1 h 37 min · 3,989 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk teaches definite emergence (the mind striving for liberation), explained as distinct from renunciation, with common and fully characterized forms at the small and middling scope levels. It draws on Je Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path and distinguishes faith in the Triple Gem from taking refuge, and causal from resulting refuge. Much of the session is taken up with student questions.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 37m
UUID: 92de0da8-95c7-4fa6-b0c9-5725ac8c115c
Words: 3,985
Mhmm. Oh, yeah. So regarding definite emergence, there are two types of definite emergence. Common definite emergence, which is present at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope, and fully characterized definite emergence which is present at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope. So here there is a traditional translation of the Tibetan term Nianjung as renunciation which is a bit problematic because it seems to imply that one has to give up one’s body and one’s possessions, and this is a little bit difficult.
The precise translation of in English is definite emergence. Now one definitely emerges into what? Into one’s goal or the object of attainment which is liberation and therefore this conveys a meaning of the mind striving for liberation. So the term definite emergence conveys the meaning in a better way than renunciation, which does not really convey the meaning of the term. And therefore here with a mind which is saddened by cyclic existence, in other words, a mind which sees the faults of cyclic existence, one then generates definite emergence.
In other words, one generates the mind striving for liberation. The meaning is the same. And there are as is taught in the Buddhist scriptures, therefore two types of renunciation. What is known as common renunciation present at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope and what is known as special or fully characterized renunciation present at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope. Now, it is difficult to generate common renunciation through meditating only on the topics of meditation of the past shared with the being of the small scope, whether they be the five or the seven topics of meditation.
Because what one is trying to generate is a state of mind which says that this life, this time literally is empty of substance. Then to generate this, one must rely on the verses of Je Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path in which Je Tsongkhapa says, so through becoming habituated to the fact that leisure and endowment are rare and this life is fleeting, turn away from the vanities of this life. And here there were two elements to this reflection. The first is understanding the preciousness of leisure and endowment and blending or combining this with an understanding that this life is fleeting. Now the instrumental in Tibetan Gompei which means through or by is quite profound as well as a term Gompa or habituation which is a very weighty term.
So some among you are new and it may be a little bit harder for them, but overall this is not a difficult topic. If we present the path shared with the being of this small scope in terms of five topics, we have the first, which is identifying a rebirth of leisure and endowment. Then death and impermanence, meditation on the lower realms, refuge and karma and causality. Now it is difficult independence on these five topics of meditation to generate common definite emergence. One has to rely on the verse of Je Tsongkhapa and through habituating, then that will arise.
Do you understand? Okay. Now the realization of the path shared with the being of the small scope is an ethics which abstains from the 10 non virtuous deeds. Now the understanding of this ethics is itself not a difficult topic. It mainly focuses on the non virtuous deeds of body and speech, but the practice is not necessarily easy.
And here it is once one is able to generate a stable mind of restraint that one can in turn accumulate virtuous karma potencies or seeds. Now generating such a stable mind of restraint is not easy. For instance, in our case, in this room, a majority of us are followers of Buddha Śākyamūni and have a refuge. Yet whether we have a stable mind of refuge is open to question. Now here, it is important once once one has taken a refuge to maintain one’s refuge vows.
And therefore, it is important to generate a conviction in the triple gem or a faith in the triple gem. This conviction or this faith are what is needed for us and they are not that easy to generate since even this life we see people who lack faith or conviction in their own parents. Then one meets people who have no trust or faith in their parents, no trust or faith in their partners, no trust or faith in their children, and then if one is able to convince them that the Triple Gem is truly worthy of trust and faith, then one is able to fill the emptiness in their lives. Otherwise, their minds will become profoundly troubled. Now here all of you enjoy study and therefore Geshela would like to enter in-depth in these topics and would like to ask you a question.
Is there in your opinion a distinction between on the one hand faith in the triple gem and on the other hand having taken refuge in the triple gem. So last Wednesday, Geshela as you remember explained what dharma was and the distinction between Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna dharma. And therefore, he would like today to ask you, do you make a distinction between the face which entrusts itself to the triple gem and taking refuge in the triple gem or not. What happened? This is called causing you problems.
Yes I would say there is a distinction and that is that there are some people who have taken refuge in the Triple Gem who have no faith and there are some people who have faith in the Triple Gem and who have not taken refuge. Yes, yes. Without faith, it is difficult to see how they would be refuge. What’s the difference? There’s a distinction between a faith that’s based in reason and one that’s just a correctly assuming mind that doesn’t fully understand the benefits of refuge in situations around Is there a difference between the faith which entrusts itself to the triple gem or taking refuge in the triple gem or not?
I would say faith is necessary in order to take a refuge whether it’s fully characterized or not. I asked what is the different? Faith, which entrusts itself to the triple gem and taking refuge, what is the difference? Is there a difference? I would say no.
If you are entrusting oneself to the triple gem that is taking refuge. I would say there is a difference Triple gem. I think faith is recognizing the triple gem as virtuous, but taking refuge is promising to follow the path that the Buddha taught. And my example given would be, for example, in children who perhaps are born into a Buddhist family. They may have faith but may not have taken refuge yet.
I would say there is a difference because faith is like you just refuge is taking is like you’re taking vows, you will honor that vow. You know, the five or six vow that we take is we have to Okay. So there is a difference and it is important to understand it. Faith which entrusts itself to the triple gem, entrusts itself to the triple gem reflecting on the qualities, the potency, the benefit of the triple gem. On the other hand, taking refuge in the triple gem occurs independent on thinking of the difficulties a triple gem can protect us from.
Therefore, there is a difference in terms of the reason between these two states of mind. Then it is very helpful to reflect in this ways through studying the Lamrim in this way, one’s understanding will become stable. Then we’re going to get all wrapped up if we are not careful here. So from time to time, I think we’re going to relax and as Geshela has explained, I will ask you questions. There are three types of refuge.
There is the refuge of the path of the being of the small scope, of the path of the being of the middling scope, the path of the being of the great scope. Akeisha, would like to ask you at present, what distinction, if any, there is between the refuge of the path shared with the being of the middling scope and definite emergence, the mind striving for liberation? To check the question is the difference between the aspiration of the being of the middling scope and definite emergence. Is that correct? Yep, just checking.
So object the of observation of definite emergence is liberation and the object of observation of refuge I would imagine would be the Triple Gem, the Buddha, the Dharma and the Sangha and so I would say the object of observation is different. That’s very good. You brought up the issue of the object of observation. Another answer. So if we proceed in this way, then our understanding is good, would have broadened and as a result, our studies are going to broaden as well.
So definite emergence, the goal is liberation. Taking refuge is the means. I mean the ultimate refuge is the, in terms of the four noble truths, is the truth of cessation, the path which is the middling scope. The desire is liberation. So in that sense, taking refuge is the means to that end.
But I can’t make a distinction otherwise. The object of observation is different. For definite emergence, it’s liberation. When one takes refuge, one is taking refuge and becoming enlightened. So it’s a different object of observation.
So let us take an example. These days, the weather is quite cold. Then when one is outside, one is beset by the cold weather and suffering from the suffering of cold, one wishes to get warm and one then goes in the temple which is warmed by the reverse cycle air conditioning unit. Now this wish to be warm, in other words, to be freed from the suffering of cold, that is taking refuge. So now at the level, this is an example now, at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope, we can say that the foundation is the same for the mind seeking for refuge in the triple gem and for definite emergence.
In both cases, the thoughts of psychic existence are seen. In one case, one goes for refuge, in another case, one strives for liberation. Then you brought up the issue of the object of observation. This makes things far clearer because when at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope, one takes refuge, one is generating a mind which hopes for freedom from suffering. Whereas, when at the level of the being of the middle scope, one strives for liberation, then one’s goal is liberation.
So the objects of observation are different. Refuge is a stable mind, which places its hope in the triple gem. Now here in general when we speak of refuge, we are referring to the causal refuge. However, we should keep in mind the existence of the resulting refuge, the refuge at the time of the effect, which is the refuge we take in our own attainments on the basis of our putting effort and obtaining them eventually. So the issues I have brought up so far are the distinction between a faith which entrusts itself to the triple gem and refuge which takes refuge in the triple gem, number one.
And secondly, the distinction at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope between taking refuge on the one hand and the mind of definite emergence on the other hand. Now, one should also try to understand the distinction between striving for liberation on the one hand and great compassion on the other hand, or for that matter between great compassion and bodhichitta. If one does this, then one’s understanding will become extremely stable. So if you reflect intensely on these topics, then this is none other than meditation. Meditation amounts to withdrawing your mind inwards from whatever exterior distractions there are and focusing on these topics.
And then we have a specific time for questions after the recitation of prayers. Alternatively, you can ask questions when you feel like on the outside as well. The etymology of the term meditation, gom in Tibetan, is to focus the mind on an object of observation in a continuous fashion. Then you can meditate as long as you want twenty, thirty minutes on these topics, the distinction between taking refuge on the one hand, striving for liberation, and definite emergence, and so forth. So we can meditate for twenty minutes, is it?
So let us I think ten minutes for ten minutes. Would you like to open the prayer book, page one? We recite one b, two, three, four, and, of course, page five, number six mandala offering, verse one and three. So if one reflects carefully, there is an important distinction between refuge on the one hand and for instance, definite emergence on the other hand. When one goes for refuge, one turns towards the triple gem and one says, I beseech you for protection from the difficulties and sufferings.
I entrust myself to you. I myself lack that capacity. On the other hand, when one takes definite emergence, the mode of taking definite emergence probably involves saying, I myself resolve to do this. This is an important difference. You seem a bit confused but if you reflect on this carefully then the more you think about the stable it will get.
So, at present Geshela will take your questions. Ask your questions. We have time today. Yes, so nearly at once. Before you know, just one question, one each.
So, at first, please one question per person. So you’ve had time to prepare these questions. You’ve had ten, fifteen minutes meditation, right? It’s very helpful if you proceed in this way. Think about the topics and ask your questions.
Otherwise, if I only present the material, then it is of limited benefit to you. It’s very relaxed for Geshele myself. Yeah, we are relaxing. Today, looks you know, all day. The burden is on you tonight.
I’m hearing that the distinction lies in an element of conviction in oneself, in one’s capacity to be able to tread the path. Being the difference between beseeching the triple gem because I’m unable to do it And then there seems to be a point where one recognizes that it’s up to oneself and one can and must do it oneself and therefore goes for definite emergence. Yes. Yes. Geshela said that whether we have a stable refuge is open to question.
What’s the definition of a stable refuge? Then if one is able to induce the realization of the Four Noble Truths by mean of a valid cognizer, then one can say that one has stable refuge. What are the differences between the three types of refuge for small, mid and great scope? So the difference hinges on the motivation. The refuge of the being of the small scope is a refuge taken for the sake of being protected oneself from rebirth in the lower realms.
The refuge of the being of the middling scope is a refuge taken for protection from the sufferings of psychic existence. And the refuge of the being of the great scope is a refuge taken for the sake of liberating all sentient beings from the sufferings of psychic existence. Geshela, I was wondering if, the refuge of the being of the small scope could also be divided into three. That there is a being of the small scope who undertakes the ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues in order to gain a future higher rebirth for their own benefit or in order to practice liberation or in order to attain full and utter enlightenment? So there could be three different kinds of refuge for the being of a small scope.
How can this be at the level of the path of being a small scope? They’re just the being this being is practicing the the ethics, which is abandonment of the 10 non virtues, but their motivation is different. They’re seeking a higher rebirth either for their own benefit or for liberation which are different. So a person might seek a higher rebirth either for their own benefit so that they have a better life in the future or they might do the same thing in order to practice the dharma in order to attain liberation. Either way it’s Motivation is the key here.
With refuge, it has that aspect of being protection from suffering with causal refuge. Is the point of attaining uncontrived great compassion when the resolve that all sentient beings be free and that I shall free them, It seems that at that point we’re then taking on the role of protecting others from suffering. Is it at that point that that becomes resulting refuge? So no. That is slightly inappropriate.
The difference between causal and resulting refuge lies in whether there is a difference between the continuum between of oneself and the object of refuge or not. So if one takes causal refuge, then one’s own continuum and that of the object of refuge, in this case Buddha Śākyamūni are different. On the other hand, resulting refuge is a a refuge in which one’s own continuum and that of the object of refuge are not different. Instead, one takes refuge in one’s own future attainment of full and utter enlightenment, independence of oneself putting effort. Overwhelmingly at present, the majority of us take causal refuge.
Taking resulting or effect refuge calls for a very careful analysis and resolve to escape from psychic existence. I hadn’t quite I hadn’t thought about the difference between taking refuge and definite emergence in the way that Geshela has explained it. Because I had always thought that taking refuge was an act and I can remember Rinpoche talking about the cave and being outside in the rain and Geshela used the idea of being outside in the cold and wanting to come inside and the act of taking refuge was the coming inside and so the idea of wanting to definitely emerge from suffering, the act of doing the practice is the act of refuge, you know, because it’s not it’s not just saying please protect me, but I will take refuge as an active action and therefore I guess I had seen the two intertwined and I hadn’t quite separated them in the way that Geshela was saying where I beseech you is the act of taking refuge and I will do it as definite emergence. Yes. So the example which Kinsu Rinpoche gave is a very powerful one.
When it is raining outside and one wishes for protection from this heavy rain, then one must go inside and one generates the strong stable wish or hope to go inside. And this strong hope that is refuge. We asked Khensur Rinpoche for the distinction between generating the Mahāyāna mind, in other words bodhichitta and Mahāyāna refuge and unlike other Geshes, Khensur Rinpoche refused to answer directly and said this is a very important point which calls for careful thinking. So my question relates to a fledgling Buddhist when we first take the first step to becoming a Buddhist and take refuge, is Geshela saying that that mind is a stable mind at the very beginning when we don’t know well some of us don’t know very much at that point. This depends on the context but if one takes refuge based on faith alone, it is difficult for that to be a stable refuge.
One must study carefully for refuge to be stable. Then, however, don’t worry, you have the opportunity to study, your faith will become stable. You know? I imagine to recognizing death is one of the most important things in regards to the refuge and are there distinction in regards to the small, mid milling, mid large scope in in in of the are there any distinction in means of understanding? Between the small, the middle and the great scope.
So in the Lamrim there is a technique of meditation called the nine point death meditation The most beneficial aspect of that meditation for our mind, in other words, sharpest, is the uncertainty of the time of death. Geshela began by saying that it was difficult to generate common refuge based on those five topics of the lower scope but then went on to say the two key elements of the first in three principles of the path were the preciousness of leisure and endowments and the fleeting nature. They seem to be the two key elements of the five topics of the lower scope. So what’s the difference between Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path and the lower scope? So these two are not contradictory however there are numerous ways of presenting the seven topics of the path shared with the being of the small scope need to be meditated upon one by one to generate this realization.
Whereas, the three principles of the path are a summarized form of this in which two key elements are linked. Would like to ask about the small scope, precious human rebirth and we were taught that to take refuge and practicing to get a high human rebirth but it’s also depending also on the state of the mind when you nearly the death stage and I witnessed that the my relative that they died, they go into hospital but they didn’t get peaceful death and they, you know, the relatives around want to keep the other one alive and then they ask all the nurse and doctor to put drip into, you know, like morphine and you know, render them to have a peaceful day but also at the last day when they leave the body, they also, you know, the nurse also come in to check that, you know, the time of death, so my question is how do you gain a peaceful death with no disturbance to get a high rebirth or something like that? So one needs to practice and to practice regularly. Habit is a very powerful force. Otherwise, at the time of death, we will not be able to use the subtle mind which appears.
I’ve been reading the handbook of near death experiences from the TBI bookshop and in it it talks about people who during their near death experience episodes they come across figures of those who have already died. How does this reconcile with if the people who have passed haven’t been reborn? So these are due to paranormal perceptions or paranormal powers. It also happens that the children can see their parents of previous lives as well. This is probably due to the memories we have of our parents from before.
There was one account of a man who had a near death experience and he saw an unfamiliar man during that episode. And afterwards, on his own mother’s deathbed, he discovered that he was actually the illegitimate child of not the man who raised him, but his biological father turned out to be the man that he saw in his near death experience when his mother showed him the photo. So in that sense, that would not have been memory. These cases do happen certainly. What would happen is that a powerful karmic imprint or a memory would be imprinted in the very young infant’s subtle mind and that would ripen much later at the time of death in this case.
Okay, thank you. Thank you, Page nine. Eight p.
Key terms in this teaching
- causal refuge
- The objects of refuge - the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha - existing in the mental continua of others, as opposed to resultant refuge. Only by relying upon these external refuge objects can we achieve our own internal resultant refuge. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mandala offering
- The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
- nine-point death meditation
- The nine-point death meditation is an important meditation on the impermanence of this life. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
How do the refuges taken by beings of the small, middling and great scope differ from one another?
The difference lies in the motivation. The refuge of the being of the small scope is taken for the sake of protecting oneself from rebirth in the lower realms. The refuge of the being of the middling scope is taken for protection from the sufferings of psychic existence. The refuge of the being of the great scope is taken for the sake of liberating all sentient beings from the sufferings of psychic existence.