43 min · 4,903 words · 30 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching explains that all beings share the same wish to be free of suffering and to be happy, so self-cherishing is the source of suffering and equalising self with others is the source of happiness. It draws on Shantideva’s Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life and Lama Tsongkhapa’s teachings, using the balance-scales meditation and the analogy of the body’s limbs. A question and answer session follows on whether all minds are one and on non-duality.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-30
Duration: 44 min
UUID: 79a56fce-cafc-4c36-a91f-e0af5b289bf1
Words: 4,903
Has the thought, the spontaneous thought, the natural spontaneous primordial thought not wanting suffering. Just as, depending on the clarity of our mind, what we recognize as happiness differs from person to person, from sentient being to sentient being, so depending on the clarity of our mind, what we recognise as suffering also varies from person to person, sentient being to sentient being. But whatever we recognise as suffering, we don’t want it. As soon as we recognize something as being suffering, there is no wish for it whatsoever. There is no sentient being who, when they recognize something from their own experience as suffering, do they want it.
Just like me. As soon as I recognize that something is suffering, I do not want it because that is the nature of mind. There is no other it is impossible, totally impossible for the mind to work any other way. So, I’d probably get totally confused, but get confused, I am confused, but anyway. Right now, one can have the ordinary mind that says that this is happiness and this is suffering.
I recognise this is happiness and this is suffering. So, of course, because I recognise these things like that, I want that and I don’t want that. I want this and I don’t want that. Right? Because that’s how I see things, that this is happiness and this is suffering.
But let us call this one, this is worldly happiness and No, am. No, anyway. But, by clearing the mind, I can start to understand that what I first saw as happiness, this thing is happiness, is just worldly happiness and therefore it’s actually changeable suffering. So then, slowly, my mind can see that what I first thought was happiness is actually suffering. So when I see it as suffering, I don’t want it anymore.
And this, which I saw as suffering, I suddenly recognize, Oh, this is the path to enlightenment. This is the Dharma. First, the worldly mind sees Dharma as something terrible. This is suffering, and the cause of suffering practicing the Dharma is suffering and the cause of suffering. But slowly, by checking it out, one actually realizes, Oh, this is happiness.
So then, one wants that. When one stops seeing it as suffering, but while we see it as suffering, we do not want it at all. But as soon as we start to see there’s some happiness there, more happiness, great happiness, we want it. Whatever we see as happiness, we want. Whatever we see as suffering, we don’t want.
Even though the happiness we see may be suffering, if we see suffering as happiness, we will want it. If we see happiness as suffering, we won’t want it. But if we see happiness as happiness, we will want it. And if we see suffering as suffering, we won’t want it at all. Impossible.
But it is possible to want suffering when we think it’s happiness. And it is possible to not want happiness if we think it’s suffering. I hope that was clear. So, you know, myself, I have this thought, not wanting suffering. Every person in this room has this thought, twenty four hours a day.
All our behavior is motivated by this, not wanting suffering, wanting happiness. Trying to distinguish moment by moment, Is this happiness? Is this suffering? Is this the cause of happiness? Is this the cause of suffering?
Is this the cause of more happiness? Is this the cause of more suffering? So however we understand, according to our confused mind, we will behave. And so it is the same if we look, it’s the same for every living being. What sentient beings do is completely different, so different from what I do.
But the motivation is the same, completely, exactly, totally the same. So please, we should check this out ourselves, whether this is true or not, and allow ourselves to, you know, the gift of understanding that we’re just the same, no different. The self-cherishing thought says, I am so uniquely different, and my wish for happiness is so unbelievably special and important, far superior for the wish to be happy than any other living being has. Not only far superior for the wish of any other sentient being, it’s superior to the totality of all sentient beings’ wish for happiness. Well, that’s kind of extreme, but that’s extreme self-cherishing.
And again, the extreme self-cherishing thought says, My wish to be free of suffering is far more important, far more real, true, valid, special, than the wish to be free of suffering that any other person has, that all sentient beings have. So that view is the source of suffering. The opposite, seeing ourselves as equal, is the source of happiness and the source of correct behavior, valid behavior, valid ways of thinking that will lead to happiness. Also, extending that, another point we can think is, just as my wish for happiness is the same as others, also, I don’t have happiness. I’m not satisfied with the happiness I do have.
Whatever happiness I have, I’m never really satisfied with it completely. If I’m honest with myself and when I have a clear mind. And it’s the same with everyone else. They may look happy, we may feel jealous of so many people because they have this and that, and they have this position and this job, and they live in this place of place, and they have this kind of dog, and this kind of boyfriend girlfriend, and friends, and this and that. So they must be happy.
They must be happier than me. They must be completely satisfied and just, you know, totally blissed out. But it’s not true. We’re all not satisfied even with the happiness we have. Whatever happiness we have, we’re not satisfied with it in the long run.
We’re all just the same. Check up. And similarly, although all of us are saying in not wanting suffering, we all experience it. We are all experiencing it in some form or other. Suffering is just suffering.
So, whenever I experience some happiness in my mind, it’s the same happiness that others experience. There’s no difference. There’s no special unique difference to the happiness that I experience. When I eat an apple and enjoy eating an apple, is this somehow superior to another person eating an apple? Their enjoyment of eating an apple.
When I have a headache, is it somehow uniquely different when someone else has a headache? When I’m lonely, is it somehow uniquely different from another person feeling lonely? When I’m hungry, is it somehow uniquely different from someone else, including a dog feeling hungry, or a mouse, or a rat, or a cockroach feeling hungry? Why are all these cockroaches in my room? Because they are hungry.
Why do I have all this stuff in my refrigerator? Because I get hungry. What’s the difference? Is there a significant difference? When I sneeze, is it different than when you sneeze?
I sneeze, you sneeze, we all sneeze. And similarly, of us, you know, not only do we, we don’t want suffering, all of us are reluctant to experience even the tiniest suffering. Even the tiniest suffering, nobody wants. I’m sorry, I always give the same boring example. But I first saw a Rambo movie in a bus going in Taiwan, going from Taipei to Kaohsiung.
So there was this what was it called, First Blood, the first Rambo movie. So there’s Rambo with his giant muscles in the forest, and of course this little mosquito comes along and he goes whack. Very brave, but you can see even Rambo doesn’t like the smallest suffering. Yeah. See?
So it’s not just the wimps who don’t like suffering, nobody likes suffering. That was a bit slow, to get that one. Also, bodhisattvas don’t want suffering. They have the courage to take it on, of course, and deal with it in a wise, courageous, skillful way. But bodhisattvas don’t want suffering.
That’s why they’re bodhisattvas, because they don’t want any suffering at all. They don’t want anyone else to have any suffering. The reason they don’t want anyone to have suffering is because they don’t want suffering. So, no one wants suffering. So we’re all the same.
Then also, myself, I have delusions, I have afflicted desire, anger talking about myself, jealousy, pride, fears, worries, and so on. Everyone else has too. But what is the difference between my delusion and another person’s delusion? Same, same delusion, basically. The object might be slightly different.
The delusion may be stronger sometimes than another. Other people may have it stronger than me sometimes. I also have it stronger than other people. But basically, it’s the same delusion. It basically works in the same way.
My delusion is your delusion, your delusion is my delusion. There’s no real difference. So why do we make some pretends? And create this huge difference between self and others. You know, because we create so much discrimination between ourselves and others, I would never do that.
Look at what this disgusting person did, said, thought, I would never do that. Never do that. We feel that. But, actually, we have done it before already many times in previous lives, the thing we find so disgusting in someone else. We have done many, many times.
You know, we’ve raped people many times, murdered them many times, stolen from them, lied to people, misused them many times in the past, past lives. So what is the difference between self and other? It’s just a matter of time in saṃsāra, while we’re in saṃsāra. Right now we have this precious human rebirth and someone is a dog, but next life I might be a dog and the dog may have the precious human rebirth. Saying we have the precious human rebirth is not saying that we’re something uniquely special and superior and better than anyone else.
It’s not saying that at all, not at all. It’s just saying very temporarily we have this incredible opportunity that we manage to create the causes for in many other lives, maybe as a dog. Sometimes, maybe one of the causes was when we were a dog, maybe we saved the life of somebody. And this precious human rebirth comes to an end, and someone else will have one, and we may not have one anymore. It’s all changing moment by moment in saṃsāra.
So, why make such a big difference between self and others? It’s just the source of suffering. But when we equalize ourselves with others, that’s the source of every kind of happiness. It’s the way to subdue our delusions. And, of course, to feel affection and compassion for others Because if we you know, by having developed on the basis of recognising these things in ourself, we are able to develop love and compassion for ourselves because of our wish to be happy, because of our wish to avoid suffering, and we are suffering and not really happy, and we’ve developed compassion for our own deluded state, and then we see, well, actually everyone else is the same, then we can feel love and compassion and affection for others, not this discriminating mind that develops pride, aversion, jealousy and so on, and that justifies harming others.
So, this mind is a really wonderful mind to cultivate. Just aspiring, admiring this state of mind is so helpful. And also, the most fundamental point is we all have Buddha nature. I have Buddha nature. I am deluded.
I, this person here with a particular name, two names, my Tibetan name and the name my mother gave me. So, I am a delusional person, but I do have Buddha nature, believe it or not, I have a Buddha nature. And every other sentient There’s a doubter in the audience. So, but every other sentient being has Buddha nature. Every human being has Buddha nature, same as me.
My Buddha nature isn’t somehow better than any other person’s Buddha nature. It’s impossible to say that. It’s just nonsense. Buddha nature is Buddha nature. So, I have Buddha nature, every other human being has Buddha nature, no matter what shape, colour, religion, background, age they are.
Every sentient being has mind, every human being has mind, has Buddha nature, just the same. Animals have mind, mind has Buddha nature. There is no difference in the Buddha nature of a cockroach and my Buddha nature. No difference whatsoever. No difference in the Buddha nature between myself and President Bush, Mr.
Bin Laden, Hitler, Mao Tse Tung, Stalin, Gandhi, President Muhammad, the Dalai Lama, no difference, Just Buddha nature, no difference. So why make a difference? Why suffer? Why make a difference and suffer? Śāntideva gives the analogy the Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life, which is in the meditation section, that if we injure our foot, then our hand will do something to help our foot.
But the hand and the foot are different things, but they’re connected. They’re all part of the one body. So, when our foot is hurt, our hand will do something to stop the pain, to cure the pain. Cure the pain, yeah. Śāntideva is saying that we can recognize that we are all part of the same body.
We are all interconnected, interdependent. So, if one of us hurts, if someone else is hurting, I am hurting. Yeah? If someone needs happiness, I need happiness, so I should do something about it. Śāntideva gives this amazing analogy that, you know, I, this I that we have, that we feel is there, this I identifies with this body.
I am this body or this body is mine. At least, it is valid to say this body is mine, it’s my body. We have identified this body as being mine. How have we done this? Through the power of familiarity.
Because what did this body start off with as? Just a little two little lumps, one sperm, one ovum, and neither of them were me or mine. One belonged to my dad, one belonged to my mom. They weren’t me or mine. But I got connected to them, got to meet this little sperm and ovum and became familiar with them.
Oh, hi, nice to meet you. And they became mine. And that they grew into my body. I’m totally familiar with them now. Couldn’t be separated from them.
Impossible to think of myself without this body which are also the product of all sorts of things which are not me. Cornflakes, bread, not many cornflakes, I don’t eat cornflakes, rice, cheese, chapatis, dal, vegemite. Vegemite is not me, but through the power of familiarity it’s become me, yeah, part of me and mine. All these things that are not me have, through the power of familiarity, I’ve identified as me. So, if we can do that, we can do it with others through the power of familiarity with others.
Śāntideva argues that it’s just a matter of doing it, of becoming familiar and seeing others as self, rather than seeing another being as other, especially as inherently other than me. We can train to see this person is me. At least we can train to start to see this person is like me, is not really different than me. And we can do this through the power of familiarity. And then the more we do that, then when there is suffering of other, it becomes my suffering.
So, have to do something about it because it’s really my suffering. All sentient beings are like limbs of my body. Every sentient being is a limb of my body. So, as when one part of my body is damaged, it harms, it threatens my whole body, so I have to do something about it. So similarly, when all sentient beings are limbs of my life, if one sentient being is suffering, I have to do something about it because it’s part of me.
This is the way to think, and it’s not complicated, it’s not complicated philosophy or anything. It’s very simple, straightforward, down to earth, and so incredibly helpful. Even if we’re not able to achieve this advanced level of equilibrium or equanimity, whatever one wants to call it, even getting a little bit of that is so helpful in our daily life, just in our daily life, even in our worldly life forget about, no, don’t forget about, let alone our spiritual life. Just in an ordinary worldly life, even if we think there’s only this world and only the happiness of this world, to think like this is so beneficial. There would be so much more peace in the world between couples, within families, communities, towns, cities, countries, internationally, if we train to think like this more and more.
We can ask ourselves, you know, in terms of all these points, you know, what valid reason can I give that I am more important, that my happiness is different, my suffering is worse? Especially if we have this long, you know, this especially trying to put it in the broader context of all samsaric suffering. I may have some particular suffering right now that is worse than some others, but others have had that suffering before, will have it in the future. So, what is so special? What is the valid thing I can say that makes me so unbelievably special that my suffering has to be dealt with to the exclusion of everyone else’s, my happiness has to be achieved to the exclusion of everyone else’s.
Can we find a valid reason for that? Other than saying, Oh, it’s because it’s me. This is the only reason the self-cherishing thought gives, because it’s me, it’s mine, it’s my problem, it’s my happiness. That’s about the only thing we’ve got to stand on, which is not very strong. His Holiness gives a little meditation to do, where he says to imagine a set of scales, set of balances, and on one side we put me.
So immediately the scale goes clunk, there’s me, and then you put, and this is my wish for happiness, my wish to be free of suffering, you put that on that side. And then you put another sentient being over there, who wants happiness, doesn’t want suffering. So does the balance equal? No. So we put another one on.
Here’s me wanting happiness and not wanting suffering, and two people wanting happiness and not wanting suffering. So does it balance? Maybe not. So we put three. Does it balance?
Four, five, ten, a million, a trillion. How many sentient beings does it take before our wish for happiness avoiding suffering can we think as equal? It’s kind of embarrassing if we have to put all sentient beings on that side. So, maybe if we’re honest, when we start out, it’s like that, but as we practice, maybe we can take one off, and two off, and three off, until even we’ve just got one person there, any one person, there’s no difference, it’s equal. Wouldn’t that be wonderful?
So, please, I hope if by listening to this, this doesn’t generate the thought, Oh, I am so evil and terrible because I think I’m better than other people. I have to hate myself, I should hang myself, and I shouldn’t eat a piece of chocolate ever again because I’m such a terrible, self-cherishing person. It’s not to think like that. It’s not to think like that. It’s just to recognize something and see the benefit of giving it up slowly, slowly, wisely, step by step.
Everything is a graduated path and we can’t change overnight. We can’t suddenly become a bodhisattva overnight and give up our self-cherishing overnight. We have to do it step by step, at our own speed, with our own ability and in own way, in our own style because only when we want to. Because we start to see that what I thought was happiness is not happiness. You know, you go to the vegetable market or the fruit market, there’s the pile of apples, we always look for the best apple naturally to buy.
If we’re going to buy an apple, we look for the best apple, so, Oh, here’s the best apple, but then you look, Oh, there’s this little brown spot. Oh, put that one on. Oh, this one, this one is happiness. Oh, it’s also got a brown spot, don’t want that one. So, go for something because it looks right, but then if we start to see it’s got something in it, there’s something a little bit wrong with it, we don’t want it so much anymore.
But it’s only when we recognize that. If we haven’t if just grab the apple and we haven’t seen it’s all bruised and rotten, we’ll buy it. But, if we take some time and see it’s not as perfect as what I thought, we won’t buy into it. It only comes at our own, you know, from knowing and feeling ourselves. If we don’t feel that this is suffering, if we feel that it’s happiness, then we can’t change.
It’s just something intellectual that we’re forcing ourselves to do which won’t work, it will backfire. We have to be able to recognize and feel ourselves suffering as suffering, but we should try to give ourselves a chance to use the Buddha’s method to see, to check up, because our method hasn’t been working so fantastically well so far. Okay, maybe this is Yeah, I think this is the basic points of how to develop this mind of equalising self with others. I mean, other points and in Śāntideva’s text, it’s in the chapter of meditation, eight, I think. Chapter eight.
So, eight is the chapter on meditation and the first part, as I mentioned, is about how to overcome attachment, which is the main obstacle to developing meditation, and then the rest of the chapter is about equalising and exchanging self with others because that is the meditation to do. Not just breathing meditation, the real meditation is to be able to meditate on equalizing and exchanging self with others. Śāntideva gives some tricky points in there that get a little bit complicated to explain. But the basic points, which I’ve outlined, which come from Lama Tsongkhapa, is that I think they’re very simple, easy ways to understand and that we can definitely meditate on. And it’s easy to remember.
All these points are easy to remember. We can do this meditation anytime, anywhere, walking around, sitting down. And it’s so powerful and beneficial to do. And it’s a way of actually developing loving kindness and compassion and becomes part of the cause of generating Bodhicitta. Any questions?
Oh, yeah, okay. Sometimes when I think about this, seeing others as part of me, you know, like part of my body, that I started to get have the wrong idea that our minds are, like, part of one mind. Right. But that’s not the case. No, no, it’s not saying that we’re all the one mind.
The question was that if one does this meditation of trying to see other sentient beings as like we’re all part of the one body, then one starts to get the idea that we’re all the one mind. But the question was, is that the case that Buddhism is teaching that we’re all the one mind? And the answer is no, we are not all the one mind. We have separate mental continuums, definitely. That’s why at any one moment, I can be happy and someone else can be suffering, or I can be miserable and someone else is happy.
And that’s why, if I create something negative, I experience the result, you don’t get the result. And if you do something good, I don’t get the happiness, you get the happiness. If there was all the one mind, then karma wouldn’t work. Everything would be a total mess. Buddhism doesn’t teach that.
Yes, but also, the Buddha didn’t teach that as an experience, we’re all one either. Everything is one. He didn’t teach that. He did? No, I’m sorry, he didn’t.
No, I’m sorry, he didn’t teach everything as one. The Buddha taught non duality, but non duality doesn’t mean that everything is one. There’s definitely a misunderstanding of the Buddha’s teaching of non duality. When one develops single pointed concentration and after, the mind has this ability to become oneness, non dual with the object, but that doesn’t mean your mind becomes the thing, You don’t become a tree. I’m sorry, there is a tree.
In reality there is a tree. Definitely there is a tree. Absolutely there is a tree. Conventionally there is a tree. Definitely, but there definitely is a tree.
You should study Lama Tsongkhapa’s teachings more. One of the crucial things is not to deny conventional reality. There are appearances, things if you study the three principles of the path, if you read the prayer, the unique feature of Lama Tsongkhapa’s teachings, because there is emptiness, things exist. Trees do exist. The way we’re experiencing them now is not valid, but trees exist.
They don’t truly exist, but they do exist, even for a yogi. In fact, a yogi experiences a tree as a tree. It’s very yeah, sorry, but this really, I think, need to check up a little bit more. I can’t say I really understand the Buddhadharma but mean, Lama Zopa Rinpoche trusts me to say something that I haven’t got completely lost. But it’s very easy, there are these expressions of being non duality, but it doesn’t mean that we are the same or that we become completely inseparable.
There’s that experience, in a sense, of being oneness with everything, but we are not one. There’s an experience definitely that one can have when that sense, this gross sense of I has gone. The wrong view of I is gone. This non dual experience, but it doesn’t mean we become one. It’s more subtle than that.
So, can you explain exactly what that non dual mind No. You have to ask Lama Lhundrup if that or Lama Rinpoche there. It comes from like, we have this experience of a truly existing ‘I’ and truly existing ‘other’, so this is the very dualistic mind. There is this inherent separation between self and anything else. That when in the state of emptiness there is no truly existing ‘I’ and no truly existing ‘other’, then there’s no truly existing separation.
There is this coming together of the experience, this non dual experience, but it doesn’t mean we become the thing. So is it just that we don’t have those delusions that make us see ourselves separate? Yes, yes. Yeah. In the dharmakaya, according to one view, the dharmakaya mind of the Buddhas, there are not separate Buddha minds, but just one Buddha mind.
This is one view. The other view are, there are separate Buddha minds. But the view is definitely our mind the minds of sentient beings are separate entities, separate mental continuums, but when enlightenment is achieved, there is one view that all enlightened minds merge as one. That’s one view. The other view is that they are also separate entities.
Excuse me? Who is that English? Oh, I think I’m not sure. Like Lama Zopa Rinpoche would take the opposite view to whatever you hold and argue very convincingly. But I think Lama Zopa Rinpoche has the view that the dharmakaya is one mind, but if you say that, then he’ll argue the opposite.
Yes. Yes, there is that view, yes. But it is only one view, in Tibetan Buddhism, in, yeah, there’s the other view as well. But I don’t think we have to worry too much about that. Yes?
Well, equanimity, which I talked about yesterday, is these words are a bit confusing. What is normally called equanimity is where we balance we have this sense of I as being important and we call we label people friend enemy and stranger, and we make a great difference that our friends are so important, these are our unique human beings, you know, the most important human beings in the world, my friends, and then there’s enemies, and the vast majority are strangers. So equanimity is balancing that and trying to, yeah, make that more equal. So, everyone is basically friend. We’re trying to get to the point where we see everyone as basically a friend.
Yeah, but even with that mind, we still have this big difference between all these friends and me. Right? There’s still the big me. The big me has turned everyone into a friend, but there’s still the big me, right? And the big gap.
These are all my friends, but I have to get happy before them, and my suffering is more important than all my friends. So then, what I was trying to talk about this morning is developing this sense of equilibrium between self and others, that actually there’s no difference between me and any other sentient being. Yes. No, I don’t know, no, I don’t think so. I’ve never heard that presented before.
But, it’s maybe possible.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
- The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
- graduated path lamrim (Tib)
- A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.