1 h 44 min · 4,770 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching covers the right motivation for listening to dharma, namely generating bodhicitta, and the need to mix the teaching with one’s mind rather than attending as a mere formality. It then explains the six discriminations of the spiritual friend as a doctor, the sickness of the afflictions, and the need to practice what is heard. The talk also covers the causes of precious human rebirth, and ends with a question and answer session on stable meditation, the wisdom arising from hearing, and the root of the afflictions.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 44m
UUID: 1ff1bd9d-20b4-4cbc-a106-7a4b5724dea1
Words: 4,766
So there is a great danger in the topic which was presented last week which we have to be fully aware of. It is that while we are physically present at the temple during the teachings, our mind may be thousands or even millions of miles away. And the way to address this is that in the same way as our body is physically present in the temple, likewise our mind should be in our body during the teachings. If this is the case, then we will not suffer from the thought of being an upturned vase. It is not sufficient however for the teacher to be, fully aware of what he teaches and for the students to be physically present and to mentally concentrate.
These are not sufficient criteria to attend teaching. If one attends teachings with the motivation of gaining information or data or of teaching in turn oneself to others, this is a wrong and incorrect motivation. Let alone this, if one attends teachings on such profound dharma with the motivation of benefiting oneself alone through training as a hearer or a solitary realizer, this is also incorrect. What therefore is the motivation with which one should listen to such teachings? The best motivation is a motivation of uncontrived or spontaneous bodhichitta.
However, at the very least, one needs a motivation of contrived or generated bodhichitta, which is a motivation thinking, I must set all sentient beings without exception in the state of full enlightenment, a state bereft of suffering and endowed with all happiness. And this is a motivation. I will attend these teachings and listen to these teachings not to gather information, but to generate the requisite states of mind within my mind stream. Geshela expanded this in detail because he feels it’s important for us to understand this and we will now meditate for one or two minutes on this motivation. We ourselves do not purify our obstructions, who will?
Practicing in this way is the practice of the Bodhisattvas. The meaning of this stanza is that irrespective of whether one is one who teaches dharma or one who practices dharma, in either case, when the teachings and our mind are separate and are not blended, then this is inappropriate practice. So the example which is given for this in the Lamrim is this is akin to checking one’s face in a mirror to see if there are any stains on it so that one can clean one’s face. So in the same way, using the Lamrim as our reference and looking at the face of our mind in the mirror of the Lamrim, we examine it to see what delusions are present within our mind, whether it is desire, anger, ignorance so forth. Whatever delusion is present, we apply the appropriate antidote.
In the case of anger, for instance, we would train in forbearance and patience to progressively eliminate anger within our mind stream. And all of you are familiar probably with the fact that patience or forbearance is the antidote to anger, then training in this way in keeping with the texts, with the scriptures is a way to train our mind. Within us in this room, there is not one of us who is not prone to anger in one form or the other. Then generally speaking, we block the gateway, we block the door to anger before it arises. However, should it arise, we then apply the appropriate antidote, in this case forbearance, to eliminating anger.
If we act in this way, trying to prevent it from arising and if it arises applying the antidote progressively over time, we will be able to reduce anger. As Śāntideva says in his body, Bodhicharyavatara, we have to apply the antidote to the enemy of anger who is at odds with us. Then if we apply the antidote to anger, we can say we are indeed practicing dharma. On the other hand, if we never apply the antidotes to anger, then there is no practice of dharma within us. In this room, we are all beginners, most probably, and therefore what is the practice which befits beginners?
It is to try to create a stable mind aiming for happiness in future lives. And then, through understanding clearly the causes for generating this wish for happiness in future lives, we will be able to generate it and independence on this over time to generate a wish to be freed from all lives. And what is the cause for obtaining in future lives the high state or the highest state of a human being or a god? As has been many times explained in the past, it is the practice of the 10 virtues. While the ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non-virtues is a general cause of higher rebirth in future lives, it cannot be said to be the specific cause of obtaining a human rebirth with leisure and endowment, a precious human rebirth.
Because in addition to this ethics, one needs also the practice of the six perfections. And in addition, therefore, to an ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues and a practice of the six perfections, one needs as a connecting factor to obtaining this precious human rebirth with the eight freedoms and the 10 endowments in a future life, pure prayers to that end. When all these three factors are conjoined, it is almost 100% certain that we will obtain this precious human rebirth. As is said in Dharmakīrti’s Pramānavārttika, Once the collection of the causes without exception have been assembled, how could the result not arise? This is said in dependence on Dharmakīrti’s own experience.
And therefore our goal cannot be merely to obtain a basis in a future life in a happy realm, in a happy rebirth. It must be to obtain a precious human rebirth of leisure and endowment with the eight leisure and the 10 endowments. And this is obtained through conjoining the ethics, which is an abandonment of the 10 non-virtues, the six perfections and pure prayers to that end at the time of death. And here, what precisely is meant by stainless or uncontaminated prayers? These are prayers which are conjoined with the roots of virtue which are created through this ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues and the practice of the six perfections acting as a substantial cause and stainless prayers acting as a cooperative condition to give rise to their result, which is a human rebirth with the Eight Freedoms and the 10 Endowments.
Once these conditions are assembled, result will necessarily arise. On the other hand, if the substantial cause, which is the ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues and the practice of the six perfection is absent, irrespective of how many powerful prayers, stainless prayers to obtain a human rebirth, which are cooperative conditions are made, the result will not arise. And if we analyze, we can see for us in this room, every single one of us is the result of the union of the spermatozoa of the father and the ovum of our mother. However, if we analyze further, we can see that this union of the spermatozoa of the father and the ovum of the mother is the result of a substantial cause, which is that ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues and the practice of the six perfections. And then once the fertilized egg has arisen then it multiplies.
So this is how psychic existence proceeds. Now the precise way in which a former substantial cause gives rise to its substantial effect and the way in which cooperative conditions are necessary for this to arrive is a complicated topic, which is addressed in studies of Buddhist philosophy. And Geshela suspects if we enter into this now, none of us is going to have time for a meal for a very long time. So in the context of our discussion or Geshela’s presentation of motivation at the beginning of this teaching, how should one proceed? These are Geshela’s own thoughts on the topic.
When one rises in the morning, one has to generate a motivation. However, motivations cannot be generated purely intellectually. It is necessary to root oneself in one’s own experience. Now, for instance, if one encounters in the streets here an invalid or someone who suffers from horrendous physical deformities, who is blind, who has no hands, who has no legs, then when the spontaneous feeling of sympathy and fear from our own side thinking how could I handle such a predicament if I was in his situation arises. At that point, we should use this to generate a motivation through examining the possible causes of this person’s predicament.
On the other hand, if when we encounter either a human being or an animal who is terribly afflicted, we are totally indifferent and just pass our way, then it is clear that from our side we can say there is no motivation of any type which is present. Would there be such a motivation present? So once such a strong motivation is present, then it can help us greatly for our practice. So someone who has an innate feeling of sympathy for afflicted or infirm persons can be probably said to be a Mahāyāna person, a Mahāyāna being. So within the general outline of the liberation in the palm of your hands, We have covered the two first general outlines.
The first outline which, explains the greatness of the author given to show the teaching has an immaculate source on page six seventy three of your English translation. And the second outline, the greatness of the dharma given to increase one’s respect for the instruction. We are at present at the level of the third outline on page six seventy four, how to teach and listen to a dharma which has these two greatnesses. And here there is a two fold presentation of the forts which avoided. Are to The three faults which Gesheera explained last time.
The fault of being like an upturned vessel, like a stained and like a leaky vessel and the six qualities which will be covered today or these six discriminations. So Gisham will recapitulate what was presented last time and initially we must understand that most probably to give rise to the six discriminations of what your transition causes, six helpful attitudes, it is necessary to have initially eliminated the three fourths of the vessel. So the first of the six discriminations is a discrimination which sees oneself as someone who is sick or as a patient. Generally here, discrimination has two aspects: seeing oneself as diseased or a patient from the standpoint of definitive meaning and from the standpoint of interpretable meaning. In this context what is referred to is seeing oneself as a patient from the standpoint of definitive meaning.
And the remaining six discriminations are presented on page six seventy four of your English translation, in the middle of the text. So, the first was developing the attitude that one is like a patient. The second, developing the attitude that the dharma is medicine. The third, that the spiritual guide or the virtuous friend is a skillful doctor. The fourth, that diligent practice will cure the disease.
The fifth, that Tathagatas are holy beings. And the sixth, that this tradition should be preserved for a long time. The five later ones are the direct result of the first one realizing that oneself is a patient. Here it is evident that based on the first discrimination, seeing ourselves as a patient, we will understand the need for medicine to cure our condition and based on the second discrimination, understanding the need for medicine, the medicine of dharma to cure our condition, we will understand the need for a doctor, a physician who is the virtuous or the spiritual friend. So the idea that we are hale and healthy and are not sick in any respect is actually the exact opposite of the first discrimination, the discrimination that we are sick or we are patients.
This very widespread attitude is due to the fact that since beginningless time we have been suffering from the afflictions and therefore are profoundly habituated to them. So in worldly matters, this is never in doubt. When someone is suffering from what is known as a disease from the standpoint of the world, from a secular standpoint, such as a high fever, then because this is totally at odds with his previous state of affairs, he is immediately acknowledged as sick. So it is not the case as is often heard that there is no suffering, no pangs associated with these inner afflictions. If we take for instance the case of someone who goes downtown shopping and goes into a big shopping mall and sees, for instance, something which is very attractive, which he would like to purchase, but lacks the money or the credit to do so.
When this person goes home, the pangs of desire are amplified as his mind thinks again and again of the qualities of what he wants but can never get. As for the pangs or the anguish due to anger, this is something we are all very familiar with. There is no need to talk about it extensively. When we are assembled in a community, there will always be someone who will, criticize us for our past faults, for our present faults or for our future faults. This creates great mental suffering within the person.
These are the pangs of anger. As for the pangs of envy, envy can probably only be experienced strongly with respect to people who are close to us, to acquaintances. We can see for ourselves that often when someone who is close to us receives a present, receives money, does very well in his studies, envy and competitiveness arise within our mind and we experience the pangs or the suffering of that. This is why Śāntideva says that for us ordinary beings, the suffering of the afflictions are like a poison. And this is why Geshe Potowa says, who does not experience disease, who has not experienced being homeless?
Now for us, most of the diseases we have the experience of are physical or bodily diseases. However, these physical diseases are actually at the end of a process which starts with the mind and within the mind which starts with afflictions. This is why Śāntideva says we have to become masters of our minds. And this is why if we have the strong discrimination which wishes to give rise to a mind benefiting others in keeping with our wish to practice the Mahāyāna, then we will be able to progressively reduce pride, competitiveness and envy within our mind and as a result of this, progressively our physical afflictions will also be reduced as is evinced by the experience of His Holiness Dalai Lama or our teacher, Kensur Kangurwa Rinpoche, who progressively over time, out of the wish to benefit others, reduced pride, desire, envy and so forth within their minds and themselves are in exceptionally good health. And while we ourselves in this room all study, the big difference between ourselves and these great beings is that we do not practice what we study.
They themselves practiced what they studied and we can see in the case of Kensur Kangurwa Rinpoche, the case of Kensur Kangurwa Rinpoche, just how happy their minds are and how healthy their bodies are for their age. And in the case of our great teacher from Sera Je, Khensur Rinpoche, even though Khensur Rinpoche passed on at the age of 93, his mind was silver sharp at 93, while so many in the West suffer eventually from Alzheimer’s and become like children. And the cause for this and it is something which was observed in Tibet in the old days is that as one grows older, the physical faculties weaken and one’s behavior becomes more and more childish. And therefore, such a being who suffers from the afflictions can be posited as someone who is sick or a patient. Second, discrimination, which is discrimination which understands the holy dharma as medicine, arises as a direct result of the first one which sees ourselves as diseased or sick.
Regarding the third discrimination, the discrimination which realizes that the Mahāyāna virtuous friend is skilled in healing diseases. This is similar to the understanding in worldly affairs of someone who has a headache. When someone has a headache, he understands he or she must take medicine. However, if he takes medicine without relying on a doctor who knows whether the medicine should be taken before or after a meal in conjunction with hot or cold water, he runs a risk not only of not healing his disease, but for some types of medicine of actually harming his life. In worldly affairs, this is something we understand very well.
When we build a house, we ask advice both from an engineer and an architect. We don’t build a house in any which way. Likewise, if we have to travel abroad, we document ourselves and don’t just jump on the plane. If we have to travel far away and we have not informed ourselves on the habits in the foreign country and the means to get there, we run the risk of not reaching our destination or running into trouble when we get there. Therefore, we must consult someone who has been there and knows how to travel.
This is why it’s not sufficient to rely on books one actually needs a teacher. Geshe knows for a fact that there are several students here who can read Tibetan quite well. Nonetheless, they don’t understand the meaning of what they read. For this reason, they obviously need a teacher. Geshela from his own side can really read English characters, but he doesn’t understand the meaning of the terms.
He also needs a teacher. The fourth discrimination is the discrimination that one must necessarily practice to heal the disease. An example for this discrimination is that someone who knows he is sick, who therefore knows he must take medicine and who understands that he needs a doctor’s advice regarding which medicine and how it should be taken, is not by that alone in the position to be healed. His healing does not depend on the doctor or on the medicine alone. It depends on his own efforts.
If he does not take the medicine which is given to him or he takes the wrong amount or he takes it at the wrong time, then it will be of no benefit to him. So for ourselves, we know full well that we have received large amounts of instructions from Mahāyāna virtuous friends and yet if we ourselves do not practice these instructions then we will not be healed and it will not be the fault of the instruction nor will it be the fault of the spiritual teacher it will be our own fault. So this is the summarized meaning of these. So, examples for this would be someone who wishes to eat sugarcane, and strives to find sugarcane stalks, but then does not eat the, sweet sugarcane or someone who has no life experience of any type and keeps watching shows to gain, artificial experiences or someone for that matter who is destitute but keeps counting and trying to figure what the king has in his treasure vault. In every single case, this is a case of someone who studies, hears but does not practice.
We should behave in the same way as someone who has just become ordained and who thinks now I am really going to practice. In the same way, once we start listening to teachings we should think now I am really going to start practicing. And this is why it is said there is absolutely no benefit in attending teaching after teaching, receiving countless profound instructions, never ever practicing and actually ending up worse after having received many teachings than before one had started. This is an absolute and complete waste of time. This is the fault of being inured to dharma.
It arises when our minds and the teaching have been kept separate for a long time. Then we attend teachings and we think, yes, they always say this, this is what they always say, here it goes on and on and on again, they always speak of this. This is a clear sign that the mind is inured to dharma. Therefore, it is very important that we be careful in this matter. So the great Kadampa teachers of yore said, giving an example for this, this is a akin to leather which has been used to carry butter and in which the butter has infused to such a degree that the leather itself is hard and can no longer be softened by butter anymore.
In the same way, people who have attended many teachings and have never put anything in practice are unhelpable. And therefore Geshela will summarize at present a little bit the instructions. This is why Je Tsongkhapa says using the example of someone suffering from leprosy, but we could use a contemporary example, let us say diabetes, that when one is sick from such a disease, one must apply the instructions continually for a long time to hope for any type of cure. This is why Buddha Śākyamūni says, formally I explained much worthy dharma to you. After listening, you did not put it in practice.
The disease has worsened. What I myself cannot heal such a one. Now this is akin to our situation when we receive instructions to take medicine, do not take it and as it were put it in a box. So returning to our six discriminations, this corresponds to a patient who has gone to a doctor and has received clear advice to take the medicine but does not take it as he was told. So likewise for us, we have attended many teachings, received numerous teaching, we have in other words much hearing.
If we practice in keeping with what we were taught, we will reach the goal. So the meaning here was collated from sūtra, from the Bodhicharyavatara and from the Lamrim Chenmo. As Atisha’s foremost disciple, Geshe Dromtonpa said, when I listen, I mix it inseparably with the practices of thinking and meditating. When I think I both listen and meditate and when I meditate, I practice hearing and thinking. So this inseparable practice of the three activities of hearing, thinking and meditating in keeping with Dromtonpa’s advice is how we should practice.
An example of this is given with an account from Geshe Chengawa’s life, a great Kadampa practitioner who when he was reading a text on Vinaya, on Buddhist monastic discipline, had been seated on a leather skin, a leather couch to protect himself from the cold. When he ran in the discipline text that monks were not allowed to sit on leather, he immediately took this leather skin and threw it away. This is a clear indication of acting immediately in dependence on hearing. And then after doing this, reading further in the text on Vinaya, Geshe Chengawa saw that there was an exception for bhikshus who were sick or in very cold climates and needed to sit on leather. Then he went, he took the leather skin and he sat back on it.
And this is how we should practice. When we are studying a text, the moment we read something relevant to us, we should apply it immediately. So this is a problem, the problem with leather skins is a problem for monks, it doesn’t concern us. You don’t have to worry about sitting on leather. So this first discrimination, Geshela suspects that we are all sick has made you all very uptight, but don’t understand it in the wrong way.
Please therefore reflect carefully on the simile of the sick person who must take medicine and who needs a doctor to give him medicine. This doctor being the spiritual friend who is wise in administering medicine. So because these teachings were formulated largely by the Buddha Śākyamūni and by Śāntideva who taught from their respective experience, They are easy to understand and very fertile. So we will stop here for today. And we have fifteen minutes.
If you have questions, please ask them. So the question is, in a nutshell, what is stable practice, stable meditation? So stable meditation means meditation we do not waver from, which is unstained, which we stick with. Are there other questions? Yes.
What we mean by the wisdom arising from thinking is certitude regarding a topic definiteness. Now when we meet someone after the teaching and we talk in a friendly fashion with them, this will not affect the wisdom arising from thinking basically because we do not have it. It will affect however the wisdom arisen from hearing. However, to prevent the degeneration of the wisdom arisen from hearing, which is what concerns us in your question, the best thing as Pabongka Rinpoche says is not only to read repeatedly what one has studied but when one leaves the temple to talk with one’s friends only about the topics studied in the temple. In keeping with what was explained in the context of generating the motivation, when in dependence on this wisdom arisen from hearing, eventually we gain certainty regarding the topic we have been receiving teachings about.
Then one can speak of attaining the wisdom arisen from thinking, not before. One cannot say that all afflictions arise from wrong views. However, certain afflictions do arise from wrong views. All afflictions without exception arise from the innate grasping at the self. With what?
By emotions, you mean afflictions or emotions? Afflictions. Geshela said I have to answer in his sentences for such a basic question. Now if one abandons the innate grasping at the self, there are no afflictions. Once one has abandoned the innate apprehension of the self, one has become an Arhat.
Then an arhat has no delusions, no afflictions. Now don’t however think that in an Arhat’s mind there is not the thought which thinks I, that is present. Arhat in Tibetan is translated is foe. Is to destroy.
It’s a foe destroyer. What is destroyed is anger and all the other afflictions. So first one must identify exactly the delusion one is trying to counter. Then one must use the appropriate counter to that delusion. If it is applied with enough force, the delusion will not continue to arise.
So if you counter the delusions well, then you eliminate them from the hand. Are there other questions? Yes. So this is a difficult and dangerous topic To be able to meditate correctly on emptiness, first, one must understand the view of the self of the non Buddhists. Once one has understood the view of the self of the non Buddhists and one has countered that, then one must understand the view of selflessness of the two lower schools, the Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika schools, since these views are eventually rejected.
Once one has countered this and one has reached the view of the highest school, the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika School, one must understand clearly within the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika School the object of refutation. This is best understood in the light of Je Tsongkhapa’s insight section of the Lamrim Chenmo. Geshela hopes at some point in the future if there is enough interest to be able to teach it. So to explain it concisely he is unable to do. To explain it extensively there is no time therefore we must leave it at that.
I I can’t hear the last bit. Excuse me. So, Wal, what you are saying is true. If you want to practice an ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues with their roots or their grains, literally, At present, all we can practice is abandoning the manifestation of the 10 non virtuous deeds. We cannot abandon them from the root up.
If we take the case of anger, we say we must abandon anger, but at all level what we mean is that we must abandon the manifestations of anger such as a flushed face, a disturbed complexion, harsh words and wild gestures. For us it is not possible to abandon anger from the root up.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- definitive meaning nitartha (Skt); ngedön (Tib)
- One of two main ways of understanding a Dharma teaching, this one is where the content is be taken literally and not open for interpretation, as opposed to the interpretive meaning. LYWA
- eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
- The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- six helpful attitudes
- The practitioner is like the patient, the Dharma is medicine, the guru is like a skilled doctor and the Sangha are like nurses, Dharma practice is like the cure, the guru is as holy as the buddhas... LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.