Lam Rim – 03 LR 1990 02 24

1 h 3 min · 3,285 words · 24 February 1990

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 03 LR 1990 02 24
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. This session continues the Lam Rim teaching on the importance of the graduated path. It explains that the path shows the apparently contradictory teachings of the Buddha, such as those on killing and on Tantra, can be harmonized into one coherent practice. The later part answers questions on the degeneration of the teaching, how much understanding of karma is needed before emptiness, and the Four Noble Truths.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1990-02-24

Duration: 1h 4m

UUID: 4bd75e87-5b31-4101-b585-f859cafb07b1

Words: 3,281

So, you know, there’s nothing particularly wonderful about explaining the Dharma. There are many people who teach the Dharma or spiritual practices in general who go to hell. But there’s something very wonderful about practicing the Dharma. That is to say by practicing the Dharma to integrate the Dharma within your own mind. And to that end, the best means of this integration process is by means of the method of the graduated path.

And I appreciate very much the older students who have, come to these teachings on the graduated path. Enjoy that very much if you have the time to come because listening is the method by which we will gain the experience, the various realizations. And so it’s very good that you have come. So continuing with the overall second division, the importance of the teachings on the graduated path and the, this begins with the sixth verse in which it says from Nāgārjuna and Asaṇga, banners unto all mankind, ornaments amongst the world sages comes to the sublime Lamrim lineage. The first reason that Dharma teachings are of not the Dharma teachings, the teachings of the Lam graduated path are of such importance is that they are the way of practicing the instructions of both of the precepts of the vast and the profound.

The vast and profound lineage coming from Asaṇga and Nāgārjuna, that their various instructions are presented within the graduated teachings of the graduated path. In this second verse, the seventh verse, fulfilling all the hopes of practitioners, it is a wish fulfilling gem combining the streams of a thousand teachings is an ocean of excellent guidance. Is setting forth the second reason for the importance of the graduated path in that it, it fulfills all the hopes of sentient beings whosoever that it is the Lamrim, the graduated path teachings are likened to, a wish fulfilling gem. The, you know, the most precious of the king of jewels, the most precious. Because there this wish fulfilling gem has the capacity that anything that we request of it, will fulfill that wish, whether it was food, clothing, or whatsoever.

And likewise, the teachings on the graduated path will fulfill the the aspirations of all sentient beings whosoever, whether it’s that of the small capacity, middling capacity, or great capacity, it can fulfill all their wishes. So the practices on the graduated path can be unmistakenly and readily put into practice because they set forth very clearly the method for subduing the mind. The initial methods for subduing the mind, those in the intermediate and the final methods for subduing the mind. There are various stages for subduing the mind. And the third reason of the teachings on the graduated path is the the latter two lines of the seventh verse where it says combining the streams of a thousand teachings is an ocean of excellent guidance.

Just as in the case of the ocean which surrounds Australia because it is all of the rivers which flow out of Australia together in this vast ocean. Likewise, all of the teachings of the Buddha, whether Sūtra or Tantra, come together in the teachings of the graduated path. It is as if the graduated path is is the takes all of these subjects and condenses them into the graduated path is the condensation of the essence of all the subjects of the teachings of the Buddha joined together. So fourth reason, with the first line on the eighth verse set forth. Through it, one perceives all doctrines as non contradictory.

So the Buddha set forth many, many, levels of teachings. He said teachings set forth teachings on on Vinaya or there’s a moral discipline on the perfections of and Sūtra and also the teachings on secret mantra or Tantra taught many many teachings and each of these various levels there are there are various admonition restrictions and prescriptions. What was to be practiced and what was to be guarded against. For example, in in the case of or moral discipline and teachings to the monks, he said you cannot you must be celibate. You cannot kill.

Various restrictions were placed upon the monks. In the case of the teachings on the perfections, especially with the case of the great vehicle, they said that sometimes it may be necessary to kill out of compassion. Then he went on in his teachings and giving teachings on, Tantra. In Tantra, the the it is necessary to to generate great bliss. So therefore, one either imaginatively or in actual fact may as a means of practice engage in union with consort as a means of generating their great bliss in dependence upon which one meditates on emptiness.

Also, may be make it it is prescribed that you make use of alcohol and meat. Meat. So it appears that there’s a great contradictions with through through all of these vast teachings. One in some he says, you cannot kill at all. Others say it may be necessary.

Some, we may some people not understanding these teachings will see that, oh, he that there’s a lot of contradiction and a lot of a lot of conflicting teachings within the Buddha. This and they’ll begin to a different discriminate between all these various teachings that this is a good teaching. This is a bad teaching. Those who wish to practice Sūtra will say, oh, tantra, was not taught by the Buddha. It’s something which is very bad.

Those who want to practice tantra say, oh, the sūtra teachings are not for me. They are not, they are not, they are beneath my practice. And therefore there become this discrimination through not understanding. If we, through the listening to and reflecting upon the meaning of the teachings of the graduated path, we can come to see that there is no contradiction in any of the teachings of the Buddha, that they all can be harmonized into a coherent view, and that they are all prescriptions of practice. They are all methods of practice, instructions on practice.

So this is one reason that for the importance of the teachings on the graduated path because they clearly demonstrate that there are no contradictions within the teachings of the Buddha even though at certain levels he said one is not allowed to kill. At other times he said well there are cases where you’re allowed to kill and sometimes he said you shouldn’t do this type of activity. Sometimes he said you should do this activity and how to harmonize these is this understanding is gained through the understanding of the graduated path. Then the next line in that same verse, the second line of the eighth verse where it says all teachings arise as personal advice. That not only does the Lam Rim, the graduated path, help us to understand that there are no contradictions or conflicts within the teachings of the Buddha, but it it enables us to understand that that all of them, the teachings, must be practiced by one person if he if that person is to attain Buddhahood.

And contradictions within the teachings of the Buddha and that all of the teachings, all of the practices explained are to be methods for one person to attain the state of the conqueror, in this way, as it says in the third line, the intent of the Buddha is easily found. So is it dependence upon these explanations that we are ultimately able to achieve the state of the conqueror, that is to say the state of the Buddha, in developing the various levels of the Three Principal Aspects of the path, renunciation or the determination to be free, the awareness of the of of of upon the practice of what is explained within the lam, the graduated path. And then the fourth line of this same verse, and one is protected from the cliff of greatest greatest evils here are the extreme negativities which arise through depreciating, deprecating, deprecating, putting down, any of the teachings of the Buddha. And, by coming by the by understanding the understanding the graduated path, we no longer are susceptible to deprecate, to put down any of the teachings of the Buddha. You know, for example, some people think that Sūtra, the discourse of the Buddha, are the are the are right teachings.

These are the the really the good teachings of the Buddha whereas the teachings on mantra are really despicable. They put them down. Or on the other hand, they think mantra is the only way to go and they put down Sūtra. They that is the they they depreciate. Deprecate.

Or they say, Oh, one should practice, you know, put down the greater vehicle teachings in favor of the lesser vehicle teachings. Or the other way about, they say that one should practice the great vehicle and they put down the lesser vehicle. And in this way they create a great deal of negativity. If by understanding how all of the teachings of the Buddha are are means of practice, one ceases from deprecating any of the teachings of the Buddha. So these are the seven these are the seven seven reasons on why I’m showing the importance of the teachings on the graduated path.

So basically what it is. Now so if we present an analogy of the way in which the the all of the teachings of the Buddha though they are are vast and varied are to be harmonized within the practice of one individual. If someone were going to paint a a painting of particular deity, they would have to gather together many different supplies and very different, different types of different colored paints for example. Red paints, yellow paints, blue paints. And one might think that all of these different colors, they don’t there’s a I’m trying to think of a good word.

They’re in discord with one another. Discord. They clash, good word. They clash with one another, know. But bringing all of these colors together, even though they is a they clash, we can harmonize them and paint a beautiful painting, bringing it together and we can harmonize them and balance them.

Likewise, the teachings on the graduated path, though these teachings, various teachings seem initially to clash, the teachings on the Lamrim, they are all brought into harmony. So, you know, we we all know this with regard to painting this painting that that we need all of these various colors to bring together to and that essentially, they will not ultimately, they will not clash. So, initially, we may we may not see how all of these various the various teachings of the Buddha are to be harmonized into a single practice for one individual. But in the same way, though we you going back to our analogy of the painting, we know that, that we have all of these various colors that ultimately they do not necessarily clash but we don’t know how to properly combine them to bring about a beautiful end result. And so we rely on an artist.

The artist says, well, you know, shows us how to make the drawing and shows us, well, we’ll paint this white, we’ll paint this green, we’ll paint this blue, we’ll paint this yellow. And through the instructions of the artist, can harmonize all of these various colors into forming a beautiful end product. Likewise, we make use of the the initially, we we are not able to see we see we’re not able to harmonize all of the apparent contradictions within the teaching of the Buddha, but it is through the teachings of the graduated path that the that the all that these various teachings are seen as a palette of precepts which will combine to form a beautiful practice for one individual. In this way, we all have to become spiritual artists that, we have to begin to harmonize our practice and know in what order the various precepts are to be, implemented. Just as in the case of, the artist the instructor who says, now this is where the red color goes, this is where the yellow yellow color goes, this is where the blue color goes and following those instructions, we we the end result is a very beautiful painting.

Likewise, through instructions of the the teachings on the graduated path, it says, now this is to be practiced first, this is to be practiced second, and this is to practiced third, making use of the palette of precepts in order to develop a beautiful practice, which which all can see for themselves. So just as in the case of painting a beautiful deity that that on on different occasions, we must make use of different colors in in different circumstance in different areas of the painting. We have to apply different color paint. For example, you know, if anyone were to see this, the painting of the Buddha, they was, oh, isn’t that a beautiful painting? It’s because everything is in its in the right place and therefore there it creates a harmony and a and a a proper form in in which which is very pleasing.

Likewise, if in the in our in our spiritual practice, everything there is an occasion for the use of the various precepts and everything must be in its right order and place in order to create the beautiful practice. You know the various, teachings on the capacities of small, middling, great, the various, principles of the path from the developing the determination to be free, awakening heart, correct view. If, you know, we take an example, if someone were first to practice the great vehicle, practicing the great vehicle, and they haven’t passed through the stages of the capacity of, they haven’t trained in the teachings of the middling and small capacity, then they they will not then there isn’t the correct order. The the practice, the precepts aren’t in the right places, and one has not ascertained the the thought of the conqueror, the Buddha. So by means of the teachings on the graduated path, an individual can ascertain the, what precepts are would be proper to his or her position on the path.

You know, the just like we talk about in the teachings on seventy topics, we talk about the boundaries of the various states, you know, where they occur. Likewise, the Lamrim sets out where various precepts are to be put into practice and one can ascertain for oneself can understand this will be a benefit to me now in the present. This is where I am along the path and therefore taking and understanding the graduated path can take the various precepts and apply them to themselves in the proper place. So just as in the case of someone who who goes to school and upon entering school, they go to the the first grade. And then from the from the first grade, they pass on to the second grade, the third grade, fourth grade, the fifth, sixth, seventh, and so forth.

That each of these grades has an appropriate course of study and before one is able to progress on to the next class, one has to bring to completion the appropriate study of the preceding class. Likewise, within our spiritual classes progression it’s necessary to advance in the same way that first beginning with the gaining the appropriate understandings of the being of small capacity, then middling capacity, then great capacity. So so we’ll spend we’ll spend five minutes on questions. So we have some questions. So the necessity for even though the teachings of Buddha will completely degenerate in the future and become extinct.

And still presently one should, the reasons for carrying on a practice are to develop all of the excellent qualities within oneself to implant latencies of various skillful actions so that, in the future that we ourselves will not have to experience suffering, that we’ll be able to experience happiness, that we can progress, progress along in our spiritual development and finally attain Buddhahood. So though in fact the teachings will degenerate in this this world if through, various practices of mind training and the making of and making prayers that we can take rebirth in a place where the teachings are still extant, where they still exist. And there we can meet with a spiritual friend, and carry on the various practices and progress in our spiritual journey. It’s not necessary that we continually take rebirth in this world. They go.

There are many different degrees of subtlety with respect to the presentation of, for example, the law of cause and effect. Ultimately, the law of cause and effect can only be thoroughly understood by a Buddha. But there are different degrees of explanations which we can understand before we are Buddha and also before we understand emptiness. We can simply understand that from unskillful actions arises suffering, skillful actions arises happiness. In order to understand this, we don’t have to understand emptiness.

So it’s not necessary for a rough, general explanation of understanding of karma before that to understand emptiness. It’s quite correct that our understanding of emptiness will facilitate the understanding of the law of cause and effect. And likewise, our understanding of the law of cause and effect will facilitate our understanding of emptiness. But initially, we are trying to gain conviction in the law of cause and effect. And difference between gaining conviction and an actual realization, to gain this conviction within the law of cause and effect, we don’t have to realize emptiness.

I wish I quoted a verse from Dharmakīrti, setting forth the motive practice of the four noble truths, which the first two of the Four Noble Truths are to be abandoned, that is to say true sufferings and true causes of suffering. The latter two Four Noble Truths are to be cultivated. That is the true cessation and the path leading to true cessation. What is most important in our practice is the practice, the path of liberation. And the Buddha set forth the practice of the path to liberation in an unerring fashion.

And he set it forth in accordance with the four noble truths. And we are to first gain conviction in the conviction in the true sources of sufferings. Even though we haven’t realized the actual paths to liberation, which is the fourth noble truth. First coming to an understanding of your suffering and the causes of your suffering which requires a conviction in the law of cause and effect. This will bring about the eventual, this is the way the path progresses toward liberation.

It’s not necessa only the Buddha can ultimately understand the law of cause and effect. So there might be some misunderstanding in your interpretation of the Buddha’s admonition for us to examine his teachings. He said as you are alluding to that we should examine his teachings as we do gold. We should investigate them. But here he was referring to his teachings on the view.

He set forth many different teachings on the view, the view of the ultimate nature of reality, and that we should examine these, investigate all of these varying views that he set forth. But with respect to the law of cause and effect, he said from skillful actions comes happiness, from unskillful actions comes suffering. He did not set forth any other interpretation, any other way of looking at law of cause and effect than that. Therefore, with respect to this, there’s no need for investigation, just a conviction.

Key terms in this teaching

four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
tantra gyü (Tib)
Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top