Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 24 Tape 46 Side 1 only. Part only. Afflictions

18 min · 1,593 words · 24 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 24 Tape 46 Side 1 only. Part only. Afflictions
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk distinguishes desire attachment, which wants to take and is the source of suffering, from loving kindness, which wishes others happiness and gives. It notes that love and attachment can alternate in a relationship. In questions, the speaker explains the refuting object as the false appearance of a truly existing self, using the rope-mistaken-for-snake analogy, which disappears when emptiness is realised in meditation.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-24

Duration: 19 min

UUID: 43bf4e8b-36a9-4ab5-a710-006b5710cc05

Words: 1,593

I don’t love you. Make me happy and I’ll love you. Yeah. It’s something I mean, this is a very gross presentation, but I’m talking about the to really because you might say, but I’m not like that. I don’t think like that.

And maybe this is true, but this is because our mind switches between a little bit of love and a bit of attachment. But attachment itself, that mind just wants to take. It just wants happiness for me. So, it’s not probably the case that most of us are totally dominated by that mind in any situation, but when we are, that’s what thinks, that’s how it perceives. It sees this thing as desirable person or object or situation because it will produce instant happiness.

While it produces instant, easy happiness, I love it. I love it. Yeah. I love you. Yeah.

But what it is, it’s demanding something for me. And it also has this quality of expecting because you made me happy before, now I expect the same thing. I love you because you’re beautiful, so you have to stay beautiful. You have to stay exactly beautiful the way I first saw you, yeah, because that was really beautiful, So don’t change your hair, your clothes, don’t grow old. You can’t grow old because maybe you won’t look the way I want you to look.

That’s how attachment thinks, desire attachment, which we call love. So that causes so many problems, so many problems. Whereas love is wishing the person to be happy, giving something for that person to have happiness, Even if it’s not the ultimate happiness, wanting that person to have some peace, wanting to give something, whereas desire attachment wants to take, extract, yeah. Yeah. Squeeze it, it.

Not to give. Like desire attachment, it’s grasping to us, pulling into us, whereas loving kindness is giving out to others, also to ourselves. Giving something to ourselves, but also giving to others. So, our mind becomes clearer, less confused, we should be able to distinguish whether we have love for someone or attachment or what the mixture is. One moment is love, one moment is attachment.

Of course, because of attachment and because of being with some person, just by being with someone, we get to know them and we see their good qualities, which is the cause to love them. Because if we get to know anyone, we can see good qualities and we can love, which because of that, we can generate love. So, hopefully in most relationships there is some attachment but some love. I mean, hopefully there’s some love even though there’s the attachment. Two things don’t exist exactly at the same time.

In one moment you can’t have love and attachment, but in one moment you can have love for a person, and the next moment it can be attachment. But it’s the attachment, the afflicted desire attachment, which is the source of suffering, not loving kindness. Sorry I didn’t get very far, but we have some questions. Yes? No, no, no, no, I mean, the monks here, young monks are studying you can start studying this quite early, and they haven’t found the refuting object.

Or you probably don’t even know there is one yet. Definitely, one can start studying the teachings now, Then by taking then the more you study them and you start to see what an amazing teaching this is and sort of indicating getting some faith in the truth of that, then one wants to experience what these teachings are about. That inspires us to purify the mind, accumulate merit, get the blessings of the Guru and find the refuting object. Yes? The mere absence of ‘I’?

No. I’m sorry, go on. Yeah, because, for example, in the example of the remember when I mentioned when we see a rope as a snake, we see a snake that appears and we believe that, and the rope that is actually there, we never actually it doesn’t appear to our mind. The rope has never appeared to our mind. What has appeared to our mind is a snake which doesn’t exist at all, other than that So, when we’re meditating, there is the appearance of the snake.

Finally, in meditation, we find the snake like me that appears but doesn’t really exist. You meditate on it with the Mādhyamika logic and you realise it’s just a fantasy, and it disappears. It disappears. But because we never saw the rope, the rope never appeared to our mind. When the fantasy of the snake disappears, the appearance of the rope can’t appear because it’s never appeared to our mind, even though it’s there.

We’ve never apprehended it. So, in meditation, the path of insight, when one directly develops this insight for the first time, the appearance of the truly existing person disappears, and all that is experienced is the mere lack of that false appearance. The appearance of what is existing does not arise because we’ve never even though it is existing, our mind has never apprehended it before. So when one first realizes emptiness, one experiences this space like emptiness. Nothing is appearing to the mind.

But the mind is not stupid, the mind is unbelievably clear and awake and blissful, but there is no conventional phenomena appearing to the mind whatsoever. There is just this space like emptiness. Do you remember the term ‘mere eye’? Yes, the mere I. No, the mere I is the validly existing ‘I’.

But that doesn’t appear at first, that appears later. The mere ‘I’ is the ‘I’ that is merely labelled by the mind on the five aggregates. That is the mere ‘I’ and that exists. And that’s what continues? From life to life, yeah.

Yes. Could you explain the term refuting object? Yeah, the refuting object is Refute? Refuting. It means denying.

Defuting or negating, to negate. How can you say it? Refuting, negating. See this painting over here? Can you see this painting over here?

I’m not wearing my glasses. Oh, there’s a painting over here of white Tārā and yes, it’s white Tārā. Yeah. So, someone might say, Oh, that’s Chenrezig because it’s a body and it’s white, so that’s a picture of white Tārā. And I say, No, it’s not.

It’s not a picture of Chenrezig, it’s a picture of Tārā and it’s not Chenrezig because it’s a female body, and Tārā is a female, and Avalokiteśvara has a male body, and the hand mudras are different. So I’m refuting, I’m refuting, I’m rejecting, denying, I’m proving, I’m refuting that this is a picture of Chenrezig. I’m refuting that. I’m denying it, logically. Does everyone understand that word?

Not denying and saying, it’s not true, it’s not, you know, but What’s the term? You’re saying what it’s not. Yeah, you’re proving what it’s not. Got it? He’s Belgian, don’t you?

He’s Dutch? You’re Dutch. Did you get that one? The Dutch word? No, it’s not.

Question of semantics. I’m not clear why it’s not a refutable or a negatable object that suggests that the object actually from its own side is assisting with refuting and negating. It’s a refuting negating object as opposed to a refutable negatable object. What? There something lost in the translation?

Because refuting is an adjective. Oh, It’s the the refutable object. Yeah. So is it actually coming from You say it’s the refuting object because you have to keep refuting it. You have to keep refuting the appearance of this as being real.

Sorry. But it is a refutable object because it doesn’t exist. So it’s refutable, it’s refuting, I’m not clear. Yeah, the object to be refuted. Okay, but that takes longer to say.

It’s the object to be refuted. It’s the refutable object. It’s also the refuting object because you have to refute it again and again and again because it keeps coming back for a while. In that sense, it’s a refuting object. Okay.

You’re not happy with that? No, I am. Is that clearer? Yes. What is the problem from grasping?

Yes, I think pretty much. Well, from the suffering thing too, from anger too, we have expectations too, suffering and pain. Expectation doesn’t come through, but you don’t get angry or upset if you react to it equanimity, is that a Yes, sure, absolutely. Yes, yes, yes. Good.

Whether the expectation comes from the desire, from the attachment. But even if you have some expectation and then it’s not fulfilled, but you accept that and maintain some equanimity, is that okay? I was saying, Yes, this is good, because one’s not reinforcing one’s attachment and so on. Yes, I think we have to finish, sorry. Okay, thank you very much.

So we can dedicate the merits. By this merit may we be able to recognize our own disturbing thoughts as the source of all our suffering. By this merit may we have the wisdom to know the antidotes, the courage to acquire these antidotes. Ah, right. Okay.

So, by doing that, purify the mind, follow the path to complete enlightenment for the benefit of all those beings who, right now, their minds are controlled by their suffering arising from their own disturbing thoughts, but they have no understanding of this, no method to deal with it. So may we achieve the enlightened state to be able to benefit all living beings. Precious bodhicitta not yet born arise and grow. May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top