Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 10 Tape 13 Side 1 Four Noble Truths

44 min · 4,580 words · 10 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 10 Tape 13 Side 1 Four Noble Truths
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains the First Noble Truth, that ordinary existence is unsatisfying and imperfect, and traces suffering to karma, disturbing thoughts and a root ignorance that grasps at a false, truly existing self. It then begins the Third Noble Truth, that suffering can cease, using analogies of dust on a mirror, waves and clouds, and argues that delusions depend on causes and so can be removed. The recording ends mid-explanation of how ignorance is undermined by doubt and reduced desire.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-10

Duration: 45 min

UUID: ee5dcdf9-ed89-48b0-8bb8-4b28cc28670c

Words: 4,580

Want it to go? Down. It can’t go further up because that’s more happiness. It can only go down. It can’t remain the same because if the happiness stops, it can’t keep going.

It can only go down. So this is really unsatisfying. It’s unfulfilling, disappointing, and there is a sense of emptiness in our heart, in our mind. So this is the very nature of ordinary existence. Buddhism does not deny that there are all sorts of pleasures within saṃsāra.

All sorts. Many, many. And we are very clever at generating as many of these as we possibly can. This world is geared to doing that, of trying to generate new ones. Because Why?

Because the old ones aren’t as good as what we thought. They’re not quite as fulfilling as what we thought they would be. That’s why we continuously have to generate new ones, new computers, faster ones, because if it’s faster, it’ll be more satisfying. It’ll be really satisfying. But then you discover it’s not.

It has flaws. Problems, faults. This is the very nature of saṃsāra. There’s always something wrong with it. It is imperfect and therefore frustrating and unsatisfying.

There is nothing perfect in this world. Nothing, no matter how much effort is put into generating perfect things, the perfect environment, the perfect product, the perfect marriage, the perfect building, the perfect education, the perfect school, the perfect family there is no such thing. The perfect society, the perfect medicine, the perfect car, a perfectly safe environment. September eleventh shouldn’t have happened, right? We have to blame all these people who didn’t check at the airport because the airport should be perfectly safe.

We’ll do these things to make airports perfectly safe. Impossible. It’s impossible. Just recently when I was in Australia, a little child drowned in a fish pond it showed on television the family totally distraught because of course their beloved little baby had drowned in a fish pond, their own fish pond in their backyard. So then the idea was that every fish pond in Australia should have a fence around it so that no baby will ever drown in a fish pond.

But it’s impossible to make life perfect so that nothing bad happens to anyone, anytime. Even if we stay in our room and don’t move, something will happen sooner or later to us. Samsāra is imperfect, it is suffering, it is unsatisfying. Every possible thing that has been invented in this world to make the world better, it may have brought some benefit that virtually everything that has ever been invented and introduced into the world has had an unexpected, unwanted, bad side effect. Everything, including the wheel.

You get run over by wheels. They’re terrific things to have but you also get run over by them and so on. It’s not perfect. One may think, well this is a really sick way of thinking, you know. But the point is, it’s true.

If you look, if we look, this world is imperfect and it cannot be made perfect with the methods we use. It is unsatisfying and to deny that, to deny what is real is suffering. We cannot be happy, genuinely happy, by denying reality. It may look like definitely this is what worldly life is about denying reality. You take all these drugs and a new little temporary reality arises that looks much better than the one before the drugs but it doesn’t work for long.

Worldly life is denying reality and it just doesn’t work. It is unsatisfying. The Buddha taught the only way out suffering is to face reality, every kind of reality. Investigate it, accept it and work with it in a wise way. So, every time This idea that existence is suffering, that life is suffering is presented.

There are always people who will deny it. I’m not suffering. I’m fine, thank you very much. I’m perfect. Some of you may be feeling like that.

I’m fine, I’m terrific, I don’t need this message. I’m just great, everything is just hunky dory, perfect, fine. Well, this may be true, to a point, but as I’ve tried to point out before, this perfectly fine state, it will become a memory because it’s arising. We may not know it, but it’s arising. Generally, we can talk about there is negative karma, positive karma, is also neutral karma, And there’s also another kind of karma which is called No, no, no.

No. Yeah, there is, but it’s not the one I’m thinking of. Yes. No, that’s true, but not the one I What’s it called? Yes, something like that.

Come on old students. Immutable karma. Yes, it has another word to it. Immutable karma. So this is the karma that is created when one generates, as I said, samadhi with a worldly motivation.

That when one dies, then the karma having generated that level of samadhi with a worldly motivation throws one into the form or formless realm. So it is a karma, a very particular kind of karma. Unchanging karma is another, yeah, immutable or unchanging karma because it is definite that having generated that state of concentration with ordinary motivation, it will throw one into these form or formless realms. We’ll have the questions at the end, if that’s okay. Please don’t forget.

So, the first noble truth, the first truth of the noble beings is that ordinary existence is unsatisfying, frustrating, and sooner or later it does lead to obvious pain, physical or mental suffering. So the Buddha discovered that this situation has a cause. It isn’t arising for no reason whatsoever. The Buddha, we believe, discovered that the cause of suffering is not because of some creator. The cause of suffering, all suffering, there are causes of suffering that we can discover.

So the first level of cause, the most immediate cause of all suffering is the ripening of negative karma. It’s because of these negative karmic imprints in the mind. So they ripen if they haven’t been purified or destroyed, they ripen as suffering, all the different kinds of suffering. But why do these karmic imprints exist? They exist only because of the disturbing thoughts.

So a more deeper reason for suffering, cause of suffering, are the disturbing thoughts, particularly the poisonous minds of desire attachment and anger. But because of those poisonous minds there are countless other disturbing thoughts of pride, jealousy, fear, anxiety, doubts and so on, and countless versions of all of those disturbing thoughts. But also these disturbing thoughts have a cause. And the root cause of these disturbing thoughts is ignorance. This consciousness, this mind which is clear and knowing, but it knows in a false way.

It creates this false appearance of who we are, a distorted appearance. We as people exist, But on the basis of that person that does exist, ignorance generates a false appearance, a distorted appearance of who we are, how we exist. And that same ignorance grasps that that appearance is real, unquestionably, totally, totally real. It’s because of that ignorance that has always obscured the mind that there is suffering. The Buddhist teachings argue that all suffering of every possible kind mental suffering, or every kind of mental suffering, dissatisfaction, every kind of physical suffering owes its origin.

All social suffering, economic suffering, political problems, problems of the weather, of the environment, of the soil. Absolutely every problem originates with ignorance. This is what the Buddha taught: that there is actually only one root cause of every kind of suffering and dissatisfaction. And that is this ignorance that creates the wrong appearance of self, the wrong appearance, a false distorted appearance of all phenomena. And one aspect of that ignorance, as I try to indicate just very briefly, is that this ignorance creates the illusion that this world is completely separate and in dependence upon us.

So this ignorance, there are many levels of it because, as I mentioned, one level of that ignorance causes us to believe sometimes that I am the body. Sometimes we grasp that I am the mind. Sometimes we grasp that we are somehow both of them in some way. So this is not the root ignorance. This is just some momentary flashes of it.

There is a more subtle level of ignorance which is grasping at this truly existent, inherently existing self, if it exist, would be an independent phenomenon, a totally isolated, independent phenomenon. Such a person does not exist. It cannot exist. But this ignorance that generates this view is something extremely subtle and it is not a conscious thought, a gross conscious thought. It is existing in a very subtle way and it’s arising moment by moment in our consciousness.

It has always been there. The Buddha taught even in the womb, in the fetus, because a fetus has consciousness from the very moment fertilization occurs, a particular sperm joins with a particular ovum and grows is because there is consciousness there. Consciousness has joined those physical substances. And then from that subtle consciousness, from the very subtle consciousness in the foetus, the subtle consciousness arises, and then the gross consciousness arises in foetus. It’s there.

And that consciousness is even then in the fetus, moment by moment, this incredibly fine, subtle grasping at true existence. And that has existed during beginningless time. What is its cause? A previous moment of the same ignorance going back and back and back. So I’m just going to indicate that now.

Maybe I’ll try and explain some of that later on. Hopefully, Lama Lundrup might try to explain it, and hopefully Lama Zopa Rinpoche comes, he will talk about emptiness because it is his favorite topic. Rinpoche doesn’t always talk about it, Rinpoche does talk about it a lot. Rinpoche’s explanations of emptiness are truly amazing. So this, the Buddha taught, is the source of our suffering.

There is this wrong view of self because of that. We have this dualistic view of self and others. Because of that we classify everything according to this perception of self, this wrong view of self. Therefore, everything uncontrollably appears to our mind as good or bad, friend or enemy, beautiful or ugly, and therefore because of it, and they appear to be truly like that. This is an interesting word, truly like that.

It’s a fact. It’s an unmistaken objective fact that this is good and this is bad, this is beautiful, this is ugly. It’s a total we believe. It’s a total objective fact. That’s why we desire what is objectively, truly, factually beautiful.

But it’s not. It’s not an objective reality. It appears to be an objective reality, but it is totally subjective. Or at least ninety nine percent a subjective reality. But that doesn’t appear to our mind.

What appears is a true phenomenon. Just the facts, man, just the facts. And because it’s really like that, desire for what is truly beautiful arises, and once that happens we’re stuck with attachment. And then there’s this really bad stuff. All this is really good, all this is really bad.

It’s really bad. Aversion arises to it. So all these disturbances occur. And desire and ignorance creates this false appearance, then desire and aversion, anger, add more layers of confusion and distortion to it. Then all these other disturbing thoughts of pride and jealousy and anxiety and fears and doubts and worries, this and that come in and add extra layers on top of everything.

And as I said, we argue because my reality is reality, your reality is wrong. So endless conflicts and confusion. And we generate a suffering environment because the environment is not a truly existing phenomenon. It’s not an objective. The environment is not an objective, factual phenomenon separate from our mind.

It appears that way, but the Buddha discovered that it’s not. It’s a subjective phenomena arising in dependence on our mind. So this may be difficult to believe, but from a Buddhist point of view, the fact that our environment becomes polluted is because of our polluted minds. Of course, the pollution comes from chemicals and car exhausts, and this and that. But why does all these things exist?

It’s because particularly of desire attachment. Our world is dominated more and more by desire attachment. So we get an environment Sorry, our minds, the minds of said human beings now are dominated more and more by desire attachment. So we create an environment that is polluted by desire attachment. The effects of desire attachment.

You actually create a physical environment that is a reflection of our mind. One puts all these imprints in the mind of stealing, of grasping and taking from others. One is creating an environment in one’s mind where there is nothing to experience, nothing good. You’ve taken good from others, and we create in our mind a desert. We get born in a place where there’s poor soil and no nourishment, and everything gets stolen.

This is what the Buddha taught. If we can really begin to see, which is not easy of course, but this is what the Buddhist path is about, is developing a clearer and clearer mind. Because it’s not just a matter of intellectually understanding, it’s not an intellectual process. Totally, it does require our intelligence, but our intelligence that is purified of all these heavy obscurations in our mind, when they start to go, our mind has the ability to see that this world is not something separate and independent. It is arising depending on our mind.

When we purify our mind, the appearance of the world changes. Our world changes. The appearance of our world changes. The things we experience in our world change. So anyway, the point to make at the moment is that from the Buddha’s perception, from the perception of the Buddhas, there is only one root cause of all suffering, and that is this wrong view that we have, this wrong consciousness of ignorance or self grasping.

Because of that, delusions or afflictions arise, all the poisons of the mind arise. These act as the basis for negative karma, and it is negative karma which is the direct immediate cause for suffering to arise. The ripening of negative karma is the direct cause for all these suffering appearances to arise. And I’d really like to ask people to consider expression I use, the appearances of this life I didn’t think of myself. It’s really an interesting expression, the appearances of this life.

Because we tend to think that this world is not just an appearance, but it’s solid stuff. But maybe all it is are just appearances. There is the appearance of shapes and colors. It appears to the eye consciousness. Beauty appears to the eye consciousness.

Sounds appear to the ear consciousness. Smells appear to the nose consciousness. Tastes appear. They just appear. They’re just an appearance.

Nothing solid, maybe just an appearance to the tongue consciousness. And then there’s all these nice sensations that appear to the body consciousness. We really like those in particular. They’re some of our favorites. Very strong ones, those ones.

But maybe they’re just this insubstantial little blip appearance, just like dots on a TV screen. All these little dots on the TV screen create these images. But it’s not really solid at all. Just these funny little dots, and our mind sees them as these these apparent shapes and colors and people and things. It’s a very interesting expression, the appearances of this life.

And it helps to understand it, I think, as I was trying to show indicate yesterday, is the time of death, that this world will continue to exist when we die, but there’s no way it can appear to our mind. No way. Even though it’s really there, even if it is really, really, really, really there, it can’t appear. It simply cannot appear to our mind. Which shows that when it is there, it’s just an appearance.

Even when it’s really, really there, it’s only really, really there as an appearance. Not as solid and heavy and graspable as we think. It’s as Lama Lundrup said last night, It is not an illusion, it is like an illusion. If was just an illusion, we don’t have to worry about it at all. Illusions, don’t have to worry about.

It’s not an illusion, it’s like an illusion. I don’t know what that means, but it’s like an illusion. So all of the Buddhadharma is about enabling our mind to become calm, clear and concentrated so we can see, so we can perceive, not conceive, but directly perceive how we generate all these false appearances which we believe are real. We start to see the mistakes, and then they can disappear from the mind, and then our mind can directly perceive what is actually there. And what is actually there is just like an illusion, totally dependent on our mind, arising moment by moment, changing moment by moment, depending on causes and conditions.

Not existing independently, but totally everything arising through causes and conditions. Who we are ourselves, the me, the I that does exist, is not some fixed thing because the I that does exist, that exists like an illusion, this illusory like person that we are, is changing moment by moment. There isn’t this fixed me that we can grasp at because who I am is not an independent phenomena, but a dependent phenomena, depending on many things, particularly this body and this mind. And the body is changing moment by moment. The mind is changing moment by moment because of causes and conditions.

And so the person I am is something arising, depending moment by moment on a changing body and a changing mind. But that person, we don’t see, we don’t believe in. That person is existing, this shimmering, momentary, insubstantial, illusory like self, totally depending on many, many changing phenomena. On top of that very insubstantial thing, on the basis of that very momentary, insubstantial, illusory like phenomena, ignorance creates the appearance that this person is really there independently, separately, by itself, depending on nothing, just really there, and we grasp that as completely true, unquestionably true, and then all suffering starts. Again, and again, and again.

So we’ve been doing this since beginningless time. Rapidly moving along because the second noble truth is a very tricky one, difficult to talk about. The third truth of noble beings is that definitely all suffering, absolutely every suffering, be brought to complete cessation. Not just temporarily, not some of it, but all of it. And all suffering within our mind can be ceased forever, in a way that it is utterly, utterly impossible for it to re enter or affect the mind, even for a moment, in any way whatsoever.

So, how is this possible? If if ignorance has always been there, suffering has always been there during beginningless time, how is it possible to stop this ignorance and suffering? How is it possible for this cessation to occur? Very briefly, it is possible because although ignorance is existing in the mind, delusions are existing in the mind, karma is existing in the mind, they are not an integral part of the very fundamental clear light primordial mind, the most subtle level of mind that arises moment by moment, life after life. They are there, but they are not an integral part of the mind.

Just like there are the analogies that we hear again and again once one becomes familiar with the Buddhadharma, that the delusions in the mind are like dust on a mirror. While the dust is on the mirror, the mirror can’t function properly. The mirror has the potential to reflect everything exactly as it is. But the dust covers that, and the mirror is not able to reflect properly. But the dust can be removed.

When the dust is removed, the mirror reflects exactly what is there, performs its function. It’s never performed its function before, but the dust never destroys the nature of the mirror. It never affects the nature of the mirror. Prevents its functioning but it never actually, even slightly affects the potential and nature of the mirror. So our disturbing thoughts do that.

They’re not an essential part of the mind, and they never harm the nature of the mind. And just like dust, they can be removed. Or another analogy is like the waves of the ocean. There can be these incredible waves of the ocean, but in the depths of the ocean, the mind is completely still, completely unaffected. So the waves are just something temporary, superficial, changing moment by moment.

Or like our delusions are like clouds in the sky, passing by moment by moment, and they never affect the actual nature of the sky. The sky is always there, blue, but then these black clouds come by, white clouds come by, temporarily obscured, but they don’t change the nature of the mind. And one can begin to see how the delusions can be removed from the mind if we engage in the basic practice, meditation practice, of looking at our thoughts, of training the mind to do this meditation where one calms the mind and then tries to objectively, you know, figuratively speaking, step back and watch objectively as possible the thoughts arising. So they arise, they abide, and then they fade away. They don’t last.

They can’t last. They’re not permanent. They just arise temporally in the mind. If we feed them, which we usually do because of our lack of awareness through our habit, through the force of familiarity, when we feed our thoughts by paying attention to them, then they arise more strongly and they last longer and they completely pollute our mind, change our perceptions and so on. And they become for us, they become me.

Yeah? Our attachment. When attachment arises in the mind, there’s not like a me and attachment, But I become this attached person. I become this person desiring, desiring something. That me that is desiring something is a different me that wasn’t desiring the object before.

It’s a different me, a different person, not totally different, but still different. The person that we are, as I tried to say, the being that we actually are is arising, dependent on the state of our body and the state of our mind. If desire is arising in the mind, I can’t be someone unaffected by desire. I can’t be a desireless person if desire is in my mind, because who I am is totally dependent on my mind and what is happening in my mind. Okay.

Yeah, yeah, thanks. But anyway, just going back, by training the mind to see how thoughts arise, we can begin to understand that our thoughts are not so solid and substantial as we believe. They exist temporarily and they fade away. And especially what we can begin to discover is whatever thought it is, good or bad, it arises in the first place depending on causes and conditions. Depending on causes and conditions.

And it is because of that very fact that our thoughts, our delusions arise depending on causes and conditions, and they only exist by depending on causes and conditions. It is for that very reason that our delusions can be eliminated. If our delusions did not exist depending on other factors, our delusions would be permanent and they could never be removed from the mind. But because and one can see our delusions are not there all the time. We are not permanently angry, We are not permanently controlled by desire, pride, jealousy, fear, worry.

These things do arise from time to time in the mind and fade away. They are impermanent. They are impermanent because they depend. They can only exist depending on causes and conditions. And because of that, the causes and conditions can be removed.

Firstly, they can be modified and they can be removed. When they are removed, the delusion cannot exist. When the causes and conditions are removed, what depends on those causes and conditions can simply not exist. The delusions don’t go anywhere. There’s nowhere for them to go.

They don’t go into somebody else’s mind. They don’t go into space. They just simply can’t exist. And once those causes and conditions are completely eradicated, the delusion can never come back. It becomes totally nonexistent, and there is no way for it to arise again.

And especially if we take the case of ignorance ignorance which is the principal cause of all the other delusions ignorance itself is not an independent phenomena. If it was an independent phenomena truly existing from its own side as an objective, factual phenomena, it would be permanent and it could never be removed from the mind, and therefore all the delusions would always exist in the mind, and suffering would always exist. But ignorance itself only exists depending on causes and conditions. Ignorance itself depends on a previous moment of existence. If we can cut ignorance in one moment, in the next moment it can’t arise.

And the ignorance that is existing in any particular moment is not existing independently, it is existing dependently. It is it is depending firstly, one major reason ignorance is able to exist in any particular moment is because we don’t allow ourselves to be aware of it. We’re totally unaware that we have ignorance. So ignorance breeds in ignorance. Through the lack of awareness of it, it is able to exist.

Ignorance exists moment by moment. Ignorance creates a particular illusion and grasps that it’s real. If for one moment we do not grasp at the reality of that illusion but question it, we raise a genuine doubt in the mind that what is appearing to us may not be reality. In the teachings it says that one moment of doubt shakes all of saṃsāra. All of saṃsāra starts shaking.

I don’t think I can. Ignorance depends. Ignorance is creating an illusion and grasping that illusion is real. But in the very moment, but in that moment, while that illusion is there, if we can generate, and we can, a doubt for one moment that that reality, that that appearance is true. We can doubt it for a moment, have a genuine doubt that begins to undermine that ignorance.

All of Samsāra shakes. If things truly existed, nothing could change. If things truly existed as independent phenomena, nothing could change. But because things do not truly exist the way they appear, but only exist dependently, All sorts of things are possible. Ignorance exists depending on a previous moment of existence, and it is also perpetuated it gives rise to all the delusions and negative karma.

These delusions and negative karma in turn act as a support for the next moment of ignorance to arise. Ignorance creates is the basis of desire, so we follow desire believing this thing is truly beautiful. So by following desire, we perpetuate the belief that of true existence, and that acts as a basis for ignorance that generates the appearance of true existence to arise again. Because the appearance of true existence arises again, desire grasps at it again. This is why if we reduce our desire attachment, we are undermining the causes of ignorance.

Key terms in this teaching

Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
dualistic view
The ignorant view characteristic of the unenlightened mind in which all things are falsely conceived to have concrete self-existence. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top