43 min · 4,453 words · 1 December 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a session on generating Bodhicitta by exchanging self with others, using verses from Shantideva’s Bodhicaryavatara and Tonglen practice. The talk then turns to emptiness, presenting the wisdom chapter as central to the Buddha’s teaching and explaining that wisdom and Bodhicitta develop together. It outlines the four Buddhist philosophical tenets, with Madhyamaka as the highest, and distinguishes the selflessness of the person from the non-existence of a self. Audience questions on desire and sexuality are also answered.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-12-01
Duration: 44 min
UUID: 51cce472-baed-498d-9b0e-448489c44e0b
Words: 4,453
Beginning of the day, recall that strongly to mind, to make this time really worthwhile for ourselves and others, and to transform it into a Dharma practice, a Dharma action, a cause for our actual happiness. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, the Supreme Assembly by the merits I create by teaching the Dharma. May I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings? So again, we just spend a little time focusing on the breath to develop some concentration, to apply that to listening to the presentation of the graduated path. Okay.
Thank you. So we’ve been talking a little bit about looking into the ways of generating Bodhicitta according to the six causes and one effect, and the method of Śāntideva, of exchanging self with others, which leads to the practice of first by equalising oneself with others, this leads to the ability to more and more actually exchange oneself in others, with others in thought and practice, in thought and deed, especially through and the strongest way we can train to do this is through the Tonglen meditation, which is done at the level of imagination. But if we do it really strongly with the right motivation and concentration, then it can become a very powerful cause to overcome the self-cherishing thought, to increase our qualities of loving kindness, compassion, and actually generate Bodhicitta. So, before going into the other topics of Bodhicitta section because once one generates Bodhicitta, then the way to enhance that Bodhicitta is through the practice of the six perfections of generosity and morality, patience, perseverance, concentration and wisdom. So this is traditionally the next topic to cover in talking about Bodhicitta.
But I thought before going into those, because there’s so little time left in the course, and I haven’t really talked much about emptiness, I thought I’d like to try and say a few things, maybe just actually repeat the same things I’ve said, if I can try and get away with that, and maybe add one or two new things. Otherwise, if I leave it till the very, very end, it will kind of really we’ll probably leave with countless wrong views. But I thought even before I start that topic, are there any questions about Tonglen, Bodhicitta, anything? I don’t have the book with me now. Yeah.
It starts with verse one forty one and it goes to the very that particular process of meditation verse one hundred and fifty five. Well, actually one hundred and fifty four, and then there’s the conclusion after that. It’s me. Yes. In the process of exchanging self with others.
And you ruined your digestion. Sorry? One hundred forty eight, by every means I’ll advertise my gifts to the world. My gifts is the other because you’re exchanging yourself with other. My gifts is the other.
You make the my the other and the other me. By every means I’ll advertise my gifts to the world ensuring that his qualities remain unknown, ignored by everyone. My faults, I will conceal to simulate for I, not he, will be the object of devotion. No, it’s a good question. I mean, really No, we shouldn’t just accept these things as as being you have we have to understand them.
Like, with the self-cherishing thought, here is another person and we love to find the faults of the other person and we want to tell all the faults of the other person so I will be in doing that, I become more important, right? So, we say, and our own faults we want to conceal, keep hidden so people will like us and praise us and we will get worldly benefits, the eight worldly concerns, right? So, to oppose that, to completely reverse that mind, we say, My faults I will conceal, because that’s what we normally do for ourselves. For me, my faults we conceal, but in this case we say, My faults, I we won’t look in other words, I will not look at the faults of the other person because I will see that other person as me and just as I hide my faults, I’m not going to look at the faults of the other person. No, no, it’s not like that, no.
This is very tricky because we’re not used to it, you see. It’s like being told tomatoes are blue and I’ve spent all my thinking of Right. Right. Exactly. Exactly.
Exactly. Can we go back to verse a hundred and forty eight? Because actually the second one hundred and forty nine follows on. It’s pity that everyone doesn’t have the book but that’s a good reason to buy it, right? It says, By every means I’ll advertise my gifts to the world.
So the self-cherishing thought thinks that about ourselves and that is a negative mind thinking, I should promote myself to the world and praise myself or somehow act so people will praise me. That is the self-cherishing thought, it’s one of the eight worldly concerns, right? So, in a sense, we try to completely reverse that by so when we ever think of ourselves, we have so much energy to praise ourselves. We have tons of energy to praise ourselves, right? So now we say, By every means, I’ll advertise my gifts to the world, which is actually We call the other person me, and as soon as we call the other person me and identify that person as me since I want people to praise me and me is now the other person, I want everyone to praise me which just happens to be the other person.
Yes? No? Just switching pronouns. Yes, but also it’s a very yeah. But it’s not just switching yeah, the words are switching pronouns, yeah.
But one has to be able to follow what that means. And it’s something just yeah. Most people get the idea? Yeah? It’s okay, I’m not trying to that’s okay.
No, no, no, it’s fine. No, really, didn’t mean to No, it’s fine, no, really. It takes time. Sometimes some people get it, some people don’t, and when you get it, you get it, which is great. Maybe just try to think it over, think it through a bit more.
Yes? It doesn’t matter. We don’t have to worry about that because we have we all have the wrong view, generally speaking here, probably, most of us here. Yeah. But even if it was the correct view, to completely overcome the subtle self-cherishing thought that wants to achieve liberation for me.
Yeah. But in that case, one would be generating virtuous thoughts, not negative ones. But still, instead of saying, I need liberation and it doesn’t matter about other, it’s not so important, I love other, I care for them, I want them to be happy and to be free of suffering, but I am not prepared to do all the effort to help liberate them because I need to be liberated. So then you reverse that, I need liberation, the other can wait. Yeah, yeah, yes.
But in this case, Śāntideva is presenting it more from the gross self-cherishing point of view as I understand it, which is our ordinary mind that probably most of us have here. Yeah. Is the whole book like that? No, no, no. This is This is some chapter some stanzas of that chapter which is a very specific it’s the specific one specific way of training the mind to exchange self with others.
This is why I this is why it’s so much easier to do Tonglen. But this is a more profound because basically, if one studies the Bodhisattvacharyavatara, this book, this is the one. What am I trying to say? Then Śāntideva is just as Asaṇga received his method of generating Bodhicitta from Maitreya Buddha, it is believed that Śāntideva received the teaching of exchanging self from others from Mañjuśrī. So, the special quality of this book, of all chapters in it, it is particularly presented from the wisdom point of view.
Even though it’s about generating Bodhicitta, the conventional mind of seeking enlightenment, the conventional bodhicitta, it is presenting it all, all of the arguments, maybe not all of them, but every chapter has this flavor of wisdom about it, that’s presented from that point of view. And the next chapter on wisdom is considered one of the greatest presentations of the topic Buddhist literature. It’s it’s so great that it’s almost impossible to understand. From our from our level. Yeah?
Yeah? And this is also why this is also just a point to make that in studying the Dharma, it is really important, this is something that is emphasised a great deal in the Tibetan tradition, to really understand the text, one needs the oral commentary, valid oral commentary from someone in the lineage who has themselves received the valid oral commentary and so on. Because much of the chapters in here are if one’s got some basic Buddhist understanding, makes sense, but certain chapters, stanzas like that, you read them, you can’t make head nor tail of them because you need someone to explain the purpose of them. And certainly the wisdom chapter definitely needs an oral commentary, but much of it is once once had some lum rim teachings, is very helpful. And by the the more you read it, the more you want to receive the commentary on it.
Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. So maybe in that case, it’s okay.
But in the Tibetan tradition, one is educated to have the tantric view of the teacher from the start, so in that case it’s not so good to do that, not correct. Yes? Yeah. Well, is the ordinary view that sexual drive is some biological instinct to preserve the species and is totally embedded in all the genes and everything and is impossible to overcome. But sexual desire is not a biological well, from a Buddhist point of view, it is not something physical, it is mind, it is a thought.
Sexual desire is a thought. It is consciousness arising from perceiving particular object and so on, which we’ve seen many times in previous lives and we have developed attachments to it. So we desire it. It is a state of mind. Of course, it operates through the body, it affects the body, but this is what karma is about.
Our particular karmic tendencies manifest through having a particular body, and certain bodies can maybe because of their physical structure and whatever, act to generate more desire than other bodies from within us, not towards others. Of course, the more attractive the body, we tend to generate more desire, but even our own body structure in some ways may how can you say? Causes in some cases more desire to arise in the mind. But it is consciousness. But it can be modified.
This is the whole purpose. Yeah, well there’s various ways. In the ordinary Sūtra way, there is applying the antidote to it in order to subdue it, then in Tantra there is ways of transforming it and to use that energy. But this is something we just have to work with step by step in either way, neither of them is particularly easy. It’s not like the tantric method of transforming desire is somehow easy to do at our level.
It’s something that takes time and knowledge and experience to be able to do, and it has to be based on having tried to subdue one’s desire to some extent. I mean, this is something that people like to misinterpret about how you practice tantra, that you just jump into it and you just use desire, or that one has to have been able to subdue it to some extent before one can even transform it. Basically, one way of doing that, apart from the directly opposing method, because in all the aspects of practising dharma, there is the aspect of applying the powerful antidote to a delusion, whatever, and then there is the other aspect of doing how can we say having the opposite positive state of mind, that if we get into that more and more, then the negative state of mind or the less beneficial state of mind doesn’t arise so much. So if in our life we develop satisfaction through other means, through for example practicing Dharma, then our sexual desire doesn’t arise so much. And it’s not a matter of forcing anything or whatever, it’s just one is finding satisfaction in another way, and then one’s desire doesn’t arise so strongly, generally speaking.
People who, just in their life, get incredibly involved in any particular thing, it can be anything, can be so totally involved in that that the sexual desire is not very strong, present at that time. Even like athletes who want to win the Olympic games, they know if they want to win the gold medal, they can’t have sex around that time. So there’s some motivation not to follow that because the mind is focused on obtaining something else. So it can be something very, very worldly or it can be some spiritual goal. Sometimes even if you’re engrossed in a book and your friend comes up and says, you know, something, said, Oh, this book’s much more interesting at the moment.
Because one is gaining some satisfaction from reading the book, especially if it’s close-up. Possible. So it’s not a matter of necessarily suppressing it and all this, you know, like that, but finding satisfaction in other things, and especially in virtuous things. That is you know, a very valuable way of of working with sexual desire. Okay.
One more. Yeah. The I and U thing. Yeah. Do they also actually they use to teach the the I and U are just labels?
Yeah. Why and then the perception and the label actually different? Yes, but that’s also another more advanced practice to do. Here, Śāntideva was presenting something just from a very ordinary perspective that we can do if we catch what it’s trying to do. It doesn’t involve understanding emptiness or anything complicated like that.
But certainly that is also something to meditate on and understand for sure. Okay. As Śāntideva says, in the wisdom chapter, at the very beginning of the wisdom chapter of the Guide to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life. So, the other chapters, the other eight chapters are all about developing loving kindness, patience, compassion and so on, based on renunciation. In other words, it is a summary of all the topics we’ve covered so far in the graduated path.
And then Śāntideva says, All these branches of the teaching, the powerful Lord, meaning the Buddha, expounded for the sake of wisdom. Therefore, they must generate this wisdom who wish to have an end of suffering. In other words, everything that the Buddha taught is for the purpose of generating wisdom, the wisdom consciousness that realizes the way phenomena exist, the way I exist. And therefore, they, that is the bodhisattvas or us, we who want to generate this wisdom I’m sorry, put it this way, then everyone who wishes to have an end of suffering has to generate this wisdom. So this is the ultimate point, that the heart of the Buddha’s teaching is developing this wisdom consciousness.
As I’ve said before, we develop it with the motivation to achieve our own liberation, or in the case of following the path to enlightenment, we generate that wisdom for the sake of all sentient beings. And of course, the more we have this understanding and experience of the way oneself actually does exist, the more we have that experience, the self-cherishing thought will naturally be less, the delusions will naturally arise less often, less strongly, and therefore becomes easier to generate Bodhicitta and to practice it. So these two things do have to go together hand in hand to some extent. The more we want to be able to really generate Bodhicitta and engage in all the practices of it, it all goes easier if we have some understanding, at least some correct intellectual understanding, and hopefully some insight into the way oneself and all phenomena exist. Because again, these two things interact because we create the wrong view of self, we create the mind controlled by that wrong view of self, creates the wrong view of all external phenomena.
And because our mind perceives this false grasps at this false appearance of phenomena is true, that reinforces the wrong view of self. So these two things feed off each other continuously. So in the teachings, says that the selflessness or the emptiness of phenomena is discussed first, and then the selflessness of persons. But in actual practice, one first cultivates an understanding of the selflessness or emptiness of the person, then we try to understand the selflessness of phenomena. And the fifth Dalai Lama said that a view of selflessness cannot be generated in the continuum of a person who does not believe in cause and effect.
So I tried to make this point quite a few times during the course, and here is the actual quote from Nāgārjuna I finally found it: So long as the doctrine that destroys the misconception of an ‘I’ is not known, take care Oh, it’s a slightly different one. It’s not the exact one, it’s a different one. Anyway, Nāgārjuna says, So long as the doctrine that destroys the misconception of an I is not known, take care to practice giving, ethics and patience. So in there is ethics, which is the law of cause and effect. So this is a huge topic and I’m really not at all qualified to talk about it, but I’ve asked Lama Lhundrup several times to please teach something on emptiness and he just kind of laughs.
He says he doesn’t know anything about it. So I’m stuck with it at the moment. I don’t know really where to start, but in the way Tibetan Buddhist traditions talk about emptiness or present it, there are four school maybe this gets in Tibet, they developed four traditions of Buddhism. The very oldest is the Nyingma, then came the Sakya tradition, then the Kagyu tradition, and the last is the Gelug tradition. So there are four schools of Tibetan Buddhism, or four traditions or lineages, whatever you like to call them.
So, this is not to be confused with the fact that within Tibetan Buddhism or within Mahāyāna Buddhism in general, There are four philosophical schools, that is four philosophical views of how presenting the correct view of what exists. There are four different philosophical schools with four quite different views of what is actually existing, how the person actually exists, how phenomena actually exist. So, these are all believed to all the four schools of Tibetan Buddhism believe, all these four philosophical schools or tenets are taught by the Buddha to suit the minds of particular people at particular times. And they were taught because they were taught by the Buddha, they are all how do you say and the highest of these schools is called the Mādhyamika school, which I mentioned before has two divisions, and the highest division, the main division, the top division, is the consequential school of the Mādhyamika. So this is, Lama Tsongkhapa argues, is the actual view that the Buddha possesses.
It is the view that we have to intellectually understand in order to directly realise emptiness. So all the other views come from the Buddha, but they are not the actual correct view of how things exist. But, because they come from the Buddha and were taught from this incredible omniscient mind, even though one holds, for example, the lowest view, which is actually the furthest away from the truth, it itself is not harmful because by understanding it, one will be able to eventually gain the highest view, and it actually becomes a stepping stone towards attaining the highest view. So of course, when we hear that there are these four schools and everything, of course, if we were interested in studying this, we would think that it would be best to go for studying the highest school first, get to the right view first, which seems logical. And I would like to try, if I can, to talk a little bit about emptiness from that view, but the more I’ve tried to understand that view, the more I’ve heard received teachings on that view from various great Lamas, including His Holiness, the Dalai Lama and Lama Zopa Rinpoche.
The more one tries to understand it, the more one realises what the Lamas say from the very beginning, which one ignores when you first hear the lamas say that, is that it is necessary to study the lowest school first, to get a correct view of the lowest school first, then of the next school, then the next school, and then one is able to understand how subtle the actual view is. Because if we just try to understand it without any background in the other teachings, the other philosophical views, one doesn’t really one may think one has understood it, but one really hasn’t understood how subtle it is. And in universities in the West and in Japan and various places, academics present claim to present Nāgārjuna’s view of emptiness, but it is wrong. It’s just an academic view by reading the books, and it’s still to the present Even from the very time that Nāgārjuna expounded the teachings of emptiness on this world, people misunderstood it and believed that Nāgārjuna was saying that nothing exists at all, that this is the Mādhyamika view, that nothing exists. And in universities today, there are academic professors proclaiming that this is what Nāgārjuna said, and that what Buddhists believe, that there is no self at all.
This is complete, complete wrong view. It is not the view of the Buddha, of Nāgārjuna, of Lama Tsongkhapa, of his holiness, the Dalai Lama. It is not the view of self, not the right view. Some people here have been studying these teachings, some may have not heard of them at all, But if you get interested in these teachings, then there’s terms that are often used are the term selflessness or self and selflessness, there’s self person and the I. So most texts say I don’t know what the equivalents in other languages are, but the terms self, person, and I are synonymous.
But I myself, personally, am not sure that this is true. So this is my arrogance, and I may be completely wrong. Because what we are trying to discover is the selflessness of the person. So the person does exist, but a self of person does not exist, because the self the term self, as it’s used in the Buddhadharma, is implying just one gross way of understanding it, it is implying that there is some essential entity existing there that one can find. If you look, there’s some essential quality, a self, a self of something, an essence within everything that you can find which is really there, which is somehow permanent, existing from its own side.
So the person doesn’t exist, but a self doesn’t. Oh, the person exists. Oh, did I say the opposite? So the person exists. There’s a validly existing person, but one can say the self doesn’t exist.
But that gets tricky because sometimes the term is used synonymously with person. But if self and person were synonymous words, you’d have to talk about the personlessness of the person. Selflessness of the self somehow makes sense, but personlessness of the person doesn’t make sense. That’s why I think that one should make a slight difference in the meaning and use person to refer to the I that validly exists, and to use the term self to apply to the I that appears to our mind right now, but which does not exist at all other than being hallucination. And also, they talk about the selflessness of phenomena.
So self and person were synonymous meanings, you’d have to talk about the personlessness of phenomena, then it starts to be meaningless, I think. So when we talk about the selflessness of the person and the selflessness of phenomena, it is talking about that there is this absence of a self, an essential findable quality that exists from its own side, which we are perceiving now, that our ignorance is creating this essential self quality to everything. That something is essentially beautiful from its own side, something else is essentially ugly from its own side. So according to Buddhist philosophy, especially Mādhyamika philosophy, if something really does exist, we can find it. If we investigate, we can find it.
We may have to investigate carefully, but if something is actually existing from its own side, we can find it. If we can’t find it, it doesn’t exist. And for something to exist really to really exist, the way it appears and the way it exists should be concordant, the same, in harmony. The way it if something is real, valid, true, factual, the way it appears should be the way it exists. So if there’s some discordance between the way something appears and the way it actually is existing, then there’s something wrong, there’s something false.
For example, this object here has the appearance of being a flower, of being flowers. But if you check, they are not flowers. There is a discordance between the appearance and what is actually existing. So these are not real. You can’t find a real flower there, even though at first there seems to be that appearance of a real flower.
Whereas something that is validly existing, the appearance and how it exists is completely in accordance. There’s no discordance between the way it appears and the way it’s existing. If there is some discordance, it’s not true. For example, the mirage of water, the appearance of water in the desert. There is the appearance there, but when one investigates that appearance, there is no water there at all, there’s nothing liquid and wet there at all.
So there’s a complete discordance between the appearance and what is existing. So we say it’s not real, even though it appears to be like that. So, in our case now, there’s very ordinary people who don’t check, don’t investigate what appears to our mind. There are many, many appearances. There’s the appearance of me, the appearance of the person.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- graduated path lamrim (Tib)
- A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Nyingma
- The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.