, two hours, go. And therefore, in the
Hours which are left after all of this, we should use our time well and not waste it. We should use it for study and so forth. Now within these five hours, ideally, we would dedicate all of them to study and meditation. In reality, this does not happen. We should try to dedicate as much as we can.
Śāntideva’s Bodhisattva Acharya Avatara says that it is difficult to dedicate even one minute to serious meditation, with concentration. Good. And then even if we have not studied and do not understand a lot, when we do our commitments, at least we should do them focusing on the meaning and trying to visualize carefully. Now regarding our lives in a day of twenty four hours, there is so little time that we should ask ourselves at the end of the day, have I actually practiced pure dharma today? Have I practiced pure dharma and for how long?
If we have for a couple of minutes, that is excellent. We should keep in mind that our situation is that of somebody who is being aimed at by the Lord of Death, by Yama with his great bow. The bow is strung. The arrow is pointed at us, and we have no control on when the arrow will be released. We cannot ask time to slow its flow for us.
It will not. It will pass. And regarding the outline, the second outline in the presentation of death and impermanence: at the time of death is uncertain. While it is said indeed that in Uttarakuru, the lifespan is fixed and that in the, higher, realms of cyclic existence, it is well nigh immeasurable. We shall just put this aside for the time being.
This is these are extremely hidden phenomena attested in scriptures. We have no access to this. If we look at this world of Oz, we can see that the time of death is extremely uncertain. Some die in the morning, some die in the evening, some die while they are eating, some die while they are sleeping. To think that we will be able at the time of death to slow the flow of time and say, give me a break.
I want to do some months in a retreat is fantasy. And regarding the second, subdivision that the causes of death are numerous, and this is the second subdivision of the second, main division, and the causes of life are few. We can see for ourselves that our situation is that of a butter lamp placed in a storm. As the wind is blowing to the left and the right, what are the chances of the butter lamp remaining lit? And therefore, of procrastinating and saying I will practice tomorrow, I will practice next month, next year or after I retire, we should realize that there is no certainty in our life.
And therefore, whenever we have a moment, whenever we have time, we should practice. This is what his holiness recommends. Regarding the third outline that at the time of death, dharma alone is of benefit. This is 100% true. We can see that every single human being in the excuse me, every single human being in the distant past has passed on.
And at the time of our death, whatever we own, however much wealth we have, however many friends, family members, and however strong our body, we will all have to leave these, behind us. We can see quite clearly that our situation at that time is similar to that which brought us in this life. We are in this life with this body because of karma from a past life which acts as the propelling cause giving rise to our set of aggregates in this life. In this life in turn, we accumulate karma which will act as the propelling cause giving rise to our aggregates in future lives. Therefore, at the time of our death, it is exclusively the virtue within our mind stream which makes a difference.
If Geshe la takes his own example, at present, the man known as Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen exists. At the time of his death. That man will cease to exist. That is strange, isn’t it? And for this reason, Namkapel, the author of Mind Training Like the Rise of the Sun says, reflecting and meditating on the fact that death is certain, the time of death is uncertain, and at the time of death, the only, thing which is of benefit is dharma practice, we should then generate the wish to train in the three trainings of renunciation, bodhicitta, and the view realizing emptiness, and specifically in the training of bodhicitta since that is the main thrust of this of Lojong.
And we will stop at the third outline. And therefore, what is the way we should, behave? As was explained, a human life can be divided into the period between sessions and the period within sessions. Sessions themselves are subdivided into three. The preliminary is the body and the conclusion of the session.
Now regarding our behavior between sessions, the Buddha has advised to keep in mind four things. The first is to practice the shared ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues. The second is to be moderate in one’s consumption of food. The third is not to sleep too much, to go to bed late and to get up early. And, the fourth is to be moderate in one’s general behavior.
If we behave in this way, we can see there will be direct benefit for ourselves in this life. If we do not eat too much, we will benefit. Likewise, if we can get up at a reasonable, hour, we have time to practice and so forth. And then during one’s job, one should try to be good natured, to have a good nature and to work for the sake of others. And if one does this, then it is 100% certain that one’s job will go well as well.
Then we have finished for today. And if you have two questions, Vishal will take two questions at present. Yes. All depends on the motivation. Definitely, if the motivation of helping others in a hospital is actually to alleviate the suffering of another person, for their own sake and not, for instance, to promote oneself to have a good social image and so forth, then definitely virtue would be accumulated.
Otherwise, it is difficult to see how virtue could be accumulated. Are there other questions?
So in this context, the explanation of the desire realm and the two higher realms, the form and the formless realm are shared by the Buddhist and the non Buddhist. There’s no difference in the presentation. The higher realms are realms in which the exterior manifestations of the truth of suffering are absent, but they are part of cyclic existence nonetheless. In addition, there is dharma practice in these realms in the form and formless realms since it is said in text that there are in these realms both practitioners on the paths of accumulation and preparation in general and Mahāyāna practitioners on the paths of accumulation and preparation. It is even said that there are beings who attain these paths in the higher realms.
Moreover, it is said that in these realms, because they are characterized by great mental pacification, there is neither hatred nor anger. Therefore, the beings in these realms have uncommon capacities. And the following question regarding last week’s class, Geshe la explained that meditation on death and impermanence and karma and causality enables one to face up to the difficulties of this life and increases one’s mental fortitude. What, how is this the case? Well, Geshe la says, generally speaking, if we do not meditate on death and impermanence, then at the time of our own death, we will experience tremendous fear and anguish with great suffering as a result thereby.
The main means to preventing this fear and anguish from occurring at the time of death is to habituate ourselves to the thought of our own death day by day and year by year through meditating on death in impermanence. This eliminates fear and suffering at the time of our own death. In addition, this acts as an antidote to desire. All beings fear death, not only human beings. An animal, when it approaches a precipice, will shrink from the precipice and draw back out of fear of its own death.
However, the animal does not have any means to counter this fear and to eliminate the suffering at the time of its own death. As human beings, we do have this possibility. Mhmm. Alright.
Key terms in this teaching
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- graduated path of the three capable beings kye bu sum gyi lam gyi rim pa (Tib)
- The three levels of practice of the lower, middle and higher capable being, based on the motivations of trying to attain a better future rebirth, liberation or enlightenment. Also known as the three scopes. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
- three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
- Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
- Yama shinchi dagje (Tib)
- The Lord of Death, seen on the Wheel of Life. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
How does meditating on death and impermanence help us face the difficulties of life and strengthen our mental fortitude?
Without meditating on death and impermanence, we will experience tremendous fear and anguish, and great suffering as a result, at the time of our own death. The main way to prevent this is to habituate ourselves to the thought of our own death day by day and year by year. This eliminates fear and suffering at the time of death, and it also acts as an antidote to desire. All beings fear death, not only humans. An animal approaching a precipice shrinks back out of fear of its own death, but it has no means to counter that fear or to eliminate its suffering at death. As human beings, we do have this possibility.