1 h 29 min · 3,630 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a Lamrim teaching on generating bodhichitta through the equalization and exchange of self and others, including the practice of tonglen. The teacher explains that great compassion, definite emergence and bodhichitta are conceptual states because they focus on the future, and that hearers and solitary realizers lack great compassion. A long question session follows on conceptual and non-conceptual minds, including whether a Buddha’s mind is conceptual.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 29m
UUID: 13486afd-a5b8-42cb-b534-561d75f6cf30
Words: 3,626
So when we speak of practicing the Lamrim, in other words, the path shared with the being of the small, the middling, and the great scope, this is very much contingent on the motivation which is generated. And in as much as the Lamrim as a whole is a practice of the Mahāyāna, then this practice should be upheld by bodhichitta. Then, to have a motivation, we should generate the motivation. If we merely study without generating a motivation, this study does not turn into practice of the long run. So, with respect to this motivation, what would it be in the context of the practice shared with the being of the smaller scope?
In that context, one would initially focus on all sentient beings as vast as space in number and then reflect that should one not attain a higher rebirth in future lives, it would be very difficult if not impossible to reach a point where one can lead all sentient beings to liberation or for enlightenment. And with this as a motivation, then engage in the central practice of the path shared with the being of the small scope, which is an ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues. So, such a practice would have dual benefits. One would train in bodhichitta since one would be focusing on attaining full enlightenment for the sake of others. But since one would be training in an ethics, is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues and it is taught in Buddhist scriptures that this leads to higher rebirth, one would also attain higher rebirth for oneself.
Therefore engaging in the practice shared with the being of the small scope motivated by bodhichitta is none other than this. Otherwise, if one were merely to engage in an abandonment of the 10 non virtues for the sake of gaining higher rebirth for oneself, how precisely would this become a practice of the Mahāyāna? Likewise, for the path shared with the being of the middling scope motivated by the wish to set all mother sentient beings in a state of liberation. We ourselves study and practice to pass through to liberation, and doing this, we are motivated by bodhichitta. Now regarding the path of the being of the great scope, it would be inappropriate to study the training in love, compassion, and bodhichitta with the motivation of teaching others how to train in it.
Instead, one should study them with the motivation of practicing these ourselves and in dependence on this practice, then one can teach others how to practice this. This becomes a Mahāyāna practice. There is a multiplicity of motivations, but generally speaking, the motivation of teaching others the practices of love, compassion in bodhichitta, others as vast in number as space is vast for the sake of leading them to the state of full enlightenment would be a motivation of bodhichitta. Therefore, it is not just a matter of talking about generating this motivation of bodhichitta, we must try to generate it even for a short period of time and try to give rise to a sensation, a particular feeling. This is a feeling of great happiness when this motivation is generated since fundamentally within outer and inner happiness, what we need is inner happiness. And once we have inner happiness, then irrespective of the exterior circumstances, whether we have good clothes or not, it really makes no major difference.
So here what we need therefore is a good motivation and this good motivation must be a stable motivation. It must be a weighty motivation, and here by motivation, we mean that force which enables us to engage in action. So if that force is present, engage in action and complete action. If that force is absent, we either do not engage or do not complete action. Then it is this motivation we have to generate.
So now at present, we are engaged in a presentation of the generation of bodhichitta by means of the equalization and interchange of self and others. And for the standpoint of the LAMREM, this has seven subdivisions. Starting with the equalization of self and others as usual. Starting with the equalization of self and others, moving through the remaining four outlines and then the practice of giving and taking. Then the resolve So at the level of the Mahāyāna, it is extremely important to be aware of these seven subdivisions.
So it is said that great compassion is absent within the mind stream of hearers and solitary realizers. But it is not just sufficient to state this or accept this, there have to be reasons for this. In your opinion, why is this the case? What is the reason or what are the reasons? What’s the meaning of great compassion?
Being able to bear the suffering of, not just oneself, but all beings, and wishing to So the empathy which wishes to free sentient beings from suffering, right? Empathy in other words. So great compassion in other words, when it is applied to oneself is definite emergence, the wish to be freed from one’s own suffering. When it is applied to others, it is great compassion, isn’t it? Then in this case, why would you say that hearers and solitary realizers don’t have the wish to free sentient beings from suffering?
So don’t you believe that the Hīnayāna practitioners wish for happiness for this world? Don’t you believe that they pray for happiness for this world? That has nothing to do with the meaning of compassion. Compassion does not actualize the happiness of others, it’s a way of thinking. So for sure in their mind stream, there is the wish, may there be peace and happiness in this world.
Isn’t there? Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. Then there must be the mindset which thinks which wishes for all sentient beings to be free of suffering and the causes of suffering.
You know? Then there’s great compassion. Right? What’s great compassion? That’s not what is being said.
If they can have the wish for all sentient beings to attain liberation, there is no reason they should not have the wish for all sentient beings to attain full enlightenment. So, they have the thought, it will be right for all sentient beings to attain liberation. It will be right for all sentient beings to attain full enlightenment. This aspiration, these prayers are present within their mind stream, but they do not put effort into this. Now, compassion is a matter of wish or aspiration.
So the reason for which great compassion is absent within their mind stream is because should great compassion be present, then the cherishing of others would also be present. In other words, love would be present. Then, in as much as this self cherishing is the exact opposite of cherishing oneself or egoism, then cherishing oneself would disappear and we know that egoism or self cherishing is present within the mind stream of both hearers and pratyeka buddhas. So I explained this many times, perhaps you didn’t understand. When great compassion has been generated, then one has the realization of the Mahāyāna.
Then if great compassion has been generated, as I said, cherishing others will have been generated. And the exact opposite of cherishing others is self cherishing or egoism egoism, then that will dwindle and disappear. So, at this point, one generates Tonglen or giving and taking. Tonglen is an uncommon technique which leads to a great amplification of both love and compassion. In the case of compassion, without thinking merely, may all sentient beings be free of suffering and the causes of suffering, one thinks I will take them upon myself.
And this causes a dramatic increase in compassion. Now at this point, one generates the resolve to help sentient beings oneself and this is called the great resolve. So what is the difference between the supreme resolve and bodhichitta? At the level of the supreme resolve, we have generated the resolve to help sentient beings. However, we do not understand their nature nor their goals.
Even in this room, we have the people of different natures and different goals. Some may be practitioners of the small scope. All they wish to do is practice the small scope. Some may be practitioners of the middling scope. All they wish to practice is the middling scope.
And some finally may be practitioners of the great scope. Then we do not know who is who. Who has which wish, which predisposition, and therefore we cannot help meaningfully and give meaningful advice. And understanding this, we take the resolve to attain the state of full enlightenment because fully enlightened beings understand precisely the predispositions of others. So, for instance, we have no way of knowing who precisely in this room is deep down a being of the small scope who thinks this life is short, I should focus on the essential and accomplish my goals.
And therefore, one must try to gain the capacities to know the innermost nature and goals of others. For this one needs numerous qualities such as, the five visions, the paranormal powers and so forth, the capacity of telepathy, all of these are attained at the level of full enlightenment. And with this as a motivation, one then strives for full enlightenment to help others. When one has generated such a motivation, it is akin to bodhichitta. Likewise, beings speak numerous languages and a fully enlightened being is able to communicate with each being in his or her own language.
The Tibetan term has two syllables. The first syllable is refers to the abandonment of the two obstructions, the Kleśavarana and Jñeyāvarana. The second, Sang, means the enhancement of all qualities. So do you now begin to understand the meaning of bodhichitta, the difference between the meaning and the purpose of love, of great compassion, and of bodhichitta. So what’s the meaning or the purpose of bodhichitta?
And and other? The perfection of all good qualities and the elimination of all negativities in order to bring all other beings to that state. So we have talked therefore about definite emergence, love, great compassion, bodhichitta. And at present, would like to bring up a delicate issue with you. I don’t know if you can answer or not.
We spoke of definite emergence. Is definite emergence conceptual or non conceptual? It cannot be both. It’s one or the other. Okay.
Those of you who say it’s conceptual, why? What’s the reason? Definite emergence. What is the way of reliance on a meaning generality of definite emergence? How does it rely?
So definite emergence is conceptual. It is not non conceptual. Then you have to be explained why it’s conceptual. What about great compassion? Is it conceptual or not?
The same? All everyone. Yeah. It’s conception. Just need, please.
It can either be conceptual or non conceptual, that’s it. So, bodhichitta is conceptual. If you’re going to say that definite emergence and great great compassion are conceptual, bodhichitta has to be conceptual. You still have given no reason for any of them. If you know these seven subdivisions of mind in Lorig, then it’s extraordinarily beneficial to try to fit definite emergence, great compassion and bodhichitta within them.
You may not be able to do so, it is quite difficult. Is asking me within the sevenfold subdivision of Lorig, where I would put great compassion. It’s a very difficult topic because Geshela is setting you up for a big one. So the problem arises when you speak of the presence of the absence of bodhichitta in the mind of a fully enlightened being. So we put that aside, Then within the minds of beings, So Geshe-la should ask me what I thought great compassion was and I think you have to fit it in an inferential valid cognizer, but there are problems with that.
So it’s a very difficult problem. Numerous scholars wrote treatises on where great compassion must be fit within the seven folds of the study of mind in Lorig. So definite emergence obviously is conceptual. It’s conceptual because it is a thought which is focused on liberation, which we do not have at present. It’s in the future.
Future, then anything which is focused on a time other than the present is conceptual by definition. Likewise, for great compassion, great compassion is a wish for all sentient beings to free be freed from suffering and the causes of suffering. Then this is something which will only happen when the causes and conditions for this are assembled. In other words, in the future. Anything in the future by definition is conceptual since non conceptual consciousnesses can probably only perceive the present.
Likewise, bodhichitta refers to the future. So be careful. Bodhisattvas, obviously, are not of the future nor is bodhichitta. But bodhichitta is a wish which is focused on the future since it is a wish to attain enlightenment we do not have at present for the sake of others, and this only happens if we engage in certain activities such as study, meditation, and so forth at present. Otherwise, it will not happen.
So within the method and wisdom components of the path, the majority of the method components of the path, since they are focused on the future, are conceptual. So, obviously, bodhichitta becomes non conceptual within the mind of a fully enlightened being. But up to that point, it is conceptual. In contrast to the wisdom components of the path, such as for instance, the wisdom realizing emptiness which is poised from the standpoint of the object and through analysis of the object eventually becomes non conceptual. The minds of the method component of the path are not poised from the standpoint of the object.
It is a transformation of the mind within us. So this is how one should practice. Practicing through study in this way is stable. Otherwise, it’s unstable. Likewise, probably the object of observation and the aspect of definite emergence are one and the same, liberation.
So let’s go for it now. Great compassion is different. The object of observation and the aspect of great compassion are different. So what’s the object of observation and what’s the aspect? Number?
And the aspect? So the object of observation is correct. It’s a bit more awkward for your aspect. I’m not sure whether we can say the thought, could they be free or might they be free of suffering? Would do the job or not.
So for bodhichitta, we also have an object of observation and an aspect. We have to analyze whether they are one and the same in keeping with the quote from Abhisamayālamkāra, generating the mind is wishing for full and utter enlightenment for the sake of others. Do you propose as object of observation for bodhichitta and as aspect for bodhichitta? Of observation. So the aspect is is utter enlightenment.
So it will be very helpful to you to start by understanding clearly the difference between conceptual and non conceptual consciousnesses. Conceptual consciousnesses are consciousnesses whose focus is any event in the future or the past, what we did yesterday, before yesterday, and so forth, as well as mind such as the mind which thinks this is blue, that is yellow. These are all conceptual consciousnesses. Non conceptual consciousnesses occur in the present. It is, for instance, the perception of yellow or of blue by the visual consciousness.
Let us therefore meditate during a couple of minutes, reflect on the object of observation and the aspect of both great compassion and bodhichitta, the basis of the Mahāyāna. Mhmm. Please open the prayer book, page one. We recite one b two three four. And also page five, number six, Manarathe, verse one and three.
If you have questions, I’ll take your questions at present. Are non conceptual minds of ordinary beings reliant on the senses? It’s very difficult to posit mental consciousness, as an instance of non conceptuality within the mind of an ordinary being. So it’s a very, good point you have made. Basically, within the mind of an ordinary being, apart from conceptual consciousnesses, if we want to posit apart from sensory consciousnesses, if we want to posit non conceptual consciousnesses, we must posit the paranormal powers such as telepathy and so forth and so forth, which is very difficult to obtain.
Then apart from that you would have within the consciousness of ordinary beings, reflexive consciousnesses which are direct perceivers but their existence is not accepted by Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika. And mother? Last week, Geshela said that Lama Tsongkhapa said that he would teach concentration and the view in the great scope and teach ethics so that practitioners wouldn’t enter directly into the middling scope. Would it not follow then that the great scope should be taught first if we are if we are saying that we are travelling in the path shared with the being of the small scope and the medium scope so that we have an understanding of the great scope first. Actually, if you read Lamrim Chemo, you will find in the section between the root reliance on the spiritual teacher and the shared preliminaries, a complete explanation of the totality of the.
In addition, if one wishes to generate the realizations of the great vehicle, such as great compassion, numerous preliminaries are required. For instance, one must be able to counter the great attraction for the vanities of cyclic existence. And for that, one must travel the path shared with the being of the middling scope and so forth. I can’t. With the conceptual and non conceptual minds, is it the case that within the mind of a being with fully characterized bodhichitta or compassion that the mind has actually become bodhichitta so is then therefore a non conceptual mind?
No. There’s no definiteness. In this case, irrespective of whether we are talking of fully characterized or non fully characterized definite emergence, great compassion, or bodhichitta, in every single case, these are conceptual states of mind. Does bodhichitta exist in the mind of a Buddha? So that’s conceptual.
Over here, we are referring to great compassion and bodhichitta within the minds of sentient beings. Then within the mind stream of a Buddha, both great compassion and bodhichitta are non conceptual. All of the minds of a fully enlightened being are non conceptual. But sentient beings haven’t yet attained enlightenment. Therefore, that is something for the future.
And Geshela said that conceptual minds are that which relates to the future. So can he explain how the non conceptual nature of bodhichitta exists in the mind of a Buddha if sentient beings haven’t been liberated or have attained full enlightenment yet? That’s a good point, but as I said, I don’t explain Buddhahood. I only explain the state of sentient beings. So we set Buddhahood aside.
The thing you see is apart from the appearance and similarity, whether the great compassion and bodhichitta within the mind stream of a fully enlightened being are actually identical to that which is in our mind stream is very open to question. It has to be examined. That’s very good. You are asking the questions as they arise, and as a result, understanding will become pure. Otherwise, if you don’t ask your questions, doubts, you will never understand fully.
It is in this interchange, questions and answers, that understanding will arise. Otherwise, if the teacher just explains from the pulpit and the students take notes, there is little benefit. I can’t. Natalie? Clearly, the conceptual consciousness is totally linked to ignorance.
But I was just wondering with the perception of colors and so forth which Geshela mentioned was a conceptual consciousness. And I know we’re not talking about Buddhahood but when one becomes a Buddha, does one have that conceptual consciousness that perceives the color blue as as blue, etcetera? Or is that completely different for them? There’s no conceptuality within the mind stream of a Buddha. That type of consciousness, this is yellow, this is Buddha, does not exist.
In brief, there is no conceptuality, no ideation within the mind stream of a Buddha, no mind which thinks this is this, that is that. Okay. Maybe a silly question. His Holiness said that once we receive once beings become enlightened, they have a choice to reincarnate or not. So can Geshela explain what choice what that sort of choice may look like in the context of his own in it?
Sorry. Once one becomes fully enlightened Enlightened, they have a they can choose to reincarnate Or not. Or not. Uh-huh. Yes.
And so how that is a non-conceptual experience. If you take the case of his holiness to Dalai Lama, for the sake of sentient beings like us, he appears like a sentient being like us. Then, in his mind stream, there would be conceptuality. Illusion. You mean ignorance or illusion?
What do you mean by illusion? And you want to know if No. Because there’s no such thing as a non conceptual consciousness with that sort of illusion, as you say. Illusions are conceptual. Another?
I just missed I didn’t hear regarding what the aspect of great compassion was. Should they be free of suffering? It’s a concept. It’s a consciousness. Samadha.
Any question? Yeah. Just one? Just with the Dalai Lama, for example, or other fully realized beings who decide to reincarnate, I’m surprised that Geshela’s answer was that it would be a conceptual mind because wouldn’t their decision to reincarnate be part of effort of bodhichitta, which at their level is non conceptual. So would the decision to reincarnate just be part of that non conceptual mind?
Yes, you can say that.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Are the nonconceptual minds of ordinary beings reliant on the senses?
It is very difficult to posit mental consciousness as an instance of nonconceptuality within the mind of an ordinary being. Apart from conceptual consciousnesses and sensory consciousnesses, the only way to posit nonconceptual consciousnesses in an ordinary being's mind is through paranormal powers such as telepathy, which are very difficult to obtain. Ordinary beings also have reflexive consciousnesses, which are direct perceivers, but the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika school does not accept their existence.