1 h 28 min · 4,100 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk begins with definite emergence (renunciation) as the essence of the path and reflects on fear of death, which is reduced by lessening attachment to this life and understanding future lives. It explains that overcoming death means abandoning the afflictions to reach arhatship, and that karma is accumulated through intention and deed. Students then question how karmic imprints form, using a possum example. The recording ends with announcements about an upcoming Chokhor Duchen puja.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 28m
UUID: 82510edd-680a-4928-846e-b33a1a8e5db7
Words: 4,096
So as is said in the preliminary verses of the three principles of the path, the meaning of the essence of all of these scriptures of the conquerors. And usually, this verse is held to refer to definite emergence. So if I speak of the thought of definite emergence, you probably understand what I am trying to refer to. And within this verse, conquerors refer obviously to the Buddhas, and the scriptures refer to the utterances of the Buddhas. In other words, sutras and tantras.
Sometimes there are topics which if we do not reflect reflect on them, are problematic and when we engage in them are also problematic. That is not the case with the three principles of the path. However, much we reflect on definite emergence on bodhicitta and on the view of emptiness, the deeper our understanding will become. So why precisely is a sort of definite emergence the meaning of the essence of all the scriptures of the conquerors simply because whether one is referring to hearers, to solitary realizers, or to bodhisattvas, none of these three categories of beings can be said to have entered the path without definite emergence. Then one could say that it is in dependence on the thought of definite emergence that the totality of the dharma arises, but this was would perhaps lead us too far.
Definitely, it is in dependence on the thought of definite emergence that one can extrapolate the four noble truths. Now if we wish to subdivide definite emergence, we can see that there are two types of definite emergence. There is ordinary definite emergence and special definite emergence. Ordinary definite emergence is generated at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope. Special or fully characterized definite emergence is generated at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope.
Now ordinary definite emergence is the realization or the attainment of the practitioner on the path shared with the being of the small scope. So one can say that once one has generated, one has attained the realization of the path shared with the being of the small scope. The greatest hardship we experience in this life of us is death. And in our cases, we have to prepare for this. It is not the case that it is not possible to prepare.
It is possible to do so, But, we must train and meditate for this. Do you offer of death? And are you afraid of death? Yes. Agree or Are you all afraid of death?
No. Really? Why? Is asking you, are you personally afraid of death? Good.
Good. Good. Very good. Thank you. So now regarding the fear of death, it has several components.
The first is a fear due to attachment to the vanities of this life, the possessions of this life. And the second is obviously a fear of the thereafter. In our cases, perhaps, the first is dominant. Then there are means to counter this fear. And the realization of the path shared with the being of a small scope is the elimination of the fear of death.
And this fear of death arises for ordinary beings like ourselves, first, because of our attachment to the vanities of this life, so this can be countered. And in addition, from a mundane standpoint, it arises from the fear of annihilation after death. So here, one should therefore reflect carefully on the vanities of this life and try to reduce one’s attachment to them. It is not that we can manage completely without the affairs of this life, but we have to reduce our attachment to them. And in addition, all of us understand, hopefully, the existence of past and future lives.
Then once one thinks about this, there should be no fear. Do you understand? So initially, one must understand the meaning, and then one must appropriate it mentally integrated within one’s mind. And to understand the meaning, one must listen. One must initially generate the wisdom arisen from hearing.
If one does not listen, one does not study or attend teachings, then how exactly is one supposed to gain any understanding? So here, as Geshe la explained last time, one should every day continually generate a good motivation at the beginning of the day and go about one’s daily affairs, garbed, if you wish, in this motivation. And then when the day of our death comes, the time of our death comes, then one should do exactly the same thing. One should generate a good motivation, thereby accumulating virtue. And then should one should look back upon one’s life, and, hopefully, one is will be able to say, I have not done anything terribly bad or evil.
You know? And independence on this, through understanding the existence of future lives, there should be no fear at the time of death. So this is a very simple topic, but I think Geshe la thinks it should be explained over and again because many of you have asked what will happen at the time of their death. Then it is simple to understand. In Australia, unlike many other countries, your children leave home when they turn 18.
Then you will probably die alone. In Tibet, the situation is rather different. The children typically stay at home there. Obviously, one has to struggle also against attachment to one’s children. Then the fact that one’s offspring stay at home in Tibet is a source of great hardship at the time of death since there is attachment to one’s offspring.
And, obviously, at the time of death, one wishes to generate a virtuous
Mind. Then for yourselves in this country, since, you will probably die all alone, then, this problem does not arise, and it’ll be easier for yourselves to generate a virtuous mind. So here, therefore, one must eliminate wrong fears at the time of death. And, specifically, one must try to die with a virtuous state of mind. Now desire is obviously a danger attachment to the vanities of this life, so one has to counter that.
And Geshe la is not sure whether anger would arise or not at the time of death that calls for investigation. But this is the realization of the path shared with the being of the small scope. Mhmm. Do you understand? And, Geshe, I think the majority of our students probably understand this.
However, it is not sufficient to understand it and like worldly studies, set it aside and pass on to something else. Instead, one must integrate this understanding with one’s mind stream. It is in dependence on this integration with one’s mind stream that one will be able to be happy at the time of death, and this is a realization of the path shared with the being of the small scope. It is from the present that we must repeatedly accustom or habituate ourselves to this way of seeing things. Otherwise, it would be very difficult to do this suddenly at the time of death.
And, obviously, the time of death is completely uncertain. So this is something we must reflect upon over and again. Then is it impossible to abandon death? No. It is perfectly possible to abandon death.
It is a matter of practicing sufficiently to reach that level. So this is a very powerful incentive to practice. Mhmm. So, therefore, this is the realization of the path shared with the being of the small scope. Now, is it the case that having been born, we necessarily must die?
No. It is not the case. It is possible to abandon death, which is caused by karma and causality. So how does one abandon death? Attain by attaining liberation.
By abandoning the cause of birth, which is the ignorance grasping at self? That’s very good, Geshe-la says. You gave different examples, different instances. Some said to abandon the afflictions. Some said to abandon self grasping.
Some said to abandon the cause of birth, but the meaning was the same. Now you have to practice this. Just practice. Right? So you have finished hearing or studying.
Now is the time, for practice. As Rinpoche, said before departing, study is over. Now it is time for practice. What precisely is the obstacle to our practicing? It’s laziness, or to put it more bluntly, grasping at one’s own permanence or believing in one’s own immortality.
So all of us are similar in this respect. In the monasteries, people would say, next month, will do a good retreat. Then next year, I will do a good retreat. Then when I finish building this house, I’ll do a good retreat. Here, people say when I retire, I’ll have time to do a retreat.
In reality, no one ever does retreats. Then, this is a manifestation of grasping at one’s own permanence or belief in one’s own immortality. As Buddha Śākyamūni said, we are like a butter lamp in the wind, which can be extinguished at any moment. Then, obviously, we are laypeople. Therefore, there are children.
There are responsibilities towards one’s family and so forth. And those do take time, but it is not that there isn’t the opportunity to practice, and this opportunity must be seized. Then, obviously, those who are ordained should dedicate the totality of their life to study and practice, and they have far greater opportunities undeniably. So, here, it is therefore possible to abandon death. It is possible to become immortal, and this is possible through abandoning the afflictions.
Now some of you seem to believe when one speaks of abandoning the afflictions that this refers to a temporary or reduction of the afflictions. That is not what is being talked about here. What is being talked about here is targeting the afflictions and applying the antidotes until the afflictions never more again arise. At this point, one will have abandoned the four sufferings, the suffering of birth, aging, sickness, and death, and specifically, the suffering of birth, aging, and death induced by karma. So once one has abandoned the afflictions by applying the antidotes, one attains a state of an akhat.
Now an arhat has a body exactly like us. The arhat attains a state of arhathood independence on a contaminated body. This is a body which suffers, which can be hurt, which can fall sick, but the arhat himself experiences mentally no suffering of any type. At the time of death the arhat abandons that contaminated body, and from the standpoint of the Mahāyāna schools of tenets, enters into a state of meditative equipoise, then what precisely happens to the base of imputation? That is an open question.
Then what exactly happens with the body? The mental body of the arhat is an open question. Some Buddhist scriptures say that they dwell in closed sealed lotuses in pure lands. Be that as it may, what matters is that the mind of the arhat is in a state of meditative equipoise, and this is not the coarse minds which we are accustomed to. This is a very subtle mind.
So these are things which we cannot see with our coarse senses, our eyes, and so forth. Mhmm. This is the central mind you see. What? Settle mind.
Settle mind. So the subtle mind is extremely important. That is what transmigrates from past lives to present life. This coarse mind obviously does not. So therefore, once one has abandoned the afflictions, one has become an arhat.
It is because we have not abandoned karma and the afflictions that we have not become and we dwell in cyclic existence. What exactly is the mode of dwelling in cyclic existence? So now what here is the cause of transmigration? It is karma and the aggregates. What is the transmigrator?
It is ourselves. What is the base of transmigration? It is the five aggregates. So here, therefore,
The cause of transmigration is karma and causality. The transmigrator is the I, and the base of transmigration is the five aggregates. Then it is through controlling or subduing the five aggregates that we are able to attain liberation. This is very clearly explained in the Lam Rim. So the Lam Rim is marvelous in this respect in that it explains to us clearly how to attain states such as liberation without introducing difficult concepts such as the truth of cessation, which are dizzying when we try to understand them.
It is perfectly adequate to understand liberation in terms of the way it is presented in the Lam Rim. And then one can progress in one’s understanding of compassion and bodhicitta. Then naturally, the section on insight, the great section on insight in Lam Rim Chen Mo is more difficult, but that is something else. So therefore, it is karma and causality which impel cyclic existence, and you seem to confuse comma and the afflictions. So Geshe la gave yesterday an example involving a possum.
So when we refer to the experience of the maturation of karma, The misunderstanding which arises arises from the fact that the term karma, which is the cause, is applied to the effect, which is the experience of happy or unhappy maturations. Now what exactly is the distinction between the afflictions and karma? The afflictions are not karma. It is independence on those intentions karma, which is the actual deed, is accumulated. Mhmm.
Do you understand? So let us take the following example. We are resting at ease, thinking about something, and suddenly a possum scrambles over the roof, disturbing our thought processes. And immediately, we think that damn possum. And an affliction arises within our minds.
Now there are many afflictions, but here it will be anger, which arises within our minds. I’m just speaking here in general. So, obviously, we have to practice patience here. I’m not saying we should, allow anger to arise. And if we practice patience, then we counter anger.
But even if anger were to arise, it wouldn’t matter because anger alone is just an affliction. Karma is only accrued in dependence on physical and mental deeds. So we have to learn to control our anger. So then once again, imagine that we are irate with a possum, furious, and we start planning to kill the possum. Then we investigate how to kill the possum using weapons, poison, whatever.
Mhmm. And once the possum is killed, at that point, karma, the karma of killing has been accumulated. Specifically, the defective part of that mind of anger is imprinted in our mind stream. Do you understand? Please?
So this is an extremely important topic, the topic of the mode of accumulation of karma. It’s a difficult topic. It is a topic which Geshe find difficult. Then if you reflect on it carefully and understand how virtuous and non virtuous karma are accumulated, you will understand what the meaning of the collections of merit and of wisdom are. Otherwise, one’s practice is totally faith based, and one stares into space with a blissed out smile on one’s face.
Do you understand? Right now. Just now. Or yes. Yes.
Yes. Okay. Yep. Yeah. Geshe la, I understand what you say, but I don’t understand how that intention is infused into into a karmic imprint.
What are you saying? That the the intention becomes a karmic imprint? Yeah. How is it that the defect of anger Mhmm. Becomes a karmic imprint?
How is it that a mind or a mental factor becomes a compositional factor? So it is not anger which becomes the karmic imprint. But under it depends on the condition of anger. Once the possum has been deprived of its life, there is a defective aspect of anger, and that is what becomes the karmic imprint. However, just think about this carefully and quietly.
It’s not an easy topic. And use the opportunity of the presence of your Lotzawa, your translator, to ask questions. This is an excellent opportunity for study. It won’t get better than this. So it is during this interval that it is really important for you to ask questions.
Do you understand? We need to put on. You know? I’ve got turned on. Anyway, what if tell me if this is off base or not.
If history was something rather than something that was behind us, but rather something that was always present, like a circle, just history, all of our accumulated acts, would that be what a karmic imprint is, is just a permanent record of past acts that we access in the ever present moment? So you’re saying that if, past history was present, and our past nonvirtuous and virtuous karma was accessible now, then what? Then that would explain the effect on us. Maybe your viewpoint is that of the Vaibashikas for which past and future are permanent. Yes.
I think that is something like that with respect to the Allah With respect to the alaya vision. Then you have a very good mind. You are intelligent. And, Geshe la, would like to encourage you to further these lines of thinking. And you have in your translator someone who is very experienced and knowledgeable.
So please discuss with him these doubts. Geshe la, just going back to imprints. In the case of a virtuous action an example of a virtuous action, would it then be the, what would you call the the element that’s imprinted from that virtuous action? Is it a quality? It wouldn’t be a defect?
Yes. Exactly. The mode of accumulation of virtuous and non virtuous karma identical except that for virtuous karma, obviously, it’s the quality, the component of quality which becomes a karmic imprint. At the moment of a direct valid cognition, can it be the presence of an affliction? Can there be what?
The presence of an affliction. Which direct that a direct cognition? When you see something nakedly, like, say, if I see the table as it is Uh-huh. At this as an example, can there be the presence of this the perceiver having an affliction at the time that they see the table directly? Yes.
Definitely. Definitely. Since at that time, for instance, you can have the grasping at your own permanent
Which arises. Excuse me. You can have the grasping at the permanence of the table which arises. When I think of Karma just in general terms of developing a habit, it makes perfect sense to me. But something or an aspect of it that doesn’t make a lot of sense to me in terms of developing a habit is say you called a pest controller to remove the possum and you’re expecting that possum to be killed by the pest inspector or controller.
They remove the pest, but they don’t actually kill it. But you’re under the impression that it’s dead. How does an event that’s independent of your own continuum have an effect on your karma when it Sorry? Yeah. Like how does something that’s independent of your own continuum, the completion of that event, which is independent of your view of it already being completed, you already have thought it’s completed, So how can something that happens outside of that then change the habit of your own mind?
The possum police. Right? Good. So the reason for which if you call the police and they take the possum away to kill him on your instructions, but don’t kill him. The reason you don’t accumulate the karma of killing at that point even though you are convinced the possum is dead is simply because the possum was not killed.
That’s the actual reality. Accumulation of karma depends on the actual reality. Because the possum did not die, you did not accumulate the karma of killing the possum. This is reality. But that implies objective reality that that in the sense that there’s something out there beyond your own mind that’s occurring that can have an influence in the habit of your own mind regardless of regardless of if you’re in I’ll reframe it.
So as I understand it, it’s the behavior of your own mind that generates the habits of your own mind. And so how can something that’s totally independent of your own mind in the sense of whether or not the possum is dead or alive then have an impact on the habit of your own mind? If you’re convinced that you’ve killed the possum and you’re happy about that, and that will then generate the habit to call pest inspectors to kill pests in the future because that seems like a great solution to the problem. How does whether or not that possum is dead or alive then change that? So in brief, the way to look at it is simply that as the possum is still alive, you cannot have accumulated the karma of killing it.
He has not been deprived of his life. As far as the accumulation of karma is concerned, it is very different from becoming accustomed or habituated to eating, to drinking, and so forth. It’s a completely different process. If if I could just clarify that, Geshe la said that the the component of anger at the point of the death of the, say, the being, the person, or the possum, that is when it is the that that sense of rejoicing happiness in the belief that the the the being has died. Then that is when that that component of anger transforms into the imprint.
Surely that is based on a perception or belief of the death of the possum. Say for example, if somebody shoots another person, they believe that they died. They go away and get hit by a bus and die not knowing that in fact the person who they shot had a bulletproof vest and was actually protected and didn’t die. Would it not be that the person who did the shooting actually believed and rejoiced in the death of the person that they shot? Therefore, they would accumulate the negative karma in their own mind because it’s their perception that the person had died even though they didn’t know.
So is it necessary to bring the bus in the picture, Geshe la says? Your example is the same as that of our friend. That’s not enough to explain to explain the intention of karma. That’ll be very strange. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Isn’t there some sort of a, like, karmic stain of some kind even though the deed hasn’t been completed? You know, almost like the, you know, the odor of of the garlic once the garlic’s been thrown out of the container.
Isn’t there something left on the continuum? You obviously generated the motivation to kill the person. Right? But that’s an evil motivation. Alright?
Okay. What happened? I was just wondering I’ve wondered before about life support life support. Yes. Yes.
Yes. If if I have left instructions to have that that life support switched off, wouldn’t would I be encouraging that person to kill? So Geshe la says the person is dead, actually. The person who’s in an iron lung is dead. So if you stop the iron lung just just breathe in.
Breathe in. Yeah. Long time. You know? So this went very well.
We’ve gone over time. And Geshe-la says we will cover this material again later. Page five. Number six.
So in brief, regarding the example of the possum which was given, once one has generated the motivation of anger and wishes to kill the possum, and that possum has been deprived of its life, at that point, in brief, that motivation of anger, which is the afflictive intention, becomes the actual basis of karma, and that is the imprint which is infused in the mind. Then we shall stop here for today. Mhmm. Okay. Thank you.
A just to let you know, next Thursday, July 27, Chokhor Duchen, the first turning of the wheel of dharma, there will be a puja at 06:00. And if you’re available during the day, 10:00 recitations, the heart sūtra and the three principles of the path. The Geshe’s will recite the Kangyur, the Buddhist Canon, 12:00 shared lunch. And then as I said, Pooja at 06:00. You don’t need to bring food, but offerings are welcome.
Monetary offerings are welcome. Thank you. Next Thursday, the twenty seventh, not tomorrow. Practice starts on Saturday with healing meditation at 10:30 and practice at 11:15. So if you’re sick, there’s no excuses.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- puja chö pa (Tib)
- Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.