Lam Rim – 06092017Lamrim(Salam 3 – KR

1 h 33 min · 4,708 words

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 06092017Lamrim(Salam 3 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Continues a Lam Rim teaching. Dharma benefits mental happiness now as well as in future lives, and training in contentment reduces desire and mental suffering. The talk then explains the Mahayana paths of accumulation, preparation and seeing, and the difference between ordinary and arya beings. It closes with a question and answer session on emptiness and calm abiding.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 33m

UUID: ed610069-0ccb-4032-ad41-b1abd6a4e708

Words: 4,704

So usually on Wednesdays, Geshe-la explains the path shared with the being of the small scope because it is important. It is something which is easy to understand, and it is helpful to us. Now usually when we refer to dharma, we think of something which helps us from the next time onwards as well as something which is of help to us at the time of death. So if dharma is something which is of benefit from the next life onwards, and is of benefit as well at the time of death, then dharma would have to be of benefit now as well. Because it is difficult to see how if dharma were not of benefit now as well, it could suddenly become of benefit at the time of death and become of benefit as well in future lives.

Then it therefore is of benefit now. If it were not of benefit now, it would be rather odd to say that it is of benefit in future lives, don’t you think? So therefore, even though the dharma is of benefit at the time of death and is begins to bear benefits from future lives onwards, nonetheless, for that to be the case, it would have to be of benefit right now. Now actually, Geshe-la does not want to say that it would have to be of benefit, but it definitely is of benefit, right now. And, this is something, which becomes very clear in the Lamrim.

There’s actually a verse which says, through accomplishing one’s ultimate goal, one’s ancillary or subsidiary goal is also accomplished. So in Tibet, there is a tradition, which is that after someone has died, his possessions are sorted out and distributed. Now this is of help to others for sure. Whether this is of benefit to the person who has died is another question because he already is dead. So Rinpoche, Khensur Rinpoche always said, it is before we die that we must accumulate merit.

And otherwise, one is in the situation of someone who takes a handful of tsampa and casts it on the roof of a house. It just scatters in all the directions. Then in your own cases, you attend Lamrim teachings, you think about them as much as you can and if possible you practice them. Then this is happiness. There’s nothing more than this.

So therefore, dharma is principally of benefit from the next life onwards. However, there is benefit in this life. There is benefit for us now. But this benefit is mental benefit. Dharma enables us to eliminate mental suffering.

Now can dharma eliminate physical suffering? That is very difficult because physical suffering is something exterior. It is unrelated. And therefore, we must first study the Lamrim, but study alone will not enable us to gain this mental happiness. After studying the Lamrim, we must put it in practice.

We must literally give ourselves good counsel, checking within our own minds what should be decreased and what should be increased. And when we see force which should be decreased, we should decrease them as much as we can, and qualities we should increase as much as we can. As a result, our mental happiness will increase. Now this will not happen at once. It will take time.

It’s a gradual process. So here therefore, this has absolutely nothing to do with your physical happiness, but your mental happiness. And when we try to apply dharma, we apply to ourselves. It’s not our business to look into what other people are doing. And then we should check our own minds and see what within our own minds prevents us from being happy.

What prevents us from being happy is this unhappiness because we feel we haven’t obtained the happiness we merit. In other words, lack of contentment. Then the more we cultivate contentment, the happier we will be, and here Geshela is in no way at all saying that we have to become ordained. It is perfectly possible to practice contentment as a laborer. Do you understand?

Do you understand? Yes. Yes, yes. So now obviously someone who is ordained has resolved to train in contentment and therefore has an obligation to be contented. But, lay people can and should train in contentment.

Geshela would like to point out that in this society, there is very little physical suffering worth talking about. There is a tremendous amount of mental suffering and this mental suffering comes from lack of contentment. Then, Geshe, I would like to give you an example from Tibet. In in Tibet, in the old days, people used to wear a special or necklace and jewelry made of a special type of stone called zi, which has eyes in it. It was extraordinarily expensive.

It would cost hundreds of thousands, even millions. Chinese yuan, you know. And these necklaces of zi these ornaments of zi were of no benefit whatsoever to anybody. They didn’t prevent you from going hungry. They didn’t prevent you from going thirsty.

They didn’t protect you from disease, nothing. This is mere foolishness because to get these necklaces of zi, one would have to have a lot of money and as you know money is hard to get. One would have to struggle to get it. At least a watch, mine is an old Chinese watch. That one I think.

Then this is not the talk of someone who is ordained, it is reality. Geshela would like you to take it on board. He’s noted some of you have very flash rings. Then what exactly, what sort of benefit do you derive from that sort of ring? Nothing at all.

Then, I guess, I noticed in some kitchens that in addition to the normal plates and so forth you need, people have silver or even gilt cutlery to eat in. Silver or even gold cutlery is of no benefit whatsoever. Geshela cannot see what difference it makes to the taste of the food. Then therefore, we should examine what we have and focus on what is useful and not get used to things, and then we can keep our money instead of wasting it. And there are numerous good uses for money, which rely on a virtuous motivation.

And therefore, proceeding in this way, we should cause our contentment with our situation to increase since lack of contentment is a source of mental suffering. And contentment is the direct antidote to desire. As our contentment increases, desire decreases. And desire itself induces the other afflictions such as anger, envy, competitiveness, and and so forth. All of these will dwindle as well as our contentment increases.

And if we proceed in this way, then we will have a quiet and peaceful death, and definitely will be be reborn in a higher realm. So this is not based on faith and unfolding one’s hands hands in prayer. This is based on logic, and this is how his holiness teaches. Then dharma therefore helps principally for future lives, but helps from now onwards. If it did not and somehow dharma only help for future lives and in this life caused a lot of problems.

Geshela would this be really dharma? Now here Geshela is referring to mental suffering and mental happiness. He is in no way talking of physical happiness, which is completely and physical suffering, are completely unrelated. For instance, if we experience cancer or physical hardship in this life, this is a result of our own past non virtues in previous lives, and in general this is impossible to counter. So we have to reduce, therefore, our focus on exterior objects and this mistaken belief that exterior objects can induce the totality of our happiness.

And as we reduce our focus on exterior objects, exterior things, as a result, our mental contentment will increase, and we will get an introduction to mental happiness. And this we can link with the Lamrim and Thing ah. This is what mental happiness is. And here we have to address the issue of conviction in the triple gem. When we speak of conviction in the triple gem, the actual object of refuge is the dharma.

And here, the term actual is of great importance. This means that the actual object of refuge is this process of becoming masters of our own mind, increasing our qualities and qualities causing our faults to decrease. Buddha himself is merely the teacher of this and the Sangha are those who accompany on this path. Therefore, the actual refuge is our own mind, our own mental improvement. This is why Je Tsongkhapa says in his concise expression of realization, the concise, Lamrim, upon taking refuge, do not allow the precepts to degenerate.

This is a very profound verse. The precepts here are nothing else than the Lamrim, and therefore, one should study the Lamrim and in dependence on this, the text continues, one should generate conviction in causality. Therefore, while dharma is principally of benefit from future lives onwards. It is also of benefit in the here and now. If it is that were not the case, it would be difficult to see how it could be of benefit in future lives.

And its benefit in the here and now, leads to a mental peace, which accompanies us until the time of our death. As a result, we can die in a virtuous frame of mind, and at that point, it is certain that we will be reborn in a higher realm. Now here, obviously, one, must endeavor to take good care of one’s body so that one does not die in a lot of pain because, obviously, pain causes difficulties. Mhmm. So do not think that at the time of death everything stops.

What happens is that there is a subtle mind and the subtle mind goes on. Now this subtle mind which the cittamatrins call the mind basis of all the alia vijnana is a mind we are completely unable to use at present. It is probably accurate to say that at present, all we can use is our brain. Then obviously, at the time of our death, our brain is destroyed. So that aspect of consciousness is gone.

However, the subtle mind remains. And Chitamatra teaches that at present we are completely unable to use the Alāyavijñāna. It is merely the receptacle of the support for imprints. It’s quite a profound way of thinking. So let us at present generate the motivation to listen to these teachings through reflecting that we must, on the one hand, reduce our levels of mental hardship and on the other hand, increase our levels of mental happiness.

And this occurs through training in contentment. And as we train in contentment, we will become happier and happier, and let us then generate the motivation to study the Lamrim to understand this to help others. Khensur Rinpoche repeatedly said that apart from subtle mind such as the Alāyavijñāna, it is difficult to deposit the imprints in coarse minds. What links past and future lives is the subtle mind. And if at present you think, what is all this talk and this talk about past lives?

I don’t have a clue or any memory about it. It is simply because all of that hinges on the subtle mind to which we do not have access. Then in the Lamrim, there are basically almost no reasons at all given to prove the existence of past and future lives. Simply because the intended trainees of the Lamrim were beings who had a profound conviction in the existence of past and future lives, and therefore it was unnecessary. On the other hand, in Dharmakīrti’s Pramānavārttika, the second chapter is totally dedicated to proving the existence of past and future lives.

Now the main opponents which Dharma Kirti was targeting in the second chapter of Pramānavārttika were probably the Sankhyas and Lokayatas, the materialists of ancient India. So the source of the Lamrim is to be found in Atisha’s Bodhipatthapradipa, the lamp for the path, which even though its topic is very profound, its topic is the beings of the three scope, is very concise in terms of its size, and nothing is said in the Bodhipattapradipa about the existence of past and future lives. It is presupposed. Now the Bodhipatthapradipa and all the Lamrims were addressed to Tibetans who believed from the depths of their heart in the existence of past and future lives. Then if you were to ask them just how precisely do these past and future lives exist, they would perhaps go blank on you and say maybe in space or in the sky or something.

So in conversation, one would encounter this type of situation, one would say, yes, my past lives definitely exist and so do yours. My future lives definitely exist and so will yours. Then should a third party ask, well, just how precisely do they exist, no one would be able to answer. Now this capacity to answer, to understand in-depth these issues arises from study. Then let us pass to Sa-lam at present, the overview of Salam Geshe has been giving.

Geshela has covered the path of accumulation, preparation, and seeing. And he would like to encourage us to have a clear view of the basics. And this clear view of the basics comes if we connect with the foundational texts and not if we sort of think in any which way in terms of what we would like. Then we get very confused. And this is the case because we have ourselves no experience whatsoever of these states.

On the other hand, Buddha Śākyamūni, our teacher, is said to have accumulated merit for three countless eons, not for a couple days, a couple weeks, a couple months, or a couple years. So he has had these experiences. And this is difficult because we are studying the mind, and we are studying how the mind operates and the afflictions and they must be reduced gradually. So let us start with a being on the path of accumulation. A being on the path of accumulation is a person.

It’s not a consciousness, it is a person. So Geshela would like to explain in sequence these five paths. The Mahāyāna path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and normal learning. Do you understand? Sure?

100%? Sorry. So one should proceed in this way incrementally and then if you have questions, your translator studied these texts at Sera, you can ask him. Now when we speak of paths from the path the Mahāyāna path of accumulation to the Mahāyāna path of no more learning, these are consciousnesses. So a being on the Mahāyāna path of accumulation or a Bodhisattva on the Mahāyāna path of accumulation is a person.

So the purpose of explaining what a being on the Mahāyāna path of accumulation is, is to situate him in terms of, if you wish, development in dharma. Now what is a being on the Mahāyāna path of accumulation? Any being which has already generated an uncontrived spontaneous bodhichitta, but has not yet generated an insight focused on emptiness. Any such being, however many in number, is a being on the Mahāyāna path of accumulation. Now within the mind of that being, great compassion, bodhichitta for that matter, training in the perfections of generosity, ethics, forbearance, perseverance, concentration and wisdom are all Mahāyāna paths of accumulation.

So the next being we consider is a being on the Mahāyāna path of preparation. Such beings have generated an insight focused on emptiness, or if you prefer, have generated a mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. Now minds arisen from meditation are subdivided into two. You have conceptual minds arisen from meditation and non conceptual minds arisen from meditation. So what are the boundaries or the range of a being on the Mahāyāna path of preparation?

In the backdrop, when the background of such a being must be the spontaneous uncontrived generation of bodhichitta. And then a being on the Mahāyāna path of preparation is a being at any point between the point where he or she has generated an insight focused on emptiness or a mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness, which is conceptual, all the way up to the point that just before he or she has generated a non conceptual mind arisen from a meditation focused on emptiness. What examples would you give of a Mahāyāna path of preparation? The examples would be, for instance, great compassion, bodhichitta, or a sapience realizing emptiness within the continuum of such a being. If on the other hand, Geshela were to present the definitions of the Mahāyāna paths of accumulation and preparation, they’re extremely long.

So at present, Geshela has covered the path of accumulation, the path of preparation, and today he will present the path of seeing. So a being, therefore, on the Mahāyāna path of preparation is not a being like us. This is a being in whose backdrop, if you wish, stands bodhichitta. And in addition, this is a being who has tremendous familiarity with emptiness and who basically will become rapidly enlightened. Now when such a being, in other words, a being on a Mahāyāna path of preparation through repeated familiarization with emptiness, for the first time generates a non conceptual wisdom arisen from meditation focused on emptiness.

He or she has entered the path of seeing of the Mahāyāna. Then obviously, once such a being has entered the path of seeing of the Mahāyāna, then the path of preparation of the Mahāyāna is over. So once one attains the Mahāyāna path of seeing, one has attained for the first time the Mahāyāna path of an ārya being. So at present, when a being on the path of preparation, the Mahāyāna path of preparation, has for the first time generated a non conceptual wisdom focused on emptiness arisen from meditation, such a being has entered an ārya path. Now there are three ārya paths, the ārya path of seeing, of meditation, and of no more learning.

So another way of presenting the difference between a Mahāyāna path of preparation and a Mahāyāna path of seeing is that on a Mahāyāna path of preparation, one gains a realization of emptiness, which is mixed with a meaning generality of emptiness. One does not therefore, see emptiness nakedly or directly. And an example will make this clear. Geshela, through watching the news and listening, to news and so forth, has become very familiar with, president Donald Trump. He has seen Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. He has seen his face, heard his speeches, and so forth, but he has actually never seen him in person. Met him, if you wish, nakedly. He has always met him or seen him through a meaning generality or a mixture of a meaning and a sound generality.

And it is the same thing as when for instance based on Buddhist texts and scriptures, one reflects on emptiness. One has not experienced emptiness directly. One is just wondering what’s it like and so forth. In the self same way as Geshela has seen many pictures of Donald Trump, but has never seen him in reality or met him in person. One day he hopes to meet Donald Trump.

Then oh, okay. So it is exactly the same thing with emptiness. Through repeated familiarization on the path, the Mahāyāna path of preparation with emptiness, eventually one reaches a point where one experiences emptiness directly, nakedly. One sees it as it is. For instance, the emptiness of this table exists, but how does it exist?

That calls for analysis. So let us therefore think about this and we will have the recitation of the prayers. Page one. Page five. So you probably know this at present, what is the boundary or the difference between ordinary beings and ārya beings?

What’s the difference between ordinary beings and ārya beings? Ordinary beings in the Mahāyāna path of preparation have a conceptual insight focused on emptiness. So the difference of an ārya being, which has through familiarization with the meaning generality of emptiness, has generated a non conceptual insight focused on emptiness. So it’s very simple. Ordinary beings are beings who have not had a direct realization of emptiness.

This does not mean that they are on the path of preparation or accumulation. Beings who are not on the path are ordinary beings as well. Then, ārya beings are beings who have had a direct realization of emptiness. This means that they have perceived emptiness nakedly as it is. So ordinary beings basically are being starting with us who are not on the ārya path, all the way up to just before the Ārya path, and if any of you are highly advanced beings on the Ārya path, Geshela says he apologizes.

Apologize. I’m so sorry, you know. Then if you can attain the path of normal learning, Geshela has accumulated great merit. It’s not easy. First, it is not easy to attain the path of an Ārya being.

Secondly, it is not easy to reach a level where you can know, you can see another continuum and say whether they have reached the path of an Ārya being or not. We have to reduce our imputations, our projections. So what is the example you would give an instance of a Mahāyāna path of seeing? A path. Any of the six perfections within the continuum of a being on the path of seeing?

Yes. In other words, great compassion, bodhichitta or a sapience realizing emptiness within the continuum of a being on a Mahāyāna path of seeing. Now both beings on the Mahāyāna path of preparation and beings on the Mahāyāna path of seeing are similar in that they are persons and their object is emptiness. If you have questions. Please ask them one question per person.

I guess you talked about the boundary between being on the path of preparation and leading on to the path of seeing when it becomes from conceptual insight focused on emptiness to non conceptual insight focused on emptiness. Does crossing that boundary occur within the same meditation session? When we speak, you should not say the path of preparation. You should say a Mahāyāna path of preparation. You’ve got three types of path of preparation.

You have the path of preparation of a hearer, a solitary realizer, and a Mahāyāna being. We’re only talking of the Mahāyāna being. We cannot confuse with the other two. So whenever you refer to these in the context of this class, you should say, a Mahāyāna path of accumulation, a Mahāyāna path of preparation, a Mahāyāna path of seeing, etcetera. Yes.

Obviously, because you are this transference can only occur any meditation session. Geshela, as I understand it, it is possible for a being to have a realization of emptiness before they have entered a path. And other than the characteristics of uncontrived bodhichitta or uncontrived definite emergence, what is the difference between the emptiness of a being prior to entering a path and the emptiness of a being on the path, on a path? Emptiness or the realization? Sorry, the realization of emptiness.

So once one enters the path of preparation, one will have generated an insight focused on emptiness, is a mind arisen from meditation, which remains conceptual. And on the path of seeing, one will have generated a non conceptual mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness, a direct perception of emptiness. These are much more powerful than the realizations of emptiness of a being who has not entered the path, and they are not present at that level. Geshela, could you clarify the arya beings? You said there there were three arya paths.

So you included no more learning. I understood that to be the Buddhahood. Yes, we will leave it there. Will explain Geshela will explain that in detail in the future. Otherwise, we must get very confused at present.

I may be mistaken but if I understand correctly, it’s possible to generate calm abiding before entering a path. If it’s possible to generate calm abiding before entering a path and it’s also possible to generate an inferential valid cognition of emptiness before entering a path, What is the necessity of generating uncontrived definite emergence to unite these two? Can I reformulate your question? So I ask Geshela, what is the necessity why can a being who has not entered the path generate an insight focused on emptiness? Then Geshela said it is necessary to have generated definite emergence first before generating an insight focused on emptiness.

It’s a very good doubt because after all, we do say that there are beings who have a realization of emptiness who have not entered the path, and one might wonder, would such beings be able to have an insight focused on emptiness without having entered the path? But to generate an insight focused on emptiness, one must initially have generated definite emergence. When we say that there exists calm abiding insight within the mind of a being who has not entered the path. This refers to ordinary calm abiding and ordinary insight. So Geshela is good to think about it.

There is subtle but important distinction between the Lamrim and the and Salam grounds and paths in this respect because the Lamrim seems to imply that, it is sufficient to enter to generate uncontrived definite emergence to have entered the path. Whereas according to Salam, the definition of a path is a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. So there is a difference. Okay. Is it correct to use the term worldly being for one who hasn’t developed uncontrived definite emergence or uncontrived bodhichitta, worldly being?

Ask another question if no one else has. So between the Mahāyāna path of preparation or between the Mahāyāna paths, given that for example the Mahāyāna path of accumulation is of similar type to the Mahāyāna path of preparation and upon the generation of the Mahāyāna path of preparation, the Mahāyāna path of accumulation disappears. Is it the case that each path is the substantial cause of the subsequent path? The Mahāyāna path of accumulation is a substantial cause of the Mahāyāna path of preparation. So then obviously as mentioned previously Geshela says, we have to examine whether an uncontrived definite emergence would be present within the mind stream of beings on the Mahāyāna paths of accumulation, preparation, or seeing.

Then obviously, an as Geshela says, such an uncontrived mind of definite emergence would be a perfect limb. Perfect complement in other words. Just one question. So who can? If you think about Sa-lam grounds and paths in this way, it’s very beneficial in an incremental fashion.

I’d just like to I guess clarify. I do recall from the stages of meditation by the Dalai Lama, he said that the special insight is a factor of analysis properly examining suchness from within calm abiding. From within calm abiding. From within calm abiding. So I’m trying to then understand the difference between special insight within that calm abiding, an ordinary insight and an inferential valid cognition.

Is there a difference between these? Sorry, just to add to that. If I’m not mistaken, the Dalai Lama has said that some scientists have generated a realization of emptiness. And if they can then generate a calm abiding, so if they were then to generate a calm abiding, I don’t understand the difference between their combining these two and the types of realizations that are generated on the path of preparation? It’s a matter of meditation, it does not happen easily, but why wouldn’t some have generated it?

Because this was the advice which Mañjuśrī gave to Jitsongkapa when he said to Jitsongkapa to train in the accumulation of merit and purification of obscurations to gain a realization of emptiness arisen from meditation. Now before this, Je Tsongkhapa had already gained a realization of emptiness. So it is not something which is easy to get. So one must meditate, meditate, meditate, and in dependence on this experience arises. Okay.

Key terms in this teaching

grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What is the difference between the realization of emptiness of a being before entering the path and that of a being on the path?

Once a being enters the path of preparation, they will have generated an insight focused on emptiness. This is a mind arisen from meditation, and it remains conceptual. On the path of seeing, they will have generated a non-conceptual mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness, which is a direct perception of emptiness. These realizations are much more powerful than the realizations of emptiness of a being who has not entered the path, and they are not present at that level.

Scroll to Top