44 min · 4,927 words · 4 December 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk teaches patience (kshanti) through Shantideva’s sixth chapter of the Bodhicaryavatara. It explains that the enemy is only a condition for anger, not its cause, and that the person harming us is deluded and suffering, so compassion is the appropriate response. It also covers forgiving oneself and seeing the enemy as a kind teacher, and briefly touches on the five kinds of wrong livelihood. Questions on anger and related topics are included.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-12-04
Duration: 44 min
UUID: 6a7242a1-67c4-4981-bda5-58e983fdce36
Words: 4,927
I do not like pain in the head, therefore I do not like enemy who is hitting me on the head. Bad enemy. I do this deliberately because actually our delusions are really childish, actually really stupid when we we look at them. We we like to think our delusions are terribly intelligent and sophisticated, but they’re really extremely primitive things, you know, very primitive. And so but if we from a logical point of view, from a very ordinary logical point of view, it’s it’s it’s to get angry with the enemy for hitting it because the enemy is hitting us on the head, the suffering is coming, the enemy stops the pain will stop, the enemy is the cause of the pain on the head.
To some point if we look like that. But if we check, what is actually causing the pain on the head is this thing, the repeated placement of this thing on the head. This is what is actually causing the pain. But because we are intelligent people, we don’t get angry with the stick. Why?
Because we are so intelligent that we know that the stick has no intention to cause the pain. There is a someone holding the stick. The enemy who is holding the stick and repeatedly placing it on our head, that person has the intention to harm us. So we don’t get angry with the stick, we get angry with the person. So up to that point it seems like this is end of the argument, we should get angry with the enemy.
But Śāntideva says that if really are intelligent then you should check further. We don’t get angry with the stick because we know the stick is under the control of the enemy. Then you look at the enemy and why is the enemy holding the stick and causing pain to my head? Because if one looks the enemy is totally under the control of anger. A happy person does not hit someone on the head.
A happy person doesn’t scream at someone, insult them, steal from them, say nasty unpleasant things, wish nasty unpleasant things to anyone. It’s only when someone is very unhappy and angry that a human being does that. So if that person is controlled by a great deal of delusion, a great deal of anger, then they cause harm. So the person actually has no intention to cause harm whatsoever. They are totally just like the stick has no intention to cause harm whatsoever.
It is controlled by other factors. And the person holding the stick has no intention to cause harm whatsoever because that person is totally controlled by anger. Therefore, there’s no reason to get angry with the enemy. Actually, we should feel incredible compassion for the enemy because they’re totally suffering from anger and an unhappy mind. Just like when we see someone else who is unhappy, we feel compassion.
So actually the enemy being controlled by anger is very unhappy, and therefore the valid response is to feel compassion. Wherever there is suffering, the only valid response is compassion. But when we’re controlled by anger, we never can work out what the valid response is. But when we have a clear, calm mind that comes with patience, can work out the valid response. It comes naturally.
We see that this sentient being is actually very unhappy. When see someone walking by, you know, looking very bitter and they don’t speak to you or something, You can feel hurt, Oh, why didn’t he smile? She smile? Why did they look so angry? And we put it on, Oh, my self-cherishing thought wants a little smile, a little word or something.
And we don’t like them for that. They shouldn’t. But then if you really look, oh this person is really suffering. Their face is all hard and bitter, and they’re all caught up in their own little world, their own little private predicament, and they’re miserable. So rather than worrying about, oh my poor little self-cherishing wasn’t patted on the head, you know, then we direct it the awareness goes to, oh this person is actually miserable, they are really miserable.
And then one can feel there’s a chance for it to feel compassion, not upset and hurt and whatever. So, again, this comes through the power of familiarity. It’s very easy for me to say these things, it’s very difficult for me to practice them, but the only choice is to do it through the power of familiarity. Just by knowing this, how we develop the patience is by firstly looking at this argument and coming to the conclusion this is true, this is undeniably true. And then we can admire this way of thinking, the way Śāntideva thinks.
What an amazing way to think. How incredible that is. It’s not a stupid way of thinking. This is the thinking of a really wise, compassionate, and very brave person, which is the way His Holiness thinks as well. So we can admire this way of thinking.
If we do admire this way of thinking, then we can aspire to think like that ourselves. And by aspiring to that, then that gives us the energy to try, to put in the effort to actually think like that, to become familiar with that way of thinking, which we can because our mind doesn’t truly exist. And therefore it can change. By creating the right conditions, reading Śāntideva’s chapter on patience again and again and again, the rainbow of patience will arise in the mind. It can’t there’s no choice.
If the sun shines, there’s enough water in the air, little droplets of water I don’t know what it is but the right sized droplets of water spaced out in the right distance I don’t know exactly how rainbows work. But if those things come together and you’re standing there, bingo, there’s no choice, there’s rainbow. So if we acquaint our mind with these wise arguments again and again and again. One day, bingo, patience in the mind. No choice.
Through the power, it arises depending on all these factors. That’s the way the mind works. So also in terms of this Śāntideva says in verse thirty, forty three, forty four, When the enemy hits us on the head, both his weapon and my body are the cause of my suffering. Since he gave rise to the weapon and I gave rise to the body, with whom should I be angry? Chapter six, page forty three, forty four.
You know? He gave rise to the weapon, I gave rise to the body. So why do I blame him and not blame me for giving rise to this body that hurts? If I had a Buddha body it wouldn’t hurt no matter how much you hit it on the head. So it’s my delusion and karma that have given rise to a body that can be hurt.
And it’s actually my negative karma that gave rise to the appearance of the enemy anyway. So why do I put all the blame on this person? So this is the way bodhisattvas think. We don’t think like that And we think in a much smarter, cleverer way and then we get angry. Terrific!
Why don’t we think like stupid bodhisattvas and be patient? Śāntideva says, When seeing an enemy or even a friend committing an improper action, by thinking that such a thing arises from conditions, I shall remain in a happy state of mind. And in that happy state of mind then we can do something beneficial. If enemy is doing something harmful, we can try to stop it. If the friend is doing something harmful, we can try to help the friend not do those things with wisdom and compassion, not with anger.
Was verse thirty three. Rabten Geshe says, If you do not interpret the action as harmful, then it won’t hurt. And if you did not label a person as enemy, then you would not interpret his action as harmful. So one of the key points of practicing real patience is having compassion for the enemy, realizing that the person causing us harm is actually suffering. That’s The only way any living being can cause harm to another is because that person is deluded, and the delusion is very strong in the mind.
So that is an object of compassion. And so the more we ourselves have developed compassion for our own delusions, not hating ourselves because we are are deluded and we have anger and jealousy and pride and so on, that we develop on the basis of the very fact that we have delusions, attachments and whatever, that we have we actually can love ourselves, we are still worthy happiness and compassion, the more we have put some effort into generating that mind, those thoughts towards ourselves. Because we are suffering and therefore we are objects of compassion for ourselves. So the more we’ve developed that, the more we can feel compassion for the enemy. When I get angry, I should be an object of my own compassion.
If that’s the case, when someone else gets angry, they should be an object of compassion. If my friends get angry towards my other friends, I feel compassion. So why not feel compassion for the enemy? It’s the same thing. So on the basis of that we can then start to see, as I mentioned before, an even more amazing way of practicing patience, which is to see that the enemy is our best friend.
No matter what the motivation of the enemy, no matter what they do to us, it’s incredibly kind because it’s forcing us to practice patience, forcing us to protect our mind from generating negative karma, forcing us to learn the ability to not get upset by anything, and therefore forcing us to develop this courage that is able to practice Dharma. So this is so kind because patience can only be developed, as I said before, on the basis of an enemy or an unpleasant object. One can’t practice patience on a sunny day. When one has a luxurious, totally comfortable life and everything is going just so fine, it’s impossible to practice patience. And one thinks, but there’s no need to practice patience as everything is going right.
But we have to remember that’s not permanent. It’s not permanent. All of that could come to an end in a moment, in a flash, such as what happened in Tibet, in Serbia. One day everything’s fine, the next day there’s a war going on and friends and neighbors are killing each other. Then you need some patience.
One day one is happy and healthy, the next day one is dying. Then one needs some patience. And just because one isn’t angry, it doesn’t mean we don’t have the potential for anger. Anger. We all have the potential for it because we all have ignorance.
So our anger will arise sometime because we will meet the object sometime. So we all need, even if our life is going along wonderfully and we’re surrounded by wonderful, kind, sweet people, and the sun is shining every day, and we have a nice house, and a nice car, and nice children, and a nice partner, and a nice job, and a nice government, and a nice health system, and everything is just so nice. We still need that is when we should be practicing, training how to learn to practice patience. So only the enemy can do that for us, make us angry and force us to practice patience. So this is incredibly kind.
One great French saint, I don’t know when he lived, maybe around the eighteenth century, I think, his name was Saint Francis de Salle, said, Be patient with everyone but above all with yourself. Do not be disheartened by your imperfections but always rise up with fresh courage. Make a fresh beginning daily. There is no better means of attainment in the spiritual life than by continually beginning again and never thinking we have done enough. How are we to be patient with our neighbor’s faults if we are impatient with dealing with our own?
A person who is upset by their own failings will not correct them. An all profitable correction comes from a calm and peaceful mind. So we have to be patient with ourselves, with all our faults, and never give up. As I said, when we practice the four opponent powers, one of them is the power of determination. So we make the determination not to get angry again, not to steal, not to lie, not to engage in sexual misconduct, not to do this, not to do that.
We make this very strong determination, and the very next day we break it. So what do we do? We practice patience with ourselves, we forgive ourselves, be kind and compassionate to ourselves, and we make the determination not to do it tomorrow, and the next day we do it again. So all we can do is be patient with ourselves, and be kind to ourselves, and forgive ourselves, and feel compassion for ourselves, and make the determination again. And then one day we will be able to do what we said.
And when we can do that, then we can forgive others and feel compassion. And actually, when we can do that, we can really feel compassion for those who can’t do that for themselves. So especially in this crazy world that we are in right now, patience is an incredible protection for ourselves and a great offering to others around us. While we are patient, other people don’t suffer. So in a sense, we protect their happiness.
So it’s an incredible practice to train the mind in, and the best way is through Śāntideva text, the sixth chapter, is the method how it shows how to train the mind in practicing patience. So there are many many other points but these are some of the main points to think about in analyzing and practicing patience. Another quotation I could read on a similar line as Saint Francis said, this is from a Ladakhilama called Tuksay Rinpoche, who said, The misery you have to endure in realizing enlightenment is nothing to the misery you will endure in life after life if you do not realize it. To get an arrow out of the flesh you have to probe the wound and that hurts. But be grateful that you have understood enough to choose this misery.
Not just grateful, be happy. It is important to be happy. However many times you fall, stand up. However many times you come close to despair, go on trusting. However many times your heart wants to close, keep it open.
And just to repeat what mister W H Auden says, We would rather be ruined than changed. We would rather die in our dread than climb the cross of the moment and let our illusions die. Die. Many years ago when I was in New Zealand, met a young monk, a New Zealand monk, was a disciple of Ajahn Chah, this very famous Thai monk, who had many western disciples, and one of them is Ajahn Sumedho, who started this center in England, where there are many monks and nuns now. So anyway, this young monk I met, he was telling me the story about when he was living Ajahn Chah set up a monastery near his own monastery just for the Western or non Thai monks.
So this young monk was living there, and he said at one stage, one point, they used to take it in turns or something, or Ajahn Chah would appoint one of the monks to be the person in charge of the discipline and leading the prayers and meditation and whatever. And at one point Ajahn Chah appointed this monk to be the disciplinarian and in charge of leading the prayers and meditation at night. And this person who was in charge was also very young, very new, and he took it very seriously. He would have the monks, they used to gather at night, and he would have them chanting for very long periods of time, because he was very pure, serious. And this drove this other monk, the one I met, really he couldn’t stand it.
And so one night he just walked out of the hall and he was just kind of really upset and he was just sitting on the steps outside and really very upset and very sad and really feeling very sorry for himself that, you know, why was this crazy monk in charge of everything? This was just like insane and he was feeling really upset and sad. And then while he was sitting there, Ajahn Chah actually came walking along. And then his heart kind of lifted up and thought, Oh, Ajahn Chah will see me and see I’m sad, and he’ll say some kind words to me, and he’ll get rid of this crazy monk and appoint a nice monk. And Ajahn Chah walked along, looked at him and walked off, and as he walked off he said, Die, die, die.
So that’s a little bit about patience. So we have to let our delusions die. I don’t know if it’s time to start another topic which is I’d like to talk a little bit about perseverance which is as I mentioned once, Rinpoche says, an important thing to have at the very beginning of the practice is develop enthusiasm, which is defined as finding joy in virtuous actions. But maybe before starting that, just some or anyway, do you have some questions? Yes.
Not that I’m aware of. There may be, but I don’t know if anyone can recommend a very good Oh yes, well that’s actually a commentary on that chapter. There’s a book by His Holiness called Healing Anger. Healing Anger. Oh, I see.
No, maybe it’s called healing emotions, isn’t it? Healing anger. Oh, alright. No, I can’t think of anything. No.
Yes. It is called healing emotions, isn’t it? There’s one called healing anger, is there? Are you sure? Healing anger and one called healing emotions, both ways wholeness.
Yeah, transforming problems, yeah. It’s a little heavy for a new it’s fantastic. It’s well, you could try. Yeah, you could try. Yeah, yeah.
Do you have the reference to these in some No, no, I don’t. Actually, there is a book by Wisdom Publications called what is it called? Relaxing Relaxation Something and Concentration. Do you know that one? Relaxation Relaxation, something, and concentration.
Yeah. Relaxation, meditation, and concentration. Something like, by by Levi. It’s in there. Sorry.
I think there’s some plan we try and have one last session tonight, a round off session. After the initiation there’ll be a break. Depends really on how long Lama Lungta gives the initiation for. The plan is there’ll be a break and then there won’t be any meditation or Karen’s meditation, there will just be one more session where I can blab one more time and then finish. I’m not sure exactly when it’ll be, Yeah.
Okay. Yes. No, if it’s not, if you assume it, if you’re not actually angry but you just like look at or pretend to be angry, that’s okay. But sometimes, you know, it is angry as well sometimes. But if you’re just pretending to be, that’s not creating negative karma.
Yeah, I just Just about anger. Imprints of irritants, you know, like an angry person, could you even say that you have an attraction to irritating food? Possibly, possibly. But I mean, if you’re a very angry person maybe there’s some foods that encourages that, but I mean that’s a very minor factor. Yes.
Yeah, I’ll try and talk about that tonight. Yeah. Yes. It’s called Tuksay Rinpoche. This quote is in a book called Journey to Ladakh, page eighty six.
Hidden journey, No, Hidden Journey, Hidden Journey, Hidden Journey, which is A Journey to Ladakh by Andrew Harvey. No questions on anger? Yeah, they take advantage of the Right, right. But I think the point is, I can’t say in an exact situation what to do, but as I was trying to say, the practice of patience is protecting the mind from creating negative harm and harming the other also physically or somehow upsetting the mind of the person protecting your own mind. But, so in doing that, doesn’t mean you can’t do things to stop the person taking advantage of you.
I can’t suggest what that is, but depending on the situation, it doesn’t mean we should let people walk over us and get away with doing negative things. But in trying to stop the harm of people, the idea is to do it without getting angry. I mean, that’s all I can say. It’s up to ourselves what we can do or say, you know, you can point, including, you can tell the person, you know, you were I don’t know, point out some things, but with peaceful mind, you know, a non angry mind. And also just take precautions so that in some way they don’t take advantage.
Groaning? Yeah. Can be, yes. Not necessarily anger but it could be like when one is moaning and groaning and whinging and whining about things. This is irritation, comes from an irritated, annoyed mind.
One of the secondary negative minds. It’s not actually anger but it comes from anger. I don’t exactly know how that happens but it says it does that. There’s many references of that where it burns them Maybe not necessarily destroys all of them but it’s like just as purification reduces the potency of the negative karma, our anger reduces the potency of our good karma so it ripens with hardly any good result at all. But how that actually works, I can’t say.
Is the difference merit and positive karma? So karma is intentional thought or the physical, you know, speech, actions, actions of speech or body that are influenced by that intentional thought. So that is karma. And then that creates an imprint. So that imprint is So if it’s virtuous karma, so it’s a virtuous intentional thought, that creates a virtuous karmic imprint which is called labelled merit.
But roughly speaking we talk about virtuous karma when we need them, the virtuous imprints. But strictly speaking the virtuous karma is the intentional thought that moves our mind, speech or body. Yeah. Yes? The advantages of what?
Yes. Yes, yeah. Can you explain that more? Think so, yes, yes. Yes, it seems to.
Yeah. Well, think something like if you don’t see Yeah. And if you did not label a person as enemy then you would not interpret his or her action as harmful. It’s like if there’s someone that we’re very fond of and then that person becomes mentally disturbed or becomes senile or something like that, and then they start doing strange things, then we don’t get so upset because we have this basic affection for them, we don’t label that person the enemy. Because we also understand why it’s happening, we have some understanding, and we have some basic affection for them in the first place anyway.
So in the same way that we don’t label that person enemy, if we don’t label someone causing harm to us enemy, it doesn’t appear so harmful to us. So is it yes. It’s wise to be patient with every kind of anger. Yes, definitely. This is the message.
This is the message I’m trying to pass on which I have got from Lama Zopa Rinpoche. There is no justification for any anger whatsoever. It doesn’t we can’t justify it. The last thing is is it useful or No, we can’t say that. We can’t say that.
Yeah. As Rinpoche says, even if all the enemies in the world came and attacked us right now, if they dropped all the nuclear bombs on us right now, if all the poisonous snakes in the world bit us right now, the most that can happen is that we can die. That’s all the enemy can do but it’s our anger, our disturbing thoughts, our own thoughts that throw us in the lower realms. I find that quite helpful to remember that one, that one. Because it’s really it’s so helpful to do this analysis of and it shows our ignorance because it looks like the enemy is making me unhappy.
Look what you’ve made me do. Yeah? You made me do this but the enemy didn’t. It’s our own anger that did it. Yeah?
And the enemy an enemy cannot make us angry. This is the interesting thing, it looks like it, it looks like an enemy can make us angry very quickly but the reality is an enemy cannot make us angry. The enemy acts as a condition for ourselves to make ourselves angry. They’re just the condition not the cause. The cause is our own wrong way of thinking and interpreting.
Because usually, like for most of us, our anger arises because someone says something. You know, most of us, I don’t know, get into brawls and things, but it’s very easy to get into verbal arguments. So the enemy says something to us, but these are just noises, they’re just sounds. So how can these sounds make us unhappy? Especially, we can have the experience if someone says the same words to someone else, they don’t hurt us.
If someone says it with the same angry intention to a stranger, those words don’t upset me. Right? And if if someone says those same ugly words with the same ugly motivation to an enemy, our enemy, it makes us happy. But when those same ugly words are said with the ugly intention to me, we’re unhappy. But if those words were truly existing, if they made me unhappy, I shouldn’t be unhappy when they’re said to the stranger and to the enemy.
But it’s the way we interpret those words that in one case causes suffering to me, when it’s to this stranger I’m indifferent, and when it’s to my enemy I can actually be happy by hearing them hurt, insulted. So it’s actually our mind interpreting those words and seeing them and grasping at me and mine that causes the suffering. So the enemy is only a condition, not the cause. If there was no anger in our mind, no potential for anger in our mind, no matter what people said or did, there wouldn’t be any anger. Impossible.
It’s lunchtime. Since there’s not going be that much this afternoon in one way, I mean there’s going be a wonderful initiation but I mean, if you don’t mind, maybe a couple of people have asked about wrong livelihood, what does that mean? So there’s not much said about it but in the section about making correct offerings it talks about the five kinds of wrong livelihood, and this is specifically, I mean generally it’s directed to monks and nuns, ordained people, five ways of getting things that we could then offer. But this can also apply, one can understand them to apply to everyone. So this is, you know, the five kinds of wrong livelihood are obtaining things through flattery, saying, You are such a wonderful, kind, generous person, I can’t think of a nicer, kinder person than you.
You are so helpful and wonderful and good looking and terrific and such a wonderful dharma practitioner. Also, you know, just if you’re trying to sell something to someone and you flatter them, oh this looks so you know, you’re selling them a car or a piece of clothing, oh, you look so terrific in this. You know, they look, you know anyway they actually don’t. Yeah, when they actually don’t, so you flatter them in order to buy it. Then hinting for something, hinting to get something rather than you can directly ask is okay, but to hint for something is wrong livelihood.
Giving something small in order to receive something bigger, you give a small present only with the motivation that this person will give you something bigger. I mean if you give something small with no expectation that’s okay but if your reason for giving is because you’re hoping this person will give you something better then this is wrong livelihood. Also pressurising people to do things which certainly can apply in the workplace, pressurising force, you know, pushing, pushing and for people to do things that they don’t want to do. So if you have some kind of authority over some people and you push them and push them, then this is not really a good thing to do. Then also acting on one’s best behaviour to impress people so that they will give you something, when one is normally not like that.
But suddenly someone it looks like you could get something from someone, so you suddenly act very, very correctly. So then also in a more general way, things that are wrong livelihood are selling alcohol and drugs, selling anything that will cause harm to other people such as weapons, work that involves killing other beings or harming other beings in some way, stealing is wrong livelihood, obtaining money through lying and deceit. We
Key terms in this teaching
- four opponent powers nyenpo tob zhi (Tib)
- The four practices used to purify nonvirtuous imprints on the mindstream. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What is the difference between merit and positive (virtuous) karma?
Karma is the intentional thought, together with the actions of speech or body that are influenced by that intentional thought. This karma creates an imprint. When the intentional thought is virtuous, it creates a virtuous karmic imprint, and that imprint is what is labelled merit. Roughly speaking, people talk about virtuous karma when they actually mean the virtuous imprints. Strictly speaking, though, virtuous karma is the intentional thought that moves our mind, speech or body, while merit is the imprint left by it.