Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 22 Tape 39 Side 2 Karma

45 min · 5,107 words · 22 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 22 Tape 39 Side 2 Karma
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Explains the twelve links of dependent arising, from consciousness entering the womb through name and form, contact and feeling, to craving and grasping, and how throwing karma ripens at death. It then teaches the seven-point cause-and-effect method for generating bodhicitta, moving from recognising all beings as one’s mother through kindness, affectionate love, wishing to repay kindness, loving kindness and compassion.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-22

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 2eb006f4-d7be-4db0-b660-8d2db0b4eb4a

Words: 5,107

Which is from consciousness entering into to make it easy, we take for example another womb and a sperm and egg of something, since it was a negative karma, maybe it’s going to be a rat womb. Could this not be the bardo? No, the bardo isn’t explained in it because it’s from a general sūtra point of view. So then, the next link is name and form, because is referring to the consciousness which has gone into the sperm and egg, and the sperm and ovum is the form. So that’s the next link.

And then that very primitive physical body substance then starts growing and then within it the sixth sense organs or bases or powers start developing. So it’s not referring to the sixth sense consciousnesses, it’s referring to the physical bases of those consciousnesses. So the eye organ, the ear organ, nose organ and whatever start developing in the fetus. So that’s the fifth link. And it’s like an empty house because it’s got all the stuff there but it’s empty.

The consciousnesses, the sense consciousnesses are not operating yet, but the base of them has developed in the foetus. With name and form, they’re not there, it’s just the most primitive little bit of lump of stuff there and the consciousness has entered. Then name and form develops. It’s still the same thing, the name and form are there but it develops the sixth sense basis. And then when that name and form comes out of the womb as a little baby, baby rat, baby human, whatever, then there is contact, is the base, the physical base, there is the consciousness, the sense consciousnesses and the object.

So the coming together of these things is contact. And that contact immediately, in the same moment, whenever there is contact, is feeling. There is feeling that goes with it, pleasant, unpleasant and so on. And then there’s old age and death. Well, we’ve had that.

Missed it, you’ve missed birth. Oh, you’ve got to be quick. You’ve to be quick. You’ll get the wrong one if you’re not careful. There was name and form, right, which is the consciousness going into the ovum and sperm, then there was the sixth sense organs, then there was birth, and then there is birth, and then there is contact, and then there is feeling.

And of course feeling also produces craving and grasping, but the craving and grasping that is referred to here as the twelve of the two links is referring to the craving and grasping at the time of death, especially at the very last moments of death. But that is also conditioned by the craving and grasping that we generate during our life, during our life, during the lifetime. So it gets all very jumping about. But I hope that helps a little bit. Contacts can’t happen in the womb?

No, no, no, the sense of the consciousnesses are dormant there because there’s not the for the consciousness this is a point that according to Buddhist understanding, think here’s a pillar, then our consciousness comes along and sees it. But according to Buddhist understanding, the consciousness seeing pillar and the consciousness seeing pillar arise in the same moment. There’s another pillar and then the consciousness seeing a pillar, these happen together instantly. So you can’t have an eye consciousness without an object, without seeing something active. So in the womb, this is not happening, there’s no external objects.

Okay, then the contact is maybe referring to later in the womb. Maybe in the later moments of the yeah, but certainly in the early part the contact is not there. This is true, yeah, this is true, that you can have contact later on. But it’s normally referring to especially because it’s very like how do you say? That awareness is very confused at that time.

What do call it? Inattentive perception, I think. One is not clearly aware of what one is perceiving. A fetus, you know, the consciousness is very primitive, operating at a primitive level. So the real contact, one could say, there’s some basic contact in the womb but it’s particularly when the consciousness meets the objects in the external world, witness the coming together of the organ, consciousness and the object.

So that is contact. And the contact also has the quality of distinguishing that something is going on, something is good is going on, something bad is going on, something neutral. And because of that, acts as the basis for pleasant feeling, unpleasant feeling, neutral feeling, and that acts as the basis to crave and grasp. I don’t think I’m capable of it gets really complicated. Can we leave it at two?

One can work it out from three but I think if I try that one right now we’ll all get lost. Or I will. But that helps because if you need all the bits and pieces and if you look at all the numbers because no, I don’t think I’ll try at the moment. Yes? Ten.

No, but it was there before. No. Yeah. Yeah. Eight, nine, four, five, eleven, six.

The numbers. It comes out with contact and feeling. I mean, just in some sort of logical sequence that’s how it works. Shall we try again? Okay, just very briefly, one way of explaining it.

Oh, no, no, I think it gets too complicated. That’s why I asked Geshe-la to explain this, to teach this topic, because it’s just really very complex. But it’s not really so much time, it’s just but it is taught from that point of view. It’s definitely taught from that because that’s what we are experiencing. It’s taught from an ordinary perspective and also from the point of view of understanding emptiness.

One of the special qualities of the incomparable Lama Tsongkhapa’s explanation of emptiness and dependent arising, that particular view of the Gelugpa tradition is that one cannot deny conventional reality. This is very dangerous to deny conventional reality. Conventionally, time goes like that. That’s how we experience it. One after that that’s what impermanence is, one moment after another, decaying moment by moment.

And you can’t experience the past in the future. Or the future in the past. It’s difficult for us to experience the present. Of course, our past influences our present and our concept of the future influences the present but step by step. One karma.

Yes, we are keeping track of one throwing karma. But while the twelve links are while we’re experiencing the twelfth link which is now aging and death, we create many moments of ignorance and therefore many karmic formations and therefore many many you know, these in our consciousness are many many of these throwing karmas. I forgot to explain your point about So at the time of death, there’s the second aspect of the third link, the consciousness holding the throwing karma that is about to ripen. But since the consciousness is holding many throwing karmas, we may have killed someone in this life and not purified it at all, but that is not the strongest throwing karma at the time of death. Some other very good positive karma we created in this life actually becomes the one at the time of death.

So that gets nurtured by craving, grasping and causes a positive rebirth. But still, that throwing karma of killing the person is there. So in another life, will become prominent at the time of death, and another set of links of craving and grasping will cause that karma to ripen and throw us there will be the becoming of seed and then causing birth in a suffering womb or in a suffering situation. And then there will be name and form in the hell realm or something. Then there will be the six consciousnesses developing, the six sense bases developing in the preter body or in the hell body, and then contact with that realm.

Then there will be feeling like an arrow in the eye. And then we will crave continuously to be free of that suffering and grasp to be free of it. Like that. Okay. So in the Sevenfold Method of generating Bodhicitta, there are six causes which lead to the one effect of actually generating the thought, I must achieve enlightenment.

So the first step is recognising that all sentient beings have been one’s mother, sort of thinking how that is possible, that all sentient beings have been one’s mother, and then practising in one’s daily life to recognise that, to be aware, to try to hold that thought in our mind as much as possible, that this person I’m talking to, this person I see on the street, in the bus, at work, in the shop, wherever, this person is my mother. And as we have that thought, we think of the kindness. If we’ve contemplated the kindness of the mother of this life, then anyone we look at, we try to then that imprint that we’ve cultivated, we see with that person. That this person is my mother and has been unbelievably kind to And so, the more we contemplate these things, this leads to oh, maybe just one more point. Even in terms of so in the Sundance Method, it’s really just focused on thinking about the kindness of the mother.

But as I mentioned, one can extend that by thinking about the kindness of every sentient being when they’re not our mother. They’re still very kind in countless ways, consciously, unconsciously, directly, indirectly. We rely on others and their basic goodness for everything that we have, everything we need, everything we want, every happiness, benefit, comfort, protection, every piece of chocolate. If you buy a piece of Swiss chocolate, on the back it says, Manufactured by such a company established in eighteen thirty two. Due to the kindness of that family that started the company in eighteen thirty two, we have the taste of chocolate now.

And of course, why is Swiss chocolate in Switzerland? Because what was it? Christopher Columbus went to America and found chocolate there, or Mr Cortez went to Mexico and found it there, actually. And so we have chocolate due to the kindness of the Mexican people, actually, cultivating it. So back and back in time.

So if we think everything is due to the kindness of others, and not just at this time, but because of other people existing back and back and back, There is a general tendency not to like the police, but the police provide protection when we want it, they’re there. We may not want it, there are other kinds of interference sometimes, but sometimes it’s very helpful to have a police force. Otherwise, this world, because there’s so much self-cherishing, it would be a pretty wild place. People are very kind. And even the enemy is kind.

The enemy has no intention to, but if we do the contemplation of generating patience, we see that actually the enemy is one of the kindest beings we have, we can meet, forcing us to see the delusion in our mind and so on, and forcing us to practice patience, or showing us the need to practice patience, which is one of the greatest qualities we can possibly have. Because by developing patience with the enemy, we are able to have patience with every kind of problem, whatever problem arises. And that we can have this courageous mind and having that courageous mind that is not overwhelmed by problems, then we can generate the courage that takes actually voluntarily takes on the difficulty of practicing the Dharma for the benefit of others. So that all comes from having an enemy, someone who opposes our self-cherishing thought, So even the enemy is kind. So all sentient beings are kind, incredibly kind to me, whether they do it directly or indirectly, consciously or unconsciously.

By thinking in the right way, see that all sentient beings are only kind. And this mind helps us. Every other mind thinking in an opposite direction, it harms others but especially it harms us. By thinking of the enemy as being terrible, we generate anger and that anger chops us to pieces and sends us to the lower realms, creates the twelve links that take us directly to the lower realms. The enemy cannot do that, only our anger can do that.

By contemplating in the right way, come to the point where we see that sentient beings are only kind and only suffering. Only suffering all the time. Not one moment of peace in the minds of sentient beings who are so kind. So the more we think about the kindness of others, we directly recognize it. Just as in ordinary life when someone smiles at us, someone gives us a small present, we think how kind and we generate some warm feeling to them and there’s some natural tendency to want to be kind in return, just naturally that is there, unless our mind is really obscured.

I mean it can be obscured where we don’t appreciate at all, we don’t feel any kindness at all towards the other person, but hopefully, especially when one has a precious human rebirth and the mind isn’t really deeply obscured, then even just someone smiling at us, we feel that that’s nice, and, oh, I want to smile back to them, at least. Even someone smiling at us can be the cause of us wanting to do a lot for that person because we appreciate that at that moment. So by contemplating the incredible extent of the kindness that we’ve received life after life from mother sentient beings, the thought wanting to repay that kindness arises. So even by doing these first two steps, is actually enough to start generating what is called affectionate love. Affectionate love is the basic kind of love where we have this pleasant feeling towards others, we feel some affection towards them, we have no wish to harm them, and we have this good feeling towards others.

And also, as Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, when one has this affectionate love by recognising their kindness, We see others as, Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, we see them in beauty. Our minds in a whole sees them as beauty. Rinpoche uses the word in beauty. I think we see them as beautiful, Rinpoche says we see them in beauty. They’re kind of like beautiful in this we put this aura of beauty around them, no matter what they physically look like.

And especially with our own mother, if we really care for our mother, if we do love our mother, then our mother is beautiful. There’s no doubt our mother is beautiful. My mother was short, fat, she had terrible varicose veins, huge, thick glasses, grey hair, but she was beautiful. There’s no doubt that she was beautiful for me. Yeah.

There’s no logic to that. I I I once would after I met the dharma, because our street where I had lived was full of old ladies, but I never thought the other old ladies were beautiful. But my mother, I thought was beautiful. Why? Because she was my mother.

Just spontaneously you think that. I mean, not the words, you don’t go around clunking with these words around, but there is seeing some you know, when you see your mother, it makes you happy. It’s just such a nicest appearance of all in many ways. So similarly, when we feel affection towards others because of their kindness, no matter what they physically look like, there’s something attractive about them, something beautiful, which is much more beautiful than any physical beauty. There are many people who are incredibly physically beautiful, that their minds are a disaster, full of self-cherishing, and it shows, you can see it.

You don’t have to be clairvoyant or anything, but you can see in some famous people, very famous beautiful people, there’s incredible pride and arrogance and harshness that comes through and it makes them look ugly. You can see the physical beauty but there’s something there that you wouldn’t want to talk to these people too much. Of course, they’re kind mother sentient beings. Then, where someone can be quite physically unattractive but you see that they have pleasant mental qualities and that person appears to our mind as being beautiful or attractive much more so than just someone with some physical, conventional physical beauty. So that’s what arises by seeing the kindness of others, especially how deep that kindness has been life after life after life.

We develop this affectionate love for others, and seeing them in beauty, and therefore we don’t want to harm them. When we see something like that, we don’t want a harm, we have some good feeling towards them. There still may not be this very strong feeling that may they have complete happiness, may they have perfect happiness, that that’s the basis for it to develop. So then, if we contemplate more, this is the third point of wishing to repay this kindness, and we put attention into thinking about this carefully, then we try and think, So I’ve received all this kindness from my mother of this life, what repays that kindness sufficiently? What really repays that kindness?

Is there some physical thing, some object I can give my mother of this life which is sufficient to cover all the kindness I’ve received from her? And what would that physical thing be? Can we think of something? Like on Mother’s Day we give our mother a box of chocolates, a bunch of flowers, take her out for a meal, so does that repay the kindness of our mother? Not quite.

Not quite. Or we could buy a car for our Mother, but does that repay the kindness, really? Does that really, just this lump of metal, repay the kindness of our Mother? Would a million dollars repay the kindness of our Mother? Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, No, it doesn’t, it wouldn’t.

So it’s good to think, not to dismiss this lightly, but really think, Is there something I could find that would do that? Some physical thing, some object, some present, some quantity of money, some kind of holiday that I could take my mother on? Someone she could meet, some rich famous person she could meet. My mother would have loved to have met the Queen of England. But, it wouldn’t have made her happy for very long.

So it really wouldn’t have repaid all the happiness and comfort and kindness she gave me, especially that I have this precious human rebirth to do so much with. So then, if we think from our own side, what do I want? Shouldn’t I give what would I really like to have in life? And what I really want is lasting happiness, pure lasting happiness, free of all suffering. Wouldn’t it be wonderful if I could give that to my mother, to the mother of this life?

To be able to know that she will be free of suffering and have every happiness and all the causes of happiness. Not just some kind of temporary happiness of having a nice home, and nice comfort food, and warmth, and protection, and whatever. These things are nice, but wouldn’t it be wonderful if my mother didn’t have to experience aging and death? Could be really happy. How wonderful that would be.

So we can try and generate some awareness that this is the way to repay our mother of this life and to repay the kindness of all mother sentient beings. So the more we do this contemplation of thinking of how to repay the kindness of mother sentient beings, this generates the next cause, which is developing real loving kindness, which is the love wishing sentient beings to have happiness, and not just ordinary happiness but complete, lasting happiness that can develop more and more. Developing it towards not just one person, but to all living beings. An impartial love towards all living beings. And so, the more we meditate on developing that love and practicing it, sort of acting on it in our daily life, trying to do acts of having this mind of love and therefore doing acts of love towards others, being kind to others in every way.

As I quoted from Rinpoche, The happiness of others depends on us, so even just talking nicely to others or not looking with a harsh face to others, you know, is some offering to sentient beings. It doesn’t upset them, gives them some happiness. And we can practice generosity and meaningful speech, inspiring speech, and so on, a harmonious speech, and all these different kinds of things we can do, and care for life, and care for other people’s possessions, and so on, and share our own, and all these types of things, with the thought of love, we can engage in these kinds of actions. And seeing the benefit, we generate more love, the wish to be more loving, and to be able to extend that to more and more people. Because if generating genuine love not attachment, if extending love to one person brings peace and happiness and a sentient beings in our life, then if we can do it to two people, ten people, a hundred people, a thousand people, imagine what it would feel like, what it would be like.

No reason to be bored, depressed. Plenty of things to do, plenty of things to do. Also, the more we contemplate this thought of how wonderful it would be for all mother sentient beings to have happiness and especially to have the causes of happiness, especially the second point, having the causes of happiness, we become aware that no matter how much we wish others to be happy and try to make them happy in so many ways with our body, speech and mind, sentient beings are suffering, mother sentient beings are suffering because they continuously create the cause of suffering. So the more we wish happiness, the more it acts as the next cause, which is to generate compassion for sentient beings. Because the more we really are actively wanting to make others happy, we become aware that what happiness we give them or encourage them to experience is not real happiness.

And they’re experiencing suffering. There’s the obvious suffering of pain in the body and in the mind that our mother is experiencing, will experience, has experienced, is experiencing, will experience aging, death, fears, growing old, sickness, not meeting with what she wants to meet with, being separated from what she doesn’t want to be separated from, not finding what she wants to meet with. All the different sufferings our mother is going through. And even if our mother is happy, conventionally happy, what is this? It is the suffering of change.

And our mother is always experiencing compounded pervasive suffering because of having a body and mind controlled produced and controlled by delusion and karma. Every sentient being is suffering, in some way. In some way, it isn’t necessarily the gross suffering, but some form of dissatisfaction is there. There is the suffering of being rich and there is the suffering of being poor. The suffering of being poor is obvious to all of us.

But there’s also the suffering of being rich, especially the attachment to being rich. There’s the pride that comes from being rich, there’s the anxiety and fears of protecting one’s wealth, There’s the discontentment of wanting more because no matter how much wealth we have, we still want more. Bill Gates has ninety five billion dollars but he hasn’t retired. Why? Because he wants more, because ninety five billion dollars is not satisfying.

Imagine that. We thought ninety five billion dollars would be satisfying, but it’s not. Imagine that. So there’s the fear of protecting it, and then there’s the discomfort of thinking, knowing that they are, Oh, I have so many friends, why do they like me? Do they like me or my money?

So there is the suffering of being rich. There is the suffering of being not very pleasant looking in this world where pleasant appearances are very important, but there is the suffering of being beautiful. Because there is attachment to that beauty and the beauty doesn’t last. The beauty attracts all sorts of unwanted people. Of course, you want to attract certain people but you also attract a whole lot of other ones you’re not interested in.

And then also there is a suffering of thinking, Do people like me or just my shape and color and appearance? And this appearance, this shape, this beauty isn’t going to last. So there is the suffering of being beautiful. There is the suffering of being not so intelligent, but there is also the suffering of being intelligent. Pride arises of being so clever.

There is attachment to that knowledge and ability which can be lost. In this world of dualities, everything is suffering. There is the suffering of being the victim, there is the suffering of being the victimizer. There is the suffering of being downtrodden, and there is the suffering of being the All Powerful. Everything is suffering.

There is the suffering of being men, and there is the suffering of being women. There is the suffering of being young, and there is the suffering of being old. There is the suffering of being unhealthy, but also there is the suffering of being healthy, because one is attached to it, but it doesn’t last. So our mothers, our kind mothers experience these things again and again and again, are creating the cause again and again and again. We just have to look around.

This is the nature of existence. Wishing happiness, most of us, create the causes of suffering. So that’s why in the Buddhadharma, in order to generate compassion and Bodhicitta, one has to understand suffering. Firstly, our own, the more we understand that’s why all these previous meditations, they are in common with path to our own liberation. The more we feel our own suffering and our potential for it, that drives us to achieve liberation, drives us to develop the wisdom to get free of that suffering.

But then, having done that contemplation, when we open up our awareness to the existence of others, we suddenly realize that everything I realize about my own state, my own suffering state, others have. If we don’t do that contemplation, we don’t open up to that, we can’t see it in others, we can’t feel it, we can’t feel the suffering of others and therefore we don’t do anything about it. So Bodhicitta can’t arise through some kind of fancy words. It comes through a gut felt feeling for the suffering of others that comes from feeling one’s own suffering, one’s own dissatisfaction. And the more we see the whole extent of suffering, that’s how we generate compassion that does not want that.

And also, it’s interesting to contemplate the point that How do we put it? We have to ask ourselves the question, do we want our suffering to stop? I have to translate this very correctly. Do we want our suffering to stop or do we want to stop our suffering? Do we want our suffering to stop or do we want to stop our suffering?

Are we willing to stop our suffering? There’s a huge difference between those two things. Everyone, everyone wants their suffering to stop. No one wants their suffering to go on. Everyone wants their suffering to stop.

So that’s not a special spiritual state of renunciation. But to generate the thought, I will stop my suffering, is a completely different mindset altogether. And that is the mind that brings about renunciation. And it is that mind which acts as the basis to develop the thought, I will stop the suffering of others. So the first level of compassion, any kind of compassion, is just not wanting the suffering to be there.

So in the case of others, we start to see more and more the extent of suffering that others have, and the potential for it. And then, greater form of So then, by contemplating that more and more, the wish to stop that suffering increases more and more because we feel it unbearable, so we want the suffering of others to stop more and more. But then also we see that the suffering will go on while the causes are there, so we realize that the most important thing is developing the thought that may sentient beings be free of the causes of suffering. Because if we just want the suffering of others to stop, then we can give them, you know, they have a headache, so here’s a headache pill that stops the suffering. But it doesn’t stop the causes of the suffering.

We just keep giving it pills, headache pills, again and again and again and again, which is one form of compassion. Definitely, it is a form of compassion that we need to develop. But the greater form of compassion is generating the mind that I must stop the causes of the suffering, to help stop the causes of this suffering. And in the analogy, there’s a simple analogy of how our compassion can increase, develop, is an example of you have some children swimming in a pond. And then, all these children start drowning.

So the ordinary mind will save our own child. Forget about the other children, There’s my child to save, so we save our child. Then, when one has so that is a form of attachment. Because of that, there’s some compassion mixed with attachment. But then, if one has real compassion free of attachment, then one will want to save all children from drowning because they’re all my children.

There’s no distinction, no friend, enemy, stranger, they’re just all they’re all drowning, they’re all suffering equally. So one can’t decide to save one or the other. One wants to save all of them from drowning. At first, see them drowning and ordinary compassion is not wanting that. I don’t want the children to drown.

It’s ordinary compassion. I don’t want them to drown. How terrible they’re drowning, but we just stand there and don’t do anything. They’re drowning, we think this is terrible, which is compassion, but we don’t really do anything.

Key terms in this teaching

Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
throwing karma phen jä kyi lä (Tib)
Also called projecting karma, the karmic imprint that ripens at the time of death to propel us into the next rebirth. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Can contact (the link between sense organ, consciousness and object) occur in the womb?

Not in the early part of life in the womb. The sense consciousnesses are dormant there, because an eye consciousness arises in the same moment as its object, so it cannot occur without an object actually being seen, and the womb has no external objects. Contact may refer to later stages in the womb, and one could say there is some basic contact, but the fetus's awareness is very primitive and confused, an inattentive perception. Real contact is when the organ, consciousness and object come together in the external world.

Scroll to Top