36 min · 3,417 words · 30 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains self-cherishing as the root of suffering, showing that it is more than selfishness and harms us in this life and in future lives through attachment, anger, laziness and fear. It contrasts this with cherishing others, which brings peace and benefit to oneself and others.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-30
Duration: 36 min
UUID: 7cca6f4b-e2e1-4486-952a-89fb23ddfd0f
Words: 3,417
And as soon as we have the appearance of the truly existing me, there is the appearance of truly existing other. And each truly existing other phenomena appears to be either truly existingly beautiful from its own side or truly existingly bad, ugly from its own side. It can’t be any other way. The beauty is really there, the ugliness is really there. I’m really here like this, this is really beautiful, this is really bad, therefore I desire this, therefore I hate that.
And that’s how we cherish ourselves. That’s what this cherishing is referring to, which is not cherishing at all. And, you know, by following the afflicted desire, attachment and anger, it is disturbing the mind, it is actually disturbing the mind. And creating the causes for future disturbance of our mind later on in this life, in future lives. So the person I am actually that actually exists as what is merely labeled in dependence on the mind is unhappy because the mind is being disturbed by desire and anger in an attempt to make a me that doesn’t exist happy.
Is this making sense in any way? Yes. No. We actually make ourselves miserable by trying to make something which doesn’t exist happy. This is a very strange situation to be trapped in and we’re all trapped in it, but we don’t have to be.
Because as soon as we start to understand the disadvantages, the falseness of the self-cherishing thought, because instinctively we wish happiness, As I was trying to say this morning, we and don’t want suffering, as soon as we start to recognize something as suffering there is some tendency to let go. Right? So just knowing, even intellectually having some idea of the falseness of the self-cherishing thought is incredibly helpful. But of course it’s not enough to eliminate it because the self-cherishing thought is a habit from beginningless time. It’s an instinct, it’s a primordial instinct. It’s a reptilian instinct that we have.
So, you know, we can be aware of it for a little while and not follow it but it comes back because the imprint is there to come back and back. But by thinking about it more and more and more deeply then we can be more mindful of it, follow it less and therefore make less fresh imprints of it. Therefore we slowly undermine it. And we also can apply direct antidotes to it as well. So, some manifestations of this self-cherishing or self obsession are well, there are many, but actually before that maybe I should try to make this point that the self-cherishing thought, the self obsessed thought is not just selfishness.
It’s not synonymous with selfishness. Selfishness is one aspect of the self-cherishing thought. It’s just one aspect. Quite a bad one but one aspect. Because just from some rough way of speaking, like the the selfish thought from a very gross worldly point of view, if we follow the selfish thought with just if we just accept the world the worldly view as being true, and if we follow the selfish thought, there will be some benefits in this life.
We follow the selfish thought and we steal something from someone and we get this thing, some benefit. That’s a benefit of selfishness. If we only think there is this life and the feelings of others don’t count and whatever, which is what selfishness thinks. It doesn’t matter about the feelings of others as long as I’m happy now, it’s okay, I’ve got what I want. So by following the self-cherishing thought definitely one can get some temporary benefits.
Which are actually illusions but we forget about that at the moment. Some the appearance of temporary benefits. But with the self-cherishing thought, there are other aspects of the self-cherishing thought, there isn’t even that. Even obvious benefits. Even in this life, for example, I was talking yesterday or a couple of days ago about, you know, when it’s a cold morning and we’re lying in bed and the self-cherishing thought, you know, just thinks about happy, easy now.
So lying in bed is definitely happy, easy now. And while our mind so the self-cherishing concentrates on that experience and that becomes the most important experience because it’s happy, easy and it’s happening now. So it’s the most important thing. So the self-cherishing thought. Again, I’m just giving extreme example, just isolating the self-cherishing thought operating without any modification.
In any situation in our life, things are more complex than that because we do have some modification, especially if we have a precious human rebirth and some good imprints in our mind. But I’m just trying to isolate, like in a laboratory, the disease, the complete thing in its entirety. So, the self-cherishing thought, if there’s nothing modifying it, it just focuses just on that as the most important thing. This warm feeling, this warm feeling now becomes the most important thing in life. It is happiness, permanent happiness, and if I just stay here I’ll be happy, everything will be fine, be wonderful, so nice.
Yeah. But possibly as we’re lying there on this particular day, there’s some important thing that we have to do today that will bring us some real benefit in this life. Just just taking a worldly example, some real benefit in this life and if we don’t do it, there’ll be some real disadvantage. You know, maybe we have to do something and if we do it I don’t know, maybe we get some money and if we don’t do it we get thrown in jail. I can’t think of an example but you know, I don’t know what it could be, but something that has some consequence like that.
But by following the self-cherishing thought, we stay in bed and we think, Oh, so nice, so nice, you know, Oh, cold out there, horrible. I have to get out of bed and then I have to do that and it’ll be cold and then I have to do that. This is so nice. So we keep postponing getting out of bed and it gets later and later and then it’s kind of late so we jump out of bed, stumble, know, you know, then make mistakes and spill something or clean our teeth with shaving cream. Have you ever done that?
I’ve done that. So, and then one gets more upset and things start to go wrong and one misses the bus or one can’t start the car whatever, or you charge out of the what do call it, the garage and bump into something and then you have to get out of the car and take it out the way. And by this time it’s too late to do the thing that was going to bring some immediate benefit in this life that we knew was going to do that and if we didn’t do it we knew something lousy was going to happen. We knew it. No one had to tell us, it wasn’t any great spiritual obligation, some moral thing that we were forcing ourselves to do.
It was some very concrete thing in this life but it was so cozy in bed, so cozy. Yeah. So that’s kind of a simple example that which we may have all got caught up in this life of how the self-cherishing thought works. So it doesn’t even bring benefit, even ordinary benefit even in this lifetime. And of course, example, a terrible example of this is people getting caught up in drugs, taking drugs like heroin.
You take it one time, oh this is nice, yeah, it’s pleasant. People say there’s some harm to it, but also, why do we take drugs? Why? I can take drugs and I’ll never become a drug addict. Why?
Because I’m me. Because I’m different than everyone else. The self-cherishing thought says, I am different from everyone else. Other people become drug addicts, but I don’t because I’m me. That’s the reason, that’s this fantastic reason we have why nothing bad will happen to me.
The fantastic, so convincing reason is it’s because it’s me. That’s a really terrific reason if we investigate. But we don’t have much other reason, it’s just me, it won’t happen to me. It’s happened to all my friends but not to me. So we take it, yeah, and then sometime maybe we start to realize, oh I’m getting addicted to this, But the self-cherishing thought says, No, I’m not really addicted to it, I can stop anytime, it’s just I like it and it’s good, you know, it’s good, I like it and I won’t get addicted.
So we follow the self-cherishing thought and suddenly one day we can’t control it at all, we have to have the stuff. And the thought to try and give up, oh, that’s too difficult, that is not easy, happy now, this is difficult suffering now, don’t want that. Solve that problem, more drugs. So this is the self-cherishing thought that doesn’t even give any benefit in this life and convinces us to do things that even obviously in this life are disastrous for our physical and mental well-being, even in this life, Completely a disaster for just me. Yeah.
The very me that we’re trying to cherish, it’s a disaster. Even for the illusory me, it’s a disaster, let alone the me that is actually exists, that needs a healthy body, not a body full of heroin. So that the self-cherishing thought is a very sneaky mind that convinces us to do things that are really so disastrous for ourselves now and in the future. So some of its manifestations are selfishness in relation to others, just totally thinking of me in the moment and not considering others. Also a kind of spiritual shortsightedness. You know,, the self-cherishing thought itself has no ability to think of the future consequences.
You know, we we do have that ability because we have wisdom, because self-cherishing is not the only thought we have. It’s not the only option in our mind, fortunately. But the self-cherishing thought itself has no ability to think of the future and its consequences, or a very limited ability, just like a child has con is controlled by that thought and and and just thinks of right now. So what we know when our ice cream falls off the cone, it’s a disaster. You know, we we totally get so upset because it was totally unexpected.
Yeah. And it’s such a huge disaster because this thing is so important in the moment. So as we can see this with children, we’re just grown up versions of that. We have different kinds of ice creams. Yeah.
But it’s the same thing. It looks more sophisticated, yeah, very sophisticated, but it’s the same thing. So, I mean, also like with drugs, there’s no ability to see the future consequence Because it’s just that is focused on the pleasure now, and that is good enough. That is the important thing. And the mind thinking just of pleasure now or suffering now is the source of all our problems, all mistakes, because it is a complete misperception of even ordinary reality.
Because everything has consequences even in this life. So other manifestations of this self-cherishing are: the more we have it, the more fear, anxiety and worry we have in our mind because we need this happiness right now so we fear we won’t get it or we fear we’ll lose it. And as I mentioned before, that the more we have this self-cherishing thought, the more we have aversion to not having easy pleasure now, and the more we get caught up in that mind being so unable to bear any kind of discomfort now, then as soon as a little bit of pleasure comes, then we grasp it immediately without any awareness of the consequences. Like being a drug addict, one has the withdrawal symptoms, so then a little bit of drug, even if we know it’s what do you call it? Not just addictive, it’s even like a bad version of it, impure, kind of poisoned, adulterated, even if we know it’s like that, we’ll take it.
Because that suffering the suffering now, I can’t bear. But by taking this, that suffering will stop. But we don’t want to think about that there will be a bigger suffering from taking this polluted stuff because that’s in the future. So that’s not important. The future is so far away.
Yeah? We destroy the forests of this world to get some benefit now. The problems in the future are so far away, we don’t have to worry about them. So also, another manifestation of it is laziness, every kind of worldly laziness and especially spiritual laziness. But just even ordinary laziness, we can’t be bothered to do things because it’s difficult.
Anything that’s difficult makes us lazy. Even getting out of bed is difficult for the self-cherishing mind. Whether, you know, we get out of bed, we know we’re going to be given a million dollars, it’s too difficult, stay in bed. If we get out of bed, we’re going to get enlightened that day, it’s too difficult, stay in bed. Practice tantra you have to lift up the bell, Oh, it’s too heavy, you know, can’t be bothered.
Too cold. So also another manifestation or another way of looking at it is self indulgence. We even from an ordinary point of view, follow the self-cherishing thought, this is pleasure now, so we want more of it, more of it, and we indulge until it harms us in some way, drinking too much, eating too much, too much of everything. Because the self-cherishing thought says, more, more, more. And it’s, of course, never satisfied, so we have to have more.
So, also an extreme form of it is like cowardice, a complete inability to face any kind of difficulty, which can lead to also another extreme form of self-cherishing, having suicidal tendencies, wanting to kill oneself, everything is too difficult, it’s too difficult to face these problems, so the easy solution is to kill oneself. Of course, with self-cherishing we also solve our problems by killing other people, harming them. Also, self-cherishing thought can also extend not just to me but mine, my things, my ideas, my religion, my country, my little group, So it produces narrow mindedness and every kind of bigotry is an expression of some type of self-cherishing. And also in its extreme form, it also produces many mental disturbances such as narcissism and Various kinds of neuroses come from very extreme self-cherishing. So it acts as the basis for all our disturbing thoughts to arise, It perpetuates the wrong view of the self, it perpetuates the view of ourselves as something very limited, incapable of doing things.
Because we’re always too lazy, it’s too difficult. So we grasp that it’s really like that, so we can’t do it, we can’t change. So, if we really think about it, it’s a disaster. It’s a total disaster from every point of view, for ourselves in this life, for other people in this life, for ourselves in the future, and for other people in the future, it is a total disaster. It doesn’t bring one single benefit in the moment, one single real benefit in the moment or in the future to oneself and others.
It is a total, total disaster. This is what the Buddha taught, we can check out ourselves. Lama Zopa Rinpoche once said that it’s really good to keep a diary of all the harmful, miserable results that have come from following one’s own self-cherishing thought. And he said, this makes the best meditation of all. Dear diary, today I did this and that happened.
And just reading that should develop renunciation and wishing to do the very opposite. So, Śāntideva says that whatever joy there is in this world all comes from desiring others to be happy. And whatever suffering there is in this world all comes from desiring myself to be happy. So, the self there that we’re desiring to be happy is this ignorant, this false self that we’re trying to make happy by following afflicted desire and anger, which also then sets off in its train all the other disturbing thoughts. But if we’re trying to actually take care of the self that validly exists, then we have to take care of the mind.
By generating a calm, clear, virtuous mind. Having love for oneself rather than attachment. Having compassion for oneself instead of attachment. Having perseverance instead of laziness. Having generosity, the quality of the mind of generosity rather than the mind of miserliness.
So whenever those thoughts are there, you know, that the mind is at peace, so we’re at peace, we are happy, contented and so on. Even if they’re directed at ourself, a genuine thought of love towards ourself, compassion towards ourself, then when the mind generating those thoughts is there, the mind is at peace, then the merely existing I that depends on that mind to exist is at peace. And then especially if we direct those virtuous thoughts more and more, we make them stronger by directing them to others and more and more others in a completely non discriminating way to friends, enemies and strangers, then the mind has even greater peace and joy. And therefore I, the validly existing I which is merely labeled on that mind, is at peace, is happy. So actually, so soon as we understand the disadvantages of following this self-cherishing thought, the advantages of cherishing others, more than that self becomes should become apparent, logically apparent.
As soon as we stop doing that process and doing the very opposite, everything should start to go okay, right now and in the future. It will immediately start benefiting us and definitely will start benefiting others right now. Śāntideva also said, What need is there to say much more? I will say more, but what need is there to say much more? The childish work for their own benefit, the Buddha’s work for the benefit of others.
Just look at the difference between them. So who are the childish? We are the childish. From the point of view of the Ārya beings, the noble ones, who have real insight into who how they exist or how things actually exist, we are the childish ones. From our point of view, little children are childish.
But from the point of view of truly spiritually mature beings, we are just incredibly childish, running around just thinking of me and trying to make me happy with such kind of meaningless things. One of the great accomplishments so called accomplishments of modern times is computer technology, and much of that is devoted to video games. This is where the money is made. So the intelligence of so many people is directed to making these things, selling these things, and then looking at them. This is the peak of our society.
It’s no different than licking an ice cream. The entertainment value. When the ice cream is licked away, suffering. When the computer game stops, suffering. I mean, there’s not much difference.
The other the computer games are just much more expensive. I mean, if you look at so much of our society is caught up in all this stuff, promoting it, selling it, saying how fantastic it is. There’s magazines and magazines about it. And then, you know, then the fashion industry. And then people who are able to place an inflated piece of leather, if they can place it in a little round ring high up, this is one of the most amazing things a human being is capable of.
Or if they can kick this oval thing, also a leather, inflated with air and they can kick it between two large sticks, then people give them half a million dollars for that. Or if you can punch another man senseless, they give you millions. So, the childish work for their own benefit. The beings who became Buddhas worked for the benefit of others. So just look at the difference.
So maybe we have not actually seen a Buddha or someone we thought as a Buddha, but if one’s had the opportunity to meet some of the great spiritual masters.
Key terms in this teaching
- merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
- The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.